UnitedHealthcare of Florida, Inc. et al v. American Renal Associates Holdings, Inc. et al

Filing 457

ORDER granting 428 Defendants' Motion for Leave to Take Additional Depositions. Signed by Magistrate Judge William Matthewman on 3/22/2018. (kza)

UN I
TED STA TES D I
STRI COU RT
CT
SOU TH ERN D I
STR I OF FLO RI A
CT
D

Ci lNo.1 c 81l8o- araM a t
vi
6- vM r / thewm a
n
UN I
TED H EA LTH CAR E O F FLORI A l C.
D g N ,
and A LL SAV ER S W SU RAN CE CO M PAN Y,
Pl n i f ,
ai t f s

FIE9 b
L y

V S.

.
C.

MA2 22 2 1
23

A M ERI
CAN REN A L A SSO CI TES LLC ,
A
etal,
.

A E N M Q MQRE
VE
ARI

Co. k' Ds.m
LRK Fk lTc
s.EoF lî. w.B.
1 - R
.

De enda s
f
nt .

ORDER GRANTI DEFENDANTS'M O TI FOR LEAVE TO TAKE ADDI ONAL
NG
ON
TI

DEPOSI ON S l 4281
TI
DE
TH I CA U SE i bef e t Cour upo Def nda s Am e i a Re lA s oci t LLC a
S
s or he
t n
e nt ,
r c n na s a es
nd

Amei n Re Ma ge nt LLC' (ç e
rca nal na me
S ûDefndant' M oton f Le ve t Ta Addii
s'
) i or a o ke
tonal

De o i o s(i oi n'g 4 81. Th smatrwa r fre t t eu d ri n db UntdSae
p st n : to ' DE 2 ) i te s e er d o h n e sg e y i tt s
i
M
)
e
D i ti tJ
s r c udge K e t A .M a
nne h
nu. Se D E 62. Pl i if ,U nie ea t a e of Fl i I a
e
a ntf s
t dH lhc r
orda, nc. nd

Al Sa r l urnc Compa (t antfs),have as fl a Re pons ( 43921 a d
1 ves ns a e
ny û i if'
pl
lo ied
s e DE
,n
Dee nt ha fl aRe y( 4463. Thematri now rpef rvi
fnda s ve ied pl DE
1
te s
i or e ew.

Th Co r frtn tsta,i isOr e dae F b u r 5 2 8 i sae ta û al ug
e u t is o e h t n t d r td e r ay , 01 ,t ttd h t ç lt h
g ho
Def nt ha note iil r sedco tpe m ison t t keaddii de ii a ha
enda s ve
xplcty eque t
ur r s i o a
tonal postons nd ve
notpr de a gume i c
ovi d r
nt n omplanc wih Rul 30a t r l ntca el t sCour wila l
i e t
e
nd he eeva
s aw,hi
t l low

'The ei aloas ald vesi oft M otonfl a Docke Enr 434- .
r s s e e r on he
i ied t
t ty
1
2The ei as as ald veson oft Re pons Gl a Doc tEnr 443- .
r s lo e e ri
he s e ed t ke ty
1
3Ther i alo as al v sonoft Re y fl atDocke Enty448- .
e s s e ed eri
he pl ied
t r
1

1

Dee d nsfv ( ) ae d rd ysfo ted t o t sOr e t fl amo ins e igla et tk
fn a t i e 5 c ln a a r m h ae f hi d r o ie
to e kn e v o a e
up t f a tona de ii ,i t y w i h t do s a i t y m e tt r quie ent ofRul
o our ddii l pos tons f he s o
o nd f he
e he e r m s
es

30()2)A)i a 26( ( ( a t a ia ec elw.' ( 41 . Dee nt tl t i
a ( ( () nd b)2)C) nd he pplc bl as a ' DE 81 fnda s ied her
M oto onFe ar 1 2018 wihi t tm epe i r quie by t Cour.
in
bnl y 2,
, t n he i
rod e r d
he
t
l t M oton,D ef nda s ls f addii li vi s w hos de ii ns t y wi h t
n he
i
e nt i t our
tona ndi dual
e post o he
s o

tk . ( 4 a p 12 . Th y a g et a t errq s i j tfe a d i c mpl nc wih
a e DE 28 t p. - 1 e r u h t h i e uet s usiid n n o i e t
a
Fe r lRul ofCi lPr dur 30. I a p. De e nt alols t t de ii t yha
de a
e
vi oce e
d. t 2. f nda s s it he en postons he ve

ara ytk na dtes b e tmatro e c o t o ed po iins 1 . tp 3 4.
le d a e n h u j c te f a h f h s e sto . d a p. I rs
n e pons Pl i if a g t t Def nda s ha no f ct or l gal ba i f t
e, a ntf s r ue ha
e nt ve
a ual
e
s s or he
end ha
e
s
d
a dto a f u d p sto s ( 43 a p 1 . Pl ntfsalocont t tDef ndant shoul not
d i n l o r e o iin . DE 9 t . 1 ai if s
i
pos tons
n f nda s
s nduc w a t ba i f
t s he s s or
be per it d t t a tonal de ii w he D e e nt ' m i co
m te o ake ddii

Pl i if be ng per ted t t a tonalde ii i t pa t i o he wor ,Pli tfsdo
antfs i
mit o ake ddii
postons n he s ; n t r ds a n if

no beive t Dee
t le hat fndant s d be Se r f (her own mic
s houl
t waded or t iq
r
s onduc.' 1 Pli if
t' d. antfs
a s r t t De e nt ha not us t r t n orgi l de ii a c
s e t ha
f nda s ve
ed hei e i na postons nd annot s
how t t t
ha he
de ii t thavebe t n ornotc d we ene s ar I a p.2.
postons ha
en ake
ie
r ce s y. d t
l r y,De e nt ar t havenote
n epl
f nda s gue hey
ngage i m ic
d n s onduc ,a e i t y ha t
t nd, ven f he d, he

mic
sonductaone woul no war de ng t rM oton. g 446,p.1. Dee t ne
l
d t rant nyi hei i
DE
1 fndans xt
c end t tt y ar notr r d t us t rfr tt n de ii bef e s e ng l ve t t ke
ont
ha he e
equie o e hei l s e postons or e ki ea o a

a dto a d p sto s I a p. Dee a t a s r t a t e h vej tfe t en c s i o te
d iin l e o i n . d t 2. fnd ns s e th t h y a usii d h e e st f h
i
y
de ii i hast n ori e t t
postons t
ake
nt nds o ake. 1 a pp. 4. Fi l D ef nda sm a nt i t tt y
d. t 2naly, e nt i a n ha he

h v s f in l j tfe tef u a dto a d p iin s u h . 1 . tp 5.
a e u fce ty usiid h o r d iin l e osto s o g t d a .

2

Fe r Rul ofCi lPr edur 30 per t apa t t t ke up t tn de ii wihout
de al e
vi oc e
mis
ry o a
o e postons t
l a ofc t l a pa t w i he t t ke m or t n t de ii ,s m us s k l a ofco t
e ve
our . f
ry s s o a
e ha en postons he
t ee e ve
ur .

Fe R. P. a( ( () I ac tgrnt apa t l vet c
d. CW. 30()2)A)i. f our a s ry ea o onduc mor t tn de ii ,
t e han e postons

i mus d s i ama n rc n itn wihF d r l l o Cii Pr c d r 2 ( )2 . Fe . Ci P.
t to on
n e o sse t t e ea Rue f v l o e u e 6 b ( ) dR. V.
30( ( ( () Rul 26( ( ( rquies t c tt deemi whehe :() t a to
a)2)A)i. e b)2)C) e r he our o tr ne t r 1 he ddiinal
di co r s hti i ea ona y c ul tve or du i a i or c n be obt ned f om s e o he
s ve y oug s t
unr s bl um a i
plc tve, a
ai
r
om t r

s c t ti mor c nint ls bur ns
oure ha s e onve e , e s de ome,or ls e nsve' ( fhepa t s ki
e s xpe i i' 2) l
t ry ee ng
dicoveyhasha a eopporuniyt obti t i or ton bydicovey i t a toni or(
s r
d mpl
t t o an he nf mai
s r n he ci ' 3)
'
tt b de or e ns oft pr e dic r o we g is lkel bene i,consde i t
she ur n
xpe e he opos d s ove y ut i hs t i y
ft
i rng he
nee oft ca e t a ounti c r r y, hepa te 'r our s t i poranc oft is sa
ds he s , he m
n ontove s t
ri s es ce , he m t e he s ue t
s a i t ac i n,a t i poranc of t di c r i r s vi t i s . Fe R . V.
t ke n he to nd he m t e
he s ove y n e ol ng he s ues' d. Ci P.
'

2 ( )2 ( ()(i) Ad iinal tc o ls ha e c nsr e Rue 3 ()2 (
6 b ()C)i-ii. dto l ' l u' v o tu d l 0a ( )A)
y, l t

t rq ie
o e ur

ap rys e ig la eo c u to e c e te ge ld p iin l tto t j siyt en c siy o
a t e kn e v f o r t x e d h tn - e osto i ain o u tf h e e st f
mi
e ch de ii
a
postonrr ï ? y t en wihoutl ve ofc t'A1 Ce enni I .Co.v O' el,N o.
cvt u/ ak
p
t
ea
our.' G nt al ns
. N il
09
-60551 201 NUL 411
,
0
6555,

( D. a Oc. 1 , 201 ) (mph ss i o ii a)
S. FI. t 8
0 e a i n rg n l.

Sf e Cour ha di c e i n t pe torde t r ue t d de ii .' Pr a S. v. he
ç'
-h
t s s r t o o nni
ny he eq s e pos tons '
oc ps A. Pat on

I .No.1 24356- V,201 W L 2090401 a * ( D.Fl M a 5,201 ;s ealoMadion v
nc,
2C1
5
, t 4 S. a. y
5) e s
s .
JackLi As oc . a Li i dr od .l ,297F. D.532( D. a. 3)
nk s s Stge ghtng Pr s, nc.
R.
S. Fl 201 .
Upo c r f r vi w oft M o i Res e Re y,a e bist r t a we la t
n a e ul e e
he ton, pons , pl nd xhi t he eo, s l s he
Cour ' pr orOr r a t e ie doc ti t s c e,a a t r a yi t a i a e l w ,t
ts i
de s nd he ntr
ke n hi as nd f e ppl ng he pplc bl a he
Cour fnds t tD e e nt s d be pe m it d t t t f a tona de ii r que t d
ti
ha f nda s houl
r te o ake he our ddii l pos tons e s e
i t rM oton. A ddii ly, he Cou t a i o c i a i t f c t tt Cour pr vi l
n hei
i
tona l t
r t kes nt onsder ton he a t ha he
t e ous y

a lwed Pli tfs t t ke f
lo
a n if o a
our a to l de ii
ddii na postons a pr ded De enda s wih t
nd ovi
f nt t he

o runiyt rque taddii lde ii i isFe uar 5,201 Or r( 41 1 M orove ,
ppo t t o e s
tona postons n t br y
8 de DE 8 .
e r
t di c r de dlne i t s c e ha notye be r c d w he t M oton w a f l d,a t
he s ove y a i n hi as d
t en ea he
n he
i
s ie nd he

ti i s tf Odo r29,
ral s e or
be
2018,s DE 351. I s bas d upon al oft f c soft sc e,t
c:
n um, e
1 he a t
hi as he

a pia l r lsa dlw, n i t itrs o j tc ,h Co r s al r v d De e d n swiht e
p l be ue n a a d n he n ee t f usie t e u t h l p o i e fn a t t h
c
o
pporuniy t t kef a tonald posto a t yhaveme t i bur n underRul 3 a t
t t o a our ddii
e ii ns s he
t he r de
e 0 nd he
r lvantca el a t si clary nota st ton whe e a pa t i l ki i t r our st
ee
s aw, nd hi s e l
iua i
r ny ry s ac ng n he es ce o
t ke a orde e a tonalde ii . No eo tep risi t i c s wilb p eu ie b
a nd/
f nd ddii
postons
n f h a t n hs a e l e rj dc d y
e
t s r lng.
hi u i

Ba ed o t f e ng,i i her by ORDERED t t Def nda s M oton f Lea t
s n he or goi t s e
hat he e nt ' i or ve o

Ta Addiina De ii ( 428 1i G R ANT ED Dee nt ma depos t i vi l
ke
to l postons DE 4 s
fnda s y
e he ndi duas
.

lse i t rM oton o orbef eAprl20, 201 5
it d n hei
i n
or
i
8.

ooxs and o loslso i cha be st sa l da ofM a c 201 , atw es pal Beach,
t t n m r hi
y
zh 8
t m
Pa m Bea h Count i t Sou he n D i ti tofFl i
l
c
y n he
t r sr c
orda.

W I A M M A TTH W M AN
LLI
UN I
TED STA TES M A G I
STM TE J D GE
U

4The ei as as ald ve son oft M otonfl a Docke Enty434- .
r s lo e e r i
he
i ied t
t r
1
5TheCo tr ogniest tt dic r cu- fwasFebr ar 20,201 H owe ,snc t M o i wa fl pror
ur ec z ha he s ove y tof
u y
8.
ver i e he ton s ied i
t t tda e t Cour w ilper i a e e i oft dic ycutof t oughAprl 201 f pur esoft ng
o ha t , he
t l m t n xtnson he s over - f hr
i20, 8, or pos
aki
t s de ii . Defndan ss l pr
he e postons
e t hal ompty no i t ef addii depostonsand s l c plt t m onor
l tce hes our
tonal
ii
hal om ee he
befr Aprl20,
o e i 2018.

4