Hartford Casualty Insurance Company v. Intrastate Construction Corp. et al

Filing 86

DECLARATORY DECREE GRANTING FINAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT TO HARTFORD CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY. Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 11/18/2011. (jw)

UN I
TED STA TES D I RI T CO UR T
ST C
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLO RI
CT
DA
K EY W EST D I SI N
VI O

CASE NO. 1 10077- KI
0CV- NG
HARTFORD CASUALTY I
NSURAN CE
COM PANY, f r gn c por ton,
a o ei or a i
Pl i if
antf,

CI OF M ARATHON,aFl i m unii lt
TY
orda
cpaiy;
a I
nd NTRASTATE CONSTRUCTI CORP.
ON
,
a Fl i c r a i n,
orda o por to
Def nda s
e nt,
/
DECLAR ATORY DECREE GM NTI FI
NG NAL SUM M ARY JUDG M ENT TO
HARTFORD CASUALTY I
NSURANCE COM PANY

THI M ATTER c e bef e t Cour upon Pli if Ha tor Ca ualy I ur nce
S
om s or he
t
antf rf d s t ns a

Co a ysa dDee a t t o M aah ' co smoi sf rs mma yj d me t ( r to s
mp n ' n fnd n Ci f rton s r s t o u r u g n . Ma ah n'
y
on
M o.f Sum.J,DE /31 Hator sM o,frSum.J,DE /42) TheCo ti f lybree la
or
.
/ ; rf d'
o
.
/ .
ur s ul ifd, nd
pr e wih t be i ofe e i or la gume . Upon c r ul i r ton oft a g e s
oce ds t he neft xt nsve a r
ntz
a ef consde a i
he r um nt
s tf t i t M otons a ator ar
e orh n he
i
nd
al gume ,t Cour fnds t tPl i ifHarf d Cas t
nt he
ti
ha antf
tor
ualy

l s r n eCo n i e t ldt s mmayj d me t
n u a c mpa y s ni e o u r u g n.
t
1M aaho r ponde t Harf d' M oton f Summay J me ( #59)on Se e r20,
rt n es
d o tor s i or
r udg nt DE
ptmbe
2011a Hator fldaRe y( #71 onSe e r30, 1 l rsat r s
nd rf d ie
pl DE )
ptmbe 201 .nta t e eponde t Ha tor s
d o rf d'
Moto f SummayJ me ( #65)onSe t r20,2011a Ha tor fld aRe y (
in or
r udg nt DE
pembe
nd rf d ie
pl DE
#72 onSe e r30, 1. rf dfldaRes et Maat sM otonf Pa ta Summay
)
ptmbe 201 Hator ie
pons o r hon'
i or ril
r
J
udgme ( #64 o Se e r20, 1 a M aahonrple ( #73)onSe e
nt DE ) n ptmbe 201 , nd rt e id DE
ptmber30 2011
, .
2The Co t l or la gume on t M otonsi M im i Fl on Oc o r1 2011.
ur hed a r
nt he
i n a , a.
t be 2,

1 B ackground 3
.

I oraound2007,heDefnda CiyofM aahonts aaho ',amuni paiyl ae i
n r
t
t nt t
rt s rt n'
M
l
ci lt oc td n
M onr Count Fl rda, a
oe
y, o i plnned a i tae t c tuc i ofas resofwa t wa e te t nt
nd nii td he onsr ton
ei
se t r r a me

fclt p oe t a v ro g o rp i lc t nstr ug o tt ect , e erd t a t M aaho
a ii rjcs t aius e g a hc o ai h o h u h iy r fre o s he rt n
y
o
a va e watwaerte t nts tm (i TS' .TheAW TS wa di de i o s ve tsr ie
d nc d se t rame yse $AW '
)
s vi d nt e n 'e vc
a e s' The a
r a .'
bove syld a ton c
-t e c i once nst s r c a e known asSer c Ar a 3 a Se vie
r he e vie r as
vie e
nd r c
A r 7.
ea

OnFe u r 1 2009, f nt ntasa eConsr tonCor . (t rsae',
br a y 2,
De enda I r tt
tuc i
p çnta tt' aconsr ton
l
)
tuci

c mp n ic r o ae u d rtelwso Flrd ,ub te is df r h Ar a3Prjc .ltatt
o a y n o p rtd n e h a f o ia s mi d t bi o t e e
t
oe t(nr sae
Ar a3Bi , # 7 3 .n rsaes b te attl i o $ 6 9,0 whc i c r o ae Ita tt '
e
d DE 3 - )lta tt u mi d o a b d f 4,0 0 0, ih n o p rtd n rsaes
t
uni c tuc i ba ebi of$ 0610 00,aswelast s tt r pa t ba ee pm e bi of
que onsr ton s d 2, ,00.
l he e hid- ry s qui nt d

$ 5 00. (
2,48, 00.Thoma De , t111
s p.a :4-25,DE #39- ) I r sae' $2, , 00c tuci bi
1.ntatt s 061000. onsr ton d
wasr c
e omm e d a de e ne t bet l
nde nd t nni d o he owes r ponsvea r ponsbl bi rf t Ar a
t es i nd es i e dde or he e

3Prj c.Th ma De , t1 4 5 DE /3 - )
oe t( o s p.a 2:-1 , /9 1 .
On or a
bout Ap i 1 2009,I r tt a M a aho e e ed i t a c r t f t
rl 4,
ntasae nd r t n nt r n o
ontac or he

c tuc i oft Ar 3W a t wae Tr am e tFa iiy i t nmounto $2, 000. e ild
onsr ton he ea
se tr e t n clt n he
f 061, 00, ntte

ttCiyo M a ah n Sevc Ar a3W atwae a So mwae P oe t(s e 3 Co sr cin
h t f rt o r i e e
se tr nd tr tr rj c ç a n tu to
Ar
Co ta t'rS n eli c nsr to c nr c '.Ar a3Co tu to Co ta t !11 4., # 5
nrc'o s d ryng o tucin o ta f)( e
u
nsr cin n rc l ., 1 DE 3 1. eCo ta te u rtsta dth W ok i g n r l d srb d a tef lo ng teCiyo
) Th nr c n me ae h t t l e r s e e al e c ie s h olwi :h t f
t
y

M aah nS r ieAr a3W atwae Trame t dl y Th p o e c n it o c n tu tn tn s
rt o e vc e
se tr e t n Fa i . e rj d o sss f o sr cig a k ,
t
buidi s a i t li wa t waerte t e a pl
l ng , nd nsalng se t r am nt nd umbi f c ltes c
ng a iii , omplt , i pl c al i
e e n a e, l n
3Thef l ng f c sa eundipu e . (oi Prti St , #76)
olowi a t r
s t d J nt eral i DE
p.
.
2

a o da e w ih t c t u ton dr wi a t c c ls cika i .' ( e 3 Consr ton
cc r nc t he onsr c i
a ngs nd e hni a pe t tons ' Ar a
tuci

Co ta t!11 DE / 5 1.
nrc ( ., / - )
3
Ono a o t un 3 2 0 , anif rf r Ca u lyl s rn eCo a y(ç a to d'is e
r b u l e , 0 9 PlitfHato d s at n l a c mp n ll rf r ' su d
z
l
)
sauo yp ro n ea d p y n b n sfrt eAr a3 Prj c u d rb n n mb r3 BCS
tttr ef nna c n a me t o d o h e
oe t n e o d u e 5
FD
61 7(h d n s).Bo d , # 5 3 . rfr e e ue t ebo d tr u hist n at r e -n
2 te t d ' ( n s DE 3 - )Ha t d x c td h n s h o g t he -to n y iBo
o
fc, P. me c ik ( nd , # 5 3 a 5 . eAr a3Pef r n eBo d,su di fvo o
a t S. Hu n hc . Bo s DE 3 - , t ) Th e
ro ma c n is e n a r f
M a ahon, r nt ed l r t t spt f m a e o t c r c e il , Ciy ofM a a hon Se vi
r t gua a e ntasae' ror nc n he onta t ntted t
rt
r ce

Ar a3W atwae a Stnn trP o e t( e 3Pef r n eBo d DE # - , t1. eAr a
e
se tr nd o wae rj c.Ara ro ma c n , 353 a ) Th e
3Pa
ymen Bondgua a e
t
r ntedpa ntoI r tt ' s bco r c or , ub-ubc r t r , l bo er , nd
yme t ntasa e s u nta t s s s ontac o s a r s a
ma e il n ont c r c e il d, t ofM a aho Se vi Ar a3 W ase t ra St
tra me
he onta t ntte Ciy
r t n r ce e
t wa e nd onnwa e
tr

P o e t ( e 3Pa me t n , # 5 3 a 7 .
rj c.Ara y n Bo d DE 3 - , t )
OnAug t3,
us 2009, a at is dt I tasa eisç rii to ofCo r c orsl ur nc
M r hon s ue o n r tt t s tfcai n
ce
nta t ' ns a e

a dBo dng'c li n h tnr sae do ti dis r n e a y n a pefr n e n s
n n i , e /igt a l tatt ha b ane n u a c ,ndpa me t nd ro ma c bo d
'
fo Ha tod i te a u to $ ,610 0.0 f rt tp oe ti e tfe a te S r ieAr a 3
r m rfr n h mo n f 20 ,0 0 o h rj c d niid s h i vc e
se
W atwae Tr t Pln . ( rikai DE #39- a 1 ) On Aug t5,2009,a ar ul of
se tr eament a t' Ce tt ton,
'
2, t 3 .
us
s es t
ha ngr c ve hei ur nc a
vi e ei dt ns a e ndbondi i o ma i fom l r sa e, a aho s uedt I r sa t
ng nf r ton r nta tt M r t nis o nta t t

aNoiet Pr c e o teAr a3P o e t( e 3No iet Pr c e , # 9 2 a 1 Th ma De .
tc o o e d n h e rj c.Ar a tc o o e d DE 3 - , t 4; o s p,
a 20: -216,DE #39- )
t 22 :
1.
Ei m on hs lt r i Apr l201 l r t t s s onta t s a s ir beg n flng
ght
t ae , n
i
0, ntasae' ubc r c or nd upple s a ii

No ie o No p y n wi Ha to da dM aah n.Ma lr f! 1 DE# 0- )Th n o Ap i
tc s f n a me t t rf r n rto ( he Af. 2, 4 1. e , n rl
h
1 201 I r t t c a t Ha tor t i or Ha tor ofl r sa e' i ol nc and ne d f r
4s 0, ntasae ont ced rf d o nf m rf d nta tt s ns ve y
e o

fn n il s itn et c mp eev ro s nd dp oe t,n ldngteAr a3Prj c.M a lrAf.
a ca a ssa c o o lt ai u bo e rj cs i cu i h e o e t( he f

!1 DE # 0 1.
0, 4 - )
Lae t tm ont on ora utAprl27, 0, I r t t a M a ahonexe ut d adoc
tr ha
h,
bo
i 201 ntasae nd r t
c e
ument

e il Cha Or rN o.1t ç ovi t s met ofs r c st buidano he te t ntpl nt''
ntted nge de
o s de he n ype e vie o l
pr
t r r a me a ,

k o a te Ar a7 W a twae Trame tFa iiyPrj c (W r a7 Ch ng Or e' . Ara 7
n wn s h e
se tr e t n cl oe t ç e
t
a e d r' ( e
)
Cha Or r DE #35- ThomasDe ,a 21: 6, #39-) TheAr a7Cha Or rdi not
nge de,
4;
p. t 7-1 DE
1.
e
nge de d

mo iyt ep a sf rt eAra3P o t t ( o sDe , t4 1 -2 , # 9 1 . t e ,heAra
df h ln o h e rj c.Th ma p.a 0:8 5 DE 3 - ) Rah r t e
7P oe t st p o e du d rac mpltl s p rt st pln a ds e iiains( ma De ,
rj c wa o r c e n e o eey e aae e of a s n p cfc to .Tho s p.
a 40:8 DE #39-)
t 1 -25,
1.

Th Ar a 7 Prj c wa t b c nsr ce a a p oe t st l c td o Grsy Ke ,
e e
oe t s o e o tu t d t rj c ie o ae n a s y
a p o maey 55mie a yfo t Ar a3P oe t ( o sDe , t :-5 DE # 9 1. e
p r xi tl . ls wa r m he e r jc .Th ma p.a 413 , 3 - ) Th
tmei f r o ltngt eAr a7Prj c wa i e e d n o t tmei ef rc mpltn t Ara
i l o c mpei h e oe t s nd p n e t fhe i ln o o eig he e
ne
3Prj d.Th ma De , t :9 457 DE#3 1 .na dto t eAr a7Prj c c mea a a d d
oe ( o s p.a 44 1 - :,
9-)I d i n,h e oe t a t n d e
i
cos of$2, 487. t t undt l ngc tu ton c r d.Ar 7Cha eOr r DE #35- .
t
984, 00 o he ryi onsr ci onta ( ea
ng de,
4)
Uli t l t Ar 7Cha Or ri r as d t bondedc r c a ountfom $ 061, 00 t
tma ey,he ea
ngt de nc e t he
onta t m
r 2, 000. o

$5, 487. - a i e eofove 1 pe c nt t orgi l nta ts ( ea7Cha Or r
045, 00 n ncras
r 44 r e of he i na co rc um.Ar
nge de ,
DE #35- .
4)

F rte Ara 7Prj c, rto is e as p rt Noiet Pr c e ( o sDe , t
o h e
oe t Ma ah n su d e aae tc o o e d. Th ma p.a
4 9 8, #39- ;Ar 7Notc t Pr e DE #39- a 2) Puruan t t tl oft Notc
4:-1 DE
1 ea
ie o oc ed,
3, t . s t o he e'
ms he ie
t Pr e I r sae wa r quied t pr de a tonalpe f m a e and pa e s ey i t
o oce d, nta t t s e r o ovi ddii
ror nc
ym nt ur t n he

a
mounto $ 98 48 00.( ea7Noiet Pr e DE #39- a 2)
f 2, 4, 7. 4 Ar
tc o oc ed,
3, t .
4Pr o t t A r 7 N o i t Pr e , M a at r eved alte fom S. Hum e hi k
i r o he ea
tce o oc ed
r hon ec i
etr r
P.
nc c

r ltngHa tor spur t c e t t Ara7Cha Or r ( a 1 201 Hume hik
eai rf d' pored ons nt o he e
nge de .M y 4, 0
nc c
Letr DE #35- .Ther or doe notco an a ye de et tHa tor e c e a bond
te ,
5)
ec d s
nti n vi nc ha rf d xe utd ny
doc e f t Ar a 7 Cha Or r t ta s hbo wasr c de ort tl r sa e
um nt or he e
nge de , ha ny uc nd
e or d, ha nta t t
4

OnJ 30, 0, tor i or e M ar t by lte t ti ha nota woul no bo
une 201 Harf d nf m d
ahon e tr ha t d
nd
d t nd

t Ar 7 Cha Or r a t r by e e t val of is bond fom $2,061, 00 t
he ta
nge de nd ht e xt nd he ue
t
r
000. o

$5, 487. ( #35- .Hator howe r di notdia t ti wa r ponsbl f t
045, 00. DE
6) rf d,
ve , d
s vow ha t s es i e or he
$2, , 00Ar a3Pe f m a eBond. ve t e s on Augus 6, 2010,ator ysr pr sentng
061000.
e
ror nc
Ne rhels ,
t
t ne e e i
M a a hon s ntHa tor al te tted ç i eofDef ul a Te mi tony't r i tng I r t t
rt
e
rf d e tr il d c
Not
a t nd r nai ' e m na i ntasae

fo iswo ko b t t eAra3Prj c a dteAra7Prjc .Au 6 2 0M aah nLetrDE
r m t r n oh h e oe t n h e oe t ( g. , 01 rt o te,

#3 - ) M aah ntr n tdI tatt o b t t Ara3Prj c a dt Ar a7P o e t e a e
57 . rt o emiae nr sae n oh he e
oe t n he e rj c b c us
Hator rf e t bondt Ara 7 Cha Or r (
rf d eus d o
he e
nge de. Aug.6,201 M aahon Letr DE #350 rt
te ,
7;

Th ma De , t 3:4 4:, # 9 1.n rsaepef r dn moewo ko teAr a3Prj c
o s p.a 5 1 -5 9 DE 3 - ) Itatt ro me o r r n h e
oe t
a dteAra7Prj c a trt d lv r o t a lte .
n h e
oe t fe he ei ey f h t etr
OnAug t9, 0, rf dfldt i t nta to a i tbot M a ahon a I r tt f
us 201 Ha tor ie he nsa ci n gans h r t
nd ntasae or

d caao yrle se igj g n fo t i Co r d cai ta :it eAr a7Ch n eOr e wa
e lr tr eif e kn ud mt t r m h s u t e lrng h t () h e
ag dr s
voi ab i tof il lt a (i t tnobond is dbyHator i udi butno lmiedt
d nii or legaiy; nd i) ha
sue
rf d,ncl ng
ti t o
bond numbe 35 BCSFH 61 a f dsc r e f t Ar a 7 Cha Or r5 Co 1, #1 .
r
27, for ove ag or he e
nge de . ( mp .DE )
Ha tor sprma y a lga i i t tM a ahon' f iur t c pe ii l bi t Ar 7 Cha
rf d' i r le ton s ha
r t s al e o om ttvey d he ea
nge

Or e viltdFlrd sau e s t tHa to dn ve h da o lg to t b n t Ara7Prj c,
d r oae o ia ttt s o ha rf r e r a n b iain o o d he e
oe t
s bm it d a addii lCe tfc ton ofCon r c orsI ur nc a Bondi t M a aho f t
u te n
tona rii ai
ta t ' ns a e nd
ng o r t n or he

Ara7Ch n eOr e. eFL S AT j25 .5 1()( 0 7 .
e
a g d rSe A. T . 50 ()a 2 0 )
5Hm f d' Compl i as s e ade a a i fom t sCour t tno s e yr ltons p
or s
ant lo e ks clr ton r hi
t ha
ur t ea i hi

e ssbewee Ha tor a t Defnda swihr pec t t Ara7Cha Or r ( /1 .
xit t n rf d nd he e nt t es t o he e
nge de .DE /)
Si t flng oft Compli , e antM a a hon ha r t ne ar a e e conta t a
nce he ii
he
ant Defnd
rt
s eai d epl c m nt r c or nd

s rt f rteAra7P o e ta n l s a dh sd cae t a ii n ts e i d ma e i is
u ey o h e rj c t o os, n a e lrd h t t s o e kng a g s n t
c u tr li f rc vea eo t Ar a7P oe t ( rah n' Re p.oHato d' Mo. o
o n ecam o o rg f he e r jc. M to s s t rf r s f r
Summar J
y udgme ,DE #59,a 3 .Ac di y,t Co twilnota e sa a g nt t t
nt
t ) cor ngl he ur l
ddr s ny r ume s ha
peran t whe he as ey r ai hi pr s nty e ssbewe n Harf d a t De e
ti o
t r ur t eltons p e e l xit t e
tor nd he f ndan s
t
wih r pe tt t Ar 7 Cha Or rorwheherM a at m a r c rf br a h ofco r c
t es c o he ea
nge de
t
r hon y e ove or e c
nta t
f t al e Ar a 7 Pe f r nc Bond.
or he leg d e
ro ma e

Hato d frhe ag st a d aah n' tr n to o Itatt fo t eAr a3Prj c b sd
rf r u t r rue h t t rt o s emiain f n rsae r m h e
M
oet ae
upon Ha tor sr us lt bond t Ar 7 Cha Or c tt es a m aera br c oft
rf d' ef a o
he ea
nge der onsiut
t il ea h
he
Contac,t r byr evi Ha tor ofispef
r t ht e di ng rf d t ronna e o i a i unde t Bonds'( # 4, t
nc blg tons
r he
. 'DE 6
a

1)
9.
OnOct r1 zol M a a honfl isM s ra Afim ai De e e , ndalobr ht
obe 9, o, r t ied t
we nd fr tve f ns s a
s oug
a c er l m a i tHa tor f br ac ofc r c ,a lgi t tç - rf d ha br ac d t
ount cai gans rf d or e h
onta t le ng ha fl tor d e he he
la
Pe f m a e Bond by f ii t honor is oblgai unde t Pe f
ror nc
alng o
t
i tons
r he ronuanc Bond, i l ng
e
ncudi
compe ai M a ahon f rt l s i i ure a ar ul ofI r t t sbr ac oft Con r t''
ns tng r t
o he os es t nc r d s es t ntasae' e h he tac .

( aaho s Co n ecam,! 1 ,DE #1 ) l is Ans rt M aah n' Br a h o Co ta t
M rt n' u trli
4
9.n t
we o rt o s e c f nr c
Count c am ,Ha tor r ie n
er li
rf d as d, mong ot r , he f l nga fr tve de e e :The fr ti t t
he s t olowi f ma i
f ns s
is s ha

dh Ciyo M aah n' camsaeb re b t d crn o c r na c n e'( rf r sAns t
t e t f rt o s li r ard y he o ti e f adi l ha g . Ha to d' .o
t
'

M aaho ' Co necam, # 2, 6 .Th sc nd i t a çh Ci o M aah n scamsae
rt n s u tr li DE 2 ! ) e e o s h t ' e t f rt o ' li r
t
y
ba r d unde t pe f m a bondduet t i o rdef ul andt r i ton ofI r tt bas d
re
r he r or nce
o he mpr pe
a t
e m na i
ntasa e e

upon Hator s de i i t bond a il ala voi c e or r' ( rf d' Ans.t
rf d' clnaton o
n leg nd d hang de.' Hator s
o

M aah n' Comtr li DE # 2, 7 . r s nl ab n htilo a1 su si sh d ld f rt
rt o s t ecam, 2 ! ) P e e ty, e c ra n l is e s c e ue o he
t wee ti pe i c
wo- k ral rod omm e i Nove be 28,2011i Ke W es,Fl .
nc ng
m r
n y
t a.

Beo et eCo rn w aeHa to d sa dMa ah n' co smoi n f rs mmayj d me t
f r h u t o r rf r ' n rto s r s to s o u r u g n.
( rt sM o.f Sum.J,DE #31;Ha tor sMo.f Sum.J,DE #42) Ha tor movesf
Ma ahon'
or
.
rf d'
or
.
. rf d
or

s mmay j d me t o b t is d caao y r l f cam a d M aah n' b e c o c n rc
u r u g n n oh t e lrtr ei li n
e
rt o s ra h f o ta t

c u tr li whl Ma ah n mo sf rp rils mmmy j d me to isbra h o c nr c
o ne cam, i
e rto ve o a t u
a
u g n n t e c f o ta t
c t r a m as i pera ns t t Ar a 3 Pe f r a Bond.A s t M otons r i e i e r l t
oun e cl i
t t i o he e
r o m nce
he
i
a s nt r e a ed

a g e s t Cou twila r st Pa te postonson t m otonsi a c oldaedm a r
r um nt, he
r l dd es he ri s' ii
he
i n ons i t
nne .
6

I .Leg St ndar
I
al a
d

S mmayj d me ts p rp it wh r h pe dng a ds p o t gmaeile tb iht t
u r u g n i a p o rae eete la i s n u p ri tras sa ls ha
n
teei n g n ieis ea t a ymaeil a t n t a temo i gp ryi e tte t j d me t s
h r s o e un s u s o n tra fc a d h th v n a t s n ild o u g n a
am at rofl Se Fe R.Ci P.56;Ce otx Cor . v Catet 477U. 31 322 ( 98 .
te
aw. e d.
v.
l e
p . r t,
S. 7,
1 6) The

movi pa t be r t bur n ofpoi i t t pa toft r or t ts st a e e ofa
ng ry a s he de
ntng o he r
he ec d ha how he bs nc
g nui is ofma e i lf c .Se Adik sv SH Krs t Co.3 8U. 1 4 1 7( 97 )Ale v
e ne s ue
t ra a t e c e . .
es f , 9 S. 4 , 5 1 0 ; ln .

T on Foods I ,1 F.d 6 6 ( 1h Ci.1 .Oncet movi pa t e tbls t
ys
, nc. 21 3 42, 46 1 t r 997)
he
ng ry sa ihes he
a e ofa ge ne is ofm ae ilf c ,heblr en s fst t nonmovi pa t t go be
bs nce
nui s ue
tra a t t zd hit o he
ng ry o
yond

t pl di a desg t ts cik f c ss wi t tt r i ag nui is f rti .' Cel e
he ea ngs nd i na e dpe f a t ho ng ha he e s e ne sue o ral ' otx,

4 7U. a 3 4; e aloCh n lI . . tla t e a o a, n .9 F.d 1 7 ,1 7( 1h
7 S. t 2 s e s a e,nc v Ia inAc i we r fFl .I c, 31 2 4 2 47 1 t
v
Ci.1 )( di t tt nonmo ng pat mus Sc f wrd wih sgniia ,pr bai
r 991 hol ng ha he
vi ry t 'ome or
t i fc nt o tve
e de de tai t e se eofatibl is offc.'.
vi nce monsrtng he xitnc
ra e sue a t'
)

l u r j d me tma b ia p o raee nwheet pate a reo t eb scfcs
i mmay u g n y e n p r p it ve
s
r he ris g e n h a i a t,
butd s g e a
i a r e bouthef c ua i e e st ts dbedrw nfom t ef c s' War i Tombi e
t a t l nf r nce ha houl
a r hes a t .
' ror
gbe

T a s Co,n . . vNa Fu g, 9 F.d1 9 1 96( 1hCi. 9 3 . amoinf r u r
r n p. .I c v M/ n n 6 5 2 2 4, 2 1 t r 1 8 ) On to o s mmay

j g n ,hec u t s v e t e d n ea rs lealn ee e i t lg t s fv rbl t
ud me tt o r mu t iw he vie c nd e ov l ifrnc s n he ih mo t a o a e o
t nonm ovi pa t Se Ande s v. j ry f obb , I c, 7 U. 2 2 2 5( 9 6 .Ho ve,
he
ng r y. e
r on L :c /
y n .4 7 S. 4 , 5 1 8 ) we r a

me e s ntla ofe de i s
r ci il
vi nce n uppor oft nonm ovi pa t sposton i i uf e t de ea a
t he
ng ry'
ii s ns fcint o f t

moinfrs mmayj g n .S ei a 25 It er c r a awhotc u dn te dar to l a t
t o u r ud mt t e d.t 2.f h e o d s
o
l o l o la aina fcfn rt fndf t nonmovi pa t t r i noge nei s off c f ti . M atus t Elc
i de o i or he
ng ry,he e s
nui s ue a t or ralSee s hia e .

I .Co. Ze t Radi Cor ,475U. 5 5 ( 986)
ndus v. nih
o p.
S. 74, 87 1 .

1 1 A nal i
1.
ys s

Theove a c ng is i t sma t i t e e t whih Ha tor , a a s ey,i la e
r r hi s ue n hi ter s he xt nt o c
rf d s ur t s ibl
purua t a pe f m a e bo is d on a c tucto c r te c e by M a a hon a
s nt o
ror nc nd s ue
onsr in ontac xe ut d
rt
nd
I r sa e Theperor nc bonda t c nt roft a
nta t t .
f ma e
t he e e he bove syld a toni gove ne byFl i sae
- t e ci s
r d
orda t t

lw. A. AT j2 50 ( 0 ) Ac o dngy,h Co r' a ay i b g n wi ab ifs n p i o
a FL ST . 5 .5 20 7 . c r i l te u ts n l ss e i s t re y o ss f
h
t r l va tFl i lw on pt f m a ebonds
he e e n orda a
ror nc
.

Th r i asau o yr q rme tnFlrd h t 1p b i c n t cinp o e t o e $ 0 0 0
ee s tt tr e uie n i o iat a al u lc o snzto rj cs v r 2 0,0
bes c e by ape f m a ebo FLA.
e ur d
ror nc nd.
STAT. j25 . ( 0 7 . p ro ma eb n i ac nr c
505 2 0 ) A ef r nc o d s o ta t

b whih as ey g r nt e t pe f r
y
c ur t ua a e s he r o manc ofa c tacoron as i d c t c i n co x c .
e
on r t
pecie onsm to nta t
Xp .
1 HomeAs r e Co v Lar n Ge Hos ., Lt , So. 1 1 ( a. 992) S di rl
su anc . . ki n. p d.593 2d 95, 98 Fl 1 .l naiy
or

ape f m a ebondonl e ur t c
ror nc
y ns ts he ompl to oft c r c . 1 l t contact def uls,t n
ei n ht onta t' d f he
'
r or a t he
.

i th s rt a r e t c mpeet e c n tu to o t pa t e o lg et er a o a e c ss o
i je u ey g e s o o lt h o sr cin r o y h bie h e s n bl o t f
g
c mpeinit ec nr do d fuls'f .s e s FL ST . 6 .5 ( )çT) es r t' la iiy
o lto f h o ta r e a t. # ;e alo A. AT j 277 6 2 .$ h u ey s ib l
'
g
t
f da esi lm ie by t t r oft bond, a t s r t sla lt ts dno bee ende
or mag s i t d he e ms he
' nd he u ey' ibiiy thoul t xt d
'

b i lc to 'fa kn 5 S 2 a 1 8 $T) el b l yo t es rt i o dnai me s rdb ,
y mp iain. r i , 93 o.d t 9 .i h i ii f h u ey s r i rl a u e y
'
(
a t
y
a coe e i wih,hela lt oft prnci l'Cr r ev Aet Cas an
nd xtnsve t t ibiiy he i pa .' abte . na . dsur Co.438So.
.
,
2d

1 2,1 ( a.DitCt App.1 )
0 05 Fl s. .
983 .
It a
n he bove syld a ton,Ha tor s e ade a a i fom t sCour a t isrght a
- t e ci
rf d e ks clr ton r hi
t s o t i s nd
la ltesunde t Ar 3 Pero m a e Bond.Spe tcal Ha tor s ksa de l r ton t tt
ibiii
r he ea
f r nc
ci ly, rf d ee
i
c a a i ha he
Ar a3Pe f ma eBo di notoblgaeHa tor t e e isbondt t Ar a7 Cha Or r
e
ror nc nd d
i t rf d o xt nd t
o he e
nge de .
Asac e cli M a ahon s e t r c rf rHa to d' al gedbr ac ofc tac oft Ar a
ountr a m, r t
e ks o e ove o rf r s le
e h on r t he e

8

3 Pe f m a e Bo 6Bef et Cour now i Ha tor sM o i f Summ a y J
ror nc nd. or he
t
s rf d' ton or
r udgme on t
nt he

d caao yrle cam a d Hato d' a d M aaho sco smo insf rs mmayj d me to
e lr tr eif li n rf r s n rt n' r s to o u r u g n n
M aaho ' b e c of o ta t o n ecam.Maah n' M o f rS m. .DE #31 Ha tod' Mo.
rt n s r a h c n rc c u trli ( r to s .o u J,
; rfr s
f Sum. , /42)l t i e etofefiinc t Cour wilfrta es t Pa te agume s
or
J.DE / .n he ntr s
fce y,he
t l is ddr s he ris' r nt
wih r s c t Harf d' cl m f de a a or r ifa t r s uton oft tma trne s a iy
t e pe t o
tor s ai or clr t y ele s he e ol i
ha te ce s rl
a f c st s e sofM a ahon' br a h ofcon r c c e cai .
fe t ht ucc s
rt s e c
ta t ount r l m
A. c ar or Rei fCl i
De l at y le am

Hato ds e d caao yj d me to ()wh te teAra7Cha eOr e wa v i a
rf r e ks e lr tr u g n n i eh r h t
ng d r s od b
i iof rilg lya (i wh t r h b n is e b Ha t r icu i gb tn tl tdt b n
nt o le ai nd i ehe t e o d su d y rf d,n ld n u o i e o o d
i
t
)
o
mi
numbe 35BCSFH 61 af dsc r ef t Ar 7 Cha Or r ( #1 .I lg oft
r
27, for oveag or he ea
nge de . DE ) n iht he
undiput m ae ilf c son t r or whe he t Ar a7 Cha e Or ri voi a whehert
s ed tra a t
he ec d, t r he e
ng de s d nd
t he
Ar a3Pe f ma Bo e e t c ngeor er , pe ii alyt Ar 7Cha Or r a ebo h
e
ror nce nd xt nds o ha
d s s c fc l he ea
nge de , r t

q e to so 1w p o el s b te t t eCo rf rd tr n to a t s mmayj d me tsa e
u si n f a r p ry u mitd o h u to eemiain the u r u g n tg .
Se ge r l Fe nande v.
e ne al r
y
z Home t atMilrCov ,l .935So. 5 55 ( a. s. .
sar
le
e nc,
2d 47, 0 Fl DitCtApp.
2006)(dfac rc i una guous t c tu to oft c r tpr e saquesi oflw.)
si onta t s mbi
,he onsr cin he ontac esnt
ton a '.
'
OnisM otonf Summ a yJ m e , tor a guest tde piet l ngua of heAr a
t
i or
r udg nt Harf d r
ha s t he a
ge t
e

3Pe f ma eBond,tne rhada oblg to t bondt Ar a7 Cha Or erbe a et Ar a
ror nc
i ve
n iain o
he e
nge d
c us he e

7Prj d wa v i fo t tsat e M aaho fie t c mp ttv l bi t p ot t n e t e
oe s od r m h tr wh n rt n ald o o eiiey d he rj c u d r h
rlva saut .DE#42 .nrs ns M a ahona I rsaea g t tt pli lngua ofhe
ee nt tt es (
) I e po e, rt nd ntatt r ue ha he an a ge t

Ara3 P ro ma c Bo d,n c nt t nwihteic r rt du d ryn c nsr cinc nr c,
e ef r n e n i o jmci t h n o po ae n elig o tu to o ta t
o
6De pie M a at sa lga i t tI r sa ede a td ont underyi c tu ton
s t r hon' le tons ha nta t t f ule
he
l ng onsr c i
c r ct M a aho hasnotbr htabr ac ofc r c c os - l i a i tI r tt
onta , r t n
oug
e h onta t r sc am ga ns ntasa e.
9

r quie atndi byt sCou tha Ar a3 Pe f m a eBond a oma i ly e e t an a a1
e r s l ng hi
rt t e
ror nc
ut tcal xt nds o y nd 1
c ng or r wiho a r quie tofnotc t orc e on be fofHa tor . ( a s rp o
ha e de s t ut ny e r men
i e o ons nt
hal
rf d Trn cit f

He rn ,a 41 46)M aah n a d l ta tt f rh ra g eta t r to dd n tfi t wav
aig t - . rt o n nr sae u te r u h t s ah n i o al o i e
Ma
bi ng r quie nt r ltve t t Cha e Or rbe a e t l bora m a e i c t f t
ddi e r me s ea i o he
ng de c us he a
nd t ral oss or he
Cha Or rwor w a acon i ton ofa de i fom t c
nge de
k s
tnua i
nd rved r he ompeii ybi a a r d uni
ttvel d nd wa de
t

p ie o te b s c nrc. ( r to s Sae n o Un ip td Fa t,! 25 DE #5 a 4 .
rc s f h a e o ta t' Maah n' ttme t f ds u e cs
'
,
7, t )
S e iial, aah nc rceie teAr a3a dAra7Prjcsa S o siu n a ditreae
p cfc l M rt o haa trz s h e n e
y
oe t si n t e t n n erltd
c t
ee nso M aah n' sau oiyma d tdW a twae Tr ame t oe t'M aah n' Sae n
lme t f rt o s tt trl n ae se tr e t n Prj c. ( rto s ttme t
'
o Unc ne tdF cs ! 3 DE #5 a 5 .
f o tse a t, 0,
7, t )
i The Pl n L anguage oft Cont ac s
.
ai
he
r t

The Cour f t l
t ks ooks t t pl n lng ge of t Ar 3 Pe f r nce Bond a t
o he ai a ua
he ta
r o ma
nd he

u ryi c tuc i c r c t ds e mi wheherM a ahon' c e i t tt Ar a 3
nde l ng onsr ton onta t o t r ne
t
r t s ont nton- ha he e

p ro ma c b n a t maial a j tda do iae Hatodt b n a ya da1 ha g st tv
e fr n e o d u o tc l duse n bl td rfr o o d n n 1c n e o h
y
g
unde l ngco r c- i a c ae. Ar 3Pe f m a eBonda es esc ng ot unde l ng
ryi
nta t s c ur t The ea ror nc
ddr s ha est he
ryi
c tu ton co r c i t f l ngma r
onsr c i
nta t n he olowi
nne :
An c nge i orunde t Conta tDocume sandc pla eornonc
y ha s n
r he
rc
nt
om i nc
omplanc
i e
wih f maltes c
t or ii , onnece wiht Contac orwih t c nges do nota f c t
t d t he
r t
t he ha
,
fe t he
Sur t soblga i unde t sbond.Sur t he e wavesno i ofa ale aton or
e y' i ton
r hi
ey r by i
tce ny tr i
e e i n oftme madeb t Ciy.
xtnso
i
y he t

( ea3Pef ma eBo DE#35- . Ar 3Pero ma Bo as i om o atsbyr ee e
Ar
ror nc nd,
3)The ea
fr nce nd lo nc r t
efrnc
t unde l ng c tu ton co r d. Ari l 9 of t Gent a Co tons of t unde l ng
he
ryi onsr c i
nta
tce
he
r l ndii
he
ryi
consr c i c r c s t f t t conta t s c nge pr s ons Sec i 9. s a e :
t u ton ont a t e s or h he
r c ' ha
ovi i . ton 1 t t s

W ihoutnvalda i t Conta ta wihout tcet a s ey, TY m a a a
t i i tng he
r c nd t no i o ny ur t CI
y, t ny
tm ea fo tmet tme,o de a tons deeto , r vii i t W or by
i nd r m i o i
r r ddii , l i ns or e sons n he
k
10

a W rte Am e
it n
ndme or Chang Or r Upon r ept of a s doc e ,
nt
e de .
ec i
ny uch
um nt
CONTRACTOR s l pr
hal ompty pr e wih t W o k i ve whih wilbe
l oce d t he r nvol d
c
l

pef medundert a ia ec to oft Contac Doc nt (xc ptas
ror
he pplc bl ondiins he
r t ume s e e
ohe wies ci lypr vi d) A1 s hcha i t W ok s lbea horz d
t r s pe fcal o de . 1 uc nges n he r hal ut ie
b a Cha e Or r
y
ng de .

( d ry n Co tu to Conrc j9 1 DE # 5 2 a 2 ) S cin9. c niue :
Un e li g nsr cin ta t ., 3 - , t 2 . e to 5 o tn s
l notc ofa c ngeafeci t g r ls ope oft W or ort pr sonsof
f i e ny ha
f tng he ene a c
he
k he ovii

t eCo ta tDo u ns(ncu ig, u n tl td t Co ta tP ieo Co ta t
h n rc c me t i ldn b t o i e o, nrc rc r n rc
mi
Ti )i rquiedbyt pr so ofa Bondt begi nt as ey,t gi ng
me s e r
he oviins ny
o
ve o urt he vi
ofs
uchno i s l CONTRACTOR' s er s
tce halbe
S ol e ponsbiiy, a hea
i lt ndt mountof c
ea h

a pl a l b n s alb a j tda c r igy
p i be o d h l e duse c o dn l.
c
( ryi Consr tonContatj9. DE #35- a 22)(mphai a d)
Undel ng
tuci
r c 5,
2, t e
ss dde .
Sf lng gei t pe f r ncebond,co tue t t rwih t pur eoft bond,
i he a ua n he ro ma
nsr d ogehe t he pos
he
gove n as e y' oblga i und rt bond. Aut twnp ,I .Co. Tr elr Cas & Sur Ct.
r ur t s i tons e he
' o l rs ns
'
v. av e s .
. ),

2 7F. p 2 1 48 1 6 ( . Fl. 0 2 (ii fa kn, 9 So.da 1 7 . o r ve o t
2 Su p. d 2 , 2 5 M D. a 2 0 ) ct
ng r i 5 3 2 t 9 )Up n e iw fhe
pli l ng ge oft con r t ,t Cour fnds t tHa to d co e e t c nge ,i l ng
an a ua
he tacs he
ti
ha rf r ns nt d o ha s ncudi
( ddii ,dee i ,orr vi i i t W or ' a wel a Sc ng a f ng t ge a s opeof
' tons ltons
a
e sons n he
ks s l s çha e fedi he ner l c
'

teW ok. Th Co r rj cs h we e , a ah n' p o o iint tM aah nh dt eu i td
h r ' e u t ee t, o v r M rto s r p sto ha rt o a h nl e ,
'
mi
unia e a rg t c
lt r l iht o hanget prc a s o oft und l ng c r c .
he ie nd c pe he eryi onta t
Gi n t spr lm i r r i t Co tnow t nst Ha tor sa g e t tt Ar a 7
ve hi e i na y ulng, he ur
ur o rf d' r um nt ha he e

Cha Or r c tt e a ca di c nge t r le Ha tor of la lt ?Alhough Ha to d
nge de onsiutd
r nal ha
o e ive rf d
ibiiy. t
rf r
7Ha tor r s d t ca di c nge docrnea a afim a i de e et M a at s
rf d aie he r nal ha
ti s n fr tve f ns o r hon'

b e c o c n rc c u trli ( rfr sAfimaieDe . 6 DE # 2 a da g dte
ra h f o ta t o ne cam Ha t d' fr tv f ! , 2 ) n rue h
o
docrnebot i rs et M aahon' M otonf Pa ta SummayJ
ti
h n epons o rt s i or ril
r udgme ( #64,a 24)
nt DE
t
a a t Ocober1 2011he rng. n a ton,t Pa te e e i l a g t degr et
nd t he t
2,
a i I ddii he ri s xtnsvey r ued he
e o

wh c t eAra7Ch n eOr e wa o wa n t d patr fo teAr a3P o e ti c ne to
ih h e
a g d r s r s o a e ru e r m h e rj c n o tx f
t a ia lt ofFl i ' c
he pplc biiy
orda s ompe ii - ddi saut Se AT&T Co
ttve bi ng t t e. e
mmc', I v W it l
n nc. . le ,

I . 1F.d 1 ,1 ( d. r 1 (e nii t i er ai bewe nt r ltve
ncs 3 201 205 Fe Ci. 993) rcog zng he ntrelton t e he eai
a i biiyoft cadi c
pplca lt he r nal hangedocrnea c
ti nd ompeii - ddi sauts.Ac or ngy,t
ttvebi ng tt e ) c di l he
Co tfndst is ofwhehe t Ar a7 Cha ge Or rquaii asa c r nalc
ur i he s ue
t r he e
n
de
lfes
a di hanget
o
r ive Ha to d ofisoblg tont bond t Ar a 7 Cha Or ri rpef r i
ele
rf r
t iai o
he e
nge de s i or ulng.
11

c e e t cha or r t oug t c
ons ntd o nge de s hr h he hangepr sonsoft unde l ng c tu ton c r c ,
ovii
he
ryi onsr c i onta t

i t naur andmagniudeoft c ngeor ri f rbe
f he t e
t
he ha
de s a yondwha t pa tesa ii t d whe t y
t he ri ntcpa e
n he
e e e i o t c r c ,i ma ne rhees quaiy asa c di lc nge t r le Ha tor of
nt r d nt he onta t t y ve t l s lf
ar na ha
o ei ve rf d
la lt Puruan t t c di lc ng doc rne t r s utonofwheherHa tor wa oblga e
i biiy. s t o he ar na ha e ti , he e ol i
t
rf d s i t d

t bondt pa tc a ea7Cha Or rt nso t e e t whiht undiput dma e i l a t
o
he riul rAr
nge de ur n he xt nt o c he
s e t ra f c s
i c t t tt Ar 7 Cha Or rwasa sgnii a e
ndia e ha he ea
nge de
i fc nt nough de a i fom t s ope oft
viton r he c
he
unde li consnlton c r c t r ive Ha tor ofisla lt und t pe f m a ebond.
ry ng
t c i onta t o ele
rf d t ibiiy er he ror nc
i.TheCar nalChangeDoc r neAsa De e et Sur t Li lt
i
di
ti
f ns o
e y abiiy

Fr t t oft Ni t en h Ce ur t pr s ntda t 1w r ga di how ac ngei
om he um
he nee t nt y o e e
y, he a e r ng
ha
n
t undery ngc r c a f ct as e y' oblgai a la ltesha dr tc ly e ved. l 1953,
he
li onta t fe s ur t s i tons nd ibiii s asia l vol
n

teFlrd S p e Co rrj ce h ln sa dngv e h t n c a et teu d ryngc n rc,
h o ia u rme u tee tdt e o g tn i iwt a a y h ng o h n eli o ta t
no m at r how mi r o s mi y i i nii nt r i d t slet of a 1 la lt o t
te
no r ee ngl nsg fca , eleve he tr y
1 ibiiy n he

p ro ma c bo dr g r ls o a ys o n o p eu iet tes rt Gi b v Ha lo dAc .t
e fr n e n e ade s f n h wi g f rj d c o h u ey. b s . rf r c t

l d m.Co,6 S 2 5 9,6 4 ( 1 .1 5 )(e e sng s mmayj d me twh r ds ue fcs
ne
. 2 o.d 9 0 F a 9 3 rv ri u r u g n ee ip td a t
e itda t t ee tn o ij r ,fa y, u fr dbys ey ; e as De .Co p. fAm. ,Un td
x se s o h x e t f nu y i n s fee
urt ) s e lo v r o
v ie
Bondi I .Co.41 F. 823,826(t Ci.1 (dti t r ei Fl i t tade rur fom
ng ns , 3 2d
5h r 969) çi s he ul n orda ha pa t e r

ac n tu to c nrc wi n ta tmaial r l vea d e o e aea s rt ) Ba i As al d
o sr cin o ta t l o u o t ly ei n x n rt u ef'; sc ph t r
l
c
e
Co s.Co p.v Pa l n I s Co,5 F.d 70 7 3 (t Ci.1 7 )8I se d t e F o ia
n t r . ri t n . . 31 2 2, 0 5h r 9 6 . n ta , h l rd
ame
Sup e Co t xpr sya e t viw t t ober ive ofla lt onape f m a ebond,t
r me ur e es l dopt d he e ha t
ele d i biiy
ror nc
he

s rt mus s o t ee itnc o amaeil h n et a c usd ij r o p eu iet tesley.
u ey t h w h xse e f tra c a g h t a e nu y r rj d c o h t t
r
Gi s, 2 So. a 604. c fc l t Fl i Supr meCour he dt tt ha i t de rur f o
bb 6
2d t
Spe iialy, he orda
e
t l ha s t f he pa t e r m
t
8Bonne v.
r

Ci o ih r Al.6 F.d 1 6( 1hCi. 981 ( ligFit Cic i
t fprc a 4 a, 61 2 20 1 t r 1 ) hodn fh rut
y
opi onsprort Oc. 1 1ar bi ngpr e nti t Elve hCic t.
ni
i o t2, 98 e ndi ec de n he e nt rui)
1
2

Gi ss So. at
bb 62 2d 604. cii ly,t Fl i Supr m eCo t dt tçha i t de rur fom
Spe fca l he orda
e
ur hel ha d t f he pa t e r
t

te c n tu to c n rc r s lsi ij r t t s rt te i of co s c d p rtr mus b
h o sr cin o ta t e u t n nu y o he u ey h n ps a t u h e a t e t e
z
c a sse a ma e i butt sley s d be r i d a dic r d onl t t e e oft
l s i d s t ral
he tr t houl
eleve nd s ha ge
y o he xt nt he

ij r . 1 .
nu y' d
'
Si et 1 Gi opi on,he ea esrki l f w ca e fom t Fl i sat c t or
nc he 953 bbs ni t r r ti ngy e s s r he orda t e ours

t El nt Cic tt ta yz t e fcta c nge t t unde l ng c r ctha on a s r t s
he eve h r ui ha nal e he fe
ha
o he
ryi onta
s
u ey'
la lt N o a y,whie af w c essa f t pr ii t am a e i c ngem a r i a
ibiiy. t bl
l e as tnd or he oposton hat
t ral ha
y eleve
s ey ofisla lt noneoft ca e add e st f cuals e ro oft i t ntca ewhe e y t
ur t
t i biiy,
he s s r s he a t c na i
he nsa
s
r b he
s r t b ispe f m a ebond co r c ,c e t t c nge t t unde l ng c r c . To t t
u ey, y t ror nc
nta t ons n ed o ha s o he
ryi onta t
ha

e Ha tor die t Co tsat n i t t ca di c ng docrnt.
nd, rf d r ds he ur ' te ton o he r nal ha e ti
I taly,t c r na cha doc rnewasco eved i t Unied St t sCour ofFe r
nii l he a di l nge ti
nc i n he t
ae
t
de al
Cl ms.Se ge r l . Li Bui r, nc v Unie ats 26ClCt 1 55, 17 ( . .992)
ai g e ne al
yAm ne l s I . . tdst e ,
de
. . 1 1 7 C1Ct1

( ovi nghit ia ba kg ot ofhedocrnal vel
pr di sorc l c r md t
ti de opmen oft cadi c
t he r nal hangedocrne .
ti ) The
docrneS sc e t a ac c ont go r ntsa lt t c r umvent hecompe ii - ddi
ti t
wa r aed s he k he ve nme ' biiy o ic
t
ttve bi ng
pr e sb o derng dr tccha sbe
oc s y r i
asi
nge yond t e c e plt d i t c r c ....'0JA. Jones
hos ontm a e n he onta t
'1

Co s. . . e r rMc v r Bo i,n .8 P.d1 0 , 0 0( v 2 0 )s ealoL. Co tc
n tCo v f h e Go e n vsI c, 9 3 0 9 1 2 Ne . 0 4 ;e s K. mso k
d Co,I c v Be o Co s. .I c, 3 F. u p. 0 , 3 ( D. .1 9 )(s epo ro te
: . n . . c n n tCo, n .9 2 S p 9 6 9 7 E. Ky 9 3 ç
Th we f h
o e,b i a fd r la e c o aprv t d v lp r t o d rc a g si s b e tt a us .) A
wn r e t e ea g n y r iae e eo e , o r e h n e s u j c o b e'.
'
9The Unie St esCour ofFe r Cl m swa f me l known ast Unied St t
t d at
t
de al ai
s or ry
he t
aes
Cl m s Cou t
ai
r.
1 Li t Fe r M ilrAc , Fl i ' LiteM ilrAc r quiest tpublc c t c i
0 ke he de al le t orda s tl le t e r ha
i onsnz ton

p oe t b s b e t oc mp tt bd ig. A. AT j2 52 ( 0 9 . ePa te d s u e
rj cs e u j c t o eive idn FL ST . 5 .0 2 0 ) Th ris ip t
i
wh te t Ar a7P oe twa c mp ttv l bd.J itPrtilS i, # 6 . eCo r d e
eh r he e rj c s o ei ey i (on era tp DE 7 ) Th u t o s
i
notr ac Harf d' cl m t tM a a honvi a e t c
e h tor s ai ha r t
olt d he ompeii bi ng saut s
ttve ddi t t e .
1
3

s e sulc r nalcha docrne dee e s ve t rle a co rcor (nd is s ey)of
ucc sf adi
nge ti
fns er s o eive
nta t a t urt
pero ma e la lt whe a go r nte iy or r a c ng t t unde l ng co tucto
f r nc i biiy
n
ve nme ntt de s ha e o he
ryi
nsr i n
c r ctt tle f c i l r r t c r c o t peror dute m aeraly dif r ntfom t e
onta ha tfe tvey equies he onta t r o f m i s t i l fe e r hos

org nal r ne f ï'x le at ral dr p.Co. Unie at s 569F. 56 563 4,
i i lyba gai d ' . jlidM e i s Equi
o '
v. tdst e ,
2d 2, -6 215

Ct C1 406( . .1 )
. . Ct C1 978 .
Alhough t r i no ca elw i Flrda on t ca di lc nge docti ,ma sa e a
t
he e s
s a n oi
he r na ha
rne ny t t nd

f de alc t t o ho t nai ac e t docrne asava i d e e i t c e ofbot
e r ours hr ug ut he ton c pt he ti
ld ef ns n he ont xt
h
publca prvaec tuc i c tacs Seegene al L. Comsoc ( Co.I ., 932 F.
i nd i t onsr ton on r t .
r l K.
y
t k : , nc
Supp. t
a

9 7( r vdnga a c u tn o t ea o to o t c r ia c a ed crn i saea fd r l
3 p o ii n c o ni g f h d p in f he a dn l h ng o tie n tt nd e ea
c u t ao n t e c u ty .ll a dto o rs h ve a k o e g d s e i al a s rt '
o rs r u d h o nr ll n d iin,c u t a c n wld e p cfc ly u eys
pr r tvet r ie t c r nalc ng doc rneasadef ns t bondi acontac t thasbee
e oga i o a s he a di ha e ti
e eo
ng
r t ha
n
ma e i l at r by t owne a t c r cor Se ,eg. Unîe St e e r l Sun Cons.Co.
t raly le ed he
r nd he onta t . e . , td ats x e .
t ,
I .v To i Gen Contact s LLC,Ca eNo. c 01 LTB- J ,
nc . rx
.
r or ,
s
07- v- 355M W 2009 W L 33 287, *3
48
at

( Co o Oc.1 , 0 9 g een fe i 'nCo s.C&' ; nr T c . rfn r Cop. 1 0B.
D. l . t 5 2 0 ) h ri atr iu n t .) I e e h Fo er r , 4 R.
u
b
'
21 217( nkr E. Te 1 ;UniedSt e v Se ar Sur Co. 622 F.Supp.882,887
4,
Ba . D. nn. 992) t ats . abo d . ,
( D. Y.l lAc or ngy,nt a e eof ybi ngprc nt s vowi hedocrneshi
E. N. g8s . c di l i he bs nc an ndi e ede dia ngt
ti t s
Co t i t anaytc lfa e kesa ihedb t sgr wi bod ofpe s i ca ea on t
ur fnds he l i a r m wor t bls
y hi o ng y
r uasve s lw
he

1 See eg, l Co s.I c v 1 t ( Vn Auh,1 7 SW .d 6 9( o. . p. 0 )
1 , ..Gil n t n . . 8 h f ie t. 5 . 3 9 M Ct Ap 20 4
,

(e nii cadi lc ngedocrneunde M is ilw) JA. sCo t Co.v fe e
rcog zng r na ha
ti
r sour a ; Jone ns.
. hr r
McGovenBovi,I .89P. 1 ( v.200 ( ptngcadi c
r
s nc, 3d 009 Ne
4) ado i r nal hangedocrnei Ne )
ti n vada ;
He e PhelsCon t Co.v Kig C?l ,5 W ah.
ns l p
s. . n 7 7 s App.170,787P. 58( a h.CtApp.1
y.
2d W s .
990)
(c no e gn c r i a c a g d crn i W a hn tn ; sn Auh./C/Po e a k n v
a k wld ig ad n l h n e o tie n s ig o ) Hou ig t J / fT x r a a .
.
f.IIJo onCon .Co.264Ar 523,573S. . 31 ( k.1 )( mitngpaole de e
' hns
I
st ,
k.
W 2d 6 Ar 978 per ti r vi nc
t pr c r na c ng i Ar ns s.
o ove adi l ha e n ka a )
14

c r ia c a ed crn t bea p ia et teisa tmatr s b e tt afn i go p eu iet
adn l h ng o ti e o p lc bl o h n tn te , u j c o id n f rj d c o
t s ey. e Gi s,6 So. a 604.
he ur t Se bb 2 2d t
To de e mi whe he a c nge or r i o sde t ge r s ope of t unde l ng
t r ne
t r ha
de s ut i he ne al c
he
ryi
c tuci n con r c s a t qua iy a a c r nalc ng c t l t t f lwi f cor :
onsr to
ta t o s o lf s a di ha e, ours ook o he olo ng a t s

() eh rt r i asg i n c a g i t ema nt eo wo kt b p ro d;
iwh t e hee s in t t h n e n h g i
ka
ud f r o e e fnne
(i wheh r h c a g i d sg e t p o u eattlydfee tie o d a tc ly
i
) te t e h n e s e in d o r c r o al ifrn tm r rsial
at t qua iy,c r ce ,naur o t ofwor co e a e by t o i na
ler he lt ha a tr t e r ype
k nt mplt d
he rgi l

c nrc; n (i wh t e t c s o t ewo kodee g e tye c e steo i ia
o ta t a d i) eh r he o t f h r r rd r al x e d h rgn l
i
cont actcos .
r
t

Be h ,I c v Un td Sa e , 7 F d. . 9 ,6 ( d Cl 2 0 ) A c u'mus c n u tafcc o n . . ie tts 4 e C1 5 5 01 Fe . . 0 0 . o l t o d c a t
t
i e i , as by- as a l i oft a or m e tone f c or . e, . ,d Thec elw i cla t t
ntnsve c e- c e nayss he f e n i d a t s Se eg. i
as a s e r ha
lff c quesi e s a t whe he t modii a i i quesi wasa c di lc nge,pa ta
s at
i
tons xit s o
t r he
fc ton n
ton
ar na ha
ril

s mmayj d me two l n tle'Se , . ,d ; e as PCL Co s. r .I c v UntdSa e ,
u r u g n ud o i. e eg.i s e lo
'
n tSe v, n . . ie tts
47 Fe Cl 745,80 ( d.Cl 2000)( di t tt mo ng pa t S tpr fcswih
d. .
4 Fe
.
hol ng ha he vi ry f
mus ove a t t
s ii t t ts ppo tt algainst t c r nal hangeoc ure ). acoolay,fnortona
pecfciy ha u r is le to ha a adi c
c r d' As r lr i ai l
f c-i r u c i r tonoft u s e f t, oul fnd t tt c ngewa notac r na
a tfnde , pon onsde a i
he ndiput d acs c d i ha he ha
s
a di l

c a g ,h ns mmayj d me ti a p o rae Se Mas s i Elc I du . .4 5U. a 5 7
h n e te u r u g n s p r p it. e tu ht e . n s Co, 7 S. t 8 .
a
W ih r ar t t fr tf cor s t rt r i a sg fca cha i t mag t of
t eg d o he is a t - ç he he e s inii nt nge n he
whe
niude
wor t be pe f m e '-ot r c t ha hed t t c
k o
ror d' he ours ve l ha hang ,s h as t col oft wa l,
es uc
he or he ls

doorr modi a i ,a t l rng ofc ii ,di no c tt eaca di lc ngewhe e
fame
fc tons nd he owe i
e lngs d t onsiut
r na ha
r

fh c mpltdp oe t s o s b tn ilydfee tr m t a c n e ae i h o ii l o ta t
s e o ee rj c wa n t u sa tal ifrn fo h t o tmpltd nt e rgna c nr c
t
plns'Se teg. Wu rih Contacig Co.v Unie St e ,351F. 956,966( .C1 1965
a . e . , nde lc
'
r tn
. td ats
2d
Ct . )
(i ng no c r na c ng des t 35 c nge or r) l a ton,a fdealdititc ti
fndi
adi l ha e pie
ha
des. n ddii
e r src our n

Co oa od n e s mmay u g n i lg o u r s le is e o fc c nc r i wheh r t lr d e id u r j d me t n iht f n e ov d su s f a t o enng te a wo
15

ye rdelya $1, 000i i r s dc t quaii dasdsgnik a cha s' r t c r t
a a nd 000, n nc ea e oss lfe ti t nt nge 'whe e he ontacor
l l t s met lt y org na l we e hie t buid, a i es e i ly t s me mn ra
t t he a unne he i i ly r r d o l nd n s ntal he a
bui
nne nd
l a i 'Sun Cons.Co.2009 W L 3348287,a *
oc ton.
'
t ,
t 4.

The i t ntc e i difr fo t a or m e i
nsa as s fe ent r m he f e ntoned be a e, he e t undiput d f t
c us r , he
s e acs
r a t tt Ar a 7 Cha Or roblgaed l r sa et buid ta he team e plnt'bas d
eve l ha he e
nge de i t nta t t o l 'not r r t nt a s ' e

on s paaeplnsa s ct tons 5. mie a y.Ar 7 Cha Or ,DE #35- Thoma
e rt a nd pe ikai , 5 ls wa ( ea
nge der
4;
s

De ,t :-1 , 0:8 5 413 , 4 1 - 7 DE# 9 1. i wa no ac a eo d rh t r l
p.a 217 6 4 1 -2 , :-5 4 :9 45:, 3 - )Ths s t h ng r e ta meey
e e d orat r d t s c fcai ,tm e i ,orcos oft o i nalteam e plnt t swa a
xt nde
le e he pe ii tons i lne
t he rgi r t nt a
hi s
c ngeo de t tor r dt buid ng o as co te t e pl nt Gi t undiput d f c s t
ha
r r ha de e he l i f e nd r am nt a . ven he
s e a t , he

Cour fnds asam at rofl t tt Ar 7 Cha Or rs ts st frtf c or
ti ,
te
aw,ha he ea
nge de aise he is a t .
The s c f t a kswhe he t c nge wasG nt mplt d by t orgi lco r c .'
e ond acor s
t r he ha
d e ae
co
he i na nta t'
Bec 47 Fe C1 a 6 .M a ahon a g t tdes t t dif r nce i l a i oft s pa a e
ho,
d. . t 01 r t
r ues ha
pie he fe e
n oc ton he e r t

te t n pln st eAra7Ch n eOr e wa n t u h rzn as p rt p oe tu e t ec nrc
rame t a t,h e
a g d r s o a t o iig e aae rj c nd r h o ta t
be aus t pl n lng geoft unde l ng c tu ton con r c c e a e c
c e he ai a ua
he
ryi onsr c i
ta t ont mplt d hange a t t
s nd ha

teAra3Prj c a dAr a7P o e t r itreae b c us t ywe eb t p r o Ma ah n'
h e o e t n e rj c wee nerltd e a e he r oh a t f rto s
lr e AW TSpln.M aah n' S ae n o Un ip tdF cs!3 DE #5 , t5 .Th Co r h s
ag r
a ( rto s tt me t f d s u e a t 0,
7a ) e uta
ar d f
lea y ound, pr Pa t I. .,ha heunde l ngco tuci ncon r c doesc e aecha s
su a r IIA it tt
ryi
nsr to
ta t
ontmplt nge .
Ye ,M art sar um e ,t ke t isl c le r m e woul pe m i M a ahon t is c ng
t
ahon' g nt a n o t ogi a xte ,
d r t rt
o s ue ha e
or e st i udet e tr t oft s ve AW TS s r i e a e und t Ar 3 Conta ta i
d r o ncl he n ie y he e n
e v c r as er he ea
r c nd, n
t n,o i t Ha tor t bond a tona m ilonsofdola swihoutc
ur blga e rf d o
ddii l li
lr t
onduc i a as es me of
tng n s s nt

rs Th Co r fn t ef c ta t Ar a3Prj c a dt Ar a7Prj c we eb t p r o a
ik. e u t ids h a t h t he e
o e t n he e
oe t r oh a t f n
e nsveove ha oft wa e te t e s t m i Ciy ofM a aho t bei uf i nt sa ng
xpa i
r ul he t r r am nt yse n t
r t n o ns fc e , t ndi
1
6

ao e t p o et a t ea dto o t eAra7Prj c (ra yo teoh rsv nte t n ae s wa
ln ,o r v h th d iin f h e oe to n fh te e e r ame t ra ) s
c e plt d a t tme M a at n,I r sae,a Ha tor e c e t consr ton a bond
ontm a e t he i
r ho nta t t nd rf d xe ut d he
tuci nd

c nrcsfrt eAr a3Prj c.
o ta t o h e
oe t
Thet r f c orconc r t e e t whih t c nge i r s st cos oft bonded
hid a t
e ns he xt nt o
c he ha
nc ea e he t he

p oe tBe h 4 F d. . t6 . v nt ewiern eo c nr c p ie , o rstp c lya ay e
rj c. c o, 7 e Cla 01 Gie h d a g f o ta t rc s c u t y ial n lz
t sf c o i t r ofpe ce a ofc ti r s Fori tnce i r as i c tofl st n 1
hi a t r n e ms
r nt ge os nc ea e.
nsa , nc e es n os es ha 00
pe c nt e no t ti rt c r na c ng docrne, l i r s i c tove 1 pe c ntdo.
r e t nd t o rgge he a di l ha e ti whie nc ea es n os
r 00 r e

Compar Wunde lc Contacig Co,351 F. a 966 (i ng 6% i ras i c t di not
e
rih
r tn .
2d t
fndi
nce e n oss d

c n ttt c r i l h n e, t Pee KiwiS n ' . . mmi Co s.Co , 2 F.d2 2 25
o si e adna c a g ) wi tr e t o s Co v Su t n t .42 2 4 , 5
u
h
(t Ci.1 )( di t e ol c ng i c r c prc fom $600, t $2, 000c tt e
8h r 969 hol ng href d ha e n onta t ie,r
000 o 000, onsiutd
cha outi t s peoft c rc) l t i tntc s ,t orgi lc rc prc wasf
nge sde he co
he onta t. n he nsa a e he i na onta t ie
or
$ 061, 00.( e 3Consr ton Co rc,DE #35 1) TheAr 7 Cha Or rc mea a
2, 000. Ara
tuci
nta t
- .
ea
nge de n t n
addii l os of$2, 487. % i r s of r1 pere ofheorgi l onta ts ( e
tona c t
984, 00- ncea e ove 44 c nt t i na c r c um.Ara

7 Ch n eOr e , # 54 .Th r fr , h Co r fn sta te u ds ue fcss o t tte
a g d r DE 3 -) eeo e t e u t i d h t h n ip td a t h w ha h
c a g k ral e c e e )h o iia c nr c c s's a t s tsyt t r fco . c o 4 F d.
h n e ' e ty x e dld te rgn l o ta t o t'o s o aif he hid a t rBe h , 7 e
g
Cl a 601.
.t

Upo ca e ulc i r ton oft undiput d f ct i t c extoft c r na cha
n r f onsde a i
he
s e a s n he ont
he a di l nge
docrne f c or ,t Cour fnds t t t Ar 7 Cha
ti a t s he
ti
ha he ea
nge Or r wa a c r na c nge t t
de
s a di l ha
o he
unde l ng c tuc i co r c .TheCour f t rfndst tt undiput d f c so t r c d
ryi onsr ton nta t
t urhe i ha he
s e a t n he e or

d mo taeasg i c n , n p tn il un u de ,n r a ei rs s a t prj d c a dij r
e nsrt in t a t a d oe tal bo n d ice s n ik o s o eu ie n n u e
i
y
H a tor Gi ,6 So. a 60 Acc di l t Cour f ndst tpur ua t t ca di c nge
rf d. bbs 2 2d t 4. or ng y, he
t i ha
s nt o he r nal ha

docrneand t sa r s tf rh by t Fl i Su e Cour i Gi bst tHa tor wa no
ti
he t nda d e o t
he orda pr me
t n b ha rf d s t
17

o i t dt bondt Ar 7 Cha Or r Theeo e s mmayj d me t nt sd caao yr le
blga e o
he ea
nge de .
rf r, u r u g n o hi e lrtr eif

i s mus beg a e i f vo ofHa tor TheCour no t nst t c os m o i nsonM a a hon'
s ut t r nt d n a r
rf d.
t w ur o he r s to
rt s
br a ofc ta tc e cai .
e ch on r c ount r l m
B.M ar hon' B r ac ofC ont ac C ount c ai
at
s e h
r t
er l m

Pur ua t isbx c o co r c c e ca m , a a hons e dama sf isl s ont
s nt o t ea h f nta t ountr li M r t
e ks
ge or t os es he

c s o c mp ei no teAra3P o e t fe M aah ntr n tdl ta tt .l e rn a p 3 1 o t f o lto f h e rj c a tr rt o emiae nr sae E- aig t . 2: 1
l

1 .Ha t r a dM a ah nh v tldco smoi n f rs mmayj g n o M aaho ' b e c
4) rf d n rt o a e le r s to s o u r ud me t n rt n s ra h
o
o c n rc c unecam. rto a va e fu ag me t i s p o t fi moi n:i Hato d
f o ta t o tr li Ma ah n d nc s o r ru n s n u p r o t to ( rfr
s
)
al edl c e dt tii boundbyt Ar 3Pero ma Bond;i)Ha to dc e e t bo
leg y onc de ha t s
he ea fr nce
(i rf r ons ntd o nd

t tAr a7Ch ng Or e v aisatr e -n fd;ii Hato dwa a t maial b u dt b n te
h e
a e d r i t to n yi -a (i) rf r s u o tc ly o n o o d h
Ar a7 Cha e Or ra br c d t e si pe f r a ebo when i at ed t ne it
e
ng de nd ea he ht xitng r o m nc nd
t tempt o gotae
and e c ea Ta ove Ag ee ntasoppos dt pe f r i undert orgi condii oft
xe ut
ke r r me
e o r o m ng
he i nal
tons he

bond; nd(v)Hator i la eont pef ma ebondbe us l rsaebrac dt undel ng
a i rf d s ibl he ror nc
ca e ntatt e he he ryi
co tuci con r c whe i f l d t s cze a tonalbondi f t Ar a 7 Cha Or r
nsr ton ta t
n t aie o e lr ddii
ng or he e
nge de

p ru n t teNoiet P o e d ( #31 a 1 ; # 3 a 4 ) I isd fns , rf r a g e
u s a t o h tc o r c e .DE , t 3 DE 7 , t -5 .n t ee e Ha tod r u s
t ti wa M a aho who de a t d ont unde l ngco tuci co r c a notl tasae.
ha t s r t n
f ule
he
ryi
nsr ton nta t nd
n r t t The
c ux of Ha tor s de e e i t t Ha tor was r l s d fom is oblgai on t Ar a 3
r
rf d' f ns s ha
rf d
eea e r
t
i tons
he e
Pero m a eBond whe M ar t de a t by i ope l t r nai I r t t fom t Ar a3
f r nc
n
ahon f uled mpr ry e mi tng ntasae r he e

P oe t a e u nHato d' r f a t b n t eAr a7Ch n eOr e .DE#6 a 1 ) Th Co r
rj c b s d po rf r s eus lo o d h e
a g d r(
4, t 9 . e u t
wila r se h o t Pa tes a gume si t n.
l dd es ac f he ri ' r
nt n ur
W ih r ga d t M a a ho s fr ta gum e ,t Cour i unwilng t fnd t tHa tor
t e r o r t n' is r
nt he
ts
li o i ha rf d

c nc d disla l yo telse o teAr a3P o e tb sai t a Hm f r n ve d sv we
o e e t ibit n h o s s f h e rj c y tt h t o d e r ia o d
i
ng
1
8

t eAr 3Bond. Cour tndst ti f t a eofisa g ntM a ahon i operyr leson
h ea
The
ti ha n urher nc
t r ume
rt
mpr l e i
i dmisbl e de ofprors tlm e ne ito , i die tc r ve i ofRul 408oft
na s i e vi nce
i ete nt gotai ns n r c onta nton
e
he

Fed a RulsofEvi nc Ass h,heCo t se r t sa e e si f t r nc ofs tl men
er l e
de e. uc t
ur dir ga ds he tt m nt n urhe a e e te t
ne tatonsa a a gmnen t t ei st r n. t r t Cour i notpe s
go i i nd ny r
t ha r le he eo Furhe , he
ts
r uade bywha i l 4
d
t s ef
ofM a ahon' a gume asi n
rt s r
nt t mount t not ngm or t n a exe c s i s m a is. ( # 3, t
s o hi
e ha n r ie n e ntc DE 7 a

3- ) The1w i cla t tapa t sa knowl gme oft valdiyofac rcti t frtse t
.4 . a s e r ha ry' c
ed nt he i t
onta s he is tp o
alegngisbr c See e. , c . a ar ee ( Co.LLC,1 F. 91 91 ( 1hCi.1 )
l i t ea h. , g.Be kv L z dFr rs f ,
75 3d 3, 4 1 t r 999

(ç ee nt ofabr c ofc tac a tonae( )avai c ntac;( amaeil e c a ()
(The lme s
ea h onr t ci x 1 ld o r t 2) tra br a h; nd 3
da ge .'. rf e i i pef tyl ii t a e ce t tHatodwoul smula
ma s' Theeor ,t s recl egtmae, nd xpe td,ha rf r
)
d i tneousy
l
afi m t va i t oft Ar 3 Pe f ma eBond a al gea fr tve de e es i l ngt
tr he ldiy he ea
ror nc
nd le f ma i
f ns , ncudi he
ca di lc ngedocrneand br a h on be l ofM a ahon.
r na ha
ti
ec
haf
rt
M a aho sne a g n st tla tor e es l c e edt e e ape f m a ebond
r t n' xt r ume ti ha l rf d xpr sy ons nt o xt nd ror nc
f t Ar a 7 Cha Or .Pur ua t Fl i saut ,t physc lbond doc e f t
or he e
nge der
s nt o orda t t e he
ia
um nt or he

c nsr cino apu i b idn musb d lv rdt tepu lco e a dte o dgd i t ep b i
o tu to f blc ul ig t e eiee o h bi wn r n t c r e ln h u lc
r
rc r so t ec u t wh r tei r v me ti l ae . F A. T j25 .5 1()( 0 7 . e
e od f h o ny ee h mp o e n s oc td' L S AT. 50 ( )a 2 0 ) Th
'
b n mu tas p o d $ d s rp in o te p oe ts fiin t ie tf i,s c a a lg l
o d s lo r vie $ e cito f h rj c u fce t o d n iy t u h s e a
a
de c i i ort sr ta es oft pr perybengi ove 'I He e,heonl e de eont
s rpton he tee ddr s he o t i mpr d. d r t
'
y vi nc
he

r c d ofHarf d' c e t bondi t Ar 7 Cha Or ri t M a 1 201 lte fom
e or
tor s ons nt o
ng he ea
nge de s he y 4, 0 et r r

S. Hume hik.M a 1 201 Hume hikLeter DE #355) Uponat oughr e oft
P.
nc c ( y 4, 0
nc c t ,
- .
hor
eviw he
r c d,he ei noe de et taphysc bonddoc e f t Ar a7Cha Or re rexit
e or t r s vi nc ha
ial
um nt or he e
nge de ve sed
o t ta bond was r c ded i a or nc w ih Fl i s a ut .I lghtoft r l ntFl i
r ha ny
e or
n cc da e t or da t t e n i
he e eva
orda

19

saut t Cour snds a a m at r of lm t t t M a 1 201 lter sa ng al , i
t t e, he
t
, s
te
a ha he y 4, 0 e t , t ndi
one s
i ufk intt bi Ha to dt bond t Ar 7 Cha Or r
ns f e o nd rf r o
he ea
nge de .
M a ahon' r m ani a gume st n o whdherM a ahon pr ryt nui t d I r t t
r t s e i ng r
nt ur n
rt
ope l e na e ntasae

fo t Ar a 3 Prj c.To d cd te e is e ,t Co r mu tfrtl o t t e d futa d
r m he e
oet
e ie h s su s he u t s is o k o h e a l n
t r nai n pr so o t unde l ngconsm ci n c nta t
e mi to ovii ns f he
ryi
t to o r c .
Pur ua t t co t ci n c r t M a a honco dtr i t l r sa ef ca ef Sa y
s nt o he nsm to ontac , r t
ul e m nae nta t t or us or sn
m ae i lbr ac orf rde a tunde t t r sa s i d, a w ela i l tasae
t ra t h o f ul
r he e m s pecse ' s l s f n r tt
'

fild t c mme c t eW ok i a c r a c wihtep o iinso t i Co ta t
ale q o o n e h r n c od n e t h r vso f hs nr c,
fild t p rom t eW o ko po t n t ee fo c mp ei nt ee fi adlg n ,
ale q o ef r h r r ri s h r o t o lto h ro n i e t
o
i
e fce , r nlke, kilul nd c r ul a ra i src ac or nc wih t
fi int wo kma i s lf a a ef m nne nd n tit c da e t he

p o iins fheCo ta t c me t,ale j ou ea a e u t q a t yo q ai
r vso o t nr c Do u ns fild t s n d q ae u ni r u ly
t
t
ofpe s
r onne , ui
leq pmen , ma e ilt c
t or t ra o omplt t W or wihi t Co r c Ti e,
ee he
k t n he nta t m

fild t pef r a yo i o lg to s n rh Co ta t c me t, ea j d e
ale ) o ro m n ft b iai n u de te nrc Do u ns b du g d
s
b n r p . . r ale t ma ep o t a me t t isS bc nr co s maeil n
n k u t . o fild)o k r mp p y n s o t u o ta tr, trame
orl bor r ....
a es

( d ryn Co sr to Co ta t! 1 1 . DE # 5 2 a 3 -3 )Up nMa ah n' tr n to
Un e lig n tuci n n rc, 4.62, 3 - , t 2 3 . o rto s emiain
of I r tt f ca e
ntasae or us ,Harf d dhal t ove a pef m t s Co r t' ( ryi
tor d l ake r nd ror hi ntac. Undel ng
s
'

Co sr cin Co ta t ! 1 1 . 1 DE # 5 2 a 3 ) Th u d ryn c n t cin c nrc as
n tu to n r c, 4.62.,
3 - , t 3 . e n e lig o sm to o ta t lo
pr dest t
ovi ha

(q a trtr n to o t i Co ta t n e t i S cin (4.62 ,ti d tr n d
if fe emiain f hs nr c u d r hs e to 1 1 .1 i s eemie
t a (nr sae wa n tnd fut r h t u fce t a s t tr naeu d rS cin
h t I ta tt ) s o i e a lo t a s fiin c u e o emi t n e e to
1 1 2 di notexit t rg sa oblga i oft pa te s l bet s m ea i
4. 6. d
s, he i ht nd i tons he ri s ha l he a
sf
t t r i ton ha be n is d f t c
he e m nai
d e s ue or he onve e e oft CI unde Sec i
ninc
he TY
r ton
1 . 6. ....
41 1

( d ry n Co tu to Co ta t! 1 1 . 2 DE # 5 2 a 3 ) Un e t pr v so o s cin
Un e li g nsr cin n rc, 4.62., 3 - , t 3 . d r he o iins f e to
1 1 1,t r i ton wihoutc us ,I r s a e c d c l c pa e f t w o k c pl t d,but
4. 6. e m na i
t
a e nt a t t oul ole t ym nt or he r om e e

20

Ha to d' la lt ast s ey,woul no be ti r d. (
rf r s ibiiy, he ur t
d t rgge e Undel ng Consr ci Conta t !
ryi
tu ton
r c,

1 1 1 DE # 5 2 a 3 )
4.6., 3 - , t 2 .
Oneofl r sa e' oblga i unde t Co r c Doc e swast s cur ape f m a e
nta t t s i tons
r he nta t um nt
o e e ror nc

bondf t Ara7ChangeOr e .Undel ngConsr ci Conta t!1 1 DE#35- a 35; e
orhe e
d r( ryi
tu ton
rc, 6.,
2,t Ara
7 Notc t Pr e DE #39- a 2) M a aho aleg t tHator i labl on t Ara 3
ie o oc ed,
3, t . r t n l es ha rf d s i e he e
Pe f nna eBondbe aus l r sa ebr ac dt unde l ngc tu tonconta whe I r sae
ro nc
c e nta t t e he he
ryi onsr c i
r ct n nta t t
f ie t s c esley bondi f t Ar 7Cha Or pur ua t t Notc t Pr e d. (
a ld o e ur tr t
ng or he ea
nge der s nt o he i e o oc e DE

# 3 a 8 He rn a p. 84 7 . t teu ip tde ie c o t erc r s o t a M aah n
7 , t ; aig t 5 :- ) Ye,h nds u e vd n e n h e o d h ws h t rt o

tr nae ltatt o b t teAr a3a dAra7P oe t s ll b c u eHa to drf s dt bo d
emi td nr sae n oh h e n e rj cs o ey e a s rf r eu e o n
t eAr a7Ch ng Or e . Au . , 01 Letr DE #3 - Th ma De , t5 5 2 DE #3 1.
h e
a e d r ( g 6 2 0 te ,
57; o s p.a 3:- 4,
9-)
The e or t onl r i ng is be or t Cour i whehe Ha to d' r f a t bondt Ar a
r f e,he y ema ni s ue f e he
ts t r rf r s e us l o
he e
7 Cha e Or rwa a s sce g ound unde s c i 1 1 2 of t unde l ng consr ton
ng
de s uf int r
r e ton 4. 6.
he
ryi
tuci

c nrc frM a ah n' tr n to o Ita tt o teAra3Prjc.
o ta t o rt o s emiain f n r sae n h e
oe t
TheCour ha a r a r e t t rf r hadnooblgai nt bondt Ar 7Cha Or r
t s le dy uld ha Ha to d
i to o
he ea
nge de
a i wasa c r nalcha t t unde l ng c tu ton c r t Furhe ,t Cour no est t
st
a di
nge o he
ryi onsr c i ontac . t r he
t t ha

lta tt manan da e u t b n i gfrh Ara3Prj c i a c r a c wi oht u d ry n
nr sae itie d q ae o d n o te e oe tn c o d n e t t he n eli g
hb
c n tu t n c n rc a d Flrd saue F A.S AT.j 25 . ( )c ( ) ( 0 7 ;( d ry n
o sr ci o ta t n o ia ttt. L T
o
505 1( )1 2 0 ) Un eli g
Co sr cinCo ta t 1 . ., #3 - , t 5 .na dto , u s a toFlrd sau e Ma aho
n tu to nr c ! 6 11 DE 5 2 a 3 )l d i n p ru n t o ia ttt , rt n
i

c ul n t e u r Itatt t s c r t b n i gf rteAra7Prj c fo Ha to ds e i al
o d o rq ie n rsae o e u e he o d n o h e o e t r m rfr p cfc l
y.
FL S AT. 2 5.5 1()( 0 7 (A p bl e tt ma n t e uieac ta t rt sc r as rt
A. T j 5 0 ( )a 2 0 ) $ u i ni y o rq r onrco o e u e u ey
ç
c y
bondund rt ss ci fom as cfca nto bondi c
e hi e ton r
pe ii ge r
ng ompa '. or ngl t Cour fnds
ny.)Acc di y,he
'
ti

21

t a Ha tod' r f a t b n t eAr a7P oe t sas uro sa di r p rra o frM aah n
h t rfr s eus lo o d h e rj c wa p iu n mp o e e s n o rto

t tr n t l tatt o t eAra3P oe t
o emiae nr sae n h e rj c.
AsM a ahont r naedI r t t f ni ufi e c us t t r i tonc
r t e mi t ntasae ora ns fcint a e,he e m na i omeswihi t
t n he

p o iin o s cin 1 1 .,tr nain wi o tc us .( d ryn Co t cin Co ta t !
r vso s f e to 4.6 1 emi t
o t u a e Un e lig nsnzto nr c,
h
1 1 2. DE#352,a 33)Unde s ton 1 1 1 Ha tor sdut t pef m t rmai roft
4.6. 2,
- t . r eci 4.6., rf d' y o ror he e nde he

Ar a3P oe t sn v rti g r d Asar s l, rf r h dn o lg to t t c mp eet eAra
e rj c wa e e rg ee .
eutHa to d a o b iain o he o lt h e
3P oe t n ,heeo e ddn t r a ht tr o t eAr a3Pef r nc Bo db n t o eig
r j c a d t rf r , i o b e c he ems f h e
ro ma e n y o c mpltn

teAr a3P oe t Ac od n l,h Co r fnd t timu tga ts mmayj g n i fvo o
h e r jc . c r i gy te u t s ha t s rn u r ud me t n a r f
Ha to d o M a ahon' br ac o con r c c e c am .
rf r n r t s t h f ta t ount r l i
l .Conc us on
V
l i

Upon c r f consde a i oft Pa te 'pl a ngsa t undiputd f t on t r or
a e ul i r ton he ri s e di
nd he
s e acs he ec d,
t Cour fndst tHa tor ne rha a o i ton t bond t Ar 7 Cha Or rbec us i
he
t i ha rf d ve d n blga i o
he ea
nge de
a et
wa a c r na c
s a di l hange t t unde l ng consr ton c r ct The Co t f t r fnds t t
o he
ryi
tuc i onta .
ur urhe i
ha

M aah n' tr n to o I ta tt o t eAra 3 P oe twa fra is fce tc u et ee y
rt o s emi ai n f nr sae n h e rj c s o n n ufiin a s h rb

rle igHato do a yla ii o ter man e o teAra3P oe t
eivn rf r f n ib ly n h e i d r f h e rj c .
t
Ac or ngl ha ngc i r t pa te 'tlngsa bei ot r s advie i i he e
c di y, vi onsde ed he ri s i i nd ng he wie
s d, t s r by
O R DER ED , DJU D G ED ,and D EC REED a f l s
A
s olow :

Ha t r sM oin f rS mmay J g n ( # 2 be a d t s me i h r b ,
rf d' to o u r ud me t DE 4 ) , n he a s e e y
o
GR ANTED . Cour DECLARES t tt Ar 7 Chang Or rwa voi and
The
t
ha he ea
e de s d
t tH a tor had no o i ton t bond t Ar a 7 Cha Or .
ha rf d
blga i o
he e
nge der

M aahon' M oi f Pa talSummayJ me ( #31)be a t s me i
rt s ton or ri
r udg nt DE
, nd he n s
he e D ENI .
r by,
ED
22

DONE a ORDERED i Cha
nd
n
mber a t J
s t he mnesLa e eKi Fede al usi Buidi
wr nc ng
r J tce l ng
a Unied St e Courhous i M i mi Fl rdaon t s 1 t da ofN o mbe ,2011
nd t ats
t e n n , oi
hi 8 h y
ve r
.
J

A

..'
.*
'
*
'

eC:

Coun efo Ha œor
sl r r d
El ne W iher
ai
t spoon
Vezi Lawr nce,& Picieli P.
na,
e
s t l, A.
1 lAl mbr Plza
2 ha a a
Suie 1604
t
Cor Gabl ,FL 331
al
es
34
305- 2043
443-

Emale t rp n@vl a c m
i: wihesoo plw.o
Ti ot ShaneTayl
m hy
or
Ve na Lawr nce & Pi t l
zi
e
scieli
l Al m br Plza
21 ha a a
Suie 1
t 604
Cor Gabl ,FL 33134
al
es
305- 2043
443Fa 305- 2048
x: 443-

Emalta o@vllw.o
i:tylr pa c m
Co efo M ar t n
uns l r a ho
Joy SpilsLundeen
li
St ar W ea M il W eiserAl
e ns
ver ler
sl
hadef & Sit s
f
ter on
M us
eum Tower
l50 W Fl erSteet
agl r
Suie2200
t
M i i FL 33130
am ,
305- 3425
789Fax:[phone]

Emaljun e tans a rc m
i:l den@se r weve.o
Chrit
s opherLawrenceBar t
net
St nsW eave M il W ei l Al
ear
r ler sser hadef & Sit s
f
ter on
M us
eum Tower
l50 W Fl e Stee
aglr r t

23

<

AMESLA
NcE K m G
U S Dl Tll rCOURT
s tc'
SOUT RN DlTll roFFLORI
HE
s tc'
DA

.
.

Suie2200
t
M i ,FL 33130
ami
305- 3200
789Fa 789x: 3395

Emalc an t@ser weve .o
i: b ret tans a rc m
Zachary Scot Bower
t
St nsW eaverM il W eisl Al
ear
ler s er hadef & Sit s
f ter on
M us
eum Tower
150 W Fl erStee
agl r t
Suie 2200
t
M i i FL 331
am ,
30
305- 3200
789Fax:[phone]

Emal z o r tanwe v rc m
i: b we@st rs a e.o
Cou el rI r t e
ns fo ntasat
Mi
chaelEnglsh St
i
earns
Lei St ns& Robe s
by ear
rt
l Sawgr s Cor a ePkway
000
as
por t
Suie 552
t
For Lauder e,FL 33323
t
dal
954- 91
382- 99
Fa 382x:
9063

Emalme@ser rbet.om
i: s tanso rsc
D ougl Jam esRobert
as
s
Lei Ta orSt ns& Robers
by yl ear
t
1 Sawgr sCor a ePkway
000
as
por t
Suie 552
t
For Lauder e,FL 33323
t
dal
954- 91
382- 99
Fax:[phone]

Emaldr eb a c
i:[e-mail]

24