Microspherix LLC v. Biocompatibles, Inc.
Filing
44
ORDER DENYING 33 Motion to Change Venue. Signed by Judge K. Michael Moore on 1/24/2012. (rg1)
I TH E UM TED STATES DI
N
STRI COURT
CT
FO R THE SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
Cm e N o.9: 1 c 8081 KM M
s
1 - v3-
MI
CROSPHERI LLC,
X
Pl ntf,
ai if
VS.
BI
OCOM PATI
BLES,l ,
NC.
De e nt
f nda .
ORDER DENYI DEFENDANT' M OTI TO TM NSFER VENUE
NG
S
ON
THI CAUSE c mebeo et eCo r u o Dee d n ' M oi nt Trn frVe ue(
S
a
f r h u t p n fn a ts to o a se n ECF
No. 3 . Pli tf fld a Re p n e( No. 9 , n De e d n fld a Re l ( Nos 41
3 ) anif ie
s o s ECF
3 ) a d fn a t ie
py ECF . ,
43 1 . Th Mo in i n w rp f rrviw. UPON CONS DEM TI o t e M oin,t e
- ) e to s o ie o e e
I
ON f h
to h
Res e a Re y,t pe tne pori oft Re or a beng ot r s f ly a s d i
pons nd pl he ri nt tons he c d, nd i
he wie u l dvie n
t pr mies t Cour e e st f l ng Or r
he e s ,he
t nt r he olowi
de .
1 BACKGROUND 1
.
The M oto t Tr ns e Ve c r nty be or t Cour a ie wihi t c e ofa
i n o a f r nue ur e l f e he
t rs s t n he ontxt
c vi a ton f pa e i rnge nt Thepaen i que to , Unie St t Pa e No.7, 31
i l c i or t nt nfi me .
t t n si n
t d aes t nt
776, 0
Cte ' 0 p tn ' c ves a n w t p o b a h hea y ç e d' o sr n o s e s
ç 31 ae f) o r
h
e y e f r c yt rp ç e , r ta d f e d .
s '
Br c he a i a f m of r diton t r py. Conta y t c
a hyt r py s or
a a i he a
r r o onve i l f m s of r diton
ntona or
a ai
t ea y, eer dain i d lv r dt t bo y vae tm a p oe to b a h t rp uiie
h rp wh r a ito s eiee o he d i xe l rj cin, r c yhea y tlz s
s ls e t ta e i a ed i t die ed ts ue The r diton i t r or l alze t t
mal e ds ha r mpl nt n he s as is .
a a i s he ef e oc i d o he
diea e a e a heat tsue i no lnne s a iy dn
s s d r a, nd lhy is s t l ce s rl mage . The ' 0 pa e de ais a ne
d
31 t nt t l
w
lThe f t he ei a e t ken fom De e
acs r n r a
r
f ndants M o i t Tr nserVenue;Pli irsRes e
'
ton o a f
antf
pons
;
a Def nda ' Re y.
nd
e nt s pl
1
b a hyt r py sr nd of s e t t i e a tc, te bl a bi g a bl The sr nd i
r c he a
ta
e ds ha s l si l xi e, nd ode r da e.
ta
s
pr e a e t e si te t nt op i be a e i c n ç ovi hi r a m or c it nt
ef r bl o xitng r a me
tons c us t a ç
pr de ghe nd
e onsse
c
once r tons ofa t r peutcal a tve s t nce t a t r tts ue,' whie a t s me tme
nta i
he a i ly c i ubsa
o a ge is ' l t he a
i
ei nai t en e f rmutpes e ij ci n .P1' Re p Ex A, t1 ( No. 4 1. Th
lmi t h e d o lil e d ne to s .s s . . a 4 ECF 3 - ) e
ng
sr nd ma a s be i plnt d i a ea of t bod ta tonal unr e i t e si
ta
y lo
m a e n r s
he
y r dii ly
ec ptve o xitng
br c he apy s ds
a hyt r
ee .
Plitf M ir s h rx LLC (M ir s h rx 6 i aFlrd c mo ain wi isp icp l
anif c o p e i
t co p ei 1 s o ia o r t
t
)
o t t rn ia
h
plceofbusnes i Bo Raon, Fl i M ir phe i wa a sgne t rght tte,a i er s
a
i s n ca t
orda. c os rx s s i d he i , il nd nt e t
i t ' 0 paen by Dr Edwa d Ka a t i n or of t ' 0 pa e , ow ner of
n he 31
t t
.
r
pln- he nve t
he 31
t nt
M ir phe i a f
c os rx, nd ounde of 1 t Li Onc ogy, a c e te t nt c nt r
r
s ne
ol
anc r r a me e e .
Def nda
e nt
Bic mp t e ,I .(t o o tbls' i a Dea
o o ai s nc E c mpai e ' s
bl
Bi
)
lwre Co p rto wih isp icpl pa e o
r o ai n t t rn i e lc f
busne si Oxf r Conne i ut Bi om paies t o h isBr c
i s n
o d,
ctc . oc
tl , hr ug t a hysc e sdi son, de l ps
i nce vii
ve o
a m a a m r s br hyt r py de ce f t team e ofpr t t ca r Bi ompa i e
nd nuf c e ac he a
vi s or he r t nt
osae nce . oc
tbl s
a quie is ç hor d' t hnol y a t Br c i nc tadi nn e fom Ga y A .
c rd t ç
Anc see ' ec og nd he a hsc e es r ng m r
r
La u e x ft e o Br c ce c s I c (BSI) a d W o l W i e M e ia Te l o is
mo r u , omd r f a hs in e , n . ç ' , n
t '
rd d
dc l cmolge ,
I c CW o l W ie'.
n . ç rd d '
)
On J y 1 2011 M i r phe i c
ul 4,
c os rx omm e d t i t nta to a i tBi ompai e .
nce he nsa c i n gans oc
tbl s
M ir phe i s Am e d Compl i aleg t t Bi om pai es ç ho see ' pr t
c os rx'
nde
ant l es ha
oc
tbl ' ç
Anc r d' oduc
i rnge M ir phe i s 5 0 pa e . Bi om pai es now s ks t ta f r t a ton t t
nfi s c os rx' 31 t nt oc
tbl
et o r ns e he c i o he
DititofConneci .
src
tcut
I LEG A L STA ND A RD
I.
Til 28U. C.j 1 a pr vi st tçf t co ninc oft pa tesa whne s ,
te
S.
404() o de ha tor he nve e e he ri nd
ses
a di t itr sso j sie adsrc c u t yta fra ycv l cint a yohe d src o
n n he n ee t f u tc , itit o r ma rnse n ii a to o n t r itit r
2
di son whe e i mi htha bee b oug ort a dititordi son t whih a1 pa te ha
vii
r t g
ve n r ht o ny src
vi i o c l ri s ve
c nsn e . 2 U. C.j 1 0 ()(sn n e b Th Fe ea Co rs Jlidito a d Ve u
o e td' 8 S.
'
4 4 a a me d d y e d r l u t l s cin n n e
r
Clrt a i Ac of2011 Pub.L.No.11 63, j 2 4,1 Sa .7 8 7 4 . The sa d r f r
a ik ton t
,
20 25 tt 5 , 6 )
tn ad o
ta se t e j 1 0 a gve b o d ds rto t t etilc u ta d atilc u tsd cso wil
rn fr md r 4 4() i s r a icein o h ra o r, n ra o r' e iin l
beo t r d onl f ra eofdic e i . M ms v.SmihKlne Be chn ClnialLa ., 1 F.
veru ne
y o bus
s r ton
on
t i
e m ic
bs 46
S p .2 1 5 ,1 8( . F a 2 01 ( i n Br wn v. .Ge .LieI s Co,9 4 F.d 1 9 ,
u p d 3 5 35 SD. l. 0 ) ct g o
i
Ct n f n . . 3 2 1 3
1 9 ( 1h Ci.1 91 ( o dn t tt etilc u tdd n ta u e isds rto i ta se rn a
1 7 1 t r 9 ) h l ig ha h ra o r i o b s t icein n r n frig
c s t a wo l i o efn nca h r s i o apat n matrwh r iwa h ad )
a e h t ud mp s i a il ad hp n ry o te ee t s e r l.
The que ton ofwhe he t ta f rve i vol a t pr
si
t r o r ns e nue n ves wo- onge i r . M as 1
d nquiy
on, 46
F.Supp.2d a 1
t 359. The fr tpr hol t tt ale a i ve u us be one i whi h t
is ong ds ha he t m tve nue m t
n
c he
a ton c d orgi ly ha be br
c i oul i nal ve en oughtby t pli tf.' I 2 The s cond pr r quies
he a n if ' d.
e
ong e r
Co rst t aa c p iaea d p bl fco s't d tr n wh t e o n tta se i j siid
u t o t ln e rv t n u i a t r' o eemie eh r r o rn fr s u tfe .
b
c
I ; e as 28U.. j 1 4a .ç fn nsmo ig frta se ha aheg tn d b r e a
d.s e lo
SC. 40 () ç e da t vn o r n fr ve ih e e u d n s
De
t y mus pr w11 pa tc a iy t i onve e c us d by t pl ntt choi off u .''
he
t ove t1 riulrt he nc
nince a e
he ai irs
ce or m
M a o 1 6 F.S p 2 a 1 9 (ii M c iv v S n a ose Co,8 8 F. p .3 7 3
s n, 4
u p. d t 35 ctng Ev l . u be m- tr . 7 Su p 3 , 45
( R..1 9 :.Co s q e ty ta se wi o l b g a td wh r t eb ln eofc n e in eo
D. I 9 4
n e u n l,r n f r l ny e r ne e e h aa c
l
o v ne c f
2 O n Dec m be 7, 2011 The Fede a CoursJ idi ton a Venue Clrfcai Ac of2011
e r
,
rl
t urs ci nd
a ii ton t
wa sgne i o lw,a on J nua y 6, 2 t 1 w t efec . The ne 1 a nds28U . C.
s i d nt a nd
a r 201 he a ook f t
w aw me
S.
j 1 4() b i e t g t wo d ç r t a y dsrc o dv so t whih alpa t s h v
40 a y nsri he r s ç o n itit r iii n o c l ri a e
n
o
e
c e e ' tt endoft ls s ntnc ofj 1 a .Pub.L. 11 63,j204,1 Stt 758,
onsntd'a he
he a t e e e
404()
No. 225 a.
76 ( 1 . The n nd ntt pemisdititco t t ta fraci la ton no ony t a
4 201 )
me me hus r t src urs o r nse
vi ci t l o
ve whe et a ton co d ha be orgi ly br
nue
r he c i
ul ve en i nal oughtby t pli if buta s t avenuet
he a ntf,
lo o
o
whih alpa te ha c e e The quesi of whehe t ta f r ve
c 1 ri s ve ons nt d.
ton
t r o r nse nue i sil a t
s tl wo-
p o g di q iy b tt efrtp o i n w dsu cie Th ,heatmai ev n emus b o e
r n e n ur , u h is r ng s o i n tv . us t l tv e u
j
e
te n
i whih t aci coul orgi ly ha be n br
n c he ton
d i na l ve e oughtby t pli iforonet whi h a1 pari
he antf
o c l tes
ha c e ed. n e s co pr r r Co t t ba a e prva e a publc f c or t
ve ons nt
e nd ong equies urs o l nc i t nd
i at s o
d tr n wh t e o n tta fri j siid Ast eAc o ya pl st a to c mme c d o
eemie eh r r o rnse s u tfe . h t nl p i o cins o n e n
e
ora rJ nua y 6,
he a r 2012, heame e i i pplc bl t t i t ntca e.
t
ndm nt s na ia e o he nsa
s
3
tep ristto l fvo s' h d fn a t l .(iig Ro i s n v. amac & Bil P. , 4
h a t ç r ngy a r't e ee d n . d ctn b n o Gir ro
e s
l. C.7
F.d25 , 6 ( 1hCi.1 9 :.
3 3 2 0 1t r 9 6
1 1 ANALYSI
1.
S
Thi Cour frtt kesup a a l i ofe c pr
s
t s a
n nayss
a h ong,be or c i rng t r l va of
f e onsde i he e e nce
t f um- eeci n ca e diput d by t pa te
ht or s l to lus s e
he ri s.
A,
ç rci lyBr ht'
r i nal oug '
Til 2 U. C.j 1 3 ()g a t d srd c u t o ii l u idcin ç fa y cv la to
te 8 S.
3 8 a rn s iti o rs rgna j rs ito ç n ii ci n
o
aii t e a yAc o Co r s r ltn t ()pae t' l s c a to sv n i p o e tnte
rsng md r n t f nge s eaig o a tn. n u h cin e ue s r p r ç h
'
i
j dca dsrc wh r t e d f n a trsd s o wh r te d fn a t h s c mmitd a t o
u iil itit ee h ee d n e ie , r e e h e e d n m o te cs f
ifig me t a d h s a r g lr a d etb ihe plc of b sn s. 28 U. C. j1 0 ( .
n rn e n n a
e ua n sa ls d a e
u ie s'
'
S.
4 0b)
Bi
ocompa i es prncpl plce ofbusnes i i Oxf d,Cor c i ta i i t ont se t t
tbl ' i i e a
i ss n
or
me tcu nd t s mc e t d ha
Bi co ailsr sd si teDitito Co n ciu .S e2 U. C. 1 0 ()(sa n e b
o mp tbe ei e n h src f n e tc t e 8 S. j 4 4 a m me d d y
TheFe r CoursJ iditon a Ve Clrfcain Ac of2011 Pub.L. 11 63,j202,
deal t urs ci nd nue aii to t
,
No. 2-
1 5S a. 5 , 6 )C ral e u p r o e . . ne tt wihtec pa i t s ea db s e i
2 tt 7 8 7 4 To l v n e u p s s . a n i t h a ct o u n e u d n
y
y
iscommon na t ra i a e lw,whe he orno i
t
me mde pplc bl a
t r
t ncom o aed,s lbe dee
r t hal
med t r i e,
o esd
i ad fn a t i a yj d ca dsrc i whc s c d fn n i s be tt t ec u tsp ro a
f ee d n , n n u iil itit n ih u h ee da t s u j c o h o r' e s n l
j rs ito wihrs e tt tecvi a to i q e to . .) us Plitf c ul h vefldt e
u idcin t e p c o h i l cin n u sin .'.Th , anif o d a ie h
'
i t ntcvi a ton i t DititofConnec iut a t r f r tans e i pe m isbl pr de
nsn i l c i n he src
tc , nd he e o e r f r s r s i e ovi d
t a ta se ij siida e i e b a a ay i o p bl a dp iaefco s
h t rn f r s u tfe s vnc d y n n l ss f u i n rv t a tr .
c
K
Publca PrvaeFa t s
i nd i t cor
l M a u lv.Co v r y Co p,4 0 F.d 1 3 ( 1h Ci.2 0 ) t Elv nh Cic i
n ne
n eg s r . 3 3 1 2 1 t r 0 5 , he e e t rut
lse a numberof publc a prvae f t s r l va t deer ne whehe o notta f r i
itd
i nd i t acor e e nt o t mi
t r r
r ns e s
j siidt e j 1 0 () Th s fco si cu e
u tfe md r 4 4 a. e e a tr n ld :
4
( )te c n e in e o tewi se ;()tel c to o r lv n d c me t a d
1 h o v n e c f h t s s 2 h o ain f ee a t o u n s n
ne
terltv e s o a c s t s mc so p o f ( )tec n ne c o tep ris
h eai e m e f c e s o o e f r o ; 3 h o ve in e f h a t ;
e
( )t e lc s o o e ai fcs ()t e a ia iiy o p o e st c mp lte
4 h o u f p r t a t; 5 h valb l f r c s o o e h
ve
t
atn a c o t lng wi se ;( )t r ltv me n o t e p ris ( )a
te d n e f mwil
i
t ss 6 he eaie a s f h a t ; 7
ne
e
fr m' fmi aiy wi te g v mi lw;( )t e weg ta c r e a p anif
o u s a l rt t h o e ng a 8 h ih c o d d litf s
i
h
c oc o fr m;a d ( )tile f inc a dt eitr sso j tc ,b s d o t e
h ie f o u n 9 ra fi e y n h n ee t f usie a e n h
c
t alt oft cr
ot iy he icumsanc s
t e
I a 1135n. No sngl f c ori dipostve,a c t ha dif r i t we g a f de t
d. t
1.
i e a t s s ii nd ours ve fe ed n he i ht for d o
e c i vi lf cor Compa e Cel a v son Tec . & Teec
a h ndi dua a t .
r lulr ii
h
l omm s.L. v. le Co . 508F.
. P. Alt l p ,
S p 24 1 8 , 1 8 ( D.Fl.2 0 ) (v l aig sx f co s,wih Trc - i o I c v
u p.
1 6 1 9 S. a 0 7 e au tn i a tr) t a eW l . n . .
c
S ma tc Co p,No.0 - 0 7 - V, 2 0 W L 4 5 3 , a * ( D.Fl.F b 2 , 2 0 )
v ne r .
8 8 8 7 C1
09
5 4 2 t 2 S. a e . 3 0 9
(v laign n f co s, ndNI M Co p. Ti W a n r l c, . 7 2 6 4 C1 2 0 W L
e au tn i e a tr) a
SS
r v. me r e. n .No 0 - 0 2 - V, 0 8
5 0 5 , t* ( D. a Fe 25 2 0 )(vau tn sve fco s.Ass v rlfco so tnsb y
4 7 8 a 2 S. Fl. b. , 0 8 e laig e n a t r)
e e a a t r se il
ove lp wih one a he ,t s Co twilsrve t a yz e h f ct i a manne m os t ior d
ra t
not r hi ur l ti o nal e ac a or n
r t al e
t t i t ntdiput .
o he nsa s e
1. Co ni eoft W ines es
The nve enc
he t s
l m s sng t c
n s es i he onve e e oft wines es t me e l ngt ofa i vi
ni nc
he t s , he r e h
n ndi dualpa te '
ris
ls ofpot n i lwine s s i no ofgr a sg f a e. Se Ce l a vii 508 F.Supp.2d a
it
e ta t s e s t
e t i nik nc
e lulr son,
t
1 9 s eas Trc - ic I c,2 0 W L 45 43 , t* (t( c u t o sn tmeeytlyte
1 0; e lo a e W lo. n . 0 9
5 2 a 3 t A1 o r d e o r l al h
t
numberofwine s who r sde i t cure f um i c
t s es
e i n he r nt or n ompa io t t numbe l a e i t
rs n o he
r oc t d n he
p o o e ta fr ef r m .' q o igFtiP o oFi Co. Le a Me i. n .41 F. u p. 4
r p s d rnsee o u ' ( u tn j h t l
'
m
v. x r d a I c, 5 S p 2
3 0 3 3 ( D. Y.2 0 ) Rah r te wi e s s a ta k o e g rltve t te isa t
7 , 7 S. N. 0 6 :. te , h t se ' cu l n wld e eai o h n tn
n
diput a t l ton a c
s e, nd he ocai nd onvenince oft wine s s a e i
e
he t s e r mpora c i r tons whe
tnt onsde a i
n
e auai wh te ta se i j siid Cellr iin 5 8F. u p. da 1 9 .
v l tng eh r rn fr s u tfe . lua vso , 0 S p 2 t 1 0
Hee Bic mpai lsa g st a t ç s mao iy' fp tn il t e s saelc tdi
r , o o tbe r ue h t he ç t j rt 'o oe ta win s e r o ae n
va
Oxf d, Conneci t Af .of Bnle Sta ns , a j 1 (
or
tcu .
f
c r wi ki t k 2 ECF No.3 - ) Ac o dn t
3 1 . c r ig o
5
Bi mpai es t e wine s s a e an i pa e t t tf t t r ea c , devel pm ent
oco tbl , hes
t se r
tci t d o esiy o he es r h
o
,
ma acur ma ketng, and s e of Bi
nuf t e, r i
als
ocompa i e Anc see lne of pr t .
tbl s
hor d i
oduc s
Appr m ael ha f of M ir phe i s wine s r i i Oxf d, Conne tc , a al ar
oxi t y l
c os rx' t s es esde n
or
c iut nd 1 e
a tcpa e t pr de t tmony r r ng t lc nsng nego itons t t t pl c be wee
n i i t d o ovi esi
ega di he i e i
ta i
ha ook a e t n
W ordW i a M ir phe i
l de nd
c os rx. W hie M ir phe i ha si a ed t de i al of
l
c os rx s tpult
o posng l
Bi m pa i eswines esi Cor tc , t ev s mao i o win s e i t i fn c s wo l
oco tbl
t s n mec iut h a t j rt f t e s s n he nsn t a e u d
y
ne rhees bei onve e ed a t y woul silha t ta lne ry 1 m iesf ti . The
ve t l s nc
ni nc s he
d tl ve o r ve a l 300 l or ral
ba a eofco
l nc
nveninc oft wines e t tpsi f vorofta f ni t a i n.
e e he t s s hus i n a
r ns e ng he cto
2.TheLocai ofRe e ntDoc l e s
ton
l va
xm nt
I a word wih f x ma nes co m a hi ,ema l ove i s p ng, a m obie
n
l t a
chi , py c nes
i, m ght hipi
nd
l
pho t tca s a a s nd doc e s t physc l ai ofdoc nt i ir e nt l
nes ha n c n nd e
um nt, he
ial oc ton
ume s s relva . n
lghtoft bm de a pa t movi f rta f rbe r , a e a s
i
he
n
ry
ng o r nse a s bs nt howi by t m o ng pa t t
ng
he vi
ry o
t c r r t s Cour c i r t l ai ofr lva doc e s a t r a i ea e of
he onta y, hi
t onsde s he oc ton
ee nt um nt nd he eltve s
ac es t s lc of pr of a non-acor Though Bi om pa i es a g s t t m os r l va
c s o otr es
o
f t .
oc
tbl r ue ha
t e e nt
docl e t a o he physc e de e ar l t i Oxf d, Co c i ,Bi
lm n s nd t r
ial vi nc e ocaed n
or
nne tcut ocompa i eshms
tbl
notal ge t tany oft e s lc ofpr a e i a bl ofbeng ta m itd or s pped t
le d ha
hes otr es
oof r nc pa e
i r ns te
hi
o
M i mi Cons nty,t l a i of r e nt docl e s and t r l tve e e of a es t
a .
eque l he oc ton
elva
lm nt
he e ai as
cc s o
s u c so p o i n u rlwihr s e tt wh t e ta se ij si e
o r e f r of s e ta t e p c o eh r r n fr s u tt d.
i
3. The Conve enc oft Pa tes
ni e he r i
Sa y,fom t pari s bre s i a a s t no m a tr whe e t s ac i i r ol ,
dl r he te ' i f , t ppe r hat
te
r hi ton s es ved
ca e pai nt wilbe a r el a f c e Com na e De .sM ot t Trnse , t8(
nc r te s l
dve s y fe t d.
r f'
. o
a fr a ECF No.33)
(û- pr onge a e eofke i vi l t adit tst woul sgniia l dir isdal
tl ol d bs nc
-he
y ndi duas o san ie
d i fc nty supt t iy
ope a i ,notonl t t de rmen of is busne s but as
r tons
y o he ti t t
i s
lo
6
. . .
t t toft hos t s a
o ha
he pial nd
ci c i s r es a wel a t c nce pai nt who r l upon Br hyscenc 'pr t .', t
lni s t e v , s l s he a r te s
ey
ac
i es oduc s ' wih
)
Pl' Rep.a 1 ( No. 4 Cçfr n fro t i ma trt teDititofCo n ciu wo l
. s , t 9 ECF 3 ) ll a se f h s te o h src
s
n e tc t u d
ad rel a f ctt i e e t ofDr Ka a sc e patent who a e r sde s oft Sout r
ve s y fe he nt r ss
. pln' anc r i s
r e i nt
he
he n
'
he i
rvi i ng uc e i
am hi
DititofFl i ')3 Att rsk ofti alzi s h s xous cl i s, t sCour e uae t
src
orda. .
t val ts he
c
onve e eoft f um t t pa tes
ni nc
he or o he ri .
Bi ompa i es a g st tta f rt t DititofCo me tc i a oprae be us
oc
tbl r ue ha r ns e o he src
r c iut s ppr it ca e
is Br c
t a hyscenc s di son ha f t f z e pl es a a eve i M i mi s h a a
i e vii
s ory-olr m oye , nd ny
nt n a - uc s
de ii ora til t tnec s ia e t a
poston
ra- ha
e st t s he ppea a e ofmuli e e oyee coul dir t is
r nc
tpl mpl s
d s up t
j ti -i ma u a t rn c p bit . Bic mp tb e as c n e ds t a i wo l ic r
us-ntme n fcu ig a a l y
i
o o ails lo o tn h t t u d n u
s t nta ta la a omm oda i e ns s wer ise oye r r t ta t M imi
ubsa i l r ve nd cc
ton xpe e
e t mpl es equied o r vel o a .
Thes co e ns howe r a e mii a e by s ve a f t s Fis,Bi ompatbl 'wines eswih
e nc r ,
ve , r tg t d
e r l acor . rt oc
i es t s
t
t mos r e nti or a i r l tng t t i t ntdiput ha a tnded ml e oustade s
he
t elva nf m ton e ai o he nsa s e ve te
m r r
hows
a conf e es l td outi of Oxf d, Conne i , wih no a r t dir pton t
nd
er nc ocae
sde
or
ctcut t
ppa en s u i o
Bi ompai e ' daiy o r tons Sec
oc
tbls
l pe a i .
ond, M i r phe i ha si a e t de i al of
c os rx s tpult d o posng l
Bi ompai es wine s i Conne tc . Though Bi ompai e woul ce ti y i m
oc
tbl ' t s es n
c iut
oc
tbls
d ra nl nc
s tnta ta la a comm odai n e ns s we e is e oye r r t ta lt M im i
ubsn il r ve nd c
to xpe e
r t mpl es equied o r ve o a
f til t s Cour ha dl bei ve t tt a e e of s l tpe s
or ra , hi
t r y le s ha he bs nc
eec r onnelf ti lwo d be s
or ra ul
o
sgnik a a t ca e a ma e i dir pton i t dal ope ai nsofacom or ton wih a m a
i t nt s o us
t ral s u i n he iy r to
ai
t s ny
e oye sasBi ompai e Ihet mpo a y pe s
mpl e
oc
tbls.' e r r r onnell sne es iaed by ati i oneoft
'
os c st t
ral s
he
mor pr di t ea e s l ma
e e cabl nd a iy nage rs ac o a i a lr a Bi
d iks om r ton s a ge s ocompa i e f c .
tbl s a es
3l Bi om pai e Re y Bref Bi
tbls' pl i , ocompa i esa t tany dim pton t isda l ope a i
n oc
tbl dds ha
s i o t iy r tons
t oul ha derme a r pe c sons f . . .Dr Ka a s 1t Li Onc og ci c a
ç d ve ti nt l e r us i
c
or
pl n' S ne
ol y lni nd
.
paint.'Def' Re y,a 9( No. )
te s' .s pl t ECF 41 .
7
Thus whie Bi mpa i es woul be i onveninc by a tili M i , Dr Ka a
, l oco tbl
d
nc
e ed
ra n nmi . pln,
t owne of M ir phe i a s e i t of t ' 0 pae , woul be f r m o e
he
r
c os rx nd ol nven or
he 31
tnt
d
a
r
i onve enc d. Dr Ka an pe s nal te t a oxi t l t ry-i c e pa int pe day.
nc
ni e
. pl
r o ly r a s ppr ma ey hit fve anc r te s r
Dr Ka a se e d a e e due t hi a tnda e a a ti i Conne tcutwoul a r e y
. pln' xt nde bs nc
o s te nc t ral n
ci
d dve s l
a f tt q lt of c r hi c nc r pa int r c ve.4 Cons
fec he uaiy
a e s a e te s e ei
l he onve e e of t
ninc
he
equenty, t c
pa te weihsagans ta f ri t a ton.
ris g
i t r ns e rng he c i
4. TheLoc ofOpe atve Fa t
us
r i
cs
çl paen i rnge e a tons t p ef red f um i çha whi i t ce e ofgr viy
%n t t nfi m nt c i , he r e r or s t t ch s he ntr
a t
of t a c ed aci t '' Tr ce W ic I ., 2 0 W L 45 43 a * ( uoig Rio Co.
he c us
tviy.' a - lo. nc 0 9
5 2, t 2 q tn c h
v.
H one e l l . 81 F.Supp.473,482 n.1 ( N..1 9 )( u tn S. J l o & S m I c.
m l. nc , 7
7 D. J 9 3 q o ig C. oms n o n .v.
GilteCo, 71F. u p. 1 5 1 8 ( D. 1.1 8 () Th c n e o g a t i g n r l wh r
let .5
S p 1 8 , 1 8 N. 11 9 39 . e e tr f rvi s e eal ee
y
y
t ope a i f t unde l ng t ca e ofa ton oc ur e . Se r c t ha he d t st be
he r tve ac s
ryi he us
ci
c rd
ve al ours ve l hi o
t l ton whe e t al ge y i rngi pr uc w a de i ned and m a acur , and f om
he ocai
r he le dl nfi ng od t s s g
nuf t ed
r
whe e m a ke i a s l de sons ae m a . SeeTr ce W ic I ,2009 W L 455
r
r tng nd aes cii
r
de
a - lo. nc.
432,a *2;
t
s as Amaz c v.Ce ant Cop . 404 F.Supp. 2 1 6 1 6 ( . W a h.2 0 )
ee lo
on.om
nd
,
d 25 , 2 0 W D. s 0 5 .
Bi ompa i esa gu t tt ce e ofgr viy i t i t ntm a tri Oxf d, Conneci ut a
oc
tbl r es ha he ntr
a t n he nsa
te s or
tc , s
Oxf d i whe e Bi ompai e i he
or s
r oc
tbls s adqua t e a whe e Bi om pa i e de i d, a
rer d nd
r oc
tbl s sgne nd
c i s t m a a m r , is Anc se d t c ogy. To t e e t t t Am e d
ontnue o
nuf c e t
hor e e hnol
he xt nt ha he
nde
4M ir phe i a gue t tt a tnda e ofBi ompa i e e oye a ta s wsout i
c os rx r s ha he te nc
oc
tbls' mpl es t r de ho
sde
ofOxf d,Cor c i t m a Bi ompa i e 'cli t tt Sout
or
me tcu , ke oc
tbl s a ms ha he
hem DititofFl i i a
src
orda s n
i nvenintf u l s lkel To s
nco
e or m es i y.
uppor t s c am , Dr Ka a s a e t t he ha ça t nde
t hi l i
. pl n t t s ha
s ç te d
num e ous c er nc a tade s
r
onf e es nd r
hows . . . i ctes outi of Connec iut a whih
n ii
sde
tc t
c
( o o ailswi se )wee atn e s' P . Re p. .B,a !1 ( No.3 -) 'he
Bic mp tb e me s s r te d e . 1' s Ex
' s
t 5 ECF
42. T
uni t nde bi r to l naur of Dr Ka a s t tm o i not l t on t s Cour. The
n e d dieci na t e
. pl n' esi ny s
os
hi
t
i e ey i vi i e na u eofDr Ka a sca e f hi pa i t , howe r l dst sCour t
ntns l ndi dualz d t r
. pln' r or s ten s
ve , ea hi
to
bele t tM ir phe i and Dr Ka a woul ne rhe e sbe m or i nve enc d we e t
ive ha c os rx
.
pln
d ve t l s
e nco ni e
r he
i t mater ta f red t Bi ompa i es woul be we e t ma t t r mai i t
nsnnt
t r nse r han oc
tbl
d
r he ter o e n n he
Sout r DititofFl i
he n src
orda.
8
Compl ntfld by M ir phe i a lgesi rnge e ,Oxf d i c ra nl t c e ofg aviy
ai ie
c os rx le
nfi m nt
or s e ti y he entr
r t
o te isa tmatr To t ee tn ta t e Ame d d Co litalg swifu ifig me t
f h n tn te.
h xe t h t h
n e mp an l e l l n rn e n,
e
howeve ,a numbe ofope a i f c se s onl a a r s tofBi
r
r
r tve a t xit y s e ul
ocompa i e aleg ac i t i
tbl s l ed tviy n
t Sou he n DititofFl i Spect a l M ir phe i c am st t
he t r src
orda.
ik ly, c os rx l i ha
M i os rx a Bi ompai e hel Ic nsng ne itonsi Fl i r ar ng
cr phe i nd oc
tbls d ie i
gota i n orda eg di
a pot nta lc ns t twoul have i ude t ' 0 pa e ,butBi ompai es
e i l i e e ha
d
ncl d he 31 t nt
oc
tbl
c e t t r nae t neg itons wihou e e i i o a lce e a e m e .
hos o e mi t he
ota i
t t ntrng nt
i ns gr e nt
De pie knowldge ofM i r pherx' pa e rght a t i a iabiiy t t
s t
e
c os i s t nt i s nd her pplc lt o he
ac us d pr t ,Bi
c e oduc s ocompa i es c i d is i rnge
tbl ontnue t nfi mentoft ' 0 paen .
he 31 t t
On i or ton a belef s i rng ntha be n a i wilu .
nf ma i nd i , uch nfi eme
s e nd s lf l
Am. mp .a ! 1 ( No.1 ) oe v r o t et l whn se lse i M ir s h rx'
Co l, t 8 ECF
1.M r o e , f h weve e s s itd n co p e i s
i ta dicl m e ,s ve a e Bi ompai es e oye who a e a ii t d t t siy r ga di
nii l s os s e n r oc
tbl ' mpl es
r ntcpa t o e tf e r ng
tlce i nego itons wih M ir phe i 'whi h wer he d i t Sout m DititofFl i .
ti nsng
ta i
t
c os rx' c
e l n he
he
src
orda
P1' liilDico u e ,Ex.C,a 3 ( No.3 - ) As a rs l,t e o eaie f csi t e
. nta sl s r s
s
t ECF
33 .
e ut h p rtv a t n h
i t t ma tr a ie fom a tvii i bot Col ctcuta Fl i a t f t i atbes
nsan
te rs r
c i tes n h
me i
nd orda, nd he acor s
t
n u rl t r s c t wheh rta se i j tfe .
e ta wi epe t o t e r n fr s usi d
h
5. A vaia lt ofPr s
l biiy
oce s
Bi om pai es i ntfe onl one s ii non- ry wines- Ga y A.Ln
oc
tbl de ii s y
pecfc
pa t t s
r
mour letx
wh i n ts be tt te s b e a po r o t e S u h r Ditito Flrd . Th r i n
o s o u j c o h u po n we f h o t en src f o ia e e s o
i c ton t t M r La ze i ac u l unwilng t t tf a a t f m e owne of
ndi a i ha
. motr ux s t aly
li o esiy, nd s he or r
r
Br c
a hysc e es W ord W i , a a f m e c r
i nc ,
l
de nd or r haiman of Bi
ocompa i e ,t s Cour ha no
tbls hi
t s
r as t bele M r Ls o e wil no be a ia e t t tf Shoul M r La om e
e on o ive . m ur ux l t
val bl o esiy.
d . m
ux
b c met valbe t tsiy h we e ,h i s b e tt c mp lo y p o e si te Ditito
e o ma ia l o e tf , o v r e s u jc o o u s r r c s n h src f
Conne tc a bot pa tes wilha s e opporu t t de e hi . Cons que l t
c iut nd h ri
l ve mpl
t niy o pos m
e nty, he
e itn e o o poe ta wi s wh i n ts b e tt t e s b o n po ro t e So t en
x se c f ne tn il t s o s o u j c o h u p e a we f h u h r
ne
9
DititofFl i ma t a ia lt ofpr e sf c ora bes ne r lwih r s c t whehe
src
orda kes he va lbiiy
oc s a t t t uta t e pe t o
t r
ta se i j siid.
rn fr s u tfe
6.n e Reatve M e nsoft Pa tes
li
a
he ri
Bi om pai e i awholyoc
tbls s
l owne s i a y ofBi om pa i esUK Lt ., whih i t n
d ubsdir
oc
tbl
d
c n ur
i a s i a y of BTG l e ai na Lt ., a publcy tade c
s ubsdir
ntm to l d
i l r d ompa o t Londo St c
ny n he
n ok
Exc ng Bi ompa i e 'Br c
ha e. oc
tbl s a hyscince di so hm f t f lre pl s M ir phe i i
e s vii n s ory-oz m oyee . c os rx s
owned by Dr Ka a who i a s t Chi f Exe utve Ofk e . N o much es i kno
. pln,
s lo he
e
c i
t r
t
le s
wn
r ga di t pa tes fna a m e and t r r peci abiii t conduc ltga i i a
e r ng he ri ' i ncil ans
hei es tve ltes o
t ii ton n
ditn f r m.Asars l,h f co i n u rl t r s e tt wh t e ta fri j siid.
sa t o u
t utt e a tr s e ta wih e p c o eh r r nse s u tfe
A For sFa la iy wih t Govem i Law
um' mii rt t he
ng
Ast i tnta ton a ie unde t lws oft Unie St t s t sCou tpr s
he nsn ci rs s
r he a
he t d a e , hi
r e umest t
ha
t DititofCor c iuti f m ii rwih pa e l w . The f c ori t ne r lwih r s c t
he src
me tc s n la t t nt a
a t s hus uta t e pe t o
wheh rta se i j si e
t e r n f r s u tt d.
i
8.n e W ei Ac or d aPl ntf' Choie ofFor
ght c de
ai its
c
um
tû- pl ntf choie off um s d notbe dit bed unls i i cl ry out i d
tlhe ai ifs
c
or
houl
sur
e s t s ea l
we ghe
by o he c i r tons''Robi on v.Gi r c & Bil P. , 4 F.d2 3, 60( 1hCi. 9 6
t r onsde ai .
'
ns
a mar o
l. C.7 3 5 2 1 t r 1 9 )
(u tn Ho l v Tn n r 6 0F.d 61 , 6 (t Ci. i B 1 81 Bic mp tbe ag e ,
q o ig wel . n e , 5 2 0 61 5h r Unt 9 :. o o ails r u s
howe r t t wher t ce e of gr viy of a diput i l a e i a dif r nt f m , t
ve , ha
e he ntr
a t
s e s oc t d n
fe e onl he
pl i ifs c c of f u i e il d t l s def r nce Se Tr ce- ic l . 2009 W L
antf hoi e
or m s ntte o es
ee .
e
a W l o. nc,
4 5 3 , t* (l l eet eo eaief csu d ryigt ec u eo a to dd n to c rwihn
5 4 2 a 2 tW h r h p rtv a t n el n h a s f cin i o c u t i
ç
t f um c e by t pl i if t c c off um i e il t Ees c i r to .' se
he or
hos n
he antf, he hoie
or s ntted o l s onsde ai n ' e
);
a s A m g o co v. nda Co p. 404 F. S p 2 1 5 ,1 6 ( . W a h. 0 ) Balv r s
lo
n. m Ce nt r ,
u p. d 2 6 2 0 W D. s 2 05 ; lo ea
v.Plr Phar a Co. N o.04-20360-C1 , 2004 W L 1 285 * ( D. a.
zdue
m
,
V
20 4, 1 S. Fl 2004) W i r
; ndmee
10
Com .v. m i
Re nlon Pr .l ,61 F.Supp. 8 1 ( D. l.1 5 . No o l i M ir s hei
odss nc. 7
, 0 S. Fa 98 ) t n y s c o p rx
aFl i c por ton ha ng a prncpa pl c ofbusnes i t Sou he Ditito Flrda, but
orda or a i
vi
i i l ae
i s n he t m src f o i
t sCour ha ar dy e m i d t oper tve f c si t i f tma t and ha c l
hi
t s lea xn ne he
a i a t n he nsan ter
s oncuded t t
ha
t f c s a ie fom a tvii i bot Co ci uta Fl i . Co eq nty,t s Cour has a
he a t rs r
c i tes n h nne tc nd orda
ns ue l hi
t
sr n itr s i a j dc tngt ei tn d s u e a dt ed fr nc a c r e t Plitf sc o c
to g ne et n d u iai h nsa t ip t, n h e ee e c o d d o anif h ie
off um weghsa i tta f r i t ac i .
or
i
ga ns r nse rng he ton
9.TralEfi e a t I e e t ofJ tc
i fcincy nd he ntr ss usie
Thei t ca ei c r l s tf tilc
nsant s s urenty e or ra omm e ng t t we ti lperod ofAugus
nci he wo- ek ra i
t
1 201 Thi Cour fndst tta f rng t scas t t Diti tofConne tc woul lkel
3, 2. s
t i ha r nseri hi e o he src
c iut
d i y
r ul i de a W hie docke consde a i a e a t i c i r ton,' Tr ce W ic I ,
es t n l y.
l
t
i r tons r
i nor onsde a i ' a - lo. nc.
m
2009 W L 455432,a *4,E pe ge r l i c i r a g t ng i f de a c t .' W i
t
t ed ne aly s onsde ed ood hi n e r l ours ' ns
s
Eg p.LLC v.Ra c M Q . lc,6 F.S p 2 1 4 ,1 5 ( . W i.2 0 ) 'h s i
ui.
vo
. n . 68
u p. 4 1 8 1 6 W D. s 0 9 . r i s
es cily tuei t pa e c e :
pe a l r n he t nt ontxt
( p tn u u ly.. i awmtn a st e r y a watn t e f ret erg tn
A1 ae t s al .s sig se; vey e r iig o n o c h ih i
c t i a yea t t a pa e e doe no have e usviy i t mar t Fo
our s
r ha
t nt e
s t
xcl i t n he
ke . r
pli if onl i e esed i dn a s deay i s e t l s of a pr e ,
antfs y nt r t n m ge , l s om wha es
obl m
be a e t da a wiluli ael c pe a e f r t de e
c us he m ges l tm t y om ns t o he f ndan ' us dtrng
ts e li
te c u t p o e dn a d te c u t r u iey a r p eu g n itr s.
h o r r c e ig n h o rs o tn l wad rj d me t n ee t
Nonehees ,tme s
t l s i pentwaii f a c tr ol i i tm et tc nnotbe s
tng or our es uton s i ha a
pent
usngt pr e oft fr ts tt s ot r . Furhe ,whie pl ntfswatf
i he oc eds he is ui o ue he s
t r
l ai if i or
a c tr s uton,def nt ca desgn a ot t pa e ee' i nton,a
our e ol i
enda s n i r md he t nt s nve i
nd
dely ma alo brng mar t cha
a
y s i
ke
nges t r nder t pae e i nton l s
hat e
he tnt d nve i es
val bl
ua e.
Mak A.Le e ,W h r t Fie Yo Pae tCa e 3 AI LA Q..4 ,4 3 (01 )(ne l
r
mly ee o l m tn s , 8 P
J 01 0 2 0 itma
ctto so t d . I t i lg t i i ce rt tte itrsso j sie wo d n tb s r e b
i in mit ) n h s ih , t s la ha h ne e t f u tc ul o e e v d y
a
e
de a ngr ol i oft i t ntdipu e.
l yi es uton he nsa s t
11
*#*
Up n rv e te mao iy o fco sa ay e b t i Co r ae n u rlwi r s e tt
o e iw, h j rt f a tr n lz d y hs u t r e ta t e p c o
h
wh t e ta fr i j siid. Of te rmanng fco s o l o e te c n ne e o t e
eh r rnse s u tfe
h e ii a t r, ny n - h o ve inc f h
wine s - we g i f vo ofta f r whie t e - t conve e e oft pa te , t we g
t s es
i hs n a r r ns e , l hr e he
ni nc
he ri s he i ht
a c r e t t e p an ifs c oc o f nl a tilet e c a d t e itrss o j sie
c o d d o h litf h ie f o m, nd ra f n y n h ne et f u t ki
c
wt g a i tta f ni t a ton. De di whehert ta f a c e i ve mor t n
i h ga ns r nse ng he ci
ci ng
t o r nser ms nvol s
e ha
j ttl i fco s Thi Co r h we e , idst a t s l f co i fvo o ta frd e n t
us al ng a t r. s u q o v r fn h t he oe a tr n a r f rnse o s o
y
out i h t nlm e ousf cor t tc
we g he l r
a t s ha ouns lag ns ta f r Asa r ul,tansert t Ditit
e ai t r nse .
es t r f o he src
ofCor ctcu i i ppr pra e
me i t s na o it .
Q
TheFor see tonCl e
um- lci aus
The pa tes exe t consde a e e f t diputng t i ia i of a f um- e e ton
ri
r
i r bl for s i he mplc tons
or s l ci
clus co aned wihi t c i ntalt ag ee ntbewe n M ir pherx a W ord W i e.
a e nt i
t n he onfde i iy r me
t e
c os i nd
l
d
M i os rx ar ue t tt ca e f c Bi ompatbls a t a r rofW ord W i - t
cr phe i g s ha he lus or es oc
i e - s he cquie
l de o
ltgae t i t ntma tri t Sou he DititofFl i whie Bi ompa i esas e t t ti
ii t he nsn
te n he t m src
orda, l oc
tbl s rs ha t
i no bot by a agr e e i wasnotapa t t W hienotdipostve t pr s nceofa vai
s t md
n e m nt t
ry o.
l
s ii , he e e
ld
f u -elc i caus i ta sg fca f c or t t fgur s c nta l i t ditit c ts
or m s e ton l e s < i nii nt a t ha i e e r ly n he src our'
c l us' r r ng whe he ta f ri a oprae. St r Or .I v.Ri h Cor ,487 U.
acul ' ega di
t r r ns e s ppr i t
ewa t g. nc.
co
p.
S.
2 , 9( 9 8 ; e as I r Rio Co p.8 0F.d5 0 5 3( 1hCi.1 9 .Ast i Co r hm
2 2 1 8 ) s e lo n e c h r , 7 2 7 , 7 1 t r 98 )
hs u t s
ar ad deer ne t tta fr t t Dititof Co c iuti i ppr it e n a e t
le y t mi d ha r nse o he src
nne tc s na oprae ve bs nt he
e se ofava i f u -e e ton clus t sCo tde i t de i a t stme wha efe t
xitnce
ld or m s l c i a e, hi ur clnes o c de t hi i
t fc,
i a t ag ee tbe wee M ir phe i a W ord W i hasi t i f nta ton be wee
f ny, he r men t n c os rx nd
l
de
n he nsn c i
t n
M i os rx a Bi om pa i es
cr phe i nd oc
tbl .
12
I CONCLUSI
V.
ON
Fort f e ngr as ,i i
he or goi e ons t s
ORDERED AND ADJ
UDGED t a t eDee d n ' M oi nt Tr n frVe u ( No.
h t h f n a ts to o a se n e ECF
3 )i DENI
3 s
ED.
DON E AND ORDERED i Cha r atM im i Foiati
n
mbe s
a , lr ,hs
d
ia o Jn ay2 1 .
y f aur, 02
,7
h.
K.M I
CHAEL M OORE
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI J
CT UDGE
cc
:
Al co e ofr c d
1 uns l e or
1
3
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?