Presendieu v. USA

Filing 28

ORDER ADOPTING REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS re 26 Motion for Certificate of Appealability filed by Stanley Presendieu, 27 Report and Recommendations, ; granting 26 Motion for Certificate of Appealability; Adopting 27 Report and Recommendations on 26 Motion for Certificate of Appealability filed by Stanley Presendieu, 27 Report and Recommendations, Signed by Judge Darrin P. Gayles on 10/5/2021. See attached document for full details. (ra)

UNI
TED STA TES D I RI T C O U RT
ST C
SO U TH ER N D I
STRI T O F FLO R I
C
DA
C A SE N O . 1: c 21
: 19- v- 524- A Y LES/ TA ZO G
O
REY E S
STAN LEY PR ESEN D I ,
EU
M ovant
,

UN I ED STA TES O F AM ERI A ,
T
C
Respondent
.

TH I CAUSE c e be or t Cour on M a sr t J
S
om s f e he
t
gita e udge Alca M .Ot z Re '
ii
a o- yes s

Re r a Rec
po t nd omme ton(he'l por'l( No. r gadi M ova StnlyPr endiu'
ndai t l
ke t' ECF 271 e r ng
nt a e es e s

Re u s f rCe t iaeof e lb ly(h l q e f)( No 2 1 OnAp i 1 , 01 , o a t
q e t o ri c t App aa ii te s u s ' ECF . 6 .
f
t
Re
rl 9 2 9 M v n
fld hi M o i r ue tng a r consde a i ofhi s ntnce of2l m ont 'i ionme .Se
ie s ton eq si
e
i r ton
s e e
2
hs mprs
nt e

Untd Sa e v Pr s n iu Ca eNo 1 - 0 3 ,g No. 7 )( D.Fl.Oc.1 ,2 5 .On
ie tts . e e de , s . 5 2 0 2 ECF
2 9 S. a t 5 01 )
J ne 28 201 t Cour r e r d t s c s t J
u
,
9, he
t ef r e hi a e o udge Ot z Re , pur ua t 28 U . C.
a o- yes
s nt o
S.

j636( ( )B) f a r i on al pr til non- s ii matr a a rpor a
b)1( , or ulng
l e-ra,
dipostve tes nd
e t nd
rc
e omme tononaldipostvematr .( No.5 . Augus 23,2021 J eOt o- yes
ndai
l s ii te s ECF
) On
t
, udg az Re
i s he Re tr c m endi t tt Re
s ued r por e om
ng ha he ques be g ant a a ce tfc t ofa
t
r ed nd
ri i a e
ppea abiiy be
l lt

is ast t f l ng queton:whehe t mova e tbls d abassf 28U. C.j2255
sued o he olowi
si
t r he
nt sa ihe
i or
S.
r le on hi c am s t t s nt nc ng c
ei f
s l i ha e e i ouns lpr ded i fe tve as itnc a t ta wai r
e ovi
ne f c i
ssa e nd ha
ve
pr s on i hi pl a r e e vi a e hi due pr es r ghtt t pr e a i of m a era l
ovi i n s ea g e m nt ol t d s
oc s i
o he es nt ton
t i ly

a c rt i o maina s ne i .ECFNo. 7a 2 . ih rp rytmeytldo j ci n .
c u ae nfr to t e tncng (
2 t 1 Net e a t i l ie b e to s

A d src c u t ma a c p , rjc, o mo f a ma itae j d e s rpo t a d
itit o r y c e t ee t r diy
g srt u g ' e r n
rc
e omme ton. U. C. 636( () Thos po tonsoft rpor a rc
ndai 28 S. j b)1. e ri
he e t nd e omme to t whih
ndain o c

o j ci n aema ea ea c r e d n v r ve it o eo j ci n S ipon tes cfcfn ig
be to s r d r c o d d e o o e iw,f h s be to sl n ith pe ii i dn s
p
t tt pat diagee wih. Unie St e v Sc t,5 F. 1 1 60 ( 1h Ci.2009) s e
ha he ry s r s t ' td ats . hulz 65 3d 353, 3 1 t r
'
;e
aloFe R.Ci P.72( () Anypori oft rpor a r omme tont whihnos ii
s d.
v.
b)3 .
t
ons he e t nd ec
ndai o c
pecfc

o j ci n a ema e aer ve d o l frce re or fie t Am.I s Gr ,l c v We t it
be to s r d r e iwe ny o la n . b ry
n . p. n . . spon
Unde wrtr,L. . ,1 F.Supp. 1 ,1 ( . Fl 2001.ac or Mac tv Pr m,I .
r ie s L C. 99
2d 271 276 M D. a. ) c d or . e nc,
,

208F. x781,78 ( 1hCi.2006)
App'
4 1t r
.
Havi r vi w e t R e tf c ea e r ,t Cour a e s w ih J
ng e e d he por or l r r or he
t gr e t udge Ot zo- e s s
a R ye '

wel-ea one a l i a c l i t tt Re ts d begr nt d.
lr s d nayss nd onc uson ha he ques houl
a e
Ac r ngl i i O R DER ED A N D A DJUD G ED a f l s
co di y, t s
s olow :

M a sr t J AlcaM . a o- ye ' Re t ndRe
gitae udge ii Otz Re ss por a
commendai ( No.
ton,ECF
271 i AFFI ED AND ADOPTED a i
,s
RM
nd ncoportd i o t s Or r by
ae nt hi de
r f r e.
e e enc
2.

M o ntStnly Pr e e sRe s f Ce tfcaeofAppe a lt ( No.
va a e esndiu' quet or rii t
albiiy, ECF
261 i GRANTED.A Ce tfc t ofAppe a lt s lis a t t f l ng
,s
riiae
albiiy hal s ue s o he olowi
que ton:whehert mova esa ihe aba i f 28U. C.j2255r i o hi
si
t he
nt tbls d ss or
S.
elef n s
cai st ts nt i c
l m ha e encng ouns pr de i feci as it nc a t ta wai r
el ovi d ne f tve s sa e nd ha
ve
pr son i hi pl aa ee e vi aedhi duepr es rghtt t pr s nt ton of
ovii n s e gr m nt ol t s
oc s i o he e e ai
m a e i ly a cur t i or a i a s nt nci
t r a l c a e nf m ton t e e ng.

D O N E A N D O R DER ED i Cham ber atM i i Fl i t i 5t d
n
s
am , orda, s h

O

r

D A RRI P. YLE
N
UN I
TED STA TES D 1
S

2

J D GE
U

er 2021.
,