Leigh v. Avossa et al

Filing 89

ORDER AWARDING ATTORNEY'S FEES TO THE DEFENDANTS AND AGAINST MR. MALIK LEIGH, ESQ., AND DANIELLE RENEE WATSON, ESQ.: granting 88 Defendants' Motion for Attorney Fees. Mr. Leigh and Ms. Watson shall reimburse Defendants for their Attorney's fees in the amount of $1,184.70 and make payment to the Office of General Counsel for the School Board of Palm Beach County on or before December 15, 2017. Signed by Magistrate Judge William Matthewman on 11/6/2017. (kza)

UNI
TED STA TES D I
STRI CO U RT
CT
SO U TH ERN D I
STRI O F FLO RI
CT
DA
Ci l o.1 8l z- v - ar a M a t
vi N
6- 6l cl M r / thewm a
n

M ALI LEI ESQ.
K GH,
,

'

?

FL D b
IE y

Pl ntf ,
ai i f

D.
C.

80k 2s 2 1
27

VS.

ROBERT AVOSSA, al,
et .

sumxubAsyT
cn.hML-w.-.
yi: u DI:.
EEl R? R
v
l E
s o!F . Fa
. r

D e e nt .
f nda s

O RD ER AW A R D I G ATTO RN EY ' FEES TO TH E D EFE ND A N TS
N
S

AND AGAI
NST M R.M ALI LEI .ESO .AND DANI
K
GH
.
ELLE RENEE W ATSON,
ESO .
THI CAUSE i be or t Cour upon t Def nda s Ro r Avos a Che yl
S
s f e he
t
he
e nt , be t
s,
r
M cKee r Cam il Col m a Di nna W e nba ,El s Epps D a d Chrs i ns n,D a r D a s
ve ,
le e n, a
i um vi
, vi
i ta e
r on vi ,

J e Lee a Pam Be h Co t Sc
os ph , nd l
ac uny hoolDitit ( r ' (l f nt') M oi f
src Boadls : enda s' ton or
De
Ator ys Fe t Deemi t AmountofFe t BeAwaded(ç oton')( 881 Counsl
t ne ' es o tr ne he
es o
r % i ' DE .
M
e
f Pl ntf ,M a i Lei Es ,a D a ele Re e W a s Es , ha f ied t fl a tm e y
or ai i f
lk gh, q. nd ni l ne
t on, q. ve a l o ie i l
rs
e pons t t M oton. The Cour has c e uly r vi w e t M oto a t Cour ' pror
e o he
i
t
ar f l e e d he
i n nd he
ts i
Or s a w e lt e ie docke i t sca e.
der , s l he ntr
t n hi s
BA CK G R O U ND

On O c obe 1 201 t unde s gned ent r an O r r G r ntng i Pa ta Denyi i
t r 3, 7, he
ri
e ed
de a i n r nd
ng n

Pa tDeenda s Moton f Sa onsa t Sti g 871 n t tOr ,t Cour grntd
r f nt' i or ndi nd o rke. DE .I ha der he
t a e
Def nda s r que t f a a a d of ator y' f es a ns bot of Pl ntf , M alk Le g s
e nt ' e s or n w r
t ne s e gai t h
ai if
i
i h'
c
ouns l M r Le gh a M s W a s f t tm e i r d by D ef nda s i ha ng t r e c
e , . i nd . t on, or he i ncur e
e nt n vi o es ar h
1

a dr f De e
nd a t f ndant moton f s nc i a t srke,r vi w a r s a c Pl ntf r pons
s' i or a tons nd o ti e e nd e e r h ai ifs es e
t r o,a dr f a r ea c Def nt 'r pl I a p.1 The Cour diece couns lf
he et nd a t nd es r h
enda s e y. d. t 0.
t r td
e or

Dee nt t fl wihi s ve ( da oft daeoft Or r ame a
fnda s o ie, t n e n 7) ys he t he de , morndum t ta e s d
ha ddrs e
t houry r t ofc
he
l ae
ouns ,t tm e e nde t nm ountofr s bl ator y' f es a cos s
el he i xpe d, he
ea ona e t ne s e nd t

t tDe e nt i ur e i r e r hi and d a tng De e n s moton f s ndi a t
ha f nda s nc r d n es a c ng
r fi
f nda t '
i or a ons nd o
s rke,r vi w i a r ea c ng Pl i if s r s
t i e e ng nd es r hi
a ntf e pons ,a dr tng a r e r hi D ef nt '
e nd afi nd es a c ng
enda s
r pl a wel a a c t i r d. I The Cour a s di e t d Pl i ift f l a m e or nd
e y, s l s ny os s ncur e d
t l o r c e a ntf o ie
m a um

rs ndn a d o o j cigt t ea u to atr e ' fe a c t s u h b t eDee a t,
epo ig n /r be tn o h mo n f to n y s e s nd oss o g t y h fnd ns
i l ng t hour y r t ofc
nc udi he
l ae
ouns la tm e cl i ed t ha be n e
e nd i
am
o ve e xpende by t D e enda s
d
he f
nt '

c el 1 a pp.l 1 The de i f t r s
ouns . d. t
0-1 .
adlne or he e pons me or ndum was s ve days a t
e m a
e n
fer
Def nt 'fl d t i m e or
enda s ie he r m andum .

Fi l t Cour pr de t D e e nt w ih a
naly, he
t ovi d he f nda s t n

o r uniy t fl a r pl 1 a p.11.
ppo t t o ie e y. d. t
D ef nda s f l d t i M oton on Oc obe 20, 201 The cont nd t t t r c
e nt ie he r
i
t r
7.
y
e ha hei ouns l
e

s nt7. hou sata$250pe hourrt prpai t motonf s nci a t srke.( 88,
pe 29 r
r
ae e rng he i or a tons nd o ti DE

p 2-1 Ho v r Dee a t ae o y s e i $11 47 b c u e Dee d n s c u e h s
p. 3 . we e, fnd ns r nl e kng ,8 .0 e a s fn a t' o ns l a
vol a iy r duc t a t e s f e c c a i by 35% afe a yi her r as bl bilng
unt r l e ed he tom y' e s al ul ton
t r ppl ng
e ona e li

j d me t f . a p. Ata h dt t eMo in aeDe e d n s c u e ' b l n e tisg 8 u g n . # t 2. tc e o h to r f n a t' o ns ls il g n re DE 8
i
1 andt Afi vi ofLiaM .Ko i Es ( 88- .
) he fda t s
hrng, q.DE 21
LEG A L STA ND A RD
A.

Att
ornev' Fees
s

A r as bl a t ey' f a ar i S opery ca cul t d by m uli yi t num be of
e ona e tom s ee w d s ç
pr l l a e
tpl ng he
r
hour r s bl e nded on t ltga i tm es a r a ona e houry r t ' Am.Ci lLi r i s
s ea ona y xpe
he ii ton i
e s bl
l a e.
'
vi be te

Uni v.Bar s 1 F. 423,427 ( 1h Ci.1
on
ne , 68 3d
1 t r 999)( ig Bl v Stns 465 U. 88
quotn um . e on,
S. 6,
2

8 8( 9 4 ) Thi ço e tr ma te b a j td frt rs lso tie b t at r e . S e
8 1 9 ). s k d sa ' y h n e duse o he e ut b an d y he to n y e
l
'
Bar s,1 F. a 427 (ii Lor ge v.Ste hei 1 F. 776,781( 1h Ci.1 4). The
ne 68 3d t
ctng an r ir m, 0 3d
1 t r 99 )
r s
ea onabl houry r t i defne ast i e lng ma ke r t i t r e tl lc
e
l a e s i d he ç vaii
pr
r t a e n he elvan ega omm uniy
t
f sm ia s r i e by l w ye s of r s na y c pa a e s ls expe i nce a r put to '
or i l r e v c s
a r
ea o bl om r bl kil ,
r e , nd e a i n.
'

Ba n s 1 F.da 4 6( o igNo manv Ho sn t. fM o to r 8 6F. 1 9 ,1 9
r e , 68 3 t 3 qu tn r
. u igAuh o ng mey, 3 2d 2 2 2 9
( lhCi.1 )
1 t r 999).
W ih r ga d t t t ofe denc t tt f e cl man s d pr
t e r o he ype
vi e ha he e ai t houl oduce i s ppor ofa
n u
t
cl i ,i Bar s t El ve h Cicui ha s a ed,
am n
ne , he e nt r t s t t
The û e a i antbe st bur ofesabls ng e il m en a doc e i
i e pplc
f
ar he den
t i hi ntte t nd um ntng
t a oprat hour a houry r t . No
he ppr i e
s nd
l aes' rman,836 F. atl
'
2d 303. Tha bur n
t de
i l
nc udesls yi t c tw ih s cii a de a l d e denc f om w hi h t
'uppl ng he our t pe f c nd t ie vi e r
c he
c tc n det nni t r a ona e hour y r t Furhe ,f couns ls d ha
our a
e ne he e s bl
l a e. t r ee
e houl ve
m a nt i d r or t s
i a ne ec ds o how t tm e s nton t dif r tcl i s a t ge r
he i pe
he f e en a m , nd he ne al

s be tmatro tetmee pe dt r so g t ob sto t t s fiin
u jc t f h i x n iu e u h t e e u wih u fce t
e
pa tc a iy s t tt di ti c tc n a s s t tm e c ai e f ea h ac i t
r i ul rt o ha he s rct our a s e s he i l m d or c tviy
. . . . A wel- epa ed f e pe ii
lpr r e tton as woul i l a s
lo
d ncude umm a y, o ng t
r gr upi he

tmeenresbyt naur oft aci t orsa oft c s 'f (iai
i ti
he t e he tviy tge he a e. #. cttons
'
omitd)
te .
168 F. at427.
3d
R easonabl H ourl R ate
e
y

I s e ng r mbur e e f isa t e sf es Def ndant r y on t Afi vi ofLia
n e ki ei
s m nt or t tom y' e , e
s el
he fda t
s

M .Kohrng,Es ,s
i
q. uppori hercai houry r t Ac r ng t t afi vi,M s Kohrng
tng
l med
l a e. co di o he fda t .
i
ac i ng a
nce
bil a t rt of$250 pe hour g 8 21 She has been pr tci lw si 2011 and
ls t he ae
r
. DE 8- .
s i i s i e pl entl w . 1
pec alze n m oym
a
d.
Based upon t Courts ow n experi
he
'
ence i as si t reasonabl s of atonz s
n ses ng he
enes
t ey'

f es a havi r vi w e t a f da ts it i t s c e, hi Cour fnds t M s Kohrng'
e , nd
ng e e d he f i vi ubm ted n hi as t s
t i hat .
i s
ho l r t i r as
ur y a e s e onabl i c pa i on t t pr vaii m a ke r t i t r e nt l gal
e n om r s o he e lng r t a e n he el va e
3

c mmu t. Th Co r as n tsta t Plitf h sno o j ce t t eh u l rt o d fns
o ni
y e u t lo o e h t he an if a t b e td o h o ry ae f ee e
couns l
e.
2.

N um ber ofH ours R easonabl Expended
y

Ne t Cour mus deer ne whehe t hour bild we e r a ona e. De e nt '
xt he
t t t mi
t r he
s le
r e s bl
f nda s
couns ls nt7. hour t a on r ea c ng a dr f i t m oton f s nc i a t s rke,
e pe
29
s ot l es r hi nd a tng he
i or a tons nd o t i
butD e e nt a e o y s e ng a a t ne s f e a a d f 4. hour afe vol a iy r
f nda s r nl e ki n tor y' e w r or 73
s t r unt r l educ ng
i
couns ls ho sby 35% .
e ' ur
The Cour has c r f l r vi w e t tm e e res Def nda s c
t
a e uly e e d he i
nt i .
e nt ' ouns lbil 2. hour
e led 1
s
o r s a c ng t c e l a t r l va Loc Rul be or dr f i t m oton f s nc i
n e e r hi he as aw nd he e e nt al e f e a tng he
i or a tons

a t srke g 8821 Defnda s c e t n bild 2. hour dr tngt moi I
nd o ti . DE - . e nt' ouns l he le 99
s afi he ton. d
Fi ly,De e nt 'couns lbil d 0. on r e i Pl i if s r pons t t m o i and 1 9
na l
f nda s
e le 3
evi w ng a ntf es
e o he ton
.

ho sd a tng ar pl 1 W hie t hour bil s e si hty e s i t Cour' fndst t
ur r fi
e y. d.
l he
s led e m lg l xce sve, he
ts i ha
Def nda s c
e nt ' ouns l s 35% r duc i of t tm e bil d m a
e'
e ton
he i
le
kes t r que t d a t ne s f s
he e s e tor y' ee

a r r a o a l. Th Co r as n tst a tePlitf h sn to j ce t t h u scame
wad e s n be
e u t lo o e h t h an if a o b e td o he o r li d
b def ns c el Ther f e, het a f awar i $1 1 7
y e e ouns .
e or t ot l ee
d s , 84.0.
CONCLVSI N
Q
Ba e on t f e ng,i i he e O RDERED a f l :
s d he or goi t s r by
s olows
D e e nt ' M oton f Atom eys Fe t D e e m i t Am ount of Fee t B e
f nda s
i or t
' es o
t r ne he
s o

Awadedg 881i GRANTED.
r DE
s
M r Le g a M s W a s s lr i bur et Def nda sf t i a t e sf esi t
. i h nd . ton hal em s he e nt or her tom y' e n he

a
mountof$1 1 70.
, 84.
M r Le g a M s W a s a e or r d t m ake s h pa e t t O f i e of G e r
. i h nd . t on r de e o
uc
ym nt o he fc
ne al
Couns f t SchoolBoar ofPa m Be ch Count on orbe or D e em be 1 201
el or he
d
l
a
y
f e c
r 5, 7.
4

DONE AND ORDERED i Chambe st s
n
r hi

l dy foebr2017 atw estPalm
aoNvme
,

Be h,Pa m Bea h Co y,i t Sout n D it i tofFl i
ac
l
c
unt n he
her s r c
or da.

W I AM M A TTHE
LLI
AN
UN I
TED STATES M A GI
STR ATE J G E
UD

5