Winn-Dixie Stores, Inc. et al v. Dolgencorp, LLC
Filing
513
ORDER granting (206) Motion in Limine in case 9:11-cv-80601-DMM; granting (178) Motion in Limine in case 9:11-cv-80638-DMM. Signed by Judge Donald M. Middlebrooks on 5/8/2012. Associated Cases: 9:11-cv-80601-DMM, 9:11-cv-80638-DMM(sw)
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
SO UTH ERN D I
STRI T O F FLO R I
C
DA
Cas N o.9: - ve
11 c 80601- M
DM
C ons i e w ih Cas N o.9: 80638- M ,
oldat d t
e
11DM
C as N o 9: e . 11 80641 D M M
-
W I N- XI STORES,l , ta ,
N DI E
NC.e 1
Pli if ,
antfs
DOLENCORP,
LLC,fk/ DOLENCORP,
/ a
1 , Ke uc c or ton,
NC.a nt y op ai
De e nt
f nda .
/
O RDER GRANTI DOLG ENCORP.LLC' M OTI I LI I WO PRECLUDE
NG
S
ON N M NE
PLAI FFS FROM I
NTI
NTRO DUCI EVI
NG
DENCE RELATI TO THE LOUI ANA
NG
SI
S
TURES
THI CAUSE c e be or t Cour upon Dol nc r LLC' M o i l Li ne t
S
om s f e he
t
ge o p,
S ton n mi o
Prcu ePlitfsfo Ito u i gEvd n e ltn ot Lo iin Str s f oi n'(
e l d an if r m n r d cn i e c Reaigt he usa a o e (û to ' DE20 )
M
)
6
fld on Fe ua y 2,201 1ha r viwe t ma tra a ad s d i t pr m ie .
ie
br r
2. ve e e d he te nd m vi e n he e s s
Dola Ge r la kst sCo t opr c udeW i Di efom i r i e de ea t fve
l r ne a s hi ur t e l
nn- xi r ntoduc ng vi nc s o i
Dola Ge r sor l a e i Louiinabe us Louii nal w doe not ovi ac us o a ton
lr ne al t es oc t d n
sa
ca e
sa a
s pr de a e f c i
frW in Dii t s eDo lrGe ea f rvoaigisgo eye cu i e .( 2 6a 2)
o n - xe o u la n rl o iltn t r c r x l sv s DE 0 t .
TheSupr m eCour ofLouii naa e s dt sis i feon dv Lavi ,1 So. 341
e
t
sa ddr s e hi s ue n
ar . gne 62 2d
( 1 .I fe d,hepli ifo aedasr c sato unde al s e uedbyEli a
La. 964) n onar t antf pert evie t in
r eae xec t
ls nd
Rut Thi ux.l a 342.Thel a ec t i asi ai n t tl s or bound çhems l ,her
h boda
d t
e s on aned tpulto ha e s s
l
t
eves t i
h isa d a sg sn tt s l o la ealo a yp r o tea j i n prpe t o d b t m t
er n sin o o el r e s l r n a t f h donig o ry wne y he o
an
yonewho wou denga i ac
l
ge n ompe ii busnes durngt pe i oft l a e, ndnot odo s
ttve i s i he rod he e s a
t
o
te ev s. .' I Plit fflds i a an tFoy a dMa g rt v g etoe j i te fo
h ms le . . d ani ie ut g is l d n r ae La in t n on h m r m
'
f
t
c tuc i o r tng,or mant i ng a fli sa i ac os t hi
onsr tng, pe a i
i a ni
ilng tton r s he ghwa fom hi on l nd
y r
m
a
ptr s d fom M r a M r Thi ux i t s s
lcha e r
. nd s. boda n hi ame ta ts eq ntt t dae ofhi l a e
r c ubs ue o he t
s es,
cl m i t swasvi atveofhi las c r t' I Thus i Le
ai ng hi
ol i
s e e ontac .' d
, n onar a i t sca e t pli if
d, s n hi s , he antf
s
oughtt e or e atr ofisla epr ve tng ot r fom c
o nf c e m
t e s e ni
he s r
onduc i c ti a tviy a i tt
tng era n c i t gans he
t r pa t al d t bevi a i t t r nott l or who wasa pa t t t l a e.
hid- ry lege o
oltng hat e m,
he andl d
ry o he e s
TheSupr meCour ofLouiinar viwedt a lt c tsdec sont tçhesi a i
e
t
sa e e
he ppela e our' ii ha ç tpulton
t
i pli ifslas wa aco na r ng wih t lnd,a a s h, ndi on t La g
n antf e e s ve nt unni
t he a
nd, s uc bi ng he vi nes
' I a 3 The s e ec t edt tt a lt c tr ledon i u e ofc mon 1w
' d t 42.
upr m our not ha he ppela e our e i
ç l s om
r
a
j s r d n e. .hajaen t o toln u e o rs se o cvla p riu al sn eweh v
mi p u e c .l t r o c nr lig nd r u y tm f i ilw, a t lry ic
t
c
ae
c lpr sonst t et t c r r ' I at3 Thes emec t ot t t mde Louii na
oda ovii ha ar o he onta y. d
'
43.
upr
our f md ha t r
sa
cvi lw,oblga i t ta e at che t i
i la
i tons ha r ta d o mmove bl pr ry a e cal d ç e o i tons. f
a e ope t r le s al blga i ' #.
r
'
E s r a o lg to . , a bee tb ih d o y b atte ...( h ra o iain mu tb
ç e e l b iains . c n sa ls e nl y il. T)e e l bl to s e
The
g
c e ry a r ntfom t tte doc nt t
l a l ppa e r he il
ume s hems l s The si a i i t c r c o la edoes
e ve .
tpulton n he onta t f e s
notc eaear loblgai u t l nd is l, i cl ryan o i ton t l s spl c d upon
r t ea i ton pon he a te f but s ea l
blga i he es or a e
t
hems l . I The c ur f
eves' d
'
o t ound t tt pli ifc dnotenf cet si ai i t c r c
ha he antf oul
or he tpulton n he onta t
a i tt La gne ,at
ga ns he vi s lhough i no e t tt r we ec ti cr m sa e i whi i co d be.
t t d ha he e r era n icu t nc s n ch t ul
Th S c n Co r o Ap e l fLo sa ar vstdteis ei Wo v No t S r vpo t
e e o d u t f p a o uiin e iie h su n # . rh h e e r
De eo n Co , 2 S . d 1 ( . dDCA 1 6 ) l Wo ,h plitfsW of ' F miyS o
v lpme t .2 8 o 2 48 La 2
9 9 . n # te an if le s n l h e
So e fld s i a an tc -e a t i is s o pig c ne s e ig t n ij n t n a ans b t
tr ie ut g is otn ns n t h p n e tr e kn ç nu ci g i t oh
a
o
d fn a t p o iiig a e j nn t c n iu d o eain ofte ça u ls o i azalg d
ee d ns r hb t nd noiig he o tn e p r t
n
o
h c s a h p' n l l e
e
vi a i ofanonc
olton
ompeii e tr i pl ntfs las ....'I a 1
ttv e m n ai if ' e e
' d t 49.Pli if ope atd as e
antf s r e ho
so ei a s
t r n hoppi c nt rund a as i nm e of a l s f o t s
ng e e
er n s g nt
ea e r m he hoppi c nt r o r t . I
ng e e pe a or d
2
Thus pli if s
, a ntfs oughtt e or e a tr i t rlas a ns a t r pa t a lge y vi l tng i.
o nf c e m n hei e e gai t hid- ry le dl o a i t
Not bl t ç i na las and isa sgnme a e d y r c de i t co ya e r c ds' I
a y, he d gi l e e
or
t si
nt r ul e or d n he nve nc e or .' d
Thelas pr vi d t t
e e o de ha :
Les ora e t t ot rs c i Sou hsdeVilgeSho ngCe e s l beus d
s gr es ha no he pa e n t i
la
ppi
nt r ha l
e
f t prma y pur eofo r tng a s sor durng t efeci t r ora
or he i r
pos
pe a i
hoe t e i he f tve e m
ny
e e i oft sl s upon t c ton, owhih Les e a e ,ha Les orm a
xt nson hi ea e,
he ondii t
c
s e gr es t t s
y
fom tmet tmeau horzeot rl s e t s l s
r i oi
t i he e s es o e l hoesi de a t t s eofot
nci nt l o he al
her
mer ha s .
c ndi e
1 Thec t onsde e é henaur ofpli if 'rght unde t con r c o las ,ha i, t
d.
our c i r d '
t
te
antfs i s
r he ta t f e e t t s wheher
s h rght a er alr ngwiht lnd, pe s l' 1 a 50.I f
uc i s r e , unni
t he a or r ona . d. t
'
t ound t f her a oblgai
hat f e l i ton
t
m us be c e ry a r ntfom t ttedocume st m s ves The si a i i t c r tof
t l a l ppa e r he il
nt he el .
tpulton n he ontac
las d snotc e t a r aloblga i upon t lnd is l,buti ce l an oblgai t l s or
e e oe
rae e
i ton
he a t ef
s lary
i ton he e s s
plce upon t m s ves Cons que l whaeve rghtt pl ntf has f t br ac oft s
a d
he el .
e nty, t r i he ai if
or he e h
hi
oblgai mus be e r i e a ns hi ls or . I a 1 .
i ton
t xe c s d gai t s e s s' d t 51
'
W im- xi sLouiina sor las sco an t f l ng caus
z Di e'
sa t e e e nti he olowi l e:
Landl d c na sa ag ee t tTe nts lhavet e l i rg t
or ove nt nd r s ha na hal
he xc usve i ht o
oper t as ma ke i t s ppi c nt ra a enlr m e t r of
ae uper r t n he ho ng e e nd ny a ge nt he e .
La or f t rcove nt a a e t ti wilno die l ori r c l l s
ndl d urhe
na s nd gr es ha t l t r cty ndie ty ea e
orr n a pr ry l a e wihi t s
e t ny ope t oc t d t n he hoppi c t r orwihi 1 f tofan
ng en e ,
t n 000 ee
y
e e irbounda y t r of f oc upa y asas r a ke ,g oc r sor m e t
xtro
r he e , or c nc
upe m r t r e y t e, a ,
fs orvegea em a ke ,no wilt La or pe mi a t na torocc nto
ih
tbl r t r l he ndl d r t ny e n
upa f
a y s h pr t t s blti a mam e ,die l ori r c l a pa tt r of
n uc opery o u e n ny l r r cty ndie ty, ny r he e
t a pe s fr o c por ton e ge i a s h busne swihoutwrte
o ny r on, im r or ai nga d n ny uc
i s t
itn
pe m ison oft Te nt a La or f t rc na sa a r e nott pe t
r si
he na ; nd ndl d urhe ove nt nd g e s
o nni
ors f ranypr ry l a e wihi t s
ufe
ope t oc t d t n he hoppi ce e t beus d f or
ng ntr o
e or
oc upi d by a busnes de i i orwhi s l ke p i soc or s l f of
c e
ny i s alng n
ch hal e n t k
el or f
pr miesco umpton any sa eorf nc gr res mea s fs veg t bls
e s
ns
i
t pl
a y oce i , t ,i h, e a e ,
fuis ba r go ,daiypr duc so foz n f
r t , ke y ods r o t r r e oodswihoutwrte pe mi son of
t
itn r s i
t Te nt
he na .
3
( 61a 5)1Thelas aloc ai aclus pr di
DE t .
e es s ont n a e ovi ng:
Thi las and a1oft cove nt a pr sonst r ofs l i e t t be i
se e
1 he
na s nd ovii he e ha l nur o he neft
ofa bebi ng upon t her ,l ga r pr en a i ,s c s sa as i of
nd
ndi
he is e l e es t tves uc es or nd sgns
t pa te he eo.Ea h pr vi i he e s l bedee d bot ac
he ri s r t
c o son r of ha l
me
h ovena a a
nt nd
c ton and s l r wiht l nd.
ondii
hal un t he a
(d a 9 .Th s c v na t aesmia t t c v na ti Le n r i ta te a ec v na t
1 t ) e e o e n s r i lr o he o e n n o a d n h t h y r o e ns
be we n t lndl d a t na and bi t i isa as i .'Li t c na si fe
t e he a or nd e nt
nd he t r nd sgns' ke he ove nt n onar
he
d
a d Wo ,W in Di i' c v n n a p ast b a o lg t n telso spa e u o
n #
n - xe s o e a t p e r o e n biai h e s r lc d p n
o
t msl s Themanditnci i t tW i Di e' la e saet tlll c pr sonhee
he eve .
i si ton s ha nn- xi s e s s tt ha te a h ovii rof
s al ed e db t ac ve a ta dac n to a ds al wi t eln ' (d a 9 .W in
h l b e me oh o n n n o di n n h lnm t h a d. 1 . t ) n i
h
'
Di ea guest tt scaus s
xi r
ha hi l e howst tt gr e y e l i wa i e
ha he oc r xcusve s nt ndedt r n wih t l nd
o u t he a
a t i e orea ea i tDefnda .( 249a 5) Howe r t cour i feo dhel
nd hus s nf c bl gans e nt DE
t .
ve ,he tn nar d
t t1 cla l e e s i enton't tac na r wih t l wasnots fc e t c e t
ha ç e ry xpr s ed nt i ' ha ove nt un t he and
a
ufii nt o r a e
ac e ntr nni wih t lnd a t tf her loblga i mus be ce l a e fom t
ov na u ng t he a nd ha i ea i ton
t
t lary ppar nt r he
tte do
il cume st m s ve .'fe
nt he el s' onar 1 So. a 342- s e alo U- rv Per eu and
d, 62 2d t
43; e s se e tol m
I v sme t, n . . mb e 4 6S 2 8 1 8 4( .1tDCA 1 8 )(ç r l saigta a
n e t ns I c v Ca r , 8 o. d 2 , 2 La s
9 6 t ey ttn h t
Me
co r c i t iun wih t lnd'doe notc e ei
nta t s o l
'
t he a
s
r at mmovabl rg s ... Alhough t c r ti
e i ht .
t
he ontac n
quesi saed t ti wa t su wih t l nd, i wasi f c ape s lc r ct... a ei
ton t t ha t s o r n t he a ' t
n a t r ona onta
bec us t
fv r dtep ro . . n no ad mia tett.)(iain o te l.Th s wh l t sca s
a o e h e s n . a d t o n n sae' ctto s mitd ) u , ie hi lu e
'
m a bes fcentt cr a ear alc
y
ufi i o e t e ovena r nni wih t lnd unde Fl rdal w,i i not
nt u ng t he a
r oi a ts
s fcintunde Louii nal
ufi e
r
s a aw.Ac r i y,Ifnd t tW i Di e' g oc r excusve
co d ngl i ha nn- xi s r e y l i s
c a ne i isLouiina sor l a i a enote o c a eag i tDola Ge r la i i
onti d n t
sa t e oc tons r
nf r e bl a ns
lr ne a nd t s
Thr ofW i D i e' l esalow com pett st s lup t 500 s e f ofs es
ee
nn- xi s eas l
ior o el o
quar eet al
ar ofgr i
ea
oceres.
he e
r by
ORDERED AND ADJ
UDGED t a Dee da tsMo in( 2 6 i GRANTED.l i
h t fn n ' to DE 0 ) s
ts
f rhe
ut r
ORDERED AND ADJ
UDGED ta Dee d n ' M oin i Ca eNo. 1c 8 63 (
h t fn a ts t n s
o
1 -v- 0 8 DE
1 )i GRANTED.
78 s
DONE AND ORDERED i Cha r a W es Pal Bea h,Fl i ,t s
n
mbe s t
t m
c orda hi
dayof
M a 201
y, 2.
C:
C
Cou elofRe r
ns
co d
ALD .M I
DDLEBROOKS
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI J
CT UDGE
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?