Harty v. EHDEN NV
Filing
15
ORDER GRANTING 8 Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment. Signed by Judge K. Michael Moore on 6/18/2012. (rg1)
I TH E UM TED STATES DI
N
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE SO UTH ERN DISTRI O F FLO RI
CT
DA
Cas No.1 c 1
e
2- v- 4087- M
KM
OW EN H ARTY ,
Pl ntf,
ai if
VS.
EHD EN , . .
NV,
De e nt
f nda .
O RDER G M NTI DEFENDANT' M O TI N FOR SUM M ARY JUDGM ENT
NG
S
O
THI CAUSE c m e be or t Cou tupon Def nda Ehde N. ' M oton t Dim is
S
a
f e he
r
e nt
n, V.S
i o s s
Co lit( No.8 . Plitf fld aRepo s ( No. ) a d Dee d n fld a Re l
mpan ECF
) anif ie
s n e ECF
9 , n fn a t ie
py
( No 1 ) OnMa 2 , 01 ,hi Co r e ee a Or e ( No.1 )n tf igtePate
ECF . 1.
y 2 2 2 t s u t ntrd n d r ECF
2 oiyn h ris
ta p ru n t Fe e a Rueo Cii P o e u e 1 ( )t i Co r c n tu d Dee d n ' M oin
h t u s a t o d rl l f v l r c d r 2 d h s u t o sr e f n a ts to
t Dim is a a M oton f Slmma y J
o s s s
i or l r udgme . The ea t ,e c Pary fld a s pplm e al
nt
r fer a h
t ie
u e nt
b if( Nos 1 1 .Dee d n ' M oin i n w rpef rrve Up nc n ieaino te
re ECF . 3, 4) fn a ts to s o i o e iw. o o sd rto f h
M oton,Res e Re y,t Pa tes upplm e a bre s t pe tne pori nsoft r cor
i
pons , pl he ri 's e nt l if , he ri nt to
he e d,
and b ng ot r s f ly a s i t pr m ie ,t sCour entr t f l ng Or r
ei he wie u l dvied n he e s s hi
t e s he olowi
de .
1 Ba
. ckground
Thi matraiesunde t Ameia wih Dia ltesAc,42U. C.j 1 81 e s q
s te rs
r he
rc ns t s biii t
S.
21 , t e
CW DA' . Pli if Owe Hary i a ççeser on be f ofhi efand ohe pes wih
'
) antf
n t s ç t'
t
hal
ms l
t r rons t
dia ltesf t pur e ofdic rng,e
s biii or he pos
s ove i ncountrng,a e
e i nd ngagi di c i i ton agans t
ng s rm na i
i t he
ds be i p bi a c mmo ains' Co l, 4( No 1 .ç r Ha t ( e jp o e d wih
ia ld n u l c o d t . mp .! ECF . ) 1 . ry t n r c e s t
c
o '
M
h
1
lg la to t e j i s c ds rmiain a d s b e u n l rt n t te p e s st v rf is
e a ci n o n on u h ici n to n u s q e ty eur s o h rmie o eiy t
l
,,
c inc ornon-ompla ewiht ADA .... J
ompla e
c inc t he
#a
On M a c 1 201 Pl ntf i taed t i t t a ton a trhe wms una e t a ces
r h 2, 2, ai if nii t he nsnn c i fe
bl o c s
Sa Pam Pl z a pl c ofpublc ac om moda i owne a o r t d by De enda Ehden,
bal l a a, a e
i c
ton,
d nd pe a e
f nt
N. (Eh e ' . Pli t fs e t e j i alg d v oain o t eADA.S cfc l Plitf
V. 1 d n' ani e ks o n on le e i lto s f h
ç
)
f
pe iial an if
y,
as t tDef nda becompele t elm i t a c t c u a ba e st tpr e l ha ra ce s
ks ha
e nt
ld o i na e r hie t r l ni r ha es nty mpe c s
by t dia e atSa Pam Pl z
he s bld
bal l a a.
I .A nal i
I
ys s
Def nda a gue t t Pl ntf s cai i ba r d by a pror s tlm e ag ee nt a
e nt r s ha ai if l m s re
i e te nt r me nd
c u tode . Se Dia ld Parosv. e N. , 0 - 4 21Cl COHN ( D.F a 2 0 )
o r r r e s be tit Ehd n V.No. 3 1 0 - VS. l. 0 3 .
Ac di t De e
cor ng o f ndan ,o Ocobe 1 2003,De e nte er d i o a s tl ntag ee nt
t n t r 0,
f nda nt e nt
e teme
r me
wi Dia ld Paro so Ameia l c,a d M a y F.Do a (h l e t me tAg e me f i
t sb e tit f rc , n . n
h
r
rn te t tl n r e n ), n
s e
whih De enda t a e t ma Sa lPam Pl a c
c
f n gr ed o ke ba l az ompla wih Til 1Ioft ADA. Se
int t te I
he
e
De .sM o . o Dimis Ex. ( No.8 1 . A rve o Dee d n ' stlme ta r e n
f' t t s s, A ECF
-)
e iw f fn a ts et n ge me t
e
wih Dia ed Pa rot ofAme ia,l a M a yF. a r ve l t i t ntaci i ba r d by
t s bl
ti s
rc nc. nd r Dor n, e a s he nsa
ton s re
t d drn o r s u iaa
he o i e f e j dc t.
Th p r o eb hid t edo ti eo rsj diaa i t tte çula d fi o p ru t t
e u p s e n h crn f e u c t s ha h f l n ar p o tni o
y
ltga epr t c sa r a i fo t e ns a ve ton a tndi muli e lws t,c e v
ii t o e t dve s res r m he xpe e nd xa i te ng
tpl a uis ons r es
j d ca r s u c s a d f ses rla c o j dca a to b mii zng te p si lt o
u iil e o re , n o tr ein e n u iil cin y n mii h o sbi y f
i
i c n itn d cso .' Ra s aev. b emad l c,1 3 F.d 1 3 ,1 8 ( 1h Ci.1 9 )
n o sse t e iins' c d l Ru b r i . n . 9 3 2 5 23 1 t r 9 9
'
( u tn Mo tn v.Untd S ae ,4 0 U. 1 7 ( 9 9 ) A ç li wilb b re b p ir
q oig n a a
ie tts 4 S. 4 1 7 ). t am l e a rd y ro
c
ai if s
ta r o hi
t antf
ied ppr m t l olr a uis
1A s s h, Pl ntf i no sr nge t t sCour. Pli ifhasfl a oxi a ey f z l ws t
uc
a i tl albusnes e t sc l nda ye r a Pl i ifhasbe n apa t t a la tffy lws t
gans oc
i s s hi a e r a , nd antf
e
ry o t e s it a uis
snc 2002.
i e
2
l iain i alfu o t ef lo n ee nsae p e e t ( )t r i a fn l u g n o te
i g to f l o r f h o lwig lme t r rs n : 1 hee s i a j d me t n h
t
meis ( )te d cso wm rnd rd b a c u to c mp tn j rs ito ( )t e p ris o
rt; 2 h e iin s e ee y o r f o ee t u idcin; 3 h a t , r
e
t o ei p iiywihte aeie tc lnb t s t; n ( )tesmec us o a to i iv l e
h s n rvt t h m, r d n ia i o h uis a d 4 h n a e f cin s n o v d
i bot c es' I
n h as . d.
'
Frt Dee d n ' s tlme ta re n c n t e ap irj d me to t emeis ln
is, fn a ts et n g e me t o si s ro u g n n h rt. ç
e
mt
l
d tr nigter s u iaaefc o a o d ro dimis l a e u o as tlme t g e me t (
eemi n h e j dc t fe t f n r e f s s a b s d p n e t n a r e n, a
e
c u ts o l)a tmp t ef c t t e pate 'itn .Th be te d nc o ta itn i,o
o r h ud te t o fe mae h ris n e t e s vie e f h t ne t s f
c s ,t s tlm e a e ntis l. Norol S.Co .v.Che om U . A . l ,371 F.
our e he e te nt gr eme t ef'
'
f k
p
vr
S. . nc.
3d
1 1 9 ( 1h Ci.200 . Consquenty,t pr cusveefe tofasi ai ofdimis i
285, 28 1 t r 4)
e
l he e l i fc
tpulton
s sal s
de e mi d notby t cai ss cii i t o i nalco pl nt ç i t d by t tr soft
t r ne
he l m pe fed n he rgi
m ai , ç nsea
but
he e m
he
(ltlme t(lr e n , sitr rtd a c r ig t ta iina p icp e o c nr c lw. l .
set n a ge me t a n ep ee c o dn o rdto l rn ils f o ta t a ' d
e
'
Theprora i b e De e
i cton e- en f ndan ,Dia e Pa rot ofAme i a,I a M ar F.Dor n,wa
t s bl d ti s
rc nc. nd
y
a
s
ds se wih prj d c a tr te p ris s tld t matr M o e v r i e c a g fr
imis d t eu ie fe h a t et he te .
e
e
ro e , n x h n e o
De e nts c pla e wih t t r s a condii oft s tlm e a ee t Dia ed
f nda ' om i nc t he e m nd
tons
he e te nt gr men , s bl
Parot ofAme i ,I and M ar F.Dor n agr e t r l % e a dic r De enda ofç l
ti s
rca nc.
y
a
e d o ee
nd s ha ge f nt ç l
a
ca ms an c us ofaci whih t have ha o may cli t ha ha arsng u
li
d a es
ton
c hey
d r
am o ve d ii ndert
he
Ame i ns wih Diabiii Ac . Def' M ot t Dim is Ex.A,a 6. Thus i lg of t
rca
t s ltes t'
'
s
.o s s,
t
, n i ht he
p ris siu ain o ds sa wi p eu ie a dt ef c t a tep rise p e syd cd d te
a t ' tp lto f imis l t rj d c , n h a t h t h a t x r sl e ie h
e
h
e
a e m e woul ba alf t e cli sa ii t rt ADA,t sCour concude f pur e
gr e nt
d r l uur am rsng mde he
hi
t
l s or pos s
o t ep e e ta to t a Dee d n ' s tlme ta re n c n tmtsa p irj g n o t
f h rs n cin h t fn a ts et n g e me t o si e ro ud me t n he
e
m e is
rt .
S c n ,t ep i rj d me twa is e b a c u to c mpee t u id ci n Th c s
e o d h ro u g n s su d y o r f o tn j rs ito . e a e
wms he r a de de i t Sou he n Ditit of Fl i
a d nd ci d n he
t r
src
orda. Def nda ' pr pe t wm a
e nts o ry s nd
antf
r
a
c i s t be l a e wihi t Sout m DititofFl rda. Pli if M a y F.Dor n wasa
ontnue o
oc t d t n he
he
src
oi
diabld i vi l wihi t m e ni of t ADA and ha sa ng t s Def nda .
s e ndi dua t n he a ng
he
d tndi o ue
e nt
Th rf r , e ue s b e tma trj s ito a d p ro a j rs ito we ea1a p o rae a d
eeo e v n , u j c te midcin, n es n l u idcin r 1 p r p it n
tep i r u g n wa is e b ac u t c mp tn ju s ito
h ro j d me t s su d y o r of o ee t tidcin.
Ne , t
xt alhough t Pa tesa enott de ia ,' he e i s fcintprviy be we Dia e
he ri r
G ntc l't r s ufi e
i
i t t en s bld
Parot of Ame i I ,M a y F.Dor n,a Owe Ha t t hol t t t pro s tl me
ti s
rca, nc. r
a nd
n ry o d ha he i r e te nt
a e m e ba st i t ntaci n. ç per o who wa notapa t t a s tge r ly ha notha
gr e nt r he nsa
to $
A
sn
s
ry o ui ne al s
d
a tu la f r opporuniy t ltg t t cli a is s tl d i t t s t' Ta or v.
f l nd ai
t t o ii a e' he a ms nd s ues e te n ha ui.' yl
Stxel 5 3 U. 8 0 8 2 ( 0 8 . I e d,te Untd S ae Su rme Co r h ssae th
t l, 5 S. 8 , 9 2 0 ) nd e h ie tts p e
u
u t m ttd f e
t
g nea r l (s ta ç n i no b t b aj d me ti pe s n m i al iain i whc h i
e rl ue i) h t o e s t o md y u g n n r o a n i g to n ih e s
t
n td sg td a ap ryo t whc h h sn tb e ma eap ryby s r ieofp o e s' J
o e inae s a t r o ih e a o e n d a t
e vc
r c s .' #.
'
( u t Ha b ryv. e 31 U. 3 , 0( 0 ).Th S p e Co r, we r h shedt a
q oi
ng ns er Le , 1 S. 2 4 20 1) e u r me u tho ve , a l h t
t r a e sx exc ptonst t sg r r e:
he e r i
e i o hi ene al ul
A c u t ya p yn n a t p e l so i:( )ten n ry a re t b b u db
o r ma p l o p ry rcu in f 1 h o pat g e d o e o n y
t e l iain o oh r ;()a s b tn ie lg lr lto hp e itd b t e t e
h i g to f te s 2 u sa tv e a eains i xse ewe n h
t
pes n t b b t a d apat t tej d me t ( )t en n a t wm a e u tl
ro o e omd n
ry o h u g n ; 3 h o p ry s d q aey
rp e e td b s me n wh wa apa t t te s i;( )t n n ry a sl d
e rs ne y o o e o s ry o h ut 4 he o pa t sl
me
c nr lo rtel iain i whiht ej g n wa is e ; 5 ap ryatmpe
o to ve h i g to n c h ud me t s su d ( ) a t te td
t
t rltg e is s t oug a pr
o eiiat sue hr h
oxy; or ( a saut y she fr l ed
6) tt or c me oecos
s c sve ltgai by nonltga s
uc es i ii ton
ii nt .
Grs l v Cn y o Hilb r u h,5 8 F.d 1 8 ,1 9 ( 1h Ci.2 0 (i n Ta lr 5 3
iwod . t . f ls o o a 9 3 2 9 2 2 1 t r 01 ) ct g vo , 5
i
U. a 8
S. t 93-94. Hee,M a y F.Dor n i a dia e i vi lwihi t mea ng oft ADA .
r
r
a s s bl d ndi dua t n he
ni
he
Dia ld Paroso Ameia l c sae i isc mp an a ans Dee a tt ti Ge r sn l)
s be tit f
rc , n . ttd n t o lit g i t fnd n ha t t p e e ts
r
t i e es of is m e
he ntr t t mber by a s i pl c ofpublc a om moda i a e ac es i e t and
s
s urng a es
i cc
ton r c sbl o
us e by t dia ed and t t is me be s ar not dic i naed a ns be us of t r
abl
he s bl
ha t
m r e
s rmi t gai t ca e
hei
d sb l is' Co l,! 8 Dia ld Paro sv. d n N. ,No.0 - 4 21Cl COHN ( .
ia ii e . mp . , s be tit Eh e V.
t '
3 1 0 - VSD.
4
F a 2 0 ) I t i sn ta to Ha t i açtse 'o b h l o hms l a d oh rp ro swi
l . 0 3 . n he n fn cin, ry s çe tr n e af f i ef n t e es n t
t
h
dia lte f t pur eofdico rng,e ount rng,a e gi dic i i to a ns t
s biiis or he pos
s ve i nc e i nd nga ng s rm nai n gai t he
d sbld i p bl a c mmo ain . Co l, 4. Th pate ae smim' stae a d t er
ia e n u i c o d to s' mp .!
c
'
e ris r i l l iu td n h i
y
i e e t a e i ntc : Dia e Paro s ofAm e i a l ,M ar F.Dor n,a Owen Hary a 1
nt r ss r de ial s bl d ti t
rc , nc.
y
a nd
t l
s e t e o ce t ADA f t be f oft m s l s a ot s The ef e,t s Cour hol
e k o nf r he
or he ne h
he eve nd her .
r or hi
t ds
t Ha t wms a qua ey r pr en e by pl i if i t orgi l s ta t r i s t int
hat ry
de t l e es t d
antfs n he i na ui nd he e s ufk e
p i iyb t e tepat sfrp r s so r s u c t .
rvt ewe n h ri o u po e f e j diaa
e
Fi l De e nts s tl me a e nti t prora ton addr s ed t s m e c am s
naly, f nda ' e te nt gr eme n he i c i
e s he n
li
br hti t i tnta ton by Pl ntf. l t a ton be we n Parot ofAm e ia,l ,M a y
oug n he nsn c i
ai if n he c i
t e ti s
rc nc. r
F. r n,a De e nt pli tfsbr
Do a nd f nda , a n if oughtcai sunde t ADA . I t s tlm e a e m e ,
lm
r he
n he e te nt gr e nt
Dee a ta re t mo iy te Sa a Pam Plz wi r s c t ( )te n mb ro d sb e
fnd n g e d o df h b l l a a t epe t o: 1 h u e f ia ld
h
p r i s a e ; 2 t ed sg o t ep r i s c s i ldngt esg sl c td a e c p r i
akng p c s ( ) h e in f h akng pa e ,ncu i h i n o ae t a h akng
s a e ( ) h r uefo t ep r i s a e t t ef clt i ld n t ede ina s ra eso e
p c ; 3 t e o t r m h akng p c s o h a ii ncu i g h sg nd u f c -lp
y,
o rmp fo t e p r ig 1tt t e so e fo t;( )t e ta c s a d e t t o h u te
f a s r m h a kn o o h tr r ns 4 he n rn e n xis hrug o t h
fcl y a d () t p lc r sr o lc td o Dee a ts p e s s Hee Plitf s
a ii ; n 5 he ubi eto ms o ae n fnd n ' rmie . r , an if
t
Compl i al svi a i oft ADA. Specic l Pl i ifal ge vi a i oft ADA
ant lege oltons he
i aly, antf le s oltons he
wih r pe tt Sa Pal Pl a' pa ki s c a t desgn a s f c so ofr m ps
t es c o bal m az s r ng pa es nd he i nd m a e-l pe
a
fom t pa ki 1 t t sor font Thus Pl ntf cai sar cove ed en iel by t pror
r he r ng ot o he t e r s.
, ai ifs l m e
r
tr y
he i
S tlme tAge me t Dee d n h se tbih dt ee itnc o afn lu me to t emeis
e t n re n . fn a t a sa ls e h xse e f i a j dg n n h rt
e
t twa rn ee b a c u to c mp tn j rs ito ,whc i v le p risi p iiy wi
ha s e d rd y o r f o ee t u id ci n ih n ov d a t n rvt t
e
h
Pl i if a whih i ved t s me c us of a i
antf nd
c nvol
he a
a e
cton. Cons quenty,Pl ntf s ca ms a e
e
l
ai if li
r
bardb t ed crn o rs u iaa
re y h o tie f e j dc t .
5
1 1 Conc us on
1.
l i
Fort f egoi r as ,i i
he or ng e ons t s
ORDERED AND ADJ
UDGED t t t De e nt Ehden,N. ' M o i t Dim is
ha he f nda
V.S ton o s s
Co an ( No 8 i GRANTED. A1 cams a ans Dee da t L Eh n N. ae
mplit ECF . ) s
l li g i t fn n
de , V. r
DI I
SM SSED W I PREJUDI
TH
CE. The Cl r ofCour i i tu t d t CLOSE t scm e. Al
ek
t s nsr c e o
hi s
1
pendi m otonsa eDEN I AS M OOT.
ng i
r
ED
DO A OR R DiCa est a ,lrati dyoJn,02
NE ND DE E n hmbraMimiFoi ,hs a fue21.
d /Wt
.
cc:
A1 co ms ofr c d
1 t el e or
6
M I A EL M O O RE
I
TED STA TES D I
STRI JUD GE
CT
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?