Ean Properties, Inc v. Chubb Custom Insurance Company
Filing
12
ORDER Granting 3 Motion for Summary Judgment. Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 5/17/2018. (jw) NOTICE: If there are sealed documents in this case, they may be unsealed after 1 year or as directed by Court Order, unless they have been designated to be permanently sealed. See Local Rule 5.4 and Administrative Order 2014-69.
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRICT CO URT
SO UTHERN DI
STR I O F FLORI
CT
DA
M I IDI SI N
AM
VI O
CA SE NO,1723024- V- N G
Cl K1
EAN PROPERTI I C,
ES, N ,
Pl ntf ,
ai if
VS.
CHUBB CU STOM I SUR ANCE
N
COM PANY,
De e nt
f nda .
/
O RDER G M NTI G M O TI N FOR SU M M ARY JUDG M ENT
N
O
TH I M A TTER com esbef e t Cour upon Def
S
or he
t
endantChubb Cus om
t
l u a eCompa (i ub s Ame de M oto f rSu ma y J gme ta
ns r nc
ny t
ch b')
n d i n o m r ud n nd
l o po a e M e a um ofLa ( 3) fldNov mbe 3, 1 1
nc r r td mor nd
w DE , ie
e r 20 7.
BA CK G R OU ND
Th Dee a tmove frs
e fnd n
s o ummayj gme ont b sst tPli ifi
r ud nt he a i ha antf s
at
temptng t r ltga e a lw s tt tw aspr ous y r ol d by w ay ofa Consde i
i o e-ii t a ui ha
evi l es ve
ntal
Mu ua Ree s a Se t me tAg e me t(s tlme tAg e me t' TheDe e a t
t l la e nd tl n r e n t te n r e n .)
e
se
'
f nd n
a guest asa r ul oft s te e ,t Pl ntf a eed t w ai and r eas any and
r
hat
es t he etl m nt he ai if gr
o ve
el e
al cl i st i has now orm ay ha i t f ur a ns Chubb r at d i a way t
1 a m hat t
ve n he ut e gai t
el e n ny
o
t dam a ale by Pl ntf conce ni cl m num be W 1 7 5787A 9 The
he
ges l ged
ai if
r ng ai
r 11C.
1 eCo r h sa diinal c nsd r dt Pli tf' Re po s ( 7 fld o No e r
Th u t a d to ly o ie e he an ifs s n e DE ) ie n v mbe
1 , 01 a d Ch b sRe y ( 1 )fld o Nov mbe 22 201
7 2 7 n u b' pl DE 1 ie n e r , 7,
Pl ntf ,i t n,diput t i a eed t w ai and r eas any and a 1cl m saga ns
ai if n ur s es hat t gr
o
ve
el e
1 ai
i t
Chubb r a e t t da agesconce ni cl m num berW KFCelt d o he m
r ng ai
5787A 9. The Pl i if
a ntf
ar
guest tt unde l ng l ws ta Se tem entA gr m ente r
ha he
ryi a ui nd tl
ee
r oneousy com bi d
l
ne
as ct oft o cli st tw asoverooked by bot pa i
pe s w a m ha
l
h rtes.
LEG AL STAN DA RD
i mmayj dg n i a pr p it wheet pla ng a s ppo tngmaeil
i
su r u me t s p o rae r he e di s nd u ri
tras
esabls t t r i no ge ne is ast any m a eralf ta t tt m ovi pa t i
t ih hat he e s
nui s ue o
t i a nd ha he
ng ry s
e ildt j me a amatro lw. CeotxCop. .Catet477U. 31 3 2
ntte o udg nt s te f a ' l e r v r t,
'
S. 7, 2
( 9 6) Fe R. v. 5 a . ummayj dg ntdspr e l rgade no a a
1 8 ) d. Ci P. 6() S
r u me l op ry e r d t s
i
dif vor d pr
s a e ocedur s t ut butr hera a i egr pa4 oft Feder Rul as a
al horc ,
at s n nt al l he
al es
whoe whihaed sg dt s c et j t s e ygla i xp nsved tr nain o
l, c r e ine o e ur he us, pe d , nd ne e i eemi to f
e e y a to 'Pac v Ca i c 28 F.d 1 ,1 4( t Ci. 002 .S
v r cin. e . poban o, 3 3 275 28 11h r 2 ) umma y
'
r
j mt ti a pr raeu est r i ag n neis o fc frtilAge v Pore ,
udg n s p op it nls hee s e ui sue f a t o ra. e . tr
21 F. p' 83 8 ( 1h Ci. 00 ) ' rf cua is e t bec nsde e ge n
6 Ap x 7, 40 1 t r 2 7 .i a t l s u s o o i r d nuie,
Fo
t ymu tha ar a ba i i t rc r 'Miev Jyes Cf Bd.fEd .9 F.
he s ve e l ss n he e o d. z . e ron f o uc, 3 3d
'
y
7 9, 2( 1hCi.1 96 .no po i amoinf rs mmayj me t t no mo n
3 74 1 t r 9 ) I p sng
to o u r udg n,he n vig
pa t t us s
ry t t how s cik f ct t s
m
pe t a s o uppor t tt e i a genui diput 'Ander on v
t ha her s
ne s e.'
s
.
LJe / Lobb I . 47 U. 242 2 ( 98 ) Theno mo ngpa t ma no r l o t
' ry
à
y nc, 7 S. , 48 1 6 .
n vi ry y t e y n he
pl adi ,butr hermus de onsr t a genui is f t i t ough af vis
e ngs
at
t m tae
ne s ue or ral hr
sda t ,
de ii ,i er oga or a wer a adm isi .Cel e 477 U .S.323- The
postons nt r t y ns s, nd
s ons
ot x,
24.
e senc ofa çm e e s ntla ' evi nce i s
xit e
' r ci il ' of de
n uppor oft nonm ovi pa t s poston i
t he
ng ry'
ii s
i uficint t r m us be e de on whi h t tnde of f tcoul r ona y fnd f r
ns t e ; he e
t vi nce
c he i r ac
d eas bl i o
t mo n pa t Na 'Ca .Co. . c e s 58 F. x 8 9,8 0- ( 1hCi. 01
he vi g ry. tl s v Pik n , 2 App' 3 4 41 1 t r 2 4)
( u tng Wale v Dar y, 1F.d 1 73 1 ( 1h Ci.1 0) .
q oi
k r . b 91 2 5 , 577 1 t r 99 )
DISC USSI N
O
Upon r ew oft f sand l lar e s t under i
evi
he act
ega gum nt , he
s gned sndsper uasve
s i
a a o sDee a tslga agu nt i s ppo to ismoto frs
nd d pt fnd n ' e l r me s n u r f t in o ummayj gme ,
r ud nt
whi sand unr buted by Pl ntf .The l ngua oft Setl entA gr em e i
ch t
e t
ai if
a
ge he tem
e nt s
unequi
vocal The Pl nt f a kst Cour t s asde t Setl entA gr m e due t
.
ai i f s he
t o et i he tem
ee nt
o
Smut m i t ke,'butofer no e denc orar e t s
s ual s a '
f s
vi e
gum nt o uppor isposton t tt
tt
ii ha he
pari agr ed t ent i o a s tl m entt ti dif e t whati cont ned i t
tes e o er nt e te
ha s fer nt han
s
ai n he
Setem e A gr em ent t r t bass ofPl ntf m oton i isr es atve'
tl nt e
.Ra he , he i
ai i fs
i s t epr ent i s
unia e a beleft tt underyi l w s ttl aga ns Chubb r a ed t an e iel
lt r l i ha he
l ng a ui i ed i t
el t o
ntr y
dif r ntcl m . I s t t a t vi pr e ed by t Pl ntf pr e sno e denc ofa
ft t ai n hor, he fsda t es nt
he ai if es nt
vi e
m ut m it t w oul alow f t s rousr edy ofr f m a i orr son ofa
ual sake hat
d l or he e i em
e or ton eces i
mut l ag eed s tem e agr entt tw asnegotat w ih t as i t nce ofw e l
ualy r
etl nt eem
ha
i ed t he s s a
l-
taned a sophitca ed c
ri
nd
s i t ouns .
el
Th rfr , ummayj me ts lb e ee i fvo o De e ntChub a d
eeo e s
r udg n hal e ntr d n a r f fnda
bn
a i tPl ntf Ean Pr ri s,l
gans ai if
ope te nc.
CO N CLU SI N
O
The e or i i O RD ER ED ,A DJUD G ED ,and DECR EED t D ef nda
r f e, t s
hat e nt
Chubb Cusom I ur nce Compa sM oton f Sum m ar J
t ns a
ny'
i or
y udgm enta l
nd ncom or t
a ed
M e r nd ofLa ( 3 be a d t s me i, r b GR ANTED. Th Pli tf s
mo a um
w DE ) , n he a s he e y
e an if
3
M o i n f rLe vet FieFis Ame e Co a n ( 6 i he e DENI . A l
to o a o l r t nd d mpli t DE ) s r by
ED
l
pe ng m otonsa e deni d asm oot The Cl k s lCl e t s ca ,
ndi
i
r
e
.
er hal os hi se
DO NE AN D O RD ERED i Cha ber a J m es La r
n
m s t a
w ence K i Unied St t
ng
t
a es
Co tou e i M imiFlrd ,hi I d yofMa 201
urh s ,n a , o ia t s
a
y, 8
.
A< S LA RENCE K I
N
U NI
TED STA TES DI
ST
J GE
UD
SOUTHERN DISTRI OF LORI A
C
D
Cc: Al counselofr
l
ecor
d
4
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?