Stelor Productions, v. Silvers

Filing 71

NOTICE of by Steven A. Silvers filing record cross designation (dj, Deputy Clerk)

Case 9:05-cv-80393-DTKH

Document 71

Entered on FLSD Docket 08/18/2005

Page 1 of 9

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA . Case No . 05-80393-CIV-HURLEY/ Hopkin s STELOR PRODUCTIONS, L .L .C . ,
n iicinwmci .(n-rnnnIuII .

f/k/a STELOR PRODUCTIONS, INC . , Plaintiff,
vs .

=vii j pV j~

FILE D

4UG 1 6 200 5
CL CLARENC USDEK C / SDFDL I FTL

STEVEN A . SILVERS, a Florida resident, Defendant .

NOTICE OF FILING RECORD CROSS-DESIGNATIO N Please take notice that Defendant/Appellee STEVEN A . SILVERS, hereby files the District Court Docket Sheet containing his record cross - designations for the appeal pending in this matter.

Respectfully submitted , DIMOND, KAPLAN & ROTHSTEIN, P .A . KOZYAK TROPIN & THROCKMORTON, P .A . CoCounsel for Defendant Counsel for Defendan t 200 S . E . First Street , Suite 708 2525 Ponce de Leon , 9`h Floor Miami , FL 33131 Coral Gables, Florida 3313 4 Telephone : [phone] Telephone : [phone] Adam T. Rabin, Esq. BY : Ke . Hartmann F orida Bar No : 664286 Gail A. McQuilkin Florida Bar No . 969338

Case 9:05-cv-80393-DTKH

Document 71

Entered on FLSD Docket 08/18/2005

Page 2 of 9

CERTIFICATE OF SERVIC E I HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of the foregoing was mailed this 141t day of August, 2005, to : Kevin C . Kaplan, Esq ., Daniel F . Blonsky, Esq . and David Zack, Esq ., Burlington, Weil, Schwiep, Kaplan & Blonsky, P .A ., Counsel for Plaintiff, Office in the Grove, Penthouse A, 2699 South Bayshore Drive, Miami, FL 33133 .

043339/101/256497 .1

CU.S. 9:05-cv-80393-DTKH Document 71 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/18/2005 Page of9 ase District Court Web PACER(v2 .4) Docket Report Page 1 3 of 7

Docket as of August 14, 2005 0 :14 am

Web PACER (v2 .4 )

U.S . District Court
Cniithwrn llliQfriof of Flnritia fW Palm Road-16 1

CIVIL DOCKET FOR CASE # : 05-CV-80393 Stelor Productions , v. Silvers
Filed : 05/05/0 5 Assigned to : Judge Daniel T . K . Hurley Demand : $0,000 Nature of Suit : 190 Lead Docket: None Jurisdiction : Diversit y Dkt# in other court : None Cause : 28:2201 Declaratory Judgmen t

STELOR PRODUCTIONS, L .L .C ., a Kevin Crow Kaplan Delaware corporation FTS 858-526 1 fka 305-858-2900 Stelor Productions,Inc . [COR LD NTC ] plaintiff Daniel Frederick Blonsky FTS 858-526 1 [COR LD NTC] David John Zack FTS 858-5261 [COR LD NTC ] Burlington Well Schwiep Kaplan & Blonsk y 2699 S Bayshore Drive Penthouse A

Miami, FL 33133 305-858-290 0
V.

STEVEN A . SILVERS, a Florida Kenneth R . Hartmann resident FTS 372-350 8 defendant 305-372-1800 [COR LD NTC ] Gail Ann McQuilkin FTS 372-3508 305-372-1800 [COR LD NTC ] Kozyak Tropin & Throckmorton 2525 Ponce de Leon Boulevard Suite 90 0 Coral Gables, FL 33134-6036 305-372-180 0

http ://pacer .flsd .uscourts .gov/dc/cgi-bin/pacer740 .pl

8/15/2005

CU.S . 9:05-cv-80393-DTKH Document 71 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/18/2005 Page of9 ase District Court Web PACER(v2 .4) Docket Report Page 2 4 of 7

Steven A . Silver s 8993 Okeechobee Boulevard #202 PMB 20 3

West Plam Beach , FL 3341 1
L L 11L L\aLll l

FTS 671-1951 [COR LD NTC ] Dimond Kaplan & Rothstein 525 S Flagler Drive Suite 20 0 West Palm Beach, FL 33401 561-671-211 0

DOCKET PROCEEDINGS

DATE # DOCKET ENTRY

5/5/05 1 VERIFIED COMPLAINT filed ; FILING FEE $250 .00 RECEIPT # 920308 ; Magistrate Judge James M . Hopkins (wc ) 5/5/05 2 EMERGENCY MOTION with memorandum in support by Stelor Productions, for temporary restraining order, and/or for preliminary injunction (wc ) 5/5/05 3 SUMMONS(ES) issued for Steven A . Silvers (wc) 5/5/05 4 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (wc ) 5/9/05 5 ORDER compelling plaintiff to serve defendant and file certificate of service ( Signed by Magistrate Judge James M . Hopkins on 5/9/05) [EOD Date : 5/9/05] (cj )

5/9/05 6 Notice of compliance : by Stelor Productions, with [5-1] order (dg) [Entry date 05/10/05 ]
5/10/05 7 ORDER REFERRING MOTION FOR TEMPORARY RESTRAINING ORDER TO MAGISTRATE JUDGE FOR REPORT AND RECOMMENDATION : ORDER OF REFERENCE Referring Motion(s) [2-1] motion for temporary restraining order referred to Magistrate Judge James M . Hopkins, [2-2] motion for preliminary injunction referred to Magistrate Judge James M . Hopkins (signed by Judge Daniel T . K . Hurley on 5/10/05) [EOD Date : 5/11/05] (pa) [Entry date 05/11/05 ]

http ://pacer . fl sd .uscourts .gov/dc/cgi-bin/pacer740 .pl

8/15/2005

CU.S . 9:05-cv-80393-DTKH ER Documentk71Repo rt ase District Court Web PAC N2 .4) Doc et Entered on FLSD Docket 08/18/2005

Pagee53of 9 Pag of 7

5/12/05 8 ORDER SETTING EVIDENTIARY HEARING HEARING ON PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION (DE2)ORDER Motion hearing before Magistrate Judge James M . Hopkins set for 11 :00 5/23/05 for [2-1] motion for restraining order, set for 11 :00 5/23/05 for [2-2] motion for preliminary injunction (Signed by Magistrate Judge James M . Hopkins on 5/12/05) [EOD Date : 5/13/05] (pa) [Entry date 05/13/05 ]
.'P lam/'

//nc

n

.'

LV J11l..L V1 QI.l.V111CV

dIJIJCdJ III :C 11)1

.)Ik-VCII H .

.lI I\/F-.r S l) V

Kenneth R . Hartmann, Gail Ann McQuilkin (pa) [Entry date 05/16/05 ] 5/16/05 10 NOTICE of attorney appearance for Steven A . Silvers by Adam Rabin (ct ) 5/20/05 11 NOTICE of Filing Declaration of Steven A . Silvers by Steven A . Silvers (rb) [Entry date 05/23/05 ] 5/20/05 12 NOTICE of Filing Declaration of Keva Labossiere by Steven A . Silvers (rb) [Entry date 05/23/05 ] 5/20/05 13 MEMORANDUM by Steven A . Silvers in opposition to [2-2] motion for preliminary injunction (rb) [Entry date 05/23/05 ] 5/23/05 -- Motion hearing re : [2-1] motion for temporary restraining order Motion hearing held, [2-2] motion for preliminary injunction Motion hearing held (ck) [Entry date 05/24/05 ]

5/23/05 14 Exhibit list by Stelor Productions, Steven A . Silvers (ck) [Entry date 05/24/05 ] 5/23/05 15 Minutes of Motion hearing re [2-1] & [2-2] motion for temporary restraining order and/or preliminary injunction : held before Magistrate Judge James M . Hopkins on 5/23/05 Court Reporter Name : Phillip May (ck) [Entry date 05/24/05 ] 5/23/05 16 Declaration/Statement of Steven A . Esrig (1h) [Entry date 05/24/05 ]

5/23/05 17 Declaration/Statement of Kevin C . Kaplan (lh) [Entry date 05/24/05 ]
5/23/05 18 REPLY by Stelor Productions, to response to [2-2] motion for preliminary injunction (lh) [Entry date 05/24/05 ] 5/26/05 ( 19 ) MOTION by Steven A . Silversto dismiss for lack of subjec t

matter jurisdiction and standing (rb) [Entry date 05/27/05 ]
5/26/05 20 NOTICE of Filing proposed Report and Recommendation Denying Plaintiffs motion for preliminary injunction by Steven A . Silvers (rb) [Entry date 05/27/05 ] 5/26/05 21 NOTICE of Filing Supplemental Declaration of keva Labossiere by Steven A . Silvers (rb) [Entry date 05/27/05 ] 5/26/05 22 MOTION by Stelor Productions to strike [Entry date 05i27i05 ] [ 21-1] notice (bs)

6/1/05 ( 23 ) RESPONSE by Steven A . Silvers to [22-1] motion to strik e [21-1] notice of supplemental declaration of Kev a

h ttp ://pacer . flsd .uscourts .gov/dc/cgi-bin/ pacer740 . pl

8/15/2005

CUsS . 9:05-cv-80393-DTKH Document 71 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/18/2005 Page of9 a . e District Court Web PACER(v2 .4) Docket Report Page 4 6 of 7

Labossiere (pa) [Entry date 06/03/05 ]
6/3/05 24 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS of Magistrate Judge James M . Hopkins recommending that [2-2] motion for preliminary injunction, [2-1] motion for temporary restraining order b e GRANTED . Motion no longer referred . Signed on : 6/3/05 Objections to R and R due by 6/13/05 CCAP (ck )
r is Inc fl c
' 5'11 0 -DE1, Dlitv111vV \111VLN rJ L'1VV1 ORDER VC11V111U QJ 1llVVL IG7-1 1 L' 1

motion for clarification of Order granting temporary retraining order (Signed by Judge T . K . Hurley on 6/15/05) [EOD Date : 6/15/05] (pa) [Entry date 06/15/05 ] 6/6/05 26 Transcript filed re : hearing held 5/23/05 before Judge Magistrate James Hopkins Pages : 1-79 (ga )

[Entry date 06/07/05 ]
6/8/05 27 RENEWED EMERGENCY MOTION with memorandum in support by Stelor Productions, for entry of temporary restraining order implementing the injunction recommended by the Magistrate (dg) [Entry date 06/09/05 ]

6/9/05 28 RESPONSE by Steven A . Silvers to [27-1] motion for entry of temporary restraining order implementing the injunction recommended by the Magistrate (mh ) 6/9/05 29 URGENT MOTION by Steven A . Silvers for clarification of Order granting temporary retraining order (Order not found) (wc) [Entry date 06/10/05 ] 6/9/05 30 RESPONSE by Stelor Productions, to [29-1] motion for clarification of Order granting temporary retraining order (mh) [Entry date 06/10/05 ]

6/9/05 31 NOTICE of filing May 23, 2005 Hearing transcript of by Steven A . Silvers (dj) [Entry date 06/10/05 ]
6/9/05 32 ORDER granting [27-1] motion for entry of temporary restraining order implementing the injunction recommended by the Magistrate ; This Order shall remain in full force and effect up to and including WEDNESDAY JUNE 21,2005 Signed by Judge Daniel T . K . Hurley on 06/09/05) [EOD Date : 6/10/05] (rb) [Entry date 06/10/05 ]

6/13/05 3 3

Notice of compliance : by Steven A . Silvers with [32-1] order (tb ) VERIFIED MEMORANDUM OF LAW by Stelor Productions, in opposition to [19-1] motion to dismiss for lack of subject matter jurisdiction and standing (mh) [Entry date 06/14/05 ] ORDER denying [22-1] motion to strike [21-1] notice Signed by Magistrate Judge James M . Hopkins on 06/16/05) [EOD Date : 6/17/05] (dj) [Entry date 06/17/05 ] MOTION by Stelor Productions, (Attorney ) to extend time emergency temporary restraining order implementing preliminary injunction (1k) [Entry date 06/17/05 ] MOTION by Steven A . Silvers to strike declaration o f

6/13/05

http ://pacer .flsd .uscourts .gov/dc/cgi-bin/pacer740 .pl

8/15/2005

CU se District Court Web PACER(v2 .4) Docket Report a .S . 9:05-cv-80393-DTKH Document 71 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/18/2005

Pagee7 of 9 Pag 5 of 7

Steven A . Esrig, set aside Magistrate's findings and report and recommendation, and to vacate [32-1] order (dg) [Entry date 06/17/05 ] 6/16/05 41 NOTICE of depositing funds into Court Registry by Stelor Productions, (sk) [Entry date 06/20/05 ] Filing Fee Paid ; FILING FEE $ 10,000 .00 RECEIPT # 230572
I

6/16/05

--

,KII

7.11 ;

r v ( I l l F' .

l l f) // l l/ l l : l

6/17/05

38

NOTICE of filing declaration of Russell B . Tewsbury by Steven A . Silvers (dg ) Notice of filing attached declaration of Paul Worshaw by Steven A . Silvers (hd )

6/17/05

40

6/17/05

42

NOTICE of by Steven A . Silvers [filing declaration of Gail M . McQuilkin] (dj) [Entry date 06/20/05 ] DECLARATION Re : of Gail A . McQuilkin (dj) [Entry date 06/20/05 ] APPENDIX to : [39-1] motion to strike declaration of Steven A . Esrig by Steven A . Silvers (dj) [Entry date 06/20/05 ] REQUEST by Steven A . Silvers for oral argument or Hearing on [39-1] motion to strike declaration of Steven A . Esrig (dj) [Entry date 06/20/05 ] OBJECTION by Steven A . Silvers to [24-1] report and recommendations, [25-1] report and recommendations (dj) [Entry date 06/20/05 ] RESPONSE by Steven A . Silvers in opposition to [37-1 ] motion to extend time of emergency temporary restraining order implementing preliminary injunction (hd )

6/17/05

43

6/17/05

44

6/17/05

45

6/17/05

46

6/17/05

47

[Entry date 06/20/05 ]
6/20/051 48 ) REPLY by Steven A . Silvers to response to [19-1] motion t o dismiss for lack of subject matter jurisdiction and standing (wc) [Entry date 06/21/05 ] ORDER EXENDING TEMPORARY RESTRAINING ORDER : ORDER denying [37-1] motion to extend time emergency temporary restraining order implementing preliminary injunction . The temporary restraining order shall remain in full force and effect up through the end of the International Trade Show in New York up through and including 6/24/05 (Signed by Judge Daniel T . K . Hurley on [EOD Date : 6/22/05] (pa ) ) SUPPLEMENT by Steven A . Silvers to : [39-1] motion t o strike declaration of Steven A . Esrig (ct) [Entry date 06/27/05 ] ) OBJECTION by Steven A . Silvers to (24-1] report an d reco mm endations , [ 25-1] report and reco mm endations (ct) [ sntry date 06%27/05 1 MOTION by Steven A . Silvers (Attorney ) to seal exhibit F n appendix to Silvers' objections to Magistrate report and

6/22/05

49

6/24/05( 50

6/24/05 (

50

6/24/05

51

http ://pacer .flsd .uscourts .gov/dc/cgi-bin/pacer740 .pl

8/15/2005

CU.S . 9:05-cv-80393-DTKH Document 71Report ase District Court Web PACER(v2.4) Docket Entered on FLSD Docket 08/18/2005

Pagee86of 9 Pag of 7

recommednation and exhibit F to declaration of Gail A . McQuilkin (ct) [Entry date 06/27/05 ]

7/1/05 53 NOTICE of filing supplemental declaration of Steven A . Esrig by Stelor Productions (kw) [Entry date 07/06/05 ]
7/1/05 54 RESPONSE TO SILVERS' REQUEST FOR ORAL ARGUMENT OR HEARING ON SILVERS' OBJECTION TO REPORT AND RECOMMENDATION b y
. I I H I O r Pr crr ii it · i irrr i .V kw·i iI r i i rv (i i i F' Cr/iCin"/ii i

7/1/05 55 RESPONSE by Stelor Productions in opposition to [50-1] objection (kw) [Entry date 07/06/05 ]
7/1/05 56 RESPONSE by Stelor Productions to [39-1] motion to strike declaration of Steven A . Esrig (kw) [Entry date 07/06/05 ]

7/1/05 57 NOTICE of filing supplemental declaration of Kevin Kaplan by Stelor Productions (kw) [Entry date 07/06/05 ]
7/1/05 58 SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION OF KEVIN C . KAPLAN (kw) [Entry date 07/06/05 ] 7/1/05 59 NOTICE of filing declaration of Martin Jeffrey by Stelor Productions (kw) [Entry date 07/06/05 ] 7/5/05 52 ORDER REJECTING IN PART AND APPROVING IN PART MAGISTRATE'S REPORT AND RECOMMENDATION ON PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION adopting [24-1] report and recommendations denying [2-1] motion for temporary restraining order, denying [2-2] motion for preliminary injunction, mooting [45-1] motion for oral argument or Hearing on [39-1] motion to strike declaration of Steven A . Esrig, mooting [39-1] motion to strike declaration of Steven A . Esrig, mooting [39-2] motion set aside Magistrate's findings and report and recommendation, mooting [39-3] motion to vacate [32-1] order, denying [51-1] motion to seal exhibit F n appendix to Silvers' objections to Magistrate report and recommednation and exhibit F to declaration of Gail A . McQuilkin ( Signed by Judge Daniel T . K . Hurley on 7/2/05) [EOD Date : 7/6/05] CCAP (kw) [Entry date 07/06/05 ]

7/6/05 25 Error in dockting . Docket #25 was a duplicate of #24 . (pa ) 7/8/05 60 RESPONSE by Steven A . Silvers to [39-3] motion to vacate [32-1] order (aj )
7/8/05 61 MOTION by Stelor Productions (Attorney ) for reconsideration of [52-1] order (dj) [Entry date 07/11/05 ] 7/18/05 62 REPLY by Stelor Productions to response to [61-1] motion for reconsideration of [52-1] order (cj ) 7/18/05 63 NOTICE of by Stelor Productions filing second supplemental declaration of Steven A Esrig (dj) [Entry date 07/19/05 ] 7/21/05 64 URDER denying [6i-1] motion for reconsideration of [52-11 order ( Signed by Judge Daniel T . K . Hurley on 07/21/05) [EOD Date : 7/21/05] (rb)

http ://pacer .flsd .uscourts .gov/dc/cgi-bin/pacer740 .pl

8/15/2005

CU.S . 9:05-cv-80393-DTKH Document 71Report ase District Court Web PACER N2.4) Docket Entered on FLSD Docket 08/18/2005

Page e 7of 9 Pag 9 of 7

7/22/05 65 NOTICE OF INTERLOCUTORY APPEAL of [64-1] order, [52-1] order . EOD Date : 7/6/05 ; Filing Fee : $ FEE NOT PAID ; ; Copies to USCA and Counsel of Record . (ga )

[Entry date 08/01/05 ] 8/4/05 66 USCA appeal fees received Re : [65-1] appeal Filing Fee $ 255 .00 Receipt # 925051 (ga )
8/8/05 67 ORDER granting [19-1] motion to dismiss for lack of subject matter jurisdiction and standing ( Signed by Judge Daniel T . K . Hurley on 08/06/05) [EOD Date : 8/9/05] (rb )

[Entry date 08/09/05 ]
8/9/05 68 Transcript Information Form re : as to Stelor Productions [65-1] appeal . No transcript requested . All necessary transcripts are already on file . (nc) [Entry date 08/11/05 ] 8/11/05 69 NOTICE of Receipt of Notice of Appeal Transmittal Letter from USCA on 8/4/05 Re : [65-1] appeal USCA NUMBER : 05-14258-I (ga) [Entry date 08/12/05 ]

Case Flags : JM H INTAPP

END OF DOCKET : 9 :05cv8039 3

PACER Service Cente r
Transaction Receip t
08/15/2005 17 :41 :4 0 PACER Login : kt0009 Client Code : Description : 11docketreport Search Criteria : 13339-10 3 19 :05cv8O39 3

Billable Pages : 8 11cost :

0 .64

http ://pacer .flsd .uscourts .gov/dc/cgi-bin/pacer740 .pl

8/15/2005