Miller v. Delta Air Lines Inc.,

Filing 32

FINAL ORDER OF DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE. Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 4/5/2012. (jw)

Download PDF
UNI TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FO R TH E SOU TH ERN D I STRI O F FLO RI A CT D K EY W EST D I I ON V SI CASE NO.4: 1 CV- 0099-LK 1- 1 J SUSAN M I LLER,on Be fofHe s l a hal r ef nd A1 Ot sSi ia l Siua e l her m lry t t d, Pl i if antf, D ELTA A I LI R NES, C . m , Def nt enda . / FI NAL O RDER O F DISM I SSAL W I PREJUDI TH CE THI CAUS c me b f r te Co r o Dee a tDet Ai Li s Ic' ($ 1a' S E o s eo e h u t n fnd n la r ne , n .s ç t ' De ) M oin t DimisCo li ( #1 J fld J n ay 2 2 2. Th Co ti f ly b ifd o t o s s mpant DE 8 , ie a u r 7, 01 o e ur s ul re e n t matera pr e wih t be k ofor la gume . 1Fo t r as e ane mor f l he t nd oce ds t he net a r nt r he e ons xpl i d e uly bel De e ow, f ndantsM oton i gr nt d a t c e i dim is d a or ngl ' i s a e nd he as s s s e cc di y. 1 . BACK GROUND Pl ntf Sus n M il r i ta e t s a ton agans Dela on Dec m be 2, 2011 f ai if a le niit d hi ci i t t e r or dama a de l r t y r i fr uli fom he bag ges nd c a a or ele es tng r r gage beng delyed o a Dela fi fom i a n t lght r M imit La Ve a o No e e 1 ,2 0. Co l ( #1,a ! 7 Pli tf sCo lit a o s g s n v mb r 5 01 mp . DE 1 t . anif mpan ale sDet ha a c r c wih alispa s nge st r i s t m u t $ 300 f e ns i lge la s onta t t l t s e r o embure he p o 3, or xpe es f t i bags a e de a d. I .a ! 2. Pli ifalge s e p i ç v r$ 5.0 f rrp a e n her r l ye d t 2 ant le s h ad t e 31 0 o e lc me t f o l anifflda Op o iint teMoint Dimiso Mac 5 21 2( # 7 a dDee a t e ido Mac Plitf ie n p sto o h t o s s n rh , 0 DE 2 ) n fnd n rpl n rh o e 9 2 2( # 9 . eCo r h adoa ag me to teMoino Mac 1 , 01 . , 01 DE 2 ) Th u t er rl ru n n h to n rh 2 2 2 2Theco r c ofCa a i s tf t i e h pa s ng ' tc t A c oft dcondii ofCara ' a ia e nta t ni ge s e orh n ac s e ers ike . opy he d tons rige' pplc bl t Plitf fih o No e e 1 ,2 0 i atc e a Ex ii 1t te Moin t Dimis( #1 )a d i o anirs lg t n v mb r 5 01 s t h d s hbt o h to o s s DE 8 n s a t ltis m e cai n,a ot r iems i he s t as as wel a ta porai t a fom t oiere , di to nd he t n r uic e, l s r ns tton o nd r he ar o ti a atmp t lc t t e ' f .a ! 7 P an iffrh ralg ss e a v s d a Det ip r n n te t o o ae h m. # t . litf u te le e h d ie ' la r pr s nt tve i LasVega t the ba e e e ai n s ha r ggage wa de a d,butwast d t t'not ng c d be s l ye ol ha t hi oul done t a ss he . I Fi l on De embe 5,201 Pl i ifal s s made a cli wih o s it r' d naly, ' c r 0, antf lege he am t Det ta wa ç ee td a do in r d' I la h t s s j ce n /r g o e . d r ' Ba e ont efct, antf s e de aat yrle damag ,at ne fes a ca s s d hes a s Pli iT e ks clr or eit es tor ys' e , nd ls a to d ma e i t re c u t; u tIf rBr a h o Co ta t Comt1 f rAsu st Unus cin n g s n h e o ns Co n o e c f nrc, t 1 o s mp i, j t En ihm e tand De a a or Relef and CountII f Vi ai n of St t Co um e Pr e ton rc n clr t y i , I or ol to a e ns r ot c i La , n ld n teFlrd De e t ea d Un arTrd P a tc sAc CE ws i cu i g h o ia c pi n f i a e r cie t FDUTPA', a Sa.j v ) Fl. tt 501. et s q. 201. . e 0n J nua y 27,201 Det fld a M oton t Dimi sa lt ee count pur u t Rul a r 2, la e i o s s l hr s s ant o e 1 ( )6 o teFe ea Rue o Cii P o e u ea d S. Fl. R. . o ti Co r. g #1 2 2 b () f h d r l ls f v l r c d r n D. a L. 7 1 f h s u t DE 8 . Th Co r h ado a a gl n o temoinso M ac 1 2 2.S eDE # 0 . e u t e r rl r l t n h to n rh 2, 01 (e me 31 I. I DI SCUSSI ON W h n e au t aRu e 1 ( ()mo in t ds s , h Co r mus ve t ealg to s e v l ai ng l 2b)6 to o imis t e u t t iw h le ain i t compl nti t lg m os f vor bl t Pli if Am.Dent As ' v Ci Cor ,605 n he ai n he i ht t a a e o antf . al s n . gna p. F.d 1 3 ( 1h Ci.2 0 . To s r ied s sa,ac mpan G s c n an s fi in fcu l 3 28 1 t r 01 ) u vv imisl o lit f t o ti u tce t a t a mu m a tr ac e e a t e t <t t a c am t r i t t i plusbl o is f e.' 1 a 1 9 te , c pt d s nl, o sae l i o elef ha s a i e n t ac '' d. t 28 ( u t Bel ln i Co p. . wo l 5 0U. 5 4 5 0 1 7S. . 95 ,1 4( S. 0 7 q oi lAt tc r v T mby, 5 S. 4 , 7 , 2 Ct 1 5 97 U. 2 0 :. ng a Dee d n Det s e dimis lo P an ifscamsu e Ru e 1 ( ()f rfiu et fn a t la e ks s sa f litf li nd r l 2 b)6 o alr o pl a s fce f cst brng e ch oft t e co t it t r l ofpl usbiiy. De e nt e d ufi int a t o i a he hr e un s n o he eam a i lt f nda alo c e t Pli ifs sa ng t r e e puttve c a s m e r . Si e t Cour i s ont ss antf t ndi o epr s nt a i l s mbe s nc he t s i or r t b r e e e i o Pl n ifs Compl nt See Dtpv T yo ,40 F.d 1 7 ,1 6 ( 1h Ci.2 5 nc po aed y efr nc nt aitf' ai . z . a lr 0 3 2 2 27 1 t r 00 ) . ((T)ec utma c n ie ad c me tatc e t amoint ds s wi ou c n et gtemoin it o efr ( h o r y o sd r o u n ta h d o to o imis t t o v ri h to no n o ( h n smmayj d me tfteatc e d c me ts()c nrlotepanif cam a ( u dip td.) u r u g n i h ta h d o u n i 1 e ta t h litfs li nd 2) n s ue '. ' perua s ded t t Pl ntf c am s a e pr e ptd by t f de a Ailne De e ai n Ac ha ai ifs l i r em e he e r l ri r gul to t (ADA',4 U.. j 01 e s q. a d bard u d r t e o ey a sau e o l tto s t 4 ' 9 SC. 4 01 t e , n re n e h n - e r tt t f i ai n ) mi conti d i t Con r tof Ca rage i ne d not r ac t s scinc of Pl ntf s f t l a ne n he tac ri , t e e h he uf e y ai if acua alegai norPl n if sr ques f rcas c rii ton. l tons aitf e t o l s e tfca i A. A DA Pr em pt on e i W ih r pec t Count 1 1,De e tar s Pl i ifs cli s a e pr e ptd by t t es t o s -11 f ndan gue antf' am r e m e he ADA be us t y i pe m isbl a t ca e he m r s i y temptt r ult t f e vi s'ofa ari s cii ly, o eg a e he ç r ce ' s n ilne, pe fca l t way De t ha l s c c ba ge a pa s nge c am sr a e t c ked ba ge. The he la nd e he ked gga nd s e r l i elt d o hec gga Cou ta e . r gr es Th ADA' p e mpi n ca s r a s i r lv n pat ( o Sae ...s alS n c o e S re to lu e e d n ee a t r: Nj tt h l ç at r e e or e a l w,r l r ulton,sa d,orot pr son ha ng t f ce a efe tof1 w nf c a ue, eg ai tndar her ovii vi he or nd f c a rltn t p ie r ue o s r ie o a arc rir.... 4 U. . j 41 3 b ()(mph ss eaig o rc , o t, r e vc f n i are ' 9 SC. 71 () 1 e a i ' a d d .Th Elv n hCic i h sisr ce t ca essp o e l af r e a e te l boa d e ) e e e t r ut a n tu td he lus ' r p ry fo d d n xr mey r d i s o e' Br n he v Aita Aiwa s I c,3 2 F.d 1 8 1 5 ( 1h Ci.2 03 ,a d h s c p , a c . rr n r y , n . 4 3 24 , 2 7 1 t r 0 ) n a ' s cfc l hed t tG gga ha i 'i pa tofa ari s f e v c s'f pum os ofADA pe ii aly l ha f ba ge ndlng' s r n ilne' t r i e ' or s es p e mp in.Ko to r dsv Det Ai Lie , n .42 F.d 1 3 ,1 4 ,1 4 ( 1h Ci. 0 5 . re to us u a i . la r n s I c, 7 3 3 9 3 3 3 4 1 t r 2 0 ) S e as Mo ae v T a s Wo l Ailn s l c,5 4 U. 3 4 3 3 4 ( 0 h li g ADA' e lo r ls . r n . rd rie, n . 0 S. 7 , 8 -8 20 8 od n S p e mp in ca s wa S eieaey e p n ie'a d o d r a s o ' Ame ia Ailn s l c re to lu e s ç lb r tl x a sv ' n f ç o d c pe); rc n rie, n . d b Woe s 5 3 U. 21 ( 9 5 ( lig Iln i Co s me F a Ac c u d n tb a pid t ln , 1 S. 9 1 9 ) hodn l os n u r rud t o l o e p l o i e r gult c ng t t Ame iaAilne fe ntfye pr r . e ae ha es o he rc ri s rque l r ogsm)3 3I Wolns t Cou tc r d outanarow e pton f t e or me ofçr i ' c r tcl msbas ont n e , he r a ve r xce i or he nf ce nt Eoutne' ontac ai ed he ailne' çs l-mpos d unde tki ' 51 U. a 23 ri s tefi e ra ngs. 3 S. t 2-33.Alhough t Su eme Cour concl ' t , he pr t uded t tt I ha he CFA waspr mp e by t ADA be us i wa ( me t gui a polc t mar tng pr ci so ari s' i as ee t d he ca e t s ç ans o de nd ie he kei a a tce f ilne y t lo ' h l t tteDee uain Ac wa n titn e t p e mp c nrc cams whc t e k()rc v r s ll frte ed ha h rg lto t s o ne d d o re t o tat li , ih d e s e o ey oey o h ariesalg db e c o i o , e i s du d ra ig . 1 a 2 7 8(mp ai a d d. iln ' l e ra h f t wn s f-mpo e n etkn sb d.t 2 -2 e h ss d e ) e s ' l Hod s v.De t Ai Li s l . t Fi Cic t r s ne t t bec us t t r n ge la r ne , nc , he hh r ui ea o d ha a e he e m çs r ie ' e e al r p e e ts abag ie -o o a tcp tdp o iino lb rfo o epa t l evc s g n rly e rs n gj r an d fr r niiae r vso f a o r m n ry ç t a he ,' t tr a us d i t ADA, i ude dt m s s h a tc tng, boa di o not r' he e m, s e n he ncl s d e i uc s ikei r ng pr e e ,pr son off a d i a ba ge ha i i a ton t t ta porato oc dur s ovii ood nd rnk, nd gga ndlng, n ddii o he r ns t i n isl. 4 F.d3 4 3 6(t Ci.1 9 )(n b n j Th Elv nh Cic i a o td ti d fni o tef' 4 3 3 , 3 5h r 9 5 e a c . e e e t rut d p e h s ei t n ' i i Br n h ,s pr a 1 5 5 .Thi Co r wil f lw Ho ge a d t e mao iy o crut n a c e u a t 2 * 7 s u t l ol o d s n h j rt f ic i pr c den i a ptng abr d de to ofts r c ' si i us i t ADA pr mpton c a e e e t n do i oa fnii n çe vie'a t s ed n he ee i l us . Pli ifmait nst the c am sha ltl t do wih çs r c 'pr de by Det afe antf n ai ha r l i ve ite o t de vies' ovi d la tr tc t pur has a i tad a ie fom Det s f l e t i or cusome s of t r rg t ike c e, nd nse rs r la' aiur o nf m t r hei i ht o ri u sme to u t $ ,0 f rl s,d ma e o d ly d b g a e Se Co l ( #1,a emb re n f p o 33 0 o o t n g d r ea e a g g . e mp . DE ) t I to. ! 2 3 1 , 1 . S e i c ly P an if s g e t t a Det mila s p s e g r i t nr , ! , , 3 9 p cf al , litf u g ss h t la se d a s n e s no i be ivi t tt y a e e il d o y t $25 t $50 perda i r i s d e ns . f a I to. le ng ha he r ntte nl o o y n e mbur e xpe es #. t n r , ! 2 1 1 Plitf d e n talg ta s ewa e rt d o s c a p rd y lmi. lse d, ! , 4, 9. anif o s o l e h t h s ve ol f u h e a i t n t a e Pl i if a lges Dela s d pos c e r r a m or pr nen sgns expl ni a pas e r s antf le t houl t l a e nd e omi t i ai ng s nge ' rg t u t $3,00 i r m bu s m e f r e ns i ured due t l t damage or deaye i ht o p o 3 n ei r e nt o xpe es nc r o os, d l d l g a e 1 . t 3 Plitf a k o e e t thealg d rg t ori re n i c n an di u g g . d a ! . anif c n wldg s ha t le e ih t embu s me t s o tie n t Conta t of Ca rage whih i puruantt a De rme ofTr ns tton r g ai 1 he rc ri , c s s o pa t nt a porai e ulton, 4 CFR PM 2 4 a di o p tdsg a ar o t.f a ! 2 3 1 & Ex.1 5 , n s n ose ins t ip rs #. t ! , , 3 . Ba e on t e f c ua aleg i ns Pl ntf a gueshe cl ms s vi unde t Wolns sd hes a t l l ato , ai if r r ai ur ve r he e e e i f d l enf c m e of c r ttr s s by t pa te t s l s' 51 U. a xc pton or kou' or e nt ontac e m et he ris hem e ve .' 3 S. t t 222. Co tdoesnotfnd t sa gume pe s i The Wol scour is l e ai t tt The ur i hi r nt ruasve. en t te f xpl ned ha he lmie e e i onl a ple whe e $a ailne is f dihonor d a tr t ailne is l i t d xc pton y p is r $n ri tel s e e m he ri t ef si a e ' I a 232 tpult d.' d. t -33. He e, Pli if s e t pur ue c am s t t go fr beyo t r antf e ks o s l i ha a nd he 4 oblga i si a e t by De t i t Conta tofCa a The Contac ofCa a doe not i tons tpult d o la n he rc ni ge. r t ni ge s , f e mpl,i or xa e mpos upo Dela a unde tki ast t t pe orsz ofsgna t tmus be e n t ny ra ng o he y ie i ge ha t pose i ar t o wha i or ai wilbepr de t apas e rwhos ba t d n ipors r t nf m ton l ovi d o s nge e ggag i de a e n l yed. Pli ifs c am s cea l r s on a l atonst tI ea e t t he r of s r i s t ta ari antf l i l ry e t leg i ha t lt o he a t e vce ha n ilne r pr de ' Koutour s 427 F. a 1 n. Pe m itng t scli t m ove f nv r a plad ovi s. ' s adi, 3d t 344 2. r ti hi am o o ad s e woul t i pe misbl s to r gulton oft m n r i whi h t ari a rie t r d hus m r s i y anci n e a i he nne n c he ilne dve ts hei r i bu s nts nic s a woul i e f r wih t pr son ofbagga handlng s r ies t em r eme e e nd d ntrb e t he ovii ge i e vc o t i pa s nge s t r by ofe ng t saedpu pos oft De egulton Ac . her s e r , he e f ndi he t t r e he r a i t Ac or ngl Co s1 1 a llofPli ifscai a e pr e pt c di y, unt , 1 nd l antf l m r e m ed. B. One yearLi ia i o Ac i i t Cont ac ofCarr age m t ton f ton n he r t i I a ton t bei pr mpt d,De e nta gues Pli ips cli s a e untmel a n ddii o ng ee e f nda r antf am r i y nd s d be dim is be us t saci wa nottld wihi o ye r fom t occ r nc as houl s s ed ca e hi ton s ie t n ne a r he ure e r quie i t Contac o Cani ge. e r d n he r tf a l i wel s tl t tç n a wrte c r c r quie notc asa c ton pr ce ntt t s l e ted ha ç whe itn onta t e r s ie ondii e de o m ant i ng s t t condii mus b meta e a vald exc e. S.Br i ani ui, hat ton te bs nt i us ' ' oad.Gr p,LLC v ou . Ge Br a I c,1 5 F. u p. d 1 1 ,1 2 ( . Fa 20 )(iig Egl Vla v Ba n t m o d, n . 4 S p 2 3 6 3 5 M D. l. 01 ct n i i ge . r et n l Na 'Ba k 8 S .d 271 2 2 ( l .9 6 S ealo Le r Holig l c v Fal ,201 W L t n 6 o2 l , 7 F a1 5 :. e s nb o dn , n . . i c 1 4 0 9 a *1 2 ( D. a Oc. , 01 )( imisn ab e c o c nta t li b s di p r o 7 61 4, t - S. Fl. t 4 2 1 d s sig ra h f o rc cam a e n at n dn u fce tfcu lalg ton t rf t' a saue o lmiai n d fn e .Th Co ta t o ç s fiin a t a l ai s o e ue' tt t f i tto s e e s ) e n rc f i e Ca ag a i a et Pl ntf cli she epr de i pe t ntpar: ni e pplc bl o ai ips am r ovi s n ri ne t No a ton s l be m ant i f a l s of orda a t ora dely i t c i ha l i aned or ny os , m ge o, ny a n he de i r of ba lve y ggag a ii out of o i c e rsng r n onneci wih ta pora i of or ton t r ns tton , f iur t ta por a pas e e orbag a l e o r ns t ny s ng r gageunl sno i ofa cli i pr s nt d es tce am s e e e t an ofi e of Det wihi 24 hour a trt ale d oc ur e e oft e t o fc la t n s fe he lge c r nc he ven s gvn rs t t ecam, n u e st ea to i c mme c d wi n o y a a tr iig ie o h li a d nls h cin s o n e t ne e r je hi suc ale d oc r e e h lge cu r nc . Co ta to Cara eE #1 -1, t e1 0 1( )(mp ssa d d . nrc f rig DE 8 1 a Rul 9 ()7 e ha i d e ) Asalege Pl ntf te and herbagga wa delyed on N ove l d, ai if l w ge s a mber 1 201 Compl 5, 0. . f #1,a ! 7. Plitf fld te isa tlws i o De e e 2,2 1- mo et n o e y a DE j t anif ie h n tn a ut n c mb r 01 r ha n e r afe t a lged occ r nce Pl i if a tmpt t a d t one ye c r cua lm ia i by tr he le ure . antf te s o voi he - ar onta t l i t ton a g n ta t efvey a saueo lmiai nu d rFo i alw a p is S eRe p. DE # 7 , t ruig h t h i - e r tt t f i tto n e lrd a p le . e s ( 2 1 a 7. Thi a gume i wihoutm e i. s r nt s t rt The tme f r flng s tt i o ii ui mderDela' Conta tofCa ra i s c t aly a ho i e by t s rc r ige s pe ik l ut rz d lw a d DOT rg lto . 1 C. R.j 2 35 1 2 ( 0 9 .T e c s lw i ce rta S cin a n e uains 4 F. 5 .4 ) 2 0 ) h a e a s la h t e to 84 95. oft Fl rda Stt t s doe nota y t e end sa ut oflm iato s tf t i f de aly 03 he o i aue s ppl o xt tt es i t i n e orh n e r l r gult d c r t orta a i e a e ontac s r ns ctons. Seef4 Scince,I .v Emer Ai Fr i Cor ,3 So. q e s nc . # y r eght p. 41 2d 27 , 2 2 7 ( l . d DCA 1 7 )4 S ealo eg.Aro Befcop.v S At d Ca ib a 2 7 - 3 Fa 2 . 9 7 . e s , . , r w e r . . l r rb e n fie, n .28 S 2 4 , 4 ( l. dDCA 1 7 )(id n ao ey a lmi t n o a to i bl n s I c, 0 o. d 3 4 F a 3 9 3 fn i g n - e r i t i f cin n il ao o ldn s be tt COGSA e f re bei o wih tn i tep o ii n o j950 , a Sa' ; f a ig u j c o n o c a l d t t sa dng h r v so s f .3 Fl . tt) n ' JB.E Rn o Co v T r eBa s Cop. 2 8 F.d 61 ,61 ( t Ci.1 5 )( od n a o - e r f s n . . h e y r , 3 2 1 6 5h r 9 6 h li g ney a lmiai n v ld i c nrc i o rtn COGS d s ie j 9 .3 Fl.S a.. Plitf c n o i tto ai n o ta t nc mo aig A e pt 50 , a tt ) an if a n t us Flrda 1 w t e e o i a o xpand Det s t ra ng i t Conta t of Ca rage by e la' mde tki n he rc ri xposng i t i to c am sm a wihi fve ye r ,r t r t n t one- a e es l pr ded i t Con r c of li de t n i a s a he ha he ye r xpr sy ovi n he ta t Ca rag r i e. 4 d hat a l ff Sce cs teFo iac u to a p a rjce tepe ieag me Pli ifma she eand hel t Fl n e in e,h lrd o r f p e l eetd h rcs ru nt antf ke r Sa.j9 .3 dd n tiv ld t ao ey a saueoflmi to i a arfeg c nrc o cni g sbe tt te tt 50 i o n aiae n -e r ttt i t in n n i riht o tat f a a e u j c o h a . Fe r lAvitonAc of1 t pr cu s oft ADA.Thec re st rf,i om o aedi t conr ctofc ge de a ai t 958,he e r or he arir' aif nc r t n he ta ania , p o d d ta tecrirwo l n tb l bl i a y ato S nls s ha t n i b o g twi n o e( )y a'a r rvie h t h are ud o e i e n n cin ç e s uc ci s r u h t n 1 er' ûe a u o hi tecrird ne apat' da g cam.Th ato i LfeSce e wa fldmoeta ayera rtecnir h are e id ry s ma e li e cin n incs s ie r h n a he h a e deni t cl m,bu wihi t Fl i sat eoflmiainsf rbr c ofco r ctcli .The c tofa a hel ed he ai t t n he orda t ut i tto o ea h nta ams our ppe l d t tt cl m was bar d by t oneyea lmiaton i t c rctofcara a s ikal sa e t tShe ha he ai re he - r i t i n he onta rige nd pecf ly tt d ha t p o iin o S cin950 , o iaSaue (9 )whihp o bth c nrcu l h re i of tttr l tto r vso s f e to .3 Flrd ttts 1 71, c rhiite o tata s o tnng sauoy i ain mi p ro s ha en efc u o (h c nrc o crig )b c u eterg lto ofs p nso g o si itrtt eid , v o fet p n te o ta t f ara e e a s h e uain hime t f o d n nesae comme c ha be n pr mptd byf de a aut rt '1 a 272r e s e ee e e r l ho iy. d. t 73. ' 11 1. CO N C LUSI N O Ac or ngl afe a c r ul r vi of t r or c i a i of t a gum e of c di y, tr a ef e ew he ec d, onsder ton he r nt c ms l a bei ot wie f l advie i i ot e, nd ng her s uly s d, t s O RDERED,ADJUDGED a DECREED t t nd ha ; 1 ) Dee d n ' M oint Dimis( /1 1b , n t esme i h rb GRANTED f n a ts to o s s DE /8 e a d h a ,s e e y a t ca ei dimi s d ac or ngl nd he s s s s e c di y. 2) A1 pe ngm oto notot r s r e upo a eDENI AS M OO T. 1 ndi i ns he wie uld n r ED Thi c ei CLO SED. s as s DONE and O RDERED i c mbe s a t J n hn r t he nmes La e e Ki Fede a J tce wr nc ng r l usi Buliga dUni dSae Co rho e MimiFlrd ,hsr da o Ap i, 2 idn n t tts u t us, n , oia ti e y f rl201 . , NOM BLE AM ES LAW I TED STA TES D I U CT J STI U SO UTHERN D I STRI OF FLO CT cc Al cou e ofr c d : l ns l e or ç KI G N E DA

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?