Ranger Construction Industries, Inc. v. Allied World National Assurance Company

Filing 46

ORDER granting in part and denying in part 21 Defendant's Motion for Protective Order; granting in part and denying in part 29 Plaintiff's Motion to Compel. Signed by Magistrate Judge William Matthewman on 4/6/2018. (kza)

UN I
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
Ci lNo.1 81 C1 M a r M at wm a
vi
7- 226- V- ra/ the
n
RANGER CONSTRUCTI W DUSTRI
ON
ES,
l C.
N ,
FL D d
IE y

Pl i if
a ntf ,

D.
C.

VS.

AF 2s 2 1
2
23

A LLI W O RLD N A TI A L A SSU M N CE
ED
ON
COM PAN Y ,

STL N M LARj
VE
MORE

CL R tb DS.T
E K ) ITc.
so. Fk. wk
- oF ' - aa.
t

Def nda .
e nt
/
O R DER G R AN TI G I PAR T A N D D EN YI G I PA RT D EFEN DA N T' M O TI N
N N
N N
S
O
FOR PROTECTI ORDER l 211AND PLAI FF'
VE
DE
NTI S

M OTI TO CO M PEL I 291
ON
DE
TH I CA U SE i be or t Cour upon D e e nt A li d W ord N a i l A s ur nc
S
s f e he
t
f nda , le
l
tona
s a e

Co a y' (Dee d n ) M oi n f r Pr tcie Or e ( 21 a Plitf, Ra g r
mp n s ç fn a f'
t
to o oe tv
d r DE 1 nd an if n e
Consr to I tis l ' Cç ai if' Mo in t Co l ( 2 1 Th s matr we e
tucin ndusre , nc.s pl ntf ) to o mpe DE 9 . e e te s r
r e r d t t unde sgned by Unied St t s D i t i t J e K ennet A .M ar a. See DE 19.
ef re o he
ri
t
ae
sr c udg
h
r

Plitf fld ar s o s t Dee da tsM oin ( 2 ) a d Dee da ttld a rpy ( 2 1
an if i
e e p n e o fn n ' to DE 3 , n fn n ie e l DE 5 .
The Cour hed ahea i ont m otonson M a ch 20,201
t l
rng he i
r
8.
BA CK G ROU N D

The pr e alposur oft s c e i as f l s On D e m be 1 201 Pl ntf f l d
oc dur
t e hi as s olow .
ce r 5, 7, ai if ie

a Ame d Compli algi br c ofc r c (
n
nde
ant le ng ea h onta t CountI,de aaor r i ( unt1) a
) clrt y elef Co 1, nd

ba fih (
d at Count11. Defnda tld isM otonf rPr eci Or r( 21 on Fe u r 22,
1)
e nt ie t
i o ot tve de DE )
br ay

2 8 Th s mo in wa fld b Dee d n a tr Dee d n h d o j ce t e r sn l
01 . i to
s ie y fn a t fe fn a t a b e td o vey ig e
1

i e a or a r s f pr uci
ntnog t y nd eque t or od ton. Def nda pr ed no docume sa di notans r
e nt oduc
nt nd d
we
one i t r og t y.
n e r a or

On M a c 1 201 Unied St es Diti tJ
r h 4, 8, t
at
src udge Ke t A.M a r e e e a Or r
nne h
r a nt r d n de

De i De e d n ' M oi nt Dimisg 2 1 Ac o dngy a1h e c u t rmanp ndn .
nyng fn a ts to o s s DE 8 . c r i l, 1 tr e o n s e i e ig
Pl i if s c
a ntf ouns l a t m pt d t co e w ih Def nda ' c
e te e o nf r t
e nt s ouns r ga di di c r a t r t
el e r ng s ove y f e he

Or r De ng M oto t Dim is wa e er d, but De e nts couns l woul not c nge
de
nyi
in o s s
s nt e
f nda '
e
d
ha
Def nda ' pos ton,a D e e n c i
e nt s ii
nd f nda t ontnued t r us t r pond t a di c r
o ef e o es
o ny s ove y.

On Ma c 1 2 8 Plitf fld isM oin t Co e ( 2 1 whih i, nef c, h
rh 6, 01 , an if ie t to o mp l DE 9 , c s i fe tt e
ti sde o De e ntsM oton f Pr e tve Or r a Pli ifs ekst c
lp i f f nda '
i or ot c i
de , s a ntf e
o ompelt dicove y
he s r
t t De e
ha
f ndant s ks t pr ve vi is M oton f Pr ec i Or r On M a ch 1 2018
ee o e nt a t
i or ot tve de .
r
9,
,

De e d n fldaM oi nt Ab t Co n IIo Ra g rsAme d d Co an ( 31 . l ta
fn a t ie
to o ae u t l f n e '
n e mplit DE 1 n h t
moton t abae,whih rmanspe ng,Defnda aguest tt ba fih cam ( t11
i o t
c e i ndi
e nt r
ha he d at li Coun 1)
a s t d by Pl i i fi isA m ende Com pl i ts d be a t d. f
s ere
a ntf n t
d
a n houl
ba e
J.
1.
I

A N A LY SI
S

Thedic y r quesspr
s over e t opoundedby Pl i ifpe ti t alt e c soft Am e d
antf ran o l hr e ount he
nde
Compl i . Att dicove y hea i c
ant
he s r
rng, ouns lf rDe e
e o f ndantac
knowl d t ts
edge ha ome dicove y
s r
s
oughti Pl i if s di c r r ques si r l va t Co s Ia 1 oft A m e d Com pl nt
n a ntf
s ove y e
t s e e nt o unt nd 1 he
nde
ai .
Couns la s ac
e l o know l dg t ti or a i a doc e s r s
e ed ha nf m ton nd
um nt e pons ve t s h r
i o uc eque t ha not
ss d

ye be pr
t en oduce Howe ,Def nda sa on a br d a s ri ofwor pr tprvie
d.
ver
e nt t nds
oa s e ton
k oduc i l ge
a a g t teve yt ng i is c ai sf l i i m une f om di cove y.
nd r ues ha
r hi n t l m ie s m
r
s
r
A . ATTO RN EY ' FEES A N D C OSTS
S

The Cour i di a
t s s ppoi ed w ih Def nda ' poston,w hi i m a nt i up untl t
nt
t
e nt s ii
ch t i a ned
i he
M a c 20,201 hea i t t i nee no pr
rh
8
rng, ha t d t oduc a di c r w hat oe r A t a m i m um ,
e ny s ove y
s ve .
ni
2

Dee d n s o l ha ep o u e a ya dal ic v r iwa n to j ci t rte t a r f sng
fn a t h u d v r d c d n n ld s o ey t s o be tng o ah r h n e u i
t p o u e a y d so e y a a1meey b c u ei h d o j cin t c ran b d fih d so ey.
o r d c n ic v r t l r l e a s t a b e to s o e ti a at ic v r
Furhe ,De e nt s d ha pr m pty r - l t a c nged is poston r gar ng is
t r f nda houl ve o l e eva uaed nd ha
t
ii e di t
c
omplt r us t pr
e e ef al o oducea dicove ywha s verafe J
ny s r
t oe
tr udgeM a r is hi Or rDe ng
ra s ued s de nyi
M o i t Dim is Pl ntf a gue t ti i e il t at ne sf s a c t unde Fede a
ton o s s . ai if r s ha t s ntted o tor y' ee nd oss
r
rl
Rul ofCi lPr e e37 duet De enda ' f iur t pr uc dic r asr quie by t nzes
e
vi oc dur
o f nts al e o od e s ove y e r d he l
a De e nts unwilngnes t c e i good f t The Cour i s rousy consde i
nd f nda '
li
s o onf r n
aih.
t s ei l
i rng
a r ng c t a f es t be pai by De e
wa di oss nd e o
d
f ndantand is co e t Pli if bec us of t s
t uns l o antf
a e
hi
co uc . How e r t Cour w ilr s r e nzi on s tonsorcos - hi tng unde Fe r lRul
nd t
ve , he
t l e e v lng
anc i
ts fi
r de a
e
of Ci l Pr dur 37 a t s tm e. The Co t w il e e an or r on Pl ntf s r que t f r
vi oce e
t hi i
ur l nt r
de
ai if e s o

a t e sf esa c t a a lt rda e.
tom y' e nd oss t a e t
The Cour w ilnow a e s s m e oft pe ng di c r i s s i t s c e.
t l
ddr s o
he ndi
s ove y s ue n hi as
B . CLA I S FI D I OV ERY
M
LE SC
G i n t pr ed al pos ur of t s ca e t Cour fnds t t i w oul pot nta l be
ve he oc ur
t e
hi s , he
ti
ha t
d e i ly
co r r t t c e 1 t r quie Def ndan t r s
nt a y o he as aw o e r
e
t o e pond t dicove y r que t t t a e s e v
o s
r e s s ha r ol l

r e ntt Pli ifsbadfihc us ofaci (
elva o antf'
at a e
ton Count11 whieDe e ntsmotont a t t
1) l f nda ' i o bae he
bad fih c
at ount(
Count11 i pe ng. The Cour wilnotor r Defnda t pr e a
1) s ndi
t l
de
e nt o oduc ny
dic r whihr ae s eyt t ba fihca eofaci ( unt11 whiet moi t a t
s ovey c elts oll o he d at us
ton Co 1) l he ton o bae
Cou t I i pe ng. Howe r t Cour tndst tDe e nti claryr r t r pondt t
r 1I s ndi
ve ,he
ti ha f nda s e l equied o es
o he

dic r r ue t t taerlva t Count Ia orCount1 (veni t ya eas r lvan t
s ovey eq ss ha r ee nt o
s nd/
1 e f he r lo ee t o
Cou 11.
nt 1)

I t sdi riy a ton i vi t e c sf ( )br ch ofc rc ofa i urnce
n hi ve st ci nvol ng hre ount or 1 ea
onta t n ns a
polc ( de aao y r i ,and ()bad f t Dee ntt st poston t tDeenda '
iy, 2) clrtr elef
3
aih, fnda ake he ii ha f nts
3

c am - ndlngm a e i sa econsde e wor pr
l i ha i
t ral r
i rd
k oduc unde Fl i lw and a enotdic r e
t
r orda a
r
s ove abl
e n i t m a e i l a e r l nta r pons ve t t br ac ofc r c a orde l a or r i
ve f he t r a s r e eva nd es
i o he e h
ont a t nd/
c ar t y elef

c u t. De e d n ' p iini t tsn et esaec u tu g n u d ryngteb df i cam
o n s fn a ts osto s ha, ic h tt o rj d me t n e li h a at li
h
i c r nty on a
s ure l
ppea ,t r i c r nty no rpe ca e ofaci f ba f t a t r f e t
l he e s ur e l
i
us
ton or d aih, nd, he e or , he
Cour c nnot or r pr
t a
de oduc i of a cl i s ha i m a e i l , e n i t e m a e i s a e
ton
ny a m
ndlng t r a s ve f hos
t ral r
r e ntt Count 1a I .
el va o
s nd l

Th Co r rj cs Dee a ts p sto . F rt e e t ug ti i a dv riy a t n
e u t ee t fnd n ' o iin is, v n ho h h s s ie st ci ,
o
fde a 1w g r wor pr ta sri . Thus Fe alRul ofCi lPr edur 26( ( )
e r l a ove ns k oduc se tons
, der
e
vi oc e b)3
c r s Str v O' nn,253 F. D.663,67 ( D.Fl 2008 ;M ii z o v St eFar I s
ontol. en . Qui
R.
4 S. a. ) lna z . at m n .
Co.247F. D. 7 ( D.Fl.2007)
,
R. 691, 00 S. a
.
Se ond,Def nda hasove l d Comme ci Lon Tr ng Cor v Sc tdal I .Co.
c
e nt
rooke
r al g adi
p. . ots e ns
,

No.1 2278 C1 201 W L 6850675 ( D.Fl De 26,2012) whih s ci tylyso t
2- 7- V, 2
S. a. c.
, c uc ncl a ut he
a ia e f de allw r l tng t cli sofwor pr t I t tca e t Honor bl J t n
pplc bl e r a e ai o am
k oduc . n ha s , he
a e ona ha
Goodma Unie St t sM agita eJ
n, t d a e
sr t udge sa e t f l ng:
, tt d he olowi
A lhough i ha notfl d aprviege l Sc t da ear ue t ise ie c ai tl i
t
t s
ie
i l og, ots l g s hat t ntr l m i e s
of-i is and, wih t t obvi e ptons m e i
flm t
t he wo
ous xce i
ntoned a
bove, c nno be
a t
c pe l d i di co r
om le n s ve y.
Sc t da e i i or e t and has not e n c e c os t m e tng is bur
ots l s nc r c
ve om l e o
ei t
den of
e t bls ng prviege
s a i hi
i l .
The e i ly,i i pe ha c
or tca l t s r ps once v e t t eve y s ngl doc e and t ng i
i abl ha
r i e
um nt
hi n
Sc t da es c a m f l i pr e t d by e t r t a t ne cle pr vie ,t w or
ots l ' l i ie s ot c e
ihe he tor y- i nt i l ge he
k
pr
oduc doc rne, bot ButSco t da e c
t t i or h.
t s l anno m ai ai isposton ofr f i t
t nt n t
ii
e us ng o
pr
oduc ot r ie r s
e he w s e pons ve doc e sby m er l s yi g t tis e i e c ai fl
i
um nt
e y a n ha t ntr l m ie

i no s j c t dic l
s t ube t o s ovey.
1 a *3. Coul si t sD i ti tdo notpr cl pr
d. t
' n hi s r c
t
e ude oduc i ofe r s ngl cl i s f l doc l e
ton
ve y i e a m ie lm nt

j s b c us teei n t rpeb dfihcam p n i g Theeo e De e d n i n t bet smpy
u t e a e h r s o a i a at li e d n . r fr , fn a t s o a l o i l
4

ld e te g n r lo j cin ta d c me t ae t li fl maeil' n Nh ly r f e t
o g h e ea b e to h t o u n s r û ams ie tras'a d v o l eus o
c
pr et doc e sfom t cli stl t ta er lva t Count Ia 1.
oduc he um nt r he am ie ha r ee nt o
s nd I
Def nda ' c t bl nc a gum e t tisc a m sf l i a ol e y s cr a ti t sc s
e nt s are a he r
nt ha t l i ie s bs ut l a os nc n hi a e

i be id by t ca el
s le
he s aw--eve t f de alc esct d by Def ndan . Fore m pl i isM o i
n he e r as ie
e
t
xa e, n t ton
f Pr e tve O r r D e enda ciesAyal v Am .Se .I s Co ,N o.09or ot c i
de , f
nt t
a .
c n. .
80053- V ,2009 W L
C1

1
873645, t*1( D. a.une30,
a S. Fl J
2009) f t pr ii t Fl i a fde a lw hol t
, orhe oposton hat orda nd e r la
ds hat
a i ur ' cai fl c tt e wor pr tand wilbe pr eced fom dico r pro t t
n ns ers l m ie onsiut s k oduc
l
ot t r
s ve y i r o he

a c u lo ab d fihc u eo a to . ( 21a p. 1 Bu,i Ayaa,h Co r noe ta t e
c r a f a at a s f cin DE
t 2 . t n l te u t td h t h
d fnd n ' o j cint p o u igicamsfl ' o st o yap rinofhecamsfl. Ayaa
ee a ts b e to o r d cn t li ie t e o nl o t
g
o t li e'
' l,
2009 W L 1873
645, t*1. Thi w oul s e t i c t t t i Ayal a pori oft c a m s fl
a
s
d e m o ndi a e ha , n
a,
ton he l i ie

wa dic r bl Furhe ,t c tor r d t tt def nda m us pr uc çt e ie c am s
s s ove a e.
t r he our de e ha he e nt t od e the ntr l i
f l pr ort J nua y 2007 no pr e t d by a t ey- le prviege. f The Ayal c ta s
ie i o a r
t ot c e
tom c i nt i l ' #.
'
a our l o

or r t de e ntt pr eaprviegel s t ng whih De e ntha a g i smpl
de ed he f nda o oduc
i l og, ome hi
c
f nda
s r ued t i y
doesnotnee t do i t sc e be a e t e iec am sfl i i unefom dic r
do
n hi as c us he ntr l i ie s mm
r
s ove y.

I Mii z ov St eFar I .Co.2 F. D. 701( D. a.
n lna z . at m ns , 47 R. 691, S. Fl 2007) aca ei whih
, s n c
onl a br a h ofcon r c cl i wasc r nty pe ng be a e t bad f ih c a m ha be n f
y
ec
ta t am
ur e l ndi
c us he
at l i
d e ound
t be pr m a ur , he c tf
o
e t e t our ound t tûa ha d a f tl l i eihe di e ton' r ga di cl i s tl
ha i r nd as ' e n t r r c i ' e r ng a m i e
u
m a e i l ç oul f s r t t varous goal of m ode n di c r pr ctce, s c t t nd t
t r a s t d nz t a e he i
w
s
r s ove y a i
o ours e o
e i t pm i ul r f c s ofea h c e. The Cour di how e r fnd i a opr a e t a y
xam ne he
c a at
c as '
'
t d,
ve , i t ppr i t o ppl

r buta e pr s ptons ç ha doc e s or t ngs pr par d be or t fnal de son o a
e t bl e um i
û t um nt
t
hi
e e
f e he i
cii n n
i ur d' cl i a e no wor pr
ns e s a m r t k oduc ,a t tdoc e spr
t nd ha
um nt oduc afe c a m s de a a e w o k
ed t r l i
ni l r
r
pr
oduc . 1 The M ii az o r buta e pr um pton i a ve y l ca a c m on s e
t' d.
'
ln z e t bl es
i s
r ogi l nd om
ens
a oa h t cl i s fl di c r
ppr c o a m ie s ove y.
5

The Cour a knowl st tt r a e sa e c s si Fl i t ta y a blck a whie
tc
edge ha he e r t t a e n orda ha ppl
a nd t
r e t tcl m s fl m a e i s a e notdi c r bl when no ba f ih c a m ha yetac r e . Sc ,
ul ha ai ie t ral r
s ove a e
d at l i
s
cud
c

eg.St eFar M utAut I s Co.v Cook,744So. 5 ( a 1 . Howe ,i M obly v
. at m . o. n .
.
2d 67 Fl. 999)
ver n
e .

Ca t l pe il Is, .1 - 0 3 - V, 01 W L 3 9 05 , t* ( D. a J y 1 , 01 )t e
pio S cat n .No 3 2 6 6 C1 2 3
y
7 4 8 a 4 S. Fl. ul 9 2 3 ,h
c te ane t t'
our xpl i d ha i rf de all w,t r i no blnke pr t c i n ofa i ur nc c
unde e r a he e s
a t o e to
n ns a e ompa s
ny'

cam fl. (iig Th Atim o te Oc a 1 Co d . As ' v QBE I s Cop.No.
li ie' ctn
'
e ru n h
e n 1 n o sn .
n. r ,
06-43269- V,
1
C1 2007W L 2972937a * ( D. a2007). M orove ,ûvi nc ge r ds el t
t 2 S. Fl. )
e r û de e a e ol y o
e
s
uppo ta ba f ih cli i pr m aur a notdic r bl as a gum e s r l e t ba f t
r
d at a m s e t e nd
s ove a e, r
nt eatd o d aih
labiiy unde Fl St t 624. 55 a e pr m a ur unt lt cove age i s i r s ved.' k e
i lt
r a. a .
1
r e t e i he
r
s ue s e ol ' Buc ly

T wesCo d miim,I c v QBE I s Cop.No. 7 2 98 - V, 0 W L 2 4 68 a * ( D.
o r n o nu n . .
n . r , 0 - 2 8 C1 2 08
6 5 0 t 2 S.
Fl J 26,2008) Howe r li e de ei r lva t t ba f t cam, ndi alor lvan
a. une
.
ve ,tf vi nc s ee nt o he d aih li a s s ee t
t t unde l ng c r c am ,t n t te denc i dic r e.' I
o he
ryi ove age l i he ha vi e s s ove abl ' d
Ta ng i o c i r ton a loft above c e l w ,t Cour fnds t tD e e nti no
ki nt ons de a i 1 he
as a he
ti
ha f nda s t

p r te t smp ya s r abln e o j cint a n camsflsmaeil ma b p o u e a ti
emi d o i l s et a k t b e to h t o li ie tras y e r d c d th s
t

j n t r i t ec s . I fd r lc u t wh r De e d n fn is l, h a ay i i mu h mo e
u cu e n h a e n e ea o r, ee fn a t ids tef t e n l ss s c r
nua e t n t t a a a m i m um ,c ai sf l doc en s c ea e bef e t unde l ng cl i
nc d ha ha , nd, t
ni
l m ie um t r t d or he
r yi
am

wasde e s d be pr e i r e ntt Count Ia I . De e nthasf l t me tis
ni d houl
oduc d f elva o
s nd l
f nda
aied o e t

b re t e tbiht thee tr camsfl i s b e tt t ewo k p o u tp i lg .
ud n o sa ls ha t n ie li i s u j c o h r - r d c rvi e
e
e
C. REOUI
REM ENTS REGARDI DI
NG SCOVERY PROCESS
De e
f ndan s l c
t hal ompl wih t s rt a lte of t r es gove ni dic y
y t he pii nd e tr
he ul
r ng s over
t oug
hr hout t r m a nde of t s ca e. The Cour i e
he e i r
hi s
t nt nds t t di c r s l pr e
ha s ove y hal oc ed

e dii l a pr e sona l i t sc e. To t te t Cour a s sa 1pa tesa t r
xpe tousy nd of s i ly n hi as
ha nd, he
t dvi e 1 ri nd hei

c u e a flo . Fis,b iepae o j cinsa d g n r l e rs o s sa ei r p r S e
o ns l s o lws rt olr lt be to n e eai d e p n e r mp o e . e
z
6

Ala v NoPrs u eRo fclann ,
vr .
e s r o e ig LLC, .1 - 0 2 - 2 8W L 1 8 7 7 a * ( D. a
No 7 8 7 5 CV, 01
1 7 7 , t 2 S. Fl.
M a . 201 ; eam,I v Has anHaki t Sar ,nc, 1 CV- 600,201 W L 878
r 7, 8)Sr
nc. . s
m t war I .No. 6- 81
7
704,

a *1( D. a.Mar 6,201 ) Se ond,a cli ofprviegemus bes cfc,a aprvie
t S. Fl
.
7. c
ny ams i l
t pe ii nd i lge
1 m us be pr par d whe r quie
og
t
e e
n e r d.

Thid, he Cour e c sgood f ih pe s lc e r
r t
t xpe t
a t r ona onf r al

a n c u s la t alds o ey ds ue a d o jcins a r q rd b t e Or e S ti
mo g o n e s o l ic v r ip ts n be to s e uie y h d r et
ng
Dico yPr dur ( 201 Thepate 'c e s lpe s l co e i g f t ast a1
s ver oce e DE .
ris ouns l hal ronaly nfr n ood aih o 1

ds o ey d s u e a d s aln tld e b iep ae o o el b o d o j cinst ds o ey a
ic v r ip ts n h l o o g o lr lt r v ry r a b e to o ic v r s
De e ntdi i t sc e.
f nda d n hi as
D . PR I I
V LEGE LO G
A spe t r e
r he el vantc e l w , uc ofwhi h i c t d a
as a m h
c s ie bove Def ndanti r qui e t c e t
, e
s e rd o rae

a pr eaprvieg 1 wih r ga dt cai sfl m a e i st twe e c e t d durngt pe i
nd oduc
i l e og t e r o l m ie t ral ha r r a e
i he rod
f om t de a oft underyi c a m t t flng oft sl w s tt a e r s ns ve a r l va
r he ni l he
l ng l i o he ii
hi a ui hat r e po i nd e e nt
t di c r r que t perai ng t Co s Iand 1 . Se Com m e c alLong Tr n Cor ,201
o s ove y e s s t ni o unt
I
e
ri
adi g
p.
2

W L 6850675, * ( c et meea s rin ofaprvie ,una c
at 3 Be aus he r s eto
i lge c ompanidby aprviege1
e
i l og
ora tda torot r s
fi vi
he uppo tng m a e i ,i i ufi i ntt m e tt bur n i
ri
t ral s ns fc e o e he de mpos on a pary
ed
t
c am i prviege Sc tda e' ar um e sa e i dequae t i uni t doc
l i ng i l , ots l s g nt r na
t o mm ze he ument and ot r
s
he

maei si iscai fl ) TheCour ag e swih Defnda t twor pr tmaera ce td
tral n t l m ie..
t re t
e nt ha
k oduc t il rae
a rc
he omme e e oft sa ton ne no be i ude i a prvie l
nc m nt hi c i
ed t ncl d n
i lge og. Se S. Fl L.R.
e D. a.

26.()2)C)
1e( ( .
11
1.

C ON CLU SI
ON

U pon c r f r e oft m otons r pons r pl couns l sa g e satt dicove y
a e ul evi w
he
i , es
e, e y,
e ' r um nt he s
r
he rng, pplc bl c e l , nd t e ie docke i t sc e, ti he eby O R DER ED asf l w s
a i a i a e as aw a he ntr
t n hi as i s r
olo :

7

1
.

Dee a tsM oi n f rPr tcie Or e g 21 i GRANTED I PART
fnd n ' to o oe tv d r DE 1 s
N
AND DENI I PART a d P an ifs M oin t Co l ( 2 1 i
ED N
n litf
to o mpe DE 9 s
G R AN TED I PA RT A N D D EN I I PA R T.
N
ED N

W ihi sve ( da oft daeoft sOr r co e f bohpa te s l
t n e n 7) ys he t hi de , uns l or t ris hal
c e i good f ih ove t t e ne or i pe s r r ng Pli tf s
onf r n
at
r he elpho
n r on ega di
a n if
dic yr ss Couns f rbot pa te s ltyt r c a ag e me a
s over eque t .
el o
h ri s hal r o ea h n r e nt s
t t be tpr e lef De e ntt r s
o he s oc dtr or f nda o e pondt t dicove yr quesst ta e
o he s r e t ha r

rlv n t Co ns1a d I,y tas p e ev iso j cin t t d so e y
ee a t o u t n l e lo rs r e t b e to s o he ic v r
r ques st ta e e us vel r l va t Count1 1
e
t ha r xcl i v e e nt o
1.

W ihi f ure n (4) da oft dat oft sOr r Defnda s lfl a
t n o te 1 ys he e hi de , e nt hal ie
s e nt r pons t Pl i ifsi e r t i sa r quessf pr uci
uppl me al es e o antf nt rogaore nd e t or od ton
c it nt wih t a
onsse
t he bove a l i . De e
nayss
f ndant s l f l a co plt l
ha l uly nd m e ey
rs
e pond t t i e r a ore and r quessf pr
o he ntrog t i s
e t or oducton t tar r l va t
i ha e e e nt o
Count I a or Count 1 r ga dl s of w he he t y m a al o be r l vantt
s nd/
1 e r es
t r he
y s
ee
o

Co n 11 Dee d n ma a sr s cfco j cinst t ed s o r rq e t
u t 1. fn a t y se t pe ii be to o h ic vey e u ss
t tar r l nts el t Count1 1 Fi l D e e nti r qui e t pr uc
ha e e eva ol y o
1 . naly, f nda s e r d o od e
a prvie l c i t ntw ih t Cou ts a l i a
i l ge og ons se
t he
r ' na ys s bove.
4.

The Cour i wilng t r vii t is s dicus e i t s Or r a t
t s li o e st he s ue s s d n hi de s he
pr edur lpos ur oft sca e c nge onc t m oton t aba e i nze upon.
oc
a
t e hi s ha s e he
i o t s ld

Th Co r rs r e j rs ito t a r atr e sfe a d c t i fvo o
e u t e ev s u idcin o wa d to n y' e s n oss n a r f
Pl i i fa ag ns D e e
a ntf nd ai t f ndantand D e e
f ndan ' c
t s ouns .
el

8

D NE and ORDERED i Cha
n
mber a W es Pam Be ch,Pam Be h Co y,Fl i
s t
t l
a
l
ac
unt orda,

f dyoApi2018.
af r
l

t s
hi

,

#

W I A M M A TT EW M A N
LLI
Unie Stt sM a sr e J
td ae
gitat udge

9

k