Perez v. NCL (BAHAMAS) LTD.

Filing 17

ORDER denying 8 Defendant's Motion to Dismiss for Failure to State a Claim. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 11/6/2017. (lfs)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SO UTHERN D I
STRI OF FLO RI
CT
DA
M i iDi s on
am
vi i
Ca e N um be :1 22018- V - O REN O
s
r 7Cl M
J SE R .
O
PEREZ, s Pe s lRepr s nt tve of
a r ona
e e ai
t Es a e ofH ORTEN SI SAN TOS,
he t t
A

De e ed;MARI
c as
ANO SANTOS(on) a
s ; nd
HORTENSI SANTOS(
A
daughe)
tr,
Pl nt fs,
ai if

NCI ( I AS)LTD . b/ NORW EGI
, BAIAM
d/ a
AN
CRU I I N E,
SE -I

De e nt
f nda .

O RDER DENYI M OTI TO PI I
NG
ON
SM SS
THI CAUSE ca bef e t Cou tupon Def nda ' M oton t Dim is Compli
S
me or he
r
e nts
i o s s
ant

( E.8) fl on Auaus 8.2017.
D. , ied
t
TIE COURT hasc i e t moton,t r pons i opposton,t r pl peri nt
I
onsder d he
i he es e n
ii he e y, tne
pori oft r cor a bei ot r i e f l advi e i t pr i es i i
tons he e d, nd ng he w s uly
s d n he em s , t s
AD JU DG ED t t m oton i D EN I .
hat he
i s
ED
1
.

Backaround

Thi tagi c e a ie outof t deah Hore i Sa os a pa s nge onboar t
s r c as rs s
he t
tnsa nt ,
se r
d he
s ui s ought by J e R. Per z,as Per onal
os
e
s
De en nts c ui e s p,t G e away. Thi s t i br
f da ' r s hi he t
Re e e a i of t Es a e of M s Sa os M a i no Sa os s of M s Sa os a
pr s nt tve
he t t
. nt ' ra
,
nt , on
. nt ; nd
Hort i Sant ,daught ofM s.Sant Pl ntf salege t on M ay 31,2016,M s.Sant
ens a
os
er
os. ai i f l hat
os

wasij r whie t s p wa i U. trioralwaes Spe fcal Pl ntfsalget t
n ued l he hi s n S. ert i tr. cii ly, ai if le ha
M s Sa os was s at d i t s p' di ng a e when a he pas e
. nt
e e n he hi s ni r a
not r s nger who w a be ng
,
s i

e c re i a whe c i by a Nor gi e oye sa med i o M s San os pi ng he
s o td n
elhar
we an mpl e, lm
nt
. t , nni
r
t s ag ns t t e s wass a e a .Shorl t r afe ,M s.Sa oswase c td t he
oro ai t he abl he
e td t
ty he e t r
nt
s ore o r
c bi whe e s s e nty be n vomii M s San oswast t n t t s p' clni
a n
r he ubs que l ga
tng. . t
hen ake o he hi s i c
whe e s was i ubae N or i n' onboar physcan r comm e d t t M s Sa os
r he
nt td. weg a s
d
ii e
nde ha
. nt
unde go he ogl n t si e r sx hour a t an e
r
m obi e tng ve y i
s nd hat
ndos opy s d be pe f me a
c
houl
ror d t
t ne r thos t lwhe t s p docke a CosaM a M e c t nextpol ofcal
he a es pia
n he hi
d t t
ya, xio, he
4
l.
U pon a rvali Cos a M a Nor
ri n
t
ya, wegi n' m edi a s a fand c ew die t d M s Sa os
a s
c l tf
r
rce
. nt
t a l alhos t .The a t ndi phys ci n a t hos t or r a s
o oc
pial
te ng
i a t he pial de ed onog am ,but ne t r
r
ihe
t s
he onogr m , nor t e
a
he ndos opy ur d by t onboa d phys c an we e pe f m e M s
c
ge
he
r
ii
r
r or d. .

Sa oss r ltve i or
nt ' ea i nf med t at ndi physc a t M s Sa os woul be fyi ba k t
he te ng
i i n hat . nt
d
l ng c o
M i mii me ae y.Ther a tr M s Sa oswas dic r d and boa de a pl ne t M i
a m dit l
e fe , . nt
s ha ge
r d
a o ami
wher he c ton de e i r t whie on t ti ht Upon a rval M s Sant wa t ke t
e r ondii
t ro aed
l
he l g .
ri , .
os s a n o
t e hos tlwhe e s wa uli t l pr
h
pia
r he s tma ey onounce de
d ad.
Pl ntfs Compl nti l s t coun s Count li a wr f deah c am unde
ai if '
ai nc ude wo
t.
s
ong ul t l i
r

t FlrdaW r ulDeah Ac,Fl Stt j768.6- i t i i tont s p t tl t
he oi
ongf
t t a. a.
1 26, f he ncden he hi ha ed o
M s Sa t ' de t t k pl e i U . t ni oralwa e s Pl ntfspl d Countl,a wr ul
. n os s ah oo ac n S. e t i
t r . ai if ea
l
ongf

d t cai unde t Deah on t Hi Se Ac,46 U. C.jj 303018,i t aler tve
eah l m
r he t
he gh as t
S.
- n he t nai ,
i t eve t tt s p wa out i ofU . t t ilwaer .Nor gi n m ove t dim is
n he nt ha he hi s sde
S. eni ora t s
we a
so s s
Count lbec us t De h on t Hi Se Ac ,r t r t n Fl i l w,s d a y.
a e he at
he gh as t ahe ha orda a houl ppl
Nor a moves t dim is Count1 f f iur t sa e a c am upon whi r if c n be
wegin
o s s
1 or al e o t t
li
ch ele a

g a td puru t Fe a Rul of Ci lPr e e 1 b)6) Thi Cour ha maii
r ne
s ant o derl e
vi oc dur 2( ( . s
t s rtme

j iditonpurua t 28U. C.j1
urs ci
s nt o
S. 333.
lI.

LezalSt
andard

û pl di t tsaesa cli f r ifmus conti ...a s ta pl n saeme of
$ ea ng ha t t
A
am or ele
t
an
hor nd ai t t nt

t cam s ngt tt pla ri enildt r if'Fed.R. v. 8a ( .W henr i ona
he li howi ha he e de s tte o ele.
'
Ci P. ()2)
ulng
motont dim is a c tm us viw t c
i o s s , our
t e he ompli i t lghtm os f vor et t pli ifa
ant n he i
t a abl o he a ntf nd

a c p t epanipswelpla e fcsa tue S eS.J sph' Hop. I c v Hop.Cop.o
c e t h litf
l ed d at s r . e t o e s s , n . . s r f
zr. 7 F. 948,95 ( 1h Ci.1 6) To s vi a moton t dimis a k mpl ntmus
'?, 95 2d
17
4 1 t r 98 . ur ve
i o s s, i
co ai
t
c an s fcintf cualma t ,a ce ed a tue,t it t acli t r le t ti plusbl on is
ont i ufi e a t
ter c pt s r o sae a m o ei f ha s a i e t

f e.'As r v l ,556U. 662,678(
ac '' hc qh . qbal
S.
2009)( i BelAt.Cor v Twombl 5 U.
quotng l l p. .
y, 50 S.
5 57 ( 07) Deald f t alegainsar notrquie butapladi mus ofe mor
44, 0 20 ). tie acual l to e
e rd,
e ng t fr e
t i a l a c l i ' o t f r a c r ciai oft ee e soft c us ofa ton.
han t be s nd onc usons' r ' o muli e tton he lm nt
l
a
he a e
ci '
'

Twombl 55 U. a 555.Jac s v l t Telcomm. 372 F. 1
y, 0 S. t , k on .Belsouh e
,
3d 250,1 ( 1h Ci.
263 1 t r
2004) (k' s vi a moton t dimis pli if mus do mor t n meel sae l l
i'o ur ve
l
i o s s, antfs
t
e ha
r y tt ega
con usons t y ar r r d t alege s
cl i ; he e equie o l
ome s cii f t bas f t econcusonsorf c
pe fc acual es or hos
l i
ae

dimis loft i c am s') l s t t c
s s a he r l i . . n hor, he ompli tm us notmer l a lge m ic
'
an
t
ey le
s onduc ,butmus
t
t
de onsr t t tt pl a ri k ntte t r lef' l ,556 U . a 677m ta e ha he e de s i il d o e i . qbal
e
'
S. t
78.
1 .
11

A nal i
vss
A.
Deat on t H i Se A c and Fl i sW r
h
he gh as t
or da'
ongf D e h A c
ul at
t

The pa te qui e wih whe he Fl i sW r ulDeah Ac ort Deah on t Hi
ri s bbl t
t r orda' ongf
t t he
t
he gh
Sea Ac a i .The Compl ntas e t Countlunde Fl i l w,a aler tve y,Cou 1
s t pples
ai s rs
r orda a nd t na i l
nt 1
unde fder llw.The De h on t Hi Se Ac pr des a c us ofac i Cwhe
re a a
at
he gh as t ovi
a e
ton s neve t
r he
de h ofan i vi li ca e by wr ula ,neglct ordef tocc rng on t hi s as
at
ndi dua s us d
ongf ct
e ,
aul ur i
he gh e

b ond 3 nauialmiesfom t s eoft Unie Stt ...' 46 U. C.j 3030 By is
ey
tc
l r he hor
he td aes '
S.
2. t
t r s t Dea h on t H i Sea Actdoe not c r de hs r s tng f om i de s oc ni
e m , he
t
he gh
s
s
ove at e uli r nci nt cu ng
wihi sat t ni oralw a er - up t t e m ies of a St t s s e.The di tnc i i c uc a
tn te e t i
t s
o hr e l
f
a e' hor
s i ton s r i l
be aus r c r unde t De h on t H i Se A c i lm ie t pe uni r l s w hie cl m s
c e e ove y
r he at
he gh as t s i t d o c a y os , l ai

re
t .
ni
/#.
23363- V ,20 W L
C1
08
f non- cu a y l s a e ba r d.Smih v Car val Ctr ,No. 07or
pe ni r os r
s
o da a s
e
o
t
2704459 a *l( D.Fl J 24,2008) l com parion,Fl ri 1 w i m or gener us as i
, t S. a. une
.n

pemisrc r ofpe ay l s.See Fl Stt 768. ( (i- s vi ng s e ma as
r t e ove y
cunir os
a. a . 212) i-he ur vi pous y lo
l
r ove f l s of t dec den ' c pa ons p a pr e i a f m ent pai a
ec r or os
he
e t s om ni hi nd ot cton nd or
al n nd

s feigfo t ed t o ij r ' .
u frn r m h ae f nu y.)
'
Nor a s poston i t tCountls d be dim is bec e t dea h oc ure i
wegin'
ii s ha
houl
s s ed aus he t c r d n
i em ai
nt tonalwa e s a t ,Fl i l i i pplc bl l s
t r nd hus orda aw s na ia e. n uppor,Nom e an r i on t
t
gi eles
he
a tda tof Br t Be n,t Die or of Pas e
fs vi
e t nna he r ct
s nger a Cr Cl m s,w hi h s a e t t a t
nd ew ai
c t t s ha t he

tme oft i de t tr ule i M s Sa os s de t t s p was i i er tona waer ,
i
he nci nt ha es t d n . nt ' a h, he hi
n nt nai l t s
t er by r uli i t a ia i oft Deah on t Hi Sea Ac .The ge r lr e i t ta
h e es tng n he pplc ton he
t
he gh s t
ne a ul s ha t
t moton t dim issag t Cou tsr vi i lm ied t t f c ner oft compli a
hc i o s s t e, he
r ' e ew s i t o he our or s he
ant nd
ma notc i rm at r outi t pl di wihoutc
y
onsde
te s sde he ea ngs t
onve tng t de enda ' m oton i o
ri he f nts i nt

one f s
or ummayj
r udgme .Cr l v Mor St e De Witr ue vî,(t. l . 87 F.
nt owel . gan anly an te % r . 7?, nc,
.
Supp.2d 1
287,1 ( D.Fl 2000) Nor gin ctsBi ly v Car mar #Arl ,461F.d
290 S. a.
. we a ie cke . e k
nc.
3
1 ( 1h Ci.200 ,f t pr ii t ti ume swhih aece r lt Plitfs cli
325 1 t r 6) or he oposton ha '
doc nt c r nta o anif' am
ma be c i r d whe r i on t moton t dimi s' To t t e Nor
y
onsde e
n ulng
he
i o s s.
'
ha nd, wegin ur s t
a ge he
Cour t r y on M r Be m a s a fda tt di m i s Count1 H oweve ,N or e a m i c tues
t o el
. r n' f i vi o s s
.
r
w gi n s onsr
Bi k e ' hol ng.l Bi kly, he El ve h Cicui hel t t
c l y . di n c e t
%
e nt r t d ha :

g l e t pl ntf rfr t c ran document i t c ant
W her he ai if ees o e ti
s n he ompli
a t e doc e s a e c nta t t pl i tf cai ,t n t
nd hos
um nt r e r l o he a n ifs l m he he
Cour m a c i r t doc
t y onsde he
umen s pa t of t pladi f
t
r
he e ng or

pupos ofRul 1 b)6)dimis l a t defnda ' at hi
r es
e 2( ( s s a, nd he e nts tac ng
s h doc e s t t m oton t di m i s w il not r r
uc
um nt o he
i
o s s
l
equie

c n eso o t emo init amo in frs mmayj dg n .
o v rin f h to n o
to o u r u me t

461F.d a 1 n. ( tng Br sv Bl e Cr s ( Bl Shil l . 1 6
3 t 330 7 cii
ook . u o s f ue ed, nc, 1
F. 1 64,1 69 ( 1hCi.1 )(mphassa
3d 3 3 1 t r 997) e
i dded)
.

Thi Cour coul r l on M r Ber a s a fda t i Pl ntf s ha r er nc i i t i
s
t
d ey
. m n' f i vi f ai i f d ef e ed t n he r

Compl nt bu t y di not Seealo Fr a v Ro Carbbean Cruie ,Lt ,772 F. 1
ai , t he d .
s anz . yal i
ss d
3d 225,

1 38 ( 1h Ci.201 (ef i t co i r t pase
237- 1 t r
4) r usng o nsde he s nger tcke c rc t dee t
i t onta t he fndan
a tc t is moton t dim is b aus t pli if di nota tc t tcke c r c t t e
ta hed o t
i o s s ec e he antf d
ta h he i t onta t o h

c ai a t c ai madenome i oft conta )
ompl nt nd he ompl nt
nton he rct.

Cii j dii efi en Nor gi hi i s t i t e ofma ng a c c of
tng u cal fci cy, we an ghlght he mporanc
ki
hoie
l w de e m i ton a t ltga i s out e .Thi Cour s r s N or e a s conc l ,but not a
a
t r na i t he ii ton'
st
s
t ha e
w gi n'
e'
n
t
t e
he xpens of a w e lpl ade Com pl nt or i c r ve i of t Fede al Rul of Ci l
e
l- e d
ai ,
n ont a nton
he
r
es
vi
Pr e e' if r c ne s ' r r m e . A s t Count 1 t Com pl i a l ge t t ç
oc dur s çou or r ' equie nt
o
, he
a nt le s ha t
upon
i or a i a b i ,' he i de i vi M s Sa os t pl ce w hie t s p w as i U.
nf m ton nd elef' t nci nt nvol ng . nt ook a
l he hi
n S.
t r ior a w a er . le na i y,i Pl i if a e m i t n a t s p w a i i e a i lw a e s
e rt i l t s A t r tvel f a ntf s r sake nd he hi s n nt m tona t r
a t tm e of t i de ,t en Co 1 under t D e t on t Hi Sea A c a i s See
t he i
he nci nt h
unt 1
he a h
he gh
s t pple .

Fe r lRul ofCi lPr e e 8( ( mitng pla ng i t alenai ) l t l t
de a e
vi oc dur a) per ti e di n he tr tve. mporanty, he

Co liti n tsln a t te lc to o te p rie ta to s C Rily v NCL ( h ma )
mpan s o i t s o h o ain f h etn n c in . f d e .
e
Ba a s
Lt ,82 F,Supp.2d 1
d 4
355,l ( D.Fl 201 ( a i motont dimisi amartmeca e
360 S. a. 0) grntng i o s s n
ii
s
wh e Pli if di notalge whe et ne i nta i t pl e) Acc di y,t Cour
er antfs d
le
r he glge ctons ook ac . or ngl he
t
ne d notr l o Nor gin' pr f r d a fda tbec us i f ls ou sde t f c ne s oft
e
ey n
we a s ofe e fi vi a e t a l t i hc our or r
he
Com pl nt Thus N or
ai .
, wegi n' m oton t dim i sC oun li de e
a s
i o s s
t s ni d.
B.

Count1 - Faiure t St e a C l m
1
l
o at
ai

Next Nor gi move t dim isCount1 be us Pl n if f lt sa e a cli u n
, we an
so s s
1 ca e aitfs ai o tt
am po

whih r i c n b gr nt d unde Fede alRul of Ci l Pr dur 1 b)6) The e s e of
c elef a e a e
r
r
e
vi oce e 2( ( .
s enc
N or
wegi nf a gum enti t tPl i if f ie t pr r y a l ge a c ai f neglge undert
a s r
s ha a ntf s a l d o ope l le
l m or
i nce
he
Deat on t H i Seas A ct
h
he gh
.

5

Topla neglge i amaii ca e $apl ntf mus alget t( )t dee ntha
e d i nce n
rtme s ,i ai if t le ha 1 he fnda d

ad t t p oe th paniffo ap riua ij r ( )ted fn a t e c e ta d t ( )te
uy o r tc te litf r m a t lr nu y; 2 h ee d n b a h d h t uy; 3 h
c
b e c a tal a d p o i tl c u e tepan ifsij r 'a d( )t ep an ifs fee a t a
ra h cu ly n r xmaey a s d h litf n u y n 4 h litf u fr d cu l
,
h m.' an 772 F. a l ( tngCha r v Car v Cor 693F. l 1 (11h
ar 'Fr za,
3d t 253 cii
paro . nial p,
3d 333. 336 t
Ci.201 ) Al f elm e sa epr enti Pli if 'Compl i .
r 2). l our e nt r es n antfs
ant

Fis,Pl nif alge t tNom e an ha a dut t execie r a ona e c r i ()
rt aitfs le ha
gi
d
y o r s e s bl ae n: 1
pr ry moniorng o asitng i ta pori whe charbound pase s ( pr ry
opel
t i r ssi n rns tng
el is nger' 2) opel
,

tai ng a s per sng is cr i opeai mot i d whe lhar' ( i e tng
r ni nd u vii t ew n
rtng
orze
ec is 3) mplmeni
,

a p o raep iisa d p o e u e f ra d e sng p s e g r wh s fe o b a d ij re ,()
p r p it ol e n r c d r s o d r si a s n es o u f r n o r n u is 4
c
'
p o cl te tn o tn ig t ij rdp se e swhi a o r t es i ; n ( )a s rn t a te
r p ry raig r e dn o nu e a sng r l b ad h h p a d 5 su ig h t h
e
hos t a physci ns t w hi i r e s is pa s
pial nd
ia o
ch t ef r t s cnge s m e t t s m e sanda d of r as
r
e he a
t r
e onabl
e

c e t whih is o me c pr esi s ar s j c.A s p owneri onl la e t is
ar o c t wn dial of sonal e ub e t hi
s y ibl o t
pa s
s enge s f m e ca ne i nc i is c
r or di l glge e f t onduc br ac t c re ' g r dut t c ci e
t e hes he ar i r s ene al y o xer s

le ona e cae u r t cicumsa e .'Fr z 772 F. a 1 (ii Ke mar c v
t as bl r nde he r tnc s' an a,
r
3d t 233 ctng r e .
Compagni Ge al Tr s l i ,358U. 625, ( 959).
e ner e an atantque
S. 630 1 )
Se
cond,N or e a pur t dl br c d s i dutes by, i e ala,f lng t p opery
w gi n
por e y ea he a d i
nt r i aii o r l

moniora a ss i t ta pora i oft whe c rbound pas e rt tsa me i o M s
t nd s it n he r ns tton he
elhais nge ha lm d nt
.
San os a pr ry tea M s Sa osw hie s wasaboa d t s p.
t nd ope l r t . nt
l he
r he hi

Thid,Pl ntfsal t tûl or a s ne i nc pr mael c ed gra bodiy
r ai if lege ha t wegin') glge e oxi t y aus e t l
ham t Ms Sa os a uli tl pr mael ca e he de t i t t butf ( egin'l
r o . nt , nd tmaey oxi t y us d r ah, n ha, or Nonv a s
ne i e M s Sa os debiiai ij i woul notha occ rdv
glgenc , . nt ' lttng n ures d
ve ure '
'

Fo rh,Plitfsalg t a M s Sa t s fe e ' e ee b d l ij r r s t g i h r
u t an if l e h t . nos uf rd k v r o iy nu y e uln n e
e
s
i
de t a ( r f l hass fr t l sofs
ah, nd hel amiy
ufeed he os uppor a s l ce fom t daeoft i i nt
t nd ewi s r he t he ncde
t he de h,a f ur l s ofs
o r at nd ut e os
uppor a s vi es snce he pa s ng...'
t nd er c i
r si
'
W he he N onv a br ac d t alege du i i a que ton t tc
t r
egi n e he he l d tes s
s i ha annota s d no
nd houl t
be ans e e a t s sage. one he e s Pl i if 'w e lpl de a l ga i a e m or t n a m e e
w r d t hi t N t l s , a ntf s l- ea d le tons r
e ha
r
r c t ton of t f c s a pl us bl r i e a entte e t r le . A cc di y, N or
e ia i
he a t nd a i y a s n il m nt o e i f
or ngl
wegi n'
a s
m oton t di m i s Count1 i de e
i o s s
1 s ni d.
IV.

C oncl on
usi

N or egi n' m oton t di m i s Count l i de ed be us r i e on N ol e a s
w a s
i o s s
s ni
ca e elanc
w gi n'
pr f r afi vi w oul be i pr r a t s s a a bec us Pl ntf s ade t l pl a d i
of e ed fda t
d
m ope t hi t ge nd
a e ai i f
qua e y e de n

t ale nai Addii l t moton t dimis Count 1 i de ed be aus Pl i if ha
he tr tve.
tonaly, he
i o s s
1 s ni
c e antfs ve
ade t y pl a a pl us bl e il e t r le .
qua el e ded
a i e nttem nt o e i f

DN ADODRDiCabraMaiFlorida,this 1 &oNvme
O E N REE n h e t i
ms m
foeb
r
,

2017.
'.
.. '
.

.>
.

FED
CO A .M O REN O
UN I
TED STA TES DISTRI J D G E
CT U

Copi f ni he t
es ur s d o:
Couns ofRe or
el
c d