Dude v. Congress Plaza, LLC et al

Filing 257

ORDER denying 256 Defendants' Joint Motion for Sanctions. Signed by Magistrate Judge William Matthewman on 8/23/2018. See attached document for full details. (kza)

UNI
TED STA TES D I
STRI C OU RT
CT
SO UTHERN D I
STRI OF FLOR I A
CT
D
Ci lN o.17-80522- V - ar a/ athewm an
vi
Cl M r M t

DI
ETM A R DU D E,

FI L
LED y

D.
C.

Pl ntf ,
ai if

AL6 2 3 2 1
28
VS.

CON G RESS PLA ZA ,LLC, ta .
e l,

s$arFbAl ps.
îEEauiDjO E
yEol U-J m:
vK .RM R
N
.

Def
endant
s.

ORDER DENYI DEFENDANTS'JO I M OTI FOR SANCTI
NG
NT
ON
ONS I 2561
DE
TH I CA U SE i be o e t Cour upon D ef nda s Davi M .G ol t i D a d M .
S
s f r he
t
e nt ,
d
ds e n, vi

Gol ti PA.Bar G.Roder n,Thoma Fars ,and Suza Fa e e' (d e nt' J nt
dsen, , ry
ma
s ee
nne r s s t nda s' oi
Def
)

M oton f Sanci (f oton' ( 2561 Thi mat wasr ere t t undesgne by
i or
tons s i ' DE
M
)
.
s ter
ef rd o he
ri d
U nied St t D it i t J
t
a es s rc udge Kenne h A . M a r Se DE 254. Pl i if D i t a D ude
t
r a.
e
a ntf , e m r

(ç ai if' hasfld ar pons ( 2521 a notmey rpl wasfld. TheMoton i now
d ntf ) ie es e DE
pl
, nd i l e y
ie
i s
rpe f r ew .
i or evi

D e e nt a e s e ng a a d of r as
f nda s r e ki n war
e onabl c t a a t ne s f es i r a a
e os s nd tor y' e ncured s

r ul ofPl ntf a o hi co elsvi ato ofRul 11 g 256,p.41 Dee nt ague
es t ai if nd/r s uns ' ol in
e . DE
. fnda s r
t t a c us of a ton f l d a ns t i vi
ha ny a e
c i ie gai t he ndi dual de e nt was d rvol r g f o t
f nda s
t i ous i ht r m he
f
s a t a had no ba i i f c ,l w or t a i a i of 1 w t t f t unde e t r Fl i
t r , nd
ss n a t a
he pplc ton
a o he ac s
r ihe orda

Stt e j 57.05 a orRul 11' 1 a p.7. I r pons ,Pli ifa g st tDee nt
aut
1 nd/
e .' d. t
n es e antf r ue ha fnda s
s d not ha fl t i M oton s nc he had tl d a M o i n t D i m i s t Ca e w ihout
houl
ve ied he r
i i e
ie
t o o s s he s
t

Prj c durng t s ehaborpei
eudie i he af r
rod. ( 252,pp.3- . Plitf addii lyase t t t
DE
51 anif tonal srs ha

hi a l ga i aga ns D e e nt i t Se nd A m e d Com pl ntw e e m a i good f ih
s le tons i t f nda s n he co
nde
ai
r
de n
at
a ba e on t i or a i t tPl ntf ha a t tm e 1 a pp.5- 0.
nd s d
he nf m ton ha ai if d t he i . d. t
1

Fe a Rul ofCi lPr e e 11c( sae t f l ng:
derl e
vi oc dur ()2) tts he olowi
A m oton f s nctons m us be m a s pa a e y f om a ot r m oton a m us
i or a i
t
de e r t l r
ny he
i nd
t

d ci t s cfc c uctt t al dl vi aes Rul 11b) The moton
es rbe he pe ii ond ha lege y olt
e (.
i

m us be s r e t de Rul 5,buti m us notbe fl d orbe pr e e t t cour
t
evd m r e
t
t
ie
es nt d o he
t
i t c le d pa ,cli ,def ns , c t nton,or de al i wihd a or
f he ha lnge
per am
e e on e i
ni s t r wn
a opra e y c r t w ihi 21 da es a tr s r i e or w ihi a he tm e t
ppr i t l or ec ed t n
t fe e v c
t n not r i he
c t s t . l war a e t cour m ay a a d t t pr va lng pa t t
our e s f
r nt d, he
t
w r o he e ii
ry he
r a ona e e ns ,i udi a t ney' f s i ur e f t m oton.
e s bl xpe es ncl ng tor s ee , nc r d or he
i

Fed. Ci P.11c ( .
R. v. ()2)
tI pa t s e ngRul 11s nci mus c ywiht pr e a r quieme s ( )
SAI ry e ki
e a tons t ompl t wo oc dur l e r nt: 1
t pa t m us fl a s pa a e m oto s ki t s nc i ns a des rbe t s c tc c
he r y
t ie e r t
i n ee ng he a to nd
c i he pe ii onduc
t

warntng snctonsa ( t pary mus s r et moton ont opposngpa t puruan t
ra i a i nd 2) he t
t e v he i
he
i ry s t o
Rul 5, but c nno fl t m oton wih t Cour untl a t r t of e ng pary ha bee
e
a t ie he
i
t he
t i fe he f ndi
t s
n
pr de w ih t e yovi d t w nt one da i w hi t c e t c le d f lng be vi .Thi s c
ys n
ch o ur he ha l nge ii / ha or
s e ond

rq ie n i c mmo l r fre t a te iaeh r o ' rq ie n. Ro s v De t o
e ur me t s o ny eerd o s h s f ab r e ur me t' s . p' f
'
Chidr No.3:3- 1185-- RK,201 W L 1
l en,
1 CVJ39J
4
2628541 a * ( . Fl M a 27,201 .
, t 2 M D. a. y
4)

Sf epur eofRul 11c ( ' s f har pr son i t alw a atr y whovi ae Rul
i'
-h
pos
e ()2)s ae bor ovii s o lo n tone
olts e

1 t c re tt alg d volto wihn t ny o d y wih u ben s b e tt sn to s'
1 o o rc he le e i ain ti we t- ne a s t o t ig u j c o a cin .
'
Pe rv fewi,606F. 1306,1 5(11hCi. 0)
e . s
3d
31 t r 201 .
The Cour has r vi w e t M oton a t e ie docke i t s c e. A ccor ng t
t
e e d he
i nd he ntr
t n hi as
di o
Pl ntf ,D e e nt 'c
ai if f nda s ouns s r d t J ntM o i f Sa tons upo Pl i ips co elo
el e ve he oi
ton or nc i
n a ntf
uns n

J y 1 201 vi e l ( 252,p.1 . The on J y 20,201 t unde sgned is d a
ul 0, 8, a mai. DE
1
n, ul
8, he
ri
s ue
Re ta Re om m e t o on t o ot m o i f r s nc i pr ous y fl by D e e nt
por nd c
nda i n
w
her tons o a tons evi l ied
f nda s

whih rc
c e omme d t alofPl ntf' cli be dimis wihoutprj c ( 2421
nde hat l
ai ifs ams
s sed t
eudie. DE
.
O n J y 23, 201 Pl i if f l d a M o i t D i m i s Cas Folow i Re t a
ul
8, a ntf ie
ton o
s s
e
l ng
por nd

Re mme ton a Se ve Rul 11 M oi g 2441 Pl ntf e ane t t he was
co ndai nd r d e
ton DE
. ai if xpli d ha

mo n t d s s t ec s wi o tp eu c wihn te21d y s f h r rp ro e tbih db
vig o imis h a e t u rj die ti h
h
a a e abo ei d sa l e y
s
Rul 11. 1 atp.2.
e
d.

Def nda s fr tfl d t i J ntM o i f Sa i on A ugus 2,201 Se DE 25
e nt is i e he r oi
ton or nctons
t
8. e
0.
The fl d t M oton a i on Augus 1 201 a t t Cour r
y ie he
i ga n
t 4, 8, fer he
t eque t a m or r a e
s ed
e e dabl
ve son oft doc en . Se D Es255,
ri
he um t
e
256.
The Cour tnds t t Pl i if c pled w ih Rul 11 when he r ques e t tt Se ond
ti
ha a ntf om i
t
e
e
t d ha he c

Ame d d Co an b d n e wih u p eu ie d rn te sf hab rp ro . S eRo is n
n e mplit e e id t o t rj dc u ig h ae r o ei d e bn o
v.Al i M ee LLC,643 F.Supp.2d 1
utq- l,
342,1 ( D.Fl 2009)(t s ehaborpr ecin
351 S. a.
$
The af r
ot to
ofRul 11 i a iabl t a ltga w ho S ihdr
e
s va l e o
ii nt
w t aws' t of endi pa r F. . .
he f ng pe . R C P.
The Rul does not a horze t m ova t pl ce co tons on t w ihd a a or r uie t
e
ut i he
nt o a
ndii
he t r w l
eq r he

wih rwa t bewi p eu ie i o d rfrt e n nmo a tt a od sncins'. He e te
tda l o
t rj d c , n r e o h o - v n o v i a to .)
h
'
r,h
s e ha borpe i w oul ha e ed on J y 31,201 a Pl ntf f l d hi M oton t D i m i s
af r
rod
d ve nd
ul
8, nd ai i f ie s
i o s s

CaeFolowi Re ta Re
s l ng por nd commendai a Se ve Rul 11Moton ( 2441o J y 23,
ton nd r d e
i DE
n ul
201 Pl i if efec i l w ihdr w t of e ng pl adi
8. a ntf f tve y t e he f ndi
e ng. D e enda s s d ha ne r
f
nt houl ve ve
fl t rM oton w ih t Courtbased on t e f s.
ied hei
i
t he
hes act
D ef
endant t y t m ake an argum ent i t r M oton t t have al pr ousl t ed
sr o
n hei
i hat hey
so evi y il

m otons r que tng Rul 11 s nc i . H o e r t pror r que t f Rul 1l s nc i we e
i
e si
e
a tons
w ve , he i e s s or e
a tons r
m a i m otons t di m i s a not m a s r t l f om a ot r m o i
de n
i
o s s - nd
de epa a e y r
ny he
ton- a do no
nd
t
appear t have been pr
o
eceded by t saf harbor coaes
he e
pondence t Pl ntf s couns , as
o ai i f
el

r quied by t Rul The ef e D e e nt 'pr orr ques s f R ul 11 s tonsw e e i ld.
e r
he e.
r or , f nda s i e
t or e
anc i
r nva i
Bas on t f e ng,t Cour O RD ER S t tD e e nt 'J ntM o i f Sa to
ed
he or goi he
t
ha f nda s oi
ton or nc i ns

( 2561beDENI
DE
ED.

J
DONE a ORDERED i Ch mbes t s4 3 d y o Au u t 01 ,a W et P l
nd
n a r hi
a f g s,2 8 t s am

Be c Pal Bea h Count i t Sout r D it i tofFl i
a h, m
c
y n he
he n s rc
orda.

X - .
W I A M M A TTH E M A N
LLI
UN I
TED STA TES M A G I
STRATE JUD G E