Kadiyala et al v. Pupke et al

Filing 153

ORDER ON ACCOUNTANT-CLIENT PRIVILEGE FRAUD EXCEPTION AFTER IN CAMERA REVIEW OF DOCUMENTS. Signed by Magistrate Judge William Matthewman on 9/9/2019. See attached document for full details. (kza)

UN I
TED STA TES D I
STRI COU RT
CT
SOU TH ERN D I I O F FLO RI
STR CT
DA
Ci l o.1 80732- V - a r / a t
vi N
7Cl M r a M thewm a
n
RAV IK AD I LA ,i vi ly,a ast
YA
ndi dua l nd he
as gnee ofCRED I UN I M ORTGA GE
si
T
ON
U TI TY BAN C,l C. an llnoi cor ,
LI
N , li s p.

FI
LED BY

Pl i if
antf,

D.
C,

S 29 2 1
EF
29

VS.

ANGEL E.
A NOBL
E
CL
ERK U S DI CX
SX

M ARK JOHN PU PK E,etal,
.

s D oF/ A. w. .
. . L - RB

Def nda s
e nt .
/

O RD ER O N A C CO UN TA NT- LI T PR I LEG E FR AU D EX C EPT I N A FTER J
C EN
VI
O
N
CA M ERA R EVIEW O F D O CU M EN TS
TH I CA U SE w a pr vi l be or t Cour upon t Pa tes J ntM oton A s ng t
S
s e ous y f e he
t
he r i ' oi
i
ki he
Cour t Te t Thr
t o s , ough l Cam e a Re ew , t Cl i s of Prvieg A s e t d A ga ns t
n
r
vi
he a m
i l e s re
i t he

Pr d ci no Ce ti Do u n sg 1 0 . i matrwa rfre t t u desg e b Un td
o u to f ran c me t DE 5 ) Th s te s eer d o he n ri n d y ie
Stt sDititJ
a e src udgeKe t A.M ara. eDE 359.On Se e be 5,201 t Co te er d a
nne h
r Se
ptm r
9, he ur nt e

Pa e ls Or e g a tn temoin rq e tn i c me a rve ( 1 2 . fn a t,M ak
p re s d r rn ig h to e u sig n a r e iw. DE 5 1 Dee d n s r
J Pupkea M ai MolyPupke(r ee nt' s te vi t
ohn
nd re l
s fnda s' ubmitd, a humbcrvea vi emalt
)
li nd a i,he
docum e st t unde s gne s c m be s a r qui e
nt o he
r i d' ha r s e r d.
BAC K G R O UN D

On or a
bout J 21 201 Pl ntf,Ra Ka yaa Cé antf ',s ve a f me
une , 9, ai if vi di l pli if) er d or r
def
endanti t s acton,J P.M il , wihas poe duce tc ( 1 p.1. rafe,
n hi i ohn
lerl t ub na
s e um.DE 50, 1Thee tr
lJ P. M ilra J P. il CPA , A .wer f meryde e nt i t sc e. owe , N o ieofSete e
ohn
le nd ohn M ler
P. , e or l f nda s n hi as H
ver a tc
tlm nt

Dee nsfld aM oi f Pr e tveOr rg 1261 TheCour hel ahe rngont ma tr
fnda t ie
ton or otci de DE
.
t d ai
he te
on J y 25,201 O n J y 26,201 t Cour e er d a O r rw hi h,i r e ntpa t g a e i
ul
9.
ul
9, he
t nt e n de
c n el va
r , r nt d n

pata de e i pa tt M otonfrPr e tveOr r ( 1 1.I t Or ,t Cou tlmied
r nd nid n r he i o otci de .DE 4 ) n he der he r i t
t s ope oft s
he c
he ubpoe a r qui e t tcouns lf bot pa te a c
na nd e r d ha
e or h r i s nd ouns l f r M r M il r
e o
. le
t onf r a a r nge a pr ce e t t pe m is D ef nda s c
' e nd r a
c
o dur ha
r t
e nt ' ouns l t de er i on a
e o t m ne
pr - oduc i n ba i whe he a of t doc e s a e prviege ' I a p.3.The Cour a s
e pr
to
ss
t r ny
he um nt r i l d. d. t
'
t lo

sae t ttll Defnda sha ag f t beleft ta oft doc nt aeprvieg d,he
ttd ha sif e nt ve ood-aih i ha ny he ume s r i l e t y
s lc e e a prvie l i c planc w ih t Loc lR ul s l t pa te ca m otr ol t
hal r at
i l ge og n om i e t he
a
e . f he r i s l
es ve he

ma tr t c n brng t is t t Cour f r ol ton. I
te ,hey a i he s ue o he
t or es u i ' d
'

Thepa te confre a deemi d apr edur f pr tonoft doc nt.(
ris erd nd tr ne
oc e or oduci
he ume s DE
1 p.21 Afe Dee t couns r viwe t docume s c ms pr e t r ponsve
50, . tr fndans'
el e e d he
nt, ot el oduc d he es i
docume st Pli ifsc el aongwih aprvie l 1 De e nt wihhed 1 pa so
nt o antf ouns , l
t
i lge og. d. f nda s t l 09 ge f
docu e s o t ba i ofa ount ntc i ntprvieg I O n A ugus 1 2019,D e e nt a s
m nt n he s s
cc a - le
i l e. d
t 8,
f nda s l o

pr edt Pli ifscouns llmie I ttQuikbooksrporst tweec e tdbyDee nt'
oduc o antf'
e i td ntl c
i
e t ha r r ae
fnda s
c el Dee nt'c ns d not howe r pr
ouns ; fnda s ou eldi
,
ve , oduce t a t l t eda td Quikbooks
he cua, mr ce
c
r t 1d.atp.3.
epor s.

l t Pa te 'moto r que tng i c r r e Pl ntf a gue t She e i no ba i
n he ri s
i n e si n ame a eviw, ai if r s hat s r s
t
ss
he e f D e e nt t w ihhol a doc e orf l t tM r M il rha pr
r or f nda s o t d ny um nt ie ha
. le s oduc d i r s
e n e pons t
eo
Pl i if s Su
a ntf ' bpoe upon a c ai t ti i pr ec ed f om di c os e t Pl ntf K a ya a by t
na
l m ha t s ot t r
s l ur o ai i f di l
he

a ou a -le prvie 'g 1 p. . or ngt Pl ntflt ac ou a -le prvie
cc ntntcint i lge. DE 50, 3JAcc di o ai it he c ntntcint i lge
'

b t e Panifa dteMilrDee d nswa fldo Ma 1 , 01 .DE 1 1. eehe, nM a l , 01
ewe n litf n h l fn a t s i n y 0 2 9 ( 1 )Th ra ro y 6 2 9,
e
e
Plitf fldaS iulto fr d r f s sa wi Prj dc a t teMie Dee d ns( 1 4 . eCo rte
anif i
e tp ain o Ore o Dimisl t eu ie s o h l r fn a t DE 1 )Th uth n
h
l
e trda Ore o Dimis l st teMilrDee da t o Ma 31201 ( 1 6.
nee n d r f s sa a o h l fn ns n y , 9 DE 1 )
e

doe not a y be us S a ntf i e
s
ppl ca e t i if nt nds t us t s m a e i t s
pl
o e hi
t ral o how t t D e e n s w e e
ha
f nda t
r
i ve i a f a ' 1
nvol d n r ud. d.
'
Def nda s on t ot erha cont nd t tt m a e i l i t prvie 1 a e pr ry
e nt , he h
nd, e ha he t r a s n he i l ge og r ope l
w ihhel a prvie be us t doc e s w oul ne rha be n di cl e t t r pari ,
t d nd i l ged ca e he um nt
d ve ve e s os d o hid tes

a Dee t t ac ountntscint do notwih t wavet prvieg g 1 p.4)
nd fndans he c a ' le s
s o i he i l e. DE 50, .
W ihrgadt t . ( c
t e r o he qbb Quikbooks fl Defnda a srst tthi doc ti s ca i t t
) ie, e nt se t ha s s umen s pe iln ha
t
ac e sw a o y pr vi d t t M il D e enda s i a ad s r r e a t fl is l w a ne r
c s s nl o de o he ler f
nt n n vi o y ol nd he ie t e f s ve
i e d t be di c os t t r pa te .Furhe m or , gi n t na ur of t f l i pos a
nt nde o
s l ed o hi d r i s
t r e ve he t e
he ie, t es n
ad tonale de i r c e n t Def nda s' 1
dii
vi nta y onc r o
e nt . d.
'
DISCU SSIO N

Th Co r, stig i dv ri j rs ito , p iste s b tn ie lw o t e f r m
e u t i n n iest u idcin a pl h u sa tv a f h o u
t
y
e
sae Fl i SeeMe a v Cl e
tt, orda.
s . ar ndon Nat l .Co. 799 F. 1
. ns
,
3d 353, 1 ( 1h Ci.201 )
358 1 t r
5;
Mont zv. i ryMut FieI .Co.No.18Cl 80788ane f be t
. r ns ,
- VRAR,201 W L 33
9
02308, t* ( D.
a 3 S.
Fl J y 23,201 .Secim 90.
a. ul
9) tc
5055,FlrdaSt ut ,st f t t ac ountntcle prvie
o i at es es orh he c a - int i lge.
The s at e s at i rel
t ut t es n evantpartt
hat

A cle ha a prviege t r f e t di c os a t pr s nta ot rpe s f om
i nt s i l
o e us o s l e, nd o e e ny he r on r
di cl i t c e s of c i nta co m uni a i w ih an a ount ntwhen
s osng, he ont nt
ontde i l m
c tons t
cc
a
s h o he pe s l r d of t com m uni a i be a e t y w e e m a i t
uc t r r on ea ne
he
c tons c us he
r
de n he
r ndii of a ountng s r i es t t c i nt Thi prvie i l
e ton
cc i
e v c o he le . s i l ge nc udes ot r
he
confde i li or a i n obt i by t a co a fom t cle f rt pur e
i nta nf m to
a ned he c unt nt r he i nt o he pos
ofr nde i a countng ad c
e r ng c
i
vi e.

Fl.Stt j90.
a a . 5055( .iA c
2) f ommuni ton bewee a ac ountnta t a c a ' cinti
cai t n n c a nd he c ountnts le s
(ontde il i i i noti e d t bedicos t t r pes ot rt n:(1 t et who
c i nta' f t s ntnde o
sl ed o hid rons he ha ) hos o m
dicos e i i f t a e oft rndii ofac ountng s r iest t cle ;( l( t e
s l ur s n urhernc
he e ton
c i e vc o he int or 2) hos

r a ona y nec s a y f t t a m i s on oft c m uni ton.' F. . C.v.Ka an,201 W L
e s bl
e s r or he r ns s i
he om
ca i ' D L
pl
5

547
4489,a *3 ( . Fl Se . 1 zolst tng Fl Stt j 90.055 1().çlo i ke
t
M D. a. pt 6,
lcii
a. a.
5 ( )c ) d- nvo
'
t a oun a - i prvieg cours g r l r quie pa test de ons r t t a or m e i ned
he cc t ntclent i l e;
t ene aly e r r i o m t a e he f e nto
e e e s a t a s pr de a prviege 1 t t e en t ta doc e sw e e w ihhe d fom
l m nt nd o l o ovi
i l og o he xt t ha ny
um nt r t l r

prduci 'TI Par Ct.9 LLC v CabotNo.16245 C1 201 W L 9988745,at* ( D.
o ton. C k r ,
'
.
,
- 69- V, 7
9 S.
Fl.J 9,201 )
a une
7.
The e a e e e i t t a co a - le prvie Forexa pl t prvieg doe not
r r xc ptons o he c unt nt c i nt i l ge.
m e, he i l e s

e s whe tgl s r i soft a c a wee s torobti d t e bl oradanyo t
xit n sthe e vce he c ountnt r ough
ane o na e i
ne o
c
ommi orpln t co twha t cintkne ors d ha known wasac i orfa 'j
t a o mmi t he le
w
houl ve
rme rud.'

90. 4)a) Thi i t e pto r le onbyPli ifwhe t yar t tt prvie doe
5055( ( . s s he xce in eid
antf n he gue ha he i lge s
notpr ec t doc nt andQuikbooksfl a is
ot the ume s
c
ie t sue.

The Cour hasrviwe t doc nt lsed i t prvie l ( 1 1 .Thet
t e e d he ume s it n he i lge og DE 50-1
wo
l tr ( 00001 000022
ete s GK
9-

and

GK 000042- , t
43) he

i ena i a
ntr l ntke

fm
or

( 0001 - 000272) a t Quikbooksfl ( 000629)aec
GK
71GK
, nd he c
ie GK
r ommuni to b we n
cains et e
a a cou a , r M il r and D e e nt . t r or ,i i cl arf om a r vi w oft doc e s
n c nt nt M . le ,
f nda s Furhe m e t s e r
e e
he um nt
t t he w e e noti e d t be di cl e t t r pe s .
ha t y r
nt nde o
s os d o hi d r ons Thus t onl w a t tPl i ifw oul
, he y y ha a ntf
d

bee ild t pr ton oft docume si i t s r i e ofM r M ilrwe es
ntte o oduc i
he
nt s f he e v c s
. le r oughto obt i
r aned
t e bl ora d D e e nt t c m i orpl n t c m i fa
o na e i f nda s o om t
a o om t r ud.
The e i a s a c t of c e 1 w i t El ve h Ci c t on t a i a i of t faud
r s c r iy
as a n he e nt r ui
he pplc ton
he r
e e i t t ac ount ntcle pr vie The onl f de alc e cied by Pl i ifi t Pa te '
xc pton o he c
a - i nt i l ge.
y e r as t
a ntf n he r i s
m oton f ri came a r vi w i M uli i
i o n
r e e s
tnatonalFor e drO bs t r v Ar ow Ai ,l . 662 F.Supp.
c
e we s . r
r nc ,

1 ( D. a.1 .nt tc e,hec tfundt tt a ount - intprvie di nota y
62 S. Fl 987)l ha as t our o ha he cc antcle i lge d
ppl
4

be us i heve yhea t t Pli ifsca e' t tt defnda hadfa e l i
ca e t
t
r
r of he antf
s 'was ha he e nt
r udul nty nduce t
d he
pli ift e e i oaco r c . d. t163.
a ntf o ntr nt
nta t 1 a
Addii ly,hec t ppea e t gi cr de t t
tonal t our a
r d o ve e nce o he
pl ntf' a g e t tafi vis fl i t c e c d be pr
ai i f s r um nt ha tda t ied n he as oul
oved f l e,s t doc e s at
a s o he
um nt

is mihte de eafa ont co t1 Thec te aned,Sl hieco de yt r i a
sue g vi nc rud he ur. d.
our xpli twl l nce dl hee s
de rh of l alau hort i e r tng t s sa ut t s Cour c ude t t t pr e f c s
at
eg
t iy nt m e i hi tt e, hi
t oncl s ha he es nt a t
co po t w ihi t l gi l i i e a f l w ihi t f a e e i Thi c l i i
m r t n he e satve nt nt nd a l t n he r ud xc pton. s onc us on s
bu t es ed by a ogy t sm ia prvieg . f A s e a ned bel ,t M uli i
tr s
nal
o i l r i l es ' J.
'
xpl i
ow he
tnatonalFor e d
c r
Obs rv r v. r Ai,I c e i f t l sm ia t t c s a ha
e e s Ar ow r nc. as s ac ualy i l r o he a e t nd.
The Co t has a s c i r Jel W e I . v N e a Gl s l ' I . N o.
ur
l o ons de ed
d- n, nc . bul
as ntl nc ,

07- 26- V,2008 W L 11
223 C1
33331 ( D.Fl Feb.26,2008) whi t Cour dic rd upon
4 S. a.
, ch he
t s ovee
c
onduc i i
tng ndepe nt r s r h. l Jel W e t c t ag ee t t t ac ount n - le
nde e ea c n
d- n, he our r d ha he c
a t c i nt

prvie i not abs ut a a knowl dge t e se
i lge s
ol e nd c
e d he xit nce of t fa e pto l a #
he r ud xce i n. d t 3.
H owe r t cou tf
ve , he r ound t t f a e e i di nota y unde t s ii f c soft ca e
hat he r ud xc pton d
ppl
r he pec t c a t he s

be us t pl ntf s va i fau cou s had be n dim is by t cou ton a numbe of
ca e he ai if' rous r d
nt
e s s ed
he r
r

o c so s 11Thec u t cie t iti ( d fn a t ofh a c u tn -le p iie eb s do
c a in .6
o rde ln d o s rp a e e d n) te c o n a tcint rvlg a e n
s
t slmiedfa e pton. 1 I e etngl e whierj tngt pli ifsagume t t
hi i t rud xce i ' d. ntr si y, ven l eeci he antf r nt ha
'
t a cou a - i nt prvie di not a y, t c t cons de e t f a e e i a
he c nt ntcle
i l ge d
ppl he our
i r d he r ud xc pton nd

s e i y i id t tt fa e e i woul a y i c e whe e a pli ifhad a lge
e m ngl mple ha he r ud xc pton
d ppl n as s
r
antf
le d
l tm at f aud cl m s i t com pl nt
egii e r
ai n he
ai .

The Cour tnds t tt c ts l i i M uli i
ti
ha he our ' og c n
tnatonalFor e (rObs r e s i a ogi ng
c f
e v r n nal zi
t f a e e i t t a t ne c i nt prvie w ih t f a
he r ud xc pton o he tor y- le
i l ge t he r ud e e i t t
xc pton o he

a oun a - int prviege t be co r c a r s
cc t ntcle
i l
o
r e t nd ea onabl
e.

de e ni wheher t
t nni ng
t
he

ci -ru e c p int t eatme -l n p i lg a p is tfis,heemus b ap i fce
rme fa d x e to o h to yci t rvi e p le ,i jrt t r
e
e
g
t e rma a i
s i t tt c i w ase
how ng ha he lent
ngage i c i i lorf a
d n rm na
r udul ntc
e onduc when he s
t
oughtt ad c
he vi e
ofc
ouns l t the w a pl nni s h c
e , ha
s a ng uc onduc w he he s
t
n
oughtt a ce of c
he dvi
ouns ,ort the
el
ha

c
omm it ac i eorfa s equ t r c vi t be ftofc
ted rm
r ud ubs ent o e ei ng he ne i
ouns lsa ce'l r Gr d
e ' dvi .' n e an

Jur I e tgaton,84 F. 1 1 ( 1hCi.1 ) Sse nd,t r mus beas ngt t
y nv si i
2 2d 223, 226 1 t r 987 .i co he e t
howi ha
t a t r y' as it nce w a obt ne i f t a e oft c i i orf audul tac i t orw a
he to ne s s s a
s ai d n urher nc
he rm nal r
en tviy
s

cl el r lt d t i. 1 ; eealo Bl e v Bat i No.1 CV- 222,201 W L 1
os y ea e o t' d.s
'
s ak . masan,
5- 81
7
0059 , t
251 a

*1 ( D. a.Oct 5,201 , e tandr omme i ado e4 No.1 81 C1 201 W L
0 S. Fl
.
7)rpor
ec
ndaton pt
5- 222- V, 8
3829803( D.Fl Aug.9,201 )
S. a.
8
Thi c e i m uc m or s m iart M uli i
s as s
h
e i l o
tnatonalFo c drObs r er t n t Je d- e l .
re
e v s ha o l W n, nc

Hee,Pli ifha e iil alge fa agans Defnda si t Compl nt( 1 . o h
r antf s xplcty le d r ud i t e nt n he
ai DE ) Thr ug
t a lga i i t Compl i ,Pl i if ha ma a prm a f i s
he le tons n he
ant antf s de
i ace howi of fa a has
ng
r ud nd
s fci nty a l ge t tt as i t nce oft a ount , r M il , a obt i i f t r nc o
uf i e l le d ha he s sa
he cc ant M . ler w s a ned n urhe a e f
f a e a tviy orw ascl e y r l e t i. or over M r M il r t a ount ntf o who
r udul nt c i t
os l e at d o t M e
, . le , he cc a r m
m

t doc
he umen sa i s wer o a n wasf m e l a de e nti t sc e who wasal d t
t t s ue e bt i ed,
or ry
f nda n hi as
lege o
ha pa tc pa e i f a wih Def nda s I s e st tt sc e i t exa tst ton a i pa e
ve ri i t d n r ud t
e nt . t e m ha hi as s he c iua i ntci t d

byt fa e e i t t a c a - le prvieg Thus be us t f a e ptona is
he r ud xc pton o he c ount ntc int i l e.
, ca e he r ud xce i pple
he e, he a cou a - le pr viege doe notpr ec t doc e sa i s .
r t c nt nt c i nt i l
s
ot t he um nt t s ue z

Ba e on t f egoi i i he e ORDERED t tDe e nt pr
s d he or ng, t s r by
ha f nda s oduc t Pl ntf a 1o
e o ai if 1 f

t docu nt pr vi d t t Cour f i c mearviw,i l ngt Quikbookstl,onor
he
me s o de o he
t or n a r e e ncudi he c
ie
2Th Cour notst tii notm a ngaGndi i t sOr t tt ac ount t M r M ilr andDefndan sw ee,i
e
t e ha t s
ki
ng n hi der ha he c an , . le ,
e t r n
fc,enga d i faud.Tha i a is t twilbede deda ti .Rahe ,he Cour fndst t r i as ce
at
ge n r
t s n sue ha l
ci t ral t r t
t i hat hee s um int
prmaf ci f t ls i madebyPl ntf t e tbls t tt faudexc ton a isi t sc es ast de e t
i a e acua how ng
ai if o sa ih ha he r
ep i pple n hi as o o f a
De e nt 'c a m ofa count ntclen prviege.
f nda s l i
c
a - i t il

be or Sept ber 12,2019. A l pr
f e
em
l oduc i s l be c pl t d pur uant t t t r s of t
ton ha l
om e e
s
o he e m
he

Pa tes StpultdPr e i Or r( 1 )e erdonJ ne11 201
ri ' i ae otctve de DE 21 nt e
, 9.

D N adO D R DiCabrti ) dyoSpmbr21,t sPl
O E n R E E n hmeshs a f et e,09aWe a
e
tm
Be c Pa m Be c Cot y i t Sout r D it i ofFl i .
a h, l
ah
mt n he
he n s rct
orda

UILLIA M M A TT EW M AN
'
W
UN I
TED STATES M A G I
STM TE J D GE
U