Longhini v. NIMA PLAZA, LLC et al

Filing 34

ORDER granting 26 Defendant Arona Corp.'s Motion to Dismiss. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 6/12/2018. (lfs)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FO R THE
CT
SOU THERN DI
STRI O F FLORI
CT
DA
M i iDi si
am vi on
CaseN um btr:1724718ClW M OREN O
DOUGLA SLONGH m I
,
Pl ntf,
ai if

NI A PLA ZA,LLC,ARONA CORP. ROYAL
M
,
ARCADE CORP. PA RAI TROPI
,
SO
CAL
PI
ZZERI RESTAURANTE Y HELADERI
A
A
LLC,a CHI EXPRESS l C.
nd
U
N ,
Def
endant
s.
ORDER GM NTI G DEFENDANT AR ONA COl P.S M OTI N TO DISM ISS
N
t '
O

THI CAUSE c me be o e te Cou tu n De e da ' M oi t Dimis( E.2 ,fld o
S
a
fr h
r po f n nt
s ton o s s D. 6) ie n
A pr l19.2018.
i

THE COURT hasconsder t m oton,t r ponseand r y,pe tne pori oft r or
i ed he i he es
epl ri nt tons he ec d,
a bei ot
nd ng henvie f l advi d i t pr m ies i i
s uly
se n he e s , t s
ADJUD GED t tt moton i GRANTED.
ha he
i s

Pl ntf ,an i vi
ai if
ndi dualw ih a qualfed diabiiy,r
t
ii
s lt eques s an or f om t s Coul diec i
t
der r hi
' r tng
t
De endantAr Cor a i t m ake isr toom avaiabl t Pl ntf t ûi pec an and a1 bar ir t
f
ona por ton o
t esr
l e o ai if o çns t y
1 re s o

a e st a weec nc ld b viteoft ba re s p e e e. D. 1!3 Dee a tAr aCor rto
cc s h t r o eae y ru he rir ' r s nc ' E. 4. f nd n on po ain
'
movest dim is,ar ng t bar i sunknown att tm e offlngt compl ntcannotser asa basi
o s s gui hat rer
he i
ii he
ai
ve
s
f a cl m .The Compl nt aleges t Ar deni Pl ntf ac
or
ai
ai l
hat ona
ed ai if cess t is r toom becaus of hi
o t esr
e
s
di a lt However cours wihi t s dit i ha hel t ta pl ntf mus have a ualknowl
s biiy.
,
t t n hi s rct ve d ha
ai if
t
ct
edge of
pur t vi atons of t Amercans w ih Diabiii Act a t tm e a c pl nt i fl M i
pored ol i
he
i
t s ltes
t he i
om ai s ied. chael

Ho r Ca a v Alr dJo e Ba ly a Ke eh Mat asBau ly,astu te o heAlr dJ sph
wa d pln . fe sph ure nd nn t
hi
re
r se s ft fe o e
Bau ly,J .fl /a e me ,Ca eNo.0: 7c - 5 0re r rf gr e nt s
y
l -v 61 9 RNS ( D.Fl.Fe 1 ,20l ( c a J)( E.
S. a b. 7
6) S ol, . D.

l ; c s Nb I c v S Fl.Stdi Cor ,l 1F.Su 2d 1 7 1 66( D. a 2 1 ( o e J.;
5) Ac e s w, n . . . a a um p. 6
pp. 35 , 3 S. Fl. 00 ) M or, )

Fo v M o rsJu trAs o .s Cas No.0 8 68 20 W L 281 22,a * ( D.Fl.Se t 25,2 7)
x . r i pie s c ', e
5- 0 9, 07
95 t 6 S. a p . 00
( iig Ac esNo I c,l F.Sup 2d a 1 5) Ba b r v Ta a Cha d,e.a . CaeNo.l - 39
ctn c s w, n . 61
p. t 36 , r e i . r
*
n t I, s
721 3,
D. 1 (u e 28 20l ( yls J)( tng t tt e pli ifçma no ba e hi cli on u no o
E. 4 J n , 7) Ga e , . no i ha h antf t y t s s ams nk wn r
un s ov rd vilton ' .l e d,t s Cou tha as src n a c mpl nt s r ndpio l wih t s
dic ee oa i s' nd e hi
)
r s lo tike
o ai e e i t usy t hi
s
ame Pl ntf t aleged ûuns fed pur t vi atons t Longhi was not a e of when he
ai if hat l
k pecii
pored ol i hat
ni
war

fl t compl nt' fonghi v.Polo Ope i I ,CaseN o.17ied he
ai .'
ni
l
ratons, nc.
23480- V ,20l7 W L 5507565,at
C1

*l( D. a No l ,2 l . ai ifct st ac s fo teNorhe nDitito Ge r i hodi t ta
S. Fl. v. 7 0 7) Pl ntf ie o a e r m h
t r src f o ga l ng ha
pl ntf hassandi t chalenge al oft ar t ur bar i s t tmay r ndera pr t i
ai if
t ng o
l
l he chiect al rer ha
e
opery nacces i e
sbl
t hi ,even bar ir ofwhi he di nothave know l
o m
re s
ch
d
edge a t tm e t com pl ntwasfl Ga or v.
t he i he
ai
ied, yl

DDR Se Ab r ty,LLC,No.l1 - 4 3- T,2 1 W L 6051 29,a *1( D. No l 2 3)
. e nah
:2 CV- 34 TW 0 3
0 t N. Ga. v. 5, 01 .
Howeve ,t cour a
r hat
t cknow l
edged t e ot coursw ihi t Nort f DititofGeor a f l
hat ven her
t t n he
herl src
gi olow
t r e t a pl ntf mus ha act knowl
he ul hat
ai if
t ve ual
edge of aleged vi atons of t Amerca w ih
l
ol i
he
i ns t

Dia l isa t tmeac mpliti fld. d ( iainso te )
s bii e t he i
t
o an s ie 1 . ctto mitd .
Thi Courtfnds per i t cas fom wihi t s diti hol ng t a pl ntf may onl
s
i
suasve he es r
t n hi srct di hat ai if
y
pur uer i f t
s elef or hosear t t albari sofwhi hehasact knowl
chiecur
rer
ch
ual
edge att tm e t compl nti
he i he
ai s

fld.Accor ngl t Cour gr s Def
ie
di y, he
t ant
endantAr Cor a i sm oton t di m i t e pori of
ona por ton'
i o s ss hos
tons
t Com pl ntt ts r es f vi atons oft Am erca w ih Diabiii Actt wer unknown
he
ai ha eek edr s or ol i
he
i ns t s ltes
hat e

orundicove ed att tmet Compl ntw asfl How e ,t sr i doesnotpr udePl ntf fom
s r
he i he
ai
ied.
ver hi ulng
ecl
ai if r
lt amendi t Compl nt as per ted by t Feder Rul ofCi lPr
aer
ng he
ai ,
mit
he
al es
vi ocedur t i ude vi ai
e, o ncl
oltons
dicove ed si t t i oft Compl nt
s r nce he slng he
ai .

DON E AND ORD ERED i Cham ber atM i ,Fl i
n
s
ami ord
FE

CO A,

UNI
TED
Copi f nihed t
es ur s
o:

CounselofRe d
cor

2

s

o une 201
8.
NO

XTES DI CT J
STRI UDGE