FREESTREAM AIRCRAFT USA LTD. v. CHOWDRY

Filing 61

ORDER AWARDING ATTORNEY'S FEES TO PLAINTIFF AND AGAINST DEFENDANT: that Defendant Ronni Chowdry shall reimburse Plaintiff for attorney's fees in the amount of $6,156.75 within thirty (30) days of this Order. Signed by Magistrate Judge William Matthewman on 10/20/2017. (kza)

UN I
TED STATES D I
STRI COU RT
CT
SO UTHERN D I
STRI O F FLORI A
CT
D
Ci lN o.1 c 81
vi
6- v- 232- A TTH EW M A N
M
FR EESTREAM A I RAFT U SA LTD .
RC
,

Pl n if
aitf ,

F L Db
IE y

C.

.

2s1 2 2 2 1
27
RON N ICH OW D RY ,d/ / A TLA S A V I TI
ba
A ON
SA LES A N D LEA SI G,a k/ A TLA S A V I TI ,
N
/ a
A ON

SuR tbLR' I.
cEE M Asr R
TVN P T
E
s fu J olMI :
.

D. zf ,.uv.8s
o! , i é? .
I . .'
.

.

D e e nt
f nda .
O R D ER A W A R DI G A TTO R N EY ' FEES TO PL AI TI A N D A G A I ST
N
S
N FF
N
D EFEN D AN T
TH I CA U SE i be or t Co t upon Pl i if Fr s r m A ic a t U SA , Lt '
S
s f e he ur
a ntf , ee tea
rr f
d.s

Cû ai if' Memor
pl ntf )
andum i Su tof Pli ifs Fee Awad (t e r ndum' g 471
n ppor
antf'
r tM mo a
' DE .
)
De e nt Ro Chowdr d/ / Atas Avi ton Saes a Le i a k/ Ata Aviton,has
f nda , nni
y ba l
ai
l nd asng / a ls
ai

fl aRe pons g 5 .Thi mat i now rpef rr e
ied s e DE 21 s ter s
i o eviw.
BA C K G R O UN D
On Se em be 27,201 t unde s gned e e e an O r r G r ntng i Pa ta Denyi
pt
r
7, he
ri
nt r d
de a i n r nd
ng

i P r Plitf sM oin f rS n to sg 4 1
n a t an if
to o a cin DE 4 .TheCo r g a tda a r o at r e sfe
u t r ne n wad f to n y' e s
i f
n avor of Pl ntf a a ns Def nt purua t Rul 37( ( ( a t i rnt
ai if nd gai t enda
s nt o e b)2)C) nd he nhee

a to iy a d j rs ito o t e Co r. 1 .a p 2. Th a r o fe wa l td t t e
uh rt n u idcin f h u t d t .
e wad f e s s i e o h
mi
at ne s f es e nded b Pli ifs c
tor y' e xpe
y a ntf
ouns l i flng and ltgai Pli ifs M oton f
e n ii
ii tng antf
i or

Sa tons g 271 1 The Cour r rd Pl ntf t fl a me a
nci DE . d.
t equie ai if o ie
morndum t s r t
o uppo t he
a o ofa t y' f es a cos sbe ng c ai ed a r qui e D e enda t fl a m e or nd
m unt tonw s e nd t i l m
nd e r d f
nt o ie
m a um
i r pons t Pl ntf sm e o andum . 1
n es
e o ai if
m r
d.
1

I Pl ntf s M e or ndum , i c am s t t is at eys e
n ai if
m a
t li
ha t tom
xpende 37. ho s i
d
4 ur n
r ea c ng a dr f i t m oton f s nc i a r pl pr - oton ana ys s a e f t t
es r hi nd a tng he
i or a tons nd e y, e m i
l i , nd f or s o

c n e .g 4 , 2) Plitf a dto al sae t a i ic re at tl f$ ,7 i atnzy'
o f r DE 7 p. . an if d iin ly tts h t t n u rd oa o 296 4 n to e s
f es f r t dr hi a a g ng of t moton f s nc i . I a p. 3. Ata d t t
e o he a ng nd r ui
he
i or a tons d. t
tche o he

M e rnd i t Afi vi ofLa e F.Loui.g 47- 1
moa um s he fda t
ur n
s DE
1.
I rs
n e pons ,De e ntfrtnot t tt m oto f s nc i wa 1 page i l ngt
e f nda is es ha he
i n or a tons s 4
s n e h,

onl ctdt s ve c e ,andc ane 2- pa sofquotd maeil DE 52,p.1 .Dee t
y ie o e n ass
onti d 3 ge
e tra.(
j fndan
ne a g s t tt 7. hour of bilng fom be or t dr hi of t moton f s tons
xt r ue ha he 4
s
li r
f e he a ng
he
i or anci
s d notbe i ude i t f a r I a p.2. Def nda con e t tt ho slse by
houl
ncl d n he ee wa d. d t
e nt t nds ha he ur itd
c
ouns li t t bl af i d t M s Loui afi vi c a nsm or hour t n M s Loui 'nar a i
e n he a e fxe o .
s' fda t ont i
e
s ha
.
s r tve

a
boutho t hour wer s ntdoe . I a p.3. Def ndan as e t t tt Afi ts itd
w he
s e pe
s d t
e
t s rs ha he fdavi ubm te
by Pli ifsc
a ntf ouns doesno c an i n ie z d b e kdown orde al d tm e s e s'a f l
el
t ont i û t mi e r a
a
t ie i -he t' nd ais
t di c s t C oc l m ar t r t f l w ye s t r l tve co pl t of t s c e or e n t
o s us he û a
l
ke a es or a r , he e a i
m exiy
hi as
ve he

p riua q aiiains o c u s lt two l j siy ez n e b l n rts' 1 .a p 5
a t lr u lfc t
c
o f o n e ha u d u tf l c d il g ae . d t . .
ha
i
'
De e ntmai ans t tt f e a r cli d i exc sve. I I s ,De e
f nda
nt i ha he e wa d a me s es i
d. n um
f ndan diput s
t s e
bot Pl ntf sc
h ai if ouns ' houry r t s a t tm e t tt y bil on t s m a t r I a p.
els
l a e nd he i ha he led
hi te . d t 6.
LE GA L STA N DA R D

A r s na e at ne s f e a r i çpr pe l ca c a e by muli yi t numbe of
ea o bl tor y' e wa d s s o ry l ult d
tpl ng he
r
ho s r a ona y e nde on t ltga i tm e a r as
ur e s bl xpe d
he ii ton i s e onabl houry r t ' Am .Ci i Li r i s
e
l a e.
'
v l be te

Uni v Bar s,1 F. 423,427 ( 1h Ci.1
on . ne 68 3d
1 t r 999)( i Bl v St son,465 U. 886,
quotng um . en
S.

8 8( 9 4 ) Thi So e tr' yte bea j se f rt r s lso tie b t eatr e S e
8 1 9 ). s t d sa 'ma h n du td o he e ut ban d y h to n y. e
l
Bar s,l F. a 427 (ii Lo ange v Ste hem,1 F. 776,781( 1h Ci.1 ) The
ne 68 3d t
ctng r r . ir i 0 3d
1 t r 994).
r s bl hour y r t i defne as t t e lng m a ketr t i t r l va l galc m uniy
ea ona e
l ae s i d
he s vaii
pr
r
a e n he e e nt e
om
t
2

f smia s r c s by l wye s of r s bl c pa a e s ls expe inc , a r put ton.
or i l r e vi e
a r
ea ona y om r bl kil ,
re e nd e a i '
'

Ba n s l 8F.da 4 6( ot gNo ma v Ho sn Auh o o to r 8 6F.d 1 9 ,1 9
r e , 6 3 t 3 qu i r n . u ig t. fM ng mey, 3 2 2 2 2 9
n
( 1hCi.1 )
1 t r 999).
W ih r ar t t t ofe de e t tt f e cli nts ul pr
t eg d o he ype
vi nc ha he e a ma ho d oduce i s
n uppor ofa
t
cl i ,i Ba ne t El ve h Cicui ha s a ed,
a m n r s, he e nt r t s t t

The' eea i ntbea st bur ofe t ihi e il me a doc e i
ç pplca
f
r he den sabls ng ntte nt nd um ntng
t a opr a e hour a houry r t . N o m an,836 F. at1
he ppr i t
s nd
l a es' r
'
2d
303. Tha bur n
t de
i l
ncudesSs yi t c twih s cii a de a ld e denc fom whi t
tuppl ng he our t pe fc nd t ie vi e r
ch he
c tc n de er i t r a ona e houry r t Furhe ,f couns ls d ha
our a t m ne he e s bl
l a e. t r ee
e houl ve
m a nt i d r c dst s
i a ne e or o how t tm e s nton t dif r tcl i s a t ge r l
he i pe
he f e en a m , nd he ne a

s be t te o tetmee e dt r so g t ob sto t t s fiin
u j c matr f h i xp n iu e u h t e e u wih u fce t
pa tc a iy s t tt diti c tc a s s t tme cai f e h aci t
riulrt o ha he srct our an s e s he i l med or ac tviy
. . . . A w e lpr
l- epa e f e pe ii a s w oul i l a s m a y,gr ng t
r d e tton l o
d nc ude um r oupi he

tmee ti byt naur oft aci t orsa oft ca e. 1 (iai
i nres he t e he tviy tge he s ' d. cttons
'
omitd)
te .
1 F. a 427.
68 3d t
AN A LY SIS A N D DISC USSIO N
1. R easonabl H ourl R at
e
y
e

I s e ng r m bur e e f isator y' f es Pl i ifr le on t a f da tofLa e
n e ki ei
s m nt or t t ne s e , a ntf e i s he f i vi
ur n
F. Loui , Es , s ppori t c a m e hour y r t of Pl i if s couns l A c or ng t t
s q. u
tng he l i d
l a es
a ntf '
e.
c di o he

a fda t M s Loui bil a t r t of$570 pe hour Dani Crs no,Es ,a sa fa t ne bil
fi vi, . s ls t he a e
r
;
el ipi
q. t f tor y, ls
a t r t of $320 perhour Cor Gr Es ,a a s it bil a a r t of $ pe hour
t he a e
; ey ay, q. n s oca e, ls t a e
480 r
;

Courney Roc t,Es ,a pa t ,bil a a r t of$900;a M i ha Cavi a pa a e la
t
ket q.
rner ls t a e
nd c el l n, r l ga nd

c s ma a e, il a ter t o $ 9 0 p rh u . ( 4 - 1 De e d n a g sta ra o a e
a e n g r b ls t h ae f 2 0.0 e o r DE 7 1. fn a t r ue h t e s n bl
r t sf Pli ifscouns lwoul be t f l ng:$350 pe hourf bot M s Roc t a M s
a e or a ntf'
e
d he olowi
r
or h . ke t nd .

Loui,$275pe hourf Mr Gr ( wa admitd t t FlrdaBa i 201 ,$ pe hour
s
r
or . ay who s
te o he o i
r n 5) 250 r
f Mr Crs no ( wasa te t t Fl i Ba i 201 ,a $1 f Mr Cal n (
or . ipi who
dmitd o he orda r n 6) nd 25 or . vi a
3

p r lg l. g 5 , 6 .
aae a) DE 2 p. j
The Co thasc i e t afi vi,t s ppori e de e,a t John on f t s
ur
onsder d he fda t he u
tng vi nc nd he
s acor .
Fis ,w ih r gar t M s Roc t,w ho i a a t ne i N ew Yor of i e of he l w fn',t
rt t e d o
. ke t
s n tor y n
k fc
r a i n he
El ve h Cicui Cour ofA ppe s has he d,a t Sout r D i t i tof Fl i has r c ni e
e nt r t
t
al
l nd he
he n sr c
orda
e og z d,
t ge r l i he û e eva m a ke 'f pur es of de e m i ng t r as na e ho l r t f
hat ne aly, û r l nt r t or pos
t
t r ni he e o bl ur y a e or
a z ator y' s vi s i the pl c wher t c e i f l d.' Bar s 1 F. a 43 s e
l t ne s er ce s t
ae
e he as s ie ''
ne , 68 3d t 7; e

Hemosla v Coc col Co.Cas No.1 21 8- V,2011W L 936
r il . a- a , e
0- 41 C1
4952a *7 ( D.Fl J y
t S. a. ul
1 2011 .l or rt rc non-oc lrts t f a ia mus s t tt r i al kof
5, ) n de o e over l a ae ,he ee pplc nt t how ha hee s ac
a t ne pr c i ng i t l lm a ke who a ewilng a abl t handl t c e. Bar s 1
tor ys a tci n he oca r t
r li nd e o
e he as
ne , 68
F. a 437. The Cour fnds t tt r a e pl nt ofa t r ys i So h Fl i t tcoul ha
3d t
ti
ha he e r e y
t o ne n ut orda ha
d ve
ha e t s c s a m or s ii aly,t di cove y pr ctc i t s c s Ba e upon on t
ndl d hi a e nd, e pec fc l he s
r a i e n hi a e. s d
he
Cour ' ow n know l dge a e r e e,t Cour c udes t t M s Roc t ' hour y r t of
ts
e
nd xpe i nc he
t oncl
ha
. ke t s
l ae

$900 i ve y hi c
s r gh, ompa e t t r nge ofr t s c r nty c r i t Sout r Diti tof
r d o he a
a e ure l ha ged n he
he n src
Fl i f sm ia s r c by lwye s of r s bl c pa a e s ls e renc a
orda or i l r e vies
a r
ea ona y om r bl kil, xpe i e nd

r put i n. See Bi i , a 1
e ato
vns t 350,n.2. l t a an houry r t of $ 00 f M s Roc t i
nse d,
l ae
400. or . ke t s
a r as bl and s t e a t r tve t t m os c os y a o m a es a r t f a c pe e
e ona e
uiabl le na i ha
t l el ppr xi t
a e or
om t nt
a r as bl prce l ad parne i t s m ar t w ho coul s es f l handl a r l tvel
nd e ona y i d e
t r n hi
ke
d ucc s uly
e ea i y

smpl m oto f s nc i . Se Naton M ot Cl b,I .v St brd Cas I .Co. N o.1
i e i n or a tons e i
or u nc . one ige
. ns
,
0-

811 CI 201 W L 6729648,*2( D.Fl Aug.2,201 (i ng$400. t bearas bl
57- V, 3
S. a.
3) fndi
00 o
e ona e
houry r t i r s ndi t a m oton f r pr t ctve or r f a pa t r w ih t e y- i ye r '
l a e n e po ng o
i o oe i
de or
r ne t w nt fve a s

e re e)
xpe inc .
The Cour no es t tt l k of a e r af i vi i s
t t ha he ac
n xpe t fda t n uppor of t c a m e r t i no
t he l i d a e s t
f t . A fe a l S he c t e t r t i or a la e,i is l a e r on t que ton a m a
a al
t r l, t
t our , ihe ral ppe l t s t e f n xpe t he
s i nd y
4

c i risown knowl e a expe i nc c
onsde t
edg nd
re e once i r as bl a pr
m ng e ona e nd operf esa ma f m
e nd y or

a id pe d n j d me tet rwih o wih u te ad o wi e s sa t v l . No ma ,8 6
n n e n etu g n i
he t r t o t h i f t se s o aue' r n 3
n
'
F.2d at1 (iai omitd) Ho r wihouta explnai a t why t rmani
303 cttons te . weve, t
ny
a ton s o
he e i ng
a t neys s d r ce ve s
tor
houl e i uch hi h r t a bas d on t Co ts ow n kno l dge a
g a es nd
e
he ur '
w e
nd

e renc t Cour fndst tM s Loui'houry r t s d be r duce t $375,M r Gr y'
xpe i e, he
t i ha . s
l a e houl
e d o
. a s
houry r t s d ber e t $275,M r Crs no' houry r t s d be r duc t $
l ae houl
educ d o
. ipi s
l a e houl
e ed o 250,a
nd

M r Cal n, houry r t shoul be r duced t $1 1
o 50.
vi s
l ae
d
e
.

2.

Num ber ofH ours R easonabl Expended
y

N e t C o tm us det nni w he he t ho s bil w e e r s bl I t t bl
xt he ur
t e ne
t r he ur led r ea ona e. n he a e
con ai d w ihi M s Loui 'afi vi,i s a e t tPl i if s c
t ne t n .
s fda t t t t s ha a ntf ouns s nt61 hour t a on t s
el pe
s ot l hi

matr ( 47- 1 TheCour frtnotst tPl ntf scouns di notat h a tmee re
te . DE 1 .
t is e ha ai if
el d
tac ny i ntis
t t a fda t s t Cou tmus r l on M s Loui 'na i e ast t ts compl t r aed
o he fi vi, o he
r
t ey
.
s nutv
o he a ks
eed elt
t t f lng a a gui of t m o i n f s nc i . The Sept be 27,2017 he r ng on t
o he ii nd r ng
he t o or a tons
em r
ai
he
m oton w a a oxi a e y 1 2 hour . W he t Cour c i r t l ng h of t he r ng i
i
s ppr m t l .
s
n he
t ons de s he e t
he a i n

c nu cin wi Ms Lo s n raie i a pe r t tMr Cavn bi e o y 7. ho r o ti
o j n to t . ui' artv , t p as ha . l i l d nl 5 u s n h s
h
l
matr( t9. hour ascl medi t tbl ,Mr Gr bild onl 1 2hour ont smatr(
te no 4
s ai n he a e) . ay le y 7.
s hi te not

1 2ascli d i t t e) a Ms Loui bil onl 20. hour ont smatr( 29. hour
8.
ame n he abl , nd . s led y 6 s hi te not 4
s
a dame i t t e .M r Crs no' 3. hour a Mr Roc ts0. hour lsedi t tbl
s i d n he abl) . ipi s 7
s nd . ket' 3
s it n he a e
a e ac ount d f i M s Loui 'na r tve.
r c
e or n .
s ra i
The Co thasc e uly r vi w e M s Loui 'expl na i oft hour bil d r l t d t t
ur
ar f l e e d .
s
a ton he
s le e a e o he
lThe Cour i not fndi t t t s r duce r t w oul ne s arl be t a i abl
ts
i ng ha he e e
d a es
d ce s iy
he pplc e
bil bl r t s i any m o i f a t y' f s w hi h m a be l t r f l by Pl ntf ' c
la e a e n
ton or tonw s ee
c
y
a e ied
ai i f s ouns l
e.
M o e r t Cour i not m a ng a ne tve com m e on t c pe enc of Pl ntf s
r ove , he
ts
ki ny ga i
nt
he om t y
ai i f

c e i t sc e.Quiet t c rr t underi d i veyf la wihLa e F. s
ouns l n hi as
t o he ontay,he
sgne s r amiir t urn Loui,
Es ,a know s he t be a hi hl s le e hi l a e r m e y com pe e c
q. nd
ro
g y kil d, t ca , nd xt e l
t nt ouns .
el
5

m oton f s nc i . Fis ,t Cour a e w ih D e e
i or a tons r t he
t gr es t
f ndants a gum e t tt a t ne s f e
' r
nt ha he tor y' e
a a d s d not i ude t 7. hour i ur e i ç na yzi D e e nts a w er pr or
w r houl
ncl
he 4
s nc r d n ç l ng
a
f nda ' ns , i

e de ,a atemptng t conf rwih de e e c
vi nce nd t i o
e t f ns ouns lbef e begi ng t undera t dr f
e
or
nni o
tke o a t
t M oto f Sa tons ' The Cour onl g a e s nc i f a t e s f es i ur e i
he
i n or nc i .
'
t y r nt d a tons or tom y' e nc r d n

pr pa i flng,a a g ng t m oton f s ncton a r pl t r t The Co tdoe not
e rng, ii
nd r ui he
i or a i nd e y he e o.
ur
s
c i rt 7. hour t f l w ihi t s
ons de he 4
s o a l t n he cope oft a t ne sf s a a d.
he tor y' ee w r
Se
cond,Pl ntf s m oton f r s nc i was a oxi a el 1 page i l t a di
ai i f
i o a tons
ppr m t y 2
s n eng h nd d
no c a n a c pl x a g e s I s d notha t ke over 22 colec i hour t dr f
t ont i ny om e r um nt . t houl
ve a n
l tve
s o at

a fnai e a l pa moton. The amountoftm e bil i be
nd i lz
z- ge
i
i
led s yond wha wa nec s r and
t s es a y
r a ona e Si lry,i s d nothavet n at alof1 5 hour t pr pa ef t he rng on
e s bl . mia l t houl
ake ot
5.
s o e r or he a i
t m oto f s nc i ns
he
i n or a t o .

Thid,t na r i i M s Loui a fda t doe s em t be co m e u ae wih bl k
r he ratve n .
s' fi vi
s e
o
m ns r t t oc
bilng. Thi i no pe s i ebe aus i pr ve st Cour fom de e ni whih pori of
li
s s t nnisbl c e t e nt he
tr
t nni ng
c
ton
t f e bil d on a pa tc a da e and ort s i r cove a e a whi h i not l i t Pl i if s
he e s le
r i ul r t
/ ak s e
r bl nd
e s . t s he a ntf

bur n t pr ry documen is hour ,a Pli if has pr de i ufi int s
de o ope l
tt
s nd antf
ovi d ns fce uppor f t
t or he
hour cl m e
s ai d.

Fourh,i a ar ba e on t lm ied i or a in be or t Cour t ts r at ne
t t ppe s s d
he i t nf m to f e he
t ha eve al tor ys
w e e w or ng on t s m e t s . Thi i not pe m it d. Se N aton M ot r Cl 201 W L
r
ki
he a
a ks
s s
r te
e
i
o
ub, 3

6729648 a *2 (çEl c at ne sc rbutonsmus beditnc,a no rdunda ,i or rt
t sg a h tor y' onti i
t
si t nd t e
nt n de o
mertcompe ai ' . Theewasno ne d f f at ne a aparl lt bei ve i a
i
nston.)
'
r
e or our tor ys nd
aega o nvol d n
r a i l s m pl m o i f s nc i ns
el tve y i e ton or a to .
3.

C al ul i ofA tor y' Fe A w ard
c at on
t ne s e

l o de t c c a e t a opra e f a a d t Cour tr tm us m uli y t r duc d
n r r o al ul t he ppr i t ee w r he
t is
t tpl he e e
6

r s bl r t of t a t e and pa a e
ea ona e a es
he tom ys
r l gal by t num be of hour t t a e a t l
he
r
s ha r c ualy

s ot l s 4 626
a ount f r i M s Loui 'na r tve. Thi t a i $1 , . The Cour w il a s s r ct3.
cc ed o n .
s ra i 2
t l l o ubta
7
hour bil d by M r Crs no a 3. ho s bil d by M s Loui be aus as e ai a
s le
. i pi nd 7 ur le
.
s c e, xpl ned bove, hi
t s

tm ef l ou sde oft s ope oft a tm e sf esa r
i als t i
he c
he to y' e wa d.Thene t a i $1 31 50.
w ot l s 2, 3.

Ne ,ûwl nadititc ti t numbe ofhour cli d i unras yhi t
xtkl he
src our fnds he
r
s ame s e onabl gh,he
c tha t o c ce ;i m a c
our s w hoi s t y onduc a hourbyt n
- hour a ys s or i m a r duce t r ques e
nal i
t y e
he e
td
hour w ih a a r s t boa d c . Bi i , 5 F. a 1
s t n c os -he- r ut' v ns 48 3d t 350. H e e,Pl ntf ha not m e is
'
r
ai if s
tt
bur n of e t bls ng e il m e t and doc e a i of al of t hour bil d, a
de
s a i hi
ntte nt o
um nt ton
1
he
s le
s
r quied. Taki i o a ount a l of t defc e e i t bilng e r e a t e es i
e r
ng nt cc
l
he i i nci s n he li nti s nd he xc s ve
na ur of tm e bil d, t Cour w il r duce t f a a d by 50% . The t al a t y' f s
t e
i
le he
t l e
he ee w r
ot tonw s ee

a r i t e or $6, 56.
wa d s her f e 1 75.
CO N CLU SI N
O

Ba e o t f egoi i i he e ORDERED t Def ndan RonniChowdr s l
s d n he or ng, t s r by
hat e
t
y hal

r i bure Pli iff r is at ne s f es i t a ountof$6, 56. Def ndanti or r d t
em s antf o t tor y' e n he m
1 75.
e
s de e o

ma
ke s h pa nt wihi t ry (
uc
yme
t n hit 30) da fom t dae
ys r
he t

t s (r r
hi lde.

2Thecac ai woul be$15 tm e 7 5 hour f M r Cavi $250 tmes3. hour f M r
lul ton
d
0i s
s or . l n,
i
7
s or .
Crs no,$275tm e 1 2 hour f M r Gr y,$375 tm es20. hour f M s Loui,a $400
ipi
i s 7.
s or . a
i
6
s or .
s nd
.

tm es0. f M s Roc t .
i
3 or . ke t
7

D O NE A N D O R DER ED i Cha be st s
n
m r hi Z&

a o Oco e, 2017,atW estPal
y f tb r
m

Be ch,Pal Bea h Count i t Sout n Di t i tofFl i .
a
m
c
y, n he
her s rc
or da
'

'

w .

$

W I A M M A TTH EW M N
LLI
UN I
TED STA TES M A G I
STM TE J D GE
U