Maryland Casualty Company v. Smartcop, Inc. et al
Filing
33
ORDER DENYING 12 Defendant's Motion to Dismiss. Signed by Judge K. Michael Moore on 7/6/2012. (rg1)
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E SOUTH ERN DI
STRI O F FLO RI
CT
DA
C a e N o. 11 c 1 00- M M
s
4: - v- 01 K
M ARYLAND CA SUALTY COM PANY,
aNe Yor c or ton,
w
k om a i
Pl i if
antf,
VS.
SM M W COP,I d/ a
NC. b/
CONSOLI
DATED TECHNOLOGY
SOLUTI S,aFl i c or ton,a
ON
orda om a i nd
LA ZARO GU ERER RO,Pe s l
r ona
Re e en a i oft Esa eofM ei s
pr s t tve he t t
ls a
Pow e s
r,
Def nda s
e nt .
/
O RD ER DEN Y I G DEFEN D A NT ' M O TI N TO D I I
N
S
O
SM SS
THI CAUSE c me be or t Cour upon De e nt Laz r Gue r r s M oton t
S
a
f e he
t
f nda
ao
re o'
i o
Dimis( No.1 ) Plitf fld aRt p ns ( No.1 )a d Dee a tfld a Re l
s s ECF
2 . anif ie
s o e ECF
7 n fnd n ie
py
( No. 3 . Th M oin i n w tp f rrv e
ECF
2 ) e to s o i e o e iw.UPON CONS DERATI o t eM oin,
I
ON f h to
t Re pons t Re y,t pe tnentpori nsoft Re or a beng ot r s f ly a s d
he s e, he pl he ri
to
he c d, nd i
he wie u l dvie
i t pr m ies t sCour e e st f l ng Or r
n he e s , hi
t nt r he olowi
de .
I BA CK G R O U N D I
*
Thi M oton mi es i t c e of a i m a
s
i
s n he ont xt
n ns nce c r e ac i . Pl i if s e a
ove ag
ton
antf e ks
de l r ton ofisoblga i a t i lr r t ra c r c is t Sm a top. Pli tf i a
c a ai
t
i tons s he nsze mde
onta t s ued o
rc
a n if s
N e Y o k c or ton w ih is prnc pa pl c of bus ne s l a e i llnoi . Sm a t r i a
w
r op a i
t t i i l ae
i s oc t d n li s
rco p s
lThe fcsheen ae tke fom Pl ntf Compl n ( No 1 ;Deenda ' M oi t
a t ri r a n '
r
ai ifs
ait ECF
) f nts ton o
.
Dimi s Pli ifs Res e t Def nda ' M oton t Dim is and De enda ' Re y. A1
s s ; antf
pons o
e nts
i o s s;
f nts pl
l
f c sa e c tue i t lg mos f vor bl t Pli ifa t non- o nt
a t r onsr d n he i ht t a a e o a ntf s he
m va .
1
Fl rdaco por ton wih isprncpalplc ofb i s l t i Fl i Def nda Gue r as
oi
r ai
t t i i
ae
usne s ocaed n orda.
e nt ro,
t Pe s
he ronalRe e en a i oft Esa e ofM e is Powe s i a Fl i cii e
pr s t tve
he t t
ls a
r, s
orda tz n. De e nt
f nda
Guer r fl d a lws tagans Sm a top i Fl i sa e co talegi t wr u de t of
re o e
a ui
i t
rc n orda tt ur l ng he ongf l ah
M eis Powe s a M onr Cot y She ifs De y. De y Powe s was kild i a m ot
ls a
r,
oe mt
rf
put
put
r
le n
or
ve ce a i nt durng t c s of he l w e or m e du i s i Ke Lar o, Fl i
hi l ccde
i he our e
r a nf ce nt te n y
g
orda.
Sma top wmsr t i d by t M onr Cot y Sherf Ofi e t pr vi s t r pr r mst
rc
e ane
he
oe mt
ifs fc o o de ofwa e og a o
monior is polc ve cls Def nda Gue r r s sae a ton alege t t Sma top wa
t t
i e hi e .
e nt
re o' t t c i
l s ha
rc
s
ne i nti f ii t pr ry mai ai orupda eis s t r pr a swhih c e t de h
glge n alng o ope l
nt n
t t ofwa e ogr m
c aus d he at
of Deput Powe s l t unde l ng lws t Pl ntf has be def ndi Sma top unde a
y
r . n he
ryi a ui, ai if
en e ng
rc
r
c mpeer s r ai n o rg t. Plitf Co litiv k sdiest j rs ito i o d rt
o lt ee v to f ihs an ifs mpan n o e v riy u idcin n r e o
s k a de l ai n c
ee
car to once ni isrg sa o i tonst de e a i m niy Sma t unde
r ng t i ht nd blga i o f nd nd nde f
rcop
r
isi ur nc polc De e ntGuer r now movest dim isPl ntf c pli f f iur
t ns a e iy. f nda
re o
o s s ai ifs om a nt or a l e
t sa eac am upon whih r le c n begr nt d.
o tt li
c e if a
a e
I .LEG A L STA N DA R D
I
A moton t dim is f f itr t sa e a cli me ey t ss t s fcinc of t
i o s s or alle o t t
am
r l e t he ufi e y
he
c
ompli ;i doe no de de t me isoft c s M ibur v. t d St t ,734 F. 76 765
ant t s t ci he rt
he a e. l n Unie aes
2d 2,
( 1h Ci.1 4 . On a moi nt d s s,te Co r mus a c p te fcu lalg to sa tu
1 t r 98 )
to o imis h u t t c e t h a t a le ain s r e
a c tu t c
nd onsr e he ompl nti t lgh mos f vo a e t t pl ntf. SEC v.ESM Gr .I .
ai n he i t
t a r bl o he ai if
p. nc,
8 5 F.d27 , 7 ( 1h Ci.1 8 .E s r ieamo int dimis ac mpan mus c n an
3 2 0 2 2 1 t r 98 ) G u vv
TO
to o s s , o lit t o ti
s tc e tf c ua m a tr a e e mstu t Et t acl m f r i t ti pl i eon isf c ''
ufs i n a t l te , cc pt d r e, o sa e ai or elef ha s ausbl
t a e.'
As c o tv I b l 1 9 S.Ct 1 37 1 49 ( 0 )(u tn BelAt. Two l 5 0 U. 5 4,
h r f . g a, 2
. 9 , 9 20 9 q o ig l l v. mby, 5 S. 4
5 0 ( 0 7 ) çl epa sblt sn ad i n ta i t a ç o b l yr q ie n p b taksf r
7 2 0 ). %- lu iii tnd r s o kn o prba ii e ur me t' u s o
-h
y
t
m or t n a s erpos i lt t ta def nda hasaced t a uly. I ç whe e t wel
e ha
he
sbiiy ha
e nt
t ml wf l ' d. f
'
But
r he l
pla d f t do notpe mi t cour t i erm or t n t mer pos i lt ofmiconduc,t
e de acs
r t he
t o nf
e ha he
e sbiiy
s
t he
c
ompl nthas a lge but i has not çhown' çha t pl a r i e il t r le .' I a
ai
le dt
s
- t t he e de s ntted o e if'' d. t
1
950. A c
ompl i mus alo c an e
ant
t s ont i nough f c s t i c t t pr s nce of t r quied
a t o ndia e he e e
he e r
ee ns W at v F a ItlUni ,4 5 F.d 1 8 , 1 0 ( 1h Ci.2 0 ) Ho v r $a
lme t. ts . l. n ' v. 9 3 2 9 3 2 1 t r 0 7 . we e , ç )
(
pla ng t tofe s ç f mul c r c tton ofeeme sofa c us ofa i wilnotdo.' I l
e di ha f r a or ai e ia i
l nt
a e
cton l
'' uba ,
1 S. . t1 4 ( u tn Two l , 5 U.. t5 5 .çcl n ls r alg to s t ra td
29 Ct a 9 9 q o ig mb y 5 0 S a 5 ) t o cu o y le ain ,mwa rne
l
de to off c orl ga c l i m a que adi asf t wilnotpr ve dim is .' or
duci ns a t e l onc usons s r ng acs l
e nt s s al'Oxf d
Ase M g -Lt . J hai, 9 F.d 1 8 1 8 ( 1hCi. 0 2 .
st mt. d v. a rs 2 7 3 1 2, 1 8 1 t r 2 0 )
1 1 A NA LY SI
1.
S
Pli ifs Co pl nt i a a ton t r t De l aor J m e Ac , 28 U. C.
a ntf
m ai s n c i mde he car t y udg nt t
S.
j2 01a. S cin 2 01i aga to j rs ito o l a t tos rg t a d la ii e t a ae
2 ()2 e to 2 s r n f u idcin ny s o h e ih s n iblt s h t r
i
i dit a r al o t t a e ce t n t a ie. Se N iva Co
mme ae nd e , r ha r rai o rs
e r na ndo. As oc. l v. OBE
s . nc.
l sco p, 8 F. u p. d 1 3 ,1 4 ( D. a 2 0 ) Toa e u tl pla acam f rf d rl
n . r .5 9 S p 2 3 6 3 3 S. Fl. 0 8 . d q aey e d li o e ea
c u tj rs ito 3Plitf mu ts tsy t e c s a d c n r v ry r q ie n o Aril 11
o r u idcin, anif s aif h a e n o to e s e ur me t f t e 1.
c
U. Cons.at 11 j2.To me tt ssa r ça t malconr s rquie a t fniea
S. t, r. 1,
e hi tndad,tn ac
tovery' e rs dei t nd
2 F d rl j rs ito f r Plitf d caao y j d me t a to i b sd o dv ri
e e a u idcin o anifs e lrt r u g n cin s a e n iest
y
j s ito a teeo e sae lw a p is t a y is n tg v m e b t Co siuin o
mid cin, nd h r fr tt a p le o n sue o o e d y he n ttto r
te tesoft Unie Stt orAc sofCongr s M i fontne Cms Co.v.Am .Prde Bl
rai
he t d aes
t
es . di nt .
i
dc.
Co, 01F.d 1 4 ,1 48( 1h Ci. 01 )(i n 28U.. j 1 5 ;EreR. Co v. mp i ,
.6 3 1 3 1 1 t r 2 0 ct g
i
SC. 6 2 i R. . To kns
3 4U. 6 ,7 ( 9 8 Hee tep risboh alg t a Flrd 1w a p ist a1s b tni e
0 S. 4 8 1 3 :. r ,h a t t le e h t o ia a p le o 1 u sn tv
e
is e o lw. S e De S v n LLC v.Bi Lo sS o e .l c,3 4 F d Ap x 41 ( 1 Ci.
su s f a
e w ee .
c t t rs n . 5 e . p' 5 1 1 r
2 0 ) (p li F o ia s b tn ie lw t dv riy a to se i d caao y j d me t
0 9 a pyng lrd u sa tv a o ie st cin e kng e lrt r u g n
c e ngac r c)
onc mi
onta t.
3Sic d caao yj d me ta t a ep o e l a me h ns a d c nfrn s b tn ierg t,
n e e lrt r u g n cs r r c dz l c a ims n o e o u sn tv ih s
r
t s Cour a i f de a 1 f is de e m i ton of t s fcenc oft compl i . Se
hi
t pples e r l aw or t t r na i
he ufi i y
he
ant
e
Niva Condo. As oc. l , 589 F. Supp. 2d a 13
r na
s . nc.
t 43. The pl a ng r quie e s ç or
e di e r m nt ç
f
de l r t y r i a e e c l t s m e asi ot rcvi a tons....' Thomasv.Bl Cr s &
c a aor elef r xa ty he n
n he i l c i
'
ue os
Bl e S il As ',5 4 F.d 8 ,8 0 ( 1h Ci.2 0 . Ho v r a d suse i Niv na
u hed sn 9 3 23 3 1 t r 01 )
we e, s ic sd n r a
Co d Aso .I c,th ee n sr q ie u e t ef d rlo Fl rd )d caao yj d me t
n o. s c. n . û e lme t e ur d nd r h e ea r o ia e lrt r u g n
t
a t a enotma e ily dif r nt' 589 F.Supp. a 1
cs r
t ra l f e e .
'
2d t 343.
3
conc ee' c r r y.'Fedka p v. Lonc Ba Pa t s LLC,N o.09- v- 3r t ontove s ' l m
v rner .
c 25 FTM 29SPC,
2 0 W L 3 0 5 ,a * ( . Fl.S p .1 , 0 . t p ry s e n ad ca ao yj d me t
01
61 4 2 t 4 M D. a e t 4 201 ) ç a t e kig e lrt r u g n
A
mus al gef ct i ac pli fom whih i a a st tt r i a s t nta lkelho t ti
t le a s n om a nt r
c t ppe r ha he e s ubsa i l i i od ha t
wi s fe ij r i t e ft r t a c n b r me id o rd e sd b a fvo a l j d ca
l uf r nu y n h uu e h t a e e de r e r se y a rbe u iil
l
d cso . Niv n Co d . s c.lc,5 9 F.S p 2 a 1 4 (iigNa. v riig Co. .
e iin' r a a n o As o . n . 8
'
u p. d t 3 3 ctn t Ad e t n
s
v
Ci o FtLa d r ae 9 4F.d2 3 2 5 8 ( 1hCi.1 91
> f . u ed l, 3 2 8 , 8 - 6 1 t r 9 $.
Th s Co r fn s t a P an ifs Co lit alg s a s fiin ij r whih c n b
i u t i d h t litf
mpan le e u fce t n u y c a e
a d e s d b afv r bej d ca d tr n to
d r se y a o a l u iil eemiain.Plitf h sa c ni u st s fe a ij r
an if a nd o tn e o u fr n nu y
by ha ng t de end Sma top i De e ntsunde l ng wr ulde t ac i Se Conl I .
vi o f
rc n f nda '
ryi
ongf
a h ton. e
v ns
Co. Nih lo , .1 - 0 2- V, 1 W L 2 4 0 ,a * ( D. a 2 0 (G l eh ra
v. c o s n No 0 60 4 CI 20 0
8 48 2 t 3 S. Fl. 01 ) dW h te n
l
i ur rha a du y t de end a s ta i tisi ur d i ge a l c i e a co r r y rpe
ns e s
t o f
ui ga ns t ns e s ner ly onsder d
ntove s i
f de a a o y r i ,e n whe t i s oft i tr rsac u la lt i t unde l ng s t
or clr t r elef ve
n he s ue he nsle ' t al ibiiy n he
ryi ui
ma n tb c nsd rd u tla ra r s lto o ta s i. (iain o t d ) Ad to al,
y o e o ie e n i he e ou in f h t ut' ctto s mit l. di n l
'
e
i y
Plit fwil ij rdi t ei daef tr i i h st i e f Sma to f rt wr n f l
ani lbe n u e n h mme it uu e f t a o nd mniy rc p o he o g u
f
d ah a to Th sij r c n b r d e s d b a fv rb ej diild cso b c us Plitf
e t cin. i nu y a e e rse y a o a l u ca e iin e a e anifs
Compl nts e a deca ai t t i has no d y t def nd or i mniy Sma top ove t
ai e ks
lr ton ha t
ut o e
nde f
rc
r he
wr n fld ah a t n. Co . a ! 212 . I s c sf l Plitf wo d b a e t so
o g u e t ci
o
mpl t ! - 3 f uc e s u, anif ul e bl o t p
,
pe f mi unde t d y t de e pr vii oft polc notbe la e f a l sa ti e
ror ng
r he ut o f nd o son he iy,
i bl or ny os trbut d
t Sm a top' c
o
rc s onduc ,a be a e t s k isl le ns t f ri ured fom Sm a top i
t nd
bl o ee t ega xpe es hus a nc r r
rc n
t unde l ng lws t Thi Co ti s ts d t tPl ntf hmsa
he
ryi a ui. s ur s a ife ha ai if
dequa ey pld t r uie e s
t l e he eq r m nt
f rad fnt ij r ta c nb rd e s db afv rb ej dca d tr n to
o e ie n u y h t a e e r se y a o a l u iil eemi ain.
A ddii ly,Pl i if s Com pl i s t c e ty a l ge t t a a l c r ve s e s s
tona l
a ntf
a nt ufi i n l le s ha n dua ont o r y xi t .
Thepa tesha abona fde diput co e ni t pr ri e pr t ton oft i tr ncepolc
ri
ve
i
s e nc r ng he ope nt r e ai
he nsla
iy
4
a t co
nd he nduc gvi rs t Sma top' la lt under t wr ul de t a ton. See
t i ng ie o
rc s i biiy
he ongf
ah c i
F lk mp 2 0 W L 3 0 5 ,a * (i dn a d s u e o r a c nr c' itr r tto i
ed n , 01
61 4 2 t 5 fn ig ip t ve
o ta ts nep eain s
s f e f t co rves r quieme ) AlhoughPli ifsCompli i a sngl c us of
ufkint or he nto ry e r nt. t
antf
ant s i e a e
a ton f de a a or r i , i i or nied i o s pa a e ç unt ' bas d upon dif r nt
c i or clr t y elef t s ga z nt e r t ç
co s' e
fe e
e l i by whi h Pl ntf a lge i i a ol d fom pe f r ng unde t polc is d t
xcusons
c ai if le s t s bs ve r
ro mi
r he iy s ue o
Sma top. Pl Re p. a 2. I a l i Pli irsCom pl nt t Cour fndst tPl i ifha
rc
f s ,t
n na yzng antf
ai , he
t i ha antf s
a
dequ e ypld a bona fdedipu east t i ur ncepolc si e r t ton a isc r e of
atl e
i
s t
o he ns a
iy' nt m e a i nd t ove ag
Sma top' alege c
rc s l d onduc .See Cor s I .Com .v.M c l ,No.96t
eci ns
colum
1068- V- 1 B,
CI T- 7-
9 5F.S p .1 0 1 ( . Fl.1 97 (idig a t cu lc nr v ry'wheet anifha a
5
u p 2 , 23 M D. a 9 ) fn n n G ta o to e s ' r ç itf s
a
pl
rg t know whe he i i bound unde isconta t de e is i m e and whe he ornoti
iht o
t rts
rt
r ct o f nd t ns d
t r
t
wo l b l b et e t c v rg o i p lc i t e e e tt e sae c u trn e sj d me t
ud e i l md r he o ea e f t o iy n h v n h tt o r e d r u g n
a
s
a ns i'.
gai t t'
)
I isM oton,Def nda i e t pr pe l galana yss unde a moton t dim isa
n t
i
e nt gnor s he o r e
l i
r
i o s s nd
as t s Cour t detr ne t t t polc s e usona y pr sons ar i pplc bl t
ks hi
t o e mi ha he i y' xcl i r ovi i
e na ia e o
Smarc s c
top' onduct whi h gi rs t la lt unde t wr u deah aci n.For e c
c ves ie o i biiy
r he ongf l t to
ah
e l i De e ntofe sisown i e r t ton oft polc a Sm a t sc
xcuson, f nda
fr t
nt p e a i
he iy nd
rcop' onduc i or r
t n de
t c ncet sCour t Pli ifhasnotpl acli f r i 4 Alhoug i ur ncec r c
o onvi hi
t hat antf
ed a m or elef
t h ns a
onta t
4Fore n e De e
x mpl, f ndan ar ue t tt polc s e uson f a l s t e uli diecl or
t g s ha he i y' xcl i or ny os t s tng, r ty
r
i r ty,fom t l sofus ofa c muni ton s t lie'doesnotpr cl c a Def
ndiecl r he os
e
om
ca i a e lt '
e ude over ge.
.
M o . o Di m i s a 6. D e e
t t s s, t
f ndantc a m s t tt e us on s dn' a y be aus t e r i
l i ha he xcl i houl t ppl c e he r or n
Sma top' s tm wa d t t çu a t t GPS s t m t twas twor ng pr ry.'
rc s yse
s ue o he çpgr de o he
yse ha
n'
ki
ope l '
De Re y,a 6. Pl ntf coun e s t tt t e e t tDe e
E pl t
ai if
t r ha o he xt nt ha f ndan ' cai sa e ba e o t
ts l m r s d n he
fiur ofSma top' s tm due t t fl sofus oft GPS,(he t s e l i s d
al e
rc s yse
o he tos
e he
t n) hi xcuson houl
a y. Pl. s ,a 7. Att ssag i t pr edi t sCo tbei vesi i i ppr i t t
ppl ' f Re p. t
'
hi t e n he oce ng, hi ur le
t s na oprae o
d ve i o f c ua a l i ofDef nts t ryi wr u de h a ton. Thi Co tonl
el nt a t l na yss
enda ' mde l ng ongf l at c i
s ur y
l
ooksa t pladi a de e mi st tPli ifhasa
t he e ngs nd t r ne ha antf
dequa ey pld a c am f r de l r t y
tl e
l i o c a aor
r i .
elef
5
i epr tton i a ma tr of lw ,5 t s Cour de i De e nts i t ton t i e r t t
nt r ea i s
te
a
hi
t clnes f nda ' nviai o nt m e he
c r c a t m oto t dimi s sage At t s poi ,t r ar sg fca f c ua dipu es
onta t t he
in o s s t .
hi
nt he e e i nii nt a t l s t
c e i Sm a top' labiiy f t tag c dea h ofDe y Power . The e f cua diput s
onc m ng
rc s i lt or he r i
t
put
s
s at l s e
pr cude t Co ts i e pr t ton of t i ur nc polc Se Co y I .Co.v.Ni s n,
el
he ur' nt r e ai
he ns a e i y. e nl ns
cholo
2 0W L 2 4 0 a * (ttn ta wh nt et c lfcsaet es b e to dipuewihnt e
01
8 48 2, t 3 saig h t e h t ma a t r h u j c f s t t i h
a
sae c t... hi Co tdo notbe ive i i awiee r ie ofisdi c e i t c
t t our
t s ur es
le t s
s xe c s
t s r ton o onduc pa a ll
t r le
po e dng a d rs ic n itn j g n s r g r ig tos d s u e fc s' . Th s r s ls
r c e i s n ik n o sse t ud me t e adn h e ip td a t.) i e ut
'
be a e i woul be i ppr it f t s Cour t fr t m a a fndi a t t c
c us t
d
na opra e or hi
t o is
ke i ng s o he ondud
r s tng i Sma top' la lt bef e de e m i ng whe he t t c
e uli n
rc s i biiy or t r ni
t r ha onduc i c r d t
t s ove e mder
Pli ifs i ur nc polcy. As a he co t a l not t de e m i ton of i m a e
antf ns a e i
not r ur pty
ed, he t r na i
ns nc
c r e i m or a oprae f
ove ag s e ppr i t or
t e s mmayj d me tsa e a trt ep risha e free o tt f csa
h u r u g n tg , fe h a te v ertd u he a t nd
de l
veoped a r or nott m oton t dim is sa ,whe e t Cour' ha
ec d,
he
i o s s t ge
r he
t nds
s
a e te t a ce alt f c ua a lga i i t cai a tu a e ua ea l
r i d o c pt 1 he a t l le tons n he l m s r e nd val t l
i e e es de i d fom t e f t i t lght mos f a e t t nonnf r nc
rve r
hos ac s n he i
t avor bl o he
m ovi pary.
ng t
AxsS r lsl s Co v. u ro Mo t. r .No. 0 -v- 9 0 2 0 W L 5 5 3 a * ( .
i u pu n . . S peir rc Se v, 8:9 c 1 6 , 01
5 5 , t 2 M D.
Fl . 2 0 . Thus t sCour l oksonl t t pl a ngsa fndst tPli ifha a qua ey
a 01 )6
to
y o he e di
nd i ha antf s de t l
,hi
pld acli f r i t s rvveam otont dim is
e
am or elef o u i
i o s s.
5 Unde Fl rda s f ntve l , t i e rt ton of pr sons of a i ur nc polc i a
r o i ubsa i aw he ntm ea i
ovii
n ns a e iy s
q e to o lw. J me Rie Is Co v Gr t Do En ' ,5 0F.d 1 0 1 7 ( 1h Ci.
u sin f a a s v r n . . . omd wn c c 4 3 27 , 2 4 1 t r
20)
0 8.
6 Si ia l t s Co tde i a t s tm e t r e on D e enda ' c e i t tt polc i
m l ry hi ur clnes t hi i o ul
f
nts ont nton ha he i y s
il or De e ntc i ly r f r nc Tl l .Co.v.Sm a tSc t s
lus y. f nda ontnua l e e e es G ns
r h. o uppo tis a gume
r t r
nt
ta P an ifsc nr c i ius r 4 F. p 2 1 3 ( D. l. 0 ) Ho ve, h c u t
h t litf o ta t s l o y. 01 Su p. d. 3 4 S. F a 20 5 . we r t e o r
l
i TI l s Co e auae ap lc str o amoin f rs mmayj dg n a d d tr n d
n G n . . v l td o iy' e ms n
to o u r u me t n ee mi e
t t co r c was notil or As dic s d,t s Co tbe ives t t s h a a l i i
hat he nta t
lus y.
s us e hi ur le
ha uc n nayss s
i ppr it a t moton t dim is sa . M or ove ,ma oft c s cied by De e nt
na opra e t he
i o s s t ge
e r ny
he a es t
f nda
wee d cd d i te c ne t o a moin f r s mma y j d me t a d f r ti r a o ,ae
r e ie n h o tx f
t o u r u g n, n o hs es n r
o
i pplc bl a t ssa i t pr e ng.
na ia e t hi t ge n he oce di
6
Thi Cour doesnote es any opi on on t uli a er ol i n oft sca e Se Pa r
s
t
xpr s
ni
he tm t es uto
hi s . e r
v.M a s u v Ho s l . No.0 -v 1 6 e b r me . nc,
9c - 2 8 ORL- 9 K,2 0 W L 51 7 0 a * ( . Fl.
1 GJ 0 9
71 7 , t 3 M D. a
De . 2 2 0 )(ttn t a ça moint dimisac mp an f rad caao yj d me ti no
c 2 , 0 9 saig h t f ) to o s s o lit o e lrt r u g n s t
l
am oton on t m e is'a onl deer nest t rt pli tf i entte t a deca a i of
i
he rt' nd y t mi t he he a n if s il d o
whe
lr ton
rg t,n twh t e i i e ild t ad ca ain i i fv n' Th sCo r o y h lsta te
ih s o eh r t s nt e o e lrto n t a o ). i u t nl od h t h
t
s
alegai nsi t Compl n a e s f en t sa ea ca e ofaci f de a a or r le . Onc
l to n he
ait r ufki t o t t
us
ton or clr t y ei f
e
t er c r h sb e f t rd veo e ,t pate ma mo e f rs mmay j dg n o te e
h e o d m e n urhe e lp d he ris y v o u r u me t n h s
is .
s ues
I CONCLUSI
V.
ON
Fort f r goi r ms ns i i
he o e ng e o ,t s
ORDERED AND ADJ
UDGED t t De e
ha
f ndant La r Gue r o' M oton t Dim is
za o
rer s
i o s s
( No.1 )i DENI
ECF
2 s
ED.
ooxsaxoo= Eu oi - b- t - iy- d ,h- d y- . sc l.
-ch --- vi , lu -tizzf - rul oc
K. I
CHAEL M OORE
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRJ J
CT UDGE
A1 c
l ouns lofr or
e
ec d
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?