Sangelus et al v. Trump

Filing 5

ORDER DISMISSING CASE for failure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted. Closing Case. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 1/8/2018. (lfs) NOTICE: If there are sealed documents in this case, they may be unsealed after 1 year or as directed by Court Order, unless they have been designated to be permanently sealed. See Local Rule 5.4 and Administrative Order 2014-69.

h

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
M i Di son
ami vii
Case Num ber:1820018- CI M ORENO
VSAI
P NGERA RD SANG ELUS, J
ATRI
C
ACQUES
K,M ARCKSON ST. FLEUR,and ALAN
SAJOUS,

Pl ntf s
ai if ,
VS-

DONALD J. TRUM P,i hi of ci capaciy as
n s fi al
t
Pr i oft Unied St t ,
esdent he t
aes
Def
endant
.
/

O RDER D I ISSI CO M PLAINT W I
SM
NG
THO UT PRE
JUDI
CE
(
THI CA USE c
S
ame bef e t Cour upon a
or he
t
sua s er e oft r d.
pont eviw
he ecor
Pl ntfs, f pr se i aes hous att Fed
ai if our o
nm t
ed he
er Cor e i
al r ctonalI iuton i Edgef 1
nstt i n
id

,

Car i brng acl m f def a i a ns Donal J
olna, i
ai or am ton gai t
d
.

Sout
h

Tr
ump,i hi of ci capaciy asPr si entoft
n s fi al
t
e
he

Unied St es of Amerea. Pl ntf s alege
t
at
i
ai if l , i er ala, t Pr dent Tr p def
nt
i hat esi
um
amed a l H
aii
tan
i m i ant , when i a Cabl News Ne wor i er ew
m gr s
n
e
t k nt vi
on December23, 2017 he sat ,
t ed
I
I mi ant have A .ID. ' Plitfsf rh rs mi t tLfora ma i M
m gr s
I
. S. an if u te ub t ha t l
'
l
nn

ta11ai
ç t1Hia
t
h
tn

r Trmpsp st rt c me
. u ' o ioto o
i

aer sasaxenophobe i natonalprme tme t evii i
os
n i
I
i i el son sextem el dit bi and hi
r y sur ng
ngeson r i .'As
a sm '

com pensa i Pl ntfs s $40 m ilon f t tment ,ps
ton, ai if eek
li or he i al ychol cal
ogi
,

sufer due t M r Tr
f ed
o . ump' s a ement
s tt

,

em otonal and s rt Iangui
i ,
piiu
sh

whih wasaddr sed t t entr naton i
c
es
o he ie i
n an atem ptt viiy
t
o lf

Haii l i ant .''
tan mm gr s

To pr lon a def i cl m under Fl
evai
amaton ai

o ia Iw,Pl ntfsmu ts ow t a ( )t d fn nt
rd a ai if s h h t 1 he e da

publshe a f s sat
i d ale t ement ( )a o t epl nif
, 2 b ut h
aitf
,

( t at r pa t a d ( t f st oftesae nt
3) o hid ry, n 4) he aliy h t me

c u e ij r t t eplitf Bas v.Ri a, 826 So.2d 534, 5 ( a.2 DCA 2 2)(ne n etto
a s d n uy o h an if s
ver
35 FI d
00 itr al iain
.

omitd .Plitfs c cus r al gains however arf
te ) anif- on l o y l to s
e
tul
,

ar i fci t sat a cl m upo whi
e nsuf i ent o t e
ai
ch

r i can be gr ed pur uantt Feder R
elef
ant
s
o
al

ul o Ci lPr e ur l ( ( See Jack v B Isout
e f vi oc d e 2 b)6)
son
l h
.

.

l
I

Tel
ecomm. 372 F.3d 1 50 1 3 (1 t Ci.2 4)(t slvi a mo in t dimis
.
2 , 26 1h r 00 i t ve
To r
to o s s

,

pl n if m us do
ai fs
t

mor t mer y sat l concl ons g ta plit f muslalg s
e han
el t e egal
usi , i e d ani s t l e ome s cfcf c al a i f
ns
f
e
pe ii a
b ss or
t econcl onsorf di ss oft rcl m s,' .Ac digl i i
hos
usi
ace smi al hei ai ' cor n y, t s
)
ADJUDGED t t Compl nt i DI I
hat he
ai s SM SSED W I
THOUT PREJUDI f f l r t sat a
CE or ai e o t e
cl m upon whi r i c be gr ed.
ai
ch elef an
ant

DONE AN D ORDERED i Cham ber a M i i Fl i t s
n
s t am , orda, hi
>
'

.
'

.
'.

ofJanuar 201 .
y 8
'

.
.

FEDER O .M OREN O
UN I
TED STATES DI
STRI JUDGE
CT
Copi f ni t
es ur shed o:
Sai ar Sangel , Pro Se
nger d
us
55728004
Edgefel Feder Corectonall tt i
id
al r i
nsiuton
I e M ai/ cel
nmat
lpar s
PO Box 725
Edgefel SC 29824
i d,
J
acquesPati , Pro Se
rck
06302-l
04
Edgefel Fe alCorectonalI tt i
i d der
r i
ns iuton

lmaeMal acl
n t ip res
/

I

Edg fel, SC 29824
ei d

j
i

PO Box 725

M ar on St Fl , Pro Se
cks
. eur
83708004
Edgefel Feder CorectonalI tt i
id
al r i
ns iuton
I e M ai/ cel
nmat
lpar s
PO Box 725
Edgefel SC 29824
i d,

AlnSaou , o<
a j s Pr %
e

98286004
Edgefel Feder CorectonalI tt i
id
al r i
nsiuton
I
nmat M ai/ cel
e
lpar s
PO Box 725
Edgefel SC 29824
i d,

2