Rafael Sandigo Aguinaga v. E.T. Zacapa Group Corp. et al

Filing 23

ORDER denying 19 Motion to Quash. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 6/6/2018. (da00)

UN I
TED STATES D I
STRI COU RT FO R THE
CT
SOU THERN D I
STRI O F FLORI A
CT
D
M im iDi son
a
vii
C as N um be 1 23052- 1 M O R EN O
e
r: 7C VD ONA LD RAFA EL SAN DI O A GU I G A,
G
NA
a a lo he s sm ia l s t t
nd l t r i l ry iua ed,

Pli if
antf,
VS
.

E. ZACAPA GROUP CORP. CANCHE
T.
,
CA RPEN TRY ,I C. a CESA R TU RCI S,
N , nd
O
Def nda s
e nt .
O R D ER D ENY I G D EFEN DA N T' M O TI N TO D I
N
S
O
SSO LV E W R I O F
T

GARNI
SHM ENT.OUASH SERVI OF PROCESS.AND SET ASI DEFAULT AND
CE
DE
D EFA U LT JUD G M ENT

THI CAUSE ca e bef e t Cour upon Def nda ' M o i t Dis ve W rt of
S
m
or he
t
e nts ton o s ol
i

Gamihme ,Quas Ser ceofPr s ,a Se AsdeDea tandDeaul J
s nt
h vi
oce s nd t i
ful
f t udgme ( E.1 ,
nt D. 9)

fl on M av3.201 Pli iftl hi Re pons t Defnda ' Moton ( E.21 on M a 1
ied
8. antf ied s s e o e nts i D. )
v 6.
2018.

Fe r Rul ofCi lPr dur 55()pr de t ta ç our may stasdean e r of
deal e
vi oce e c ovi s ha s t
c
e i
nty

d futfr g o c u e a d i ma s ta ie a fn ld futj dg n u d rRu e6 ( )' Rue
ea l o o d a s , n t y e sd i a ea l u me t n e l 0 b . l
'
60( ( )pr desf r i fom afnalj
b)1 ovi or elef r
i udgme f te usbl neglc'upo a moton ma
nt or sxc a e e t' n
i
de
w ihi a t e ona e tm e ' if e de er i i of w ha c tt e e
t n
i as bl i .' l '
r
-h
t m naton
t ons iut s xcus bl ne ec i
a e gl t s
ge r ly a e t bl one,t ki i t a coun t t t lt oft c r um s a es s r
ne a l n quia e
a ng n o c
t he o a iy
he i c t nc ur oundi t
ng he

pat s omison. Sl sI .Cor v.Eurs ,488 F.d 922,93 ( 1h Ci.2007)(ii
ry'
si ' os ndus p.
'
iol
3
4 1t r
ctng
Pi erl Se v.Co v Br wi Asoc.Lt Parne s p,5 U. 38 38 3 ( 993).
one nv. rs . . uns ck s
d. t r hi 07 S. 0, 9, 95 1 )

Def nda E. Za pa Gr up a kst s Cour t dis ve t wrtofga nihm e , qua h
e nt T. ca
o s hi
t o s ol he i
r s nt s

s r c o p o e s a d s ta ie d f uta d d futj d e n o t e g o n st a sr ie o
evie f r c s , n e sd e a l n ea l u g me t n h r u d h t evc f
pr e s w a i va i O n Aug t 1 201 Pl n if s pr e s s r s r d Ce a Tur i wih a
oe s
s n ld.
us 7, 7, ai tf
oc s e ver e ve
s r c os t
c oft s m ons a c pl i a l 27 N W 1 tSt e t M i m i FL 331 Pl i tf co e
opy he um
nd om a nt t 8
s re, a ,
25. a n if nt nds
t tCes r Tur i w a t r i t r a ntof E. Zac pa G r a C a he Ca pe r I a
ha
a
c os s he eg s e ed ge
T. a
oup nd nc
r nty, nc. t
t tm e ofs r i e.
he i
e vc
De enda E. Za a Gr
f
nt T. c pa oup di put Pl i if s c entons a gui t t s r c of
s es a ntf
ont i , r ng ha e vi e
pr e s on Ces Tur i cn
oc s
ar c os nnotc tt e va i s r c a t E. Za pa Gr p be us Ces r
ons iut ld e vi e s o T. ca
ou ca e a

Turi i ia i vi lunr ae t t cor r i ' ( f' M o.at5. I ed,Edua do
cos s 'n ndi dua eltd o he poaton. De .s t
'
) nde
r
Tur i ,w ho c a m st be t Pr s de ofD e e
c os
li o
he e i nt
f ndantE. Zac pa G r p,s e unde oa h i a
T. a
ou wor
r t n n
a fda tf om M a c 1 2018 t tCes r Tur i t sneihera of i r oft cor a i n noris
f i vi r
r h 5,
ha
a
c os '
i t
n fce
he por to
t

Re see Ag nt'( bi A.Ed r Tur osas c endst tCe a Turi ne rnotfed
gitrd e . Exhi t ) uado ci lo ont
'
ha s r cos ve ii
hi a
m boutt s r i ofpr es i t s pr ee ng.
he e v ce
oc s n hi oc di
l e e tngl i a a s t tCe a Tur i was a s bus m a ng a a f da tunde oa h
nt r s i y, t ppe r ha s r c os
l o y ki n f i vi
r t
o M ar h 1 2018.J tlke Edua do Tur os s a fdavi,Ce a Tur i ' a fda tac m pa ed
n
c 5,
us i
r
ci ' f i t s r c os s f i vi co ni

amo in t s ta ie d fu t u g n i a oh rc s wh r E. Za a a Gr u n ge td t
to o e sd ea l j d me t n n te a e ee T. c p o p e lce o
r pond t ora w e t c pl i t l t ta fda t Ce arTur os s a e ûIa t Pr i
es
o
ns r he om a n . n ha fi vi, s
ci t t d, ç m he esdentof

t Dee ntCor ai Ca heCape r I a E. Za a Gr Co1 . ( bi B.
he fnda
porton, nc
r nty, nc. nd T. c pa oup, ' ' Exhi t )
p'
l o he wor ,E. Zac pa G r p' pos ton i t s c e ie ,t t Ce a Tur i i S e a e
n t r ds T. a
ou s ii n hi as . . ha s r c os s t l t d
unr
t t c por ton' - di e ty c lc s w ih is pos to i a r l e c e Le ,t tCes r Turos
o he or a i ' - r c l onfi t t t
ii n n e at d as
. ha
a
i
i t Pr dentofE. Zacapa G r
s he esi
T.
oup.

The Co t no e t t t Tur os ir c lbl afi vis c an a mos i ntc l
ur t s ha he
ci ' r e oncia e fda t ont i l t de ia
lnguag we e s n t a s c i d on t s m e da be o e t s m e notr a m os
a
e, r wor o nd ubs rbe
he a
y f x he a
a y, nd
t
not bl we etld on be l ofE. Za pa Gr by t s m eat ne , J r m e R a s r n. s
a y, r ie
haf
T. ca
oup he a
tor y e o
m a a Thi
Cour sr y s
t tongl ugge t t tM r Ra s r n t ke s etm e t r vi w hi ehialr s i ltes
ss ha
. m a a a om i o e e s t c e ponsbiii

a a l e ,pari a l hi dut ofc ndort r t ti
s awy r tculry s y
a
owa d he rbunal Shoul he c i t sr l
.
d
ontnue o tugg e
wih t se
t hi onee , heCour wilgl dl r e hi t t Fl rdaBa f a to lgui nc .
pt t
t l a y efr m o he o i
r or ddii na da e
Uli aey,De e ntE. Za a Gr f is t e t bls g
tm t l
f nda
T. c pa oup a l o sa ih ood ca e t dis ve t
us o s ol he
w rt of ga ni hm e t q s s vi e of pr s , a s ta ie d futa d d futj dg me t To
i
r s n , ua h er c
oce s nd e sd ea l n e a l u e n .

t e entDe e ntsconduc qualfe asneglc ,a oppos t i e i lmir pr e a i
he xt
f nda '
t
ii s
et s
ed o nt ntona se es nt ton

a d o sr cin o t e j d ca p o e s i c ranl i n t e c a l. Ac o d n l, i i
n b tu to f h u iil r c s , t e ti y s o x us be c r i gy t s
ADJ
UDGED t tDee nts M oto t Dis ve W rtof Ga nihme ,Qua h Ser ie of
ha fnda '
in o sol
i
r s nt
s
vc
Pr e s and SetAsdeDe a ta De aul J
oc s ,
i
f ul nd f t udgm e i DENI
nt s
ED.

D ON E AN D O RD ERED i Cha be s a M i m i Fl i t s
n
m r t a , orda, hi

1 o 28
f 0
1

FEDERI
CO .M OR EN O
UN I
TED STA TES D I
STRI J G E
CT UD
Co e f nihed t
pi s ur s
o:
Couns lofRe or
e
c d

.

Exhi tA
bi
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLO RI
CT
DA
DONALD RAFAEL SANDI AGUI
GO
NAGA ,
an alOt er smia l st t d u r29 U.S. 21 b)
d l h s i lry iua e nde
C. 6( ,

Ca e no.1 CVs
7- 23052

E, ZA CAPA GRO UP CORP,
T.
CAN CHE CARPEN TRY ;
CESA R TURCI S,
O
/

M TI
DAVI OF EDUARDO TURCI
T
OS

STA TE OF FLORI
DA

Count ofM i m iDade
y
a -

ls
s.

Be or me,heundt sg d a t hy, r o ly a a e EDUARDO TURCI who,
f e
t
ri ne uhor pe s nal ppe r d
OS,
bengby medul s m , pos asf l :
i
y wo de ed olows

1 t unde sg d De e n ,n o reiht e ( 8)ye r ofa ,c
,he
ri ne f ndn t m ve g e n 1 a s ge ompe e ofm a ng
tm
ki
t safi vi a pe s naly a quant dwih t fc she en saed:
hi fda t nd r o l c i e t he a t r i t t

a) Ia t Prsd toft Dce ntComorton,E. ZACAPA GROUP CORP.
m he e ien hc fnda
ai
T.
b) Theidi dua na dont Afi viofSe vcei neihe a ofieroft c
n vi l me
he fda t r i s t r n tc
he omorto
ain
norisRe se e A g nt
t gi t r d e .

c Thei vi lna e o t Afl avi ofSe vie d notr sdea t a e s 2354
)
ndi dua m d n he td t
r c oes e i t he ddr s :
N W 29t St , M i i FL 33142.
h reet am ,

d) Tha t a a twasnet rgi nkno e oft a
the m n
ihe ve
wldge he bovepr e di nornotfedbyt
oc e ng
ii
he
i vi alls e i t e A m da tofSe v c
ndi du i t d n h
vi
r i e.

Cas 1: c 23O52e 17- vFAM Docum ent19- Ent ed on FLSD Docket05/ 2018 Page 2 of2
1
er
03/

<

E
ouARoo TuRcl
ok
STATE OF FLORI :
DA
SS

CO UNTY OF

BEFORE M E,t unde i
he
rsgned aut t per onaly apN ar EDUA RDO TURCI
horiy, s l
ed
OS.

who, ei g by me frtd y s r a d c u i e sa e t tt i or a i co ai d
b n
is ul wo n n a ton d, t t d ha he nf m ton nt ne

he en i tu a c r :t t b tofhi/ rk ed a b le a who i p s ly
r i s r c nd orec o he es
she nowl ge nd e if nd
s erona l

ko tmer bpoue t '(& . qdnictn
nwno owordcd
î . G iet ao.
i A si
sw oRx To ANo SUBSCRI - bef em et s I5' uay ofM ar 2c1:.
BFD
or
bi r
H
ch,
z

'

-

r
e

ë

-

-

NöTARY PUBLI jaeofFl ia
C. tt
ord
M y Com m isi Expies:
s on
r
. #
f.
y'

AMTONI poR- t
O
r
ek

.
.
u
# r xq
!f :1Mv cogMt m l x i , ?
J
%
%fz1 . > RRESF
%
2 . @n@1
3
4

Per onaly known . .
s l
or

poid1 . f-tl t œpw
rv e . lïk î é
d 0
e

Exhi tB
bi
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI CO URT FOR THE
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI O F FLO RI
CT
DA
VI
CTOR HUGO CORDON BARAHON A , )

M YSOR RENE CORDON TRUJLLO, nd)
I
a

aI esi lr sutdudr 9U., )
lYhrs al iae ne 2 SC,
mi y t

26b,
1h)

)
Plitft)
an ifs,

Cas N o.1 CV - 4- LK
e
7- 235l J

)
)
)
)
)

V.

1cp Gopop
z AA R u c R,
A

E.
T.

CAN CHE CARPEN TRY m C.
,

)
)
)

c clA CARPENTRY I
l
NC,
cEs R w Rcl
os,

)
)

De e da t)
f n nts.

/

A FFIDAVIT O F CESAR TU RCI S
O

S/E FLRD
T O FO IA

)s .
s

Cou t o M imiDad
ny f a - e

)

Bef e m e,t under gned aut iy.per onaly appear CESAR TU RCI S,who,
or
he
si
hort
s l
ed
O

bei by m e dul s n,depos a f l s:
ng
y wor
ed s olow

1t un ri e De e da t a o reihte ( 8)y a sofag ,c mpeen ofma n
. he de sgn d f n n . m ve g e n l e r
e o tt
kig

1
t safi tand per onaly acquai ed w ih t f sher n sat
hi fdavi
s l
nt
t he act ei t ed:

a l m teDeed n i teao erfrn e matr
i a h fn a tn h b v-eee cd t .
e

b Imte rsetfh Df dnCroai ,ace apnl IcadETZcp
à a h Pei not ee atopr o CnhCret n.n ..aaa
d e n
tn
y
Gr
oup,Cor
p.

sTwidvdanme o teAmdvtfevc iniea oneo tecmoain
l niiula d nh aio- ri s et rn fcrfh o rt
s e h
o

c

l n isRe serdAg t
ort git e en.

!
!

d Th i viual
) e ndi d nmnedo teAm da tofSe vie doesnotr sdeatt eaddx s :1827
nh
vi
r c,
ei
h
s
N W l t nu ,M i i FL 3 25
SAve e am ,
31 .
Th tt a a twa n ihe gi e kn e g oft e a ov pr t di n rno i ed b t e
a he m n s e t r v n owl d t h b t oc t ng o tt y h
i
i di i al it d i t e Af vi ofSe vie.
n v du lse n h sda t
rc

CESAR TURCI
OS

l

S A/ oFF- J
T E I DA:
OR

C jT O
OU Y F
1

jBE OREME teudrindatoi ,esnl apae C S T R I , o
F
,h nes e uh rypr al perd E AR U COSwh,
g
t o y

1b igb messd l s rn and cauti st ed t tthe i orm ati oontai herei i
en y rt uy wo
oned. at ha
nf
on
ned
ns
!tu a dc retot:b so hwh r n wld ea db l f n wh iNro al k o
re n orc t h et f i e k o e g n ei a d o s sn l n wn
e
y
1t mer h poxe-Y
o ow o rd d1 l
-

$ LYf' ainictn
tS
' ï&. sd t ai .
.
en o

I
r ORN TO AND SUBSCRI b or met s 1 : d y ofMa c 20l .
SW
BED ef e hi 5h a
rh 8

F
.

OTA Y PUBLI St t ofFl i
C' a e
orda

My r si Epr :
Jmmi o xis
sn e
I
I
Per enalyknown .s l
Or

e
l'%' . A oNo
* '- r
1
C. yz
.

%
j

/.

poi dI . j S tt
xvlt . ;y
i D
,

e
.
.
.,

Exae *

Ek
t

#œ & D. *
M 1