ABRAMS-JACKSON v. Avossa et al

Filing 98

ORDER AWARDING ATTORNEY'S FEES TO THE DEFENDANTS AND AGSINST MR. MALIK LEIGH, ESQ., AND DANIELLE RENEE WATSON, ESQ.: granting 97 Defendants' Motion for Attorney Fees. Mr. Leigh and Ms. Watson shall reimburse Defendants for their Attorney's fees in the amount of $932.75 and make payment to the Office of General Counsel for the School Board of Palm Beach County on or before December 15, 2017. Signed by Magistrate Judge William Matthewman on 11/6/2017. (kza)

UN I
TED STATES D I
STRI COU RT
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
Ci lN o.l 8l
vi
6- 6z4- v - a r / a t w m a
cl M r a M the
n

RAQUEL ABRAM S
UACKS
ON,
Pl i if
a ntf ,

FI EZ by
L

VS.

D.
C.

N 26 2 1
0k
27

ROBERT AVOSSA,e a .
t 1,

S VEN M LARI
TE
MORE

cuihq. DlTc.
E?l L s. T
sD. r u -w. a.
. o!r i. R

D e e nt .
f nda s

O R DE R A W A RD IN G AT TO R N EY ' FEE S T O TH E DEFEND A N TS
S

AND AGAI
NST M R.M ALI LEI .
K
GH ESO .AND DANI
.
ELLE RENEE W ATSON,
ESO .
TH I CA U SE i be or t Cour upon t D ef nt , Che yl M c e r a Pa m
S
s f e he
t
he
enda s
r
K eve nd l

Bea h Count SchoolBoad' Cl fnda s' M oton f Ator 'Fe t Deemi t
c
y
r s Dee nt'
) i or t neys es o tr ne he
Amo ofFee t BeAwar d Cû oton' g 971 CounslfrPli if M ai Leg Es ,
unt
so
de M i ' DE .
)
e o antf, lk ih, q.
and Da ele Re e W aton,Es , ve f ie t fl a tme y r pons t t M oton.TheCour
ni l ne
s
q.ha al d o ie i l es e o he
i
t
has c r f l r vi w e t M oto a t Cour ' pror Or r ,as w e lt e ie doc ti t s
a e uly e e d he
i n nd he
ts i
de s
l he ntr
ke n hi
CaSC.

BA CK G R O U N D

O n O c o r 1 2017,t under i d e er d a Or Gr ntng i Pa ta D e ng i
t be 3,
he
s gne nt e n der a i n r nd nyi n

Pa t fnd ns Mo in f rS n to sa t S rk .g 9 1 n t a Or e, h Co r g a td
r Dee a t' to o a cin nd o tie DE 4 .l h t d r t e u t rn e
Dee
f ndan s r que t f a a a d of a t e s f es a i t bo h of Pl i if Ra l A br m s
t ' e s or n w r
tom y' e ga ns t
a ntf , que
a J c on' c
a ks s ouns ,M r Lei and M s W a s f t tm e i ur e by D e enda s i ha ng t
el . gh
. t on, or he i nc r d
f
nt n vi o
r e c a dr f Def nda s m oton f s tons a t s r ke,r vi w a r s a ch Pl i t f
es ar h nd a t e nt ' i or anc i
nd o ti e e nd e e r
a n ifs
1

r pons t r o,a dr h and r s a c Def nda s'r pl 1 a p. 1 The Cour die t d
es e he et nd a
eerh
e nt e y. d. t
0.
t rce

c e f Deenda st fl,wihi sve ( )da oft dae oft Or ,a me a
ounsl or f nt o ie t n e n 7 ys he t he der
morndum
t ta es e t hour y r t of c
ha ddr s d he
l ae
ouns l t tm e e nde t a ountof r as bl a t ne s
e , he i xpe d, he m
e ona e tor y'

f es a c t t t Def nda s i ure i r ea c ng a dr fi De e
e nd oss ha
e nt nc r d n es r hi nd a tng f ndant' m o i n f
s
to or
s nc i a t srke r vi ng a r e c ng Pl ntf s r pons , a dr fi a
a tons nd o ti , e ewi
nd es ar hi
ai if es e nd a tng nd
r e r hi D ef nda s r pl a w e l as a c t i r d.
es a c ng
e nt ' e y, s l
ny os s ncur e

The Cour alo die t d
t s rce

Plitf t fl ame rn u r s o d n a / ro j ci t t a u to at me sf e a d
anif o ie
mo a d m e p n i g ndo b e t o he mo n f to y' e s n
ng
c t s
os s oughtby t Def nda s i udi t houry r t of c
he
e nt , ncl ng he
l ae
ouns a tm e c a m e t ha
el nd i
l i d o ve

be e nde by t De e nt ' c
en xpe d
he f nda s ouns l 1 a pp. 1 11 The dea i f t r pons
e . d. t
0- .
dlne or he es e
m e or ndum was s n days a t Def nda s fl d t i m e or ndum . I Fi ly,t Cour
m a
eve
fer e nt ' ie he r m a
d
na l he
t
pr ded t D e enda sw ih a opporuniy t fl a r y. I a p.11
ovi
he f
nt t n
t t o ie epl d. t
.

De e
f ndant fl d t r M oton on Oc obe 20,201 They c e t tt i c
s ie hei
i
t r
7.
ont nd ha he r ouns l
e

s nt5.4 hou sa a$250pe hourrt prparngt moi frs tonsa t srke.( 97,
pe 7
r t
r
ae e i he ton o anci nd o ti DE

p 2 3 . Ho v r De e d ns a e o l s e i g $ 3 7 b c us De e d n s c u e ha
p. - )
we e, fn a t r ny e k n 9 2.5 e a e fn a t' o ns l s
vol t rl r duc t ato
un a iy e ed he tnwy' f s c l ul ton by 35% a tra yi herr a ona e bilng
s ee a c a i
fe ppl ng
e s bl li
'

J me .
udg nt

a p.2. De e nt f t r e ai t tt y Sa id a sgnii ntr duc i
t
f nda s ' he xpl n ha he lpple
ur
i fca e ton

be us atlas s
ca e e t ome oft c e l r ea c c td i Def nda s'M oton t Sti i t sc s
he as aw es r h ie n
e nt
i o rke n hi a e
wa pr vi l r s a che r vi
s e ousy e e r d/e ewed t pr pa e Def nda s M oton f Sanc i a t Sti i
o e r
e nt ' i or
tons nd o rke s
ca e no. 9: 6- v- 61 KA M .' f a p. 3, n. 4. A ta hed t t M oton a e D e e nt '
s
1 c 81 2' J. t
tc
o he
i r
f nda s

co elsbilnge res( 97 1 andt Afi vi ofLiaM .Kohrng,Es g 97- .
uns ' li nti DE - 1 he fda t s
i
q.DE 21

2

LEG A L STAN D A RD
A.

At orne s Fees
t
v'

A r as bl a t ne sf e a r i l ope l c c a e by muli yi t num be of
e ona e tor y' e wa d s t
pr ry alult d
tpl ng he
r
hour r s bl e nded on t ltgai tmesar s bl hotry r t .' Am.Ci lLi ris
s ea ona y xpe
he ii ton i
ea ona e zl a e'
vi be te

Uni v.Bar s 1 F. 423,427 ( 1h Ci.1 ( ig Bl v Stns 465 U. 8
on
ne , 68 3d
1 t r 999) quotn um . e on,
S. 86,

8 8 ( 9 4 ) Th sio e tr' yt e b a j se f rt er s lso ti e b t eat r e Se
8 1 9 ). i û d sa 'ma h n e du td o h e ut b an d y h to n y. e
l
Bar s 1 F. a 427 ( tn Lor ge v Stehei 1 F. 776,781( 1h Ci.1 4). The
ne , 68 3d t
ciig an r . ir m, 0 3d
1 t r 99 )
r as bl houry r t i defne a t S e lng m a ke r t i t r l ntl ga communiy
e ona e
l a e s i d s he t vaii
pr
r t a e n he eeva e l
t
f s m ia s vi es by l
or i l r er c
awyer of r as bl com par bl s ls e
s
e ona y
a e kil , xpere e,and r put ton.
i nc
e ai '
'

Ba n s 1 F.da 4 6( u tn No ma v Ho sn Auh o ngo r 8 6F.d 1 9 1 9
r e , 68 3 t 3 q o ig r n . u ig t .fMo t mey 3 2 2 2, 2 9
( 1h Ci.1 )
1 t r 999).
W ih r ga d t t t ofe de e t t t f e cl i a s d pr
t e r o he ype
vi nc ha he e a m nt houl oduc i s
e n uppor of a
t
cl i ,i Bar s t El ve h Cic thas s a ed,
am n
ne , he e nt r ui
tt

Theû e a i a be st bur ofe t bls ng entteme a doc
i e pplc nt ar he den sa ihi
f
il nt nd umentng
i
t a oprae hour and houry r t . No man,836 F. a 1
he ppr i t
s
l a es' r
'
2d t 303.Tha bur
t den
i l
ncudesSs yi t c twih s cii a de a ld evi efom whih t
tuppl ng he our t pe fc nd t ie
denc r
c he
c tc n det r i t r a ona e hour y r e.Fur he , ee c
our a
e m ne he e s bl
l at
t r f ouns s d ha
el houl ve
m a nt i d r or t s
i a ne ec ds o how t tm e s nto t di f r ntcl i s a t ge a
he i pe n he f e e
a m , nd he ner l

s be tmatro tetmee pe dt rso g t ob s to t t s fce t
u j c te f h i x n iu e u h t e e u wih ufiin

pm i ul rt s t tt dit i tc tc n as es t tm e c a m ed f e ch a i t
c a iy o ha he s rc our a s s he i
li
or a ctviy
lpr pa ed f e pe ii n a s w oul i l a s m a y,gr ng t
r e tto l o
d nc ude um r oupi he
. . . . A wel- e

tmeenre byt naur oft a i t orsa oft ca e. 1 (iai
i tis he t e he ctviy tge he s ' d. cttons
'
omitd)
te .
1 F. a 427.
68 3d t
1. R easonabl H ourl R at
e
y
e

I s eki r i bur e e f isator y' f es Def ndant r y on t A fi vi ofLi a
n e ng e m s m nt or t t ne s e , e
s el
he fda t
s
M .Kohr ng,Es ,s
i
q. uppor i he cl i e houry r t A c di t t afi vi,M s K ol i
tng r a m d
l a e. cor ng o he fda t . l ng
r
3

ac i ng a
nc
bls a te rt o $ 5 pe h u . g 9 - 1 She has been pr tci l w si e 2011 and
il t h ae f 2 0 r o r DE 7 2 .
s i i s i e pl entl w . 1
pec alze n m oym
a d.
Ba ed upon t Cour ' own e r e e i a s s i t r as bl s of a t ne s
s
he
ts
xpe i nc n s e s ng he e ona ene s
tor y'
f e ,a ha ng r vi w e t a fda ts it d i t s c s ,t s Cour fndst tM s K ohrng'
e s nd vi e e d he f i vi ubm te n hi a e hi
ti
ha
.
i s
hou l r t i r as
r y a e s e onabl i c pa i on t t pr ii m a ket r t i t r l va l ga
e n om r s o he eva lng r
a e n he e e nt e l

c mmu t Th Co r as n tst t h Plitf h sn to j ce t t eh u l rt o d fn e
o ni
y. e u t lo o e ha t e an if a o b e td o h o ry ae f ee s
c
ouns l
e.
2.

N um be o H our R e onabl Expended
r f
s as
y

N e t Cour m us de e m i w he he t ho s bil d w e e r as bl D e e
xt he
t
t t r ne
t r he ur le
r e ona e. f ndan s
t'

c
ouns ls nt5. hour t a on r ea c ng a dr tng t moton f s nc i and t srke,
e pe 74
s ot l es r hi nd afi he
i or a tons
o ti
bu De e nt a e onl s eki a at r y' f e a r f 3. hour afe vol a iy r duc ng
t f nda s r
y e ng n to ne s e wa d or 73
s tr unt rl e i
c
ouns ls hour by 35% .
e'
s

The Cour hasc r f l r viwe t tm e e res Def ndan s'c
t
a e uly e e d he i nti .
e
t ouns lbil d 17 hour
e le .
s
on r e c ng t c e l a t r l va Loc Rul be or dr fi t moton f s nc i
es ar hi he as aw nd he e e nt al e f e a tng he
i or a tons

a t srke. ( 97- . Defnda s c e t n bild 1.4 ho sdahi t moto 1
nd o ti DE 21
e nt' ouns l he le 8 ur r ng he in. d.
Fi ly,Def nda s c
na l
e nt ' ouns lbil d 0. on r e i Pl i t f s r po e t t m oto a 1 9
e le 3
evi w ng a n if es ns o he
i n nd .
hour d a tng a r pl 1 W hie t hour bil s e s i hty e s i t Cour ' f nds t t
s r fi
e y. d.
l he
s led e m lg l xce s ve, he
ts i
ha

Def nda s c
e nt ' ouns ls 35 r duc i of t tm e bil d m a t r que t d at ne s f s
e ' % e ton
he i
le
kes he e se tor y' ee

a r r a o a l. Th Co r as n tst a tePlitf ha n to j ce t t h u scame
wad e s n be
e u t lo o e h t h an if s o b e td o he o r li d
b de e ec el The e or t t alf eawar i $932.
y f ns ouns . r f e, he ot e
ds
75.
CO NC LU SI N
O
Bas on t f e ng,i i he e O RD ER ED a f l
ed
he or goi t s r by
s olows:
Def nda s M oton f r A tor ys' Fe s t D e e m i t Am ount of Fe t Be
e nt '
i
o
t ne
e o
t r ne he
es o
4

Awa d d g 9 )i GRANTED.
r e DE 7 s
2.

M r Lei a M s W aton s l r m bure t De enda sf t i at ne sf si t
. gh nd . s ha l ei
s he f nt or her tor y' ee n he

a ountof$93 75.
m
2.
M r Lei a M s W at on a e or r t m a s h paym e t t Of i of G e r l
. gh nd .
s r de ed o ke uc
nt o he fce
ne a

Couns lf t Sc
e or he hoolBoa d ofPal Bea h Count on orbef eDec m be 15,
r
m
c
y
or
e r 2017.

D N A DO D R DiCabrti; dyoN vm e 21aWeta
O E N R E E n hm e hs a f oebr 07t sPl
s
,
m
Bea h,Pa m Be h Count i t Sout r D i ti tofFl r da.
c
l
ac
y, n he
he n sr c
oi
-

W I A M M A TTH E
LLI
AN
UN I
TED STA TES M A G I
STM TE J D GE
U

5

.