Nguyen et al v. Biondo et al

Filing 138

*ORDER re 132 Order, Set/Reset Deadlines/Hearings,, Signed by Judge Donald M. Middlebrooks on 3/20/2013. (sw)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
SOUTH ERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
CASE N O.1181156- V- l
CI M DDLEBROOK S
THANH NGUYEN , e al,
t .

Pli if,
a ntfs
BARRY BI
ONDO , e a1,
t .
Def nda s
e nt .
/

OR DER ASSESSI SANCTI
NG
ONS

THI CAUS i b f r teCo r u o a Or e t S o Ca e( 1 2 (or e t S o
S
E s eo e h u t p n n d r o h w us DE 2 ) t d r o h w
t
Ca s ' is e o v mb r7 201 OnNo e e 1 , 2012,Def ndant Bar yBi andTi y
u e),su d nNo e e , 2.
v mb r 2
e
s r ondo
ps
Spa a Sa o I . (olciey t ee d n s' fld aRe p n et te Or e ( 1 7
nd l n, nc c le tv l, o fn a t' ie
)
s o s o h d r DE 2 )
.

1ha
ve

r vi d t r co d o t m a tra a ot r s f ly a s d i t pr s s.
e ewe he e r n he te nd m he wie u l dvie n he emie
1 Background
.

Pli if Th n Ng y n(Th n ' a Lu n
ant s n h u e d a h' nd o gNgu e (Lu n ' ( olci l, t an if'
f
)
y n ç o g' c l t y & itfs'
f
) e ve pl
)
iiitdt i a to a an tDe e d n sBar Bin Cç o d ' a dTis S aa d Sao , l .
ntae hs cin g is fn a t ry o do Bi n o' n p y p n ln nc,
)
(s- y I c' algn Dee d n sb e c e t etr o t Pa t s Busn s S l Ag e me t
çlps n .) le ig fn a t ra h d h e ms f he ri ' i e s ae re n
-i
'
e
(s re nf)a d u e t en me i i y' n c n e to wih Ti s I c whi i ri d upon
ç e me ' n s d h n % ps 'i o n cin t p y n
Ag
f
ch nf nge
.

Thn sr g se e ta m a k i vi a i ofsa ea f r llw . Spe ii a l Pl ntfsa s red
nh' e it r d r de r n olton t t nd ede a a
cfc ly, ai if s e t
cai s f f de a tade k i rngeme , f s de i ton of orgi , c be s ti Fl rda
l m or e r l r mar nfi
nt ale sgna i
i n y rqua tng, o i
c m o 1 w t a m a k i r nge e t diu i , t us e ihme a br c ofc rc .
om n a r de r nf i m n , l ton mj t nrc nt nd ea h onta t

Pl ntfsa e i t busne sofowni a ope a i f l s r i ehai a nai s onst t
ai if r n he i s
ng nd r tng u l e v c
r nd l al ha

p o ieac h l op to s ( 7 - a !2 DE 7 - a !2 .Th n frtu e t eTis mako
r vd lo o t ar n . DE 9 1 t ; 9 3 t ) a h is s d h p y r n

o a o t c mb r1 2 6 ( 7 - . t 5.nJ n ayo 2 7 Plitfso e dt eTi s s ln
r b u De e e 5, 00 .DE 9 1 a ! )I a u r f 00 , an if p ne h p y ao
lc tda 1 3 S aeRo d7, ui 1 2 W el go Flrd , 3 4Cç el gtnLo ain) (
o ae t 0 7 tt a S t 1 , li tn, o ia 3 41 W li o c to '. DE
e
n
n

7 - . t 6 . h rl tee fe , n ha pl dt rg se teTis ta e r wihteUni dS ae
9 1a ! )S o t h r atrTh n p i o e itrh p y rd mak t h t tts
y
e
e
Pae t n Trd makOfie(S
tn a d a e r fc G
USPTO' ( 7 - a !7 , iht eUS g a tdo No e e
' DE 9 1 t )whc h PTO r ne n v mb r
)
1 ,2 0 (e DE 7 - a 2 . a ho sterg t t u eter gsee t p y' r ( g No
1 0 8 se
9 1 t ) Th n wn h ih s o s h e itrd ' s 'mak Re . .
Ti

35 969 )i c nn cinwihb r e c s Th saeo Flrd g a tdTh nhat is 'ta e r
,2 , 9 n o e to t a s ni e . e tt f o i a r ne n ç p y'rd mak
f
o No e e 1 , 0 9.S eDE 7 - a 2 .
n v mb r 9 2 0 ( e
92 t )
I be we t tme t tThn a id f a wasgr nt d t rght t us t tfi y'
n t en he i ha
nh pple or nd
a e he i s o e he i ps '
-

mak, n ha dDee d n Bar Bind (Bi n o'o al a r e ta Th n wo l sl Bin o
r Th n n fn a t ry o o ç o d ' rly g e d h t n h u d el o d
s
)
a5 % i ee tnteW eln tnLo ain ( 7 - a !1 ) Th tr o t eo a a r e n wee
0 ntr s i h ligo c to . DE 9 1 t 4 . e ems f h r l g e me t r
t tBi
ha ondo wo d pa Thn i e ha f 50 oft W elngt St r a ii naly,Bi ndo
ul y nb n xc nge or %
he li on o e, ddto l o
ag e d t pa ar lyf e f usng t d ps ' r t n ot oft f e wast b deer i d
r e o y oyat e or i he Ti y'ma k, he m mt he e
o e t m ne

i tef tr . DE 7 - a ! 1 - 4 . ePa t srlto s i sg iia tyd tro ae a tr n
n h uu e ( 9 1 t ! 3 1 ) Th ri eain hp in fc n l ee irtd fe Thn h
e
a dBi n oe tr di t teo a a re n .DE 7 - a ! 1 - 9 . M ac 1 , 01 , an if
n o d nee no h r l g e me t ( 9 1 t ! 5 1 ) On rh 1 2 0 Plitfs
a dBin oe tr dit awrte a re n Cç r e nf)whc pr vd dta Pli if wo l
n o d n ee n o itn g e me t Ag e me ' ih o ie h t antfs ud
s lBin ot er e iigi tr s i t eW el gtnStr fr$1 4,0 ( 7 - a !21 DE 7 el o d h ir mann nee tn h li o o e o 6 0 0 DE 9 1 t ; 97
n

a ! 1 a dp o ie ta Bin oc udu et eTis makt iM ac 1 , 01 ( 7 - a !2 )
t ) n r vd d h t o d o l s h p y r mtl rh 1 2 1 DE 9 1 t 4 .
Pe t tr o teAg e me tBind wa r q ie t ( ) yPli tfsad wnpa me t
r he ems f h r e n , o o s e ur d o 1 pa anif o
y n

o $ 00 0 a te t te Pa te sg e t eAg e me ta d ( )pa te rmanig b ln e o
f 2 ,0 t h i h ris in d h re n n 2 y h e i n aa c f
me
$1 40 0 b ma ig we kl pa me t o $ 0 t Plitfs ( 7 - a ! 1.Pu s a tt t e
4 ,0 y kn e y y n s f 8 0 o an if. DE 9 7 t ) ru n o h
a e m e ,fBi
gr e nt i ondo f ie t m a awe ypa m e ontmehea e t payPl ntfsalt f e
a ld o ke
ekl y nt i
gr ed o
ai if a e e

whihi ç ac ltda 1 % o tep y n fr a hwe ko pata we ktep y n i ltgl'n
c sû luae s 0 fh a me to e c e r ril e h a me t s ae p'a d
c
af iur t payawe ypa e wihi t ryc l ndarda oft duedaeco tt e abr c of
al e o
ekl ym nt t n hit a e
ys he
t nsiut d ea h

te Ag e me t (d a ! 2 .Mo e v r t e Ag e me tp o ie ta i Bin o b e c e te
h re n . I t ) r o e , h r e n r vd d h t f o d r a h d h
Age me , anif ç a et erg totk a ya dale a a t nt e f reti ( g e me t n
r e ntPli t s t v h ih t a e n n 1lg l ci o n o c h s Aq re n a d
f h
o

s al ee tt l t rc ve ra o a l c ssa da tr y sfe rltdt s c a to . (d a !3 .
h lb nil d) o e o r e s n be o t n t ne ' e s eae o u h ci n' 1 t )
e
o
'
Bi
ondo wa e il d t us t t i y' mar f a perod ofone y rbe nni on t da e t
s ntte o e he T ps ' k or
i
ea gi ng
he t he

P rise e ue teAg e me t ( 7 - a !8 .n e d teAg e me te p iil p o i dth
a t x c td h re n . DE 9 7 t ) Id e ,h re n x lct r vde ç e
e
y
t
rghtt t us ofnn i i y'orany ma k a s i e wih t tbusnes na e i not beng
i o he e
me ' ps
r
r s ocatd t ha
i s m s
i

p rh sdb 'Bi n o.1 a !8 . dto al teAg e me t r vd ddthef lo nga s ae
u c a e y' o d (d t )Ad iin l h re n p o ie s l ol wi sds r
y,
l
n tp r o t e s l t ( o d la s alb rtie b ( an if) ()alrg t,maks ec
o a t f h ae o Bi n o nd h l e ean d y Plitfs : a l ih s r , t.
a s cae wiht n meç i s (xc p t t Bin o wil eg a tdao e( ) e ru a erg t f
so itd t he n ' p y'e e tha E o d ) lb r ne n 1 y a s g ih o
T
te n me i o d r t ta sto i t a o h r n me ;a d ( ) alrg t u d r c ta t a d
h a n r e o r n iin no n t e a ) n b l ih s n e onrcs n

c mmime t o ( anif)wh c aen t x r sl a sl db ( o d )u d rteAg e me t'
o t n s f Plitfs ih r o e p e sy sl
me y Bi n o n e h re n .l
'
(d. t 8 . we e , f n a t c ni u dt u eteç ps 'mak, n Plitfsflds i.S e
1 a ! ) Ho v r Dee d n s o tn e o s h Ti y' r a d an if ie u t( e
DE 1.
)
OnJ n 1 2 2 ti Co re trda Omnb Or e t 9 ) t iu Or e' ga tn
u e 5, 01 ,h s u t n ee n
ius d rDE 9 (ç b s d r' rn ig
omn
)
i p r P an if' to f r u r J d me t I h Omn b Or e ,t s r e e t tç l o
n a t litfs Mo in o S mma y u g n . nte ius d riwa o d rd ha lu p n
l

e tyo t sOr e, f n a t aep r ne t e j ie fo u igt eS i s mak. ( 9 a
n r f hi d rDee d n s r ema nl n on d r m sn h ' p y' r ' DE 9 t
y
r
'
21.
)
I .LegalDi c s on
I
s us i

ljmcinsaee f r e t r u ht til o r' cvl o tmp po rRe nod v Ro e t,
nt t r n o c d h o g he ra c u ts iic n e t we . y ls . b rs
o
2 7F.d 1 8 ,1 9 ( 1hCi. 0 0 (i n I r Gr n uyPr c e ig ,1 2F.d 1 6 1 2
0 3 2 8 2 8 1 t r 2 0 ) ct g n e a dl r o e dn s 4 3 41 , 41
i

( 1hCi. 9 8 . he apanif eiv sta t eDee d n i a tn i volto o a ij n to
1 t r 1 9 )W n litf b le e h t h f n a ts cig n i ain f n nu cin,

l ih r s c t t we st Bi ndoag e d t Er diec t domai nn eTi ys co t
W t e pe t o he b ie, o
r e o Ee r t he
n m
ps pa. m o

a oh rl ainwi o t h n mei is a tro e( )y a . (d a !8 .
n te oc to t u t e a ' p y' fe n 1 e r' 1 . t )
h
r
'

t pl ntf i r quie t m ove f a or r t ûs
he ai if s e r d o
or n de o çhow c e why t de e nts d notbe
aus
he f nda houl

a j d e i iic ne a ds n to e .t: (ne n l iain o t d )G ep an ifsmo in
d u g d ncv l o tmpt n a cin d'f itr a ctto s mit l.Th litf
'
e
to
ctst te ij nci p o iin a is eal alg sta t d fnd n h sr f s d t o e is
ie o h n u t r v so t su r l e h t he ee a t a eu e o b y t
ve
d e
man e. (é (ii Wyatv Ro r 92F.d1 4,1 n. :.ft pl ntf motonesabls s
dat ' 1 ctng
'
t . ges, 3 07 078 8 I he ai ips i t ihe
non- ompla ,t c tor r t de e ntt s
c
ince he our de s he f nda o how c e ast why he s d notb he d i
aus
o
houl
e l n

c n e ta d s h d lsah ai f rt a p r s . 1 Afe teh ai g th c u t eemie
o tmp n c e u e e rng o h t upo e (d) tr h e rn ,ç e o r d tr n s
t
wh te ted fn a t a c mp idwi teij n tv p o iina is e a dino,hes n to t)
eh rh e e d n h s o le t h n u cie r vso ts u , n f tt a cin s
h

n c s ayt e s r c mpin e'(d (iigNe nv Stt o a , 8 F.d 1 2 1 8( 1h
e e s r o n u e o la c . 1 ct
'
n wma . ae fAl. 6 3 2 31 , 31 1 t
Ci. 9 2 ).
r 1 9 ))
On Se e be 28,201 Pl ntfs moved f t i s nc ofan Or rt Show Ca e
ptm r
2, ai if
or he s ua e
de o
us

algngt t fn a t h dfie t c mp ywi t i Co rs Omn b sOr e .S eDE 1 2 .I
le i ha Dee d ns a ald o o l t hs u t' i u d r (e
h
1) n

spp ro ter to Plitfs r vde r o o Dee d n s vilto s f h Co r' ij n to
u o t fh imoin, an if p o i dp o f f fn a t' oain o t e u t nu cin.
s
( e DEs1 2 1 1 2 3 1 2 4 1 2 5 1 2 6 . p cfc l , litfscame t a o S p e e 2 ,
Se
1 - , 1 - , 1 - , 1 - , 1 - ) S e i al Panif li d h t n e tmb r 6
i y
201 t wor ç i y S a Sa on' we e silpr i nty dipl ye a il naed a
2, he
ds T ps pa nd l ' r tl om ne l s a d nd lumi t t

Dee a t'b sn s .( 1 2a ! 1 ) Alo Plitfscame t a De e d n swe esil sn
fnd n s u ie s DE 1 t 1. s , an if li d h t fn a t r tl u i g
t i t r tdoma nna wwm tps pa.om a
he n e ne
i me
i ys c ndDe e
f ndan s busne ssil srbut st c t r
t ' i s tlditi e o usome s

as lnç n 'h t s a st eS p y'mak.(d. t 1 )
ao i u't a diply h i s ' r 1 a ! 2 .
me
Ti
I r pons t Pl ntf M oton De enda scli e t tt t
n es e o ai ips i
f nt am d ha hey houghtc
omplanc wih t
i e t he

Cou tsOr e wa o vae b c u eo asa p n i ga elt rve ( 1 4a 1) Ho v r
r' d r s b itd e a s f ty e d n pp lae e iw. DE 1 t .. we e ,
noM oton t Styhasbe n fld. e nt as a knowldg t tt ha vi a e t Cour'
i o a
e ie Defnda s lo c
e ed ha hey d olt d he
ts

Omni Or r ( 1 1 Ci a as awaet tyourde soni per ntandt fc t tI
bus de . DE 27- ) 1 m lo r ha
cii s mane
he a t ha

flda a p a d e n t iemeterg tod f y u o d r . ( 1 6a 1 Co ee d nsd n t
ie n p e l o s o gv
h i h t e y o r r e s' DE 1 t ) fn a t o o
);
de t tt yaecontnui t i rngeont Ti yMar '.
ny ha he r
i ng o nfi
he ps
k.'
)

OnNove be 7s 2,heCour is da Or rt Show Ca edie i Pl ntfst s
m r 201 t
t s ue n de o
us r ctng ai if o how

ca e as t why t y s d notbe hed i c empta f t r or e Def nda s t o pa
us
o
he houl
l n ont
nd urhe der d
e nt t y
t

Pl ntf s$1 f ea h da t tDefnda sdiobe t Omni Or by c i ng t us t
ai if 00 or c y ha e nt s y he
bus der ontnui o e he

Q is M ak()' i t e fie t s o g o c us frt erfiue t c mpy wih te Co ts
' p y r ,' f h y ald o h w o d a e o h i alr o o l t h ur'
F
'
Omnb sOr e .DE 1 2 a 2 .
iu d r ( 2 t )
I Res e t t Cour' Or r Def nt c ende t tt y had t ke t e r
n
pons o he
ts de , enda s ont d ha he
a n he ve y

ra o a e a to t c l wih t e Co r' Omnb s Or e .( 1 7 a 1 .S cfc ly
e s n bl cin o ompy t h u ts
iu d r DE 2 t ) pe iial ,
Defnda sc am e t tt y:
e nt l i d ha he

( )c vee t esg a ed pit teTi ymak f rteb sn s u tlic udbe
1 o r d h in g e ci h ps r o h u ie s ni t o l
ng
p o e so ali! e v d ( ) e v dtet lr eTi yl g so t efo d o s
r fsi n lsc rmo e ;2 rmo e h wo ag ps o o n h rnt o r;
( ) e sda1 d e t igu igt Ti s mak; n ( )rdie tngt ed mann me
3 c a e 1a v ri n sn he p y r a d 4 e rci h o i n
s
t i yspa.om 't go t t pa ki pag f t hos pr de .
' ps
r
c
o o he r ng e or he t ovi r

( 1 7a 1) W hl De e d n scame t tk ra o a ese t e u ec mpin ewihte
DE 2 t .. i fn a t li d o a e e s n bl tps o ns r o la c t h
e
Omni Or r t y f ie t r a ona y expli t i c
bus de , he a ld o e s bl
a n her onduc orp o dean ba i whi h woul
t r vi
y ss c
d
e us t rf iur t compl wih t Cour' Omni Or r Se M e ce v M ic l 908F.
xc e hei al e o
y t he
ts
bus de . e r r . thel,
2d

7 ( 1hCi. 9 0 .Plitfs v as alg dt t nNo e e z, 01 Bi n op se apcu e
63 1 t r 1 9 ) an if ha e lo le e ha o v mb r 2 2, o d o td itr
o f e
n ac book,de ci hi s l a wha a a st bet e oy s wea i ç-i y Spa a
pitng m e f nd
t ppe r o
wo mpl ee
rng i-ps
l
nd
Saon't t , ndt tonNove be 1 201 Pl i if dic r dt f ce
l 'nnk ops a ha
m r 3, 2, antfs s ove e wo a book f npa sf
a ge or

Ti y W el tn.( 1 8 a 51 - ,1 8 2 . s do t ef r g ig,ti ce rt tPlitfs
ps li o l DEs 2 t 28 1 2 - ) Ba e n h o e on i s la ha anif
ng
ha esa ihe aca eofnon- om planc a ns Def nda s
ve tbls d
s
c
i e gai t e nt .
Tode e mi t e e ta na ur ofDe e nt ' oltonsof hi Cour' Omni Or r
t r ne he xt n nd t e
f nda s vi a i
t s
ts
bus de ,
t Cour s ta i tme on W e s y M a c 20, 3. eRe ds v Robers,207 F. 1
he
t e sde i
dne da
r h 201 Se ynol .
t
3d 288,

1 8( 1hCi. 0 )(l s tsidt a t panifsmoin sae ac s o n n c mpin e te
29 1 t r20 0 l f aife h the litf
i
to tt s a e f o -o l c ,h
a

l aorme i dfce
' f e ntone a bookfnpag weermove onNove r1 201 ( 1 a 5)
rhe
a es r e
d
mbe 3, 2.DE 28 t .

c tor r t de e ntt s
our de s he f nda o how c us why he s d notbehe d i c e
a e
houl
l n ont mpta s he esa
nd c dul

h a igfrt a p r os .
e rn o h t u p e'
).
Att hea i Pli if pr e ed e de t untlt day,De e
he rng, antfs es nt vi nce hat i o
f ndan s ha aced i
t ve t n
vi a i of t s Co ts Om ni Or r Spe ii aly,Pli if ha pr de e de e t t
olton
hi ur'
bus de . c fc l
antfs ve ovi d vi nc ha
Defndan s ha no t ke t çli y Si ' a ound t W elngt l a i do
e
t ve t a n he ç-ps gns' r
he li on oc ton wn.M or ove ,
e r

Pli if ha de
antfs ve monsr t d t tDe e nt c i t ope a et ww w.i ys c we ie,
tae ha f nda s ontnue o r t he
tps pa.om bst
e n t h t we ier die t i e ne ta fct De e nt 'we ief fspa M os ,' d t t
ve houg he bst e r c s nt r t r fi o f nda s bst or ç - a'an ha
De e
f ndan s we ie co ans a rie t f Ti y Spa on t fr tpa Thi e de e i
t ' bst nt i dve ts men s or ps
he is ge. s vi nc s

s fcint ode onsr t vi a i of heCour' Or r De e
ufi e t m tae oltons t
ts de . f ndant a s f ie t s w goodca e
s lo al d o ho
us
whih e us t i f iur t c
c xc es her a l e o ompl wih t Cour' Omni Or r
y t he
ts
bus de .

Ba e ont f eg ng,De e nt s lbesncinedatart of$1 pe da f at a
s d he or oi
f nda s hal a to
ae
00 r y or otl
of277da .
ys

ORDERED AND ADJUDGED t tDeenda ss lpa Pli if as of$27, f r
ha f nt hal y antfs um
700 o
t rvi a i oft Cour' Om ni Or r
hei oltons he
ts
bus de .

DO NE AND ORDERED i
ncha r ,nW es pal Be c
mbe s i
t m ah
201
3.

Copi t Cot elofRe r
es o: ms
co d

oi t
rda,h'

a M ac
yof r h,
<

ALD M M I
DDLEBROOKS
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI J
CT UDGE