Great American Insurance Company v. Seaboard Marine, Ltd., Inc.

Filing 38

ORDER Denying 16 Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment. Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 6/18/2019. See attached document for full details. (jw)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
SOUTH ERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
M I IDI SI N
AM
VI O
CASE NO .1: CV18- 21346JLK
GIEAT AM ERI
I
CAN I
NSUM NCE
COM PAN Y,af ei co por ton,
or gn r ai

Pli if
antf,

SEABOARD M ARI LTD .l C.
NE,
,N ,
a f ei c por ton,
br gn or a i
Def nda .
e nt
/
O RDER DENYI DEFENDANT' M O TI FO R SUM M ARY JUDGM ENT
NG
S
ON

THI M ATTER comesbe or t Cou tupon Def nda Se
S
f e he
r
e nt aboa d M a i ,Lt ,
r
rne d.

(de b adM ai ' M o inf rSu r J d me t D. 1 ) fldM a l , 01 .
i a o r rne' to o mmay u g n ( E. 6 , ie y 4 2 9 1
s
)
BACKGRO UND

Thi s ogai s ta iesou of t t h ofa f t f s ppi c ai asi wa
s ubr ton ui rs
t he he
ory-oot hi ng ont ner t s

beng tans tdbytuc t apor whe ei wast bel de ont aves elde tne f t Unie
i r pore
r ko
t r t
o oa d o
s si d or he td
Stt . Ac r ng t t e bil ofl ng da e N ove
aes co di o hr e ls adi
td
mber1 201 Defnda Se boa dM arne
5, 7, e nt a r
i

c nr ce wihn n p ryDai Entmrs s I c (d s ao do e' t ta p r t o s n so
o ta td t o - a t rk e ie , n . 'he e f o wn r' o rns o th u a d f
t
)
c e offoz s f fom i ac of r cept'Ra Ni r ua t S tofl ng' Pue t
as s
r en ea ood r s e
pl
e i ' ma, ca ag o s
por
oadi ' ro

Li n Co t Ria te vav se ç geiaJ 't i ot f ic re' o ky , a dfnai
mo , sa c ;h n i esl* l #'o i ro dshag 'Bro ln NY; n i ly
An n
p
i
t $ lc o d l ey' ia eh, w J re (e D. 1 - , t -9 .
k a e f ei r 'El b t Ne es y s e E, 6 2 a 6 )
v
z
l
o p
i

1
I
i
7

1The Co tha as c ie e Pli ifsRes o e i Oppo iin ( E.1 ,fld M a 28 201 al
ur s lo onsd r d antf
p ns n
sto D. 8) ie
y , 9; l
d
De e da tsRe l ( E. 4) fldJ ne4, 9.
f n n ' py D, 3 , ie u
201
)
i

:

i

)
i

i u ds ue t to No e e 1 ,20 7 c nane No.CXRU 1 5 3 8 wt
s n ip td ha n v mb r 6 1 , o ti r
577
s
ta poredby De e ntSe boa d M a i bytu fo Ce r Ame i a Fihe ist t Cosa
r ns t
f nda
a r
rne r ck r m ntal
rc n s re o he t
Ria bor r a onNovember1 201 i wasta poredt De e ntscont ne ya d Socae
c n de , nd
7, 7 t
r ns t o f nda '
ai r r t td
l

af w mie o ti ePu roLi n Co t Ria' D. 1 ,a 3 ! 7 )
e ls u sd e t mo , sa c '( E. 6 t , ! -8 .The ,o No e e 2
n n v mb r û,
2 7a 1 4 am.t ec n an rd p re Dee d n ' c nan ry r o t epo td e ei w4
01 t 2:8 . , h o tie e a td fn a ts o tie adf r h r t r t s
wh

l
i

t b lae o t tesi An eia whc wa shd ldt dp rta d y'D. 1,t , 9.
o e odd no h hp gl , ih s ceue o eatht a'( E. 6 a 4 ! )
n
Ii u dsue tec ti rwa l ti teae b t e tec nan ry r a dtep r, ih
ts n ip td h onane s os n h ra ewe n h o tie ad n h o twhi
)
:

i k o a t eS ao e'( E.1 ,a 2 . Plitf atc e t isCo litaç u r g t n
s n wn s h d r usl D. 6 t )2 an if ta h s o t mpan s b o ai
c
'
s
g
Re ept sg e b t s aoo o e frt els a is e( E.1 a 7 .
c i ' in d y he e f d wn r o h o s t su D. , t )
'

!

y
1
1

l t i t ntM oton f Sum ma y J
n he nsa
i or
r udgm e , Dee d n a g sta (çgl ru n t tl
nt fn a t r ue h t p u s a t o h
l
e
i

e p e str o teRe p nsbit ca s o g fn a ts b l o ld n tr a d c n ii n ,
x rs e ms f h s o i l y lu e f De e d n ') il f a i g ems n o d to s
i
l
( ee a t i n tla l f rls aiigfo hj c ig a di t ee o ee t ldt j d me ta i
D fnd n) s o ib e o o s rsn r m i kn n s h r f r ni e o u g n sa
a
t
j
l

matrO lw'( E.1 ,a 8 . l r s o s , an ifa g st t()t Ha trAc p o i t l
te f a ' D. 6 t ) n ep n e Plitf r ue ha a he re t r hbi a
s
$

cne fo uigtr adcn io si i blo ldn t a odl bly( E, 8 a 4 1t;
airrm sn ems n o dt n n t i faig o v i i it D. 1 ,t - 1
i
s l
ai
t
)
a ( Dee thasnotme isbur nunde t bur n-hitngfn wor oft Carage(f
nd b) fndan
t t de
r he de s fi rme k he ri !
)
2
j
Go d b s aAc o 1 35(cOGSA' t s o i wa n t tfut(d a 1 -1 )
os y e tf 9 $
i
' o h w t s o a a l i. t 1 5 .
)
r
p

I.
I

DI
SCUSSI
ON
A . Lega St
l andard on Sum m ar Judgm e
y
nt

@
)
r
l
i

S mmayj d me ti a p o raewh r t eei t og nun is ea t a maeila t
u r u g n s p r p it ee h r s ' e ie s u s o ny tra ft
n
a d ta te mo ig pa' i e tte t j d me a a matro lm ' Fe R.Ci P.5 ()
n h t h vn ly s n i d o u g nt s
t
l
te f a ' d.
v. 6 ç

7De e a tp o fr t de ostonofPlitf c r ort rpr s nai , ulaPrc ,ora kn e e /
f nd n r fes he p ii
an ips o p ae e e e ttve J i ie f c owldg me2t

ta tec nan r sdnec pe b ame hjc eswh soetec nan r ( E.l , t , 1 ) b t
h t h o tie wa ' tre td y r d i k r o t l h o tie,, D. 6 a 4 ! 1, ?
i
a
Pl n ifdip t st t' s P iewa ac t n win s t pr detsi ny a t t a l e c us p
aitf s u e ha ç . rc s ompee t t e s o ovi e tmo s o he leg d a e f
M
I s' D. .1 , 1 )
os'( E 9 ! l.
(
l
!

l
i
l

'

i
I
(

l

(mp a i a d d ; d r o v fi e t Lo b ,I . 4 7 U. 2 2 2 7 48 ( 9 6 . An is S
e h ss d e ) An e s n . b ry b y nc, 7 S. 4 , 4 - 1 8 )
sue s
q

gen nei ar s na ef c snd c dr t naver c f t nonmovi pa t . Mie .efrs
ui f ea o bl a t er oul eur
dit or he
ng ry z vJfes n
i

Ci Bdo dc,3F.d7972(1hCi.96. fcimaeilft yafcte ucYe
t .fE u.9 3 3,4 1t r19)A ats tr iima feth oto
y
a
I

o t c s u e t ea p ia es bsa t lw.Al n v T o Fo d ,I . 1 F.d 6 2 6
f he a e nd r h p lc bl u tni a
ve
l . ys n o s nc, 21 3 4 , 16
e
l
( 1hCi 1 9 ) l ar a o a l fc fn e c ul d a moet n o ei e e c fo t efc!
1 t r 9 7 . f e s n b e a t id r o d rw r ha n nfrn e r m h a t,
s
)
.

j

ce t ag n i eis eo maeilfc, u r j d me ts o l n tb g a td. S mpls#
r ai
ng e u n su f tra a t s mmay u g n h u d o e r ne a e x
l
r lS mplsv Ci o lnt,8 6 F.d 1 2 ,1 3 ( 1hCi.1 8 ) Th mo i p ryh st e
e. a e . t fAt a 4 2 3 8 3 0 1 t r 9 8 . e vng a t a l
y
a
j

b re o etbihn b t teasneo agn ieiseo maeilat n taiietldj
udn f sal ig oh h bec f eun su f trafc ad h tts nie l
s
t o
)

i
udgmenta amatroflw.Se Matus t Elc I .Co.v Ze t Radi Cor ,1 S.Ct
s
te
a
e s hia e . ndus
. nih
o p. 06
.
13
48
l
, 1 5 (9 6.
3 6 18 )
;
(
B.
' BilofLadi i Voi Unde t H ar e Ac
l
ng s d
r he t r t
i
l
Clus 4 b ofDe e a s
a e ()
fnd nt

!

Defnda Se boad Ma i ag st ti i no la ef t l sa is be us Clus
e nt a r rne rue ha t s t ibl or he os t s ue ca e a e
k

4b o i Blo Ldn T r adC niositnefrebepo io . .elcn te
() ft i f aig ems n odt n s' nocal rvs n . rf t g j
s l
i a
i
ei l
Pre'gemetoalctrknte vnoa icig'D..6a8. h poio sth
atsare nt l aei i h eetf hakn' E 1,t)Te rvsn te:
i
o s
j
(
i a
.

The Ca re s lnotbe la e i a c pact wha s ve f ...a t oft e ,
ri r hal
i bl n ny a iy
t oe r or
c s hi ves

hj c i g
ia k n

l
k

i
j

Cont i r o ot rpac gesoc uri a anytmec e a e unde s vii
ane s r he
ka
c rng t
i ont mplt d
r ubdi son
*

o a y ohe l so d ma et o i c n e to wih t Go dso
r n t r os r a g o r n o n ci n t he o r

!

a)oft sClus
hi a e.

l

. . .

l

( E. 6 1 a 2 ) S b vso ()o t tClu ed fne t ea pl a l t a ç u igtee tt
D. 1 - , t -3 . u diiin a fha a s ei s h p i b e i s s rn h n ie
c
me d
q
tmet Ca ri r s i ef t g
i he nie s e ponsbl or he oods'
.3
'

;

I
J

i
3Thef lde c itono t r lv n tmep ro i Cl s 4 a i:
ul s rpi f he ee a t i e id n au e ( ) s
. .

b fr la igo a datrdsh refo tev se a dtru h u tee t etme
eoe o dn n n fe ic ag rm h e sl n ho g o t h ni i
r

!

j

l

t eGoo orCo t ie so o h rpa k g sa ei t c r , sod an / rc r oft
h
ds
n an r r t e c a e r n he a e cu t y d o ontol he

1

Ca e ,isa n s sr ns Pa tcp tngc rir o ide e e tc n rcor (n l ieof
ni r t ge t, e va t, riiai are s r n p nd n o ta t s icusv
als c nta t s, t e e ga dbyora tn f t Ca re ora ote pe s n,a
l ub o rcor) wheh r n ge
c ig or he rir ny h r ro nd

.

durng t entr tm et Cari ri r
i he ie i he re s esponsi e f t Goods.
bl or he

( E.l - , t2)
D. 6 1 a .

'

l

l
Pl ntf c est tt Ha trActa ist t sa ton (
ai if ountr ha he re
pple o hi ci D

l
E.1 , t4 1.Th Hatr
8 a -1) e rr

.

l

Ac sae t a a((c n e e a e i tec rig o g o st o fo a yp r i t eUnie S ae r
t tts h t a i r ng g d n h a ra e f o d o r r m n o tn h td tts,
t
,
i

4 US .372a$ y oiet aiol i osi i dcmetpoioao i
6 ,Cj00()1 nt sri bl fan rh pn ou narvsnvil
,ma n n l d g p g
i dj
g
(

is la lt f l sor da
t i biiy or os
mage a i i fom ne i nc orf ul i . . . c t
rsng r
glge e
a tn
usody,ca e,o pr @
r r opt
r

delvey, i j30704. S s pr son i voi ' d. TheElve h Cic tha r c ze
i r 'd
'
s uch ovii s d.
Any
'I
e nt rui s e ogni d
t tt Ha t Ac gove nsa ca ersc t y or c r ofpr t durng t pr oadi pha ç
ha he rer t
r
ni ' usod
ae
opery i he el ng s ,
)

Alsat I .Co.v 1 1Shipi Cor ,7 F. 497, ( 1hCi.1 (f a et da :
lt e ns
. nt p ng p. 03 2d
499 1 t r 983) s us he map
Bec
e

h r u e ibyo c rdp irt t t teg od weela e ,h HatrAc .. c nr s'.
ee nd na l cure ro o he i h o s r o d d te re t . o tol.)
me
'
1

I Als at,aca rert tc r cedt s p c r o f om M o l A lba at Sa J n,Pue t Rio
n lt e
ri ha onta t o hi a g r
bie, a m o n ua
ro q

)

b oket s l oft iemswhiesili M obie, a ma.1 a 498.TheElve h Cic tsa p
r he ea s he t
l tl n
l Al ba
d. t
e nt r ui t t d
i
.

t twh nac rirC c e ts c so yo t c r o i u d rlk s alo lg to si sd u p
ha e are d c p g) u t d f heEa g ) t n e ta e j l biai n mpo e p n
a
1
ac rir yteHa trAc . .ncu igter s o i ii e o ac mmonlw bale' f . t 9 :
are b h re t . i ldn h ep nsbl is f o
t
a ie . # a 4 94
'
(

Hee Dee d n is l a s rst tte f ry fo s ipig c n an r d patd is o
r , fn a t tef s et ha h o t-o t hp n o tie e re t Wn
I

c nane y r a 1 : am.f rc rig i t ec r u e t tep r tr na,wheei wa t l
o ti r ad t 248 . io ara e n h ao s l o h o te mi l r t s o e
f
I
;

la e o t tes p Ang ln ,whc wa sh due t d patta da '( E.1 ,a 4, 9 .
o d d no h hi eia ih s c e ld o e r h t y' D. 6 t ! 1
)

1
Dee da t ie t teaûd vt fiso Dietro Co in e Da O' i1frhsfc là;
fn n cts o h f a io t wn rco f mpl c , n Ne1,o ti a t i
a
l
l

!
J
4

@

Th Ha t rAc , i na l pa s d i 1 93, s l r l s pp a e b t e Ca ra e ofGoo b S a Ak
e re t orgi l s e n 8 wa a ge y u l nt d y h r ig
y
ds y e t

o 1 6 ($
f 93 i
COGSA' ,no c diid a te n e f lwi 46 U. C.j307 . Alho h COGSA by is
' w o fe s h ot olo ng
)
S.
01 t ug
i
!
tr onl go r sf rt pe idt a c r o i la d onoa o e nve s , c rirma e t n COGSA
e ms y ve n o he ro h t a g s o de t n c a sela a re y x e d
b co ta tot ee tr tmeteg dsa ei i c sod (icudngap i ofi a ta po t' Kawa a
y nr c t h n ie i h oo r n t u t y,Cn l i erod nlnd rns r.
s
'
s ti

Kie Kas Lt v Re alBe otCo p.5 1U. 89 96( 01 (n ena qu ai makso te ) He k
s n iha d. . g - l i r , 6 S. , 2 0) itr l otton r mitd . r ,
Clus 4a o Dee ntsBilofLa ngTemsa d Con ton e e sCOGSA t t tme( fi
a e () f fnda ' l
di r n
dii s xtnd
o he i s oi.
be e

la igo ,A tev se.Ho v rc ut ta h v ((u h l c nrcu le tn in o COGS t p ro s
o dn n h esl we e, o r h t a e p ed o tata xe so s f
s
A o eip
odn rl c v rdb teHa trAc, h v d n s o l t t ee tn ta COGS d e n tc nlc wi
r iai o ee y h re t' a e o e o ny o h xe th t
y
'
A os o ot t j
i '
h
teHa trAc .PTl don saEps nI s v Ore tOv re sCo ai rLi ,I c, 1 F.S 2d 1 6$
h re t
n e i o ndu . . in e s a nt ne ne n .2 9 upp. 2 :,
1 69 ( D.Fl.20 )(or n,J) eg. Un l Be ,sI e n Di.o Unce Be , ,I c v Ha g- l)d
2 S. a 02 J da .; . , c e n ntr . v f l n s n . . pa L o?

Aken s l c a 8 5F.d2 5 2l (t Ci. 9 8; utfteL o vARAWAK Ca ib a LieL4,
tigeel h f, 5 2 1 , 7 5h r 1 8 )Fr io h o m .
s
rb e n n t
1 6F S p . d1 3 ,1 414 ( D. a 1 9 ) L n h M .. Th rfr, e b adMaiesc nrcu l
2 . u p 2 3 7 3 - 2 S. Fl. 9 8 ( y c , J) eeo e S a o r rn ' o t th
.
a
ext i ofCOGSA i isbilofldi hasno bearng on whe hert HarerActa i her
enson
n t l a ng
i
t he t
pples e.
l
4
l
q
l
$
.

k

!
!

i
2

s eas D. 1 - , t4 ! 1 ) a di i t epo iino b t p rist t h c r owa l tSa fi
e lo E. 6 2 a , 8 , n t s h sto f o h a t ha t t ag s os % jtr
e
g

d prigfo tec nan ry r '( E.1 ,a 4 ! l ;D. 1 ! 1 ) Theeoe t Co z
e at rm h o tie ad' D. 6 t , 1 E. 9, 1. rfr,he u
n
)
l

'

c n ld s h th S a o s l a e wh r tec r owa l s i c ran yp rofh p eo dngp a'
o cu e t a te i r u e' r a ee h a g s o t s etil a t te rl a i h p
c
'
t

gove ned byt Ha trAc i t sCic t Se Alsat I .Co ,703 F. a 498.
r
he re t n hi r ui. e lt e ns .
2d t
I is Re y,
n t pl

!
:
(
I
l

Dee d n ctsasrn o c s sfo ao n tefd rl u iir fr$e
fn a t i tig f ae rm ru d h e ea j dcay o
e
p iin t a ih Ha trAc d e n ta pl t a (o s o c ni g d rn t e iln p a e o i
0sto h t d e re t o s o p y o ls ) c u n u ig h na d h s fa
t
l

mut d l a ig '( E. 4 a 4 ,ve wh ni tec so yo tec nir(d a 5 .I tetrt
li a c n a e'D, 3 , t )e n e n h utd fh a e i t ) n h 'j
mo
i
i
c s i t sl e J g n eg Ic v Ge r aPo tAuh rt 8 2F. p .1 65( D. .1 9 i
ae n hi i , a e b r, n . . ogi rs to i 8 Su p 0 S. Ga 9 5,
n
y
j
1

t c tf
he our ound ii advia et ke p s a c r ir t t s a r i pos d by t Ha trAc untl
st s bl o e e a re s o he t nda ds m e
he re t i
i

g o saei teha d o ln crir a dat lyla igtemaii ae a' 1 a 1 78 l
o d r n h n s f a d ares n cual e vn h rtme rn . d. t 0 . n
'
i
1

J
agenbe g,c r o wast ne ove t as pa a eentt a a por i Sa nna Ge gi f sor gk,
r ag
ur d r o e r t
iy t
t n va h, or a or t a

'

i

a dwa d ma e wh l b i rtiv dfo t so a ea e b a tnln tu k rhr db (l
n s a g d ie eng ere e r m he tr g ra y n i a d r c e ie y t!
i
e
ë

s ac ni r t tk i t M a o ' 1 .a 1 6 . De e d n ct so h rc s sa p yn t e sn e
e a e) o a e t o c n. d t 0 9 fn a t ie t e a e p l ig h a j
'
i

r ao i ga i J g n e g al r m o ti et Elv nh Cic i a aliv l igc r ol s J r
e s n n s n a e b r , lfo usd he e e t rut nd l n o vn ag o t /4
I
i

iwa u la e fo av se (d a 4 5 . Re ad e st i Co r d cie t c bi t eHatrAt,
t s no d d r m e s li. t - )5 g r ls,h s u t e ln s o a n h re t

5Th c s saeMan s n De g Cor v M / CONCERTFATAF5 225F. 5 ,58 5 -9 ( t
e ae r
ne ma ma
p. . V
X,
3d 87 8, 94 5 5,
h
Ci. 00)( agoda ge e r t b tu k fom p ti Batmor ,M ayln t Ter Ha e l a )
r 20 c r ma d n oue y r c r or n li e r a d o re ut, ndinj ;
Su ln Wi
zo ndEne gyCor v Shipe sStv d ig Cas 1- 7- 5 20 W L 68 206, t* -4,l ( D.
r
p. . p r e e orn
No. 10 1 5, 08
6 a 3 8 S.

T x Ma . , 0 8 (ag d ma e wh l b igla e o t tu ka p r i Ho so , x s d sie fr
e . r 7 2 0 ) c ro a g d i en o d d no rc t o tn u tn Te a, et d i
e
n 1
Mi eot) Grat Is Co.o J v A/ MolrMa rkA/ 48 F.Su 2 3 ,358( D. Y.
nn s a; e Am. n . fN : . P le- es S, 2
pp. d 57
S. N.
ï
2 7 (agohia k dwhl ben ta s re b tuc fo p ti Guae at Guae aCiy;Soy
00 ) c r j c e ie ig rnpotd y r k rm or n tmal o tmal t) n
Co tr Ent I .v Nipo Ex es U S. .(li s,I c,3l F.Sup 2d 3 3 -35 33 36
mpu e . nc . p n pr s
A Il ) n . 3
noi
p. 33, 34 , 7, )
0
( D. Y. 04 (a g orgn t d i J p n solnfo c t ie y r i Ne J r e whiei p s s/
S. N. 20 ) c r o iia e n a a t e r m on an r a d n w e sy l n osesin

o riwa ) Phii - a He sn Cop.v Mis iO. K Lie Lt ,No.Ci A.: 0 06 20 2 WL
f al y; l V n ue r . tu S. n s d
ps
V. lCV-0- 65, 0 .
3 48 3 a # 5( D. n Au 1 2 2)(s so t cr- oc urddui- i a p t o-oun.
23 26 , t 3, M. Pe n. g. 4, 00 - -ços fhe a- c re rna nlnd-ori fi ri
l
go
on
y
-

whlte o tiesrse i Harsug,, Pn slaio junyfo p riNe Jre)Ab o Chn ,
i h c nan r etd n ribr, e nyvna no re rm otn w esy; b t e q
e
I .v M oi sdePue t Rio I . 62 F.Su 2 4 l 444, 9 ( P. 1 9)(o grt da g d
nc . lno
ro c , nc,
pp. d 4 , 44 -50 D. R. 99 s y is ma i

whldp stdi slsi P et Riofrsoa eatrsime trm Lo iin)adCog tPamoi
i eoi n i n uro c o trg fe hp n fo usaa;n lae l l
e
e o
h

C .. P'TA I CO EY R'NO. 5Cv 19( , 96WL726,t 16(. N.
ovM/-' L NTC NV O ' 9 i. 5 MBM)19
A
,
48 la *, SD. y.
De 3l 1 6) ( ago da ge durng ta s r b tu fom p t i Batmor, Ma ylnd f
c. , 99 c r
ma d i r n po t y r ck r
or n li e
ra o
J fkron l l a )
eï s vil ndina .
e,
!
5

i
i
;
.

I

I
l
t
l

whihb i tr a le t at are e g g di tecrig o g o st o fo a yp r i te
c y t ems ppis o s rir n a e n h ara e f o d o r rm n o tn l
s
c
l
J

Unie St
td

!

ae , 4 U. C.j 3 7 2 a , nd whih t eElv n h Cic i s csc l e tn st a
ts' 6 S.
'
0 0 () a
c h e e t r ut pe i al xe d oj
y
i

ca e , pos es i ofc r o prort l di ont as p, Alsat l .Ct. 703 F. a 498,t #1
ni r s s son
a g i o oa ng o hi lt e ns ),
2d t
ot
j
a bir r poi a whi ht ar nai no l rS a ii .''
r ta y nt t c he e s onge ç rtme
m
i
j

'

iw j n Gu fCaibe n a c p e c so y oft extusi ns i underook al oblgatoàs
i he l rb a c e td u t d
g
he r o t
t
l i ij

!
j
mpos upon aca rerby t Ha trAc .' Alsat I .Co. 7 F. a 499. The Cour hol)
ed
ri
he re t' lt e ns
, 03 2d t
t ds
l
t tt s me i tue he e:whe Se boar M arne ac e e c t oft s f co aner !
ha he a s r
r
n a d
i c ptd usody he ea ood nt i ,l
i
t
i
i

u d ro kalo l ainsi o e o i b teHa trAc, n e whc Clu e4 b ofisTe
n eto l bi to mp s d n t y h re t u d r ih a s ( ) t nss
g
I
!
i
I
I

a
6
nd Condii i voi
tons s d.

11
1.

CONCLUSI
ON

j
i

Un e fd rl1w ta g v rstec nig o g o t a dfo p rso teUni dSae,
d r e ea a h t o en h a a e f o dso n rm o t fh t ttà
e

Cas 4b i Deedn cre'Blo Ldn Tr adCodt n i vi adde nt
lue ()n fnat ar r i f aig ems n n ios s od n os j
is l
i
i

eclaeDeedn crirf m lblyfrls o croi i pseso pirolaigte
xupt fnat ar r i it o os fag n t ossin ro t odn l
e o ai
s
j
l

cro o t a v se. Acodigy i i ORDERED,ADJ
ag no esl c r n l, t s
UDGED,a DECREED ti
nd
ht
D

I

I

N

efnda sM oto frSummayJ
e nt
in o
r udgme ( E.1 be, ndt s mei,he e DENI
nt D. 6) a he a s r by
ED. k
DONE and ORDERED i Cha be s a t J mes La e
n
m r t he n
wr nce Ki Fe al J tç
ng der usie

B
uidi a Unie Stt Courhous i M i mi Fl i o t s 1 h da ofJ ,201
l ng nd t d a es
t e n a , orda, n hi 8t y une
9.
.

#x .
x

%
%

AM ES LAW RENCE KI G
N
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF F
CT
CC:

GE
I
DA

AI CounselofR ecord
I

tBe a eClus 4( )d sno a pl t sa toni go er e b COGSA' bu de -hitn fa wo k.
i c us a e b oe t p y,hi ci s v n d y
S r n s fig rme r
So y Ma t Pr s I .o
n gnei od . nc fAme iav M e iin i F 8 F.d 1 ,1 39( lhCi.1 9 .
c
rc . rve t 0/ , 63 2 537 5 1 t r 98 )
6

i
j