Sexton v. Carnival Corporation

Filing 14

ORDER granting in part and denying in part 7 Motion to Dismiss as to Counts II, IV, and V. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 7/10/2018. See attached document for full details. (mmd)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SOU TH ERN DI
STR I O F FLORI A
CT
D
M i miDi son
a
vii
Cas Num be 1 20629- V- ORENO
e
r: 8Cl M
RODGER SEXTON,
Pl ntf,
ai if

CARNI
VAL CORPORATI , d/ a
ON b/
CARN I L CRU I LI E ,
VA
SE N
Dee
f ndant
.

ORDER GRANTI I PART AND DENYI I PART M O TI TO DI I AS
NG N
NG N
ON
SM SS

TO COUNT: l v V,AND V
lI

Plitf i s ig Canva Co p rto f rij re r s li fo a sr k h s fee
an if s un r i l r o ain o n u is e u t r m to e e u frd
ng
onboa d a c uie s p.Def nda i m ovi t dimist e c si t fve- c
r r s hi
e nt s
ng o s s hr e ount n he i ountc pl n .
om ai t
The Cour gr nt t m o i t dim is t vi rousla lt c am , bec us i i notpr ry
t a s he ton o s s he ca i
ibiiy l i
a e ts
ope l
pl d a c l t wih Pl ntf' diec neg i nce cai . The Cour a s gr nt t m o i t
e nd ontaed t ai ifs r t lge
lm
t l o a s he ton o
di m i s Pl ntf s c a m t tCar va br a hed a non- l ga e dut , as m a ii e l w doe not
s s ai i f l i ha
ni l e c
de e bl
y
rtm a
s

r c ze t c e ton of s a dut The Cour, howe r de es t m oton t dim is t
e ogni he r a i
uch
y.
t
ve , ni he
i o s s he
Pli ipscai bas on Ca ni ' a s
a ntf l m
ed
r vals s umpto ofdut .
in
y

THI CAUS c meb f r t Co r u nDee a t M o int Dimis( E 7) sl
S
E a e o e he u t po fnd n ' to o s s D. , ed
s
.

on M ar h 26. 8.
c
201
THE COURT hasc i r d t m o i , t pe tne po tons of t r or , and bei
onsde e he ton he ri nt r i
he ec d
ng
o he wief l advie i t pr m ie , i i
t r s uly
s d n he e s s t s
ADJUDGED t t m o i i GM NTED i pa ta DENI i pa t Pl ntf m a
hat he ton s
n r nd
ED n r. ai if y
f l a a e d c pl i c i t tw ih t s or rby J y 24, 20 18.
ie n m nde om a nt ons sen t hi de
ul

Bac ound
kir

Pli iffl a tve c
antf ied i - ountc
ompl i a ns De enda Ca ni Co po a i . W hie he
ant gai t f nt r val r r ton
l
wasapa s nge on t Ca ni Vit Pli ifs f r d a sr . Hecli t s p' physcin
s e r he r val sa, antf ufe e toke
a ms he hi s
ia
midi gnos d hi c ton asa ba t i i e ton. Pl ntf alege he s f r l sofmemor
s a e s ondii
ceral nf c i
ai if l s
ufe ed os
y
a vii a i per nen l i ie . The tve c s a e ne i nc , via i la lt
nd son, nd s ma ty mpa r d
i ount r glge e c rous ibiiy,
a r nta ncy,a s m pton ofdu y,a a non- e bl dut t pr de r s bl m e c
ppa e ge
su i
t nd
delga e y o ovi ea ona e dial

c r Def nda i movi t dimi sCount 1 f via i la lt , I f a s
a e. e nt s
ng o s s
s 1 or c rous i biiy V or s umpto ofdu y,
in
t
a V f t no deega edut t pr vi r as bl me c c r .
nd or he n- l bl y o o de e ona e dial a e
l.
1

LeaalSt
andard

' s vi a m oton t dimis pl n if mus do mor t n m e el sae lgal
' ur ve
To
i o s s , aitfs
t
e ha
r y tt e

concusons'i t a pl ntfsmus S l ge s e s ii f c ua bassf t e c l i or
l i r' nse d ai if
t t e om pecfc a t l i or hos onc usons
al
f cedimis loft rc am s' Jac s v.Belsout Teec
a
s sa
hei l i . ' k on
l h l omm., 272F. 1
3d 250,1 ( 1h Ci.
263 1 t r

2004 . W hen r i on amoto t dimis acoul mus viw t c ai i t lghtmos
)
ulng
in o s s,
' t e he ompl nt n he i
t
t
fvor e t t pl i if a ac e t pl i ifs we lpl a d f t as tue. See St Jose s
a abl o he antf nd c pt he antf
l- e de ac s r
.
ph'
Hos ,I .v.Hos Cor . o
p. nc
p. p fAm. 7 5F.d 9 , 5 ( 1h Ci.1 8 ) Thstn tho v r d e
, 9 2 48 9 3 1 t r 9 6 . i e e, we e, o s

n ta pyt lg lc n l in . S eAs c o tv I a ,1 9 S. .1 37 1 4 ( 0 9 M or
o p l o e a o cuso s e h rj . qb l 2 Ct 9 , 9 9 2 0 )
eover,
.

çwj ielg lc n lso sc npr vd tefa wok o ac mplit t y m ustbe s
i h l e a o cu in a o ie h rme r f o an, he
g
uppored by
t
f c ua al tons' l a 1 . Th e'ta t lalg to smus b e o g t r iearg tt
a t l lega i . d t 950
'
os 'q cua le ain
g
t e n u h o as ih o

ri a
elef bove t s ultve l ve on t a s pton t ta loft c
he pec a i e l
he s um i ha l
he ompl nts a lga i a e
ai ' le tons r
tue' BelAt.Cop.v Twombl 550 U .S.5 545 (
r .
' l l r .
y
44,
2007 . I s t t co antmus no
) n hor, he mpli
t t
m e el a l ge a m i conduc ,b m us de ons r t t tt pl ade i entt e t r le . Se I ,
r y le
s
t ut
t m ta e ha he e r s il d o e i f e qbal
l S.Ct a 1
29
. t 950.

1 1 Leaa Anal i
1.
l
vs s

M a ii e lw c r s a tons se i fo al ge t t on c ie s ps Kef v
rtm a ontol c i
t mm ng r m le d ors
nls hi . ee .
Baham a Cr s Li 867 F. 1 8, 1 20 ( 1h Ci.1
s ui e ne,
2d 31 3 1 t r 989) Ge rly,a d hi
. neal ç powne i o y
s
r s nl

la et ispa s nger f medialne i nc i is c
ibl o t s e s or
c
glge e f t onduc br che t c ni r smor ge r l
t ea s he a e '
e ne a
dut t e r it tea ona e c e unde t cr um sa es''Fr a v Ro Carbbe Cr s ,
y o xe cs r s bl as
r he ic t nc . ' anz . yal i an uies

Lt , 7 2 F.d 1 2 , 1 3 ( 1h Ci. 2 4 ( u tn Ke mar c
d. 7 3 2 5 23 1 t r 01 ) q oi g r e

Co ne Ge e al
mpa i n r e

Tr atantque 358U. 625,63 ( 959)
ans l i ,
S.
2 1 ).
Count2.Viarou Li lt
. c i s abii
y

Count2 ofPl i ifsco pl nti f vi rousla lt . A soppos t a cli ofdiec
antf
m ai s or ca i ibiiy
ed o am
r t
neg i nc Pl i i f he e,i a t ptng t r ove i t e nt C a ni ls m e c s a f w a
lge e, a ntf , r s tem i o ec r n he ve
r va '
di al t f
s

ne i n i tea i Pl ntf. The a lgai i t sco ta et tDef ndan br a he isdut
glge t n r tng ai if
le tons n hi un r ha
e
t ec d t
y

t e r s r as bl c e by f ii t ens e Pli if obt i d medi lte t e wihi a
o xe cie e ona e ar
a lng o ur antf
ane
ca r am nt t n
r s bl a
ea ona e mountof tme.Pl i if as al s t tDe e ntf ie t tme y a pr pe l
i
antf lo lege ha f nda al d o i l nd o ry
dignos Pl ntf sm e ca co to , f ie t ate t Pl i ifafe hi sr , f l t es r
a
e ai if
di l ndii n al d o t nd o antf tr s toke aied o co t
Pli ift obt i r a ona e m e ca c r f ie t pr de r s na e m e ca c r , f ie t
antf o an e s bl di l a e, a ld o ovi ea o bl
di l a e a l d o

r a o a l dig o e P an if a d f i d t p o el e mi et e Plitf sij re . Th r i
e s n by a n s litf, n al o r p ry xa n h an if nu is e e s
e
o sa e ntt Def ntS hr h is e oye a a nt , .
ne tt me hat enda ' oug t mpl es nd ge s
t

. .

t s p' me c saf,
he hi s dial t f

kne o s d ha kno t tt m e c lpr dur t e oye vi a e a o di no
w r houl ve wn ha he di a oce es hey mpl d olt d nd/ r d t
m e tr a ona e s a r ofca e.
e e s bl t nda ds
r'
'
The alega i i t s countcont e t o di f entt i of labiiy:di neglgence
l t ons n hi
lat w
f er heor es i lt rect
i

a vi a i
nd c r ous la lt C o m i lng di e t a vi a i
i biiy. m ng i
r c nd c r ous la lt i a i pr r pl adi
i biiy s n m ope e ng

p a tc .Wo f r v Ca nv lCop.No.1 - 07 - V, 01 W L 77 22 ,* ( D. a M a
rcie h o d . r ia r ,
72 03 C1 2 7
31 5 3 S. Fl. y
11 201 (ipje di a die tneglge e cam t t wih a via i la lt cl m...s
, 7) dg la ng rc
i nc li ogeher t
c rous ibiiy ai i

i rp r c n u ig a voae Rue 1 ( )' .Th r i n q sin, when r adi t
mp o e , o f sn , nd ilts l 0 b .) e e s o ueto
'
e ng he
ne i nce and vi rous labiiy c s s de by- i t t t vi a i
glge
ca i
i lt ount , i - s de, ha he c r ous labiiy c
i lt ount i
s

e ee ngl smia a i ude e e nt oft die tne i nc cl m i Co 1 The e or
xc di y i lr nd ncl s l me s he r c glge e ai n unt .
r f e,

t Cour gr nt t moton t dim is Count2 f vi a i la lt , wih u p eu ie a
ht
t a s he
i o s s
or c rous i biiy t o t rj d c nd
gr nt Pli if l ve t a e t s co t a l why Ca ni l i via i l la e f r t
a s antf ea o m nd hi unt o lege
r va s c rousy i bl o he
ne i enc ofism e c lsa f
glg e t di a t f .

Co n 4 Asu inJ /
u t : s mpto /DZ.
/
P
I Count 4,Pl i if c am s Ca ni asumed a dut t pr vi m e c l c r , and
n
antf l i
r val s
y o o de dia a e
t r o e ha t oblgai t us r as bl c r i t pr son ofm e ca s r ce . Fe r l
he ef r , d he i ton o e e ona e a e n he ovii
di l e vi s de a
c t ha r cogni d t tt t s
ours ve e
ze ha he k umpton ofdut 'dodrne, a stf t i j3 oft Se nd
as
i
y'
i s e orh n 23 he co
Resae e ofTors S sapplca e i m a ii e c es'D unawa v,Unie St e ,CI At tm nt
t, k
i
i bl n rtm as . '
y
t d ats V 98-

2035,
2000W L 64291 a *3( D. Jn.26,2000)( tngl an Towig Co.v.Unie St e ,
, t E. La. a
cii ndi
n
td ats
350U. 61 69( 955). Se ton 3 oft Sec Re ttme ofTors whih pe ti t t
S. , 1 ) ci 23 he ond sae nt
t, c rans o he
ne i en pe f manc ofunde tki t r nde s r ce , pr dest t
glg t ror
e
ra ng o e r e vi s ovi ha :
Onewho unde tke gr t t usy orf rc i r ton, t r r
ra s a uio l
o onsde ai o ende
s r c t a herwhi hes d r cog z asnec s r f
e vies o not
ch
houl e nie
es a y or
t pr edi n o t ot r per on or t ngs i s b e t t
he ot o f he he
s
hi , s u j c o
la lt t t ot rf physc ha m r s tng fom hi f l e
ibiiy o he he or
ial r e uli r
s aiur
t e r s r as
o xe cie e onabl ca et pe f m hi unde tki , i
e r o ror s
ra ng f

()h sf i r t e ecs s c c r i ra e t ers ofs c
a i al e o x r ie u h a e nce s s h ik u h
u
har ,or
m

()t eh r i s fee b c us o t eohe ' rla c u o t e
b h a m s u frd e a e f h t rs ein e p n h
unde tki
ra ng.
D il r v Ro Car bbe Cr s , L/ , N o. 17 2387 C l - or no, 2018 W L 1 661 *4
s e . yal
i an ui e J
4- V M e
91 4,

( D.Fl Aprl23,2018 ( i Rettment( c
S. a. i
) quotng sae
Se ond)ofTors j 323) Ro v Car val
t
; jas . ni
Cor , o.13 21
p. N
- 897- V - na d,201 W L 7736 , *6( D. a Nov. 201 .
C1 Le r
5
475
S. Fl.
30, 5)

Pli ifpld t tDe e ntvol a iy a s ed a dut t us r as
antf e ha f nda
unt rl s um
y o e e onabl c r whe i
e ae
nt
e e td t pr de Pli ifwih medials r ce . Pli if al ge t De enda br a he is
l ce o ovi
a ntf t
c e vi s a ntf le s hat f nt e c d t
d is be a e t physc a a ot rc ew me be sr ponsbl f tea i Pl ntf lcke
ute c us he
ii ns nd he r
m r es i e or r tng ai if a d

a e u t e p re c i te tn Plitf sij re a fie t p o ry da n ePlitf They
d q ae x e in e n r aig anif n u is nd ald o r pel ig os an if
.

alo f ie t pr de m e c lteam e i a r as
s al d o ovi
dia r t nt n e onabl a
e mountoftm e. As a r ul,Pli if
i
es t a ntf

alg sh s fee a dto a ij re .
le e e u frd d iin l nu is
Car va c e t r i no a s
ni l ont nds he e s
s umpton ofdut cai whe a c ie lne unde t st
i
y lm
n nls i
rake o
pr de me c ls l c be a ea c uie s p i notr uie t pr demedi ls r c . M any
ovi
di a ewies c us r s hi s
eq r d o ovi
ca e vies
pç Fr za c eshel t tas p hasno dut t s c e m e ca team e f ispa s nge s See
z- an as
d ha hi
y o e ur
di l r t nt or t s e r .

eg. Za a v Ro Carbbe Cr s s Lt ,No. 1 21 C1 201 W L 1
. , pat . yal i an uie , d
2- 897- V, 3
296298, at *3

( D.Fa Ma . , 01 )(ttn t ta s i i n tato tngho pi la d ac ieln h sn t
S. l. r 27 2 3 saig ha hp s o l ai
s t n nl ie a o
a
s
dut t pr dedoco sorme ca cae . TheElve h Cicui' decson i Fr za, however
y o ovi
tr
di l r)
e nt r ts ii n an
,
c ls i o quesi t r tona e of ea ler de sons se mi fom t r e a
a l nt
ton he a i l
ri
cii
tm ng r
he ul nnounc d i
e n
Bar ta v S/ Be muda St r,8 F. 1 , 1 6 (t Ci.1 8 ) whc pr vd d ' r a
bet . S r
a 48 2d 364 3 7 5h r 9 8 , ih o ie ç o d
b
i m uniy f c ui e lnes ' l Fr z , t Elvent Cic ts c fcal ç lne t a
m
t or r s i , n an a he e h r ui pe i ly d i d o doptt
'
dec
he

Bar ta r e be us of a ong ot r r a ons çhe e uton of l l nonns t rs of a
bet ul ca e , m
he e s , t vol i
ega
, he i e
c pl c ui e i ty, a t pr e s on of m ode n t c
om ex r s ndus r nd he ogr s i
r e hnol .' Ghareh v Car v
ogy '
'
f . nial
Cor ,N o. 1 20499- V ,2018 W L 1
p.
7C1
697025, a * ( D. a. .6,201 )( tngFr a,
t 9 S. Fl Apr
8 quoi anz

772F.da 1 )
3 t 228).
Alhoug Fr a bea s on t ditnc is of whehe a c uie lne c n be he d
t h anz
r
he si t s ue
t r
r s i a
l
vi a i usy labl f t m a pr tc of is m e ca pe s
c r o l i e or he l ac i e t di l r onne , ti a s c a ns a c pr he i
l ût l o ont i
om e ns ve
ove vi ofm a ii e ne i nc l w a is deve o e , and i a l es m y i d publc polc
r ew
rtm
glge e a nd t
l pm nt
t na yz
ra
i
iy

c e ns t t miiae i f
onc r ha
lt t n avor of a i a m or c e por r appr c t c ie s p
doptng
e ontm a y
oa h o nzs hi

l iain. Gh re , 01 W L 1 9 0 , t# tn t dt a t pa s n e who flsi1a o r a
i g to ' af h 2 8
t
'
6 7 25 a 9.I oe h t t s e g r
a
al 1 b a d
c u s s p ha pr c o ltl c i e but t s
r ie hi s e i us ite ho c
o ubmi t on r ca e'a S a ha lt r ly
t o boa d r ' nd s y ve ie a l
m
now he e e s t go.' an a, F. a 1
r l e o ' Fr z 772 3d t 242.

Fr n a,Gh re ,a d ti Co r' h l n i Dilr d n i a mo in t dimis a
az
af h n h s u ts odig n se e yng
to o s s n
a s pton of dut cl i , di t t t t t s Cour a l t s c ai t s vi t m oton t
s um i
y am
c a e ha hi
t low hi l m o ur ve he
i o

ds s .Th Co r ma r vstti is ea s mmayj dg n t d tr n t eva l yo t i
imis e u t y e ii h s su t u r u me t o eemie h ibit f hs
i
cam, u, t h s u cu e Plitf h sprpel p e i.
li b t a t i j n t r , anif a o ry ld t
Count5:Br ac o heNon- lgabl Dtf t Pr deMe c Car
e h ft
Dee e / o ovi
y
dial e
Co 5 i a cli t tCa ni lbr e
unt s
am ha r va ea hed a non- lgabl dut t pr de r ona e
de e e y o ovi eas bl
m e c l ca e. Pl ntf r le on Fr z t s
di a r
ai i f e i s
an a o uppor t s cl m , quotng l ng ge t t s ys
t hi ai
i a ua ha a

kc areso t i aln p se g r $ d t t e ecs r a o a l c r t f mih s c ad a d
s j rir we her iig a s n e s a uy o x r ie e s n b e ae o u s u h i n
g
a s sa
s itnce a or na iy pr t pe s wo d r nder unde sm ia cic sa s'' Thi
s di rl uden r ons ul e
r i l r r um t nce . '
s

a s ri howe r i tki Fr at dit t f r Fr za a l s powne st be vi rousy
s e ton,
ve , s a ng anz s ca oo a . an lows hi
r o
ca i l
la e whe a pas e r r c vesneg i ntm e ca ca e by is a nt a r is s p. Franza,
ibl
n
s nge e ei
lge
di l r
t ge s boa d t hi
772 F. a 1
3d t 235. Thi Cou thas a s a l
s
r
l o lowed Pl i i f t pr ee on is a s pton of d y
a ntf o oc d
t s um i
ut

cai sa i t twhe a s p unde tke t pr dem e c lc r t ispas e s i m us do s
l m, ttng ha
n hi
ra s o ovi
di a a e o t s nger , t t o
wih r a ona e c r W hie t sCour r c ni est tFr a c nges t prorl gall nds pe
t e s bl a e.
l hi
t e og z ha anz ha
he i e
a ca ,
t r i no l ngua t s
he e s
a
ge o uppor t cr a i of a non- l bl d y. Pl i ifhasnotcie a
t he e ton
de ega e ut
a ntf
td ny

sa u ol a hort or cas lw t s
tt t ' ut iy
y
e a o uppor t s as e ton. Ac r ngl t Co t g a s t
t hi s ri
co di y, he ur r nt he
m oton t di m i s
i o s s.

A

D ON E A N D ORD ERED i Cha ber a M i m i Fl i ,t s
n
m s t a , or da hi

ofJ y 2018.
ul

FED ER
. OREN O
UNI
T STATES DI
STRI J
CT UDGE
6

Copisf nihe t
e ur s d o:
Couns lofRec d
e
or

7