Kornagay v. Acosta et al
Filing
10
ORDER DISMISSING CASE FOR FAILURE TO STATE A CLAIM. The Court finds that the Complaint fails to state a claim upon which relief can be granted. Accordingly, it is ADJUDGED that the Complaint is DISMISSED without leave to amend. Closing Case. Mot ions terminated: 7 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS on 42 USC 1983 case re 1 Complaint 42 USC 1983 or Bivens filed by Robert D. Kornagay Recommending that the Complaint (DE#1) be DISMISSED, because it fails to state a claim upon which relief can be granted as to any. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 11/20/2017. (da00) NOTICE: If there are sealed documents in this case, they may be unsealed after 1 year or as directed by Court Order, unless they have been designated to be permanently sealed. See Local Rule 5.4 and Administrative Order 2014-69.
UN I
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SO UTH ERN D I
STRI O F FLORI A
CT
D
M im iDi son
a
vii
C as N um be 17- 3516- V- O R EN O
e
r: 2
Cl M
RO BERT D .K ORN A GA Y ,
Pl ntf ,
ai i f
W A RDEN A CO STA ,e a .
t l,
Def nda s
e nt .
O RD ER DI I N G CO M PLA I T FO R FA I R E TO STAT E A C LA I
SM SSI
N
LU
M
I roduc i
nt
t on
Robe tD.Ko na y- apr s Pli if tld t scvi rght a ton unde 42 U. C.j
r
r ga
o e antf- ie hi i l i s ci
r
S.
1 8 t r c v rf rij re s fe e wh n flo i mae a tc e h m i te p io yad a
9 3 o e o e o nu is uf rd e elw n ts ta k d i n h rs n r t
Ever a
gl des Cor e tona l tt i Bec us K or ga i a pr s r s e ng r dr s a i t
r c i l ns iuton.
a e
na y s
i one e ki e es ga ns
go mme ale oyee orofie s hi pla ngsae s j tt s e ng unde 28 U. C.j
ve nt mpl s
fc r , s e di r ubec o creni
r
S.
1 5 . t r a onsdic s d beow,t Cour fndst tKom a y' Compli f ist sat
9l A For he e s
s us e l he
t i ha
ga s
ant a l o t e
acai uponwhi r i ca b gant Fe R. v. l b)6)Ac or ngl i i ADJUDGED
lm
ch elef n e r ed. d. Ci P. 2( ( . c di y,t s
t tt Com pl i i D I I
ha he
a nt s SM SSED .
Il. St
atem entofFacts
lges t t on Dec mbe 6, 201 he wa s
ha
e r
6,
s uddenl atac d whe he
y t ke
n
K or
nagay ale
unknowi y wal d i o a t i s ' Le.an unguar d a unmonior d ar a oft prs
ngl
ke nt s nd pot'
bl
de nd
t e e
he ion
ya d.Des rbi t atac Kom aga saes t ta gr ofappr m ael tve ot r i aes
r
c i ng he t k,
y t t ha
oup
oxi t y i
he nm t
nlhe hi fom be nd,knocke hi t t gr
s d m r
hi
d m o he ound,sa d hi i t he a t r bb
tbbe m n he ad, nd hen o ed
hi ofhi pe s lbel ngs He c e t tt i i tc us d e uc atng pai n i t t
m
s r ona ongi .
ont nds ha he nc den a e xcr i i
n, otng ha
hei ure ahe d wou r quii ni si s andt heco i t s f rfom bl r dvi i
nc r d a
nd e rng ne tche ,
hat
ntnues o ufe r
ure son
a dh a a h s l a dto t t s p ysc ln u is Kon g ycamst a h s fesfo me tl
n e d c e .n d iin o ho e h ia ij re , r a a li h t e u fr r m n a
a emoto dites ,se pl s s e ba s e ,a pa anoi asa r ul oft a t k.
nd
i nal sr s le es nes , m nus m nt nd r a
es t he tac
Ko na y al ge t t Def nda s W a den Ac t an Ca an Lovet- a e
r ga le s hat he
e ntr
osa d
pt i
t r
rs o sbef rh sij re b c u ete fie t tk ra o a l me s r st r me y ters o
ep n il o i nu is e a s h y ald o a e e s n be a u e o e d h ik f
ha m c us d by t blnd s .He c e t tbot De e nt we e e pl
r a e
he i pot
ont nds ha
h f nda s r m oyed a Ever a
t
gldes
Co r c i ll tt ton, nd t t pro t t si de , he we emadea r oft blnd s on
r e tona nsiu i a ha , i r o hi nci nt t y r
wa e he i pot
tej g igta ka dk e i ce tdas sa ta rs o s ro sij r . c r i gt Ko n g ys
h o gn rc n n w t rae ub tnil ik f e iu n u y Ac o d n o r a a
û i t Dec mbe 6,201 ...alr nu rofasauls r re ,a sabbi U t plce
û or o e r
pr
6
age mbe
s t, obbeis nd t ngs ook a
i t spa tc arae o a fe ntbass'(
n hi riul ra n rque
i. Compl ! 8. He aguest tDee nt a td wih
'
. )
r
ha fnda s ce t
delbe a ei fe e t hi s ey by f ii t i vel a mehodst cur t vi e e, s h
i r t ndif r nce o s af t
a lng o t
de op ny t
o b he ol nc ' uc
'
as()t a ng moniorde c i t shi rs ae ' (i û ovi ng ade t sc iy on t
i t ci
pl
t vies n hi gh-ik ra, i) t di
' pr
quae e urt
he
rcrai yad,'or(i)i tngupafnc bl ngof t shi rs ara. (d ! 1 )Hes e
e e ton r ' ii t i
put
e e ocki f hi gh-ik e ' 1 0.
'
e ks
com pensat y,nom i ,and punii dam ages.
or
nal
tve
11 LeaalSt
1.
andards
A . M oton t D i i
i o sm ss
$ s v ve a m oton t dim i s pl i if m us do m or t
1
To ur i
i o s s , a ntf s
t
e han m e el s a e l gal
r y tt e
c us ons ' i t d pl i i f m us û le s e s cii f ct bas s f t e c us o or
oncl i , nsea a ntf s
'
t t l ge om pe fc a ual i or hos oncl i ns
a
f c dim is oft i cl ms' Jac s v.Belsou h Teec
a e s s al her ai .
' k on
l t l omm. 37 F. 1
, 2 3d 250,1 ( 1h Ci.
263 1 t r
200 . W he r i on amoton t dimis a c tmus viw t c aiti t lgh mos
4)
n ulng
i o s s, our
t e he ompl n n he i t t
f vor bl t t pl i if and a ce t pl ntf s wel- e ded f ct as tue. Se
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?