Peer v. Home Depot U.S.A. Inc.
Filing
66
ORDER granting in part and denying in part 30 Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment. Signed by Judge K. Michael Moore on 4/26/2012. (rg1)
I TH E UN I
N
TED STA TES DI
STRI T C O UR T
C
FO R TH E SO U TH ER N D I
STR I O F FL O R I A
CT
D
CA SE N O .2: c 14356- M
11- vKM
PATRI PEER,
CK
Pli it
antfl
VS.
HOM E DEPOT U . A.m C.a f r i
S. ,
, o egn
c por ton,
or a i
D e e nt
f nda .
/
O R DER G M N TI G I PA RT A N D D EN YI G I PA RT D EFEN D A NT ' M O TI N
N N
N N
S
O
FO R SU M M M W JU D G EM E NT
THI CAU SE c m e be or t Cour upon De e nt Hom e Depot U. A. I '
S
a
f e he
t
f nda
S. , nc.s
(il meDe f)Mo in frS mma yJ dr e t( No. 0 .Pli tf fld aRe p n e(
tlo
po ' to o u r u
n ECF
3 ) anif ie
s o s ECF
No. 7 a d Dee d n fld aRe y ( No. 7 .Th M oin i n w rp f rrv e Up n
3 ) n fn a t ie
pl ECF
4 ) e t s o ie o e iw. o
o
co i r ton oft M oton,t pe tne pori of t Re r , a beng o he wie f l
nsde ai
he
i he ri nt tons
he co d nd i t r s uly
a s d i t pr m ie ,t sCour e e st f l ng Or r
dvie n he e s s hi
t ntr he olowi
de .
I BA CK G R O U N D I
Pl i ifParc Pee br hta neglg e a i n i t Cic tCour oft Ni t e h
antf tik
r oug
i enc cto n he r ui
t he ne e nt
J c a Cic t St Luc e Co y,Fl i ba ed upon a i i ntwhih occ r d o Augus 1 ,
udii l r ui, . i unt orda s
n ncde
c
ure n
t 4
201 On Oc o r 1 2011 D e e ntfl d a N otce ofRe ovalpur ua t 28 U .S. j 1 41
0.
t be 2,
, f nda ie
i
m
s nt o
C. 4 ,
e s q a 28 U. C.j 1
t e nd
S.
332. Pli ifParc Pee i ar i ntofFl i Dee ntHo
antf tik r s esde
orda. fnda
me
D e i a D e a a e cor a i n w ih isprnc pa pl c ofbus ne s i G e gi . J idi to i
pot s
lw r
por to
t t i i l ae
i s n or a urs ci n n
1Thefcshe en aetke fom Pli ifsCompli ( No 1 1 ;Defnda ' M oton f
at ri r a n r
antf
ant ECF
- ) e nts i or
.
Slmm a y J
l r udgme ;Pl i ifs Res e t De e nts M oton f Summ a y J
nt antf
pons o f nda '
i or
r udgme ;a
nt nd
De e ntsRe y. A1 f cs a e co tue i t lg m os f vor bl t Pl i ifast nonf nda ' pl
l a t r nsr d n he i ht
t a a e o antf
he
m ova .
nt
t scae i f
hi s s ounde o c eedi riy;no fdea quesi i i ve 28U. C.j 1
d n omplt vest
e rl ton s nvol d.
S.
332.
Acc di y,t s Cour m us a y Fl i s t ntve l w. Se Ere R. v.Tompki ,3
or ngl hi
t t ppl orda ubsa i a
e i R.
ns 04
U.. 4( 9 8 .
S 6 13)
On Augus 1 201 Pe rvi ie De e nts sor l td a 700 SW St Luce W es
t 4, 0, e std f nda ' t e ocae t
. i
t
Bo lv r , r S . ce Flrd 3 98 (he<- meDe tSo e).l wa r ii beo ePe rs
u e ad Po t t Lu i, o ia 4 6 t tl
lo
po tr ' t s anng f r e '
a rva a c ntnue whie he wa a t Ho e De tSt e. Pe rwa ac ompa ed by ohe
r i l nd o i d
l
s t he m
po or
e s c
ni
t r
pe e i udi hi br he ,Ni Pe r a hi ne w,Ausi Pe r Pe r viie t Hom e
opl, ncl ng s ot r co e , nd s phe
tn e . e st d he
De o So ei o d rt pc u s p le f rac n tu to o Tofcl ael a igt es p is
p t tr n r e o ik p u p is o o sr ci nj b. a itt o dn h u ple ,
i
Pli ifr ntd a tu fo t Ho e De St e a dr i o a a e r f r e t a t
antf e e
r ck r m he m
pot or nd ove nt n r a e e r d o s he
ç nta t o r ng' whi h i a ç ove e pa ki a ea f l di ' M undtDe ,a 6. Thi
4 r cor veha ' c s e r d r ng r or oa ng.
co
c
'
p. t
s
a ea ha a m e a r w ih s
r
s
t l oof t uppo tpil r , w e r t s de a e ope a e
r la s ho ve , he i s r
n nd xpos d t t na ur l
e o he t a
ee nt.L= a 23.Pe ra hi br he weerdi t t whe t y e ee t c rco
lme s d t
e nd s ot r r i ng ogeher n he ntrd he onta tr
ove ha
r ng. Acc di t Pli if a a e undert c r c orove ha wa bl ke of wih
or ng o a ntf, n r a
he onta t
r ng s oc d f t
c s a yel t pe pr ve i c t e a ce s An uni ntfe Hom e De e oye
one nd low a
e ntng usom r c s .
de ii d
pot mpl e
move t co sa t pe a wave Pe ri o t a eai or rf rt t l d s is Pe r
d he ne nd a nd i d e nt he r n de o hem o oa upple . e
De ,a 56,5 Ni o Pe rDe ,a 20. Pee pa ke t t u k i t pr vi l ba c de a e
p. t
9; c e p. t
r r d he r c n he e ousy ni a d r a
whiePee ' ne w ,i a s pa a eve cl pa ked be nd t r nt ltuc AAe prki Pe r
l
r s phe n e r t hi e, r
hi he e a r k.
r
ng, e
a hi br he e t t r nt ltuc Ass asPe r sf hi t gr
nd s ot r xied he e a r k.
oon
e ' oot t he ound,he si d a f l
lppe nd el
unde neah t tu k. Bot Pe r' br he a ne w s w Pe rf l a a oa he hi . Ho e
r t he r c
h e s ot r nd phe a
e al nd ppr c d m
m
De e oye sa Pee ' br he heped hi of t v ound.Pee ' br he a ne w bot
pot mpl e nd rs ot r l
m f he
rs ot r nd phe
h
notc d a si s t nc on t gr
ie
lmy ubsa e
he ound whe ePee ha f le Ac di t Pli if a Hom e
r
r d al n. cor ng o antf,
D e e pl e a ogi d t Pe r be us t a e w a bl ke of be us i w a v e s .
pot m oye pol ze o e ca e he r a s oc d f ca e t s a y
Pe r D e ,a 59;N i Pee D e ,a 27. A m a
e p. t
co
r p. t
nage ,R a ond M undt w a cont ct t t l t
r ym
, s
a ed o a k o
Pe r a
e boutt a c de . M undtnot d t tPee wa we a d ry fo t f l butt tt r
he c i nt
e ha
r s t nd it r m he al
ha he e
we e no Home De e pl sa ot Pe r M undtDe ,a 3 5 66. Addii ly,M t
r
pot m oyee r md e .
p. t 2, 3,
tona l
mdt
di nots e a c
d
e ny onesi t a ea M undtDe ,a 1 Pee a hi br he s
n he r .
p. t 5. r nd s ot r howe M und whe e
d
t r
Pe r ha f le howe r M undt c am s t a ea wa not si r a onl c r wih
e d a ln,
ve ,
l i he r
s
lppe y nd
y ove ed t
r i tr M undtD e ,a 35. M undtne rs ke t a Hom eD e e oye i o de t
anwae .
p. t
ve po o ny
pot mpl es n r r o
i si t t i i nt M t De ,a 54. Pe rr que t d a i de r por be fl d butdi
nve tga e he ncde . mdt p. t
e e se n nci nt e t ie
d
no r ceve a m e c te t nta t s e
t e i ny dial r a me t he c ne. Afe t ve ce wa l d by Hom e De
tr he hi l s oade
pot
e oyee a Pe ' co pa o ,Pe r dr hi t c hom e r t t n t wor as he ha
mpl s nd ers m ni ns e ove s nz k
aher ha o
k
d
o i na l plnned.
rgi ly n
Si t i de ,Pee ha i ure s bsa i lm e c lexpe e a unde g t
nce he nci nt
r s nc r d u t nta
di a
ns s nd
r one wo
szge i s o hi nec a l w e ba k.
lr r e n s k nd o r c
I .LEG A L STA ND A RD
I
S mmayj dg n ma bee tr do ywh r t r i nog n n is o maeilfc.
u r u me t y n ee nl e e hee s e uie sue f tra a t
Twisv.Kt',2 F.d 1 5 ,1 5 ( 1h Ci.1 9 ) Th mo i pa t h s t bzd n of
s
uv 5 3 5 1 5 4 1 t r 9 4 . e vng ry a he l e
r
me tng t s e ctng sa r Adikes v.S. Kr s & Co. 398 U. 1 1 ( 970)
ei hi xa i tndad.
c
H. e s
,
S. 44, 57 1 .
M o eo r C pa t m us s ppor is a s r i t t t r i no ge ne i s of m a e i lf c by
r ve , W r y
tu
t t s e ton ha he e s
nui s ue
t ra a t
< ii t pa tc a pa t of m ae i l i t r c d, i l ng de ii , docl nt ,
ctng o riul r rs
tra s n he e or ncudi
postons
lme s
eecr cal sor d i or ai n, afi vis or de a ai ns si a i .
l toni ly t e nf m to
fda t
clr to , tpultons
a m isons
d si ,
ie
ntnoga or ans r ,o ot rma e i l.' Riche v.S.Nucl rOp r tna Co. No.1 11 2,
t y we s r he t ras'' t v
ea e ai
,
0- 96
2011W L 1
490358,a *1( 1h Ci.Apr 20,2011 ( i Fe R.Ci P.56()1) Anis
t 1t r .
) quotng d.
v.
c (). sue
of f c i ç a e i l'i i i a l gal e e e of t cl i t de t a i bl s t ntve 1 w
a t s ç tra ' f t s e
m
l m nt he a m m r he pplca e ubs a i a
whi mi afc t o c oft c e.Ale v.Tvs n Foods l ,1 F. 642,646( t
ch ght fe t he utome he ms ln
o
.nc. 21 3d
11h
Ci. 9 7 .Anis eo fc i ç e une'fterc r tk n a awh ec ul la arto a t r
r19 )
s u f a t s t n i 'i h e o d a e s ol o d e d ain l de
g
offc t fndfrt nonmovi pa t J
a t o i o he
ng ry. #.
I a yi t s sa r t diti cour m us viw t e de e a a l f c ua
n ppl ng hi tnda d, he srct
t
t e he vi nc nd 1 a t l
i e e st r fom i t lghtm os f vor bl t t pa t opposngt m oton. 11 t ' mee
nf r nce he e r n he i
t a a e o he ry
i he i
(, t he r
. l
e itn eo asi t l o e ie ei s p o t fte Eo mo n ')po i o wil i s sce t
xse c f cni a f vd nc n u p r o h n n va ts st n l be n uf in ;
l
i
t r mu t t i e c o whiht j r c udr a o a l fn frt eE n va t. An gs n
hee s be v d n e n c ht u y o l e s n by i d o h no mo n l' d ro
'
.
v Li rvLo b . n .47 U. 2 2 2 2( 9 6 .
. bet b y l c, 7 S. 4 , 5 1 8 )
1 1 A N AI, SI
1.
Y S
Un e Flrd lw, p anifalgn ne lg nc mus e tb ih ( )alg ld t t a te
d r o ia a a litf l i g gi e e t sa ls 1 e a uy h t h
e
d fn a to dt p an if ()ted fn n' b e c o t td t ( )a ij r t tepanif
ee d n we he litf,2 h ee da t r a h f ha uy, 3 n nu y o h litf
s
ta wa c u e b teb e c a ( )d ma e a ar s l o t ij Ca tla sv. r e
h t s a s d y h r a h, nd 4 a g s s eut f he n my. selno Taa t
Co . 2 1W L 51 8 3 ,a * ( D. a Oc.1 2 1 (ing Zioi o ih v. m e,5 5
m , 01
7 3 4 t 3 S. Fl . t 4, 01 ) ct
i v in vc Ba r 2
F.d 1 9 1 6 ( 1h Ci.2 08 Ad iin ly t ln o e o st d te t abu ie s
3 05 , 0 7 1 t r 0 :. dto al, t a d wn r we wo u is o
a
sn s
ivte ( )t u er ao bl c r i manann t ep e s si ar m o a ys f c ndto ; n
n i : 1 o s e s na e ae n itiig h rmie n e s n bl ae o i n a d
e
i
() t gv t iv te wnnn o c nc ae peis wh c a e o s o l be k o t t e
2 o ie he n ie r ig f o e ld rl ih r r h ud
n wn o h
lndo r a whi h a eunkno t t i t e a cn tbe dico r by hi t oug t
a wne , nd c r
wn o he nvie nd nno
s ve ed
m hr h he
e r ieo d ec r . I (iig Emmo sv. o itHo p.4 So 2d4 0, 4 ( a Dit Ct
xecs f u ae' d. ctn
'
n Ba ts s , 78 . 4 4 2 F1. s. .
Ap 1 8 :.
p. 9 5
F o ia S au e j7 .75 2g v m ssi a fl camsb sd o a ta io y o j c i
lrd tt t 680 5 o e lp nd al li a e n rnst r b e t n
busne s esa ihm e s a r q r a pl i ift pr t tQhe busnes e tbls ntha
i s tbls nt nd e uies
antf o ove ha ç
t
i s sa ibme
d
2 j 768.
0755 c m e i o efec o J y 1 201 a rpe ld Fl i Stt e j 768. 0. The
a
nt f t n ul ,
0 nd e ae orda aut
071
s a ut s c ea pur e w a t r i t t a t lor c t c i know l
t t e' l r pos
s o e ns a e c ua
ons nz tve
edge a a e s ntalel m e
s n s e i e nt
ofa c us ofa to Se Ke s v.Bi Lo St e .I ,No.8: CV- 286, 201 W L 288988
a e c in. e lo
a t or s nc.
09- 01
0
2,
a * - ( . Fl. uy21 2 0 Snc ti icd n o c re o Au us 1 2 0 Plitf s
t 3 4 M D. a J l , 01 :. i e h s n ie t c u rd n g t 4, 01 , an if
c e in t tj768. 0gove st sc ei i c lae Se Pl' Re p.a 5ontnto ha
071
m hi ms s na ct t. e .s s , t 6.
r
4
a ua or c tuc i knowldge oft da r c ton a s d ha tke a to t
ct l
onsr tve
e
he nge ous ondii nd houl ve a n ci n o
r me y i. FL S AT j 7 80 5 4) Co sr ci e n tc c n be p o n tr u h
e d t'
'
A. T .
6 .7 5 1.
n tu tv o ie a
r ve h o g
cru tnile ie es h a : 1
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?
|