Hopkins v. American Security Group A-1, Inc

Filing 16

ORDER denying 10 Defendants' Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Jurisdiction and for Failure to State a Claim. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 9/26/2017. (lfs)

UN I
TED STATES D I
STRI COU RT FOR THE
CT
SO UTHERN D I
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
M i iD i son
am
vii
Cas N um ber:17e
22447CIV- O REN O
M
ROD RI HOPKI S,
CK
N

Pl ntf ,
ai if

AM ERI
CAN SECURI G RO UP A-l.m C. et
TY
,
al,
.

Def
endant .
s
O RD ER DENYING DEFENDA NTS'M O TI N TO DISM ISS
O

THI CAU SE cam e bef e t Courtupon Def
S
or he
endant 'M oton t Di i Count I V,V I
s
i o sm ss
s V,
,

V1,VlI a I ofAme dCompli ( E.1 , ie on Aueus 1 3Q1
I I, nd X
nde
ant D. 0) fld
- 8v 7.
t
THE COURT has consi ed t m oton, t r pons i opposton, t r y, peri
der he
i he es e n
ii he epl
tnent
pori oft r d,and bei ot wie f l advied i t pr ies,i i
tons he ecor
ng her s uly
s n he em s t s
ADJUDG ED t t moton i DEN I .
hat he
i s
ED
1
.

BAC K G RO UND

Pl ntf fl t i t acton i Fl i s El
ai if ied he nsant i n orda' event Judi alC icui agai t Def
h
ci
r t
ns
endant,
s
Amercan Securt Gr
i
iy oup A-1 I ,d/ a A-1 Lock and Key, M GN Conques Cor aton,and
nc. b/
t por i

M iha lNete .Def da stmel r mov d t t sCou tpurua tt 28 U. C.j 1 .Thi Co t
c e tls en nt i y e e o hi r s n o
S.
441 s ur

h s orgialj iditon purua t 28 U. C.j l
a i n urs ci
s nt o
S.
33lbe a e t Ame d Co aitalge
c us he
nde mpl n le s
cl i sag n tDe en n s f u i wag und t Fai La S a ar Ac .Def da s s ek t
am
ai s f da t or npa d
es er he r bor t nd ds t
en nt e o
di is Count I , V, V l Vl , Vl I and I of t Am ended Com pl nt t alege s a e and
sm s
s V
s I l,
X
he
ai hat l
tt

c
ommon Iw cai f lc of s e nalj rs ci 28 U. C.j 1 a) Addiinal
a l ms or a k
upplme t u iditon,
S.
367( .
to l
y.
Def
endant m ove t di i Count I and V f f l e t sat a cl m upon whi r i can be
s
o sm ss
sV
or aiur o t e
ai
ch elef
gr ed.
ant

I
I.

LEG AL STAN DARD

Unde F r Rul ofCi lPr e e 1 b ( ,a c tma dimisa cam f k a lr t
r edeal e
vi oc dur 2( )6) our y s s li or t iu e o
f
sat a cl m upon whi r i can be grant ' ç'' s vi a m oton t di m i , a com pl ntm us
t e ai
ch eltf
ed.' t o ur ve
f
'
i o s ss
ai
t
cont n s fci f ualmater accept as tue,t lt e a cl m t r i t i pl bl on is
ai uf i ent act
t,
ed
r o s at
ai o elef hat s ausi e
t

fce-' h r h v l al55 U. 662, ( )( otn #e/Atani Cop.v Twombl 55 U.
a a'As c q . qb . 6 S. 678 2009 qu ig / l tc r .
y, 0 S.
5 57 ( ) .i cl m ha f calpl sbii wh n t pl n ifpla f t c e t a alo
44, 0 2007 ) i ai s a i au i ly e he aitf e ds acual ontnt h t lws
A
t
t cour t dr w t r onabl i tr
he
t o a he eas
e nf ence t t def
hat he endanti labl f t m iconductaleged.' 1
s i e or he s
l
' J.
W hen a cour consi s a m oton t dim is, i m us acceptt alegatons i t compl ntas tue
t
der
i o s s t
t
he l i n he
ai
r

and consr t
tue hem i t Ight m os f abl t t pl ntf . See, e. . i s Lobo v. Cel t
n he i
t avor e o he ai if
g. d.
.
ebriy

Cr s s l . 7 F. 8 88 ( 1h Ci. l )
uie , nc, 04 3d 82, 7 l t r 20 3 .
11 .
1

DI
SCUSSI N
O
A.

Suppl ent Juri cton
em al
sdi i

Defnda sag t tt sCour s ul d clnet e ries ppl tlj rs ci ove
e nt rue ha hi
t ho d e i o xecs u emena u iditon r
Count I I because t tr r pr of el ent and f s t ar not r r t pr
s V- X
hey ûequie oof
em s
act hat e
equied o ove

Plitf Fai La or Sa r Ac cai . Th s e na j iditon saue pr de ,i
anips r b tndads t l ms' e upplme tl urs ci ttt ovi s n
'
r evantpar:
el
t

( )Ex p a pr de i s e tons( )an ( ...i an ci lac i ofwhih t ditit
a ce t s ovi d n ubs c i b d c) n y vi ton
c he src

c t ha eorgial urs ci tedititc rss l ha es pl tl u iditon o r
ours v i n j iditon, h src out hal v up emena j rs ci ve
a1ohercl mst tar s rltdt cai i t a tonwihi s chorgi l u iditont t
1 t ai ha e o eae o l ms n he ci t n u i na j rs ci ha
t
hey f m par of t s
or
t
he ame cas or cont over under A ri e l I of t Unied St t
e
r sy
tcl 1
he
t
a es

Consiui Su h s pplme al uiditon s l i u cai t tivol t j nd or
ttton. c u e nt j rs ci hal nclde l ms ha n ve he oi er
i er i ofaddi onalpari 28 U . C . j l ( .
nt venton
ti
tes.
S.
367 a)

()Thedititc t ma de ln t e ries pplme al u idito ov acli un r
c
src ours y cie o xecs u e nt j rs cin er am de
s e ton( )i
ubs c i a f
( )t e cai r s sanov o c e is ofSt t lw,
l h l m aie
el r omplx s ue
ae a

( t e cam s tntaly pr domi ts ov t e cli or cl ms ove whih t
2) h li ubsa i l e nae er h am
ai
r c he

dititc th sorgi j rs ci
src our a i naluiditon,

()tedititc th sdimisd alcl msov whih i h orgial urs ci
3 h src our a s se I ai er c t as i n j iditon,

( i e e i cicu t nc s t r a e ot r c
4) n xc ptonal r msa e , he e r he ompelng r a on f de lni
li e s s or c i ng

j iditon.
urs ci
28U. C.j1 67( .
S.
3 c)

Th Cour ha orgi j iditon o rCouns111b a e Pl nifal esvi ai sof
e
t s i nal urs ci ve
t -1 ec us aitf leg olton
t Fai LaborSt
he r
andar A ct The ques i i whet Count I I arse outofa icom m on nucl
ds .
ton s
her
s V- X i
û
eus

ofop a ie f c' wih Cou s111 Lu e o v Tr c 1 F.d 5 ,597 ( 1h Ci.1
ertv a t- t
nt -1. c r . os h, 21 3 91
1 t r 997)( tng
cii

Unie Mie Wor est Am.v Gi ,383U. 71 72 25 (966) Todeer n wheh rasae
td n
kr ?
f
. bbs
S. 5, 4- l ).
t mie te tt
l cl m s ifes t s sandar a cour shoul exam i ûw het t cl m s arse f om t s
aw ai ats i hi t
d,
t
d
ne i her he ai
i r
he ame

f s,ori ve si iaroccur ences w ines orevi
act
nvol m l
r
, t ses
dence.'H uds v.Dela Ai Li I ,90 F.
'
on
t r nes nc.
3d

451 455 ( lh Ci.1 6)(iig Pame v Hos t Auh.o Ra ph C@. 22 F. I 9,1
,
l t r 99 ctn l r . pial t f ndol
,
3d 55 566
( lh Ci.1 4).Se Luc r 1 F. a 598 (i ng s ppl tlj iditon ove sae a
1 t r 99 ) e eo, 21 3d t
fndi u emena urs ci
r tt nd
f er cli t tr id on i n iala ton oft e de e n s ;Pal r,2 F. l
ed al ams ha ele
de tc c i s h f nda t) me 2 3d 559,l 3- 4
56 6

( di s plme al j rs ci whe fdea a sae cli i ol s
Gn ng up e nt u iditon
n e rl nd tt ams nv ve ame wine ss
t se,
p e e t tonofs mee de e d t r na i o s fc s .
r s n ai
a vi nc , e e mi ton f ame a t)
Def
endant cont i i not t Count I I do not ars f om a comm on nucl of
s'
enton s
hat
s V- X
ie r
eus
oper i f w ih Count 1 11 nor coul t
atve act t
s -1 ,
d hey because t cl m s al arse f om Pl ntf s
he ai
l i r
ai if

empl men .Rahe ,Defnda t s es t ti e r sng isdic e i purua t s c i 1 ( )
oy t t r e n s ugg t ha n xecii t s r ton s nt o e ton 367 c ,

teCouts drjc sppl nt j rs ci ove CounsI I be a et yie r poofof
h
r houl ec t u eme al u iditon r
t V-X c us he i quie r
r
el
ement and f s t ar not r r t pr Pl ntf s Fai Labor St
s
act hat e
equied o ove ai if
r
andar A ct cl m s.'
ds
ai '
Def
endant alo mai ai t t addii
s s
nt n hat he
tonaldicover r r t vet Count I I w il del
s
y equied o
s V- X l ay
pr ecuton ofCount 1 1 1 1
os i
s - 1 . d.

1
.

Count IV and V
s

Count I and V alege br
sV
l
each ofcontactf f l e t pay 'al com m i on due t Pl ntf
r or aiur o
il
ssi
o ai if
f s vi pr ded and peror ed duri hi em pl ent' Def
or er ces ovi
f m
ng s
oym . ' endant ar t tPl ntf w ilbe
s gue ha ai if l

r quie t pr e e d ce of a v i c r c ,br a h,a da a s none of whi coi de w ih
e r d o es nt vi en
ald onta t e c nd m ge ,
ch nci
t
t el men s r quie f a c ai of unp d wa s un r t e Fai Lab St nda ds A c . W hie t
he e t e r d or l m
ai ge de h
r or a r
t
l he

elmensae u btdl difrnt t Cour woul notbebur ne b aj c tn t bra of
e t r ndou e y fee , he
t d
de d y dudiaig he e ch
contactcl ms becaus t aleged f l e t pay com m i on and unpai wages s em f om t s e
r
ai
e he l
aiur o
ssi
d
t r he am
aleged actonsofDef
l
i
endant I f ,deci ng t cl m s t herw oul lkel be l oner f a
s. n act
di he ai oget
d i y ess
ous or
ti of f aleady f ii wih t em pl ent r atons p bet
rer
act r
am lar t he
oym
el i hi
ween t pari . M or
he tes
eover t
, he

br
each of contactcl m s do not pr ent noveli ues ofs at I or subs antaly pr
r
ai
es
ss
t e aw
t i l edom i e over
nat

t Fai Lab Stnd d Ac cl ms Th ,s e nalj iditon ov Couns I a V i
he r or a ars t ai . us upplme t urs ci er
t V nd s
pr .
oper

2.

Count V I I
s -X

N ext Def
, endant posi t because cl m s under Fl i s W hi l ow er Act Fl.Stt j
s
t hat
ai
orda'
stebl
,
a a.
ll 3l and Fl i sW or s Com pens i Act Fl St . j440.05,ha smiaree nt t t
2. 87,
orda'
ker
aton , a. at
2
ve i l lme s ha

d n ove l p w ih t e e e s f Pl n ifs Fa r Lab St nda ds A c c a m s t shoul not
o ot ra
t he l m nt or ai tf ' i
or a r
t l i . hey
d

c wihi t sCour' s e ntlj rs cton.Ho ve,sci l 67c doe no rquiet t
ome t n hi
ts upplme a uidi i
we r e ton 3 () s t e r ha
t Cour ' anal s wei t el ent of a caus of acton t de er i whet suppl ent
he
ts
ysi
gh he em s
e
i o t m ne
her
em al

j rs ci i pr r I t sc s Dee ansha n s ownt tdif en win s sore d c
uiditon s ope. n hi ae, fnd t ve ot h
ha fer t tese
vien e
woul be needed f Count VI I .
d
or
s -X

Deen nt alo s es ta te Cour s d de ln t e r s j iditon be a e n
f da s s ugg t h t h
t houl cie o xecie urs ci c us o
Fl i D i rctCour has ari at el
orda sti
t
tcul ed ement r r t esabls a pri a f e cas ofr alaton
s equied o t ih
m aci
e
et i i
undert Fl da W hitebl erAct How ever t El
he ori
s l ow
.
, he event Cicui has hel t i t abs
h r t
d hat n he ence of

any gui ng cas l f om Fl i s at cours t Cour i t appl t bur shitng f amewor
di
e aw r
orda t e
t, he
ts o
y he den fi r
k
esabls i cas underTil V I oft Ci lRi s Act of 1964. Si i v.Tr out Fi
t ihed n es
te I he vi ght
erm nski
ans h n.

Co p. 2l F.d 9 950 ( lh Ci.200 .Se alo Casil v Roc e Labs,I , F.App' 859,
r , 6 3 45,
1 t r 0) e s
tlo . h
. nc.467
x
86 ( lh Ci.201 (ppl ng Til VI dic i n ton a r t ito Iw t a cl m u rt e
2 1 t r 2) a yi te l s rmia i nd eala in a o ai nde h
Fl i W hite owe Ac ) Thi Cour i i i t l f miir wih Til Vl' b d s fi
orda
slbl r t. s
t s ntma ey a la t te ls ur en-hitng
fa ewor a woul no be bur ne i a yi g i t c ai s unde Fl i s W hitebl
rm
k nd
d t
de d n ppl n t o l m
r orda'
sl oweran
d

W or er Co ns ton Acs F. ,M a s v M i k s mpe a i
t . g. s o . amiDadeC+. 465 F. p. 1 1 ( D.Fl
,
sup 2d 260, 263 S. a.

2 0 ) afd 2 7 FAp x 1 0 ( 1h Ci.2 0 ) J n sv WinDii Strs I c,7 F.S p 2
0 6 . f 's 4 . p' 9 1 t r 0 7 ; o e . n - xe o e , n 5 u p. d
l ,1 ( D, a.1 9) qf' 203F.d84 ( 1hCi.l 9)
357 361 S. Fl 99 , f #,
3 2 1 t r 99 .
Accor ngl t Cour deni Def
di y, he
t
es endant moton becaus Count I I ars out of t
s' i
e
s V- X ie
he

s me n lusofop aitfc a te FarLa Sa r Ac cai a t prn plsofj ci
a uce
ertv a t s h i bor tndads t l ms nd he ici e udi al
econom y, conveni
ence, and f r s t t par i r r t t Cour exer s suppl ent
aines o he tes equie hat he
t
cie
em al

j iditon.
urs ci
B.

Faiure t St e a Cl m
l o at
ai

Def
endant ar t tCount I and V f br ch ofcont ctm us be dim istd pur
s gue ha
sV
or ea
ra
t
s s
suantt
o

Fe r Rul ofCi lPr e e 1 b)6)frf lr t saeacam upo whihr ifc nbegrntd.
deal e
vi oc dur 2( ( o aiue o tt li
n c ele a
ae
l Def da s vi w , t Am en d Com pl i i a l t a l ge a t r s of a e pl e t
n
en nt ' e he
de
a nt s is o le
f
ny e m
n m oym n
agr ent i udi paym entt
eem , ncl ng
enms.'
'
Pl ntf s Am ended Com pl nt sat , i r evant par, t Pl ntf and D ef
ai if
ai t es n el
t hat ai if
endant %wer
sl e

e a d i av b a ee twhee yPli ifwoul bee oy d b ( ee nt asaI ks t
ng ge n eral gr men
rb antf
d mpl e y Dlfnda s
oc mih,

a d Pli ifwoul b c nstdasta ntde ndi o tedifc t oft j b p ror d.
n antf
d e ompe ae e mou , pe ng n h fs uly he o ef me '
'
' en n ll ...f ld t pa Pl ntf f wor p f me fom a r mael Nov er20l
t
Def da ts
aie o y ai if or k eror d r pp oxi t y emb
6
u i Fe u r 201 5Fi ly,i antf s f r d da ge a ar s tofDe en nts )b e ch ofs i
ntl br a y 7. nal ç i if ufe e ma s s e ul
5
pl
f da g' r a
ad
agr ent' Vi
eem .' ewed i t lghtm os f abl t hi ,Pl ntf aleges t t pari had an or
n he i
t avor e o m ai if l
hat he tes
al

a e n,d ciedtec enstontr (amel t tte v idbae ontej sdifc t)
greme t esrb h omp ai ems n y ha h y are sd h ob' fiuly,
and s outa s fc 3et
pecii mont perod t Def
h i hat endant alegedl di notcom pl w ih t agr ent
s l
y d
y t he eem .
Res vi al i er
ol ng 1 nf ences i f
n avorof Pl ntf, t Cour fnds t Count I and V s at a cl m f
ai if he
t i hat
sV
t e ai or
5

r i t i pl bl on is f A ccor ngl Def
elef hat s ausi e
t ace.
di y, endant 'm oton i deni on t basi off l e
s
i s
ed
he
s aiur
t sat a cl m .
o t e ai
lV.C ON CLUSI N
O

Def
endant ' M oton t Di is i deni becaus Count I -X ars out of t s e
s
i o sm s s
ed
e
s V I
ie
hc am
nucl ofoper i f and becaus Count I and V pl i y s at a cl m upon w hi r i can
eus
atve act
e
sV
ausbl t e ai
ch elef
be gr ed.
ant
,

DON E AN D ORD ERED i Cham ber atM i i Fl i t s .t*
n
s
am , orda, hi pe

( NSeptem ber2017.
of

.
.

l'è'
'e
'
'
' A.
,. . .

'

. .'
- WX
'

e

ft .
;
.

.. z
)
'
.

.

FED ERI A .M O RE
C
UN I
TED STATES DI
STRI JU DGE
CT
Copi f nihed t
es ur s
o:
Couns ofRecor
el
d

6