FREESTREAM AIRCRAFT USA LTD. v. CHOWDRY
Filing
61
ORDER AWARDING ATTORNEY'S FEES TO PLAINTIFF AND AGAINST DEFENDANT: that Defendant Ronni Chowdry shall reimburse Plaintiff for attorney's fees in the amount of $6,156.75 within thirty (30) days of this Order. Signed by Magistrate Judge William Matthewman on 10/20/2017. (kza)
UN I
TED STATES D I
STRI COU RT
CT
SO UTHERN D I
STRI O F FLORI A
CT
D
Ci lN o.1 c 81
vi
6- v- 232- A TTH EW M A N
M
FR EESTREAM A I RAFT U SA LTD .
RC
,
Pl n if
aitf ,
F L Db
IE y
C.
.
2s1 2 2 2 1
27
RON N ICH OW D RY ,d/ / A TLA S A V I TI
ba
A ON
SA LES A N D LEA SI G,a k/ A TLA S A V I TI ,
N
/ a
A ON
SuR tbLR' I.
cEE M Asr R
TVN P T
E
s fu J olMI :
.
D. zf ,.uv.8s
o! , i é? .
I . .'
.
.
D e e nt
f nda .
O R D ER A W A R DI G A TTO R N EY ' FEES TO PL AI TI A N D A G A I ST
N
S
N FF
N
D EFEN D AN T
TH I CA U SE i be or t Co t upon Pl i if Fr s r m A ic a t U SA , Lt '
S
s f e he ur
a ntf , ee tea
rr f
d.s
Cû ai if' Memor
pl ntf )
andum i Su tof Pli ifs Fee Awad (t e r ndum' g 471
n ppor
antf'
r tM mo a
' DE .
)
De e nt Ro Chowdr d/ / Atas Avi ton Saes a Le i a k/ Ata Aviton,has
f nda , nni
y ba l
ai
l nd asng / a ls
ai
fl aRe pons g 5 .Thi mat i now rpef rr e
ied s e DE 21 s ter s
i o eviw.
BA C K G R O UN D
On Se em be 27,201 t unde s gned e e e an O r r G r ntng i Pa ta Denyi
pt
r
7, he
ri
nt r d
de a i n r nd
ng
i P r Plitf sM oin f rS n to sg 4 1
n a t an if
to o a cin DE 4 .TheCo r g a tda a r o at r e sfe
u t r ne n wad f to n y' e s
i f
n avor of Pl ntf a a ns Def nt purua t Rul 37( ( ( a t i rnt
ai if nd gai t enda
s nt o e b)2)C) nd he nhee
a to iy a d j rs ito o t e Co r. 1 .a p 2. Th a r o fe wa l td t t e
uh rt n u idcin f h u t d t .
e wad f e s s i e o h
mi
at ne s f es e nded b Pli ifs c
tor y' e xpe
y a ntf
ouns l i flng and ltgai Pli ifs M oton f
e n ii
ii tng antf
i or
Sa tons g 271 1 The Cour r rd Pl ntf t fl a me a
nci DE . d.
t equie ai if o ie
morndum t s r t
o uppo t he
a o ofa t y' f es a cos sbe ng c ai ed a r qui e D e enda t fl a m e or nd
m unt tonw s e nd t i l m
nd e r d f
nt o ie
m a um
i r pons t Pl ntf sm e o andum . 1
n es
e o ai if
m r
d.
1
I Pl ntf s M e or ndum , i c am s t t is at eys e
n ai if
m a
t li
ha t tom
xpende 37. ho s i
d
4 ur n
r ea c ng a dr f i t m oton f s nc i a r pl pr - oton ana ys s a e f t t
es r hi nd a tng he
i or a tons nd e y, e m i
l i , nd f or s o
c n e .g 4 , 2) Plitf a dto al sae t a i ic re at tl f$ ,7 i atnzy'
o f r DE 7 p. . an if d iin ly tts h t t n u rd oa o 296 4 n to e s
f es f r t dr hi a a g ng of t moton f s nc i . I a p. 3. Ata d t t
e o he a ng nd r ui
he
i or a tons d. t
tche o he
M e rnd i t Afi vi ofLa e F.Loui.g 47- 1
moa um s he fda t
ur n
s DE
1.
I rs
n e pons ,De e ntfrtnot t tt m oto f s nc i wa 1 page i l ngt
e f nda is es ha he
i n or a tons s 4
s n e h,
onl ctdt s ve c e ,andc ane 2- pa sofquotd maeil DE 52,p.1 .Dee t
y ie o e n ass
onti d 3 ge
e tra.(
j fndan
ne a g s t tt 7. hour of bilng fom be or t dr hi of t moton f s tons
xt r ue ha he 4
s
li r
f e he a ng
he
i or anci
s d notbe i ude i t f a r I a p.2. Def nda con e t tt ho slse by
houl
ncl d n he ee wa d. d t
e nt t nds ha he ur itd
c
ouns li t t bl af i d t M s Loui afi vi c a nsm or hour t n M s Loui 'nar a i
e n he a e fxe o .
s' fda t ont i
e
s ha
.
s r tve
a
boutho t hour wer s ntdoe . I a p.3. Def ndan as e t t tt Afi ts itd
w he
s e pe
s d t
e
t s rs ha he fdavi ubm te
by Pli ifsc
a ntf ouns doesno c an i n ie z d b e kdown orde al d tm e s e s'a f l
el
t ont i û t mi e r a
a
t ie i -he t' nd ais
t di c s t C oc l m ar t r t f l w ye s t r l tve co pl t of t s c e or e n t
o s us he û a
l
ke a es or a r , he e a i
m exiy
hi as
ve he
p riua q aiiains o c u s lt two l j siy ez n e b l n rts' 1 .a p 5
a t lr u lfc t
c
o f o n e ha u d u tf l c d il g ae . d t . .
ha
i
'
De e ntmai ans t tt f e a r cli d i exc sve. I I s ,De e
f nda
nt i ha he e wa d a me s es i
d. n um
f ndan diput s
t s e
bot Pl ntf sc
h ai if ouns ' houry r t s a t tm e t tt y bil on t s m a t r I a p.
els
l a e nd he i ha he led
hi te . d t 6.
LE GA L STA N DA R D
A r s na e at ne s f e a r i çpr pe l ca c a e by muli yi t numbe of
ea o bl tor y' e wa d s s o ry l ult d
tpl ng he
r
ho s r a ona y e nde on t ltga i tm e a r as
ur e s bl xpe d
he ii ton i s e onabl houry r t ' Am .Ci i Li r i s
e
l a e.
'
v l be te
Uni v Bar s,1 F. 423,427 ( 1h Ci.1
on . ne 68 3d
1 t r 999)( i Bl v St son,465 U. 886,
quotng um . en
S.
8 8( 9 4 ) Thi So e tr' yte bea j se f rt r s lso tie b t eatr e S e
8 1 9 ). s t d sa 'ma h n du td o he e ut ban d y h to n y. e
l
Bar s,l F. a 427 (ii Lo ange v Ste hem,1 F. 776,781( 1h Ci.1 ) The
ne 68 3d t
ctng r r . ir i 0 3d
1 t r 994).
r s bl hour y r t i defne as t t e lng m a ketr t i t r l va l galc m uniy
ea ona e
l ae s i d
he s vaii
pr
r
a e n he e e nt e
om
t
2
f smia s r c s by l wye s of r s bl c pa a e s ls expe inc , a r put ton.
or i l r e vi e
a r
ea ona y om r bl kil ,
re e nd e a i '
'
Ba n s l 8F.da 4 6( ot gNo ma v Ho sn Auh o o to r 8 6F.d 1 9 ,1 9
r e , 6 3 t 3 qu i r n . u ig t. fM ng mey, 3 2 2 2 2 9
n
( 1hCi.1 )
1 t r 999).
W ih r ar t t t ofe de e t tt f e cli nts ul pr
t eg d o he ype
vi nc ha he e a ma ho d oduce i s
n uppor ofa
t
cl i ,i Ba ne t El ve h Cicui ha s a ed,
a m n r s, he e nt r t s t t
The' eea i ntbea st bur ofe t ihi e il me a doc e i
ç pplca
f
r he den sabls ng ntte nt nd um ntng
t a opr a e hour a houry r t . N o m an,836 F. at1
he ppr i t
s nd
l a es' r
'
2d
303. Tha bur n
t de
i l
ncudesSs yi t c twih s cii a de a ld e denc fom whi t
tuppl ng he our t pe fc nd t ie vi e r
ch he
c tc n de er i t r a ona e houry r t Furhe ,f couns ls d ha
our a t m ne he e s bl
l a e. t r ee
e houl ve
m a nt i d r c dst s
i a ne e or o how t tm e s nton t dif r tcl i s a t ge r l
he i pe
he f e en a m , nd he ne a
s be t te o tetmee e dt r so g t ob sto t t s fiin
u j c matr f h i xp n iu e u h t e e u wih u fce t
pa tc a iy s t tt diti c tc a s s t tme cai f e h aci t
riulrt o ha he srct our an s e s he i l med or ac tviy
. . . . A w e lpr
l- epa e f e pe ii a s w oul i l a s m a y,gr ng t
r d e tton l o
d nc ude um r oupi he
tmee ti byt naur oft aci t orsa oft ca e. 1 (iai
i nres he t e he tviy tge he s ' d. cttons
'
omitd)
te .
1 F. a 427.
68 3d t
AN A LY SIS A N D DISC USSIO N
1. R easonabl H ourl R at
e
y
e
I s e ng r m bur e e f isator y' f es Pl i ifr le on t a f da tofLa e
n e ki ei
s m nt or t t ne s e , a ntf e i s he f i vi
ur n
F. Loui , Es , s ppori t c a m e hour y r t of Pl i if s couns l A c or ng t t
s q. u
tng he l i d
l a es
a ntf '
e.
c di o he
a fda t M s Loui bil a t r t of$570 pe hour Dani Crs no,Es ,a sa fa t ne bil
fi vi, . s ls t he a e
r
;
el ipi
q. t f tor y, ls
a t r t of $320 perhour Cor Gr Es ,a a s it bil a a r t of $ pe hour
t he a e
; ey ay, q. n s oca e, ls t a e
480 r
;
Courney Roc t,Es ,a pa t ,bil a a r t of$900;a M i ha Cavi a pa a e la
t
ket q.
rner ls t a e
nd c el l n, r l ga nd
c s ma a e, il a ter t o $ 9 0 p rh u . ( 4 - 1 De e d n a g sta ra o a e
a e n g r b ls t h ae f 2 0.0 e o r DE 7 1. fn a t r ue h t e s n bl
r t sf Pli ifscouns lwoul be t f l ng:$350 pe hourf bot M s Roc t a M s
a e or a ntf'
e
d he olowi
r
or h . ke t nd .
Loui,$275pe hourf Mr Gr ( wa admitd t t FlrdaBa i 201 ,$ pe hour
s
r
or . ay who s
te o he o i
r n 5) 250 r
f Mr Crs no ( wasa te t t Fl i Ba i 201 ,a $1 f Mr Cal n (
or . ipi who
dmitd o he orda r n 6) nd 25 or . vi a
3
p r lg l. g 5 , 6 .
aae a) DE 2 p. j
The Co thasc i e t afi vi,t s ppori e de e,a t John on f t s
ur
onsder d he fda t he u
tng vi nc nd he
s acor .
Fis ,w ih r gar t M s Roc t,w ho i a a t ne i N ew Yor of i e of he l w fn',t
rt t e d o
. ke t
s n tor y n
k fc
r a i n he
El ve h Cicui Cour ofA ppe s has he d,a t Sout r D i t i tof Fl i has r c ni e
e nt r t
t
al
l nd he
he n sr c
orda
e og z d,
t ge r l i he û e eva m a ke 'f pur es of de e m i ng t r as na e ho l r t f
hat ne aly, û r l nt r t or pos
t
t r ni he e o bl ur y a e or
a z ator y' s vi s i the pl c wher t c e i f l d.' Bar s 1 F. a 43 s e
l t ne s er ce s t
ae
e he as s ie ''
ne , 68 3d t 7; e
Hemosla v Coc col Co.Cas No.1 21 8- V,2011W L 936
r il . a- a , e
0- 41 C1
4952a *7 ( D.Fl J y
t S. a. ul
1 2011 .l or rt rc non-oc lrts t f a ia mus s t tt r i al kof
5, ) n de o e over l a ae ,he ee pplc nt t how ha hee s ac
a t ne pr c i ng i t l lm a ke who a ewilng a abl t handl t c e. Bar s 1
tor ys a tci n he oca r t
r li nd e o
e he as
ne , 68
F. a 437. The Cour fnds t tt r a e pl nt ofa t r ys i So h Fl i t tcoul ha
3d t
ti
ha he e r e y
t o ne n ut orda ha
d ve
ha e t s c s a m or s ii aly,t di cove y pr ctc i t s c s Ba e upon on t
ndl d hi a e nd, e pec fc l he s
r a i e n hi a e. s d
he
Cour ' ow n know l dge a e r e e,t Cour c udes t t M s Roc t ' hour y r t of
ts
e
nd xpe i nc he
t oncl
ha
. ke t s
l ae
$900 i ve y hi c
s r gh, ompa e t t r nge ofr t s c r nty c r i t Sout r Diti tof
r d o he a
a e ure l ha ged n he
he n src
Fl i f sm ia s r c by lwye s of r s bl c pa a e s ls e renc a
orda or i l r e vies
a r
ea ona y om r bl kil, xpe i e nd
r put i n. See Bi i , a 1
e ato
vns t 350,n.2. l t a an houry r t of $ 00 f M s Roc t i
nse d,
l ae
400. or . ke t s
a r as bl and s t e a t r tve t t m os c os y a o m a es a r t f a c pe e
e ona e
uiabl le na i ha
t l el ppr xi t
a e or
om t nt
a r as bl prce l ad parne i t s m ar t w ho coul s es f l handl a r l tvel
nd e ona y i d e
t r n hi
ke
d ucc s uly
e ea i y
smpl m oto f s nc i . Se Naton M ot Cl b,I .v St brd Cas I .Co. N o.1
i e i n or a tons e i
or u nc . one ige
. ns
,
0-
811 CI 201 W L 6729648,*2( D.Fl Aug.2,201 (i ng$400. t bearas bl
57- V, 3
S. a.
3) fndi
00 o
e ona e
houry r t i r s ndi t a m oton f r pr t ctve or r f a pa t r w ih t e y- i ye r '
l a e n e po ng o
i o oe i
de or
r ne t w nt fve a s
e re e)
xpe inc .
The Cour no es t tt l k of a e r af i vi i s
t t ha he ac
n xpe t fda t n uppor of t c a m e r t i no
t he l i d a e s t
f t . A fe a l S he c t e t r t i or a la e,i is l a e r on t que ton a m a
a al
t r l, t
t our , ihe ral ppe l t s t e f n xpe t he
s i nd y
4
c i risown knowl e a expe i nc c
onsde t
edg nd
re e once i r as bl a pr
m ng e ona e nd operf esa ma f m
e nd y or
a id pe d n j d me tet rwih o wih u te ad o wi e s sa t v l . No ma ,8 6
n n e n etu g n i
he t r t o t h i f t se s o aue' r n 3
n
'
F.2d at1 (iai omitd) Ho r wihouta explnai a t why t rmani
303 cttons te . weve, t
ny
a ton s o
he e i ng
a t neys s d r ce ve s
tor
houl e i uch hi h r t a bas d on t Co ts ow n kno l dge a
g a es nd
e
he ur '
w e
nd
e renc t Cour fndst tM s Loui'houry r t s d be r duce t $375,M r Gr y'
xpe i e, he
t i ha . s
l a e houl
e d o
. a s
houry r t s d ber e t $275,M r Crs no' houry r t s d be r duc t $
l ae houl
educ d o
. ipi s
l a e houl
e ed o 250,a
nd
M r Cal n, houry r t shoul be r duced t $1 1
o 50.
vi s
l ae
d
e
.
2.
Num ber ofH ours R easonabl Expended
y
N e t C o tm us det nni w he he t ho s bil w e e r s bl I t t bl
xt he ur
t e ne
t r he ur led r ea ona e. n he a e
con ai d w ihi M s Loui 'afi vi,i s a e t tPl i if s c
t ne t n .
s fda t t t t s ha a ntf ouns s nt61 hour t a on t s
el pe
s ot l hi
matr ( 47- 1 TheCour frtnotst tPl ntf scouns di notat h a tmee re
te . DE 1 .
t is e ha ai if
el d
tac ny i ntis
t t a fda t s t Cou tmus r l on M s Loui 'na i e ast t ts compl t r aed
o he fi vi, o he
r
t ey
.
s nutv
o he a ks
eed elt
t t f lng a a gui of t m o i n f s nc i . The Sept be 27,2017 he r ng on t
o he ii nd r ng
he t o or a tons
em r
ai
he
m oton w a a oxi a e y 1 2 hour . W he t Cour c i r t l ng h of t he r ng i
i
s ppr m t l .
s
n he
t ons de s he e t
he a i n
c nu cin wi Ms Lo s n raie i a pe r t tMr Cavn bi e o y 7. ho r o ti
o j n to t . ui' artv , t p as ha . l i l d nl 5 u s n h s
h
l
matr( t9. hour ascl medi t tbl ,Mr Gr bild onl 1 2hour ont smatr(
te no 4
s ai n he a e) . ay le y 7.
s hi te not
1 2ascli d i t t e) a Ms Loui bil onl 20. hour ont smatr( 29. hour
8.
ame n he abl , nd . s led y 6 s hi te not 4
s
a dame i t t e .M r Crs no' 3. hour a Mr Roc ts0. hour lsedi t tbl
s i d n he abl) . ipi s 7
s nd . ket' 3
s it n he a e
a e ac ount d f i M s Loui 'na r tve.
r c
e or n .
s ra i
The Co thasc e uly r vi w e M s Loui 'expl na i oft hour bil d r l t d t t
ur
ar f l e e d .
s
a ton he
s le e a e o he
lThe Cour i not fndi t t t s r duce r t w oul ne s arl be t a i abl
ts
i ng ha he e e
d a es
d ce s iy
he pplc e
bil bl r t s i any m o i f a t y' f s w hi h m a be l t r f l by Pl ntf ' c
la e a e n
ton or tonw s ee
c
y
a e ied
ai i f s ouns l
e.
M o e r t Cour i not m a ng a ne tve com m e on t c pe enc of Pl ntf s
r ove , he
ts
ki ny ga i
nt
he om t y
ai i f
c e i t sc e.Quiet t c rr t underi d i veyf la wihLa e F. s
ouns l n hi as
t o he ontay,he
sgne s r amiir t urn Loui,
Es ,a know s he t be a hi hl s le e hi l a e r m e y com pe e c
q. nd
ro
g y kil d, t ca , nd xt e l
t nt ouns .
el
5
m oton f s nc i . Fis ,t Cour a e w ih D e e
i or a tons r t he
t gr es t
f ndants a gum e t tt a t ne s f e
' r
nt ha he tor y' e
a a d s d not i ude t 7. hour i ur e i ç na yzi D e e nts a w er pr or
w r houl
ncl
he 4
s nc r d n ç l ng
a
f nda ' ns , i
e de ,a atemptng t conf rwih de e e c
vi nce nd t i o
e t f ns ouns lbef e begi ng t undera t dr f
e
or
nni o
tke o a t
t M oto f Sa tons ' The Cour onl g a e s nc i f a t e s f es i ur e i
he
i n or nc i .
'
t y r nt d a tons or tom y' e nc r d n
pr pa i flng,a a g ng t m oton f s ncton a r pl t r t The Co tdoe not
e rng, ii
nd r ui he
i or a i nd e y he e o.
ur
s
c i rt 7. hour t f l w ihi t s
ons de he 4
s o a l t n he cope oft a t ne sf s a a d.
he tor y' ee w r
Se
cond,Pl ntf s m oton f r s nc i was a oxi a el 1 page i l t a di
ai i f
i o a tons
ppr m t y 2
s n eng h nd d
no c a n a c pl x a g e s I s d notha t ke over 22 colec i hour t dr f
t ont i ny om e r um nt . t houl
ve a n
l tve
s o at
a fnai e a l pa moton. The amountoftm e bil i be
nd i lz
z- ge
i
i
led s yond wha wa nec s r and
t s es a y
r a ona e Si lry,i s d nothavet n at alof1 5 hour t pr pa ef t he rng on
e s bl . mia l t houl
ake ot
5.
s o e r or he a i
t m oto f s nc i ns
he
i n or a t o .
Thid,t na r i i M s Loui a fda t doe s em t be co m e u ae wih bl k
r he ratve n .
s' fi vi
s e
o
m ns r t t oc
bilng. Thi i no pe s i ebe aus i pr ve st Cour fom de e ni whih pori of
li
s s t nnisbl c e t e nt he
tr
t nni ng
c
ton
t f e bil d on a pa tc a da e and ort s i r cove a e a whi h i not l i t Pl i if s
he e s le
r i ul r t
/ ak s e
r bl nd
e s . t s he a ntf
bur n t pr ry documen is hour ,a Pli if has pr de i ufi int s
de o ope l
tt
s nd antf
ovi d ns fce uppor f t
t or he
hour cl m e
s ai d.
Fourh,i a ar ba e on t lm ied i or a in be or t Cour t ts r at ne
t t ppe s s d
he i t nf m to f e he
t ha eve al tor ys
w e e w or ng on t s m e t s . Thi i not pe m it d. Se N aton M ot r Cl 201 W L
r
ki
he a
a ks
s s
r te
e
i
o
ub, 3
6729648 a *2 (çEl c at ne sc rbutonsmus beditnc,a no rdunda ,i or rt
t sg a h tor y' onti i
t
si t nd t e
nt n de o
mertcompe ai ' . Theewasno ne d f f at ne a aparl lt bei ve i a
i
nston.)
'
r
e or our tor ys nd
aega o nvol d n
r a i l s m pl m o i f s nc i ns
el tve y i e ton or a to .
3.
C al ul i ofA tor y' Fe A w ard
c at on
t ne s e
l o de t c c a e t a opra e f a a d t Cour tr tm us m uli y t r duc d
n r r o al ul t he ppr i t ee w r he
t is
t tpl he e e
6
r s bl r t of t a t e and pa a e
ea ona e a es
he tom ys
r l gal by t num be of hour t t a e a t l
he
r
s ha r c ualy
s ot l s 4 626
a ount f r i M s Loui 'na r tve. Thi t a i $1 , . The Cour w il a s s r ct3.
cc ed o n .
s ra i 2
t l l o ubta
7
hour bil d by M r Crs no a 3. ho s bil d by M s Loui be aus as e ai a
s le
. i pi nd 7 ur le
.
s c e, xpl ned bove, hi
t s
tm ef l ou sde oft s ope oft a tm e sf esa r
i als t i
he c
he to y' e wa d.Thene t a i $1 31 50.
w ot l s 2, 3.
Ne ,ûwl nadititc ti t numbe ofhour cli d i unras yhi t
xtkl he
src our fnds he
r
s ame s e onabl gh,he
c tha t o c ce ;i m a c
our s w hoi s t y onduc a hourbyt n
- hour a ys s or i m a r duce t r ques e
nal i
t y e
he e
td
hour w ih a a r s t boa d c . Bi i , 5 F. a 1
s t n c os -he- r ut' v ns 48 3d t 350. H e e,Pl ntf ha not m e is
'
r
ai if s
tt
bur n of e t bls ng e il m e t and doc e a i of al of t hour bil d, a
de
s a i hi
ntte nt o
um nt ton
1
he
s le
s
r quied. Taki i o a ount a l of t defc e e i t bilng e r e a t e es i
e r
ng nt cc
l
he i i nci s n he li nti s nd he xc s ve
na ur of tm e bil d, t Cour w il r duce t f a a d by 50% . The t al a t y' f s
t e
i
le he
t l e
he ee w r
ot tonw s ee
a r i t e or $6, 56.
wa d s her f e 1 75.
CO N CLU SI N
O
Ba e o t f egoi i i he e ORDERED t Def ndan RonniChowdr s l
s d n he or ng, t s r by
hat e
t
y hal
r i bure Pli iff r is at ne s f es i t a ountof$6, 56. Def ndanti or r d t
em s antf o t tor y' e n he m
1 75.
e
s de e o
ma
ke s h pa nt wihi t ry (
uc
yme
t n hit 30) da fom t dae
ys r
he t
t s (r r
hi lde.
2Thecac ai woul be$15 tm e 7 5 hour f M r Cavi $250 tmes3. hour f M r
lul ton
d
0i s
s or . l n,
i
7
s or .
Crs no,$275tm e 1 2 hour f M r Gr y,$375 tm es20. hour f M s Loui,a $400
ipi
i s 7.
s or . a
i
6
s or .
s nd
.
tm es0. f M s Roc t .
i
3 or . ke t
7
D O NE A N D O R DER ED i Cha be st s
n
m r hi Z&
a o Oco e, 2017,atW estPal
y f tb r
m
Be ch,Pal Bea h Count i t Sout n Di t i tofFl i .
a
m
c
y, n he
her s rc
or da
'
'
w .
$
W I A M M A TTH EW M N
LLI
UN I
TED STA TES M A G I
STM TE J D GE
U
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?