Matthews v. Applied Concepts Unleashed, Inc. et al

Filing 65

ORDER GRANTING 62 Plaintiff's Motion to Strike. Signed by Judge K. Michael Moore on 8/1/2012. (rg1)

I TH E UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI CO URT
CT
FOR THE SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
Ca eN o.2: - v- 4347- M M
s
11 c 1
K
STEPH EN M TTH EW S,

Pli if
antf,

APPLI CONCEPTS UN LEASHED,I C.a
ED
N
nd
STEPHEN FREN CH ,
Defnda s
e nt .

ORDER GM NTI PLAI
NG
NTW F' M O TI TO STRI
S
ON
KE
THI CAUSE c m e be or t Cour upon Pli if St phen M a t
S
a
f e he
t
antf e
thew' M o i t Sti
s ton o rke

( No 6 ) Dee d n fldaRe p n e( No 6 )a dPlitf fld aRe l ( No 6 )
ECF . 2 . fn a t ie
s o s ECF . 3 n an if ie
py ECF . 4 .
The M o i i no rpe f r vi w . UPON CON SI
ton s w i or e e
DEM TI of t M o i n,t pe tne
ON
he to he ri nt
pori of t r c d,and beng o he wie f ly ad s d i t pr mi e ,t s Co te e s t
tons
he e or
i t r s u l vie n he e s s hi ur nt r he
f l ng Or r
olowi
de .
1.

BAC K G R O U ND l

Pli if wa a e pl e of De e nt Apple Conce s Unl as d, I , fo
antf
s n m oye
f nda ,
id
pt
e he nc. r m
a oxi a el 1998 t 201 .2 Pli tf a lges t t De e nt f l t compe a e hi f
ppr m t y
o
0
a n if le
ha
f nda s aied o
ns t m or

e oyme i e es offry ho spe we k i vi ai oft FarLa StndadsAc (
mpl nt n xc s o t m r e n olton he i bor n r
t 29
U. C.j201e sq. (t
S.
t e ) GFLSA'orGheAc'. OnJ nuay31 201 Defndan fld isAns ra
' t
t
t'
)
a r , 2, e t ie t we nd
Afimai Dee e t Pli ifsAme dCompli ( No.24) Pli ifnow sekst have
fr tve fns s o antf
nde
ant ECF
. antf
e o
t sCour srke De e ntsThid a Se nt Afima i Def e .
hi
t ti
f nda '
r nd ve h fr tve ens s

1Thef t heen aet nfom Pli ifsAmende Compli ( No.22)
acs ri r ake r
antf
d
ant ECF
.

2 I i l c ea f om t Com pl i w ha cor e ton Def nda St phe Fr nch has t D e e nt
tsm l r r
he
a nt
t m ci
e nt e n e
o f nda
Apple Conc pt U nl s d,I
id
e s ea he nc.
1

I.
I

STA N DA RD O F REV I
EW

P rl n t Fe e a Ru eo Ci i P o e u e 1 ( ac u tt y srk fo apla ig a
u sl t o d r l l f vl r c d r 2 9, o r ç ti e r m
a
ma
e dn n
i ufi e de e e orany r dundan ,i t ra ,i ri nt ors nda ousm a tr' Fe R.Ci
ns tcint f ns
e
t mma e il mpe tne , ca l
te .' d.
v.

P.1 9.ç fr t d fn e a eas s b e tt t g n r l e dn sa d r o Fe . Ci P.
24 t imai e e s s r lo u j c o he e ea pla ig tn a d f d R. v.
Af
ve
8a ,wh c rq ie a dh r a d p an sae n 'o te a s re d fn e' Ro r v S.W at
() ih e u rs s o t n li ttme t f h se td e e s . meo .
'
se

S . LLC, 61 F.Su p.2 1 5 , 1 5 ( D.Fl. 2 0 ) Thu ,ç e pt l e a pe dn
ys.
9
p d 3 6 3 8 S. a 0 9 .
s ç s ie i rl la ig
d
b
rq ie ns wh r a afr tv d fns i nomo et a t aeb n sc n l s r alg to ,(t
e urme t, ee n fimaie ee e s
r h n b r o e o cu oy le ains i
)
mus besrc e ' I ( u tn M o s n v Ex c Aic at fn s i . n .43 F. u p. d 1 1
t tik n.' d.q o ig nio . e . rr f Rei ihnc I c, 4 S p 2 3 4,
'
1 8( D. a 2 0 ).
31 S. Fl. 0 5 )
11
1.

A NA LY SI
S

Pli ifmotonst s Cour t srke De e ntsThid a Se nt Afima i De ens s
antf
i hi
t o ti
f nda '
r nd ve h fr tve f e .
De e nts Thid Afima i De e e alege t t t f nda s a e e ild t a s tof f
f nda '
r
fr tve f ns l s ha t e nt r ntte o
De
e - f or
dn a s f r d bec us pli if St phe M a t ws sol tade s cr t a ml e ous y ht
m ges ufe e
a e antf e n
the
t e r
e e s nd m r
ac
desg bel ng t de e ntApple Conc pt ,a f rhe t t pl i if St phe M a t ws
i ns ongi o f nda
id
e s nd u t r ha antf e n the '

b e c hi e o me ta re n c u i g d ma e t d fn a t. An we ,a 3 ( No 2 )
ra h s mply n g e me t a sn a g o ee d n s' s r t ECF . 4 .
'
De e nts Seve h Afima i Def ns a l es t ttpl i ifs c am s a e ba r d or lm ie by
f nda '
nt fr tve
e e leg ha ç antf l i r r e
i td
pl i ifs ba f ih,a ot r eq tbl def es bec us pl i if St phen M a t w s de toye
antf
d at nd he uia e ens , a e antf e
the
sr d
def nt' busnes r or r ar ng hi e pl e hit y pror t tnni tng hi
enda s
i s ec ds eg di
s m oym nt sor
i o e na i
s
em pl en ,a s ol tade s c e s a num er ya ht des g be ongi t def nda A ppled
oym t nd t e r
e r t nd
ous c
i ns l ng o e nt
i
Co p s c us ng s gnii a da age ' I a 4.
nce t , a i i f c nt m .' d. t

l Br r n v.He r 4 F.d 1 (t Ci.1 7 ) rv' o o h rg o n s M c u hi v
n ema
ad, 91 2
5h r 9 4 , e d n t e r u d , La a l .
n
Riha d S o Co.48 U. 1 ( 9 8 ,te f r rU. Co r o Ap e l frte F fh Cic i
c ln h e , 6 S. 28 1 8 ) h o me S. u t f p as o h it rut
3
a r s d t dititco ts de ii t al w s tofs a i tt n oun ofbac pa o d t a
dd es e he src ur' c son o lo e- f gans he m t
k y we o n
empl e. Hol ng t tt dititcour e r by al ng t empl ye t ca m s tof s t
oye
di ha he src
t red
lowi he
o r o li e - f , he
f me Fit Cic tr a one t tt f de a co t
or r fh r ui e s d ha he e r l urs

we e no de i t d by t FLSA t be et rc lc i age s ora bir t sf a
r t sgna e
he
o
ihe ole ton nt
r ta or or n
e oy ' c edior .Thers e f ton a dut unde t Ac i t as ur t t
mpl ees r t s
i ol unci nd y
r he t s o s e o he
e oy s of a c r compa a mi mum lvel of wa . Ar ume s a
mpl ee
ove ed
ny
ni
e
ges g nt nd
dipu a i ove c am s ag ns t e wa s a e f e gn t t ge i ,hit r
s t tons r l i
ai t hos
ge r or i o he ness so y,
i e r t ton,a phios
ntm e a i nd l ophy oft Ac .The onl ec
he t
y onom i f ud con emplt d by
ce
t
ae
t FLSA i ves t e pl rs obe e e t mi mum wa a o ri e
he
nvol
he m oye '
di nc o ni
ge nd ve tm
sa r . To cl tr t s pr e ngs wih t m i ie of ot r e oye t nda ds
ute he e oce di
t he nuta
he mpl r
e o r l tons pswoul be a ihe ialt t pur eoft Ac .
mpl yee e ai hi
d
ntt tc o he pos
he t

J a 4.TheFit Cic tt hel t ,tse- f a i tba kpa a r de i t e oye of
. t
Z
fh rui hus d hat ç tofs gans c y wads prve he mpl e
t G s i hand' c e aed by t Ac ,a a e t r or i ppr it i a pr e di
he cm h n
ont mpl t
he t nd r he ef e na opra e n ny oc e ng
br ug t enf c t FLSA m i m lm wa a ove tm epr sons whehert s ti i ta e
o ht o or e he
ni l
ge nd ri
ovii , t he ui s niit d

b i viua e oyee orbyt Se rtr ofLabor' J Theonl e eptont t sge r r l
y ndi d l mpl s
he ceay
. #.
'
y xc i o hi neal ue
i whe t he s tof wilnotc us a pl n ifswa st di bel t sa u or mi mlm' s h a
s
n t e- f l
t
a e aitf
ge o p ow he t t t y ni l ' uc s
whe a de e
n
f ndan cli st to m a
t am ha ve ymen sofwa t e oye i s
t
ges o mpl es n ome wor pe i s d be
k- rods houl
s tof a ns s tal i ot rwor pe i . Se Nelon v.CK Ne s I ,No.07- 41 CI
e - f gai t horf ls n he
k rods e s
lon. nc.
61 6- V,

2 08W L 2 2 8 2 a * ( D. a J n 2 2 0 )(ii Snc rv. t o W a o 3 4F.d81 , 2
0
3 3 9 , t 3 S. Fl. u e , 0 9 ctng i e Civ f c , 2 3 3 8 8
n9(t Ci. 0 3
. 5h r 2 0 :.
He e De e
r , f ndantsThid a Se t Afim ai De e esdo no al an ove pa e of
' r nd ven h fr tve f ns
t lege
r ym nt
wa s t Pli if buti t a r ques s tofs due t Pli ifs a l ed t ta desr c i of
ge o antf,
nse d e t e - f
o a ntf leg hef nd tu ton
busnes r c ds Ther ue td s tofswo d f c t Cour t add e st f c ua cr lmsmnc
i s e or .
eq se e - f ul or e he
t o r s he a t l ic l t es
ofml r uso he cam sl ea e t whe he Pli tf wasa
me o t r li mm lt d o
t r a n if
dequa ey co pe a e a or ng t
t l m ns t d cc di o
3 l Bol erv. Ci o Prc ad 6 F.d 1 0 1 0 ( 1h Ci.1 1 ( nb n )teU. Co r o
n m
t f ih r , 61 2 2 6 2 9 1 t r 98 ) e a c h S. u t f
v
Appe l f t El ve h Cic tado e a bi ng pr e nta 1oft dec sons oft f r
a s or he e nt r ui
pt d s ndi
ec de 1
he ii
he o mer
Fit Cic tpro t t cl eofbusne so Se e be 30,1 1.
fh r ui i r o he os
i s n pt m r
98
3

m i m um wag a ove tme sa r a wo d t ute t e pr e ngs wih t mi ie of
ni
e nd ri t nda ds nd ul ç tr hes oc edi
cl
t he nuta
ot empl re pl
her
oye -m oyeer l to hi . Br ma 491F. a 4.
e ai ns ps' er n,
'
2d t

M or ve ,a s tof a id t a r ove y by Pl i ifwoul r s ti Pl n if f ii t
eo r ny e - f pple o ec r
antf
d e ul n aitf alng o

r c ve hi t s i ha ' I Pl i if al s he i owt $1 445. i unpa d ove tm e pl
e ei s t h n nd. d. antf lege
ca
'
s d 5, 31 n
i
ri
us

$2, 27 f at wee tm e pe i i whih he cai shew a notpai a a l PlsSt t ntof
305. or wo k i
rod n c
lm
s
d t l. ' aeme

Cli ( No 7 .Dee a tha ar a yGld alws i a an t an ifi Flrd saec u t o
am ECF . ) fnd n s le d e a ut g is Plitf n o i a tt o r f r
mia opra i ofta s c es br a h ofa c i talr ltons p,c t u tve fa sande ,
s ppr iton r de e r t, e c
ontden i ea i hi onsr c i r ud, l r

a dlb l S eAp le Co c psUne s e Ic v. ate , 1 - 4- ( a Ci. . 01 )
n i e. e pid n e t lm h d.n . M th ws No. 167 CA Fl. r Ct 2 2 .
De e n ha as fld a l ws t agans Pl i if i t s Cour f co i i rnge nt
f nda t s lo ie
a ui
i t antf n hi
t or pyrght nfi me ,
co putrfa a a e,br a h ofempl e ag ee ta ci lt f. Se Ax i d Conce t
m e r ud nd bus e c
om nt r men nd vi he t e mle
ps

Une e .Ic. M at ws No.1 - 1 0 5 DLG ( D. a 2 2 . I e c oft e elws t
luh d n v. t
he ,
2 CV- 4 3 S. Fl. 01 ) n a h h s a ui
s
De e
f ndan s e damag i exc s oft amountofdâ a s Pl ntf alege he i owe i t
t e ks
es n e s he
m ge ai if l s
s
d n he

i t ta ton. The ef e, r Def nda t pr vai on isThid and Seve h Afima i Def ns ,
nsnn c i
r or we e e nt o e l t
r
nt fr tve e es

Plitf j d me tmih b r d e b lw t mi i l wa elv l Ac o dngy Dee d n '
ani u g n g t e e uc d eo he nmz
fs
m g e e. c r i l , fn a ts
Thid a Se nt Afim ai De e e a ei ppr i t i t sa ton.
r nd ve h fr tve f ns s r na oprae n hi ci
I
V.

CONCLUSI
ON
Fort f r goi r as ,i i
he o e ng e ons t s

ORDERED AND ADJ
UDGED t a Plitf Mo in t Srk (
h t an ips to o ti e ECF No. 6 ) i
2 s
GRANTED . Def nda ' n id a Se nt Afima i Def ns s a e her by STRUCK fom t
e nts r nd ve h fr tve
e e r
e
r he
Re r
co d.

DO ANDORDE i ChmbraMimiFoiati
NE
RED n a est a , lr ,hv
d

dyo Auut2 2
a f gs,01.

K.M I
CHAEL M OORE
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI J
CT UDGE
c
c:

A1 c
1 ouns lofr co d
e
e r
4