Rafael Sandigo Aguinaga v. E.T. Zacapa Group Corp. et al
Filing
23
ORDER denying 19 Motion to Quash. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 6/6/2018. (da00)
UN I
TED STATES D I
STRI COU RT FO R THE
CT
SOU THERN D I
STRI O F FLORI A
CT
D
M im iDi son
a
vii
C as N um be 1 23052- 1 M O R EN O
e
r: 7C VD ONA LD RAFA EL SAN DI O A GU I G A,
G
NA
a a lo he s sm ia l s t t
nd l t r i l ry iua ed,
Pli if
antf,
VS
.
E. ZACAPA GROUP CORP. CANCHE
T.
,
CA RPEN TRY ,I C. a CESA R TU RCI S,
N , nd
O
Def nda s
e nt .
O R D ER D ENY I G D EFEN DA N T' M O TI N TO D I
N
S
O
SSO LV E W R I O F
T
GARNI
SHM ENT.OUASH SERVI OF PROCESS.AND SET ASI DEFAULT AND
CE
DE
D EFA U LT JUD G M ENT
THI CAUSE ca e bef e t Cour upon Def nda ' M o i t Dis ve W rt of
S
m
or he
t
e nts ton o s ol
i
Gamihme ,Quas Ser ceofPr s ,a Se AsdeDea tandDeaul J
s nt
h vi
oce s nd t i
ful
f t udgme ( E.1 ,
nt D. 9)
fl on M av3.201 Pli iftl hi Re pons t Defnda ' Moton ( E.21 on M a 1
ied
8. antf ied s s e o e nts i D. )
v 6.
2018.
Fe r Rul ofCi lPr dur 55()pr de t ta ç our may stasdean e r of
deal e
vi oce e c ovi s ha s t
c
e i
nty
d futfr g o c u e a d i ma s ta ie a fn ld futj dg n u d rRu e6 ( )' Rue
ea l o o d a s , n t y e sd i a ea l u me t n e l 0 b . l
'
60( ( )pr desf r i fom afnalj
b)1 ovi or elef r
i udgme f te usbl neglc'upo a moton ma
nt or sxc a e e t' n
i
de
w ihi a t e ona e tm e ' if e de er i i of w ha c tt e e
t n
i as bl i .' l '
r
-h
t m naton
t ons iut s xcus bl ne ec i
a e gl t s
ge r ly a e t bl one,t ki i t a coun t t t lt oft c r um s a es s r
ne a l n quia e
a ng n o c
t he o a iy
he i c t nc ur oundi t
ng he
pat s omison. Sl sI .Cor v.Eurs ,488 F.d 922,93 ( 1h Ci.2007)(ii
ry'
si ' os ndus p.
'
iol
3
4 1t r
ctng
Pi erl Se v.Co v Br wi Asoc.Lt Parne s p,5 U. 38 38 3 ( 993).
one nv. rs . . uns ck s
d. t r hi 07 S. 0, 9, 95 1 )
Def nda E. Za pa Gr up a kst s Cour t dis ve t wrtofga nihm e , qua h
e nt T. ca
o s hi
t o s ol he i
r s nt s
s r c o p o e s a d s ta ie d f uta d d futj d e n o t e g o n st a sr ie o
evie f r c s , n e sd e a l n ea l u g me t n h r u d h t evc f
pr e s w a i va i O n Aug t 1 201 Pl n if s pr e s s r s r d Ce a Tur i wih a
oe s
s n ld.
us 7, 7, ai tf
oc s e ver e ve
s r c os t
c oft s m ons a c pl i a l 27 N W 1 tSt e t M i m i FL 331 Pl i tf co e
opy he um
nd om a nt t 8
s re, a ,
25. a n if nt nds
t tCes r Tur i w a t r i t r a ntof E. Zac pa G r a C a he Ca pe r I a
ha
a
c os s he eg s e ed ge
T. a
oup nd nc
r nty, nc. t
t tm e ofs r i e.
he i
e vc
De enda E. Za a Gr
f
nt T. c pa oup di put Pl i if s c entons a gui t t s r c of
s es a ntf
ont i , r ng ha e vi e
pr e s on Ces Tur i cn
oc s
ar c os nnotc tt e va i s r c a t E. Za pa Gr p be us Ces r
ons iut ld e vi e s o T. ca
ou ca e a
Turi i ia i vi lunr ae t t cor r i ' ( f' M o.at5. I ed,Edua do
cos s 'n ndi dua eltd o he poaton. De .s t
'
) nde
r
Tur i ,w ho c a m st be t Pr s de ofD e e
c os
li o
he e i nt
f ndantE. Zac pa G r p,s e unde oa h i a
T. a
ou wor
r t n n
a fda tf om M a c 1 2018 t tCes r Tur i t sneihera of i r oft cor a i n noris
f i vi r
r h 5,
ha
a
c os '
i t
n fce
he por to
t
Re see Ag nt'( bi A.Ed r Tur osas c endst tCe a Turi ne rnotfed
gitrd e . Exhi t ) uado ci lo ont
'
ha s r cos ve ii
hi a
m boutt s r i ofpr es i t s pr ee ng.
he e v ce
oc s n hi oc di
l e e tngl i a a s t tCe a Tur i was a s bus m a ng a a f da tunde oa h
nt r s i y, t ppe r ha s r c os
l o y ki n f i vi
r t
o M ar h 1 2018.J tlke Edua do Tur os s a fdavi,Ce a Tur i ' a fda tac m pa ed
n
c 5,
us i
r
ci ' f i t s r c os s f i vi co ni
amo in t s ta ie d fu t u g n i a oh rc s wh r E. Za a a Gr u n ge td t
to o e sd ea l j d me t n n te a e ee T. c p o p e lce o
r pond t ora w e t c pl i t l t ta fda t Ce arTur os s a e ûIa t Pr i
es
o
ns r he om a n . n ha fi vi, s
ci t t d, ç m he esdentof
t Dee ntCor ai Ca heCape r I a E. Za a Gr Co1 . ( bi B.
he fnda
porton, nc
r nty, nc. nd T. c pa oup, ' ' Exhi t )
p'
l o he wor ,E. Zac pa G r p' pos ton i t s c e ie ,t t Ce a Tur i i S e a e
n t r ds T. a
ou s ii n hi as . . ha s r c os s t l t d
unr
t t c por ton' - di e ty c lc s w ih is pos to i a r l e c e Le ,t tCes r Turos
o he or a i ' - r c l onfi t t t
ii n n e at d as
. ha
a
i
i t Pr dentofE. Zacapa G r
s he esi
T.
oup.
The Co t no e t t t Tur os ir c lbl afi vis c an a mos i ntc l
ur t s ha he
ci ' r e oncia e fda t ont i l t de ia
lnguag we e s n t a s c i d on t s m e da be o e t s m e notr a m os
a
e, r wor o nd ubs rbe
he a
y f x he a
a y, nd
t
not bl we etld on be l ofE. Za pa Gr by t s m eat ne , J r m e R a s r n. s
a y, r ie
haf
T. ca
oup he a
tor y e o
m a a Thi
Cour sr y s
t tongl ugge t t tM r Ra s r n t ke s etm e t r vi w hi ehialr s i ltes
ss ha
. m a a a om i o e e s t c e ponsbiii
a a l e ,pari a l hi dut ofc ndort r t ti
s awy r tculry s y
a
owa d he rbunal Shoul he c i t sr l
.
d
ontnue o tugg e
wih t se
t hi onee , heCour wilgl dl r e hi t t Fl rdaBa f a to lgui nc .
pt t
t l a y efr m o he o i
r or ddii na da e
Uli aey,De e ntE. Za a Gr f is t e t bls g
tm t l
f nda
T. c pa oup a l o sa ih ood ca e t dis ve t
us o s ol he
w rt of ga ni hm e t q s s vi e of pr s , a s ta ie d futa d d futj dg me t To
i
r s n , ua h er c
oce s nd e sd ea l n e a l u e n .
t e entDe e ntsconduc qualfe asneglc ,a oppos t i e i lmir pr e a i
he xt
f nda '
t
ii s
et s
ed o nt ntona se es nt ton
a d o sr cin o t e j d ca p o e s i c ranl i n t e c a l. Ac o d n l, i i
n b tu to f h u iil r c s , t e ti y s o x us be c r i gy t s
ADJ
UDGED t tDee nts M oto t Dis ve W rtof Ga nihme ,Qua h Ser ie of
ha fnda '
in o sol
i
r s nt
s
vc
Pr e s and SetAsdeDe a ta De aul J
oc s ,
i
f ul nd f t udgm e i DENI
nt s
ED.
D ON E AN D O RD ERED i Cha be s a M i m i Fl i t s
n
m r t a , orda, hi
1 o 28
f 0
1
FEDERI
CO .M OR EN O
UN I
TED STA TES D I
STRI J G E
CT UD
Co e f nihed t
pi s ur s
o:
Couns lofRe or
e
c d
.
Exhi tA
bi
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLO RI
CT
DA
DONALD RAFAEL SANDI AGUI
GO
NAGA ,
an alOt er smia l st t d u r29 U.S. 21 b)
d l h s i lry iua e nde
C. 6( ,
Ca e no.1 CVs
7- 23052
E, ZA CAPA GRO UP CORP,
T.
CAN CHE CARPEN TRY ;
CESA R TURCI S,
O
/
M TI
DAVI OF EDUARDO TURCI
T
OS
STA TE OF FLORI
DA
Count ofM i m iDade
y
a -
ls
s.
Be or me,heundt sg d a t hy, r o ly a a e EDUARDO TURCI who,
f e
t
ri ne uhor pe s nal ppe r d
OS,
bengby medul s m , pos asf l :
i
y wo de ed olows
1 t unde sg d De e n ,n o reiht e ( 8)ye r ofa ,c
,he
ri ne f ndn t m ve g e n 1 a s ge ompe e ofm a ng
tm
ki
t safi vi a pe s naly a quant dwih t fc she en saed:
hi fda t nd r o l c i e t he a t r i t t
a) Ia t Prsd toft Dce ntComorton,E. ZACAPA GROUP CORP.
m he e ien hc fnda
ai
T.
b) Theidi dua na dont Afi viofSe vcei neihe a ofieroft c
n vi l me
he fda t r i s t r n tc
he omorto
ain
norisRe se e A g nt
t gi t r d e .
c Thei vi lna e o t Afl avi ofSe vie d notr sdea t a e s 2354
)
ndi dua m d n he td t
r c oes e i t he ddr s :
N W 29t St , M i i FL 33142.
h reet am ,
d) Tha t a a twasnet rgi nkno e oft a
the m n
ihe ve
wldge he bovepr e di nornotfedbyt
oc e ng
ii
he
i vi alls e i t e A m da tofSe v c
ndi du i t d n h
vi
r i e.
Cas 1: c 23O52e 17- vFAM Docum ent19- Ent ed on FLSD Docket05/ 2018 Page 2 of2
1
er
03/
<
E
ouARoo TuRcl
ok
STATE OF FLORI :
DA
SS
CO UNTY OF
BEFORE M E,t unde i
he
rsgned aut t per onaly apN ar EDUA RDO TURCI
horiy, s l
ed
OS.
who, ei g by me frtd y s r a d c u i e sa e t tt i or a i co ai d
b n
is ul wo n n a ton d, t t d ha he nf m ton nt ne
he en i tu a c r :t t b tofhi/ rk ed a b le a who i p s ly
r i s r c nd orec o he es
she nowl ge nd e if nd
s erona l
ko tmer bpoue t '(& . qdnictn
nwno owordcd
î . G iet ao.
i A si
sw oRx To ANo SUBSCRI - bef em et s I5' uay ofM ar 2c1:.
BFD
or
bi r
H
ch,
z
'
-
r
e
ë
-
-
NöTARY PUBLI jaeofFl ia
C. tt
ord
M y Com m isi Expies:
s on
r
. #
f.
y'
AMTONI poR- t
O
r
ek
.
.
u
# r xq
!f :1Mv cogMt m l x i , ?
J
%
%fz1 . > RRESF
%
2 . @n@1
3
4
Per onaly known . .
s l
or
poid1 . f-tl t œpw
rv e . lïk î é
d 0
e
Exhi tB
bi
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI CO URT FOR THE
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI O F FLO RI
CT
DA
VI
CTOR HUGO CORDON BARAHON A , )
M YSOR RENE CORDON TRUJLLO, nd)
I
a
aI esi lr sutdudr 9U., )
lYhrs al iae ne 2 SC,
mi y t
26b,
1h)
)
Plitft)
an ifs,
Cas N o.1 CV - 4- LK
e
7- 235l J
)
)
)
)
)
V.
1cp Gopop
z AA R u c R,
A
E.
T.
CAN CHE CARPEN TRY m C.
,
)
)
)
c clA CARPENTRY I
l
NC,
cEs R w Rcl
os,
)
)
De e da t)
f n nts.
/
A FFIDAVIT O F CESAR TU RCI S
O
S/E FLRD
T O FO IA
)s .
s
Cou t o M imiDad
ny f a - e
)
Bef e m e,t under gned aut iy.per onaly appear CESAR TU RCI S,who,
or
he
si
hort
s l
ed
O
bei by m e dul s n,depos a f l s:
ng
y wor
ed s olow
1t un ri e De e da t a o reihte ( 8)y a sofag ,c mpeen ofma n
. he de sgn d f n n . m ve g e n l e r
e o tt
kig
1
t safi tand per onaly acquai ed w ih t f sher n sat
hi fdavi
s l
nt
t he act ei t ed:
a l m teDeed n i teao erfrn e matr
i a h fn a tn h b v-eee cd t .
e
b Imte rsetfh Df dnCroai ,ace apnl IcadETZcp
à a h Pei not ee atopr o CnhCret n.n ..aaa
d e n
tn
y
Gr
oup,Cor
p.
sTwidvdanme o teAmdvtfevc iniea oneo tecmoain
l niiula d nh aio- ri s et rn fcrfh o rt
s e h
o
c
l n isRe serdAg t
ort git e en.
!
!
d Th i viual
) e ndi d nmnedo teAm da tofSe vie doesnotr sdeatt eaddx s :1827
nh
vi
r c,
ei
h
s
N W l t nu ,M i i FL 3 25
SAve e am ,
31 .
Th tt a a twa n ihe gi e kn e g oft e a ov pr t di n rno i ed b t e
a he m n s e t r v n owl d t h b t oc t ng o tt y h
i
i di i al it d i t e Af vi ofSe vie.
n v du lse n h sda t
rc
CESAR TURCI
OS
l
S A/ oFF- J
T E I DA:
OR
C jT O
OU Y F
1
jBE OREME teudrindatoi ,esnl apae C S T R I , o
F
,h nes e uh rypr al perd E AR U COSwh,
g
t o y
1b igb messd l s rn and cauti st ed t tthe i orm ati oontai herei i
en y rt uy wo
oned. at ha
nf
on
ned
ns
!tu a dc retot:b so hwh r n wld ea db l f n wh iNro al k o
re n orc t h et f i e k o e g n ei a d o s sn l n wn
e
y
1t mer h poxe-Y
o ow o rd d1 l
-
$ LYf' ainictn
tS
' ï&. sd t ai .
.
en o
I
r ORN TO AND SUBSCRI b or met s 1 : d y ofMa c 20l .
SW
BED ef e hi 5h a
rh 8
F
.
OTA Y PUBLI St t ofFl i
C' a e
orda
My r si Epr :
Jmmi o xis
sn e
I
I
Per enalyknown .s l
Or
e
l'%' . A oNo
* '- r
1
C. yz
.
%
j
/.
poi dI . j S tt
xvlt . ;y
i D
,
e
.
.
.,
Exae *
Ek
t
#œ & D. *
M 1
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?