FREESTREAM AIRCRAFT USA LTD. v. CHOWDRY

Filing 276

OMNIBUS ORDER ON MOTIONS IN LIMINE:granting in part and denying in part 224 Defendants' Motion in Limine; granting in part and denying in part 229 Plaintiff's Motion in Limine; granting in part and denying in part 230 Plaintiff's Motion in Limine; denying 233 Plaintiff's Amended Motion in Limine. Signed by Magistrate Judge William Matthewman on 9/18/2018. See attached document for full details. (kza)

UN I
TED STA TES D I
STRI COU RT
CT
SO UTHERN D I
STRI OF FLOR I
CT
DA
Ci l o.1 c 81 M A. THEW M AN
vi N
6- v- 232- T
FREESTR EAM A I CR AFT U SA LTD .
R
,
Pl i tf ,
a n if
F L D ùy
1E

C.

.

VS.

R ON NICH OW D RY ;
A TLA S A V I ON LLC;
ATI
A TLA S SA LES AN D LEA SI G ,LLC;
N
a d A TLA S LUX U RY J
n
ETS LLC,

SEF 12 2 1
28
S'EVEN M LARI
F
MORE

CLR u, DlTc
E K q s. T
SD. rF i - n .
. ol L . w. B.

D e e nt .
f nda s
O M NI S O RD ER O N M O TI N S I LI I E
BU
O
N M N

THI CAUSE i befr t Co tupont pa tes motonsi lmi (û otons' (
S
s oe he ur
he ri ' i n i ne s i ') DES
M
224,229,230,233 . TheM otonsaea1f l bree andt pa tesha fldaJ ntNotc
1
i r l uly ifd, he ri ve ie oi
ie
ofConfral( 2661f t r lmii t is ague i t Motons. The Cour hel a
er DE
urhe i tng he sues r d n he i
t d
he r ng on t M o i on Se e be 1 201 The Cour has c i r d t M otons a1
ai
he tons
pt m r 7, 8.
t
onsde e he
i , 1
r l t d t lngs t a g e of t pa tes c
e a e i i , he r um nt
he r i ' ouns , a t e ie r c d i t s c e The
el nd he ntr e or n hi as .
m ater i now rpe f r ew .
t s
i or evi

Ba ed o t f e ng,i i her by O R D ERED A ND A DJU D G ED a f l s
s n he or goi t s e
s olow :

Deendant' M oton i Li ne t Excude Evi
f
s
i n mi o
l
dence i Tral I 2241 i
n i DE
s
GRAN TED I PART AN D DEN I I PART.
N
ED N

a. Pl ntf has a e t e l e de a
ai if
gr ed o xc ude vi nce boutR or iChow dr s di ce a
m
y' vor nd

domesi is . g 266,p.1 . Ac or ngl t se denc i e l d.
tc sues DE
)
c di y,hi vi e s xcude
The M oto i g ant d t t e e i s e t exc ude e d e a t i
i n s r e o he xt nt t e ks o
l
vi enc t ral

r a di pror unr aed l ws t i vi Def nda s Pl i if i no
eg r ng i
elt a uis nvol ng
e nt . antf s t
pe m it t a i e de e or t s i ony r ga di t t ac i ns a ns
r ted o dm t vi nc
e tm
e r ng he wo to gai t
RonniCho dr a At a Avi to t a bir t o a i tChowdr a Ata
w y nd l s a i n, he r ta i n ga ns
y nd l s
Avi to by ECG ,t a ton ag ns Chowdr a A ta A vi ton by RPA ,
ai n
he c i
ai t
y nd l s
ai
LLC , or t a on a i t Chow dr by M er ede Be . The e de e
he di
ga ns
y
c s nz
vi nc
r ga di pror u el t d l w s t i nota i s bl a a ha torr i unde
e r ng i nr a e a uis s
dm s i e s
bi
outne
r
Fede a R ul of Evi nce 406. 1 The pr o unr a e l w s t do not
rl
e
de
ir
el t d a uis
c ul tve y cons iut e de e ofha torr i asr quied by t c ti
um a i l
tt e vi nc
bi
outne e r
he our n

fou
ghan v Fiet Tie d:Rubbe Co. 49 F. 1 9,1 ( 1h Ci.
. rsone r
r ,7
2d 51 524 1 t r

1 , a c s whi boh pa te ctd t t Cour. I Loughan, t
985) a e ch t ris ie o he
t n
he
de e nt w a pe m it d t i r uc evi nc of t pl ntf ' ha t of
f nda
s r te o nt od e de e
he ai i f s bi
d i ng be w e n 1
r nki
t e 968 and J y 24, 1
ul
974,a t c tde m ed i r l va t
s he our e
t e e nt o
t de e nt s def ns s of a s pton of t rs a a
he f nda '
e e
s um i
he i k nd ppor i e of
tonm nt
labiiy. How ever t El
i lt
, he event Cicui s at SW e s r t t f t or
h r t t ed: t
t ess ha habi

pa t r of c
te n
onduc i ne rt be lghty es a i hed,a e denc ofe m pl
t s ve o
i l t bls
nd vi e
xa e,
f pu pos of e t bls ng s h ha t i t be c r f l s nzi z d bef r
or r e
s a ihi uc
bi, s o
a e uly c tni e
oe

a miso ' 7 F. a 1 2 (ii Wi o v V ls ge o Ame ia
d sin.' 49 2d t 5 4 ct
'
ng l n . o kwa n f
s
rc ,
I . 561F. 49 511( h Ci.1
nc,
2d 4,
4t r 977:. l t i tntc e,afe caeuly
n he nsa as tr rf l
s utni ng t unr l t d l w s t ag ns Def nda Chow dr a Def nda
cr i zi he e a e a uis ai t e nt
y nd
e nt
Atas A vi ton, t Cour ea iy fnds t t t do not es a ih a ha t or
l
a i he
t sl i
ha hey
t bls
bi
cus om underRul 406. Thus,t pror l s t shal notbe i r
t
e
he i aw uis
l
ntoduced i o
nt

'l t J n N otceofConf r al Plitf sae ta iwa o l se igt a mitee d n eu de Rue40 . (
e r , anif ttd h tt s ny e kn o d th vie c n r l 6 DE
n he oi t i

2 , 2.
66 p. )

e de e,t es Def nda s s how ope t doort t ra s i lt a
vi nc ml s e nt ome
n he
o hei dmi sbiiy t
ti .
ral
c. The M o i n i de e t t e e i s ks t e l e de e pe t ni t
t o s ni d o he xt nt t ee o xc ude vi nc rai ng o

t pa tc a us De e
he riulr es f ndant made of t $1 1 475. ba a e a is .
s
he , 30, 00 l nc t s ue
Pl i if m a a i e d e r ga di how D e enda s s nt o us d t
a ntf
y dm t vi enc e r ng
f
nt pe r e he
m oney a t i . Suc e d e i c e ry r e nt t t a l ga i i t
t ral
h vi enc s l a l el va o he le tons n he

ThidAm e d Compl i .
r
nde
ant
d. The M oto i de e t t e e i s ks t e l a c t i e a lbe wee
i n s ni d o he xt nt t ee o xc ude era n m i t n

RonniChowdr a Stve Kaae sdae Aprl1 201 ( 226 . The
y nd e n rlka td i 0, 4 DE 1
e a l i not pr t c e by t a t ne clen prvieg M o e r t em a l
m i s
oe td
he tor y- i t i l e.
r ove , he
i

i r e nt a ispr tvevauei notouweg dbyt unfi prj cei
s elva , nd t obai l s
t ihe
he ar eudi t
a l gedl m ay c us t D e e
le y
a e o f ndan s pu s nt t Fe r l Rul of Evi nc
t r ua o de a
e
de e

403( .
b)
e. The M o i i g a e i pa t a de e i pa t t t e ent i s eks t
ton s r nt d n r nd ni d n r o he xt
t e
o
e ude e de
xcl
vi nce r l t d t t GCV C A s oci t s 'ta ac i n. Pl ntf i
e a e o he E
s a e ' r ns to
ai i f s
pe te t i r
nnit d o nt oduc evi nc r r ng t a ount of m o y i ve i
e de e ega di he m
ne nvol d n

t ta aci (. t t a s l prc a t a
he rns ton ie.he otl ae ie nd he mountoft commison) a
he
si , s
wel a t da e of t t a a ton. A ddii l t pa te a e or r d t
l s he t
he r ns c i
tonaly, he r i s r de e o
conf r di appr at r
er egar ng
opri e edactons t t pur e and sal agr ent
i
o he chas
e eem

whi h Pl i if s e t i t oduc a ti l The nam es of t non- r i s t
c a ntf e ks o n r
e t ra .
he
pa te o
t l w s t a t s ii a r a i ntte m a be r c e a di c s d
he a ui nd he pec t c ipl ne de ii d y
eda t d, s s us e
att Sept ber 17,2018 heari
he
em
ng.

f The M oton i gr nt d i pa t a de e i pa t t t e en i s e t
.
i s a e n r nd ni d n r o he xt t t e ks o

e l e de e pe ti ng t as e s i om e or r ve
xc ude vi nc rani o s t, nc , e nue of Atas Luxur
l
y
J t , LLC. The Cour frt not s t t Pli ifs couns l sa e a t
es
t is
e ha a ntf'
e tt d t he
Se e be 17,2018 he i t t Pl i if doe not r ly ha a s h
pt m r
, arng ha a ntf
s
ea l
ve ny uc
e de e. The Cour fnds t t e d nc pe t i ng t a s t , i m e or
vi nc
t i
ha vi e e r a pi o s e s nco ,
r ve
e nue of A ta Luxur J t LLC, i no r e nt t Pl i if s t r o
ls
y e s,
s t el va o a ntf heo y f

s c s la lt Howe r e de e r ga di t fna i l de lngs
uc es or ibiiy.
ve , vi nc e r ng he i nc a
ai
bet een St
w
even K ar ekas and A tas Luxur J t , LLC , m a pos i y be
al
l
y es
y
s bl

r l va ba e on t c e i whi h s h e de i i r
e e nt s d
he ont xt n
c uc vi nce s nt oduc a ti l I
ed t r a . f
Pl i if w ihe t i r
a ntf s s o ntoduce s h e de e or t s i ony a t i ,i s l a e t
uc vi nc
e tm
t ral t ha l l r
o
pposng c
i ouns la t Co ti ad nc s t Cour c n r l o t i s
e nd he ur n va e o he
t a u e n he s ue
i lg oft ot e denc a t tm ony a
n i ht he her vi e nd es i
dduce a ti l
d t ra .
2. Pl nt f M ot on i Li i t Excl Testm ony R egardi Pl nt f Tax and
ai i cs
i n m ne o
ude
i
ng ai ics

Ac ountng Praci sand Pl ntf' Pr i ' Di ce I 2291i GRANTED
c i
tce
ai ifs esdents vor DE
s
I PART AN D D EN I I PA RT.
N
ED N

a. TheM oto ( 2291i grntd t t e entt tPl ntf s e t e l e
in DE
s a e o he xt ha ai if e ks o xcud
e de e r ga di Pl ntf s pr i nt s di c pr ee ngs a di c
vi nc e r ng ai if
es de ' vor e oc di
nd vor e
s tl m e a t i l Bas upon t da e and f c spr s nt d t t Cour a t
e te nt t r a .
ed
he t s
a t e e e o he
t t he
Se e be 1 201 he r ng, he Cour tnds t D e e
pt m r 7, 8 a i t
ti
hat f ndan s s k t i r
t ee o ntoduc
e
e de e r ga di Pl i ifs pr i nts di ce bas d on m er s c a i n.
vi nc e r ng a ntf
es de ' vor
e
e pe ul to

S he i e c i n trlv n a d a p a st b mo eu fil p eu iilta
uc v d n e s o ee a t n p e r o e r n ary rj dca h n
pr tve t
oba i mderFe r lRul ofEvi nce 403. H ow e r a di c s d a t
de a
e
de
ve , s s us e t he
Sept ber 17,2018 hearng,s d D ef
em
i houl
endant pr de t Cour w ih m or
s ovi he
t t
e

s ii da e , i or a i a s
pec tc t s nf m t on, nd uppo t by w a of a i sbl e de e
r
y
dm s i e vi nc
4

r ga di t a l ged pr tve na ur of t di c pr ee ngs t Cour
e r ng he le
oba i
t e
he vor e oc di , he
t
w ilr addr s t m a tr The Cour a s not t tD e enda s ha ag e d
l e- e s he te .
t l o es ha f
nt ve r e

t e l e de epe ti ng t t r as f rPl i ipspr sde ' di r
o xc ude vi nc rani o he e ons o antf
e i nts vo ce

@ 266, 21 a t te de e t tmo orag nti as e l
DE
p. , nd ha vi nc ,esi ny, rume s lo xcuded.
b. The M oton i de ed t t e e t tPl i ifs e t e l q s i a
i s ni o he xt nt ha a ntf e ks o xc ude ue tons nd

t si o r gar ng Pl i ifand Pl ntf spr i ' t xes tx oblgai ,
e tm ny e di
antf
ai if esdents a , a
i tons
a a co i pr tce . Suc e de
nd c untng aci s
h vi nce i r e nt as i i i ti bl
s elva
t s nex rca y
i e t i w ih t f c salege i t Thid Am e d Com pl nt2 I w o d
nt rw ned t he a t l d n he r
nde
ai . t ul

b u f i a dp eu iil oDe e d n s d fn et tyt s r ial e cs t i
e n ar n rj d ca t fn a t' e e s o r o u gc l x ie hs
y
e de e a ti l The Co tsm pl ha no f i w a t e l s h e de e
vi nc t r a .
ur i y s
a r y o xc ude uc vi nc
ort tm ony a t i li lg oft s r ng a uni f t i ve i t sca e
esi
t ra n i ht he ta e nd que ac s nvol d n hi s .
I a s m ia vei t Cour wil a l t i t oduc i of e de e a
n
i l r n, he
t l low he n r
ton
vi nc nd

t tmony r r ng Def nda s t xes t x oblga i , a ac ountng
esi
ega di
e nt ' a , a
i tons nd c i
pr c i es H ow e r t Cour c i ns c
a tc .
ve , he
t auto ouns t t i w il not alow s h
el ha t l
l
uc

e de eortsi
vi nc e tmonyt be omeamaorf t eoft tila ii j tonepat
o c
j eaur he ra s t s us
r
oft t alevi , t be adduced i t s case.
he ot
dence o
n hi
3. Pl ntf M oti i Li i t Excl
ai irs
on n m ne o
ude A rgum ent R egardi D et l of Tyrus
ng
ais

W i Trans to I 2301i GRANTED I PART Ar DENI I PART.
ngs
acin DE
s
N
ED N
D e e nt ha agr e t e l e de e o t i ntt oft pa te t t Tyr
f nda s ve e d o xc ude vi nc f he de iy he r i s o he us

W i Tr ns c i a e de e pe ti ng t t s l prce a t i ntt oft
ngs a a ton nd vi nc rani o he ae i nd he de iy
he
2 Att Sep em b l7,2 8h aig Plit f c u sl r u dta Plit f s oln e p ruigterl f o ! tn
he t er
01 ern , ani ' o ne ag e h t ani in o gr us n h ei su h i
fs
f
e

Co tI o teThr Ame d dCompan, c c n Plitf' c u sl e cie a s e igs eyij n tv
un V fh id n e
litwhih ou t anifs o n e d srb d s e kn oll nu cle
rl f Dee d ns c u sl r u dta Co n I s e sb t ij n t er l fa mo eayda g sa dta
ei . fn a t' o ne ag e h t u t V e k oh nu ci ei nd n tr ma e n h t
e
v e

Pl ntf ha n moved t a e iscom pl n t r m ove Cou I asr r d. TheCour wilhe raddii
ai if s ot
o m nd t
ai t o e
nt V, equie
t l a
tonal
ar um enta
g
boutCountI a t Sep em b 20,201 hea i a wilde e m i w he he t s ve ,srke, ordim i s
V t he t er
8 rng nd l t r ne
t r o e r ti
s s
Coun I ort ean ot ra i r r ng Countl .
t V ak y he cton egadi
V

arr f. ( 266,p.21 Dee nt ma pr e a e de a tilt W ic at DE
. fnda s y esnt s vi nce t ra he 9
r lt d t t Tyr s W i ta a ton a a s a e doc e s de ii
ea e o he
u
ng r ns ci
nd s ocit d
um nt, poston
des g tons f om Ge f A ndr w s de ii r ga di t t a a ton,and e a l
i na i
r
of
e ' pos ton e r ng he r ns c i
m i
c r s nde e t o f om G e fA ndr w s r l t t t t a a i n. Such e de e
or e po nc o r r
of
e e a ed o he r ns cto
vi nc
i i xt i a y i e t i d w ih t f c soft s c e a i r l va t t i s t be
s ne r c bl nt r w ne t he a t
hi as nd s e e nt o he s ues o
d i a t i l H ow e r Def nda s m ay not pr e as e de e a t i e a l
ec ded t r a .
ve , e nt
es nt
vi nc t ral m is

be we n Ge fAnd e a de e e couns ,a t e e ais wo d po e i l a
t e
of
r ws nd f ns
el s hos m l ul t ntaly nd
unne s a iy t n def ns c
ce s r l ur
e e ouns l i t a w ine s M or ove ,t y a a t l c
e no
t s.
e r he ppe r o a k
a r lr e nc t t i s st be t i d.
ny ea el va e o he s ue o
re
Pl ntf A m ended M ot on i Li i t A dm i Evi
ai irs
i n m ne o
t
dence of C ert n Pri
ai
or

Conduc I 2331 whih de l wih Defnda s prorl uis i DENI f t
t DE
, c as t
e nt' i aws t, s
ED or he
r s sae i Paagrph 1b)a
eaons ttd n r a ( bove.
5. Fi l ast a lf M otons t Cour ' r lngs a e pr -r a a a e ba ed upon t
naly, o l our
i , he
ts u i
r e ti l nd r s
he

e d n ea ag me t r s ne t teCo r a ti j n t r . Th Co r n tsta
vie c nd r u n p e e td o h u t t h s u cu e
e ut oe h t
i ca a w a r co i r t e us on of a e de or t s i on ba e upon t
t n l ys e ns de he xcl i
ny vi nce
e tm y s d
he
r ltes oft i l The pa tes a e fee t r - dd e s t e us on ofevi nce i t s
ea ii
ra .
r i r r o e a r s he xcl i
de
n hi

Or e d rn tilo tiet e p e e e o t ej r i te h v a ra o be g o
d r u ig ra u sd h r snc f h u y f h y a e e s na l, o d
f t ba i t do s ba e upon t t s i on e de e, o a g e s pr s nt a
aih s s o
o sd
he e tm y, vi nc r r um nt e e ed t
t al
ri .

D N E and O RD ER ED i Cha be s a W es Pal Bea h, m B e c Count Fl i a,
n
m r t
t m
c Pal
ah
y, or d
t s
hi

y ---spe e 201:.
/dyo etmbr
af
,

%
.

W I A M M A T EW M AN
LLI
U nie St t s M a i t a e J
td ae
sr t udge
6