APL Microscopic, LLC v. Corporate American Solutions, LLC et al
Filing
26
ORDER DENYING DEFENDANTS' MOTIONS TO DISMISS. Defendants' Motions to Dismiss the Complaint for Insufficient Service of Process (D.E. 6 & 7) are DENIED. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 11/9/2017. (da00)
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
M i m iDi s on
a
vi i
Cas N um ber 17e
: 23316- V - O R EN O
CI M
APL M I
CRSCOPI LLC,
C,
Pl i if
a ntf ,
VS.
CORPOR ATE A M ERI
CAN SO LUTI S,
ON
LLC,a CARI
nd
OLA GROUP,LLC,
Dee
f ndan s
t.
O R DER D ENY I G DEFEN D AN TS'M O TI N S TO D I I
N
O
SM SS
THI CAUSE c me bef r t Co t upon De e nt ' M otons t Dim is t
S
a
o e he ur
f nda s
i
o s s he
Compli frI ufi e Ser c ofPr es ( E.6-7) fldonOct r9.201
ant o ns fcint vie
oc s D.
,ie
obe
7.
THE COURT ha co i r d t motons t pe tne pori oft r c d,a bei
s nsde e he
i , he ri nt tons he e or nd ng
ot r s f l advie i t pr m ie ,i i
he wie uly
s d n he e s s t s
ADJUDG ED t t motonsa eDENI
hat he
i
r
ED.
BA C K G R O U N D
A . Pr e alBackero
oc dur
und
On Se embe 1 201 Pli if APL M i r c c,LLC fl d a c i hti rnge nt
pt
r , 7, a ntf
c os opi
ie
opyrg nfi me
s t agans De enda s Cor a e Am e i n Sol i , LLC a Ca i a Gr
ui
i t f nt
por t
rca
utons
nd
rol
oup, LLC.
De e nt s e nty moved t dimis t Compli bas d on i ufi int s r i of
f nda s ubs que l
o s s he
ant e
ns fce e vce
pr es.Afe c lngi Pl nipss r ie a i t n,heCour' pes l urs ci ove
oc s tr hale ng aitf e vc - nd,n ur t
ts rona j iditon r
Dee d n s Dee a t i d aeyflda Ans ra mit ta ()f fn a t aes b e t
fn a t- fnd ns mme itl ie n we d ti h t i s e d ns r u j c
ng
De
t p ro l u idcin i Flrd , a d(i t v e u i p o e i t i d src u d r2 U. C. j
o es na j rs ito n o i a' n i) s ln e s r p r n h s itit n e 8 S. j
'
g
1 b) a () a 1 a be aus Dee nt r i i t s ditit a Dee ns a e
391( nd c nd 400() c e fnda s esde n hi src, nd fnda t r
ng e
s be tt p ro a j idcin i ti d src. ( s 1 1 1 -1 (d ti alg to i
u j c o e s n l urs ito n h s itit' An . 1 1 3 4 a mit l ains n
'
Compl 11111 4))
.
3-1 .
B. Fac ualB a kzr
t
c ound
Cor r t Am e i n Sol i a Carol Gr ope ae a lm ie la lt co pa e
po ae
rca
utons nd
i a oup r t s i t d i biiy m ni s
unde t lws of Fl rda.M a i no J Ca i a i t r se ed a nt f bot De e n s
r he a
oi
ra
. rol s he egit r ge or h f nda t .
Not y,Cor a eAme ia Soltons Ca i a Gr up,a M r Carol s r t s me a e s
abl
por t
rc n u i , rol o
nd . i a ha e he a
ddr s :
7255NW .Cor at Drve,SuieE,M i FL,331
por e i
t
ami
26.
Plitf hr d M ae tc P o e st s r e De e d n s On M o d y,Se e e 1 ,2 7
an if ie j si r c s o e v fn a t.
n a ptmb r 8 01 ,
M aetc d l e e a c p o t e s mmo s a d c mpan t M ec d sPee - M r Cai as
j si ei r d o y f h u n n o lit o re e rz
v
. rol'
a nitai a ssa t a t Cor a eDrve a e slse a
dmi sr tve s it n - t he por t i ddr s itd bove.
C . A reum ent
s
Dee da t ag e t a M ae tc dd n tefcu t sr ie o p o e s b c u e ()M r
f n n r u s h t j si i o fe t ae ev c f r c s e a s i .
Cai l wa a yfo t o tc whe M ae t d l ee t es mmo a d c mp an , n (i
roa s wa r m he f e n j si ei r d h u ns n o lit a d i)
i
c v
M e c desPe e wasnota ho iedt r c veany doc nt o be l ofM r Ca i a.
re
rz
ut rz o e ei
ume s n ha f
. rol 1
DI
SCUSSI
ON
W hees r ieo p o e si is fiin ,ad src c u tlc p ro a j rs ito o e
r e vc f r c s s n u fce t itit o r a ks e s n l u idcin v r
ted f n a tKel v Sa eo o ia 2 3F d Ap x. 8 , 8 ( 1hCi. 00 ) Co rsr q r
h ee d n . l . tt fFlrd s 3 e . p 8 3 8 4 1 t r 2 7 . u t e uie
y
t ti tc
' rc ompla wih s vie ofpr e s pr e es' Bar
s
ince t er c
oc s oc dur .
' aban v Su s
. s man,439 So.2d 1
046,
1 ( a.4t DCA 1 )( tng Elcr En ' Pr .Co.v fe 352 So.2d 8 ( a.
047 F1 h
983 cii e ta g g ods
. wg,
62 F1
1 )
977).
SWhe t s fcincyofsr iei br
i n he ufi e
e vc s oughti oque ton,t pli ifhast bur n (o
nt si he antf
he de t
pr prpe s r i ofpr s . Cor lv.M i -Dude Cr Cor .drRe De ',No.
ove) o r e vce
oce s' nwal
'
ami
y. r
hab. p t
.
1 235 - V,2011W L 3878352 ( D.Fl Aug.31 2011 (iai omit .Sfapli if
0- 61C1
S. a.
,
) cttons ted) t
l
antf
m a a prm a f i s i ofpr
kes
i ac e how ng
oper s r i e,t bur n s fs bac t t def nda t brng
e v c he de hi t
k o he e nt o i
sr a c ncng e denc ofi ufii pr es. Holande v.WoliNo.09tong nd onvi i vi e ns fcent oc s' l r
'
f
80587- V,
C1
lDee a t r frt M ec d sPe e asG fe ant 'e e to s a e o e' ( f' Re y
f nd n s ee o re e rz G nd s rc p init nd mplye . De .s pl
De
'
a I e ha i a de l)
t ( mp ss d d .
2009W L 3 1 a *3( D.Fl Oc.1 2009)( tngO 're v R. O 'rent As oci e ,
3360 2, t S. a. t 4,
cii B in . J B i o s ats
f ,998F. 1 4,1 ( t Ci.1
ac.
2d 39 400 7h r 993:.
D . LezalA nal s
vsi
i pl i ifmay s r pr e son a lmie la lt c
% antf
A
e ve oc s
i t d ibiiy ompa by de i rng t s
ny
lve i he ummons
and c
ompl i t a ofi e ,m a gi or ge r a nt or ot a nt who i a ho ied t
ant o n fc r na ng
ne al ge ,
her ge
s ut rz o
r c i s vc ofpr es ,orby f lowi sa el w f s r i ofpr s . Fiz r c v Bank
e e ve er ie
oc s
o l ng t t a or e vce
oce s' tpati k .
'
o w Y r Meln 5 0Fe Ap ' 6 0 6 3( 1h Ci. 01 )(mp a i a d d (ii Fe R.
fNe o k lo , 8 d. p x. 9 , 9 1 t r 2 4 e h ss d e ) ctng d.
Ci P.4( ( ).t ordaStt espr det tpr es a ns a lmie la lt co ny may
v. h)1) i i aut ovi ha oc s gai t i td ibiiy mpa
Fl
be s r e upon ...t c pa s r se e a nt o a empl e of t r gitr d a nt'
evd
he om ny' egit r d ge r n
oye
he e se e ge .
'
Wiln , 01 W L 1 8 4 , t* (iigFl. tt j4 .6 1) S e iial j480 2 1 o t e
na d 2 7
3l 5 4 a 2 ctn a S a. 80 24 ). p cfc l
y, .6 () f h
Fl i Stt essa e
orda a ut tt s:
Pr s ag ns a lmie la lt c
oce s ai t i t d i biiy ompa domesi or f ei
ny,
tc
or gn,
ma be s r d on t r it r d age de i na e by t lmie
y
e ve
he eg se e
nt s g t d
he i t d
la lt c
ibiiy ompa unde c pt r605.4 pe son ate i t Fe e
ny
r ha e
, r
t mptng o rv
pr e spur
oc s
suantt t s subs c i m a J r e t pr e s on any
o hi
e ton y e p he oc s
e o eo hergitr da ntd rn t etrtatmp a sr ie
mplye ft e se e ge u ig h ss te t t e vc
eve i t r gitr d a
n f he e se e genti a na u alpe s a i t mpor rl
s
tr
r on nd s e
a iy
a e fom hi o he of .
bs nt r
s r r sce
Fl Stt j48. 1 (mphassa d)
a. a. 0624 ) e
i dde .
Hee Mae tcc mpee - a d Plitf tld aveiid rt r o sr ie afd vtf r
r , j si o ltd n an if ie rfe eu n f e vc fi a i o
e c De e d n . afd vt saet tM aetcp re td s r ieby d lv rng ac p o t e
a h f n a t The fi a is tt ha j si ef ce evc
eiei
o y fh
s
ummons a c
nd ompli tS tt a es of7255 NW .Cor ae Ce erDrve,Suie E,M im i
a n l he ddr s
a
por t nt
i
t
a ,
FL 331 ... o M e ce Per z a Admi itai As t/
26
t
r des e s
n sr tve s.Empl e oft Regit r d Age ...
oye
he
se e
nt
'( E.1 1.
' D. 0-1 )
U nde Fl i l w ,S he a r t n of s r c doc e i r gul on is f ce t bur n
r orda a i n e ur
w
e vi e um nt s e ar t a , he de
s fs t t de en n t s y cea a c ncng e de e ofi ld s vc ' Pore v
hit o he f da t o uppl l r nd onvi i vi nc
nva i er ie.
' tr .
Mai and Se tonsldrJ Ci cAsoc.I ,No.1 6281 C1 2015W L 111 23 a *4(
nl s ci
vi s nc.
4- 7- V,
98 2, t SD.
Fl Aug.7,2015 (ii Robls
a.
) ctng
e -Mari zv.Di ,Reu t Tar LLP,88 So.3d 1 1 -81
tne
az s t g,
77, 80
( l.Dil Ct Ap .2 1) I oh rwo d ,Safi a isb p o e ssr esc n ttt a p i
Fa s. . p 01 ). n te r s t lfd vt y r c s e v r o si e rma
g
u
fce s
a i howi t tdef nda shave bee s r e ' Sol
ng ha
e nt
n e v d.
' omon v.We tak Se v . LLC,No.2:6sl e r s,
1
CV-43- 2 FTM 99CM ,201 W L 6083781,a *1 ( Fl.Oc.1 201 ;s alo Madar v.
6
t MD. a t 8, 6) ee s
a
Hal 91 F.d 1 0 1 4( 1hCi.1 9 )( ( n c n lc i t p ris afd v t o pe dn s
l, 6 2 51 , 51 1 t r 9 0 $A)y o fitn he a t ' fi a is r la ig
$
e
s d ber ol i fvoroft pli if' . ,Pl ntf ha ma aprmafci s ngof
houl
es ved n a
he antf.) Thus ai if s de i a e howi
'
a qua e s r c ofpr es .
de t e vi e
oc s
Def nda ma onl t atempt t r
e nt kes y wo t s o ebut t s prma f ci s
hi i
a e howi of s fc e
ng
ufi i nt
sr i
e v ce:
S aitfs dei r of t s
t n if ' lve y
pl
he umm ons a co pl nt t a
nd m ai o
r ce t o s w ih no r al or a r nt a hort t r ei
e p i nit t
e
ppa e ut iy o ec ve
a c r doc e s c tt es i f e tve s r c of
ny ou t
um nt ons iut ne f c i
e vi e
pr s pur ua t Fe r lRul sofCi lPr e e 1 b 5
oce s s nt o de a
e
vi oc dur 2
Ruls(i)'( f' M o. )
e sc . De .s t 4.
'
(
2)
k r i on ac ny dee ntse oye ...i nota
i vce
se
ompa
fnda ' mpl e
s
r cog z d m ehod of s r i unde Fl rda lw, unl s
e nie
t
e vce
r oi a
es
s i e oye has bee de i t d by t compa t
ad mpl e
n sgna e
he
ny o
a c pt s h sr ie. j 48. 2)c, Fl Stt' ( f'
c e uc e vc
062( () a. a. De .s
'
Re y 1.
pl )
Th s sae n smir p e e t h a pl a l lw b r ligo j4 0 2 2 /)rt e t n
e e ttme t se rs n t e p i be a y eyn n 8.6 ( ) ah r ha
c
j48. 1.The as fi t pr dedsr a c ncng e de ofi uf i pr es.
062( ) y lo al o ovi ttong nd onvi i vi nce ns fcent oc s'
'
Holande ,2009 W L 333601 a *8.
l r
2 t
Plitf s we t ti c id wih t rquieme sof j 48. 1 by s r i t
anif ho d ha t omple t he e r nt
062( ) e vng he
s
ummonsa c pli ton a e pl e ofDef nda s r git r a nt a pr di r t of
nd om a n
n m oye
e nt ' e se ed ge , nd ovi ng e um
s r i e afi vis t t t e f c .Bec us Def nda s f ie t r but Pl n ifs prma f c e
e v c fda t o ha fe t
a e
e nt al d o e
aitf
i
ai
s
howi ofs fc e s r c ofpr es ,De e nt 'motonst dimi sa eDENI
ng ufi i nt e vi e
oc s f nda s
i o s s r
ED.
4
CONCLUSI
ON
Bas on t f eg ng,i i her by
ed he or oi t s e
O R DE RED AN D A D JU DG ED t tD e e nt M oto t D i m i s t Co pl ntf r
ha f nda s' i ns o s s he m ai o
l ufiintSe vceofPr e s( E.6-7)ar DENI
ns fce r i
oc s D. - e
ED.
&yh
-
DONE AND ORDERED i Cha r a M i mi Fl i t s
n
mbe s t a , orda,hi
.- -
.
FEDERI
C
.
.z '
.
J. .
. .
.
. .
.
.
.. .-'
M
z
>
.. .
..
x e
zy ofN ove r201
z.
mbe
7.
'
.
....
w-.
'
,s
-.
,
.
.
-....
m' y ..
' ...
- .
REVO
UNI
TE STATES DI
STRI J
CT UDGE
Copi f ihe t
es unzs d o:
Couns lofRec d
e
or
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?