Florida Atlantic University Research Corporation et al v. TPV Technology Limited et al

Filing 323

ORDER denying 308 Motion for Reconsideration of the Court's Order Granting Summary Judgment on Indefiniteness and to Alter or Amend the Judgment By Vacating It; denying 309 Request for Oral Argument. Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 10/3/2014. (jua)

UN I
TED STA TES DISTR I CO U R T
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRICT OF FLORI
DA

Cas No.1 CVe
2- 80701SEI c oIdat
- TZ(ons i ed)
FLO RI A TLAN TI UN I ERSI
DA
C
V
TY
RESEA RCH C ORPO RA TI , tal,
ON e .
Pli if ,
a ntfs
C ASE N O .1 80694- V - TZ
2C1 SEl

V.

ACER,l C . etal,
N ,
.
Def nda s
e nt .
-

/

FLO RI A TLAN TI UN I ERSI
DA
C
V
TY
R ESEAR CH C ORPO RATI ,e al
ON t .
,
Pl i if ,
a ntf s
V.

.

Cas N o.1 80697- V - TZ
e
: 2Cl SE1

A SU S CO M PU TER I
NTERN ATI A L, al,
ON
et .
D e e nt .
f nda s
/
FLO RI ATLAN TI UN I ERSI
DA
C
V
TY
RESEAR CH CO RPO RATI ,e Jl,
ON t
Pl i if ,
a ntf s
Cas N o.1 80701 C1 SEl
e
: 2- V- TZ

V.

TPV TECHN O LOG Y LI I
M TED , al,
et .
D e e nt .
f nda s

O RD ER D EN Y I G M O TIO N FO R REC O N SI ER AT I N A N D M O TIO N FO R O R AL
N
D
O
A RG UM ENT

TH I M A TTER i bef et Cour o Pl i tf s'M o i f r Re ons de a i oft
S
s or he
t n a n if
ton o c i r ton he

Cour' Or rGr ntng Summ a y J
ts de a i
r udgme on l fnie sa t Ale orAm e t
nt nde i tnes nd o tr
nd he

J d me tByVa ai gl ( 3 8 a dt ePlitfs Re u s frOr l g me ( 3 9 .
ug n
c tn t DE- 0 1 n h an if ' q e t o a Ar u nt DE-0 jl
D e e nt ha fl d a r po e and Pl i tf s ha fl a r pl t t M oton f r
f nda s ve ie es ns
a n if ve ied e y o he
i o

l heM o i f rRe onsde ai n i DE- i Cas No.1 8 4 a 1 27 i Ca e
'
r
ton o c i r to s
270 n e
2- 069 nd 3E- 2 n s
N o.1 80697. The M oton f Or Ar e i DE- i Cas N o.1 8069 a 1 E- i
2i or al gum nt s
271 n
e
24 nd 7 273 n
Cas N o.12e
80697.

Re i r ton.TheCour' Am e
consde a i
ts
nded Or Gr ntng De enda s M oton f Summ a y
der a i
f nt ' i or
r

J
udgme f
nt oundt tPl ntfs pae , S. tntNo. 349, (he $ Pae ort Pae )
ha ai if' tntU. Pae
5, 385 t 385 tnt he tnt,

frana ptvesa c re,i i fnieunde 35U. C.j11 b)bec us i doesno ceal
o
da i c n onve tr s ndei t
r
S.
2(
a et
t l ry
lnk c r pondi sr t et t ç nsf rr c zi t numberoflne i s d
i ores
ng tucur o he t
mea o e ogni ng he
i s n ai

gnputfrtjf ma.'
i /isz or t'
Thi c ai i a m ea - us f ton c a m . The ef r a pr vi l s a ed by t Cour ,
s lm s
ns pl - unc i l i
r o e, s e ous y t t
he
t

t dipostve i r f ri i t s i whet rone ofo di r s l i t a twoul
he s ii nquiy o ndefniene s s
he
r na y kil n he r
d
u r t nd t wrte des rpton is l t dic os asr t r ,notsm pl whe he s h ape s
nde sa he it n c i i te f o s l e tuc u e
i y
t r uc
ron,
r a ng t s c fc i n,woul bec pabl ofi e
e di he pe iiato
d
a e mplmentng a sr t et pero m t f ton.
i
tucur o f r he unc i

Se DE- a 9(ii Bi di LLC r Watr Te hnolgisCor ,490F. 946,95 ( d.
e 303 t ctng ome no,
. e s c o e p.
3d
2 Fe
Ci. :.Attmes Pl ntfssem t c lt f to andsr t e
r 2007
i , ai if e o ontae uncin
tucur .Theei noquetonas
r s
si
t t f ton oft diput ca m - cou i t numbe ofho i ntllne . Howeve ,
o he unc i
he s ed li
ntng he
r
rzo a i s
r
m ea - us f to c ai i r quiesan i ntfabl sr t e f ca r ng outt tf ton.
ns pl -unc i n l m ng e r
de ii e tuc ur or r yi
ha unc i

He e, ai if havenots
r Pl ntfs
hown t t Cour e r i fndi t tt $ Pa e doe not
hat he
t red n i ng ha he 385 t nt s
dicos s asr t r Be us Pli if ha notmett i bur n f rr co i r ton,t
s l e uch tuc u e. ca e antfs ve
her de o e nsde a i he
motonsa ede e
i
r nid.
1. R econsi
derat on St
i
andard

Rec i r ton ofan or rt san e r r na y r m e t beempl d s rng y.
onsde a i
de i
i
xtao di r e dy o
oye pa i l '
'

Bu ge Kig Cor v. hl Equiis I . 1 lF.Sup 2d 1 1 ( D.Fl 2002)
r r n
p. As and
te, nc, 8
p. 366, 370 S. a.
.
Theeaetreg oundsf rconsdeaton:( )a i eve ngc ngei c r lnglw;( t
r r le r
z
or e i r i 1 n ntr ni ha n ontoli a 2) he

2 pa te a e t tt t m s d nputf
The r i s gr e ha he er i
i
onnat'a l is f r a ' a e e s nta l
' nd t r t o m t' r s e i ly
f
i t r ha
n e c ngea e i t $ Pa e .
bl n he 385 t nt
2

a alblt o n w e d n e a ( ) h n e t c re tce rer ro p e e tma ie tn u tc .
v ia ii f e vie c ; nd 3 t e e d o o rc la ro r r v n n fs ij sie
y
11 a 1
6 t 369.I or rt de onsr t cea e r ,apli ifm us do mor t n sm pl r t t
n de o m tae l r ror
antf
t
e ha i y esae
pr vi a g e s Bau i t v.Cr s Shi Cat i g t Se v ce l er ' N) r,350 F.Supp.
e ous r um nt . ts a
ui e ps er n f r i nt n I J
,
2d

98 9 2( D. l. 0 3 .
7, 9 S. F a 2 0 )
I i a i operus oft motont r co i rt a k t Cour t r t nkwha t
t s n mpr
e he i o e nsde o s he
t o e hi
t he
Cou'...ar a t
l
t
le dy houghtt ough-i l orwr y ... Themoton t r co i
hr
rghty
ongl
,
i o e nsder
woul bea opraewhe e, ore m pl t Co t spaenty m iunde sood apa t
d
ppr i t
r f xa e, he ur ha t l s r t
ry,
o ha m a ade son outi t adve s ra is spr s nt d t t Cour by t pari ,
r s de
cii
sde he
r a i l s ue e e e o he
t he tes
o ha m a a e r notofr a oni butofa e nson.
r s de n ror
e s ng
ppr he i

Z#. a i I .v.
M rne nc M/vAr hi ts 808F.Supp.15 1 63 ( D. a.1 )(iai o te
c gei,
61, 5 S. Fl 992 cttons mitd
a brckesomitd) Thus aS i f rco i rtonc no beus t r-ii t o1
nd a t te . , d on or e nsdeai an t
mot
ed o e ltgae d
m at s r s a gum e orpr en e de et tc dha be r ie prort t e r oft
ter , aie r
nt
es t vi nc ha oul ve en a s d i o he nty he

g le dor q Thi pr bii i ude ne agume st twer prvi l a ia e,
chalnge der. s ohi ton ncl s w r nt ha e e ousy valbl but
no prs e 'Wic
t e s d. lhombev.Te e Toons I .555F. 949, ( t Ci. )(ntr
'
ev e
, nc,
3d
957 11h r 2009 i enal
quoai a ciainsomitd)
ttons nd tto
te .
lI. D i cuss on
s i

Pl ntfs a g t tt Cour e r i fndi t 1 Pa e i i t be us t
ai if ' r ue ha he
t red n i ng he 385 t nt ndefnie ca e he
Cour i o l ba e isde ii n on e denc r r ng i rnge e , n i s d o y
t mpr pery s d t c so
vi e ega di nfi m nt whe t houl nl
ha l ke t t Pae t dee m i t sr c ur dicl ed t a pe s ofor na y s l i t
ve oo d o he tnt o tr ne he tu t e s os o
r on
di r kil n he
a t D e e nt oppos t m oton on ism e isand be us i r t r t s a gum ent pr vi l
r . f nda s
e he
i
t rt
ca e t eie a e r
s e ous y

ma a drj ce b teCo r.Th slte ra o ao ei s f in t d n temoi n.W h l
de n ee td y h u t i atr e s n ln s u fce t o e y h to
ie
Pli if at m ptt a guet tt Cour' e r wasoneofk ppr he i 'notoneofr s ni
a ntfs te
o r ha he
ts ror
s e nson,'
a
ea o ng,
i t s c e, hi di tnc i i one ofs m a i s nots t nce a i no hi m or t n a
n hi as t s s i ton s
e ntc ,
ubs a , nd s t ng
e ha n

at mptt ge a ou t hi sa r f r onsde ato None he e s t m oton s d a s
te
o t r nd he gh t nda d or ec i r i n.
t l s , he i houl lo

be de e on ism e is
ni d
t rt .
Pl i if a s l t tbot e r s une voca l t s i i d t tt 1 Pa e di c os a
a ntf s s e' ha
t
h xpe t
qui ly e t fe ha he 385 t nt s l es

c e ,de pie no me i ofo i t wrten s cfc tons a t tape s ofor nar
ountr s t
nton
ne n he it pe ii a i , nd ha
r on
di y
s l i t a twoul know t sr t r oft tc e .Pli if poi t Fi e 1oft 1
kil n he r
d
he tuc u e ha ount r a ntfs nt o gur
he 385
Pae t s
tnt o uppor t st y.I Fi e 1oft Paent t r eva pori ofwhi h i s tout
t hi heor n gur
he t , he el nt ton
c se
bel bot t H s nca t V s sgna sent Aut Li Num b 30.
ow, h he y nd he ync i l er o ne
er

H %M

0
2

AUTQ Q'
NE
NUVBER

I
N 3
0

FI 1
G.

34

A c di t Pl i if , hi Fi e i c est t onl r e f t H s and V s s g s
cor ng o a ntf s t s gur ndi at hat he y ol or he ync
ync i nal
i t c e t cou e i i A ut Li N u be 30 t c m tt H s pul esa r e t
s o aus he nt r ns de o ne m r o ot he ync s nd es t he

counton t V s pu s Pli if a s r t tape s n ofor na y s l i t ar woul
he ync le. antf s s e t ha
ro
di r kil n he t
d
i edi el r ogni t s r t e di c os d, pa tofA ut Li N u be 30,t be s m e hi
mm at y ec ze he t uc ur s l e as r
o ne m r
o
o t ng

t tc spules des t t abs nceofa a t lsr t e i t s c fcai nso t Fi e.
ha ount s , pie he e
ny c ua tucur n he pe ii to r he gur
Howeve ,Pl i if own e r t tfedatt M ar man he rng t tt c i c dbedone
r antfs'
xpe t esii
he
k
a i ha he ountng oul
i a l as ,t o w a usng t s nc s g l usng a c e t c
n, t e t w
ys i he y i na s: i
ount r o ountt H s pules o tm i
he ync s r i ng

t difrnce bewe t s sgnal t c t H s ncpule .( 1 at29:3- 8.
he fee s t en he ync i s o ount he y
s s DE- 30
1 1)
Thus w hie bo h e r st s ii d a t M ar m an he r ng t ti w a ne es a y t c
, l t xpe t e tf e t he
k
a i ha t s c s r o ountt H
he
s pul es a t he i ne t rone de i tv y s a ed t t Pat ntm ake i c ea t t
ync s , t he arng, ihe
fnii el t t hat he e
s t l r hat he

4

cou i mus bedoneby acoun e , oppos d t atmer orot rd ce. I ot rw o ds, h
ntng
t
t r as
e o i ,
he evi
n he r bot

expe t a e dont f ton(ountngs pules butnet rdei t y sae wha t
rs gr e
he unci c i ync s )
ihe tniel ttd t he
dicos d core pondi sr c ur wa .
sl e
rs
ng tu t e s

Pl i if ar uet ta1 oft e d e s
antfs g ha l he vi enc upporsonl onec uson: he 1 Pa e
t y
oncl i t 385 t nt
dicos sac e ofknown snlt et ape s n ofor na ys l i t a4.Thee de e,
s l e ount r
t c ur o
ro
di r kil n he l
vi nc
howeve ,i notnea l t dei tve.W hie Pli if 'e tlt rsatd i hi Va i t Re r
r s
ry hat tnii
l antfs xper a e t e n s ldiy po t
t tt c r s
ha he ore pondi sr t ei a c e t ti r m e so ea h H s nc a r s t on aV
ng tuc ur s ountr ha nc e nt n c
y nd e e s
s nc,hewa nott tdefnii a t M ar
y
s
ha i tve t he
kman hea i Furhe , l Def nda s expe t
rng. t r whie e nt '
r
r ognied t tt Pa e dicl est tt H s sgnal mus be c ed,her pe t dl saed
ec z ha he t nt s os ha he ync i s t ount
e ae y tt
t Pa e d notdic os t exa tsr t eo m ea f c i M or ove , he
he t nt oes
s l e he c tucur r
ns or ountng.
e r ot r
wines es who wo d qua iy a pe s ofor na y s l i t a4, n a ke a
t s ,
ul
lf s r ons
di r kil n he l whe s d boutAut Li
o ne
Numbe 30, r una e t i ntf a c er ltaone as c fcco e ofknown sr t e.
r we e bl o de iy ount , e l
pe ii untr
tucur
Dr W ila Gl l ,t i nt oft Pa e ,a t havi hadtm et r ew t Pa e , tt d
. li m em he nve or he t nt fer ng
i o evi he t nt s ae

ta t eewe e( e e a p sbl cru t ta c u d(e o n z t en mb ro ln s. l e n
h t h r r C v r l osi e ic is h t o l rc g ie h u e f ie l' Gln
s
'
Dep.21 22- l 5. J hnM ari Dr Glnn' lbortr mana ra t tmeoft
6: 2 7: ) o
cnka, . e s a aoy
ge the i
he
i nton,saedt thedi no know wha t Aut Li Number30boxwas ( aci De
nve i tt ha
d t
t he o ne
. M r nka p.

77: 125. Dr Frde i Ka alosaedt thedi notknow wha wa i i t Aut Li
2 - ) . e rc hn s tt ha
d
t s nsde he o ne
Numbe 30box.( hnDe 26: 1 39: 11. I i undiputdt ta1oft epe ewoul
r
Ka
p. 5- 6; 7- ) t s s e ha 1 hes opl
d
quaiyasape s ofor na y s l i t a4.Ye ,heywe euna et i ntf t coun e t
lf
r on
di r kil n he l
tt
r
bl o de iy he
t r hat
Pli if as e t
a ntfs s r woul be çm medit l ' e
d d
i
a ey'r cogni bl t s h ape s Thus c r r t
za e o uc
r on.
, onta y o
Pl ntfs co e i ,t 1 Patntdoe no c e ry dicl ea c e ofknown sr t e.
ai if ' nt ntons he 385 e
s t l a l s os ountr
tucur
Pl i if f t rcontndt tt Cour e r usy c l t t t tmony a o ni
antfs urhe
e ha he
t roneo l onfaed he esi
nd pi ons

r l t t i fnie sa t t tmony a opi onsr lt t i rnge e .Fis, heCour
e aed o nde i t nes nd he esi
nd ni ea ed o nfi m nt r t t
t
not t tanyt si ony gi n a t M ar man hea i wa s e yf t pur eofconsr ng
es ha
e tm
ve t he
k
rng s oll or he pos
tui
t c am s Thus whe Pl ntfs expe'tsii d att M ark
he l i .
, n ai if '
l e tte
t
he
man he rng,a s outa
a i s et
bove,hat
t
t numbe oflnescoul ber ogni d byusng ac e ortm e , wa t tf ng onl a
he
r i
d ec ze
i
ount r i r he s esiyi
y bout
how t co t ue t c ai s nota
o nsr he l m ,
boutpos i e e val nt oft cl i s Furhe , pie
s bl qui e s he a m . t r des t

Pl ntfs co e i ot nv s pori oft i e r' l rnge e Re t d diecl
ai if ' ntntons he ie, tons her xpe ts nfi m nt por di r ty

a d e stePae tn t u th e u v lnt tu tr s S e iial,h ln u g q oe b
d rs h tn, 0 j s te q i ae sr cu e . p cfc ly te a g a e u td y
Pl i if i t rmoton sa t by sai t t$ now consde t s c fcelm e sr ie i
antfs n hei
i t rs t tng ha t
1
i r he pe ii e nt ect d n
cai 1' Thus c r r t Pli if a s ri t Cou tsr lanc o po i oft I ldiy
lm .
'
, ontay o a ntfs' s e ton, he
r ' ei e n rtons he nva i t
Re t o pur e o cli co tuci n wa notm igui a di no r ul i t co l ton
por f r pos s f a m nsr to
s
s ded nd d t es t n he nla i
ofc a m sco t uc i a i ldiy. A c or ngl i i
li
nsr ton nd nva i t
c di y, t s
ORD ERED t :
hat

1 Pl ntf s'M oton f Rec i r ton oft Cour ' O r rG r ntng Sum m a y J dg e
. ai if
i or ons de a i
he
ts de a i
r u m nt

o I d fni ne sa t Ale o Ame dt eJ d me tByVa ai l ( 3 i Ca eNo 1 n n ei t s nd o tr r n h u g n
e
c t t DE- 08 n s . 2
ng
8 01 DE- i Cas No.1 80 4;a 1E- i CaeNo.1 80697ji DENI
07 ; 270 n e
2- 69 nd 7 272 n s
2s
ED.

2.Pli if Re tf Or Ar nt( 309i Cas No.1 80701 DE- i Cae
antfs' ques or al gume DE- n e
2, 271 n s
No.1 8
2- 0694;a DE- i Cas No.1 8 ji DENI
nd 273 n e
2-0697 s
ED.
DONE and ORDERED i M im i Fl i ,t s
n a , orda hi
a

JD d
A

ay o Oc obe ,201
f t r
4.

<

*

PA TRI A A .SEI
CI
TZ
UN I
TED STA TES DI
STRI J D G E
CT U
c A l Couns lofRec d
c: l
e
or