Collado v. Enterprise Leasing Company of Florida, LLC et al

Filing 29

ORDER REGARDING IN CAMERA REVIEW ON WILLIAM W. PRICE, P.A'S OBJECTIONS AND MOTION TO QUASH SUBPOENA DUCES TECUM:granting in part and denying in part 15 Motion to Quash. Non-party, William W. Price, P.A., must produce the documents to Defendant on or before August 11, 2017. Signed by Magistrate Judge William Matthewman on 8/3/2017. (kza)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
SOU TH ERN D I
STRI OF FLO RI
CT
DA
CA SE N O .I 8OI - - A RR A/ A TTH EW M AN
7- ZI CV M
M
A LFREDO CO LLA D O ,
Pl i if
a ntf ,
FI j
LED y

D.
C.

Ad 23 2 1
C
27
ENTERPRI LEASI COM PANY
SE
NG
OF FLORI LLC,d/ / ENTERPRI
DA,
ba
SE
REN T- A TRU CK ,

SI ofFb -w pa.
Ja' '/.Wï.
t %I !
C
E
s.. r L
o

De e nt
f nda .

O R DE R R EG A RD I G I CA M EM REV I
N N
EW O N W I I M W .PR I . A . S
LL A
CE P. '

OBJECTI
ONS AND M OTI TO OUASH SUBPOENA DUCES TECUM
ON

THI CAUSE i beor t Cour uponPl ntf,Alrdo Cola (ç antf a no
S
s f e he
t
ai if fe
ldo û i if), nd npl

p ry W iim W .P ie A. Ob e to a d M oin t Qu s S b o n Duc s Te =
a t, l a
l
rc ,P. ' j cins n
S
to o a h u p e a e c
(ç to ' ( 1 1 f n a t Eneprs Le sn Co a y ( ee a f)fldaRe p ns t
s in' DE 5 .De e d n , tr ie a ig mp n C fnd n ' ie
Mo )
r
so e o
Obe to s a d Mo in t Qu s S b e a Du e Te u a l o r td M e rnd m o
jcin n
to o a h u po n c s c m nd nc mo ae
mo a u f
La g 1 j Thsmatrwa r fre t t u d ri n du n a Or e r fn nga1 ic v r
w DE 8 . i te s ee rd o he n e sg e po n d r e e i l d so e y
m at r t t unde sgned f a oprat diposton. Se DE 8. The under i d c
te s o he
ri
or ppr i e s ii
e
sgne onduc e a
td

he rngont M otononJ 8, 7.( 201
ai
he i
une 201 DE .
The Cour t k t M o i n unde a s nta or e non- t W ilam W .Prce
t oo he to
r dvieme nd der d
pary, li
i ,
P. .t s i is t l on Pl i ift t Cour f e par e i c er r vi w i or rt e ur
A o ubm t t i e
a ntf o he
t or x
t , n am a e e n de o ns e
t tD e e
ha
f ndant obt i al r l nt di c r i t s l w s t wihout i r ngi o a w or
a ns l e eva
s ove y n hi a ui t
nf i ng n ny
k

pr tprvie orat ney-le prvie ( 25,p.2J
oduc i lge tor cint i lge. DE
.
The Cour has r ce ved t doc e s a has c e u l c
t
e i
he um nt nd
ar f ly onduc e an i came a r vi
td
n
r e ew
1

oft m . Ahe r viw,t Cour fndst f l ng doc e sfom Pl i ifs fl atW ila
he
r e e he
t i he olowi
um nt r
antf ie
li m
W . Prce P. a e r l va and s d be pr e Pr r s i ools ul me . f r
i , A. r e e nt
houl
oduc d: og e sve. .e e ntofe

( rd ce )
Un e a td ;

Pr g e sv .o
o r sieo 4

( rd ce )
Un e a td ;

Pr g e sv .o
o rs ieo 6

( z d ce )
Un e a td ;

M e ai summay. no ( eda td) Cle . II E ( r hi r ce e e f t
diton.
r Roma Unr ce ; intol .M Eve yt ng eda td xc pt or he
fr t pa a a
is
z gr ph

t lte) Cl i sttme ( na il a
he etr; osng. ae nt Fi nca mount r ce ; a
s eda td) nd

E.
n,
23585- V , 201 W L
CI
2
Medi l lsummay. ( r de . See S. C.v.M erki N o. 11caBil
r l Uneda d)
kc

2 6 5 ,* ( D. a Jme2 , 01 )(h li gt a atr e wo kp o uc ma bep o uc d i
5 81 8 3 S. Fl. t 9 2 2 t od n h t to n y r r d t y r d e n
r aced f
ed t onn i f t i or ai wa not ot ie a ia e a m ovi pa t s
f acual nf m ton s
hem s va lbl nd
ng ry howe
d

s tnta ne a unduehads p.) TheCour a ee wih Dee ntt tt s doc nt
ubsa il ed nd
r hi l.
t gr s t fnda ha he e ume s
a e r e nt be us t c a n i or ton r ltng t Pl i ifs pror ca c as a hi
r elva
ca e hey onti nf ma i ea i o antf' i
r r h nd s

s san d ij re ,wh c a esmia t te ij re t a Plitf i cami g i t ei tn c s .
u ti e nu is ih r i lr o h nu is h t an if s li n n h nsa t a e
The ot r doc e s i Pl n if s fl a W ila Prc P. a e ir l van a s lnot be
he
um nt n aitf ie t lim i e, A. r re e t nd hal
pr ed.
oduc
Alho h W ila Prc P. cai st tt e doc e sa e prvie d be a e oft
t ug
lim i e, A. l m ha hes
um nt r i lge c us
he
w or pr
k- oduc pr ec i n, D e e nt has s n a s t nta ne f t doc e s whi h
t ot to
f nda
how
ubs a i l ed or he
um nt ,
c

c
nnno be o he wieobt i d wiho t
t t r s
a ne t ut mdueha ds p.Se Pi i v De t Ailne ,I . No.1
r hi
e p no . la ri s nc,
5-

c - 0 3 , 01 W L 41 41 5 * ( D.F a Apr 2 ,2 6 ;S en v ' in 2 3 F. D. 6 ,
v8 3 0 2 6
8 8 , 2 S. l . . 9 01 ) tr .O Qun , 5 R. 6 3
686 ( D.Fl.2008) Defndan atmptd t obt n t e doc nt and r ae doc t
S. a
. e t te e o ai hes ume s
eltd umens
fom Pl n ifs pr vi doc or a o he medi ls c s butt e s ce ha pr
r
aitf
e ous t s nd t r
ca our e ,
hos our s ve oduce
d

ltl t n i fnnaino Pli tf sp ira cd n a dij re .
i e o o n o to n anif ro c ie t n nu is
t
Mor ove,ast t me ai s
e r o he diton ummay,Fl i Stt e44. sat t ttll or ton
r orda aut 405 t es ha dinf mai

t ti o h r s a misbe o s be tt ds o e y d e n tb c me ia misbe o p o e td
ha s t ewie d si l r u j c o ic v r o s o e o n d sil r r tce
fom dic r by r as ofisdicos e orus i me aton. Fl Stt j 44. 5) df e
r
s ovey
e on t s l ur
e n di i ' a. a.
'
4054 . t'
-h
2

pur e of t ba on dicos e of m e a i comm uni tons i t pr cl a ison of
pos
he n
s l ur
di ton
cai
s o e ude dm s i
s tl m e of e s be w e n pa te who ar oppos ng pa tes a t t i i whi h t e de e of
e te nt f r t e
ri s
e
i
r i t he ral n
c he vi nc

t es tlme ti s u h t b ito u e . Ca ls Co s. I c v T a ee sCa .d Su .Co o
h ete n s o g t o e nr d c d' re n t n . . r v lr s r r . f
'
,
Amerc 56F. pp. 1 9,1 ( D.Fl.201 .Theef e,hei or tonco ane i t
ia, su 3d 25 272 S. a 4)
r or t nf mai nti d n he

me ito s mmay o Plitf sd co f rh sk e s r ey a oh rij re i rlv n a d
dain u r n anif o t r o i n e u g r nd t e nu is s ee a t n
notpr e t d.
ot c e

Furhe ,Loc Rul 1 2( r est ç-ralUpon Faiur t Sete'a rquiest ta1
t r al e 6. g) efr o s-i
l
l e o tl' nd e r ha 1
pr e ngsoft mediton fom t s m e ca e r m an c i nta a notbe us d t ora
oce di
he
a i r he a
s e i onfde il nd
e d ny
f
pum os a a a i s o a i ti t r t' How e r Loc Rul 1 2 doe notr l t t t us
e s n dm s i n ga ns n e es .
'
ve , al e 6.
s
e a e o he e
of m e a i pr e ngs i a t r c e. Se Car e Cons I ,5 F. pp. a 1 ,n.33.
di ton oce di
n no he as
e
ls
t, nc. 6 su 3d t 271
A ddii ly,none of t Ss tl e ofer'l te s s nt by W ilam Pr c P. .t Pr e s ve
tona l
he te tem nt f ' e t r e
li
i e, A o ogr s i

i c t t tt a e c i i li a wa
ndia e ha hey r onfdenta n ny y.
The e or i i he e O R D ER ED and AD JU D G ED :
r f e, t s r by

l No - ry,W il m W . ie P. ' Obe t nsa d M oin t Quah S b o na
. n pat li
a
Prc , A.S j ci n
o
t o s upe
o
Du e Te u ( 1 )i GRANTED I PART AND DENI I PART.
c s c m DE 5 s
N
ED N
Non- ry,W ila Prc ,P. ,m us pr e t doc nt asdes i a
pa t
lim i e A.
t oduc he ume s
crbed bove
t De e nt on or be o e A ugus 11, 201 N on- r y, W ila Prc P. .
o f nda
fr
t
7.
pa t
li m i e, A ,

s l be pe mit t r dac onl t i o ma i des rbe a
ha l
r ted o e t y he nf r ton
c i d bove fom t
r
he
doc e s
um nt .
3. A st t non- ry' r
o he
pa t s eque tf atom e s f es a cos s i pr pa i t M oton
s or t y' e nd t n e rng he
i
a pr viege l pur ua t Fe r lRul ofCi lPr e e 45, he Co tde e
nd i l
og s nt o de a
e
vi oc dur
t
ur ni s

t sr que t Puruan t Rul 45( ( ) C()pat or at ne r s i e f
hi e s. s t o e d)1, ça ry
tor y e ponsbl or
i s ng a s r ng a s
s ui nd e vi
ubpo
ena m us t ke r s bl s e t a d i posng
t a ea ona e t ps o voi m i

3

u d eb r n o e p ns o apes n s b e tt te s b o n . Th c u tf rt e
n u u de r x e e n ro u j c o h u p e a e o r o h
ditit whe e c
src
r ompla
ince i r quie m us e or e t s dut and i
s e rd
t nf c hi
y
mpos a
e n
a o it s ton whih m a i ude l te ni a r as bl a t ney'
ppr pra e anci c
y ncl os ar ngs nd e ona e tor s
f s
ee --on a pa t or a t e who f l t c pl ' I t s c e,Defnda
ry
tom y
ais o om y.
' n hi as
e nt

a tm pt t lmi t s
te ed o i t he ubpoe bot bef e t non- ry,W ila Prc P. .
na h or he
pa t
li m i e, A ,

tld iso j ci n a d dli te h aig. Th r f r ,te cru tn e d n t
ie t be to s n t ng h e rn
r
e eo e h ic msa c s o o
wa r nta a r ofator y' f es Se DHA Cor v Har y, 1 M C- 0201,
ra n wa d
t ne s e . e
p. . d No. 5- 8
i
ha
2 5 W L 3 0 3 8 * ( D. a Jme 1 , 01 ) Furt r t Courtfndst tan
01
7 7 7 , 3 S. Fl . t 5 2 5 . he , he

a r ofatr y' fe wo l b u j s.
wad tone s e s ud e n u t
The Clr i DI
e k s RECTED t ma la co oft sOr rt M i ha S.Her
o i
py hi de o c el
man,J . Es ,
r, q.
W ila W .Pr c P. . 521 Sout O lve Ave ,W es Pal Be ch,FL 33401 a t A lr do
li m
i e, A ,
h i
nue
t m
a
nd o f e

Cola 8 Roya Hi s usDrve,
ldo, 09
l bic
i Roya Pam Be h,FL 33411.
l l
ac
DO E and ORDERED i Cha be sa W es Pam Be c Pam Bea h Count Fl i
n
m r t
t l
a h, l
c
y, orda,
t s3
hi

a o- g s, 2017.
y t ut
Au
#

W I A M M A TTHEW M N
LLI
UN I
TED STATES M A G STM TE J D G E
U

4