McIntosh v. Royal Caribbean Cruises LTD.
Filing
24
ORDER Granting 7 Motion to Dismiss for Failure to State a Claim. Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 2/7/2018. (jw)
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
SO UTH ERN D I
STR I O F FLO R I
CT
DA
M I M ID I I O N
A
V SI
CA SE N O .1 c 23575- 1
7- vK N6
NI
KKIM CI
NTOSH ,on he own be l and
r
haf
on beha f of a 1 ot r s m ia l st t d
l
1 he i l ry iua e
pa s nge s s hed e t ha bee a r
s e r c ul d o ve
n boa d
t M / Lf r., o h S a ,
he V hc r fte e s
p
Pli if
antf ,
ROY AI CA RI
,
BBEAN CRU I
SES LTD .
,
D e e nt
f nda .
/
O R DE R G M NTI G D EFEND A N T' M O TI N TO D I I
N
S
O
SM SS
TH I CA U SE co es bef e t Co tupon D e e
S
m
or he ur
f ndants M oton t D i m i s Pl ntf s
'
i o s s ai if
Co ant( /7) Theen,Dee nts ksa Or r purua t Fe R.Ci P.1 b)6)
mpli DE / . ri fnda ee n de, s nt o d.
v. 2( ( ,
dim i s ng Pl i if s Com pl i a gui a o ot r gr
s si
a ntf
a nt r ng, m ng he ounds t t Pl i i f s Com pl nt f is
, ha a ntf
ai a l
t alg a y ij re o d ma e s eh refs tie ,o id e ta s e s tie a y a al
o l e n nu is r a g s h e s l usan d r n e d h t h usan d n t l.
e
Def nda f rhe a g s t tPl ntf' cl m i CountI If i e i li l c i ofe oto l
e nt u t r r ue ha ai i f s ai n
l or nt ntona nti ton
m i na
dsrs fis t sae a cam a d s o l b d s se wih p eudc .Th s ma tr i f l
ite s al o tt li n h ud e imis d t rj ie i te s ul
y
s us e l
bre e 1a d asdi c s d be ow , t Cour fnds t tDef nda ' M oton s d be gr nt a
i f d, n
he
t i ha
e nt s
i houl
a ed nd
Plitf c mpan ds se wih u prj d c a d wih la e t n n wih r s c t h r
anips o lit imisd t o t eu ie n t e v o me d t epe t o e
ne i nc c s a t tt i e i na i lc i of e i ldite s cli be dim is d
glge e ount, nd ha he nt nto l nfiton
motona sr s am
s se
wihprj ce.
t eudi
1. B ackground
Thi m a t r a i e f om a ca eled c ui e t t w a s t t l a t Por of G a ve t i
s te r s s r
nc l r s ha s e o e ve he
t
l s on n
Te on Augus 27, 201 whi h da e c nc de w ih Huni ne H a v y' l ndf l a ong t
xas
t
7, c
t oi i d t
ca
r e s a al l
he
1 anifh sfldhi Re po s i Op o iin ( /1 ) a dDe e a t h v GldaRe y ( / 2 .
Plitf a ie s s n e n p st DE / 6 , n fnd n s a e e
o
pl DE / )
2
Gul Coa ti e se n Te s Bre l sa e Pli ifsCom p antalege ,on he o be l a
f s n a t r xa . ify tt d, antf
li l s
r wn ha f nd
on be l ofa cas ale dl num be e i t t ands t tDe e ntsde son nott ca el
haf
l s lge y
r d n he hous , ha f nda ' cii
o nc
t es b e tc us u tlte d y i wa s tt s i,c u ld wi n tc sDe e d n is e i te
h u j c r ie n i h a t s e o al o pe t o ie fn a t su d n h
h
da l di up t t cr s t i wa silon s dul f c d t andsofpeo eta lt t
ys ea ng
o he uie hat t s tl
che e, or e hous
pl r ve o he
Houson a e pl cng t m die ty i t pah oft so m .Pl ntf s c
t r a, a i he
r cl n he t
he t r
ai if ompli al ge t t
ant le s ha
t s f c d woul be pas e r t e r t r nta r i a dange ous huni a c tons
hi or e
d - s nge s o ndu e ore il a ns nd
r
c ne ondii ,
a al ge t s woul bepa s nge s now sr nded i a a ou Houson,s f r a l ls
nd le s he e
ds e r,
ta
n nd r nd
t ufe ed ong it
o g iv u ij re r n ig fo b i ij rd o a o tt i bo i e te te ,t te o ay
f re o s n u is a gn r m eng n u e n b u her dl xrmiis o û mp rr
y
t
a or pema nt physc s biiy, t t ntland emoi
nd/ r ne
ialdia lt ' o l a
' me
tonala s 'a û e lngs of
nguih' nd k ei
f
e onomi i ec rt ' antf s c ant alges t t t e ij is wee a1 c usd by
c
c ns u iy. i if ompli le ha hes nure r 1 a e
'Pl
D e e nt s f iur t c elt t i s
f nda ' a l e o anc he rp oone , f l e t w a' of t dang s of t a i t a
r aiur o l
n
he
er
r velng o
hur i a z durng a i pe ng hu r c ne,a f iur t pr m ul t r und polc es a m ed
rc ne one i n m ndi
r ia
nd a l e o o ga e ef
ii i
a e urng t s ey of pa s nge s Pli if f rher a lges t t t e a i we e s
t ns i he af t
s e r . antf u t
le
ha hes ctons r o
outa
r geousa t a ountt a i e i li lcton ofe oto di t e s
so m
o n nt ntona nfi i
m i nal sr s .
Defnda ar si isM oton t Dim ist tt sa ton ca
e nt gue n t
i o s s ha hi c i
nnotbem ant i a acl s
i aned s as
a ton bas d upon
ci
e
cl s a ton w a ve c a ned wihi t tc t c r c . M o e
a s ci
i r ont i
t n he i ke ont a t
r
f m e a l how e r D e e nt a gue t t t c pl i m us be di m i s be us , as
unda nt ly,
ve , f nda r s ha he om a nt
t
s s ed ca e
pld Plitf h refd e n talg ta s es san d a y ij re ,wh tt y wee h w s
e , an if e s l o s o l e h t h u tie n n uis a he r , o he
e
wa ij r d o t a s e e e ta eldt t eHo so ae h reflk t e ca so p o l s e
s n u e , r h t h v n rv l o h u t n r a e s l i e h ls f e pe h
e
hopest r pr e .M or ove ,Def nda a guest tPl n ifscli f i e i li lci of
o e es nt
e r
e nt r
ha aitf' am or ntntona ntiton
e otona di t e s f l t s a e a c a m ,a D e e
m i l s r s ais o t t
l i s f ndants a l ged a tons and i c i w e e no
' le
ci
na tons r t
s tci nty out a oust m a nt i s h a c ai .
ufi e l
r ge
o i a n uc
lm
Il. LegalSt
andard
To s vveaRul 1 b)6)moto t dimis ac antmus i l çe
ur i
e 2( (
in o s s, ompli
t ncude snoughf t t
acs o
s a e a cl m t r i t i pl i e on i sf ' Bel At.Cor v.Tw om bl 550 U . 544,570
tt
ai o elef hat s ausbl
t ace,' l l p.
y,
S.
( ) k cai ha fcilplusbiiy whe t pli ifpladsf t lc e t tal t
2007 .; l m s a a a i lt
A
n he antf e acua ontnt ha lows he
c tt d a t r s na e i e enc t tt def nda i la e f r t m i c
our o r w he ea o bl nf r e ha he e nt s i bl o he s onduc a l ge '
t le d.
'
As c o v I al 5 6U. 6 2, 6 ( 0 9 . lg to a s n s p o t g fcsaeno e t ld
h r? . qb , 5 S. 6 6 3 2 0 ) Al ains b e t u p ri a t r t ni e
e
n
t
t t spr s pton ofve ac t l at681
o hi e um i
r iy. d
.
W he e l tng a m oto t dimi s t Cour mus tke a 1oft welpl f ct l
n va uai
i n o s s , he
t ta 1
he l- ed a ua
a lga i a tu 1 a 664.
le tons s r e. d. t
Howe r û hr ad r r ct l oft ee e sofa c us ofaci
ve , l e ba e e ia s he lm nt
t
a e
ton,
s
uppore by m e e concus y sa e t ,do nots fc ' 1 a 663.And,t Cour' dut t
td
r
l or tt men s
ufi e. d. t
'
he
ts y o
a e t f ct la l ga i i t c pl i a t u doe notr r i t i e s ii f ct
cc pt he a ua le tons n he om a nt s r e s
equie t o gnor pec f c a ual
d tisûn fv ro g n rlo c ncu o y alg t n . Gr n I d s,l c r Iwi,49 F.d
eal k a o f e e a r o ls r le ai s' @ n u . n . . l n 6 3
i
o '
1 89,1 06 ( 1h Ci.2007) The Cour mus dimisa c antt doesnotpr e a
1 205- 1 t r
.
t t s s ompli hat
esnt
pl us bl c a m de onsr tng e tte e tt r le .
a i e li
m t a i n il m n o e i f
Ill- i
D scuss on
i
Pl i if s com pl nt alege c es of a i s
a ntf '
ai
l s aus
cton oundi i neg i nc a wel as f
ng n
lge e, s
l
or
i e i li lci ofe otona dites Ge r lm a ii 1 w a i st t sc e.SeeKe.j
ntntona nfiton
m i l sr s. ne a rtme a pple o hi as
eb
v BahamaCruieLi s I . 8 F. 1 1 1 ( 1h Ci.1 . saeaneglge ecam,
.
s ne, nc, 67 2d 3 8, 320 1 t r 989) To tt
i nc li
Pl i ifm us a l t tD e e ntha a dut of c r ,Def nda br c t tdut t t s h
a ntf
t lege ha f nda
d
y
ae
e nt ea hed ha
y, ha uc
b e c wa t e a ta a d p o i t c us o Plitf s ij r ,a d t a Plitf s fee
ra h s h cu l n r xmae a e f anif n u y n h t an if u frd
da ges Sor esv NCL (
ma . r l .
Bahama)Lt ,796F. 1 1 ( 1hCi.201 .
s d.
3d 275, 280 1 t r 5)
Fu te ,la panif algng ( tnina ifito o e to a dite s fc s a
rh r i l litf le i i e to l n lcin f mo in l srs) a e n
g
n
e r m ey hi h bur n' i t f m ofal ga i ofc
xte l g
de ' n he or
2
le tons onduc s outa ousça t g be
t o r ge
ts o o yond a1
l
bo
unds of de e
c ncy, a t be r a d as odi
nd o
eg r ed
ous a ute l i ol r bl i a c vii e
nd t r y nt e a e n
i lz d
c m uniy.:,3
om
t
3Flrd 1 pr dest tf ree e sm us bepl deda s ppore byf cualale tonst s ppor acl m f
o ia aw ovi ha ou lm nt
t
ea
nd u
td
at
lgai o u t ai or
i e ina i lci ofe otonaldites :
ntnto l ntiton m i
sr s
al e o l
ha he r el ufe e
Fa a t Pl ntf s neglge e cai i her f iur t alege t t s he s f s f r d
t l o ai if
i nc l ms s
ij l o d ma e .W h l s rctsalu d y ls o h r alg d y s fe e b te ca ss e
n uy r a g s ie he e ie a n r it f a ms le e l u fr d y h ls h
hopest r pr s nt s f ist ale a s c fc ha mst tbef l he a ar s tofDe e
o e e e , he al o lge ny pe ii r ha el r s e ul
f ndants
'
v rous a lged f l es a ne i nta s M or r whie s al ges i he c pl ntt
ai
le
aiur nd glge ct.
eove , l he le
n r om ai hat
t ands ofwoul be cnls pas e r wer f c t ta t t Houson ar a be aus of
hous
d
ie s nge s e or ed o r vel o he
t
e c e
De e nts ne i nc t r by pu tng t m i ha m ' wa a f r i t m t e e s i
f nda ' glge e, he e
ti he n r s y nd o cng he o ndur ad
lundr ls of ha m s Pl i if doe not a lge a
a y it
r , antf
s
le nywhe e i he compli t t s he s l
r n r
ant ha he r ef
tav l t Houson a e e t s ha m s Acc di y, Pl i ifs co pl nt does no
r eled o
t nd ndur d he e r .
or ngl
antf
m ai
t
pl usbl saea cai f neglge a m us bedim is d.
a i y t t l m or
i nce nd
t
s se
Fi ly,Pl i ifsi e i na i lcton ofemotona di te scai i duet bedim is d
nal antf nt nto l nti i
i l sr s l m s
o
s se
wihprj ce Asnotd,i or e t mai ans hacam, pli ifmus algec
t eudi .
e n d r o nti uc li a antf t le onduc ont
t he
pa tofDe e nts ou r geo ast go be
r
f nda o ta us o
yond albounds ofde e y,a t be r ga ded a
l
c nc nd o
e r
s
odi a ute l i ol r bl i a c vii e c m uniy.A pl i i f wil r r y a e t s a e a
ous nd t ry nt e a e n i lz d om
t
a ntf l a el bl o t t
c a m f i e i na i lc i ofe o i
l i or nt nto l nf i ton
m tonaldit es i Fl i ,a a w i r
s r s n or da nd
de ange of c
onduc ha
t s
be n he d i ufi i ntt s v ve a m oton t di m i s
e l ns f c e o ur i
i o s s'
.
A bref s ve of Fl rda a ma ii e c e ad e sng cam s of I ED
i ur y
oi
nd
rtm
as s dr s i
li
I
undes o e t spoi .Se e. ,Rubi v.Lo z,445Fe Appx.a 1 (i ng
rc r s hi nt e, g.
o
pe
d.
t 75 fndi
f iur t a l ge s fc e outag
a l e o le uf i i nt r eous c
onduct w he e de y s r f hob e-i
r put he if bl ted
a r s ee o bl c as t pa m en i s r s tng i s c
r e t n a k phal ve t n un, e uli n e ond- gr e bur t
de e
ns o
fc a c e t;W als 3 6 F.d a 8 (i dn n o ta e u c n u twh r
a e nd h sl li, 0 3 t 42 fn ig o ur g o s o d c ee
c e m e be on c ui e s p r m a ke i t pl i ifs he r ng a tr he hus
rw
m r
r s hi e r d n he a ntf
a i fe r band
f l ove boa d t the hus nd wa pr bl de d a t thi body woul be
el r r ha r ba
s oba y a nd ha s
d
s ke unde t s p,c ppe up by t pr l r ,a w oul pr bl not be
uc d
r he hi ho d
he opele s nd
d oba y
rco e ;Gari v.Cani lCor ,838 F. zd 1 1 ( D.Fl 201
e verdl ca
r va p.
supp. 334, 339 S. a. 2)
( oo e J)(i ngno ourgeo c
M r , . fndi
ta us onduc wheece me r asa td c us
t r rw mbes s ule r ie
pa s nge a prve e he fom l vi he r om f ape i oftme;Va ,
s e r nd e ntd r r ea ng r o or rod i l mper
1 F. Su a 1 -07 (i ng no outa us conduc wher dee nt
4
pp. t 306
fndi
rgeo
t
e fnda s
()Th wrn d e'(h h tli Co n I c n u twa itn in l rrc ls,h ti, eitn e hs
l e o g o rs te oe,n u tVq o d c s ne to a o e kes ta sh ne d d i
be orwhe hekne ors d hav known t tem o i dite sw oul lkeyr s t
havi
n
w
houl
e
ha
tonal sr s
d i l e ul;
( )t ec n u t sour g o s t a i, st g b y n al o n so de e c , n t berg r e a o i u
2 h o d c wa ta e u , h t s a o o e o d l b u d f c n y a d o e a d d s d o s
a utery it er ei aci lz comm uniy;
nd t l n ol abl n viied
t
()tec n u tcu e e to lldsrs; n
3 h o d c a s d moinal ites a d
( )t ee t n l ite swa s v r .
4 h mo i a d sr s s e e e
o
Galgyv Ro rgu z 9 0S . d4 0, 7l( a Di . . p. 0 7 (nen l i t no te )
l l . d i e, 7 o 2 7 4 Fl. s CtAp 2 0 ) itr a ct i mitd.
o
t
ao
4
f brc t r c e s drvi c ge a ns pl i if c l hi t tn' wor
a i aed e kl s i ng har gai t antf, aled m he t ' d,
t e t dhi wiht nai a physcal sr khi ona e.
hraene m t enni ton, nd i ly tuc m
nkl)
rk,2 7 W L 1 31 2 a * ( D.Fl.Ap .1 ,20 7 ( c l,J)( imisng wih prj die
r 01
z
3 71 , t 2 S. a r 1 1 ) S oa . d s si
t eu c
i e i li lci ofe oto dite scli agans c uie s p whe e al ga i i ude
ntntona nfi ton
m i nal sr s a m
i t r s hi
r le tons ncl d
de i er t y f ii t m oniorchidr s a e o t a n c l e s a e s af s el t s m one
lb a el a lng o
t
l en' r a r r i hidr n' r a t f ol y o ave
y
a dir gad t rs t c l e pos d by muli e ha ads i c lr s aea . Pli iFs
nd se r he ik o hidrn e
tpl z r n hiden' r ) antf
Compl i f ist a lge c
ant al o le onduc s fce l outa oust me t r uie e sofFl i lw
t uf inty r ge
o et he eq r m nt
orda a
f s h acli ,a m us bedimis d.
or uc
am nd
t
s se
The eor,i i ORDERED,
rf e t s
ADJUDGED,andDECREED t tMotont Dimis(
ha
i o s s DE
#9 be a t smehee i GRANTED.Cot s1a 1 ofPl ntf' Co ai ( #1)ae
) , nd he a
rby s
mt nd 1 ai ifs mpl nt DE
r
DI I
SM SSED wihout preudie Coun 1l of Pl ntf' Compl nt i DI I
t
j c.
t1
ai ifs
ai s SM SSED wih
t
prj c Pl nifma fl a a nde compl ntwihi 20da oft daeoft sOr r
eudie. aitf y ie n me d
ai t n
ys he t hi de .
DONE a ORDERED i c mbe s a t J m e La e e Ki Fede a J tc
nd
n ha r t he a s wr nc
ng
r l usi e
Buidi a U nie St t C o t e,M i m i Fl i t s 7 da ofFe ar 201
l ng nd
t d a es ur hous
a , orda, hi t y
bnl y
8.
A M ES LA
N CE KI G
N
UN I
TED STA TES D I
STR
cc:
A l counselofrecord
l
5
J DGE
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?