Zeltiq Aesthetics, Inc. v. Narotique Beauty Bar, Inc. et al

Filing 30

ORDER denying 16 Defendant Robinson's Motion to Quash. Robinson shall file an answer to the complaint no later than 12/12/2017. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 11/28/2017. (kcg)

UN I
TED STATES D I
STRJ CO U RT FO R TH E
CT
SOU THERN DI
STR I O F FLORI A
CT
D
M i m iD i son
a
vi i
C as N um be 17e
r: 23053- I - O R EN O
C V M

ZELTI AESTHETI I ,
Q
CS,NC.
Pl ntf ,
ai if
V S.

NAROTI
QUE BEAUTY BAR,I d//
NC. ba
NAROTI
QUE BEAUTY BAR OR
NAROTI TEETH W HI
QUE
TENW G
SERVI
CES,a CASSANDRA ROBI
nd
NSON,
D e enda s
f
nt .
/

ORDER DENYI DEFENDANT RO BI
NG
NSON ' M O TI TO O UASH
S
ON
Thi tade a k di put wmsbr htby Zeli Aes he i , nc.a ns N a otque Bea y
sr m r s e
oug
tq
t tcs l
gai t r i
ut

Ba ,l a Na otque' owner Ca s ndr Robi on.Zetq i amedi lt c ogy c
r nc. nd r i s
, sa a
ns
li s
ca e hnol
ompa
ny
t townsori t e us ve lc e ofa pr es know n a Cr i ys s a non-nvasve
ha
s he xcl i i ens e
oc s
s yolpol i ,
i i

pr e e i vi fe i f tcel wihoutdama ng s n.Zetq mar t isCr i yss
oc dur nvol ng r ezng a ls t
gi ki
li
ke s t yolpol i
de cea s t m unde t r se edtade ksZetq* ,Cool ul i
vi nd yse
r he egitr r mar
li
sc ptng@,Cr lpol i* ,
m i yss
a Snowfa Desgnm a ks whih i diti e e usvel t a horze m e ca
nd
l ke i
r , c t srbut s xcl i y o ut i d di l
pr e sona s Zeli a l est tNar i a riesa ç
of s i l . tq leg ha
otque dve ts
i sc ptng'body s ul i
cool ul i '
c ptng

te t n .Th ,tb o g tti f u - omt o lit le i :( )fd rl rd mak
r ame t us i r u h h s o rc t c mpan algng 1 e e a ta e r
co efii a i rnge nt ( fde a f s a tsnga fledesg tonoforgi (
untretng nd nfi me ; 2) e r l ale dverii nd as inai
i n; 3)
fderlta maki rnge nta unfi c
e a rde r nfi me nd ar ompeii a ( vi ai ofFl i sDe ptve
tton; nd 4) olton
orda' ce i
a U nf i Tr de Pr c i sA c .
nd
ar a
a tce t
On A ug t 1 201 t s m ons a c pl i w e e s r ed on bot D ef nda s The
us 7, 7, he um
nd om a nt r e v
h
e nt .
pr vi d a es w a va an . The pr es s r ert n a t m pt d a s ond a e s w he e
o de ddr s s c t
oc s e v he te e
ec
ddr s , r

Gl sor Robi on wass r ed i hi ca ciy a f t ra co-e i ntofCas a aRo ns
af d
ns
e v n s pa t s ahe nd r sde
s ndr bi on.

Nao iu a we e t ec mplitwi o to j ci t s r ie Ho v r Ro is nflda
r tq e ns r d h o an t u be t o e vc . we e , bn o ie
h
ng
m o i n t qua h s r i ofpr es . Z e tq r ponded, a Robi o c e nott r pl
t o o s e v ce
oc s 1 li es
nd
ns n hos
o e y.

Robi o a gue t tt a es lse on t s
ns n r s ha he ddr s it d
he umm onsi no he a es ,a t ta
s t r ddr s nd ha
dii n s a ch oft publcr c dswoul r ve he cure a es . Thus Robi o a gue
lge t e r
he
i e or
d e al r r nt ddr s
,
ns n r s
t tt a e swhe e s r i wa e f ct t d wasnothe t ualpl eofa
ha he ddr s
r e vce s fe ua e
rl
us
ac
bode, a s he
' nd o r
'
f t rc d nota ce s r c on he be l.Robi on' ar
ahe oul
c pt e vie
r haf
ns s gume f isf t r s ns Fis,
nt a l or wo ea o . r t
s ha no s
he s t ubmit s fcente de t s
ted ufi i vi nce o how t ts doesnotr sde a t addr s s r ed.
ha he
e i t he
es ev

Se ond,t motondoesnotcompl wihLoc lRul 7.( ( .
c
he i
y t
a e 1a)3)
A de e nts e ng t qua h s r c ofpr es S us s w i ldiy ofs v c by c ea
f nda e ki o
s e vi e
oc s t t ho nva i t
m
er i e
l r

a c ncngpr be or bengentte t a or rgr ntng am oton t q s Any co lc
nd onvi i
oof f e i
ild o n de a i
i o ua h.
nfit
i t pa te 'a fda t orpladi s d ber s ve i f voroft pl i if' Kammona v
n he ris fi vis
e ngs houl
e ol d n a
he antf .
'
.

OntchCop. 587Fe App' 575,578( 1hCi.201 (ntma cttonsomitd) He e
e
r ,
d. x
1 t r 4) i e l iai
te . r ,
alhough Robi on diput st ts r i a t a e ss r ed,s hasnots itd any
t
ns
s e ha he esdes t he ddr s e v he
ubm te
afi vi o o he e de et r f t t e de e i t Afi visofSe v c s
fda t r t r vi nc o e u e he vi nc n he fda t
r i e howi t tbot
ng ha h
De e nt we epr l s r ed. W ih onl a ba e a s ton t tRobi on di notr i a t
f nda s r opery e v
t
y
r s eri ha
ns
d
esde t he
a e ss r ed,a e s
ddr s e v
bs nt uppor ora r t t Zetq' e de ,Robi on doe notove come
t ny ebutal o li s vi nce
ns
s
r
Zetq' e denc wih c e rand c ncngpr t ts r cewa i i Se i a 579.
li s vi e t l a
onvi i
oof ha e vi
s nvald. e d. t

Furhe ,Loca Rul 7.( ( rquie amova t ( )co e i goodfihwiht
tr
l e 1a)3) e rs
nt o: 1 nfr n
at t he

o po i pat p i rt fl ga ymo in - h rta c ranmoi n no rlv n h r- a d( )
p sng ry ro o ii n to - ote h n e ti to s t ee a t ee n 2
n
i l i t m oton a c r ii t ofs h c e r l t a lz e t c pl w ih t r r m e s of
nc ude n he
i
e tfca e uc onf r a . T ilr o om y t he equie nt

t sLoca Rul ma beca ef t Cour t .de t moton. S. Fl L. 7. a( .
hi
l e y
us or he
to.. ny he i ' D. a. R. 1()3)
'
1N ot y,N a o i andRobi on aer pr e e byt s ec el
abl
r tque
ns r e es ntd he am ouns .

-

2-

Acc di y,i i
or ngl t s

ORDERED AND ADJUDGED t tRobi on' M otont Quas i DENI
ha
ns s i o
hs
ED.
Ro ns s l f l a a w e t t co pl ntno l t rt n D e em be 1 2017. The C o t
bi on ha l ie n ns r o he m ai
a e ha
c
r 2,
ur

not t tt c s i s tf ti lf t t we pe i be nni J 11, 8.
es ha he a e s e or ra or he wo- ek rod gi ng une 201
D O NE A N D O R DE RED i cha be sa M i m i Fl i ,t s
n
m r t n , or da hi

J oNoe e21
f vmbr07
.

M
.-

> .,
r

,
-,--

FEDERI A . O REN O
M
UN I
TED STA TES D I
STRI J D GE
CT U

Copi f r s d t
es u nihe o:
Couns lofRe d
e
cor

-

3-