Tillman v. Advanced Public Safety, Inc. et al

Filing 113

ORDER AFTER IN CAMERA REVIEW re 61 Plaintiff's MOTION to Compel First Request for Production. Defendants shall produce documents to Plaintiff on or before January 25, 2017. (See Order for list of documents to be produced by Defendants). Signed by Magistrate Judge William Matthewman on 1/18/2017. (kza)

UN I
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
SO UTHERN DI
STR I T O F FLOR I A
C
D
Ci lN o.IS- V- 78Z- ARR A/ A TTH EW M AN
vi
C BI
M
M
K 1 PETER TI
M
LLM AN ,
Pl ntf ,
ai i f
FI D b
LE y

VS.

A DV AN CED PU BLI SA FETY ,l C.
C
N ,
a TR I BLE N A V I TI ,LTD .
nd
M
GA ON
,

D.C.

J 12 2 1
AN
27

SEE-joIOE
#VN uL-gj
T Rf A M;
2 Jy .j R
M

Def nda s
e nt .

.

O RD ER AFTER IN CA M ER A R EV I W
E

THI CAUSE i beor t Co tonPli if Ki Pee Til n' (i ai if'M oi t
S
s f e he ur
antf, m tr lma s û ntf ) ton o
pl

Compe Fis Re tf Pr uci g 61. Thi matrwasr erd t t undesgne by
l rt ques or od ton DE j
s te
efre o he
ri d
U nie St t s Di t i tJ
t d a e sr c udge Kenne h A . a r Se D E 37.
t
M r a. e
Pur ua t A gr d Or r on Pl ntf s M oton t Com pe Fis Re
s nt o
ee
de
ai i f
i o
l r t ques f Pr
t or oduc i
ton

dae Augus 3, 201 ( 691 Dee
td
t
6 DE , fndant, Adva d Publc Saey, l , a Trmbl
s
nce
i ft nc. nd i e
Na gai LTD.t f nt' weerquiedt s tt t unde sg dfri c r r e
vi ton,
(t enda s' r e r o ubmi o he rine o n ame a eviw
De
)
al doc e s i t fe on D e e nt ' Suppl m e a Prvieg Log dat d J
l um nt den ii d
f nda s
e nt l i l e
e une 1 201 as
5, 6,

tAtor y/ int Prvie ' or :W or Pr t' De e
i t ne cle
i lge'
i k oduc .'
f ndan s s
t ubmit d t doc e s as
te he
um nt
r quie Ata O c ober 1 201 di co r he r ng,t Cour and pa tes f t di c s d t
e r d.
n t
9, 6 s ve y a i he
t
r i urher s us e he

pa a tr Oft i c r r e OnNove r7,201 t Coul is d a Or r( 941
r mees he n ame a eviw.
mbe
6, he ' sue n de DE
t
r uii D e enda s t r - u i t doc e s f i cam e a r vi w a t r e i i tng a
eq rng f
nt o e s bm t he
um nt or n
r e e f e lm na i ny
non- i l d doc ent . The Co ta s r r t tDef ndant i ude Ba ess am ps o t
prviege
um s
ur l o equied ha
e
s ncl
t t
n he

doc e s a t r vie t i prvie l
um nt nd o e s her i l ge og. 1 De enda s r - ubmit d t doc e s a
d. f nt e s
te he
um nt s
r quie a t Cour ha c r uly c
e r d, nd he
t s a ef l onduc e a i c r r ew oft doc
t d n n ame a evi
he umen s
t.
BA CK G ROU N D

l Pl i i fs m oton t com pel he as e t d t tt Cour s d r vi w t docu e s
n a ntf '
i o
,
s r e ha he
t houl e e he
m nt
f om D e e
r
f ndant ' Suppl m e a Pr viege Log t de e m i w he he D e enda s cl m of wor
s
e nt l i l
o t r ne
t r f
nt ' ai
k

pr t' sove comeby M r Til a ss tntal d'f doc e sr l t dt a i e nal t
oduc ç
i
r
. lm n' ubsa i nee ' or um nt e a e o n nt r audi

p ro me b Dee a t. g 61 p. . Plitf a s re t tt et e utn ç tr a a d t
ef r d y fnd n s DE , 41 an if s e td ha h ' s lig i en l u i'
r
n
c
onduc e by D e e
td
f ndant i r ac i t hi whi te bl i i crtc e de e t t w il
s n e ton o s
s l - ow ng s ii al vi nc ha
l
de o t a e D ef nt ' t n- xitng r t la or i e . Thus Pl i if a gued t t he ha a
m nsr t
enda s he e s i e a i t y nt nt
, a ntf r
ha
s
s t nta nee f t c e por ne
ubs a i l d or he ont m a ous doc e s c e t d i 201 r ga di t s a us of
um nt r a e n
4 e r ng he t t
D e e nt 't n- xi tng ve s ons of s t a e t t a e a i s i t s ltga i as w el as t
f nda s he e s i
ri
ofw r ha r t s ue n hi ii ton,
l he
doc e s s
um nt howi Def nda s c e por neous de i i on Pl i t f ' e pl e s a us '
ng
e nt ' ont m a
c s ons
a n i f s m oym nt t t .'
1 a pp. 4- A cc di t Pl i if he ca
d. t
5.
or ng o a ntf ,
nnot obt n a s t ntal e val nt of t s
ai
ubsa i qui e
he e
doc e s I a p.5.
um nt . d t
W O RK PRO DU CT D OCTRI
NE

Fe r Rul ofCi l oc dur 26( ( ,whihs sf t t wor pr tdocti ,sae
deal e
viPr e e b)3) c et orh he k oduc
rne tts
i r evantpart
n el
:

( Document and Tan bl Thigs Or naiy, a pary ma not dic r
A)
s
gi e n . di rl
t
y
s ove
doc e s a t ngi e t ngst ta e pr pa e i a i i ton of ltga i orf
um nt nd a bl hi
ha r e r d n ntc pa i
ii ton
or

tilby or f anot r pat or is r prs nttve (ncudi t ot r pa t s
ra
or he ry t e e e ai i l ng he he ry'
at n c ns la t s rt,i d mni r i urr o a e t.Bu ,s b e tt Rue
to wy, o u tn , u ey n e t , ns e, r g n) t u j c o l
o
26( ( ,t emaei sma bedic e i:
b)4) hos tral y
soverd f
()t yar ot wiedic a eunde Rul 26( ( ) a
i he e her s soverbl
r e b) 1; nd
(i t pa t s
i) he ry howst ti hass tnta ne d f t maeil t prpar is
ha t
ubsa il e or he tras o e e t
ca e a c l ot w ihoutundue ha ds p,obt n t i s t nta e va entby
s nd a m , t
r hi
ai he r ubs a i l qui l
ot m eans.
her

( Pr e tonAgai tDicos e l t c t der dic r oft emaei s
B) otci
ns s l ur . f he our or s s ovey hos tral,
i mus pr e ta i tdicos eoft men a i es i ,
t t ot c ga ns s l ur
he
t l mpr sons concusons o ni ,
l i , pi ons
or l al t or e of a pa t s a t ne or o he r pr e a i c
eg he i s
r y' tor y
t r e es nt tve once ni t
r ng he
ltga i
ii ton.

Fe .R.Ci P.26b () Th b r e i o t e p ry wih odig ds o e y t s o ta t e
d
v.
()3 . e u d n s n h a t t h l n ic v r o h w h t h
doc ent a e pr e t d by t wor pr uc pr vie
um s r ot c e
he
k- od t i l ge. M ii z v St e Far I .Co. 247
lnaz o . at
m ns
,

F. D. ,698( D.Fl.2007)
R. 691
S. a
.
Upon c r f r vi w oft doc nt t tDe e
a e ul e e
he ume s ha f ndant ha wihhed on t bassoft
s ve t l
he i
he
wor pr
k- oductpr vie , t Cour fnds t t t f l w i doc e s ar no pr e t d by t
i l ge he
ti
ha he olo ng
um nt e t ot c e
he

wor pr
k- oductdoc rne as as e td by Def nda s:Baes St mp #1
ti
s re
e nt
t
a
39601396 1
4, 4052- 4079,
1
14121-14182, 14195-14266, 1
4423-1
4429, 1443814447, 14458-14469 1 , 14470-14471,

1 2- 471 1 8- 4723,t botom t o-hids of 1
471 1 7, 471 1
he t w t r
4734- 4741 t botom t e - our hs of
1
, he t
hr e f t
1
4742- 4744,1
1
4746- 4761 1
1
, 4500- 45 a 1
1 03, nd 4602- 4650.
1
W ih r ga d t Ba e St m p #1
t e r o ts a
4777- 4830,whi h i a pos ton s a e entt t l a Ci l
1
c s
ii t t m
o he ow
vi
Ri s Com m i s on,t C o t fnds t t t docum e i no pr e t d by t w or pr
ght
si
he ur i
ha he
nt s t ot c e
he
k- oduc
t

docrne. M or r t r i anot ton i t prviegel t tPl i ifa r a hasacopy oft
ti
eove , he e s
ai n he i l og ha antf le dy
he
pos ton s a em e . D e e
ii t t nt
f ndant s l be r r t pr
s hal
equied o oduc B a es s a p #1
e t tm
4777- 4830 t
1
o
Pl ntf i a a
ai i f n n bundanc ofc uton.
e
a i
Thef l ng doc e ss l be pr
olowi
um nt ha l
oduce t Pl ntf hasheha a s t nta ne f t
d o ai i f
s ubs a i l ed or he
doc e sa i u bl t obt i t rs t ntale va entel e he e w ihoutundue ha ds p:
um nt nd s na e o a n hei ubs a i qui l
sw r t
r hi
Ba e St m p # 1
ts a
4730- 4733, 1 5- 458 1
1
458 1 9, 4593- 4657, a 1
1
nd 4766- 4770. The fr t s t of
1
is e
doc e s Ba e St m p #1
um nt , t s a
4730- 4733,i udesa cor e tve a ton t tw a w rten f Pl i if
1
ncl
r c i c i ha s it or a ntf

1Thes doc
e ument a enotcli e o t prvie l , butae i u i t doc ent s it f i c e a
sr
am d n he i lge og
r nclded n he um s ubm ted or n am r
r viw . The a enotprviegedast y ha notbe lse ont prvie l
e e
y r
il
he ve
en it d he i lge og.

3

whie hewor d f Def nda s butwhih wa neve gi t hi . Ther
l
ke or e nt ,
c
s
r ven o m
emai ng doc e s
ni
um nt
c itofcor e ponde f om D e e
ons s
rs
nce r
f ndan s t a i s i at t t U nie St t D e rm e of
t o n nve tg or o he t d a es pa t nt
La , O c upa i
bor
c tonal Sa e y and Hea t A dm i s r ton. A l of t e doc ent a e hi hl
ft
lh
ni t a i
1
hes
um s r g y
r l va t Pl ntf scl m sa c nnotbe obt ned e s w he e w ihoutundue ha ds p.
e e nt o ai if ai nd a
ai
le r t
r hi
ATTO RN EY - EN T PR I I
CLI
V LEG E
ç
i
confde i di c os esby a c i ntt a a t y m ade i or t obt n l gala s s a e
i ntal s l ur
le o n tonw
n der o ai e
s it nc
a e prvie ' Fihe v. Unied St e 425 U . 391 96 S. . 1
r i l ged.' s r
t
at s,
S. ,
Ct 569, 1
577, 48 L. 2d 39
Ed.

( 976) Uponc eulrviw oft docume st tDeenda sha wihhel on t ba i oft
1 .
arf e e
he
nt ha f nt ve t d he ss he
a t y- le prvie t Cour tnds t tt f l i doc e s ar not pr e t by t
tonw c i nt i l ge, he
ti
ha he olow ng
um nt e
ot c ed
he
a t e c i nt pr vie
tom y- le
i l ge: Ba e St m p #1
ts a
3978- 3983, 1
1
4287, 1
4291 1
- 4338, 1
4340- 441
1 4,
1
4423- 4429,
1

1
4438 1
- 4447, t
he

botom
t

ha f
l

1
4450- 4452,
1

1
4676- 4677,
1

1
4470- 4471 1
1
2 1 2- 4717,1 8- 4723,t botom t o-hids of 1
471 1
471 1
he t w t r
4734- 4741
1
1
,
, 4458- 4469 ,
t botom t ee f t of 1
he t
hr - ourhs
4742- 4744, 1
1
4746- 4761 1
1
, 4480- 4486, 1
1
4488, 1
4500- 4503,
1

1
4565- 4582,1 2- 4650,a 1
1
460 1
nd 4777- 48
1 30. A1 oft s doc e s s l be pr
l he e um nt hal
oduce t
d o
Pl i if
a ntf .
Ba e on t f egoi
sd
he or ng,i i he e ORD ERED t t D e e nt s l pr
t s r by
ha
f nda s hal oduce t
he
a
bove- c i d docum en st Pl ntf on orbe or Januar 25,201
des rbe
t o ai i f
f e
y
7.
D NE and O R D ERED i Cha be s a W es Pa m Be h,Pal B e c Count Fl i ,
n
m r t
t l
ac
m ah
y, or da

ti /? d yo J nu r , 01
hs
a f a ay 2 7.
N

W
W I A M M A TTHEW AN
LLI
Unied St t s M a s r t J
t
ae
gi ta e udge
-

-

2Thes docu e sa enotcl m edon t prviegel , butar i uded i t doc e ss itd f i c ra
e
m nt r
ai
he i l og
e ncl
n he um nt ubm te or n ame
r viw . The aenotprviege ast yha notbeenlsedon t prviegel
e e
y r
i l d he ve
it
he i l og.

4