De Rendon et al v. Ventura et al

Filing 58

ORDER Adopting 49 Report and Recommendations. Closing Case. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 9/18/2018. See attached document for full details. (mmd)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SO U THERN DI
STRI O F FLO RI A
CT
D
Cas Num be 17 24380- V- O RENO
e
r: CI M

ESTHER VEN TUM DE RENDON a J
nd UAN
M A RI REN D ON G U TI
A
ERREZ,
Pe ii ne s
tt o r ,
V S.

VI ANE VENTUM a M I
VI
nd CHAEL D.
VENTUM ,
Re ponde s
s
nt .

/
O RD ER A D O PTI G M A G I
N
STR ATE JU D G E L O U I S R EPO R T A N D
S'
R EC O M M EN DA TI N
O
THE M ATTER wa r f r d t t Honor bl La e F.Loui ,Unied Stt M a sr t
s e ere o he
a e ur n
s
t
aes gitae

J
udge,f aRe ta Re
or por nd comme tonon Peii t Contr t Ar talAwad ( E.13)
ndai
tton o
im he bir
r D. - .
TheM a srt J
gitae udgefld aRe r a Re omme to ( E.49)on Auzus 8.2018. The
ie
po t nd c
ndain D.
t
Cour hasr viwe t e ie fl a r co d. The Cour hasm a a denov r vi w oft is
t
e e d he ntr ie nd e r
t
de
o e e
he s ues

t a t e o j ci n t t M a itae J d es Re o ta Re o nd to p e e t a d ben
h t h b e to s o he gsrt u g ' p r nd c mme ain rs n , n ig
ot r s f l a s i t pr mies i i
he wie uly dvied n he e s ,t s
ADJUDG ED t t Unied Stt M agita e J
ha
t
a es
sr t udge Laur n F. Loui ' Re t a
e
s s por nd
Re om m e ton i A FFI M ED a A D O PTED . A c di y,i i
c
nda i s
R
nd
cor ngl t s

ADJUDGED t t t Pe ii t Confr t Ar tal Awa d i GRANTED.
ha he tton o
im he bir
r s

Repo d n s p i ia o jcin i t a t Ar ir lAwad i iv ld u e t e Ne Yok
s n e t' rncp l b e to s h t he b ta
r s n ai nd r h w r
Co ton Ari esV( )a a V( )d)be us t a ntd abirt swe enotColmbin
nveni
tcl
1() nd 1( ca e he ppoi e r taor r
o a
na i l . Re ponde s c ai t t t a nt e of f e gn a bir t s i c r y t t
tona s
s
nt l m ha he ppoi m nt
or i r ta or s ontar o he

pa tes a e me t adomesi abirton. Thi ob e ton i wihoutmei bec us t pa tes
ri ' gre nt o
tc r tai
s j ci s t
rt a e he ri
a e d t be bound by t l er to l Cha ber of Com m er e Rul s w hi h pr des f t
gr e o
he nt na i na
m
c
e , c ovi
or he

a nt ntofa bir t r byt tbody.The Re ponde s a gume t tCol m bi 1w s d
ppoi mt
r ta o s ha
s
nt ' r
nt ha
o an a houl
ha a id t de de t pa a ee s of t s a bir ton i i
ve pple o ci he r m tr
hi r ta i s nconsse wih t pa tes
itnt t he ri '

a re n . Theeo e t o j cin d e n tp o ie a b ssf rd ca ig te abi a a r
g e me t
rf r , he b e to o s o r vd a i o e lrn h r t l wad
r
i i unde t Conve i .
nvald
r he
nton

Re p n e t as o j c ta t a bta pa e e e d d isa to iy be a e i d nid
s o d ns lo be t h t he r i l n l xc e e t uh rt c us t e e
r
t m a o runiy t pr s ntt i c e c am , whih s htt fnd t pa tes s tlm e
he n ppo t t o e e he r ount r l i
c oug o i he ri ' ete nt

a e m e nul a voi due t fa o m it ke Thi c e cl m wa orgi ly i ude i
gr e nt l nd d
o r ud r sa . s ount r ai
s i na l ncl d n

t t r sofr f r nc butt n lt rwihdr wn by Re ponde s Re ponde s a gum e i t t
he e m
e e e e, he a e t a
s
nt . s
nt ' r
nt s ha

t ea bta a r ia r p itl a j dc t st ewi d a c u tr li wh ni sae ta dn
h r i l wa d n pp o raey d u iae h t rwn o n ecam e t tts h t t
r
h
i
t sa bir ton,i i notde o taed t e se e ofa ilctc e i t s crpton oft
hi r ta i t s
m nsr t he xit nc
n lii aus n he ubs i i
he
Se te e tA gr em e .' I Res
tl m n
e nt' n
ponde s'vi , t i sae n c n ttt sa a j iain o t e
nt ew hs ttme t o si e n dudc to f h
u
c t r l i . The Cour ag e w ih t Re t and Re m m e ton t t t Re ponde s
oun e c a m
t r es t he por
co
nda i ha he s
nt

ha notm e t i bur n on t sis A lhough t a bir lti
ve
t her de
hi s ue. t
he r ta rbunalnot d t lc ofe de e
e he a k
vi nc
on t c nt r am ,i as e es l satd i t a r t twihdr wa oft c er l i was
he ou e cli t lo xpr sy t e n he wa d ha t a l he ount c am

a c pe wih u p eudc , lo n s c camst p o e d i af t r abtain.S eAr irl
c e td to t rj ie alwig u h li o r c e n uu e r irto e bta
Awad( E.1 1 a !59)
r D. - 3 t
.

Repo e t'fn l o j cin i ta t e awar vi at publc polcy becaus i was
s nd ns ia be to s h t h
d ol es
i
i
e t
pr c rdb fa d I t ero jcins t eRe po d n sp o d ac ncus r sae n ta t e
o u e y r u . n h i be t ,h s n e t r vie o l o y ttme t h t h y
o
we e de r uded. Thi sa e e i i ufi intt m e tt bur t tt sa bir la r i voi
r fa
s t t m nt s ns fce o e he den ha hi r ta wa d s d

a a an t bi poiya rq ie b t eNe Yo kCo v n inAril V( )b .
s g is pu l l s e ur d y h w r n e to t e 2 ( )
c c
c
*

D ON E AN D OR DER ED i Cha be s a M i m i Fl i ,t s
n
m r t a , orda hi

.
.
.

of Se e r
pt mbe

201
8.

FEDERI X.
CO

O

UN I
TED STA TES D I
STRI J D GE
CT U

.

9

t
!

)
l
.
r
ê
t

J

l

t
è
'

j

'
è
7
6
E
)
;
f
1
.

'
j
g
(

Copi f nihe t .
es ur s d o.
,
,
,
,
Unle St t s a s r t J e La e F. ,s
td a e
gl t a e udg ur n Loul
Cou e ofRec d
ns l
or

.
.
'

j
t

'
.

'
j
.

J

t
)
1
.
2
j
.
.
.
.
.
.

'
j
j

'
t

(
j
f
E
.
î
(
:
)
t

è
,

j
!
;
k
'
j
(
E
.
)
:

i
'

t
.
!

'
ï
p
.
!
.
)
t
J
'
t
'

1
'

j
t
.
l
.
y

!
)
j

.
)
t

i
:
;
1
(
i
.
(

i

)

(
.

'
j
:
j
.
'
.

!

t

)
.

.

j

j
'
.

i

L

l

t

)
(
.
i
.

è
.

t

t

y
t
t
:

)
'
j

t
i

t
)
.
(
1

k
)

.
j
'
y
.
.
:
'
1
(
.

t
t
i
l
).
.'
J
(
.

6

3

L
J

t

l
.'
j
t

i
.
.
.

k
.