Ibezim v. The GEO Group, Inc.

Filing 54

ORDER denying [DEs 49 and 50] Plaintiff's Motion to Reconsider. Signed by Magistrate Judge William Matthewman on 12/27/2018. See attached document for full details. (kza)

UN I
TED STA TES D I
STRI CO UR T
CT
SOU THERN D I
STRI OF FLOR I A
CT
D
CA SE N O .17- 80572- A RRA/ A TTH EW M AN
cvM
M
M I A EL I
CH
BEZI ,
M

FI ED hy
L

Pl ntf
ai if,

..

D 2 21
E2
28
7J'-Fb.-w.l.
) '- ? Rr.
& 7: ltE
%' :
ï3
sD. . oh l

GEO GR OU P,I C .
N ,
D ef
endant.

O RDER DENYI PLAI FF' M OTI TO RECONSI
NG
NTI S
ON
DER I
DES49.501

THI CAUSE i beor t Cotr uponPli if M iha I zi s(k ai if' M oton
S
s f e he lt
antf, c el be m' l ntf ) i
pl
t Rec i rOr rGr ntng A TD M e a i n & Ar t a i P. .S M o i t Com pelPl i if s
o
ons de de a i
di t o
bir ton A '
ton o
a ntf

Pa ntofM editon Feea f Fee a Coss(é oton' g 49,50j Thi malrwa
yme
ai
nd or s nd t t i ' DES
M
)
. s te s
r e r d t t unde sgne by Unie Stt s Diti J
efr e o he
ri d
t d a e srct udge Ke h A.M a r See DE 45.
nnet
ra.
Pl i i fs eksr ons de a i oft Cour ' pr orOr rG r ntng A TD M e a i n & A r ta i
a ntf e
ec i r ton he
ts i
de a i
di to
bir ton

P. ' Motont Compe Pli ifsPa ntofM e ain Fe a f Fee a Cossg 48 ,
A.S i o
l antf' yme
dito e nd or s nd t DE 1
da e D e m be 6,201 N on- r y,A TD M edi ton & Ar t a i P. .has f l d a r s ns
t d ce r
8.
pa t
ai
bir ton A
ie
e po e

( 521 a Pli ifha fldarpl g 531 Thematri no rpef rviw.
DE , nd antf s ie e y DE .
te s w i or e e
1
.

BA C K G R O UN D

The r l nt f ct of t c s a e as f l s On J
e eva a s
he a e r
olow .
une 1 201 t Cour e e e a
5, 7, he
t nt r d
i
ect
a
Sc
hedulng Or ra Or rReerng Cas t M e ai r 1 . The partes sel ed Laur
i
de nd de fri
e o diton DE 0J
Bonn,Esq. ofA TD t m edi e t s m ateron M ay 29,2018. See D E 31. The m edi i w as
,
o
at hi
t
aton
com pl ed on M ay 29,2018. See D E 32. ATD pr ed m edi i bil f bot Pl ntf s
et
epar
aton ls or h ai if

a De e nts c e . See DE 44- . Eac pa t was c ge $675.
nd f nda ' ouns l
1
h ry
har d
00. 1 Acc di
d.
or ng
1

t A TD ,D e e ntpai is pori oft m edi ton bil butPl i if di no pa hi pori of
o
f nda
d t
ton
he
ai
l,
a ntf d t y s ton

t me ai bil g 44,p. . ATD ma s ve atmpt t c lc on t unpadi c
he diton l. DE
2)
de e n te s o ole t he
i nvoie.
1
d.

ATD wasf c d t r ti c ns t puruecole tonoft unpad bil ( 44,p. .
ore o ean ou el o s
lci
he
i l. DE
2j
A TD ' c
S ouns ls ntPl i if s c
e e
a ntf ouns le ai c r ponde e on O c obe 30,201 a sng t t
e m l or es
nc
t r
8, dvi i ha ,
i paym entw asrecei by N ovem ber 5,2018,A TD ' counselw oul w ai hi ator s f
f
ved
S
d
ve s t ney' ees.

1 Pl n if s c
d. ai t f' ouns ldi notr pond t t e a lc r pondenc l
e d
es
o he m i or es
e. d
A TD ' notc of m edi ton s a e t t i a di put a i es be wee t pa te ove t
S ie
a i t t s ha , f
s e rs
t n he r i s r he

me at ' f es t m e aori e il d t r c r fom t pa te ,a t i c
di ors e , he dit s ntte o e ove r he ri s nd her ouns la l w
e nd a

fnn, on l a d s v r l hi o h rfe a t eh u l r t o $ 0 g 4 p 2 3 . Th
i j ity n e eal s r e e s t h o ry ae f 4 0. DE 4, p. - 1
y,
e
a e m e f t rpr des f ra 1 pe a m i e e tr t f a i i e t ti m or t n 1
gr e nt urhe ovi
O
2% r nnu nt r s a e or ny nvo c ha s
e ha 0
days over
due. 1 atp.3.
d.

O n N ove be l 201 A TD fl d a M o i t Com pe Pl i if s Pa entofM e aton
m r 4, 8,
ie
ton o
l a ntf ' ym
di i

Fe a frFee i Coss g 444 s e ng a a r of$675 f t unpai mediton fe,
e nd o
s n t DE , e ki n wad
or he
d
ai e
a tona i e e ti t amountof$37. a $2,40 i atom ey' f es ATD fld ismoton
ddii l ntr s n he
73, nd 0 n t
se .
ie t
i

tc
o ompelwiht sCour puruantt Loca Rul 1 2()7 . I atp.4. Ther s ns t t
t hi
t s
o
l e 6. b () d
epo e o he
m oton w a due o N ovem be 28,2018. W he no r s
i
s
n
r
n
e pons w a tm el f l d,t Cour e e ed
e s i y ie he
t nt r
a Or ron D e m be 6,201 gr ntng A TD ' m o i t c pela r quii Pl i t f a o
n de
ce r
8, a i
S ton o om
nd e r ng a n if nd/ r

Pl ntf' c e t pa ATD $2, 83 on or b or De ember21 2018. ( 48,p.3)
ai ifs ouns l o y
757.
ef e c
,
DE
.

Thi a
s mounti l Pli ifspori oft mediton bil( ) $ 83 i i ees,a
ncuded antf' ton he
ai l $675 , 42. n ntr t nd
$2, i at me s f s 1 The Coul s ci ly f
040 n tol y' ee . d.
' pe sca l ound i t Or r t tt al
t
n he de ha he tonwy'
s
f e r ue t d w e e r a ona e and t tA TD was e il d t a 1of t r le s
e s eq s e
r e s bl
ha
ntte o l
he e i f ought 1 a pp.
. d. t
23.
2

A . Pl nt f M oton f R econsi
ai i ps
i or
derati
on

On De e r 1 201 Pl ntf fld hi M oi f Rec i r ton ( 49,50 .
c mbe 2, 8, ai if ie s ton or onsde ai DES
1
Pl n if tr t e ai t thi c
ai tf i s xpl ns ha s ouns lpr ry fl d a N o i e of Una ia lt f om N ove be
e ope l ie
tc
va l biiy r
m r
9,201 ,t Novem be 26,201 w ih t El vent Cicui,butt tc
8 o
r
8, t he e h r t
ha ouns ldi notbe i ve i was
e d
le t
nec s al t fl t N otc ofU na l biiy i t s cou ta w el s nce no hi w a pe ng i
e s ' o ie he
y
ie
vaia lt n hi
r s li
t ng s ndi n
t case. 1d.atp.1. Pl ntf f t expl ns t hi couns w as i N i i f om N ovem ber
he
ai i f urher
ai hat s
el
n gera r

1 201 t oug N ove be 24,20l a t ti ht ii r r i a t he t t M oton. 1 a
2, 8, hr h
m r
8, nd he l g tne a y s tac d o he
i
d. t
pp. l 2. Pl ntf c ends t t hi c
ai i f ont
ha s ouns of e ed t pa Pl i tf s por i of t m e aton
el f r o y a n ip
ton
he di i
bil i m e a el afe t m e a i n,but w a t d t t bil woul b m a l d. I a p.2.
l m di t y t r he di to
s ol hat he l
d e ie
d t

Pli ifc de t hi at ne owesATD $71 7 (heme ai f spl i ees) a wel
antf once s hat s tor y
2.3 t
diton ee us ntr t, s l
a r as na e a t m ey' f es but Pl ntf a gues t t t a t ney' f es cl m ed by A TD a e
s e o bl t o
s e ,
ai if r
ha he tor s e
ai
r

e s i be aus ATD' couns lt d nots nd fve hour on t sc e.' I
xce sve c e
S
e l
di
pe i
s hi as ' d

Pl ntf cai
ai if l ms

t tA TD ' co e onl co m uni a ed onc wih Pl i if s c
ha
S uns l y m
ct
e t a ntf ouns l 1
e . d.
B . A TD ' R esponse
S

l r pons ,A TD fr ta gue t Pl ntf ha notpr de any bas sf r c i r i n
n es
e
i s r s hat ai i f s
ovi d
i or e ons de ato

oft Cour' Or . g 52,pp.3- . ATD ne aguest tPl ntf hasf ldt c lnge
he
ts der DE
51
xt r
ha ai if aie o hale
a of t s cii tm e e res s it d by is c
ny
he pe fc i
nt i ubm te
t ouns l 1 a pp.5- ATD c e t t
e . d. t
6.
ont nds ha

Pli ifsM oton fist c y wih Loc Ruls 7.()1 a 7.()3 i t ti doe no
antf
i al o ompl t
al e 1a( ) nd 1a( ) n ha t s t
i ude a m e or ndum ofl w a Pl ntf f ie t c e w ih t oppos ng pa t pr ort t
ncl
m a
a nd ai if a l d o onf r t he
i
r y i o he
f lng oft M oton. 1 a p. A TD a tonaly a s r st te h ofPl ntf s a gum en s i
ii
he
i
d. t 6.
ddii l s e t ha ac
ai if r
t n
f vor of r c i r ton i wihout m e i. 1 a pp. 1- Fi l A TD s e a addii na
a
e onsde a i s t
rt d. t
3. naly,
e ks n
to l

$1200 i at r sf si ure i flng isr po et t M oton. 1 a p.
, n to ney' ee nc r d n ii t es ns o he
i
d. t 7.

3

C . Pl ntf R epl
ai ips
v

l r y,Pli if a n e
n epl a ntf gai mpha ies t the agr est the i r s i e f $71 73 i
sz ha
e ha
s e ponsbl or 2. n

me ai cossa i ees. g 53,p.1. Pli ifonl tkesis wih t f scai d
diton t nd ntr t DE
1 antf y a sues t he ee l me
by ATD ' c
S ouns l
e.

Pl ntf argues t A TD ' counselcl m s t have spentt o hour on
ai if
hat
S
ai o
w
s

r s rhi c e lw a a rt of$400perhou,a t Cg nyr s bl mi c n clal s e
eeac ng as a t ae
r nd hat cal eaona e nd a e ry e
f r hundr d dola s pe hot i e e s ve f r a a t ne t c r f r r s a c ng c s l
ou
e
l r r l s xc s i o n tor y o ha ge o e e r hi a e aws
r

gi) M e aorsAtome haso y be prci ng f 11 ye r whi make hi r ues f
sc . dit ' t y
nl en a tci or
as ch
s s eq t or
400 dola spe hourf doi r s a ch unr as bl ' I a pp. - Pl ntf ne a gue t t
lr r
or ng e e r
e ona e. d. t 1 2. ai i f xt r s ha
'
hi couns onl r ved t o em ais f om A TD i t l tsi m ont and t one em ai ar i
s
el y ecei
w
l r
n he as x
hs
hat
l rved

w hie Pl ntf c
l ai ips ouns lw as outof t cou r I a p.2. Fi l Pl ntf a i cont nds
e
he nty. d t
naly, ai if ga n
e
t t hi c ns l ha no tm e t co er on t m a t be aus c
ha s ou e d
i o nf
he ter c e ouns was i N i r a a t
el
n ge i nd hat

co elpr pe l tl d aNotc ofUna ia lt wih t Elve h Cicui. 1
uns o ry ie
ie
val biiy t he e nt r t d.
1
I.

AN A LY SIS

I or t pr lon a m oton f r
n der o evai
i or econs der i t m ovi part Sm ustdem ons r e
i aton, he
ng
y l
t at

why t cou t s d r ons de is pr or dec s o and s t f t f ct or 1 w of a sr ng y
he
r houl ec i r t i
ii n
e orh a s
a
to l
c nci
onvi ng

na ur
t e

i e
nduc

t
he

c t
our

t
o

r re
eve s

is
t

pr or
i

de s on.
cii

A m oton f r ons de a i s d r s new i s s not m e e y a e s i s es ltga e
i or ec i r ton houl ai e
s ue ,
r l ddr s s u
ii t d

prvi l ' I ttt de Pr ii M iiar v Leh Br .485 F. zd 1
e ousy.' nsiuo
evson lt . man os,
supp. 340,1 43 ( D.
3 S.
Fl 2007)( i Soci itWor e s'tz. v.fe y,957F.
a.
quotng als
k r z'
/
p
'
ah
supp.1
262,1 ( D. a 1 :.
263 S. Fl. 997
Thetr egoundswar ntngrconsdeai t tc t ha a tc ae ae:( )a i e ve ng
he r
ra i e i rton ha ours ve riultd r 1 n ntr ni
c ngei c r lng lw;( t a lbiiy ofne e de o ( t ne d t c r tcla
ha n ontoli a 2) he vaia lt
w vi nce; r 3) he e o orec e r

er orma f tij tc I ,s ealo Dude v Cong.Pl a,LLC,No.1 80522- V,201
ror
nies nusie. d ' e s
.
az
7C1
8
W L 2291 a *1( D.Fl.M ay 1 201 ,r co i r i de e No.1 8052 C1 201
308, t S. a
8, 8) e nsdeaton niJ
7- 2- V, 8
4

W L 343 4( D.Fl.J y 1 201 .
271 S. a ul 6, 8)
H e e,t e i cl a l no c nge i contoli l w ,a t Pl ntf ha notes a i he
r her s e r y
ha
n
r lng a nd he ai i f s
t bls d

ce rer ro ma ie tij tc o s o t ea alb l yo n w e ie et a wo l i a ywa
la ro r nf s nusie r h wn h v ia ii f e vd nc h t ud n n y
t
i pactt Courts pri O r
m
he
' or der. l hi M oton,Pl ntf t s r i on t f t he fl a
n s
i
ai if ir t eles
he act hat
ied

N otc of Una ia lt a a bas s f r r c i r ton. H ow e r he tl d t N otc i t
ie
va l biiy s
i o e ons de a i
ve ,
i e he
i e n he
El ve h Cic t noti t sD i ti t M or ove , otce ofU na ia lt ha no ef e ti t s
e nt r ui,
n hi sr c .
e rN i s
va l biiy ve
f c n hi
D it i tand a e notpr vi d f i t Loca Rul s
sr c
r
o de or n he
l e.
Pl ntf has addii na l a t he t t M o i a ti ii r r es a ihi t t hi
ai i f
t o ly tac d o he ton l ght tne a y t bls ng ha s
counsel w as out of t count y f om N ovem ber 12, 2018, t ough N ovem ber 24, 2018.
he
r r
hr

Howe r t r pons t ATD' Moton t Compe ( 44Jwa due o No mbe 28,201
ve , he es e o
S i o
l DE
s
n ve r
8.
Fu t r t Co ts Or r g a i A TD ' m o i t c pelw as note er d un i D e em be 6,
r he , he ur ' de r ntng
S ton o om
nt e t l c
r

201 ( 48 . Pl ntf' c e t rf e silhadtmet r pond t t moton,ors e
8. DE 1
ai ifs ouns l heeor tl
i o es
o he i
ek
a extnson,a trher t ne t t Unie Stt s
n e i fe
e ur d o he t d a e .
Fi l i A TD ' m oton t com pe ,ATD e a ne t t i t i t co ac Pl n i fon
naly, n
S
i o
l
xpl i d ha t red o nt t ai tf

s en o a i t pa t outtndi me ai i ce ( 44,p.2J Pl ntf hasnot
ev cc sons o y he sa ng diton nvoi . DE
. ai if
di put d t t t e a t m pt t colec oc ur e
s e ha hes te s o
l t c r d. The e i s m pl no e us f Pl i if
r s i y
xc e or a ntf

i i ATD nume o tm e on am at rhe c d ha e iy r ol d by c a tng ATD and
gnorng
r us i s
te
oul ve asl es ve
ontc i
pa ng t a o d
yi he m unt ue. Pl i i f a s a kno l dges t t hi c
a ntf l o c w e
ha s ouns l r e ve a em ai f o
e ec i d n
l rm

ATD' c e beor Pli ifsc e l tf Ni i g 53,p.21 Howe ,Pli if
S ounsl f e antf ounsl ef or gera. DE
.
ver antf
has notpr vi d a ex a ton f r w hy hi couns di no r pond t s i e a l Pl i if
o de ny pl na i o
s
el d t es
o a d m i . a ntf
s e s t a g t t be a e he ofer d t pa t m edi t on t da of t m e a i he
e m o r ue ha , c us
f e o y he
a or
he y
he di ton,
s d notbe puni he f notpa ng t m e a i bill t ron. Thi a gum e i no e i l
houl
s d or
yi he di ton l a e
s r
nt s ns nsca .
The Cour di not onl gr A TD ' m oton t com pelon t basi t Pl ntf f l t t e a
t d
y ant
S
i o
he
s hat ai if aied o il
5

rs
e pons t t m o i buta s on t m e is oft m oton t c pelis f Se DE 48,p.3.
e o he ton,
lo
he r t
he
i o om
t el. e
Pl i tf ha not i a w ay es a i hed t t t f c s underyi t m oton t c pelha
a n if s
n ny
t bls
ha he a t
l ng he
i o om
ve
changed. l f ,i i cl t t Cour t bot Pl ntf and Pl ntf s couns , Em elke
n act t s ear o he
t hat h ai if
ai if'
el
i
N w os
uocha,Esq. have been diat evasve,and uncooper i r di Pl ntf ' oblgaton
,
l ory,
i
atve egar ng ai if s i i

t pa t m e a i f esand c t .
o y he di ton e
os s
Pl i if f t r di put s t f c t A TD ' c
a ntf ur he s e he a t hat
S ouns l s nt fve hour on t c l cton
e pe i
s
he ole i

matr
te.

g 49, p. 21 Pli if smpl c e t t S e aors Ator y onl
DE
. antf i y ontnds ha t dit ' t ne
M
y

c m uni a e onc w ih Pl i if s Ator y. Thi s s M e a or s A tor y di not s nd
om
c td
e t a ntf
t ne
s how
di t ' t ne d
pe
fve hotr as cl i e on t s ca e. 1 H oweve ,Pl ntf pr des no s ppor w ha s ve
i
ls
am d
hi s '
' d.
r ai if ovi
u
t
t oe r
f hi a gum e t t tm e bil d w as unr as bl The Cour pr vi l f
or s r
nt hat he i
le
e ona e.
t e ousy ound t t t
ha he
fve hour c a m e f r vi ng t flng a doc t d afi e ai c r ponde e t
i
s l i d or e ewi he ii
nd
ke , r tng m l or es
nc o
Pl i if s co e r ga di s tl m e of t out t ndi bil d a tng t m oto t c pel
a ntf
uns l e r ng e te nt he s a ng l, r fi he
i n o om ,

r e c ng c elw,a drfi t pr e or wasra ona e. g 48,p.2,n.1. l
esarhi as a nd a tng he opos d der
e s bl DE
1 n

h srpl,Plitf as o j cst ATD' c u s lsh u l rt o $ 0 Ho v r tepat s
i e y an if lo be t o
S o n e' o ry ae f 4 0. we e , h ri
e
ha pr vi l a ee t a houry r t of $
d e ousy gr d o n
l ae
400 i a di pu e a os ove t medit ' f e
f
s t r e r he
a ors e
r quii t medit t fl c tpape s Se DE 31 p.2. The Cour a s fnds s ch a
e rng he
a or o ie our
r. e
,
t lo i
u n
houry r t t be r as na e i t s c e. I s ,Pl ntf ha not pr de a ba i f t
l ae o
e o bl n hi as
n um ai i f s
ovi d ny s s or he
Cour t r
t o econsi t ator s f
der he t ney' ees.

The Cour fnds t tPl n ifs M oton i d t be d ed on t m e is The Cou t
ti
ha aitf '
i s ue o
eni
he rt .
r
ad to ly de e Pl i ips M oton due t Pl n if s vi a i of t Loca Rul .
dii na l
ni s a ntf
i
o ai tf '
ol ton
he
l
es
Spe i i aly,t Cour not t t Pl i if f ie t co er w ih A TD bef e f lng hi M o i
c fc l he
t es ha a ntf a l d o nf
t
or ii
s ton.

Fal e
iur

c tf c era unde Loc Rul 7.( (
eriy onf r l
r
al e 1a)3)

gr
ounds fr de al
o
ni

a

moton. SeeL. 7.()3 (l iuet c ywih t rquieme soft sLoc Rul maybe
i
R. 1a( ) s lr o ompl t he e r nt hi al e
Fa
6

cause f t Courtt gr or deny t m oton and i pose on counselan appr i e s i
or he
o ant
he
i
m
opr at ancton,

w hi m a i ude a or r t pa t a ot of t r as
ch y ncl
n de o y he m mt he e onabl e ns i ur e bec us of
e xpe es nc r d
a e

t vi ai i l ng a ra ona e at ne s f ' 's e alo l do v Ro Car i an
he olton, ncudi
e s bl tor y' ee.) e s ncar ne . yal rbe
',
Cr s s Lt No.1 209 C1 201 W L 65 4,a * ( D.Fl.De 11 201 .
uie, d,
6- 24- V, 8
2093 t 4 S. a c. , 8)
The fna i s f t Cou ts co i r tc i whet r A D T i e il d t a addii l
i l s ue or he
r ' ns de a im s
he
s ntte o n
tona

$1200 i at ney' f es i ured r s a c ng c e lw a dr tng a r pons t Pl i ifs
,
n tor s e nc r e e r hi as a nd afi
es e o antf '

M o in Att i j n tle te Co r wiln ta r t e e a dto a atnwy' fe t ATD.
to .
hs u ct , h u t l o wa d h s d iin l to s e s o
r
Ho ver t Cour r s vesj iditon on t sis a wilrconsde a r ng a tona
we , he
t eer urs ci
hi sue nd l e i r wadi ddii l
a t r y' f s i Pl i iff l t abi by t s Or r
to ne s ee f a ntf ais o de hi de .
11
1.

CO N CLU SI N
O

l lg oft f egoi i i he e O RD ER ED A N D A D JU D G ED a f l s
n i ht he or ng, t s r by
s olow :

Pli ifsMoton ( 49,50ji DENI
antf'
i DES
s
ED.
TheCour' Dec mbe 7,201 Or rg 481rmansi f lf c a efec.
ts e r
8 de DE
e i n ul ore nd f t
3. Pl i if M i ha l I i and Pl i if s couns Em elke N w os ha,Es a t
a ntf
c e bez m
a ntf
el
i
uoc
q. nd he

lw fr of Emelke Nwos ha,P. ae j nl a s vealy la e t ATD
a im
i
uoc
A, r oity nd e r l ibl o
M e ai n & Ar taton P. i t a
di to
bir i A. n he mountof$ 757.
2, 83.
4. Ful pay e s lbem a t DanilT.Fed P. .Cle Tr tAc nton Orbe or
l m nt hal
de o
e
l A int us cou
f e
January 14,2019.

5. l Pl ntf a or Pl i if' c
f ai i f nd/
a ntf s ouns l f l t m a paym e i f l by Januar 1
e ai o ke
nt n ul
y 4,

201 ATD may fl amoi f e r ofj
9,
ie
ton or nty udgmen ag ns Pl ntf a Pli ifs
t ai t ai if nd antf'
counseland/ f any f herr i
or or
urt elef
6. PLA INTIFF AN D PLA IN TI S C O UN SEL AR E H EREB Y A D VISED TH A T,
FF'

7

I TH EY FA I TO FULL Y CO M PLY W I
F
L
TH TH I O R DER AN D FA I TO
S
L
PA Y TH E M ED I TI N C O STS A ND A TTO R N EY ' FEES A S O R D ERED
A O
S
BY TH I CO UR T, A JUD G M EN T M A Y BE EN TER ED A G A I
S
NST
PLA I I AN D PLA I TI S C O U N SEL, C O N TEM PT PR O CEEDI G S
NT FF
N FF'
N
M AY

BE

IN STITU TED

A G AIN ST

PLA INTIFF

AND

PLA I TIFF'
N
S

CO UN SEL, A ND PLA I TI
N FF A ND PLA I FF' C O UN SEL M A Y BE
NTI S
FO UN D I C O NTEM PT O F C O UR T.
N

A DD ITIO N ALL Y, FU RT H ER

SAN C TI NS M A Y BE IM PO SED UPO N PLAIN TIFF AN D PLA IN TIFF'
O
S

C O U N SEL,I C LUD I BU T N O T LI I
N
NG
M TED TO A FU R TH ER A W A R D O F
CO STS A N D AT TO RN EY ' FEE S.
S

The Cour rs r esj iditon t deemi f s a c t expe
t e e v urs ci o tr ne ee nd oss
nded by ATD a
s
noe a
td boveand a t c lci oft a
s o ole ton he mountdue a coleci ofanyj
nd l ton
udgme t
n
whi m ay be ent ed.
ch
er

8. The Cl r of Coul i D I
ek
' s RECTED t m a l a copy of t s Or r t D a el T.Fe d,
t
o i
hi de o ni
l
Es ,D a elT. l P. . 2847 H olyw ood Bl , olywood,Fl i 33020.
q. ni
Fe d, A ,
l
vd. H l
orda
D O N E A ND O RD ER ED i Cha be s a W e t Pal B e c Pa m Be h Co y,
n
m r t s
m
a h, l
ac
unt

a foe e r 8.
Fl i t s lfd yo- cmbe, 201
orda, hi
W I AM M A TH EW M A N
LLI
Unied St t M a s r t J
t
a es gi t a e udge

8