United States Of America et al v. AM-MED Diabetic Supplies, Inc., et al

Filing 97

ORDER denying without prejudice 79 Defendants' Motion for a Protective Order. Signed by Magistrate Judge William Matthewman on 1/25/2019. See attached document for full details. (kza)

UN I
TED STA TES D I
STR I COU RT
CT
SOU THERN D I
STRI O F FLORI A
CT
D
Ci lN o.1 8l
vi
5- szo- v- a r M a t w m a
cl M r a/ the
n
UN I
TED STA TES OF A M ERI and
CA
t STA TE OF FLORI A e r l
he
D x e.
DAN I YA RBROU G H a e r .
EL
nd x el
COD IFLETCH ER,

Pl i if ,
antfs

FI
LED BY

D.
C.

J 25 2 1
Ay
98
ANGELA E.NOBL
E
CLERK U S DI cm
SI

AM - ED D I
M
ABETI SUPPLI I C.d/ a
C
ES, N
b/
BEY ON D M ED I L U SA ,e a1,
CA
t .

s. oFd à. eB
D. u -w. .

Def
endant
s.

O R DE R D ENY I G W I O U T PR EJUD ICE D EFEN D A NT S'M O TIO N
N
TH

FOR A PROTECTI ORDER ( 79l
VE
DE
TH I CA U SE i be or t Cour upon D e e nt ,A M - ed D i tc Su i ,l .
S
s f e he
t
f nda s
M
abe i pples nc
d b a Be
/ / yond M e ca U SA , a d Soblc K e t Ar f Robi So i k, BKD ,
di l
D vi
i k, ih onof ,
n blc M
LLC, nd A J
a
T

Dibei,I d// Countywi M e ca' (d fnda s' Moton f a Pr tci Orer
a tc nc. ba
r de di ls t e nt'
De
)
i or
oe tve d

(k i 'g 79 . Thi matrwasrfre t t undesgne byUniedSttsDititJ
sMoton' DE 1
)
s te
ee rd o he
ri d
t ae src udge
K ennet A .M ar a. See D E 89. The Unied St es of Am erca and t St e ofFl i ex r .
h
r
t
at
i
he at
orda
el

Da elYa brug a ex rl CodiFlthe (û lt s',ha fld a r pons ( 861 a
ni r o h nd
e.
ec r ikeaor' ve ie es e DE , nd
l
)
Dee nt ha fldarpl g 871 TheCo 'hel aheai ont Moton onJ nuay 23,
fnda s ve ie e y DE .
ul d
t
rng he i
a r
The M oton i now rpe f r ew .
i s
i or evi
D ef
endant M oton
s'
i

Def
endant ar seeki a pr ectve or t s op Rel or and t rcouns ,Jam esH oyer,
s e
ng
ot i
der o t
at s
hei
el

P. , fom dis mi tng e rj ca sae nt a fom publcl s rng M e c r
A. r
se nai xtaudiil ttme s nd r
i y hai
diae
1

be t ires Pr e t Heat I or ton. g 79,p.1 . Dee t as r que tt tt
nek ai ' otced lh nf mai DE
) fndans lo e s ha he

o d r ie t o n e t r mo eF c b o a dwe i p ssc n anige tau iil ttme t a d
re drc c u s lo e v a e o k n bst o t o ti n xrj dca sae n s n
e
Pr ec e H e t l or a i n. I
ot t d
alh nf m to
d

D ef nda s cl i t t ne s s a i
e nt a m ha
w t tons ha r pea e y
ve e t dl

pu i he d
bls d ocum e son t l vi i s i m edi ,a ne sw e ie t t w hie pa ta l r da t d,
nt
e e s on, oc al
a nd w
bs t s ha , l r i ly e c e
s ilr ve t i ntt oft pa i nt . 1 a p. Def nda s a s c a m t tRel t s couns l
tl e al he de iy he te s d. t 2.
e nt l o l i ha
a or '
e
ha s r d t s m e i or a i o t i 1 w fnn w e ie a on Fa book.
ve ha e he a nf m ton n he r a i
bs t nd
ce

A ccor ng t
di o

Dee da t,h me ac mp in itre e wi Dee d n s fmd me tl ih t afi j r a d
fn ns te di a ag nef rs t fn a t' t a n a rg t o ar u y n
h
vi aes Lo l Rul 77. g) a Rul 4- 6 of t Ruls Re ai t Fl i Ba . 1
olt
ca
e 2( nd e 3.
he e gultng he orda r d.
De e nt f rhe ar
f nda s u t r gue t t dis m i ton of i or ai n c ani Pr ece He lh
ha s e na i
nf m to ont i ng ot td
at
l or a i i a vi a i ofH I A . I a p.1 1
nf m ton s ol ton
PA
d t 9.
I
I.

Rel ors'R es
at
ponse

l r pons ,Rel t r e a n t t t i s o y e r i e es f om a ca e r i s i tve
n es
e
a o s xpl i ha he r t r a ned nt r t r
r e nve tga i

j t aitnteflo 2 8 ( 8 , . j Ac o d n t Reao s t so yt e o r aitwr t
omzls i h al f 0l . DE 6 p 7 . c r i g o lt r,he tr h j u n ls o e
f us d on t o a t lvi tm s oft f a a a doc or w ho i ve t ty f iiat d t f a
oc e
w c ua c i
he r ud nd
t
nad ren l ac lt e he r ud.
Onl 52 s conds of s r e tm e wer de t t Re at s 1 Rel t s c end t t t
y
e
ce n i
e vo ed o l or . d.
a or ont
ha he
prnt d a vi o ve s ons of t s or r f r e R e a or ' ' le tons'a s a e t t Re a or
i e nd de r i
he t y e e enc
l t s f l ga i ' nd t t ha l t s
a
i le ' ora e d cc i ' hei f m e e pl r ofm i c
s l ge ' r s us ng' t r or r m oye s
a
a
s onduc . I a p.8. Re a or a gue t t
t d. t
lt s r
ha

Relt s c ms lpose a da ualdes i i of t nai pr em of ( a e media
aor ' ot e td c ct
f
crpton he tonal obl
durbl
cl
e pme lfa Reaor'i ve ntwiht sor a lnkst t sor on iswe iea
qui nt rud, lt s nvol me t he t y, nd i o he t y t bst nd
Fa book pa ' I A c or ng t R e a or ,ve y f us r ha a ce s d t w e pa a
ce
ge. d.
'
c di o l t s r ew e s ve c s e he b ge nd
Facebook pos . I
t d.

1TheHI
PPA ar e wasa ndone on Deendans'r y. ( 8 , .1 )
gum nt
ba
d
f
t epl DE 7 p l.

2

Relt sf t raguet tDefnda s(l c nno mee t rbur n ofetbls ng g
aor urhe r ha e nt ) a t t hei de
sa ihi ood

c us f a prt tve or r ( ha no me t e rj cilsaeme prdiaer uie by
a e or oeci de , 2) ve t t he xtaudi a tt nt e c t eq rd
Lo lRul 77. i t tDee nt c nnots t tt e se ofa a t le rj cal
ca e 2 n ha fnda s a
how ha he xitnce n cua xtaudii
sae
ttmenta ca tesa ih aras bl lkei t ts hdismi tonofa e rj cal
nd nno tbls e ona e i lhood ha uc se nai
n xtaudii
sae ntwoul i efr wih afi til a ()ha notetbls d avi ain o t Flrda
ttme
d ntree t ar ra, nd 3 ve
sa ihe
olto f he oi

Ba Rul 4- 6. g 86, 11 1 . Reaor as c endt tsncet doc nt i q ton
r e 3. DE pp. - 64 lt s lo ont ha, i he ume s n uesi
a e publc r or obt ne by t Fl i O f i e oft A to n G e a i r s
r
i ec ds ai d
he orda fc
he t r ey ner l n e pons t a publc
eo
i
r c ds r ue t D e e nt 'r que tf Per o H e 1h I or a i r le i m oot l a p
e or eq s , f nda s e s or s nal a t nf m ton e i f s
. d t p.
16-1
7.
11
1.

D efendant R epl
s'
v

D e e nt a guet tRel t sha e c a e t ver c
f nda s r
ha
a or ve s al t d he y onduc D e e nt co pl i d of
t f nda s m a ne
i t rM o i by unnec s rl a t c ng t 1 pag r pons t t publc r cor r que tt
n hei ton
es a iy ta hi he 32- e es
e o he
i e ds e s o

t i rs e t t Moton. ( 87,p. 1. Defnda s ne ase tt t Reaor have
her e pons o he
i
DE
j
e nt xt s r ha lt s
mii er ee and unras bl lmied Loca Rul 77. g)a t Defnda sha me t
snt prtd
e ona y i t
l e 24 nd hat e nt ve t he
r uie en s of t Rul 1 a p 2- D e e an s poi out t t W e t Pa m Be c news
eq r m t
he
e. d. t p. 6. f nd t
nt
ha
s l
ah

sain h v p se a o tte c s ,wh c c u d i c aj r 1 .a p
tto s a e o td b u h a e ih o l mpa t u y. d t p.

Dee ns
f nda t

co e t tt ne ss or r s son t i tga i ofRe a or 'co el w hi h alow scouns t
nt nd ha he w t y e t
he nves i ton
l t s uns , c l
el o
co r t f t pr s nt t t publc. 1 a pp.8- 0. Fi l D e enda s a ndone t i
nt ol he ac s e e ed o he
i d. t
1
naly, f
nt ba
d he r
prora g e ta
i r um n boutt di c os e ofPe s na H e t I or a i 2 I . p. 1 .
he s l ur
r o l alh nf m ton. d at 1

2 Def ndan s c elc imed a t J nua y 23,2019heai t tt y ha aba
e t ' ouns onfr
t he a r
rng ha he ve ndonedt sHI A a gumen .
hi PA r
t

3

I .
V

Di cussi
s
on

A . A pplcabl Law
i e

Fe rlRul ofCi lPr ed e26()1 prvi t tapa t ora peronma mo fr
dea e
vi oc ur c( ) o des ha
ry ny s
y ve o
apr t c i or r a t S ur m a f good ca e,i s a or r t pr t c a pa ' o pe s
o e tve de , nd he t t y, or
co
us s ue n de o o e t
ly r r on
t
fom a
r
nnoya e,e ba r s e ,oppr s i or undue bur or e ns ' The pary s e ng
nc m r as m nt
e s on
den
xpe e.
'
t e ki
t pr e tve or ha t bu de t pr de t Cour w ih S
he ot c i
der s he r n o ovi he
t t é
good ca e ' f r t pr e ton
us ' o he ot c i

s
oughtFe R. v. 26( . dGoodc e'ha bee dei da aSs ba i orl tmaenee
. d. Ci P. c) i
aus ' s n tne s ûound ss egii t d

t tk j iila to ' Wr n n v Pe n yv i Lu e ma sM u.I s Co, 9 F.S p 2
o a e udca cin. a ge . n s lana mb r n t n . .5 3 u p. d
'
1 1 ( D.Fl 2008)(ii I r Alxande Gr ( Co.Lii i ,820 F. 35 356
273, 277 S. a.
ctng n e e
r ant f
tgaton
2d 2,
( 1hCi.1 5). Thepa t r que tngapr e tveor rmus ma as cii de
1 t r 98 )
ry e si
otci de
t ke pe fc monsrtonof
tai
f c si s
a t n uppor oft r ques . 1 A c tm us t n bal nce t com pe i f t r i vol d i
t he e
t d.
our
t he
a
he
tng ac o s n ve n

deemi ng whehe goodca eha bee s wn.d.( tngFar s t v.Pr t d Gambe
tr ni
t r
us s n ho 1 cii
n worh
ocer r
l,
Co,758F.2d 1 1 ( 1hCi.1 5).
.
545, 547 1 t r 98 )
I t s c e,D ef nt as e tgood ca e ba e on Re a or s a l ge vi a i of Loc
n hi as
enda s s r
us s d
l t ' le d ol ton
al
e
Rul 77. 3 LJ derLocalRul 77 2( ,
e 2. n
g)
.

A l w ye o l w f11 a s a ed w ih a ci la ton s lnotdurng isi t g ton
a r r a 174 s oci t
t
vi c i hal
i t nves i a i

orltgain ma orpatci t i maki a e rj calsae nt ot t n a
ii to ke
ri pae n
ng n xtaudii ttme , her ha
quot ton fom or r e e t publc r or ,whi h a r as bl pe s w oul
ai r
ef r nce o
i ec ds
c
e ona e r on
d
e c t be di s i t d by m e ns of publc c m uni ton i t r i a
xpe t o
s em na e
a
i om
ca i f he e s
r as
e onabl lkelhood t t s h di s m i ton w il i er e e w ih a f i ti l a
e i i
ha uc s e na i
l nt f r t
a r r a nd
w hi r at t
ch el es o:

( )Evi nc r gadi t oc re eo ta a i i ved.
l de e e r ng he cu rnc r rns cton nvol

3 D e e nt di n make a a g
f nda s d ot
ny r umenta t e J r 23, 201 he i abou a pos i e vi a i oft Rul
t h anua y
9 arng
t
s bl olton he es
Regultng t Fl i Ba a t bass f t rm oton f pr e i or r The lm ie t is t whe he Loca
a i he orda r s he i or hei
i or ot ctve de .
y i t d he s ue o
t r
l
Rul 77. ha be vi a ed. TheCour hasi
e 2 d en olt
t ndepe ty consde ed Rul 4- 6 oft Rul Regul tng t Fl i
nden l
i r
e 3. he es
a i he orda

Ba a df d ta Dee d nsh v n t oae teRuea tij n tr f rh s mera o sDee d nsh v n t
r n i s h t fn a t a e o viltd h l ths u cue o te a e s n fn a t a e o
n
voltdLo a Rue7 . a tij n tr, sf rh re pan di ti Ore .
i ae c l l 72 ths u cue a ute x lie n hs d r
4

()The c rce,cedi lt or ci na r c d ofa pa t wines,or
2
haa tr r biiy, rmi l e or
ry, t s
pr pe tve w ines .
os c i
t s

( Thepef nc orrs t ofa e mi tonsortssort r f a or
3)
ronua e euls ny xa nai
et he eus l
f iu e ofa pa t t s i t s h.
a lr
ry o ubm t o uc

( The lwy ' opi on a t t meisoft camso defns sofa
4)
a ers ni s o he rt
he li r e e
pary,exceptasr r by l oradm i s r i r e.
t
equied
aw
nit atve ul

( Any ot rmat ras bl lkey t i efr wih a fi tiloft
5)
he ter e ona y i l o ntree t ar ra he
acton.
i

S. Fl L.R.77. g .
D. a.
2( )
The e a e a lm ied num be o c esr ga di t i s a ha outoft Sou he n D it i t
r r i t
r f as e r ng he s ue t nd
he t r s rc
of Fl i
orda. The Coul has c r f l r vi w e t f l ng c es
'
t
a e uly e e d he olowi as :Unie St e v.Fi e i
t d at s
or ntno,

No.1 20025- 201 W L 1
4CR, 4
877411 a *2( D. a. a 9, 4) Te l v Car v Cor ,
, t S. Fl M y 201 ; ry . nial p.No.
1320571CV, 201 W L l1
4
79851 ( D. Fl. J n. 27, 201 ; Gar a v Cha
9 S.
a a
4)
ci . pman, No.

1 218 - V,201 W L 1 867,a *1( D. a Oct22,201 ,rpor andr comme i
2- 91C1
3
2061
t S. Fl. .
3) e t
e
ndaton
a pt4 No.1 21 - V,201 W L 1 8 ( D.Fl. v.1 201 ;Gar i v Cha
do e
2- 891CI
3
2061 68 S. a No 5, 3) ca . pman,

No.1 21 - V,201 W L 1 868,a *1( D.Fl Nov.1 201 ) D..v Sl tt No.
2- 891C1
3
2061
t S. a.
5, 3 ; f . atey,
l 61 Cl 20l1W L 1 67,at*1( D.Fl M a.31 20l1 ;Ros b hv.Ru e,1 F.
0- 902- V,
3031
S. a. r , ) s ac
ndl 28
Supp. 1 ( D. a.2000) Unie St e v.Henan z,1 4 F.Supp.2d698,702( D.Fl
2d 348 S. Fl
,
* td ats
r de 2
S. a.
2000 .a Unie St e v Gon alz 85F.Supp. 1 ( D.Fl.1 .
) nd td ats . z e ,
,
2d 306 S. a 999)
B. A nal s
ysi

The Cour ha ca e uly r vi w e t M o i r s
t s r f l e e d he ton, e pons ,r pl t r e nt c s l w ,a
e e y, he el va a e a nd
t a i bl r es The Cour i s ewha t oubl by t l ng ge on Rel t s c
he pplca e ul .
t s om
t r ed
he a ua
a or ' ouns ls
e'

we ie Thewe iesaesi r e ntpa ttg ebeivegetngconr oft fcsi t bet
bst.
bst tt n elva r,twl le
ti
tol he a t s he s
gam e pl f s
an or ucces .lam esH oyer' f ltm e i tgat and ourEm m y- i ng m edi t
s. .
s ul- i nves i ors
w nni
a eam

gi you quit white owe ca e unpaaleld a hort ' ( 79- . The we ie as
ve r
am
slbl r s
r l e ut iy. DE 21
'
bst lo

c ai a lnk t a i tgai newsr ta sae ,(ll powerulivetgai rpor
ont ns i o n nvesi tve
epor nd tts da
f n si tve e t
a a i on s ve a Fl r da TV s a i i e
ppe r ng
e rl o i
t tons s xpos ng t a a m i pr e ofm edi ale pm e
i he l r ng obl m
c qui nt
f a whi cos s t ye s bilons of dola s e r ye r .Tw o w hi te ow e s r pr s nt d by
r ud, ch t axpa r li
l r ve y a . .
s l bl r e e e e
t J m esH oy 1 w t r w e e i e vi w e a s r d t i s orest hel e
he a
er a i m r nt r e d nd ha e he r t i o p xpos t pr e .
e he obl m '
'

Addii l Rel t s c
tonaly, a or ' ouns l pos e a lnk t t i tga i ne s r por on J m es
e
t d i o he nves i tve w e t
a
urhe
t he olow ng
ay
Ho , A.SFa ebookpage. ( 79-1. Counself t rposedt f l i com m ent r on
yerP. ' c
DE
1
O ct
ober 10,2018:

Bilng t xpa r f r m e c l s i s s t dea pe e e es l har s i
li a ye s o
di a upple ent o
d opl , ndl s y a s ng
pa i nt t buy s i t y don' wa . M e c l e pm e f a i a huge
te s o
upples he
t nt
di a qui nt r ud s
pr e c tng t xpa r bilons of dolar e r ye r Thi i a huge pr è
obl m osi a ye s li
l s ve y a .
ss
obl m
c tng t xpa s bilons of dola s e r ye r Chec out t s e elen
os i a yer li
l r ve y a .
k
hi xc l t
l s i tve Re twhe e t o w hi te ow e s r pr s ed by J m es H oyer a e
nve tga i
por
r w
s l bl r e e ent
a
r
i er ew ed t hel expos t i sued.
nt vi
o p
e he s

Cou elalo pose o t s me dae 'g e s e t c ck outt spowef i si tve
ns s td n he a
t, sbl ur o he
hi
rul nve tgai
r por on t na i i pr e of m e c equi e f a
e t
he tonw de obl m
di al
pm nt r ud. W hi te ow e s e
s l bl r xpos t
e he
t o i a e. I ' c tng al t xpaye s a 1 t ofm one ' 1 I t m e a r por pos e on
r ublng bus t s os i
1a
r o
yl' d. n he di e t t d
Rel t s co e ' w e ie a Fa e
a or ' uns l s bs t nd c book pa t t Re a or i t s ca e D a e Y a br h
ge, he wo l t s n hi s , ni l r oug
and CodiFl cher di ecty addr evi
et , r l
ess dence r di t occur
egar ng he
rence or tans i i ved i
r acton nvol
n

t s ltg ton. To t e e t t Rel t s c
hi ii a i
he xt nt ha
a or ' ouns l J m es Hoye , P. . pa tc pa e i t s
e, a
r A , r i i t d n hi

e taudca sae n , c l l 7 .( )1 i i lc td.
xrj iil ttme t Lo a Rue 72 g( ) s mp iae
Taki i o a ountt l nguage on t fr w e ie a Fa book pa and t f c t t
ng nt cc
he a
he im bst nd ce
ge,
he a t ha

Relt swe ei er e d by t i si tvej naita Reaorsc e' 1w fnn f t
aor r nt viwe
he nve tgai our ls t lt ' ouns ls a i or he
sor w hi w as t pos ed on R el or couns ' l f r w ebst and Facebook,i a
t y
ch
hen
t
at s'
els aw i m
ie
t ppear
s

4 The e t ale i hite ower ,' Da elYa br
s wo lged s s lbl s ' ni
w
r oughandCodiFlther ar t Relt si t sc e.
ec , e he aor n hi as

6

a g bl t t Re a or ' co el m a ha or he ta e a m e a ca pai abou t s ca e.
r ua e ha
l t s uns
y ve c s r t d
di m gn
t hi s
A lhoug Rel t s c
t
h a or ' ouns ldi put t tt y or he t a e any m e a c m pai i r l i t t s
e s e ha he c s r t d
di a
gn n e aton o hi

c s Reaor'sae nt comeprcaiusycos t vi ai Loc Rul 77. g)a ma cos
ae, lt s ttme s
e ro l l e o oltng al e 2( nd y r s
t lne e t bls by t tLoc Rul
he i s a ihed
ha
al e.

Howe r gi n t tt possweemadei Ocobe 201 a t j ytili t sc ei
ve, ve ha he t r
n t r 8 nd he ur ra n hi as s

stf rNo e e 1 , 9 te Co r smpy c n tfn ,a t sj ncu e t tDee d nsh v
e o v mb r 2 20l ,h u t i l a no id t hi u tr ,ha fn a t a e
e t bls s tc e good c us f a pr t tve o de t t f c s R e a or l w fl t t is
s a i hed ufi i nt
a e or
o ec i r r ha or e
l t s' a im o ake t
'
pos sof isw e ie a Fac book page. S
t f t bs t nd e
ç
cours i t s dit i tha pr vi l expl ne t ta
t n hi s r c ve e ousy
ai d ha
pa t m us de ons r e t tt alege y- nnf s a e e s r m ai i ac i c r ul ton,orha
ry
t m tat ha he l dl ha ul t t m nt e n n tve ic a i
ve

oh r s p eudc d o c ni et p eu iete c mmu iy a an tte d fn a t i o d rt
tewie rj ie r o t o rj dc h o nt g i s h ee d n , n r e o
nu
s bs a i t t S oogl m i ti 'f a . Te r 201 W L 11
u t nta e he G
e s ral e r'
' r y, 4
79851 a *3;s e a s D . . 201
9, t
e lo f , 1

W L 1 1 a * (i ngt twhieCe rj cilsae nt a is a eundoube yac ve
303 67, t 5 fndi ha, l ûxtaudi a ttme s t sue r
tdl rhi d
i f niel i a o i di t lf m a ,a a e m os ne s s ores a pr s r l s s i t s di t l
nde i t y n n nlne gia or t s r
t w t i nd e s e ea e n hi gia
age,'def
' endant arestl r r t m akea sufi entshow i t t st em ent r ai i actve
s
il equied o
tci
ng hat he at
s em n n i

cr uain o ha ep eu ie o c ni u t p eudc te c mmu iy a an tt e d fn a t,
ic lto , r v rj dc d r o tn e o rj ie h o nt g is h ee d n s
ce tngar s na elkelhoodt tt yc nn rc veafi ti ..
rai ea o bl i i
ha he a ot e ei ar ral)
De e nt ha no i tf e a s ngl c e i t Sout r D it i t of Fl i a t
f nda s ve t den ii d i e as n he
he n s rc
orda, nd he
Cour ha notfnd a s ngl c s i t Sout r Di t i tofFl r da, hr
t s
i
i e a e n he
he n sr c
o i t ough is own i pende
t
nde
nt
r s a ch,t tha gr nt t r i f s ht by D ef nda s Her D e e nt c nnot m e tt i
e e r ha s a ed he ele oug
e nt .
e, f nda s a
e he r
bur ofshow i t pos s f O c ober 2018,even i s ili cicul i now i January 201
den
ng hat t rom t
f tl n r aton
n
9,
ar r
e easonabl lkel t i er er w ih a f rti oft sacton i l e 2019 oreven 2020 i t t al
y i y o nt f e t ai r al hi i n at
f he ri
get del
s ayed.

The Co tdoe fnd,how e r t t i lg of t f c t t Re a or 'c
ur
si
ve , ha , n i ht he a t ha l t s ouns l pos e on
e
td
t i we pag a on s i m e a t pos s a i s coul ga n m or pr i nc ast ca e g t
he r b e nd
oc al di , he t t s ue
d i
e om ne e he s e s
c os rt ti l I ot w or , he pos scoul l t ri pa tD e e nt 'rghtt a f i ti l W hie
l e o r a . n her ds t
t
d a e m c f nda s i o a r r a .
l
t Cour w ilnotor R el t s'counselt r ove t rpos s att spoi ,t Courtsrulng i
he
t l
der a or
o em
hei t
hi
nt he
' i s

wihou prj cet Defnda s a lt t rne t i motoncl e t tili t yc ne t iha
t t eudi o e nt' biiy o e w her i os r o ra f he a sabls
vi ai ofLoc Rul 77. g andas e tbls goodc ef apr e tveor r
olton
al e 2()
lo sa ih
aus or otci de .
Fi ly, whie t Co ' w il not e e a pr e tve or r at t s poi t t Cour does
na l
l he ul l
t
nt r
ot c i
de
hi
n , he
t
e our ge Re a or 'c
nc a
l t s ouns l who a e ofi e soft c t t r vi w t i w e ie a Fac book
e,
r tc r
he our , o e e he r bs t nd
e
page and det m i w het couns beleve i i approprat t m odiy orr ove al orportonsof
er ne
her
el i t s
ieo
f
em
l
i
t pos sati ue.
he t ss 5

R el t s c
a or ' ouns ls d kee i m i t t ast scase get cl t t al an
e houl
p n nd ha , hi
s oser o ri ,

is ma aie unde Loca Rul 77. g) Thi Cour doesnotwantany is s ofp eti
sue y rs
r
l e 2( . s
t
sue
r -ral
publciy oc as one by a pa t s c
it c i d
ny r y' ouns t i pa tt f i t i lrght ofa pa t t t s c s
el o m c he a r ra i s ny ry o hi a e.
The Cour w a st s c s t be ltga e a t i d i c t noton s i m edi
t nt hi a e o ii t d nd re n our ,
oc al
a.
Bas on t f egoi i i he e O R D ERED asf l s
ed
he or ng, t s r by
olow :

Dee nt M oto f a Pr e tve Or r g 79 i DENI W I
fnda s' in or
otci
de DE 1 s
ED
THOUT
PREJU D I t D e e
CE o f ndan s ha ng t a lt t r ne t i m oton cl e t ti li
t vi he biiy o e w he r i
os r o r a n
t sc e i Def nda sha a good- a t bas st do s
hi as f e nt ve
f ih i o
o.
2. Couns f al partesi t scas ar diect t s rcty abi by t l t erand s ri of
el or l i n hi e e r ed o t i l de he e t
pi t

Loc Rul 77. a t Rul Re a i t Fl i Ba i t sca e. A 1 c
al e 2 nd he es gul tng he orda r n hi s
1 ouns la e
e r
her advi ed t t Courtwilbe s rcty enf ci LocalRul 77. on an ongoi
eby
s hat he
l
ti l
or ng
e 2
ng
5 TheCour alo not st tt l fr ' cl m son iswe t t t t i c r oft f t' a t n u ii ng an
t s
e ha he aw im s ai
t bsie hat ç tng ontol he ac s' nd he tlzi
ge

i
ç
Emmywinigme ata 'ot iey u q ia whslblwe c s un aallda to i , i c nu cinwi
- n n di e m't t v o r u tm ite o r ae p rl e uh rt ' n o j n t
g
e
y'
o t
h
oh rc mme t, o dag a yb sbe tosrtn u e teFlrd Ba a v riigg d l e . S eRue
te o ns c ul ru bl e u j c t cuiy nd r h o ia r d et n uiei s e ls
s
n
4- 1 4- 1 a 4- 1 oft Rul Re a i t Fl i Ba . TheCour mak no fndi i t srgar but
7.3, 7.4, nd 7.5 he es gultng he orda r
t es i ng n hi e d,
not s t i i Rel t s c elsdut t e ur compla ofis a r i ng eforson is we ie a s i m edi
e hat t s a or ' ouns ' y o ns e
ince t dve tsi f t
t bst nd ocal
a
w ih t Fl i Ba . Se Rul 4- 19 oft e Rul s Regul tng t Fl i Bar
t he orda r e e 7.
h
e
a i he orda .

8

ba i,a a vi a i oft Loc lRul m a r s ti c e
ss nd ny olton
he
a
e y e ul n ont mptpr ee ngs a
oc di
nd
f t rs tons
ur he anc i .
D O NE and O RD ER ED i Cham ber atW es Pal Beach,Pal Beach Count Fl i
n
s
t m
m
y, orda,

tiA YyoJna ,09
hs S a faur 21.
y
j
l

- '

W I A M M ATT W M A N
LLI
Unied St t M agi t e Judge
t
a es
srat

9