Christman v. City of Ft. Pierce et al
Filing
24
ORDER GRANTING IN PART 4 Defendant's Motion to Dismiss and DENYING 5 Plaintiff's Motion to Remand. Signed by Judge K. Michael Moore on 12/20/2011. (rg1)
I TH E UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE SOUTH ERN DI
STRI O F FLO RI
CT
DA
Cas No.11 c 1
e
- v- 4322- M M
K.
SI
EGFRI CHRI
ED
STM AN,
Pli it
antfl
VS.
CI OF FT. RCE,
TY
PW
RALPH HOLM ES,a
nd
J ES TED D ER,
AM
D e e nt .
f nda s
/
O R D ER G R AN TI G I PAR T D EFEN DA N TS'M O TI N TO
N N
O
D I I A N D DENY I G PLM NT FF' M O T I N T O RE M A ND
SM SS
N
S
O
THI CAUSE c m ebe or t Cour upon Def nda sCiy ofFt Pir ,RaphHol e ,
S
a
f e he
t
e nt t
. e ce l
m s
a dJ me Te d rsMot nt Dimis( No. )a dPlitf M oint Re n ( No.
n a s d e ' i o s s ECF 4 n an ifs t o ma d ECF
o
o
5 .The emoto ha be n f l brefda aeno rpef rviw.
)
s ins ve e uly i e nd r w i or e e
UPON CONSD ERATI oft M oto ,hepe tne pori nsoft r or a beng
ON
he
i ns t
ri nt to
he ec d, nd i
o he wief l a s d i t pr mies t Cour e e st f l ng Or r
t r s uly dvi e n he e s ,he
t nt r he olowi
de .
1
.
BA C K G R O U ND I
Thi c ese s9om Pli ifSe gfi d Chrsm a sa r ti Fe u r 2009,f blr a y
s as tm
antf i re
it n' res n br a y
or zglr
a t tofta s rt.Compl!9.Chrsma wmse oye msa i pe ntco rcorby
nd hef rde eces
.
it n
mpl d n nde nde nta t
W iln a dJ h s n,n . ç &J'.J= Up na e n wi h sma a e, f n oJ l o ,
l m n o n o I c (ç ' # o pe me t t i n g r Alo s oms n
i
W )
h
Chr sm a ke cle fl s a hi r i nc bec us ofa l c ofs ce a t ki k whe e he
i t n pt i nt ie t s esde e, a e
ak
pa t he os
r
woke P1Rep. . udii Not,Ex. De Ans I er.( No. ) Ahe t mutal
r d. . s DefJ cal . A f .nt r ECF 21 . r he u
1The f c a bac o
a m l kp und i t ke f o D e e nt M oton t Di m i s Pl i i fs
s a n rm
f nda s' i o s s , a ntf
M oint Re n , anifsCo an ( No 12 , fn a t' q e tfrJ d ca
t o ma d Plitf
o
mpli t ECF . - ) Dee d n s Re u s o u iil
Noi ( No.1 ,a Pli ifsRes et Dee nt'J calNotc ( No.21 .
tce ECF
5) nd antf
pons o fnda s udii
ie ECF
)
The f c sa e vi w e i t lg m os f vor bl t t Pl i ifast non- ova .
a t r e d n he i ht
t a a e o he a ntf
he
m nt
tr i i ofhi i pe ntconta ora e m e ,Ch it a a lge y f ie t r tln c int
e m naton
s nde nde
r ct p e nt rsm n le dl al d o elr le
flst W &J.V J hns caldt For Pir ePolc a rpore t tChrsma had
ie o
o on le he t ec ie nd e td ha it n
te pa s d a bur a i d t W &Jki k,tki t ci ntfls.Se P1 Re p. f J c a
r s s e nd gl rze he
os a ng he le ie
e . s De . udii l
Not, B Of. m e Ar e tAf. Ofi e Hol e c le Chrsma t i r a tt
.Ex.
f Hol s r s f fc r m s a ld
it n o nquie bou he
i i nt I Chrsma t d hi t theha t flsi hi pos e son,butt thewoul not
ncde . d. it n ol m ha
d he ie n s s s i
ha
d
rt nt m.K Chrsma t nhunguponOfie Hol .V Ofie Hol t nwe t
eur he
it n he
fc r mes
fc r mes he nto
Chrsma sr i nc a arse hi a co ic tdt fls J
it n' esde e nd re td m nd nfs ae he ie . .
z
Chrsma fld t Compli i t scas i t Ni e nt J cilCicui i St Luc e
it n ie he
ant n hi e n he nete h udi a r t n . i
Co ny Flrd .Ch it n' camsa an theCiyof r Pir ea ef rFas Are t co n
u t, o ia rsma s li g is t t Fo t ec r o le rs t u t
1, caao yReift u t , n vo ainof sFo rhAme d n rg t t u tV)
) De lr tr l co n H) a d ilto hi u t
e
n me t i hs co n 1 .
Ch it n' cam a an t fc rHome a dOfie Te de t u t 1)i frvo ainof i
rsma s li g is Ofie l s n fc r d r co n 11 s o ilt
o hs
Fourh Ame e rg s Def nt r m ove t ca et t sCour puruantt 28 U. C.
t
ndm nt i ht . enda s e
d he s o hi
t s
o
S.
j 1 41 Dee da t te mo e t d s s teCo anta dPlitf mo dt rma d.
4 . fn ns h n v d o imis h mpli , n an if ve o e n
I.
1
STA ND A RD O F R EW EW
A m o i t dim isf f iu et s aea ca m m e ey t sst s fc e y oft
ton o s s or a lr o tt li
r l e t he ufi i nc
he
c
ompli ;i doe notde det me isoft cas . M ibu n v. t d St t ,734F. 762,765
ant t s
ci he rt he e
l r Unie aes
2d
( 1h Ci.1 8 ) 0namo int ds s,h Co r mu t c e t fcu lalg to sa tu
1t r 94.
to o imis te u t s a c pthe a t a le ai n s r e
a c nsr t co pl nti t lghtm os f vor bl t t pl i if SEC v.
nd o tue he m ai n he i
t a a e o he antf
ESM Gr .I .
o. nc,
8 5F. 27 , 2( 1h Ci.1 8 ) % s r i eamoint d s s, c mplitmu tc nti
3 2d 0 27 1 t r 9 8 . To u vv
to o imis a o an s o an
s fci ntf c u m a t r ac e e ast ue t t t t a cl i f r i t ti pl usbl on is f c ''
uf i e a t al te , c pt d r , o s a e a m or elef ha s a i e
t a e.'
As r v.q l 1 S. .1 1 49( )( i BelAt. Twombl 550U. 544,
hcoh Iba, 29 Ct 937, 9 2009 quotng l lv.
v,
S.
570( :.çrhepl i lt sa r i nota nt ai oba lt rquie nt'butaksf
2007 ç
ausbiiy tndad s ki o pr biiy e rme ,
s or
mor t n as e posi lt t tadefnda ha a t u a ul ' I l t fct dono
e ha he r sbiiy ha
e nt s ced nlwf ly. Z fhe a s
'
t
pe mi t c tt i e m o et n t m e epos i lt ofmico
r t he our o nf r r ha he r
sbiiy
s nduc , heco pl i ha al d,
tt
m ant s lege
buti hasnots
t
hown t pl a ri e ild t r le .1 a 1
he e de s ntte o ei f d. t 950.A c pl i m us alo co an
om ant t s nti
e
noug f t t i c t t pr s nc oft r quie e e nt .W a t v.Fl I ' Uni ,495F.
h acs o ndi a e he e e e he e r d l me s
ts
a. ntl v.
3d
1 8 , 3 2( 1hCi. 0 7 .Ho v r ç a p e dngt a o fr ç f r li r ctto o
2 9 1 0 1 t r 2 0 ) we e ,t ) la i h t fes a o mu ac e iain f
l
ee nt ofac us ofaci wilnotdo.' Iba,1 S. .a 1 49( i Twombl 550
lme s
a e
ton l
'' q l 29 Ct t 9 quotng
y,
U. a 5 5 .ç o o cu o yalg to , n ra tdd du to o f c o lg lc n l so
S. t 5 ) ç n ls r le ains u warn e e cins f a t r e a o cu ins
l
mm que a ng a fct wilno pr ve dimis l' Oxf r As e M emt.Lt v.J ha i,297
s r di s a s l t e nt s s a .' o d s t
. d. a rs
F.d 1 8 ,1 8 ( 1hCi. 0 2 .
3 12 18 1t r2 0 )
h pr s pli ifspl di a er d lbe a l a t Cou thol t pl i ift a ls
o e antf
ea ngs r ea i r ly nd he
r ds he antf o e s
srn e tsa adta pla i sb at me s S eEsel v. mb e 4 9U. 9 ( 9 6 .
tig n tnd r h n e dng y to y . e tle Ga l, 2 S. 7 1 7 )
Alhough t Cour mus afor apr s ltga wi le y i pladi ,apr seltga sil
t
he
t t f d
o e ii nt de e wa n e ngs
o ii nt tl
mus ale s fc e f c si ac
t lge ufii nt a t n ompli t s
ant o uppor a c za e lgalc am . Exce sRik
t ogni bl e
li
s s
Un ewrtr.n . . a et I . , 8F. p 2 1 0 1 3( D. a 2 0 )
d r ies Ic v Le v te ns Co.20 Su p. d 31 , 31 S. Fl . 0 2 .
11
1.
AN AIY SI
- S
1 Defnda Ofi rHol
e nt fce mes
Chrsm a pr vi usy ltgae t sma tra i tOfi rHol e i Chrs a v.
it n e o l ii td hi te gans fce
m s n i% n
Home . ta.CaeNo. 0c 1 25DLG.J g Grh m ds se t t a ewi p eu ie
l s e 1, s
1 -v-42 ud e a a imisd ha c s t rj dc
h
f fitr t sae aca m upon whih r le c d beF a ed.TheElve h Cic ta fr d t s
or a lle o t t li
c ei f oul
nt
e nt r ui fime hi
d s sa i Ch it nv. l s e a.2 1U. Ap .
imis ln rsma Home . t l 01 S. p LEXI 1 0 4 ( 1hCi. 01 )
,
S 8 7 1 t r 2 1.
Th d crneo rs u iat, rcam p e l in, r as bs q n a to i: 1 t ep ir
e o ti f e j dc a o li r cuso bas u e ue t cin f () h ro
de iinwm r n ee b ac u t fc mpee t u id cin; 2 t r wa afna j d me to t e
cso s e d rd y o r o o tn j rs ito ( ) hee s i l u g n n h
meis ()t pa te wer i ntca i bot s t;a ( t prora pr s ntca e ofa to
rt; 3 he ris e de i l n h uis nd 4) he i nd e e us s cin
aet sme Da l v. laAi Li .I ,326F. 11 11 ( t Ci.2003)( ttons
r he a . via Det r nes nc.
3d 83, 87 11h r
ciai
omitd) Thi ba pe t nsno onl t cli t tweerie i t prora to butalot
te . s r rai t y o ams ha r as d n he i cin,
s o
camsta c udh v b e r ie p e i u l.V ( ingTr smak I . v. LU. n .2 9
li h t o l a e e n as d rv o sy
ct
i u t r ns Co. ES I c, 9
F.d 1 6 ,1 71( 1h Ci. 0 2 I dee miigwh t rt pro a dp e e tc u e o a to
3 2 5 2 1 t r 2 0 :. n tr nn ehe he ir n r s n a s s f cin
a et s me, us de i whehe t aci nsa ieE oft s m enuclusofope a i f c ,
r he n m t c de
t r he to rs ç
out he a
e
r tve a t or
(rqbm e u n tes mefcu l r dc t . Da ia 3 F.da 1 8 ( u tn I r Pie
a e s d po h n a t a p e iae' v l, 26 3 t 1 7 q o iz n e p r
'
Aica Co .2 4F.d 1 9, 2 ( 1h Ci. 0 :.
rr h m , 4 3 28 1 97 1 t r 2 01
I Chrsma v. m e .e a .J
n it n Hol s t 1, udgeGr ha ' dim is lofChrsm a sCo pl i wa
a m s s sa
it n' m ant s
wi p eu iefrfi let saeacam u o wlc r le c udbeva td I wa te eo ea
t rj dc o alr o tt li p n t h eif o l
h
t
i
n e . t s h r fr
j d e t p ntemeis Ch it n' Co an i t ei sa tc s i ba e u o tesme
u r n u o h rt. rsma s mplit n h n tn m e s s d p n h a
a r s i i ntt twa t ba i f li Com pli i Chrsm a v.Hol e .e al Bot oft s
re t nc de ha s he ss or ls
a nt n
it n
m s t . h he e
Com pli st r or a os fo t s m enuclusofope a i f c s Chrsm a ha t
ant he ef e r e r m he a
e
r tve a t . it n d he
opporu t t ale t pr e c am agans Ofi rHol i Chrsm a v. m e .e a1,
tniy o lge he es nt l i
i t fce
mes n it n Hol s t .but
di no .Ac or ngl Chrs a sCompl i a i tOfk e Hol e i t i tntc ei
d t c di y, i% n'
ant gans t r m s n he ns a as s
bardbyt docrneofr s c a.Chrsma sCompli a i tOfie Hol si
re
he ti
e judiat
it n'
ant gans fc r me s
t eeo ed s se wihprj ie
h rf r imis d t eudc .
K Re i ngFe a La Cli
mani derl w ams
TheCour e mi st r m ani f de al1w cli si Chrsm a sCompli be us
t xa ne he e i ng e r a am n it n'
a nt ca e
t er s lto o to ecamsd tr n swheh rt i Co r ha c ni u dj rs ito o e t s
h e ou in f h s li eemie
te h s u t s o tn e u idcin v r hi
m a tr TheCo tde lne t e l t t sa e1w cli i Chrs a sCompli a t s
te .
ur c i s o vauae he t t a a ms n
i% n'
ant t hi
tm e.
i
1.CountIIAgans De e ntOfk e Te r
I
i t f nda
t r dde
I Cot 11Chrsm a al ge t tOfi e Te rvi a e hi Fourh Am e
n mt I
it n le s ha fc r dde olt d s
t
ndme rght
nt i
t betsctr i hi homefo unr s bl s r ha s i e.... Co . 24.Chrsma
o çe le n s
rm eaona e eac nd ezur
' mpl!
'
it n
4
ca mst tOfi rTe rvi ae t srghtwhe he a r se hi i hi home,a s e
li ha fce dde olt d hi i
n
re td m n s
nd e ks
rme yp ru n t 4 U. C.j1 8 J. Th o yo h ralg to i teCo litta
e d u s a to 2 S.
9 3. . . e nl t e le ain n h mp an h t
4
Chrsm a ati est Ofk e Tedde i t thelnr s na y c us d Chrsm a spr ec i
it n trbut o t r
r s ha
l em o bl a e
it n' os uton
wihoutpr bl ca e J. ! 1
t
oba e us . . 3.
I
L
I o de t saeacli unde j1 3, pli ifmus alget tadee nta i
n r r o tt am
r 98 a antf t le ha fnda , ctng
unde col ofsae lw,de i dhi ofarghtpr e t d unde t Consiuton orf de allw.
r or t t a
prve m
i
ot c e
r he
tt i
e r a
Litev.CivofN. imi 805F. 962,965 ( t Ci.198 .Howe r qualfe i miy
tl
t
M n ,
2d
11h r 6)
ve, iid mmt t
of e sco pl t pr ec i n f gove m e of i i s i t i c
f r m e e ot to or
m nt fc al f he r onduct6doe notvi a e c e ry
< s
ol t l a l
e t bls d sa u o y orc tt i na rg sofwhi h ar a o bl pe s n w o d ha k wn.
sa ihe t t t r
onsiuto l i ht
c e s na e r o
ul ve no '
'
Vi adv. i o , 1F.d 1 40 1 46( 1 Ci. 0 2 ( u tn Halw v. tg r l, 5
ny r W l n 31 3 3 , 3 1 1 r 2 0 ) q o ig ro Fi e ad 4 7
s
z
U. 8 0 81 ( 9 2 .
S. 0 , 8 1 8 )
I t i t ntc s ,Chrsm a m a sc us r alegai nst tOfi e Tedde vi aed
n he nsa a e
it n ke oncl o y l to ha fc r
r olt
hi Fo t Am e
s urh
ndme rght a t thea t d unr as bl a wihoutpr bl ca e. The
nt i s nd ha
ce
e ona y nd t
oba e us
Compli f l t alegea f c sr ga di Ofie Te rsa ualc
ant ais o l
ny a t e r ng fc r dde ' ct onduct M or ove ,t
.
e r he
f ct pr s ntd i t Pa te motonsi caet tt polc ofie sha pr ba e c us and
a s e e e n he ri s' i ndi t ha he ie fc r d o bl a e
a t d ptr ua t a c i i lc pl i fl d by J hns t m a ge ofW & J Se P1 Res
c e l s nt o rm na om a nt ie
o on, he na r
. e . p.
De J c a Not,Ex. De Ans I e r W he Ofi rHol e tl phone Chlsma t
E udii l . A f
. nt r.
n fce
m s ee
d it n o
i si t t r pore c i e Chrsma hungup o hi .Se P1 Re p. f J cilNot,
nve tga e he e td rm , it n
n m
e . s De udi a
.Ex.
B Of Hol sAres Af Ofie Hol t n we t Chrsman' homea arse hi V
f me r t f fc r mes he nto it s
nd re td m.
l i u e rwha r eOfierTe rplye i t spr es ,a equal uncl rhow Ofi r
t s ncla
t ol fc
dde a d n hi oc s nd
ly
ea
lce
Te rvi a e a ofChr s m an' c tt i lr ght A ss h,Chr s m an' Co pl nt
dde ol t d ny
it
s onsiutona i s.
uc
it
s m ai
a l ge i ufi i ntf c s t s a e a cl i a i tOf i e Te rand Count1 1aga ns Of i r
le s ns l c e a t o t t
a m ga ns f c r dde
I
i t fce
Te d ri t eeo ed s s e wih u p eu ie
d e s h rf r imis d t o t rj dc .
5
Thi i t fr ttme t tCh it a ha br htt sCo pl i a i tOfi e Te r
s s he is i ha rsm n s oug hi m ant gans fc r dde ,
a t Cour r cogniest tChrsma fld t sCompl i i sat c r butt De e nt
nd he
te
z ha
it n ie hi
ant n t e ou q
he f nda s
r move t c s t t sCour.Ac r ngl t Co tgi Chrsm a la t a e hi
e
d he a e o hi
t co di y, he ur ves it n e ve o m nd s
Co pli t pr ry al gea f de a cli s I Chrsm a doesnota e hi Compli t
m a nt o ope l le ny e r l am . f it n
m nd s
ant o
al ges fce f de alc am s onl sat 1 w ca mswilr mai a t Cas wilber m a d
le ufi int e r l i , y t e a li
l e n, nd he e l
e nde
t t Ni te h J c a Dititi St Luc eCot y.
o he nee nt udii l src n . i
mt
2.Co I Agans TheCiyofFor Pir e
unt V
i t
t
t ec
Toa s r acam a ans act u d rj1 3 aplitf mu t r v t a ac nsiu in l
s et li g i t iy n e 98 , anif s p o e h t o ttto a
de i ton r ule fom ac t , iy,orpr c i oft ct
prvai es t d r
usom polc
a tce he iy.M onel v. . C.De tof
l N Y.
p'
So . r s, 6U. 6 8 6 4( 9 8 .S c l bi t, o v r ma n tb p e iae o a
c Se v .43 S. 5 , 9 1 7 ) u h i l y h we e, y o e r dc td n
a i
t or ofr s ndeats pe i L.
he y epo
u ror. d
x
I CountI ofhi Compli ,Chrsm a brngsac eofa ton agans t CiyofFor
n
V
s
ant
it n i
aus
ci
i t he t
t
Pir i whih healeg t tpolceofi r vi a e hi Fou t Ame m e rghtwhe t y
e ce n c
l es ha i fce s olt d s rh
nd nt i
n he
are t d li i hi ho e.Theonl me i ofa c t o polcybei t c us oft sa r ti
r se lm n s m
y nton
usom r i
ng he a e hi res s
i pa a a s ve whe e n Ch it a a lge Ofi e sHol e a Te rwe eaci
n r gr ph e n
r i rsm n le s fc r
m s nd dde r tng
a c di t t c t sa polci s oft Ciy ofFor Pi r
c or ng o he us om nd i e
he t
t e ce.
The ec n l o ysae n saei u fce tt saeaj18 cam a an tteCi o
s o cus r ttme t r ns fiin o tt
9 3 li g is h t f
y
Fo t ec , n Co n I o Plitf sCo an i te eo ed s se wih u prj d c .
r Pir e a d u t V f an if mplit s h r fr imis d to t eu ie
Chrsma i a i gi n la t a e hi Compli i o de t pl a s fcintf de al
it n s gan ve e ve o m nd s
ant n r r o e d ufi e e r
c ams o t sma trwilber ma d.
l i , r hi te l
e nde
I .
V
CO N C LU SIO N
Fort f r goi r as ,i i he e
he o e ng e ons t s r by
ORDERED AND ADJ
UDGED t tDee nt'M otont Dimis( No. i
ha fnda s
i o s s ECF 4) s
6
GRANTED m PART.Pl i ifsCo pl i agans De e ntPolc Ofi rRal Hol i
antf
m ant i t f nda
i e fce
ph mes s
1 nd V
antf
a nt e SM SSED
DI I
SM SSED W I PREJ DI
TH
U CE. Count11a I ofPli ifsCompli ar DI I
WI
THOUT PREJ CE. I i f rhe
UDI
ts ut r
ORDERED Ar ADJ
UDGED t tPl ntf M oton t Re a i DENI .I i
ha ai iFs i o m nd s
ED t s
f rhe
ut r
ORDERED A. D ADJ
N
UDGED t tPl i ifi gi n lavet Am e hi Compli i
ha antf s ve e
o
nd s
ant n
a c r a c wi t sOr e a dmu t os wi i fu te ( 4 da so t eis a c o ti
c o d n e t hi d r n s d o t n o re n 1 ) y f h su n e f h s
h
h
Or r orhi f de alc am swilbed s is d a hi r m ani sa e1w cai swilbe
de , s e r l i
l
im s e nd s e i ng tt a l m
l
r ma dt t 1 t J c a Diti ti St Luc eCount
e nde o he 9 h udii l src n . i
y.
ooxsAxo ORDE i c a esaMimiFlrda ti rta o oee e,0 1
RED n hmbr t a , o i ,h / y f cmbr2 1.
-
K. I
M CHAEL M OORE
UM TED STATES DI
STRJ J
CT UDGE
cc:
A l col s ofr c d
l m el e or
7
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?