FREESTREAM AIRCRAFT USA LTD. v. CHOWDRY

Filing 177

ORDER granting 151 Defendant's Motion to Compel Better Responses to Second Request for Production. Signed by Magistrate Judge William Matthewman on 3/22/2018. (kza)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
SO U TH ERN D I
STRI OF FLO RI
CT
DA
Ci l o.1 c 81
vi N
6- v- 232- a t w m a
M the
n
FR EESTREA M AI
RCR AFT U SA LTD .
,

FL D W
IE

Pl i if
a ntf ,

D.
C.

M#2 22 2 1
23

VS.

STEVEN M L MDRE
ARI

RON N ICHO W D RY ,e a1,
t .

CLR (' D1mc
s-EoFJ.A - RB
o.K Fb. w. m
l $ .

Def nt .
enda s

O R DER G R AN TI G D EFEN DA N T ' M O TI N T O C O M PEL BETTE R R ESPO N SES
N
S
O

TO SECOND REO UEST FOR PRO DUCTI OF DOCUM ENTS I 1511
ON
DE

THI CAUSE i befr t Cour upon Dee nt RonniChowdr s (r efnda )
S
s oe he
t
fnda ,
y' ç e nf'
M oi t CompelBetrRes est Sec Reque tf Pr
ton o
te pons o ond
s or oducton ofDoc
i
umensCl oto '
t M in'
)

( 1 1 P an if F e srn Aic a US Lt .(t anif) fld ar s o s t teM o in
DE 51. litf, r e te m rr h A d C itf , ie e p n e o h
pl
to
( 1 6 , n Dee d n fldarpy ( 1 9 . Th sma tri n w rp f rrv e
DE 5 1 a d f n a t ie e l DE 5 1 i te s o ie o e iw.
BA CK G R O U ND
l Def nda ' M oton, he a g s t t Pl i if s r s
n
e nt s
i
r ue ha a ntf e pons s t hi Se ond Req s f
e o s c
ue t or

Pr d ci n o Do u n s wee is fiin . ( 1 1 a p.3 . Dee a tag e t a çh
o u to f c me t r n u fce t DE 5 t 1
fnd n r u s h t û e
t
Req t a e s tcinty t l ed a s c fcaleg tonsco a ne i t Am e d Compli ,a
uess r ufi e l aior t pe i
l ai
nt i d n he
nde
ant nd
t docume s whih we eor ni e a pr edbyt Pl i ifsc
he
nt , c
r ga z d nd oduc
he antf ouns l asoppos dt beng
e,
e o i
m a nt i d i t or nar co tof Pl n if s bus ne s s d be pr r y ba es s n pe a
i a ne n he di y ur
ai t f
i s , houl
ope l t - t m d nd
c eg i e t m e t t pari a Re
at or z d o e he
tcul r ques s' 1 a pp. 3- Def nda f t r ar s t
t . d. t
'
4.
e nt ur he gue hat
Pl ntf' r s
ai if s e pons t R e s f Pr
e o que t or oducton /21 aludes t c t i pr vie but was not
i /
l
o era n i l ges
1

a compa e by aprvieg l
c
ni d
i l e og. 1
d.
I r pons Pl ntf c ends t tis r pons t t Sec
n es
e, ai i f ont
ha t es
e o he
ond Re
ques f Pr
t or oduc i of
ton
D oc e s was i c pla e w ih Fe a Rul of Ci l Pr ed e 3 a t d um e s i
um nt
n om i nc
t der l e
vi oc ur 4 s he t
doc nt n
que to we e r e ve f om va i t r pa te pur ua t t s
s i n r ec i d r
r ous hid r i s
s nt o he ubpoe s a Pl ntf
na , nd ai i f
m ai ai d t doc ent a t w er r e ved a pr uc d t m a t wer m ai ai d.
nt ne he
um s s hey
e ec i
nd od e he s hey
e
nt ne '
'

( 1 6 a p.1 . Plitf a s rsta,wi r g r t Re u s frP o u to #21 i p o u e
DE 5 t 1 an if se t h t t e ad o q e t o r d ci n , t r d c d
h
doc e t i a cor ncewih Rul 3 a ha pr de aprvie l
um n s n c da
t
e 4 nd s ovi d i l ge og. 1 a p.3.
d. t
I r pl D ef nta g st tPl i if spr uc i w asi pr pe be us t doc en s
n e y, enda r ue ha a ntf
od ton
m o r ca e he um t

we eno pr
r t oduce a t we e acualy ke i t or na y c s ofbusne sby Pl i if but
d s hey r t l pt n he di r our e
i s
antf,
r t wer pr
a her e oduc i t m a
ed n he nneri w hi h t y w e e ke i t or na y c s ofbus nes by
n
c he
r pt n he di r our e
i s

t r p ris ( 1 9a p. ) Dee a t e u sst a teCo r o d rPlitf t t r a iea d
hid a t . DE 5 t 1. fnd n rq e t h th u t r e anif o k g nz n
e
o
l l is pr
abe t oduc i i a m a r t t r a ona y cor es
ton n
nne ha e s bl
r ponds t t ca e i c a ned i
o he t gores ont i
n
Dee
f ndan ' Sec Re
t s ond ques f Pr uc i ' 1 a p.3.
t or od ton. d. t
'
1.
I

A NA LY SI
S

Fis ,i a a s t tt pr vie l i s ha be r ol d. The e or t Cour ne d
r t t ppe r ha he i l ge og s ue s en es ve
r f e, he
t e
notcons de t ti s .
i r ha s ue
Se ond, Fe a Rul of C i l Pr dur 34 s a e i r e nt pa t t t a S l y m us
c
der l e
vi oce e
t t s n el va
r ha l '
pa t
t

pr e doc
oduc
umen s a t a e ke i t us co s ofbusnes ormus or ni and lbel
t s hey r pt n he ual ure
i s
t ga ze
a

t m t c r pondt t c tgoresi t rques.' Fe R.Ci P.34( ( ( () Coursha
he o ores
o he ae i n he e t' d. v.
b)2)E)i.
t ve
deemi dt tt r i at dt balnc Rul 34( ( ( ()sl tmaepur eofalevitng
tr ne ha hee s l
nee o a e e b)2) E)i' egii t pos
l ai
a r pondi pa t sbur n ofpr uc i w hie r as bl a s i a r ques i pa t s a lt t
es
ng r y'
de
od ton l e ona y s ur ng e
tng ry' biiy o

obti dic r bl docume sund Rul 26( () Rul 34 i ge r lydesgne t fciiae
an s ove a e
nt er e b) l. e s ne al i d o a ltt

d so ey o r lva ti o to b p e e tn lte ts t hd a n e l i a h y tc b
ic v r f ee n nfnnain y r v n ig atmp lj o ie e de n a sa k y
m i i r s ns ve doc e sw ih l r e num ber ofnonr pons ve doc e s.'A r orScr n
nglng e po i
um nt t a g
s
es
i
um nt '' m
ee

Cor v St m Cathe,I .No. 81091C1 2009W L 2911 a * ( D. a. b. 2009)
p. . or
c r nc, 07- V,
60, t 2 S. Fl Fe 5,
(ii Wilamsv Tas rI ' I .No.1: -CV-0051 S,2006W L 1
ctng li . e ntl nc,
,
06
-RW
835437,a *7( D. .
t N. Ga
J 30,2006). lk e 3 asumest tt doc nt wilbe ara
une
) t ul 4 s
l
ha he ume s l
rnged i s way t ti
n ome
ha s
r as bl us bl by t oppos ng pa t ' Se e tEx
e ona y ea e
he
i
ry.
' l c p.Cor v Ri he on,N o.1 8 26- V ,
p. . c s
0- 05 C1

201 W L 11 203,a * ( D.Fl De 22,201
0
561
t 2 S. a. c.
0)
Dee
f ndan prm a iy r les on M i ne G r
t i rl e i
z r and Condo.As ' I . v Tr l r Pr p. Cas
s n, nc . ave e s o
.

Co o , 7 F. D. 8( D. l . 01 ) l t tc s ,h c u tf u dt a t plitf h d
. fAm. 2 0 R. 69 S. F a 2 0 . n ha a e te o r o n h t he anif a
l a no m e ni ula tmptt s
l de
m
a ngf te
o how t tispr ton s ts i t busne sr c dso i i
ha t oduci a ifes he i s e or pton n

Ru e3 ( )2 ( ()' 1 a 7 . Th c u tfrh re p an d ta l u ne sM in rh btal
l 4 b ( )E)i. d. t 01 e o r u te x lie h t t l ls z e a i l
'
g
u y
kee aldoc nt i r eve i sor e wih is a t ne ,t doc e s M ine a quie
ps l
ume s t ec i s n t ag t t tor ys he
um nt z r c r d
dur ng t underyi ltga i n w e e sm pl not m ai a ne i t û ua c s of bus ne s '
i he
l ng ii to
r i y
nt i d n he us l our e
i s.

l t d, he edoc
nsea t s
umen swe eac umult d d i as i ,non-outneoc ur e e, nd byt i
t r c
a e urng pecfc
r i
c r nc a
her

v r nau eaen tb sne sr c r su d rRul 3 ( )2 ( ()' I
e y tr r o u i s e o d n e e 4 b ( )E)i. d
'
The Cour has c i r t a gum ent of t pa tes and t r l va c e l w . Rul
t
ons de ed he r
s he r i
he e e nt as a
e

34( ( ( ()saest tal rymus pr edocume sa t aeke i t us c s of
b)2)E)i tt ha s t
pa
t oduc
nt s hey r pt n he ual oure
busne sorm us or ni e and lbe t m t core pond t t c t gore i t r que t' The
i s
t ga z
a l he o r s
o he a e i s n he e s .
'
c m on s ns i e pr t ton oft sRul i t ta pa t m us pr
om
e e nt r e a i
hi
e s ha
ry
t oduce doc e sa t pa t kee
um nt s he r v ps
t m i t pary' us l co s of bus ne s or e s or ni e a l
he n he t s ua ur e
i s
l e ga z nd abelt doc e s H e e,
he
um nt . r

Pli ifobt ne docume sfom s ve aldif e t r pa te a t n pr
antf ai d
nt r
e r fer nt hid ri s nd he oduce t m i t
d he n he
f m a i w hi h t e t r pa tes ke t doc e s i t us co s of t t r pa te '
or t n
c hos hid r i
pt he
um nt n he ual ur e
he hi d ri s
3

busnes .
i s
Thi pr dur a
s oce e ppea st be i c r ve i ofRul 34,a Pl ntf ha no pr vi d
r o
n onta nton
e
nd ai if s t o de

c s lw ta c n n e t e Co r oh r s . Ad iinal s h a pr c dze p eu ie
a e a h t o vic s h u t t ewie
d t l uc
o y,
o e l rj d c s
r
De e nt and i pe s t di co r pr s . The e or , t Cour w il r qui e Pl i if t
f nda
m de he s ve y oce s
r f e he
t l e r a ntf o

o ganiet doc e spr ousy pr
r z he um nt evi l oduce t De e ntand lbe t docume st c r pond
d o f nda
a l he
nt o ores
t t c t or e i D e enda ' Se ond R e s f rPr
o he a eg i s n f
nt s c
que t o oduc i ofDocum e s
t on
nt .

Bas on t f e ng,i i ORDERED t t De e nts M oton t Com pe Bet r
ed
he or goi
ts
ha
f nda '
i o
l te

Repo s st S c nd Re u s frPr d cin o Do u n s( 1 )i GRANTED. Plitf
s ne o e o
q e t o o u to f c me t DE 51 s
anif
s lpr deDe e
hal ovi
f ndantwih a a e d r pons t De enda ' Se ond Reques f Pr ton
t n m nde es e o f nts c
t or oduc i

ofDoc nt wihi s ve ( da oft daeoft sOr r Pli ifi as r quiedt or ni
ume s t n e n 7) ys he t hi de . antf s lo e r o ga ze
t docume spr ousy pr ed t De e nta lbelt doc e st c r pond t t
he
nt evi l oduc o f nda nd a he um nt o ores
o he
c t goresi Def ntsSec Re tf Pr
a e i n enda '
ond ques or oduci ofDocument.
ton
s
22 L
DONE and ORDERED i Cha be st s
n
m r hi
da ofM ar h,201 a W es Pal Bea h,
y
c
8, t
t m
c
Pa m Be c Count i t Sou he n D i t i tofFl i
l
ah
y n he t r sr c
orda.

X<A- V
i'

W I A M M A TTH EW M A N
LLI
UNI
TED STATES M A GI
STM TE J D G E
U

4