Zurich American Insurance Company v. Amerisure Insurance Company et al

Filing 66

OPINION AND ORDER granting 43 Motion to Dismiss for Failure to State a Claim. Third Amended Complaint due by 1/27/2017. Signed by Judge Donald M. Middlebrooks on 1/19/2017. (yha)

Download PDF
I THE UNI N TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FOR THE SOUTHERN DI STRI OF FLORI CT DA Cas No.9: 6- 81 M I e 1 CV- 393- DDLEBRO OKS ZURI AM ERI CH CAN I NSUM NCE COM PANY, Pl ntf, ai if AM ERI SURE F NSURANCE COM PANY, AM ERI SURE M UTUAL W SUM NCE COM PANY,HARTFORD FI I RE NSURAN CE COM PANY, HARTFORD CASUALTY I NSUM NCE COM PAN Y a HARTFORD w nd UNDERW RI TERS m SURAN CE COM PANY, De e f ndant. s / O R DE R A ND O PI I N G R A NTI G DE FEN DA N TS A M ER I R E I SU M N C E N O N SU N COM PANY AND AM ERI SURE M UTUAL I NSUM NCE COM PANY' M OTI TO S ON DI I THE SECOND AM ENDED COM PLAI SM SS NT THI CAUSE c e be or t Co ton Defnda sAme iur I ur nce Compa a S om s f e he ur e nt rs e ns a ny nd Ameiur Mut ll urnceCo ny' (ogehe,SAmeiur ' M otont Dimist Sec rs e ua ns a mpa s t t r ' rs e' ) i o s s he ond Ame d d Co lit ($ o in' fld o De e e 8 2 6 ( 43 . Plitf Zu ih n e mpan $ to ', ie n c mb r , 01 . DE ) anif rc M ) Ameia I u a c Co a y (f rc ' fld aRe p n ei o po i o o De e e 21 2 1 rc n ns rn e mp n ' ih' ie zu ) s o s n p st n n c mb r , 0 6 i ( 51,t whih Ameiur rple on Dec mbe 28,201 ( 54) Fort ras saed DE ) o c rs e e id e r 6 DE . he e ons tt beow, heM oton i g a ed. l t i s r nt BAC K G RO UN D Thsd caao yj dg n a to c n en ads ueb t e i s r n ep o i eso e a i e lrt r u me t cin o c r s ip t ewe n n u a c r v d r v r n alge oblgai t defnd a i urd i a undel nglws t Sec Amende Compli le d i ton o e n ns e n n ryi a ui.( ond d ant ( 3 ,heri trdco ai 'o $ DE 9) enafe f mpl nt' r $ Compl,'a ! 15 .I i aguedt tDef nt' ale d .' t ) t s r ha enda s i lge f iur t co pl wih t i dut t def nd has ld Zurc t s de t fna i lbu d , al e o m y t her y o e e ih o houl r he i nc a r en t r i rng ator ey' f es c t , a e ns a entti i t r i bur e nt wih heeby ncuri t n s e , oss nd xpe es nd ilng t o em s me t itrs fo ten l e p n iei u e s (d. t! 3 , 6 6 , 4 . ne et r m h oz s o sv ns r r. 1 a ! 2 4 , 0 7 ) r Th u d ryi a to se fo a c n tu to prj c i Pam Be c Co ny, oi a e n el ng cin tms r m o sr ci n oe t n l a h u t Flrd k wna ' ir a teGad n '(h d rj c'o ç o e' (# a ! 1 ) Th g n r l o ta t r no s ' o e t h r e s't e t oe t r b r' f . t 7 . e e e a c nrco F p ' Fi ) f rt eprj c wa W P S u hBui es ( o i aS ,LLC (S P S u h'.(#. t! 1 ,1 ) Th o h oet s o t l r, Flrd ) d ' W o t' f a ! 7 9. e ) Compl i s ss butsudi l a dssa i t tW P Sout htl a i ur nc polc wih ant ugge t , t ousy voi t tng, ha h d n ns a e iy t M aya d Ca u ly Co a y (i aya Ca u l ' (d.a ! 6 1 ,3 ) a e tt f rwhih r ln s at mp n i r lnd s at ' i t ! , 7 2 , n n iy o M y) c Zu ih i s c e s ri itrs (d a ! 7 . To c mp ee t e p o e t W P S uh rtie i rc s u c so n n ee t i . t )2 o lt h rj c, o t ean d i a n mb r'o s bc nr co s (d a ! 1 ) tr e o whc ae r lva t t t s a to Co a u e ' f u o ta tr i . t 9 , h e f ih r ee n o hi cin: br Co sr cin l c (d b a', Co tu to o Flrd sl c (C Co sr cin',a d Gls n tu to , n . d r ' KD nsr cin f o i a n . S Co ) KD n tu to ' n a s ) Engne rng& l tlaton,l .(s as Engi rng')(ole tvey,t ts i ei nsal i nc d s neei ' c lci l he subcontacor' . (d. Gl r t s' 1 ) a !20 .I i a r e nswi t es b o ta t r, P S uh rq ie e c t t a eW P S u h t ) n t ge me t t h u c n rco s W o t e ur d a h o ç c s h pl ot o (t)o c mme ca g n rll bl y is r n ep lc te)a a Ad to a Is rd, whc n i wn o ril e ea i ii n u a c o iy is s n diin l n u e ' ih s a t ' t s onta t sdi (d.a !!25, .Two oft s onta t s KD Consr ci andGls he ubc r cor d. 1 t 27) he ubc r cor, tu ton as Engi rng, r is dpolce b Ameiur (d.a !26& Exs 5& 6) a i ur epr de neei wee s ue iis y rs e i t , , n ns anc ovi r (d.a ! 8 9 . Th Ameiu e p iis c n an d f dto a l u e e d re n s'(h i t ! -) e rs r ol e o tie i i n l ns r d n o s me t' t e c Ad i t ndore nt' whih gr e W P Sout t Addii l I ur saus r quie by t i s me s' e ) c antd h he tona ns ed tt e rd he : Defendant H a f d Fie l urance Com pany, Hartor Casualy l urance Com pany, and s rtor r ns f d t ns Ha tor Undewrtr I urnceCompa ( l tvey,ida tor ' ha ye t fl ar pons rf d r ies ns a ny coleci l s rf d' ve t o ie es e l ) t teS c ndAme d dCo an a dh v n t on dt ei sa tM o in o h eo n e mplit n a e o j ie h n tn to . 2As di cus e f t r bel ,Zurc hi s i is Re pons br e a t c e t of is prm a y s s d urhe ow i h nt n t s e i f t he ont n s t i r p iy. I patc ar i rfr esce t n t msconti d i S olc n riul , t eeenc rai er ane n s compei polcytes' a 'he tng i i l' nd : t Ge a Conta or s ow n polc '- pr s a y bet e n W P Sout a M a yl nd Ca ua t ner l r ct ' i y' e um bl w e h nd r a s ly whih Zurc cone wilneg t t f c ofAmers e' polces ( 51a 9) c ih tnds l ae he ore iur s ii . DE t . 2 s b o ta t ra x e ns(d. t 27 a d i o e ad t o Ame iu et d f n t a dio a u c nrco ge me t i a ! ) n mp s d uy n rs r o ee d he d t n l i i urd i lws t c r b t polc t ms (# a ! 3 ) Th s e d re nt ae ns e n a uis oveed y he iy er / t 0 . e e n o s me s r . c ompone s of polces t t Zurc i nt i i ha ih ncom o aed by r er nc i o t Compl nt i t r rt ef e e nt he ai n hei i niey. (d. t!2 . Th yi ld l te i s r n e' lus s whi r ad: i trt ' 1 a J 7) e ncu e s h r n u a c 'ca e , ch e e ' o Any c r pr vi d i t sendor e nti e es ove a ot rvald ove age o de n hi s me s xc s r ny he i a c lc i e i u a a ia e t t addii l i ur whe he prma y, nd ole tbl ns r nce val bl o he tona ns ed t r i r exc s c i nt o on a ot rbassunls t wrte c r t agr ent or es , ontnge , r ny he i e s he itn ontac , eem , ce tfc e ofi ur e r quie t tt si u anc be prm a y, i whih c e t s rii at ns anc e r s ha hi ns r e i r n c as hi i ur nce wil be prma y wiho c rbuto fo s ns a l i r t ut onti i n r m uch ot i ur nc her ns a e a ia e t t a tonali ur d. va lbl o he ddii ns e (d.Ex. a 2& Ex.6at2) l 5t . I 2009, t Fi e a t Ga de Condom i u As ociton, I (he S ndo n he or t he r ns ni m s ai nc, t d co a s cain' fldalws i (h i n el n s i )algn d fcsi t ep oe tsc nsr cin so ito ' ie a ut te ' d ryig uf' l ig e e t n h rj c ' o tu to ) u e . (d.a !21& Ex.1 . Theco a s ai ss c andt r ame edcompli sname W P 1 t )3 ndo sociton' e ond hid nd ant d Sout a a deenda . (#.a ! 21 a Exs 2- . Afe i r eve t lws t W P So h h s f nt f t nd . 3) tr t ec i d he a ui, ut ç e r d t c amst t Def nt a de ' nde e he l i o he enda s nd mande a de e e a wel a i m ni a i unde t d f ns s l s nde Gc ton r t tr a d c n iin o t ep lc te l' (d a !28 . Ho ve,De e d nsd ne t t h he ems n o dto f h o iy is. 1 . t ) we r fn a t e id ha t e ' p l isi o e s c o lg to s (d.a ! 2 ) Asa r s l,W P S uh d fn e t e cams oi e mp s d u h b iain . 1 t 9 . c e ut o t ee d d h li a i ti on is own a a s a s re t r pary cai s a i tt s ontacor . (#.a ! ga ns t t nd lo s e td hid- t l m ga ns he ubc r t s / t 22)4 . At s ome undicl ed poi ,W P Sout a M a ylnd Ca ualy e cu e a ot r s s os nt h nd r a s t xe t d n he wi e c i talisete ntAgr me a Reea e. (d.a ! 1 . The stlme conansa onfdeni s tlme ee nt nd l s ' 1 t 6) ' ete nt ti n a sg ntofrg s(l sg nt' fom W P So ht Mar a Ca ualy (d.,whih pur t s imne iht ' inme ' r as ) ut o ylnd s t i 4 c pors 3A c pli i t u ryi s twasfld i t Fi nt J c a Cic ti a f Pam om a nt n he nde l ng ui ie n he hee h udii l r ui n nd or l Be c Coun y,Fl i a i syld Fi e att Gar n Condo.As oc,l v Fi e att ah t orda nd s t e or he de s s . nc. . or he Gar ns LLC,e a1,Cas No.502009CA 001 XXXXM B- ( de , t . e 047 AE. ComplEx.1a 1. . t) 4 A c or ng t Zurc t condo a s a i s c pl i a l ged da a s t t r ule f om c di o i h, he s oci ton' om a nt le m ge ha es t d r wor ati a et t s onta tr .( k trbutbl o he ubc rco s Compla !23) .t . 3 t g a t lte t powe t sa i t f o r nt he at r he r o t nd n he onne ' s sa e or any ofW P Sout srg s rs hoe nd nf ce h' i ht a i ti urr ofiss ontacor ont bassoft Addii lI ur polc prvii (d gans ns es t ubc r t s he i he tona ns ed iy o sons i . a ! 1 ) I i u ce rfo t e fc o t Co litwh t e i wa tr u h te stlme t t 7 . t s n la r m h a e f he mp an eh r t s h o g h ete n ag e r emen or s t ome ot r i tu e t t M a ylnd Ca uat c he nsr m nt ha ra s ly ompe aed W P Sout f t ns t h or he a t ne sf esa c t t tt l te e nd de e ng is fa ns t unde l ng s t tor y' e nd oss ha he at r xpe ed f ndi tel gai t he ryi ui. Zurc asM ar a Cas t ss c s i i er s ,fld a amende compli on J y ih, ylnd ualy' uc es or n nt e t ie n d ant ul 26,201 i Fl i sa e c ti o de t pur ue t a sgne rght . ( 12)5 On Augus 8 6 n orda tt our n r r o s he s i d i s DE - . t, 201 Ame iu e r mo e te c s t t i Cou t algn f d r ls be tmatrj rs ci n 6, rs r e v d h a e o h s r, l i g e e a u j c te u idito e bas d on t Pa tes co plt di r iy of cii ns p a a a ount i contovery ove e he ri ' m e e ve st tze hi nd n m n r s r $75000. ( 1 . Zurc fl aSe ond Ame d Compli on Dec mbe 5,2016,whih , 00. DE ) ih ied c nde ant e r c wa mae ilyi e tc l o i Fis Ame e Co an b tfrt j i d ro a oh rAmeiu e s tral d nia t t rt nd d mplit u o he o n e f n te s rs r e iy a aDeenda . ( 39) TheCompli lsst eec sc rs ntt s f nt DE . ant it hr ount ore pondi t t polces ng o he ii f e c oft t e s or a h he hre ubcontacor -t ls t ofwhi aea i tAmeiur ( mpl a !! r t s he at wo ch r gans rs e. Co . t 47- & 6174) The onl r dy Zurc s ksi decaaor r le underFl Stt j86. 1 60 - . y eme ih ee s lr t y eif a. a. 01 Ciu idcin o tilc uf' (d a ! 3 48 6 ) S e iial,i r q e t t tte Co r l rs ito f ra o l l 1 . t ! 4, , 2 . p cfc ly t e u ss ha h u t . d e m i t t t s onta t r 'polc e r quie Ame iur t def nd W P So h i t etr ne ha he ubc r c o s ii s e r d rs e o e ut n he u e lig s i (# a ! 6 .. d. e,f,g, 7 c,d,e,f,g) t a Zu ih i e tte t b nd ryn ut /. t ! 0c, , . . , 4.. . . . .; h t rc s nild o e r mbur e by Ame iur f t at e s f es and c t pa d t W P Sout f is def e ei sd rs e or he tom y' e oss i o h or t ens a ans t u d ryigs i a df rtos e p n e i tep e e t a e(d a ! 6 ,.i, 4. ,.; g i the n el n ut n o h e x e d d n h rs n c s i . t ! 0h, .7 h.i) a ta Zu ih ma a s rc v rp e a d p t u g n itr s (d.a ! 6 j,k,7 j,k. nd h t rc y lo e o e r- n os- d me t nee t i t ! 0. . 4. ) j . , . 5Zu ih' s ae c tac i was fl d i t Fit nt J ci Cic t i a f Pal Be ch rc s t t our ton ie n he fee h udi al r ui n nd or m a C o y,Fl i a i s yl d Zur c Am .I . Co. v Amersu e l . Co. etal, Ca e N o.50unt orda nd s t e ih ns . i r ns , . s 201 CA- 706- 0081 XXXX- B.( 12a 2) M DE - t . 4 Amers emove f rdim is ofZurc scli sa i ti pur ua t Fed. iur s o s s al ih' am ga ns t s nt o R.Ci P.l b)6) v. 2( ( . ( 43a 1. DE t ) LEG AL STAN DARD W. 1 () 6 M ol n Ge r l 2 b () to s ne al y A moin t ds s u d rRu e 1 b ()c aln e t lg ls fiin y o ac mpli t t o imis n e l 2()6 h l g s he e a u fce c f o an o e . Se Fe R. v. 1 ( )6 . l a s s igt lg ls ice c o a c mp an ' alg to s t e d. Ci P. 2 b ( ) n se sn he e a uf in y f o l its le ai n , he Cou ti b r s ound t a y t pl a ng sanda d a tcult d i Bel Atantc Cor v Two ys 55 o ppl he e di t r ri a e n l l i p . mbl 0 . U. 5 4( 0 7 a dAs c o v I b l 5 6U. 6 2 6 ( 0 ) Th ti, t com pli çm us S. 4 2 0 ) n h rh . q a , 5 S. 6 , 78 20 9 . a s he a nt i t . . . c ai s fcintf t mat r a ce e astue, t ttt a c am t r i t ti plusbl on ont n ufi e acual te , c pt d r o sa e l i o elef ha s a i e is f c '' Am .D e alAs ' v. Ci Cor ,605 F. 1 t a e.' nt sn gna p. 3d 283,1 ( 1h Ci.20l ( i 289 1 t r 0) quotng Twomby,550U. a 570 .SDimis i t r or per te whenont ba i ofadipostve l S. t ) d s sal s heef e mitd he ss s ii i s oflw,no c tuci oft f t lal ga i wils s ue a onsr ton he acua le tons l uppor t ca e ofac i .' Gl er t he us ton ' ov Li tGr ,I ,459 F. 1 gget p. nc. 3d 304,1 ( lh Ci.20 (ntr quottonsomit (ii 308 1 t r 06) i enal ai ted) ctng Ma s a l Bd o c v Ma s alC@. sDit, 9 F, d 1 71 1 7 ( 1hCi,1 9 ) r h l C@. fEdu . . r h l Ga s.9 2 2 1 , 1 4 1 t r 9 3) . W he r e ng a m o i t dim is a c tmus co tue pl i ifs c pl nti t n eviwi ton o s s , our t nsr antf om ai n he lght mos f vor bl t pli tf a tke t f t al ga i sa e t r i as tue. See i t a a e o a n if nd a he acual le tons tt d he en r Erik on v Pa du ,5 U. 8 93- 4 ( c s . r s 51 S. 9, 9 2007) Chrso r v.Har r 536 U. 403,406 ; itphe buy, S. ( 0 2 ; o k v BleCr s & BleS il o a,I c,11 F,d 1 4,1 6 ( 1h Ci.1 9 ) 2 0 ) Br o s , u o s u hed fFl. n . 6 3 36 3 9 1 t r 9 7 . Howeve ,pla ngs t f e no m o e t n c usons ar no e il t t as umpton of r e di hat t ar r ha oncl i , e t ntted o he s i tut W hie l l c l i ca pr dt t f a e k of a c pl nt t y mus be r h. l ega onc usons n ovi he r m wor om ai , he t s uppored by f c ua a l gatons' I , 556 U . . a 678;s e al o Si t ai v. Coc col t a t l le i . qbal ' S t e s nalr nal a- a Co. 578 F.d 1 2,1 ( 1h Ci.2009)(ttngt ta unwar nedde ton offc i not , 3 25 260 1 t r sai ha n ra t duci at s c i r tuef pumos ofdee ni whehe acl m i l lys fcint. onsdeed r or e tnni ng t r ai s egal ufi e ) 5 Ge al apli ifi notr uie t det lal t f c supon whi h he bas hi cl i . ner ly, a ntf s eq r d o ai l he a t c es s a m Fe R,Ci P,8()2) Rahe , e8()2)rquiesas tandpl nsae ntoft cam t t d. v. a( . t r Rul a( e r hor ai ttme he li ha f il notfe t de e ntofbot t c am a t s ary ii s he f nda h he l i nd he uppori gr tng ounds Twom bl 550 U , at . y, S. 555 5 Howeve,t e 8a)2)silrquie a çho ng,'r t rt n a bl nketass rton, of - 6. r i Rul ( ( tl e r s s wi a he ha a ei e ilme t r le ,'1 . a 556 n.3. Pl ntf' i i ton t pr vi t 'r ntte nt o ei f' d t ai ifs s ga i o o de he g ounds of hi obl ' s ' ntte e t r le r quie mor t n l be sa c usons and a f mul cr ct ton oft e ilm nt o ei f e r s e ha a l nd oncl i , or ai e ia i he elm e t ofa c us ofa i wilnotdo.' I a 555 ( tton omitd) S t al tons e ns a e cton l 'd t ciai te . l ual l i Fac ega mu t ee o g t rie( ant ps rg tt rle a o tes c ai elv lon t ass i s b n u h o as pli i ) ih o eif b ve h pe ultv e e, he umpton f t tal oft a lga i i t c ha l he le tons n he ompli a etue' 1 ant r r . ' d. B. Decar or Judgm e Ac i l at y nt tons As a t es d ma tr Zurch a guest tAme iur ha r s d m t isba e ar m e s hr hol te , i r ha rs e s aie rt- s d gu nt ta aei a pop it onamo in t ds s ad ca ao yj d me ta o Howe e ,Z ih' h t r n p r rae to o imis e lr tr u g n din. v r urc s p e s mic nsr st en t r o de lrtr j d me t. Frt Zu ih rfr t t eo e ai n rmie s o tue h au e f ca ao y u g n s is, rc ee s o h p rto of a sa r of r ew f ,Fl i s Deca aor J dgm e Ac . Se Fl Stt jj 86. 1 , nd tnda d evi or orda' lr t y u nt t e a. a . 01 , 86. . But Fl i 1 i not c r lng her l i a f m e a r e t t when f de a 021 orda aw s ontoli e. t s unda nt l ul ha e rl j rs ito a ie t r u ht ep ris dvest o ctz ns i s b tn ieis e aeg vene b u idcin rs s h o g h a t ' i riy f i e hp, u sa tv su s r o r d y e i sae lw a pr ed a is s by f r ll w, Br wn v Ni hol,8 F.d 770, 773 ( 1h Ci. t t a nd oc ur l s ue edt a a o . c s 3 1t r 1 ;s gene al Hannav.Pl r 380U. 460 ( 965) TheEl nt Cicui hashed t t 993) ee r l y ume , S. 1 . eve h r t l ha t Fl i De a a or J he orda clr t y udgmtn Ac i snotconf ra s tntve rgh s'bu i i t a û t t' doe e ny ubsa i i t , ' t s nse d $ a p o e u a me h n s ta c nfr s be tmatrj rs i o o Flrd ' cr uta d c u t r c d r l c a im h t o es u j c t u iddin n oi as ic i n o ny e c s' Cocc ov GecoGe l .Co.648F.App' 876,881( 1h Ci.201 ( tngM anue ount. ' ar . i n. ns , x 1 t r 6) cii l v Conv rys Cor ,430 F.d 11 11 n. ( 1h Ci.2005)( di t tdititc tmus . eg p. 3 32, 38, 3 1 t r hol ng ha src our t a l fdea De lrtr J dg n Ac, ahe t a saed ca ao yj d me ta wh n stig ppy e rl caao y u me t t rt r h n tt e lrtr u g n d, e i n t 6 i d v ri a to l. Bengp o e u a,h F o iasaued e n ta pl i t sdv ri c s n i est cin ) i r c d rl te l rd ttt o s o p y n hi ie st a e y y . I ta lmus act ti t s ofrviw unde t fdea De aaor J nse d, t s ran he cope e e r he e rl clrt y udgme Ac ( A) nt t DJ . Se 28U. C.j2201. e S. Se ond,and c r y t Zu i h' t r , purui one' rg s by s e ng a deca aor c ontar o rc s heo y s ng s i ht e ki lr t y j d me td sn tpemi ap ry t a od s rtn u d rRul 1 ( )6 , ast whet ri i has u g n oe o r t a t o v i cuiy, n e e 2 b ( ) o he t s s e suly sa e a c am f r i . l i t u t t a moton t dim is ma c l ge t ucc s f l t t d l i or elef t s r e ha i o s s y halen he s f in y o a d ca ao y j d me ta to t te e tn te c mpan fis t p e e ta u sce c f e lr tr u g n cin o h x e t h o lit al o rs n n i c ua c tove s 'ha m ir sAri l Ilsd s - - ntove s ' equie e . W al n v C/ . k t l on r r y't t ror tce 1' t e orco r r y'r r m nt a ca de . r ForDiea e Contol& Pr ve i 66 F.d 1 , 1 ( 1h Ci. 2)6 Bu t sgr s s r e nton, 9 3 277 284 1 t r 201 . t hi ound f r o dim is i c uren wih,nota s tt e f , t oblga in t sa e acli upon whi r le s s al s onc r t t ubsiut or he i to o tt am ch e if ma begr nt d. Tha i be a et DJ ( r t a r m e notaca e ofaci .' Buc v Am. y a e t s c us he A ç eaes e dy, c us ton ' k . Ailne,I . 476 F. 29,33,n. ( s Ci.2007) As s h,a pli ifmus pr e vai ri s nc, 3d 3 1t r . uc antf t esnt ld Ss tntve c am s'i o d t s t i t ' eque t f de l a o y r i i r lton t t e 'ubsa i l i ' n r er o usan he f r s or car t r elef n ea i o hos c am s' fon v.Wels Far Bank N A. li . ' g l go , , F.App' x , 201 W L 6803706,a * ( 0t Ci. 6 t2 1h r 201 (ii Fe owizv Pe c 641F.App' 773,776,n. ( 0t Ci.201 ;Adamsv Fe 6) ctng dr c . ar e, x 2 1 h r 6) . dEx Gr ound Pack ge S . I ,546 F.App' 772,776- ( 0t Ci.201 ) And snce a Rul a ys, nc. x 77 1 h r 3). i e 1 b)6)moi atc t s fcenc ofapli ipss tntvecli ,i i i e s nc as an 2( ( ton ta ks he ufii y antf ubsa i ams t s n s e e lo a s ul on t r m e t t t s ca ms s sa t he e dy ha he e li uppor. Thus i of r as Am e iur con e t t t , ns a rs e t nds ha Zurc s puttve rg s as c r nty pl d,a e ba r d a a m at r ofl w , t s çme is ba e ' i h' ai i ht , ure l e r re s te a he e s rt- s d' a g nt ar e iel a oprae a t ssa r ume s e ntr y ppr it t hi t ge. 5zurch a a s t i i ppe r o nvoke a a l n na ogous sa r under Fl i l . Se Ok oo a I l tnda d orda aw e al s sand Le e de sAs ',I .v Okal a Il Aut ,308 So,2d 1 1 ( a.DCA 1 t1 as hol r sn nc . oos sand h. 20, 22 Fl s 975) ( e ci igt es o n n c say t s r ieamoin t d s s ad ca ao yj d me ta to d srbn h h wi g e e s r o u vv to o imis e lrtr u g n ci n unde t Fl i DJ . r he orda A) DI SCUSSI N O Am e iur a gues t tt Compl nte tbls s on is f c t tAm e iu e c tt e rs e r ha he ai sa ihe t a e ha rs r onsiut d onl a e s i ur . Ther f e,unde Fl i i ur nc l w , Zurch coul not cl i t t y n xce s ns er e or r orda ns a e a i d a m ha Amers e owed W P Sout a du y t defnd wihoutalo al ng t tW P Sout e use is iur h t o e t s legi ha h xha t d t prm m. co r ge wih Zurc - r aly,is pr c s r M a ylnd Cas t . l t at r tve i y ve a t ih e l t ede es o , r a ualy n he lc nai , Ame iur m ant i t tt t e e Zu ih s ks c rbu i n o e t bl s oga i a tr rs e i ans ha o he xt nt rc ee onti to r quia e ubr ton fe t f c f r de e e c t , t t ki of r co r i pr bie Zurch fr t r s he a t o f ns oss ha nd e ve y s ohi t d. i is e ponds t t ha Am e iur ha m e ey r s d afima i def est i ne nota i pa e a o c rs e s r l aie fr tve ens hat t ed ntci t nd ver ome i is n t own pladi e ng. Se ond, i ct s t e e i t t ge r r l on e e s i ur nc a c t ie o xc ptons o he ne al ues xc s ns a e nd c rbuton,rs ci y:() whe t opposng i urr mut ly pur tt is e e s onti i e pe tvel a n he i ns e s ual por o sue xc s polcis a ( wheeonei urd e iyha a e d by c r tt i i e ; nd b) r ns e ntt s gre ontac o ndemniy a he . Thid, f not r r Zu i h s rc ubmis t t e i t s onta t s Addii t ha , ven f he ubc r c or ' tonalI ur d polcis we e oft e es ns e ie r he xc s va i t t e ba i f la lt a nc i t underyi s tsilb ough t a ton wihi t rey, h ss or ibiiy dva ed n he l ng ui tl r t he c i t n he s opeoft polcis'c a a t r byti r Am e iur sdut t def nd. c he i e over ge nd he e rgge ed rs e' y o e Ameiu eso j cin t t e Compan ' alg to sh vemei. W i rs e tt t e rs r ' b e to s o h lits l ain a e rt t e p c o h h dut t de e t El nt Cic ti e r t Fl i lw s h t twhen a i ur nc polc y o f nd, he eve h r ui ntp e s orda a uc ha n ns a e i y dei sisc r ge a s conda y orS xce s't aprma y polc t e s i ur rhasno d y fne t ove a s e r i s' o e i r i y, he xce s ns e ut t d e t i ur d - s l a t prma y polc pr desf ra d e e a iscove a has o ef nd he ns e o ong s he i r iy ovi o ef ns nd t r ge n tb e e a se Na ' Uno Fie Is Co f Pis u gh v T a ee s l s Co,21 F.d o e n xh u td. t1 in r n . .o t b r . r v lr n . . 4 3 t 1 1 73( 1h Ci. 269, 272- 1 t r 2000)(xce si ur rs' yt dee wasc e tvet rt t n e s ns e' s o fnd dut ons cui o, aher ha c ure wih,a ot runde l ng i urrsdut t defnd' s e alo U S.FieI .Co onc rnt t ny he ryi ns e ' y o e ); e s r ns . Fr e o Vl.O n ( y C/.f/. 2 9 F. px 8 9 8 ( 1h Ci.2 0 )(eyng o Na 1 e d m il fsu 71 r, #, 7 Ap ' 7 , 81 1 t r 0 8 rli n t Uni r ef Fl i ca e ;Cok rv Am.Gu .( Li lt l .Co.825F. 1 7,1 4 ( 1h on ul or orda s ) e . ar Q abii ns , y 3d 28 29 1 t 8 Ci. 01 )(o sr ig Ge r i lw i i nia mame ) Th c u t e s n dta t i r s l wa r 2 6 c n tun o ga a n de tc l r r. e o r ra o e h t hs e ut s compele by Fl i a pr ce ntwhi h mea ur d t pa te 'i e 's e yby t lngua oft ld ord e de c s e he ris ntnt ioll he a ge he polc e unl s t lngua i nmbi uo .' Nat1Uni 21 F. at1 ii s e s he a ge s g us ' ' on, 4 3d 272 (uoi Towne q tng Re l I c v Sae oI s Co o q , 5 F2 1 6 ,1 6 ( 1hCi.1 88) a t n . . f c n . . fzm.8 4 .d 2 4 2 7 1 t r 9 ) y . l t sca e,Zurc expr s l i m or t t S ntr t 'oft Am e iur polcisis d n hi s ih e sy nco aes he 6 iey' he e rs e i e s ue t KD Consr ton a Gls Engi rng ( mpl a ! 27) t Addii l I ur o tuci nd a s neei Co . t he tona ns ed , e sme sf whi aeatc t t Co ai a exhi t (d.a Exs 5 6 . Zurc doe ndore nt or ch r ta hed o he mpl nt s bis i t -) ih s . no diput t tt endor e nt una bi t s e ha he s me s m guousy de i t Ame iur scove age ofW P Sout l sgna e rs e' r h asS xc s'u e sa ot rpolc hed by W P Sout r quied t Addii lI ur d c r e f es ' nls ny he e iy l h e r he tona ns e ove ag t beprmay(hed xprs exc pton'.(d.a Ex.5a 2& Ex.6a 2) s ealoGov'Emp I o i r t t es e i ' 1 t e ) t t ;e s t ns. . Co.v Lal ,327 F. 568,572( t Ci.1 (ntmrtng f ny ot ri ur e'lng . l y 2d 4h r 964) i e ei i a he ns anc ' a uagei n e s mt t mea 'ns a e s pa ae a ditnc fom t polc of whih t ndor t nt o n s ur nc e r t nd si t r i he i y c he . e s ntf msac tt tpa t'.Furhe ,heCompl ntdoesno a rt tW P Sout had ndoreme or onsiuen r' ) t rt ai t ve ha h no prmar polc ,7 nor does i ale t W P So h' polc wih M ar and Cas t ora i y iy t lge hat ut s iy t yl ualy ny ot i ur r aci td t e e s e p i , or t t s h a polc s c a had bee her ns e tvae he xpr s xce ton ha uc iy' over ge n e used. On isf e t t Compl ntsde a f a r i onAm e iur sd y t def nd xha t t ac , hen, he ai ' m nd or ulng rs e' ut o e woul appe rt bef e l e byNat Uni Nat Uni 21 F.3d at 1272d a o or c os d 1 on. 1 ons 4 73. Ame iur alo c r ty sa e t 1w on c rbuto be we n i ur nce c ri s rs e s orec l t t s he a onti i n t e ns a a rer . Fl i cou t ha consse l hed t t onc t dut t de end i a tva e , e ey s be t orda rs ve itnty l ha , e he y o f s c i t d v r u jc 1By r m ani sl nt i t Com pli t on t orgna r l to hi be we n W P Sout a e i ng ie n he an he i i l e ai ns p t e h nd M a ylnd Cas t Zurc ke ps o t t or tca pos i lt t tAmers e wa t onl r a ualy, i h e pen he he e i l sbiiy ha iur s he y i ur t is e a polc c i W P Sout whih woul negae t e es i ur r r l . ns er o s u iy overng h, c d t he xc s ns e ue Howeve ,f c ua alega i mus not be mer y t sbl ' but a s t ausbl .' Re ni v r a t l l tons t el t i e' pos lo i pl i e ' s ck . AvMe l . 693 F.d 1 7,1 ( 1h Ci.201 . 1do notfnd i plusbl t an i urr d ncs 3 31 326 1 t r 2) i t a i e hat ns e woul s bsdiet c tofacompa sdee e( d u i z he os ny' fns Compl a ! 3 a nego it t a quiii . t 2) nd tae he c ston o ta c mpa y' rg t (d a ! 1 )u ls teewa a u d ryn ta fro rs fo te f h t o n s ihs i. t 7 nes h r s n n elig rnse f ik rm h com pany t t l er o he nsur . 9 i ur ra s m e i on a pe s ns e s u s t r onala i vii e bass Pe Lumbe me ' M ut l .Co.v I nd ndi s bl i . nn. r ns ns . nd . Lumbe me M ut l .Co., 43 So.3 1 1 1 ( a.4t DCA 201 ;Cont Cas Co.v r ns . ns d 82, 86- 88 Fl h 0) 1 . . Unie Pac l s.Co. 6 So.2d 270, 271275 ( a.5h DCA 1 ; gonautI .Co.v Md td .n , 37 - Fl t 994) Ar ns . Ca .Co. 37 So.2d 960,963- ( a.3r DCA 1 . Thatme nst twhen a i ued s , 2 64 Fl d 979) a ha n ns r t nde s a cai t muli e i ur nc pr de s t e iy t tacual e ge i t defns e r lm o tpl ns a e ovi r , he ntt ha t ly nga s n he e e a i ur t f es a c t a s i t wih i c m ot s e n l s e c rbuton or nd nc s he e nd os s s oc aed t t al ubs que ty e k onti i e utbes b o ainfo tef l w is rrwh ûa gld b hnd' Con 1Ca ., 6?7 So.2d at q ia l u r g to r m h el n u e o l g e l e i . o l ' t s 8 a i l or hi ti s oot d n i i f ns er d u c he 273. The r tona e f t sdoc rne i r e i publc polcy:i i ur scoul s e ea h ot r f r i r e e , he S ul ha no i en i t s tl a pr e tt i e e toft i ur , or embu s m nt t y s d ve nc tve o e te nd ot c he nt r s he ns ed wo snc ano he l w s t woul be f t omi t r ol t c ag diput be wee t i e t r a ui d orhc ng o es ve he over e s e t n he i ur nc com pa e . Ar ns a e ni s ' gonau ,?72 So. 2d a 964. He e,Zurc uli t y bor t cos of ' t t r ih tma el e he t W P Sout s de e e. l di s bt us of is pr de es ori i e e ts i pe nto i ton. h' f ns t d o ca e t e c s n nt r s ' nde nde blgai Re r e sofwhe he Am e iur wa alo bound a t tm et def nd W P So h, Zur ch car ot ga dl s t r rs e s s t he i o e ut i m ke he ut now s e t di u t c t d i fom ispr c s ' unia e albur n.g Li t d y e k o vvy p he oss erved r t edt es ors lt r de 8An e s i ur r who de e xce s ns e f nded is i u e wihoutis du y beng ti r d may, howe , t ns r d t t t i rgge e ver obt i e t bl s ogai fom a no e po i prmar i ur r Phoe x I . Co. v Fl an quia e ubr ton r nr s nsve i y ns e . ni ns . a. Fa m Bu e uMu, n . .5 S . d 1 4 ,1 5 ( a 2 dDCA 1 9 ) r r a tI s Co, 58 o 2 0 8 0 0 Fl. n 9 0. 9Ia notpe s de by Zurch' at mptt ditng s t Ar nautlne ofca e . Zurch c t s m rua d i s te o si uih he go i ss i ie s r l opi ons f t unc r r i l pr posto t t c r c ua rg s a e ge r l eve a ni or he ontove sa o ii n ha onta t l i ht r ne aly a sg bl l a s r f st aFl i de son i whi h a i ur d t te ora sgne isrght t s ina e. t lo e er o orda cii n c n ns e orf as s i d t i s o a ij rd plitf,wh t e c u tp nni e t e o c a s tlme ta an tt e s l i u e n nu e an if o h o r e t d o nfr e ete n g is h oe ns rr t r f i t co rbut t t s tl ntf e usng o nti e o he eteme und. Fl .I .Guar As ' v Gi dano,485 So.2d 453 a ns . s n , or ( a 3r DCA 1 6) Fr t s s res Zu ih co udest tt a ic rbutonprncpl Fl. d 98 . om he e ouc , rc ncl ha he nt-onti i i i e d sn ta pl t a sg e s Th ti n ttec s . Gir an iv le arc vey b a ij rd oe o p y o s in e . a s o h a e o d o n ov d e o r y n n u e t r pa t no a i ur e pr de . Gi dano, 485 So.2d a 455. M or i pora l hid ry, t n ns anc ovi r or t e m tnty, Pe ylani Lumbe me ' s cik a l a es edt vibiiy ofa aci pr s d on s h an nns v a r n s pe f ly ddr s he a lt n ton emie uc a s g e , fndi i S ontar t c e l a publc polc 'bec us i a t m pt t el va e s i nm nt i ng t û r y o as aw nd c i i y' a e t te s o e t f m over s t nce Pe Lumbe m e ', 43 So.3d a 1 or ubs a . nn. r ns t 88. The a iconti ton r l w as nt- r bu i u e desg t de i e i ze i urr fom s r ng t i oblga i t t i i ur ds 1 Tha i ned o -nc ntvi ns e s r hiki her i tons o her ns e . d. t pur e woul be fusr t d i ca r c d r ope t door t ltga i t ough t l l pos d r ta e f nie s oul e n he o ii ton hr he ega sci ofo ani t i i ur ds rgh s 1 Zurc sco e i t tt r ul i Pe yl ani ton bt i ng he r ns e ' i t . d. ih' nt nton ha he es t n nns v a 10 t d fndq e to ,tep rin o teCo an s e i g aj d me to Zu ih' e tte n t o ee u sin h o t f h mplit e k n u g n n rc s n i me t o o l ri embur e e f at ne ' f esa cossi doc rnaly ba r d. l Ac or ngl , unl sZurc s m nt or tor y s e nd t s ti l r e o c di y es ih ca i ntf a a i a e e e i t t exc s i ur r or a ic rbuton docrnes t n de iy n pplc bl xc pton o he es ns e nt- onti i ti , he ope a i Compli doe notsa ea c us ofa i f rwhi h r le ca begr nt d. r tve ant s tt a e cton o c ei f n a e Zurc s fr t c t r t Am e iur s lne of at ck i plc t s t r es r a i t i h' is oun e o rs e' i ta m i a e he ul eltng o i o o ai by r e e nc m r ton ef r nce. Zurch pr i opoundst tby dic sng t tr soft polci i s d ha s us i he e m he i es s ue t t s onta t s Ame iur a kst Cour t d nsde doc e sou sdet f urcor r ' o he ubc r c or , rs e s he t o t i r um nt t i he o co ne s' oft Complit ( 51 a 8) I is viw,Ameiur ha meel diguie afr tve ht an. DE t . nt e rs e s r y s s d fimai detns ,e rnsct t Compl i ,a c ii f es xti i o he ant s rtquesofZurc spl di . M o e r c i ue t i h' ea ngs r ove , ontn s he ag e , r um nt Ame iur demandsal velofde a lt tt e t r quie rs e e t i ha xc eds he e r ment oft f de a r l s s he e r l u e whe i i it t t i or rt s vi a moton t dim is Zu i h m us plad f c sand a tc n t nsss ha , n de o ur ve i o s s , rc t e at ta h doc nt an i pa i a r pondi t t eafim a i de ens . ume s tci tng nd es ng o hes fr tve f es Thi r buta m is s t m a k bec us i doesno t ke i o ac ountt f c t tZurc s e t l s e he r a et t a nt c he a t ha ih volnt rl m a t Am e iur polci - a t ,t c tt ntendor e u a iy de he rs e i es nd hus he onsiue s ment - a pa tofis s r t Co ant A diti t c r c n ge al c i r doc e s ç t he t a c pli t or mpli . src ou t a ner ly onsde um nt i ac d o at om a n i poae i t compli by rfrnc ...on a moton t dimisund Rul 1 b)b)' ncor rtd n he ant eee e i o s s er e 2( ( .' Saundesv Du ,766 F. 1 1 ( 1h Ci,201 ( tng Telabs I .v Mak ls s& r . ke 3d 262, 270 1 t r 4) cii l , nc . or s ue Ri s Lt 551U. 308,322 ( ). Hee,Zu ih hasdone bot Eve ha Zurc not ght, d, S. 2007) r rc h. n d ih fu r ' c be e a ne by t r e r ve s - c mbe men s an xpli d he ol e r al ompar d t t i t ca e - ofge r e o he nsant s ne al a s c r ct si nots nd ub- onta or s upporedby a lngua fom t to ni t ny a ge r ha pi on. 1 Furhe m or ,t r i me i t Am e iur s ar um e t t wihout a diput o r fna i 9 t r e he e s rt o rs e' g nt ha , t s e ve i ncal c ompe a i t Cour c d not c i r Am e iur s dut t de e by is l. Tha i ns ton, he t oul onsde rs e' y o f nd te f t s be a e on is own, t l te c c us , t he a t r once ns a ac m i que t o of a pas oblga i r n ade c si n t i ton. Bu a t decaaor j lrt y udgme ca r e s onl a lve c r ry i whih khee i a s t tal nt n edrs y i ontoves n c t r s ubsani t l eio d ta ( e pan if wils fe ij r i te f tr . Malwn y v Fe Colcin i lh o h t t litfl l u fr nu y n h uu e' k h ' o e . d. l to e De st p. 1 3F.d 1 4 ,1 4 ( 1h Ci. 9 9 .Ana j dc to o a Sin u yi t ep s . po iGr , 9 3 3 2 3 6 1 t r 1 9 ) d u iain f n ' jj r n h a t g . . woul be not ng mor t n a gr t t c me wihouta f c orefe t' 1 a 1 48 d hi e ha a uious om nt t ny or e f c . d. t 3 ' (nena q ai a atrtonsomit . itr l uottons nd leai ted) 11 ad e t polci e i ty, Rul 1 c saest ta' py ofawrte i tume ttati a opt d he i es xplcil e 0() tt ha ' co itn nsr n h s n e bi t a pl di i a pa toft pl a ng f ral pur es' Fe R.Ci P. xhi t o ea ng s r he e di o l pos . ' d. v. 1 c ;s alo 0() ee s S l - mie v Untd S ae De 'o u tc ,7 8F 2d 1 1 ( 1h Ci.1 ( di o i Ra rz . ie tts p t fl sie 5 s 426, 430 1 t r 985) hol ng . t tRul 1 c)a s e c tsconsdeai ofdoc ntatc d t c antdoesnotc vert ha e 0( sur s our' i rton ume ta he o ompli on t moin t d s s it moi n f rs mmayj d me t l Adm it dl cours m ustconductan to o imis no to o u r u g n ) 1 te y, . i r i o t nat e oft doc e t isr la lt and t pur e f whi h i i at c nquiy nt he ur he um n , t ei biiy, he pos or c t s ta hed bef e as u i t ti sandsf t tut oft cont tf i l r pr ent t r i Goi es v, or s m ng ha t t or he r h he en acaly e es ed he e n. n Vale C-/&Ser .Bd ,8 F.3 1 9 1 7( t Ci. 01 ) Ba n k r V ntr s LLC v Gr am, ly ) v 22 d 5 , 6 4 h r 2 6 ; n e e e u e, . ah 7 $F.d 1 1 ,1 3 -4 ( C. r 20 5 ; I d Gu & Oud o Sh ws I .C/ o Bends 9 3 1 9 1 33 D. Ci. 1 ) N n n to r o , nc / fs. y 1 F.d 449,455 (t Ci.1 ;Gantv Wali or Bd o u . 6 F.d 6 9,6 4- ( 63 3 7h r 998) . lngf d fEd c, 9 3 6 7 75 2d . Ci.1 .Ho ver i i i ce rt tt docu ntlswha t co ai sy i i'a t tt r 995) we ,f t s la ha he me s i t he mpl nt a t s' nd ha he a tc ng pa t endor e is r es t tons t n i d l be r a t e denc wha ta hi ry s d t epr en a i , he t i l wi e d o vi e t i nt sa y s nco e t bl hows' Gant 69 F. a 674. Tha i t c e he e. Zurch i t r or i ore .' , 3d t t s he as r i s he ef e nc r ct t des rbe t e s m e s a t e e s polcy c a e as ( sde t f c ne s'oft o c i he ndor e nt nd he xc s i l us t i he our or r ' he out Co ant mpli . Ac e i t e s polc clus as par of t Com pl i , I m ay ent rai an c ptng he xce s iy a e t he a nt et n st a fr tvede e e1 t a i fima i f ns 2 h t nvoke i. Tha i bec us t s a e: 1 I e unde t i i t fi or a i by r e e ' docrne t Cour c d pr bl 1 nde d, r he mplci inc por ton ef r nce' ti , he t oul oba y ha co i e t c e soft polcis e n had t y bee i r ed f r t frttm e i ve nsder d he ont nt he i e ve he n ntoduc o he is i n t i tnt M oton, See Hor e v Fel ,30 F.3d 1 25,1 34 ( 1h Ci.2002)( ume he nsa i sly . dt 4 1 1 1t r doc nt atc d t moin t dimisma b c i rd i d 1 c r t t pli ifscai a ( ta he o to o s s y e onsdee f 1 ) ental o he antf' l m; nd 2) ( u iputd' ;Da v.Ta or, F. 1 1 ( 1hCi.2 )(a ) nds e ' y ) yl 400 3d 272, 276 1 t r 005 sme . 1 W hehe Ame iur s ar 2 t r rs e' gume s d be des rbe as a S fim a i de e e'wihi t nt houl ci d n d fr tve f ns ' t n he a me nngo Rue8 c i q e to a l,A d fn ei ç fsmaie' e i tase )n wf csa d a i f l () s u si n bc e e s s i tr tv 'wh n t ' ils e a t n a r a gu e st t i t e wildef a t pl ntf' orpr e uton' cai , e n i a lale ton i r m nt ha , f nz , l e t he ai ifs os c i s l m ve f l l ga i n t c he ompli a e tue. Sak v Fr ln C/v y Co., 31 F. 337, ( Ci. ant r r ' ' s . ank i e 6 3d 350 2d r 2003 ( i ) quotng Bl k' La Ditonay)(mpha i ad . By r ee ng t e sme s Ameiur does ac s w ci r e ss ded) efrnci he ndore nt, rs e notr s a ne f c ,butm e e y i olt sa e e aie w at r l s a e n l mentofZurc spl di . Se Am.Goo e c , ih' ea ngs e s ne k 12 . . . ac antmay bedimisd underRul 1 b)6)whe isown ale tons ompli s se e 2( ( nt lgai i c t t e senc of a afi ma i def ns , s l a t de e e cla l ndia e he xit e n tr tve e e o ong s he f ns e ry a ppea son t f eoft c r he ac he ompl nt The cai ma beade t l sa e . . . but ai . lm y qua e y t t d i n a ton t t cai t c ddii o he l m he ompl i m a i l mat r of a da e t t ant y nc ude te s voi nc ha p e l etepla e' a ii t rc v r Wh nti o c r,tec mpan h sa rcud h e d rs bly o eo e. e hs c us h o lit a t buiti de ens a i es e lly s l- e tng. The pr e i nott tpl i if l-n f e nd s s nta l e fdef a i oblm s ha antf mer y ha a ii td a d ti d t ne t a d e ehe bele shi op el s ntc pae n re o ga t ef ns ive s pone wil nt l at mptt us ag ns hi ; a he pl i ifsown alegai s te o e ai t m r t r antf l tons how t tt de e e ha he f ns e ss xit. Qule v Ba ca sAm. e tI c,7 7 F.d 1 6 ,1 6 ( 1h Ci 1 (ntma qtoai ilr . r ly / di n 2 2 0 7 0 9 1 t r 984) i e l lttons cr , . a dctto so te ) a c r T yov Blg j vc ,5 6F 3d 1 1 6 ( h Ci. )($f n i in mi d ; c o d. ama . a o e ih 2 a t 074, 08 7t r 2008 ç l . t pl ntf vol arl pr de unne es a y fct i he c he ai if unt iy ovi s c s r a s n r ompl nt t def ntma us t e ai , he enda y e hos f c st de o tae t ts i note ild t r le .' .Si et e es pol y ca egi srs a t o m nsr t ha he s ntte o ei f ' nc he xc s i lus ve ie ) c t t Nat Uni de e e,isi l i wa f e fde e tng.' Qule ,7 7 F.d a 1 6 F r o he 1 on f ns t ncuson s i l- f a i ' i r 2 2 t 0 9. o s l smia r a ons Am e iur s i itnc t tZurch pl a a f t pr cae f cic ve i i lr e s , rs e' nsse e ha i e d acual edi t or r um ntng teNa 1 Unin r l d e n tg b y n t eb u d o Rue8a ( ) W hl Zu ihha n ii a h t o ue o s o o e o d h o n s f l ( )2 . ie rc d o nt l i b re t r iet e is ,o c t le ain o (Jp an ifsc mpan ee td t e afr tv u d n o as h sue n e i lg to s f a litf o lit rce h fimai e a d fn e y i wa h sd tl)i o d rt e tiae hms l t eer mgjt pla a y e c p in e e s ll t s i uy , n r e o xrc t i ef h rfo , o e d n x e to s upon whih he r i ' Marh v Bute C@. 268 F. 1 4,1 ( 1h Ci.2001 ( i c eled. ' s . lr , 3d 01 022 1 t r ) quotng Kic lev Fa me , 1 F.d 6 4 60 ( t Ci.1 5 )(n e l l r to so te ) a r gae n heo . r r 2 4 2 0 , 5 7h r 9 4 itma at ai n mi d , b o td e t on ot r gr ds b Twombl 550 U, at561 63. As a c e nc , i wasi umbe upon he oun y y, S. ons que e t nc nt Zurc t al f t ora t c doc e sfom whi h a e e i t t Nat1 Uni r eco d i h o lege ac s ta h um nt r c n xc pton o he on ul ul be i e r d. nf re I .v Wats Tr kig Se v,I . 1 F. 1 19 W L 698937,a *4 ( t Ci.1 nc . t uc n r . nc, 59 3d 355, 98 t 5h r 998)( not publs d)(1 de a t ta e sntalelmentofacli e ssi nott s mea a afnnai ihe d nil ha n se i e A am xit s he a s n fi tve d e et t cli ...) l t slgh,t r i no quesi Ameiur hasf und a i enal efns o he am ' . n hi i t hee s ' ton rs e o n ntr ic n itn y t tbas a d ca ao y j d me to t e fcs p e No ehee s b c us t n o sse c ha r e lr tr u g n n h a t ld. n t ls, e a e he out o e i uli t l t s me a be aus us e of t t nn Sa fr a i def ns 'i mor c m s tma e y he a nd c e ag he e tfim tve e e' s e co itntwih t El ve h Cic tso docrnepe ti ng t t s cic sa s lcontnue nsse t he e nt r ui' wn ti rani o he e r um t nce , i t e pl i . o m oy t 13 Zurc sf iur i t sr ga d die ty a f c st valdiy ofiss cond r buta a gument i h' a l e n hi e r r c l fe t he i t t e e tl r . Thoug not lbe e a s h,Zurc b ialy a s rs a par of r cognied exc tons u r h a l d s uc i h asc l s e t i e z ep i nde Fl i lw, one dea i wih a exc s i ur rs dut t de e , t ot r wih t a i orda a lng t n es ns e ' y o f nd he he t he nt- conrbuto r l . Fis ,Zurc obs r e t twhe a i ur d hol muli e i ur ncepolces ti i n u e r t ih e v s ha n n ns e ds tpl ns a ii t t al pur t t be i e s t a prm a y polc , t t l ha 1 por o n xce s o i r i y ha angua i ' e e mut ly ge s f m d de ual r pugna ,' T ave e sI .Co.v fe n on I . Co, 8S 2 3 3 3 5 ( a 5hDCA 1 8 ) e nt' r l r ns . xigt ns .47 o. d 6 , 6 Fl. t 9 5; Alst e l .Co.v T1 l s Co ,711 So. 2d 8 85 ( a.1tDCA 1 ) Fieman' Fu l . l at ns . G n. . 4, Fl s 998 ; r s nd ns Co.v Tr pi alShi n t Con t.Co., Lt , F. 987,1 ( 1t Ci. 1; . o c ppig t sr d. 254 3d 005 1 h r 200 ) Cons .S . ol ys, I v Alsat ls Co.411F. 1 1 ( t Ci.1 .Hee,Zurcha r ,heeaetr i nc. . lt e n . , 2d 57, 62 5h r 969) r i ve s t r r ems n t d he l ur nc ' pr son of i ompei polc i l't twoul i t s wa t r he d r ns a e' ovii ot i c tng iytes' ha d, n hi y, hwat Ameiur se es i urrsaus ( 51at9) Amers e' Re y brefdiput whehert rs e' xc s ns e tt . DE . iur s pl i s es t he e pton woul a y i t sst ton. Howe r i i notpos i e t detr i t a we t xce i d ppl n hi iua i ve , t s sbl o e m ne he ns r o t sque to be a eZurch hasnotpld t co e soft polc is d by M ar a Ca uat hi si n c us i e he nt nt he i y s ue ylnd s ly t w p So h.1 w hie t Cour m us a ce as tue a 1f t l a lga i co ane i t o ut 3 l he t t c pt r 1 acua le tons nt i d n he Compli t Erc s 551 U. a 93- t s me does nothol f new f c s t ta pl ntf a n , ik on, S. t 94, he a d or a t ha ai if beltdl r iesi r s ae y a s n e pons t am o i t dim is Tha a o t t an i pe misbl at m p t eo ton o s s . t m un s o m r s i e te t o a e t Co a ntwihou l veofCour.Bur sv. lgi Te h.Ct l . 600 F.App' m nd he mpli t t ea t ges Re i ous c n, nc, x 657,665( 1hCi.201 (i erpe tdl ha hel t tpli if c nnota ndt i compl nt 1 t r 5) i e ae y ve d ha antfs a w me her ai t oughars et amoto t dimis' ac or CarCar ir,I .v For MotrCo. 7 hr e pons o in o s s.); c d. re s nc . d o , 45 F. 11 ,11 (t Ci.1 4)(i i a omai t tt c an ma notbea 2d 01 07 7h r 98 tt s xi tc ha he omplit y i mende byt d he 1l c 3 n onne ton w ih t s a g e ,Zurc s a es i pas i t tw he a ge r lcon r c or ha ci t hi r um nt i h t t n s ng ha n ne a ta t s b n a d a a a tonali u ed t is s ee dde s n ddii ns r o t ubcon r c orspolc t tpolc i tne rexc st ta t ' iy, ha i y s ' ve es o t ( e rl( ontacorsown polcy. ( 51a 9) Besde beng abar lgalc uson he glnea cj r t ' i ' DE ' t . i s i e e oncl i wihouts pori a hort t st or f isf t s mer s a sa e a ve. t up tng ut iy, hi he y al or he a ea on s t t d bo 14 b if i o p iint amoint d s s' Asa r sul,Zurch has notaleged enough t r ie res n p osto o to o imis' ) e t i l o as , a S nc lng- 'e pton t t Nat1 Uni do rne. i eli out' xce i o he ca on cti A smia def c i r Zurc ss c cied e pton. Fl i c t have c afe a i lr e t mpais ih' e ond t xce i orda ours r td na r wor a ou t t a ic rbuton doc rne. A ç e ponsve 'i ur who co ple row k- r nd o he nt- onti i ti 's r i ' ns er m id wih isi ur d' t nde f de e eca ex r c r i t t ns e s e r or f ns n ta t e mbur e s mentfom t ç es nsve' i ur r r he s nonr po i ' ns e whe t i ur d had s pa a ey con r c ed wih ano he en iy is f a i ur d of t n he ns e e rtl ta t t t r tt tel n ns e he , no es i c r ir t i mniy t frti ur d. Co t1Ca .Co v C/ o Da o a, 0 nr ponsve a re , o nde f he is ns e n ' s . . @ fs. ytn 8 7 So.2d 91,93 ( a.5h DCA 200 ( di t ct or is i urrc d rc expe e Fl t 2) hol ng hat iy t ns e oul e over ns s - r ltng t def e of t ta i - fom ltl lague' i ur r snc ltl l a ea i o ens or cton r ite e s ns e , i e ite e gue ag ee t r d o i mniy ct ;s ealoPr gr s Ex e sl s Co.v Fl.De 'o n S r . 1 5 S 3 2 , nde f iy) e s o es pr s n . a p t fFi. e v, 2 o. d 01 . 204 ( a,4t DCA 201 )( tng Sout Da o ;Ma e Fl h 3 cii h ytna) plwood Parnes L. v.I an Harbor t r, P. ndi l .Co. 65 F.App' 466,46869 ( 1h Ci.201 (a a y cii t ns , 4 x - 1 t r 6) fvorbl tng, hough ditnguihi , si s ng Souh Da ona) The l c oft e e i i t tt i urd pari 'e e s de ii t t yt . ogi he xc pton s ha he ns e tes xpr s cson o S hfl e p s r 'fo o et t eoh ri i ue t t eis r rr lto s i a do ec me t e i itl x o u e'r m n o h t e s mp td o h n u e eain hp n v ro s h s g r la icon rbuton prncpl S.Da ona,807 So. 2d a 93. ene a nt- ti i i i e. yt t Zu i h a g t tSout Da on c r sbec us W P Sout ss ontacorag e ment rc r ues ha h yt a ontol a e h' ubc r t r e s wih KD Consr c i a Gl s Engi rng r quie t e s onta t s t G end an t tu ton nd as nee i e r d hos ubc r c or o i def d id mn W P So t f ra y a d alcamsa ii g o to terwo k p ro me a t ePrj c. ne h u h o n n l li rsn u f h i r ef n d t h oe t' ' ( 51at1 (mpha i a DE 4) e ss dded) Ag i t salegai i f nd nowher i t Compli . . an, hi l ton s ou e n he ant Tr ,Zurc di plad t tt s conta t s we e co r ct ly bound t pl c W P Sou h on ue ih d e ha he ub r c or r nta ua l o ae t t rge r la lt polcis a an Addii hei ne al ibiiy i e s tonall ur . ( ns ed Compl a !25 . And i f t sae .t ) t urher ttd t t W P Sout de a d t tAme iu e i mniy i unde t tr oft s nta t r ' ha h m nde ha rs r nde f t r he e ms he ubco r c o s polcis (d.a !28) Butt et a s tonsaedifr ntfom t fcua i r di tt twas i e. 1 t . hos wo seri r fe e r he a t l ng e en ha 15 decsve i Sout Da ona - a pr ie by one of t i su e , i pen nt of t i ur nc ii n h yt om s he n r d nde de he ns a e p l is t id mn? t eoh r S Da o a 8 So 2 a 91 9 . Be a s id mnfc to a d oi e , o n e c h te . . ytn , 07 . d t , 3 c u e n e iiai n n t dut t de e a e ditnc c ep s a a lga i t tt s onta t s we e oblga e t he y o f nd r s i t onc t , n le ton ha he ubc r c or r i td o mak W P Sout a Addii ll ur i i de t . Se Li Tr e Vil Comm. Cl As ' v e h n tona ns ed s na qua e e me e l. ub s n . St eFar Ge I .Co. 980F. 1 2,1 (11hCi.1 (( i urr' d t t dee i at m n. ns , 2d 40 405 t r 993) $ ns e s duy o fnd s An ditnc fom a br de t t d yt i si t r nd oa r han he ut o ndemniy . . .')( i Bar Oi Co. , i de f ' quotng on l v Natonwi ' Mu . r I s Ct,4 0 So 2d 8 0, 3 ( a 1tDCA 1 5:. Dic u tn Zu ih' po th t Fie n . ) 7 . 1 81 F1. s . 98 ) s o ni g rc s s-oc at mpt t e nc is pla ngs or ele is c te o nha e t e di , s t onqa i of t t r l nt conc pt , t ton he wo eeva e s he Compli t doe not pr de a s fce f c ua f an s ovi uf int a t l ounda i t o ton hr ugh whih t Sout Dayt c he h ona e e in c d be i e r Bur s , F.App' a 665. xc pto oul nf red. ge s 600 x t Fi ly,Zurc a nc t t y t tt na ur oft underyi s ta ns W P na l i h dva es he heor ha he t e he l ng ui gai t Sou h ti r d Am e iur s d y t def nd, ir s c i of t e t rgge e rs e' ut o e re pe tve he ndor eme s e ii s nt ' xplct qua ii a i Ye t s a gume smpl i est f eg ng a hortes The ca e ofer d by lfc ton. t hi r nt i y gnor he or oi ut ii . ss f e Zurc sa f t pr ii t ta i ur i oblga e t de e onc i i dee mi t ta ih t nd or he oposton ha n ns er s i t d o f nd e t s tr ned ha t r pa t s c r a ns t i ur d c hid ry' ha ges gai t he ns e ome wihi t s ope oft polc See e. ,Pi er t n he c he i y, , g. one Nat1 Til I . Co.p Fou t Co r Prp.Cor ,48 So.2d 1 , 1 4 ( a.1 . te ns . rh mmece o p. 7 051 05 Fl 986) Tur ng t t f c s Zurch nots t tt c ni o he a t , i e ha he ondo as oc ai sa l a i nsi t unde l ng s t s i ton' leg to n he ryi ui pe ti t pr t dama a l scove e by t Addii lI ur e r eme s Thatm a raned o opery ge, os rd he tona ns ed ndo s nt . y welbe tue. Buti doesnotf l t tAm e iur sdut ha bee ti r a t sar oft l r t olow ha rs e' y d n rgge ed t he t t he ltga i - bef eany prm a y i u e had con rbut d t t def e.A sar dy dic s an ii ton or i r ns r r ti e o he ens lea s us ed, e es i ur ' dut t d e i pr pt d when t prm a y c r i r r ac t dola lm i of xc s ns er s y o ef nd s om e he i r a r e e hes he l r i t is c e age N at' Uni 21 F. a 1 t ov r . 1 on, 4 3d t 27273. Pl nl t s doc r ne m odii s t br der ai y, hi ti f e he oa prnc pl t whi Zurc aludes i i e o ch i h l .Zurc doe noti ntf a c essa i ot r s Nora e ih s de iy ny as t tng he wie. r 16 s h a hortes lkey t e s,a a r quieme t def nd one' i ur r ga dl s of t uc ut ii i l o xit s e r nt o e s ns ed e r es he polcy' e i i pr son ofe es sa uswoul s low t Nat1 Uni l e whol . Bec us i s xplct ovii xc s tt d wa l he on ' ul e a e Ame iu ed mo tae t tad ca ao yj d me ti Zu ih' f v ri, nt alg to p e rs r e nsrts ha e lrtr u g n n rc s a o s o he l ains ld, e bar a amat roflw,t Compl ntsc sa i tAmers ewa r n dim is l red s te a he ai ' ount gans iur r a t s s a . Acc di l i i ORDERED a ADJUDGED t tDe e nt Am e iur l ur or ng y, t s nd ha f nda s rs e ns mwe Compa a Amers e M ut lI ur nc Co pa sM oton t Dimi st Sec Amen d ny nd iur ua ns a e m ny' i o s s he ond de Co ant( 43)i GRANTED. Count 1 and IIoft Se mpli DE s s1 I he condAme d Compli ( nde ant DE 39)aeDI I r SM SSED.Zurc ma fl aThidAme ih y e r ndedCompli byJanuar 27, ant y 2017. DONE AND ORDERED i Cha r ,a W e t P n mbe s t s ' . ' .w e ch,Fl i t s a orda, hi J nuar 2017. a y, > x' < . # z ' e x - D D M .M I D LEB ROO K S D UN I TED STATES D I STRI J GE CT UD c c: Al Couns lofRec d l e or da of y

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?