Ranger Construction Industries, Inc. v. Allied World National Assurance Company

Filing 65

ORDER denying without prejudice 57 Plaintiff's Motion to Compel. Signed by Magistrate Judge William Matthewman on 6/15/2018. (kza)

UN I
TED STA TES D I
STRI COU RT
CT
SOU TH ERN D I I O F FLO RI A
STR CT
D
Ci lN o.1 81
vi
7- 226- V - a r / a t
CI M r a M thewm a
n
M N G ER CON STRU CTI I DU STRI
ON N
ES,
I C.
N ,

FL:d
IE y

D.
C.

Pl i if
a ntf ,

J 152
UN
:3
STE M G RI
VEN
MQRE

C E Kui os c
LR
l: m

A LLI W OR LD N A TI A L A SSU R AN CE
ED
ON
CO M PAN Y ,

sD. /.. w. .
. e: I - RB
â

Def
endant
.

O RD ER DEN YIN G W ITH O U T PR EJU DICE PLAIN TIFF' M O TIO N
S

TO CO M PEL I 571
DE
TH IS CA USE i bef e t Cour upon Pl ntf ,Ranger Consructon l
s or he
t
ai if
t i ndusti l '
r es, nc.s

(s ai if' Motont Compel( 5 . Thi matrwasr erdt t undesgne byUnie
t ntf ) i o
pl
DE 71
s te
efre o he
ri d
td
St es Di t ct J
at
sri udge Kennet A . M ar
h
ra. See D E

D e e nt A li W o l N a i nal
f nda , led
rd to

Asurnc Compa (s fnda ) fl ars et t M oto g 581 a Pli iffld a
s a e
ny s e nf',ied e pons o he in DE , nd antf ie
De
rpl ( 601 TheCour hedaheai ont Moton onJ 1 201 Thi matri now
e y DE .
t l
rng he i
une 2, 8. s te s
rpe f r vi w .
i or e e
BA C K G R O U ND

l t Ame dComplitg 1 , antf alge bra ofc rc, lr t yrle,
n he nde
an DE 2) Pli if le d e ch onta tdeca aor eif
and bad f t agai tD ef
aih
ns
endant On Apri 6,2018,t Courtent ed an OrderG r i i Par
.
l
he
er
antng n t

a Denyi i Pm'Dee ntsMoton f Pr eci Or ( 21 a Pli ifsM oto t
nd
ng n t fnda '
i or ot tve der DE J nd antf
in o

Compel( 291 See DE 46. The Cour nze t tDef ntwa r quied t r s nd t
DE .
t ld ha enda
s e r o epo o

Pli ifsdic y r que t t twer r e ntt t br ac ofc r c a deca at y r if
antf
s over e ss ha
e elva o he e h
onta t nd lr or ele

c t (ve i t yweeas rl ntt t ba fih c mt. 1 TheCour as e ane t t
ouns e n f he r lo eeva o he d at ot ) d.
t lo xpli d ha

Dee n c dno smpl ase t blnke o j ci t tnocamsfl maeilmaybep od e
fnda t oul t i y s r a a t b e ton ha li ie tra
r uc d
a t sj ur 1 Fi l t Cour rquie t t Dee t f l al oft ge a
t hi unct e. d. naly, he
t e rd ha fndan olow 1 he nerl
di c ve y r e a t tD e e
s o r ul s nd ha f ndan c ea e a pr
t r t nd oduc a pr vie l
e i l ge og. I
d
On A prl20,201 t H onor bl K e t A . a r U nie St t sD i ti tJ
i
8, he
a e nne h M r a, t d a e sr c udge e er d
, nt e

a Or rGrntngDee ntsM otont AbaeCountlloft Amende Complit( d f t
n de a i
fnda '
i o t
l he
d
an ba aih)

( 5 .
DE 41
I Pl ntf' M oton,Pl ntf a guest tD e e nt s s em e a di c r r s ns s
n ai i f s
i
ai i f r
ha f nda ' uppl nt l s ove y e po e
a prvie l ar s il i uf i i nt as s ve a di c
nd i l ge og e tl ns f c e
e r l s over r ques s s e i or a i n t t i
y e
t e k nf m to ha s

r lva t t bra hofc r c a deca aor rle c s ( 571 Pl i ifi s ciicaly
ee nt o he e c
onta t nd lr t y eif ount. DE . antf s pe t l
s ki pr
ee ng oduc i of a tonaldo e s i l ng t f l i
ton
ddii
cum nt , nc udi he olow ng: 1 cli handl not
) ams
i
ng es

a i e lc
nd ntma ommuni tons 2)j y e l ton rpors 3)moc tilr uls 4)me aton
cai , ur vauai e t,
k ra es t,
di i
sae ns 5)i erofieemalc r pondenc r r ngs tlme a s tlme de nds 6)
ttme t, nt - fc
i ores
e egadi ete nt nd ete nt ma ,

t undewrtng fl,7)l sr s r si or ton,8 r i urnc i or ton,9 ma sa
he
r ii ie os e eve nf mai ) ens a e nf mai ) nual nd
g dei rltng t ha i ofpunii da
ui lnes eai o ndlng
tve mage a e c ai oflr l s cams 1
s nd s alton a ge os li , 0)
doc ntrtntona ltgai hodprci s a 11 i or tona pro cams i udi
ume ee i nd ii ton l a tce , nd ) nf mai bout ir li ,ncl ng
l w s t ,i Fl i c
a uis n or da once ni how Def nda has de e m i d w he he t r i c age f
r ng
e nt
t r ne
t r he e s over
or

pt tveda ge . ( 57, . Pli ifi as s e ngamor de ci i prvie l I
mii ma s DES 601 antf s lo e ki
e s rptve i lge og. d
I r pons ,D e e ntc e t t i or rt esabls t ts ve a di c r r quess
n es
e f nda ont nds ha , n de o t i h ha e r l s ove y e
t

a erlva t Cot s1a l,andnotj tCo 11 Pli ifi i ntngc r t dute f
r ee nt o mt nd I
us unt 1, antf s nve i ontacual is or
Dee ntt tdo nota ari t i urncepolcyt 1 i taes te
fnda ha
ppe n he ns a
i o ) niit etlmentdic sonsa 2)
susi nd

a ce r s bl stlmen ofer. ( 581 Dee ntpoi so t edute aeacual pat
c ptea ona e ete t f s DE . fnda
nt ut hos is r t ly r
ofFl r da sco m on l dut ofgood f ih a t tbad f t i notcur e l a i s i t sc e.
oi ' m
aw y
a t nd ha
aih s
r nty t s ue n hi as
D e e nta s a s r s t tPl i tf s a g e t tva i ot r doc l e s a e r e ntt
f nda l o s e t ha a n i f r um nt ha r ous he
tm nt r el va o
Def nts unde s a ng ofc r ge i w ihou m e i . 1 D e e
enda '
r t ndi
ove a s t t rt d.
f ndantpoi s outt tFl i
nt
ha orda
l w pr dest ta i tr r sbelef and c
a
ovi ha n nsle ' i s
onduc a e i r l va t t de e m i ton ofco r ge
t r r e e nt o he t r na i
ve a
underan i ance polcy. 1
nsur
i
d.
I
I.

A NA LY SIS

The Cou tha c r uly cons de e t a gum ent oft pa tes co m s a t pe tne
r s a ef l
i r d he r
s he r i ' t el nd he ri nt
c s l w c t d by t pa tes c
a e a ie
he r i ' ouns l a f nds t t t a tona i or a i n a doc e s
e nd i
ha he ddii l nf m to nd
um nt
s
oughtby Pl ntf a eno r l va a pr r i t Pl i if sbr ac ofconta ordec a a or
ai i f r t e e nt nd opo tonal o a ntf
e h
r ct
lr t y

rle cams purua t Fe rl Rul of Ci l Pr e e 26( ( ) The i onnai a
eif li
s nt o dea
e
vi oc dur
b)1 .
nf ton nd
doc e s s ht a ar t be s el r e nt t Pl i if s ba f ih c a m ,w hi ha be n
um nt oug ppe o
ol y el va o a ntf ' d a t l i
ch s e
a t
ba ed. The Cour w il alow di c r whi h i s el r l va t a a e c
t l not l
s ove y
c s ol y e e nt o n bat d ountt pr ee
o oc d
w hie t tc mtr m a ns a t d. Thi i be aus Rul 26b) 1 i tt r dt pe ngcamsa
l ha ot e i ba e
s s c e e ( () s ehe e o ndi li nd
def
enses.

A lhough Pl ntf di alege i t A m ende Com pl i tt tCA W A C f ie t c pe a e
t
ai if d l n he
d
a n ha f
a l d o oo r t
i t s tl m e oft A s a n s t i udi f l e t i ta e s te entdi c s ons be o e
n he e te nt he t pha ui, ncl ng aiur o nii t etl m
s us i
fr
a a t rt As a n ve di ta r f i t ac ep r as bl s tl e of e si br a oft
nd fe he t pha r c nd e us ng o c t e ona e e tem nt f r n e ch he

AW AC polc 'g 1 p. !671t ealgai ar ma wihi t c i oft brac of
iy' DE 2, 9, ,hos le tons e de t n he onfnes he e h
c nta ta decaat y j me c s ( 1 p. 1 !8 . The me e fc t tPli if
o rc nd lr or udg nt ount DE 2, 2, 51
r a t ha antf
i l d t e algai i t br c ofconta t a de lrt y j
ncude hes le tons n he ea h
rc nd caaor udgme co s oft
nt unt
he
A m ended Com pl nt w hen s h alegatons are not el m ent of t e count does not m ake
ai ,
uc l i
e
s
hos
s,

whol c t goresofdocum e sw hi h a e s e y r l va t t a t d ba f t c tr e nta
e ae i
nt
c r ol l e e nt o he ba e d aih oun el va t

ti j n tr .
hs u cue
The a t i ur nce polc l ng
c ual ns a
i y a uage a i s sm pl sa e t f l i
t s ue i y t t s he olow ng:
The c pa s l have t r gh ,but no t dut t a s e c r of t
om ny ha l
he i t
t he y, o s um ha ge
he
i ve tga i s tl m e o d e e ofa c ai m a ,s tbr
n s i ton, e te nt r ef ns
ny l m
de ui ought orpr e ng
,
oce di
i tt e a i ta i ur upon e
ns iut d ga ns ny ns ed
xhaus i oft a i bl unde l ng lm is
ton he pplca e
r yi i t .
I t co pa e r s s h rght i wilnoti si at s tl ordef a
f he m ny xe cies uc i , t l
nve tg e, ete
end ny
cl i , ui orpr e ng a t ri ha e us e t a i a eLi i O fI ur nc of
am s t
oce di f e t s xha t d he pplc bl m t ns a e
t s polc a s a ed i l e 4.of t De a a i . l t c pany doe not
hi
iy s t t n t m
he cl r tons f he om
s
e c s s h rght or i t a i a e unde l ng lm is a e no exha t d,t
xer i e uc i , f he pplc bl
r yi i t r t
us e he
c pa w il ha t rght a w il be gi n t opporuniy, t as oc a e
om ny l ve he i , nd l
ve he
t t o s it
e f tvel w ih t i ur o any unde l ng i ur , bot i t i s i ton,
f ec i y t he ns ed r
ryi ns er or h, n he nve tga i

stlme to d fn eo a ycam,sio po e dn ta i l eyt iv let s
et n r ee s f n li ut r rc e ig h t s i l o n ov hi
e
k
polc I s h e t t l ur t unde l ng i ur r a t c pa s l
i y. n uc ven , he ns ed, he
r yi ns e , nd he om ny hal
c
ooper t i t i s i ton s tl m e or de e e of s
a e n he nve tga i
e te nt
f ns
uch c a m , s t or
li
ui
pr ee ng.
oc di

( 18,Se tonlA1 Dee tsdut t c rt assatd i t i ur nc polcyprvii
DE - ci l . fndan ' y o oopeae t e n he ns a e i o son
d
oes not s e t e i il r quie t t D ef nt i ta e s tl m e di c s ons or a c pt
e m o xplc ty e r ha
enda nii t e te nt s us i
ce
r a ona e s tl m e of e s
e s bl e te nt f r .
The Cour ag ee w ih D ef nda t tt l ngua us d i t alega i oft A m e
t r s t
e nt ha he a
ge e n he l tons he
nded
Co pl i i t ge r l nguag t t Fl i c t ha us d whe de c i ng i tr nc
m a nt s he ne al a
e ha orda our s ve e
n s rbi nsla e
co pa es c m on 1 w du y of g
m ni ' om
a
t
ood f ih. See ie ,Bos on Ol Col y I .Co.v Gute r z
at
, ..
t
d
on ns
. ir e ,

38 So.2d 783,785 ( a.1 . Theeor t Cour wilnotrquieDee
6
F1 980)
rf e, he
t l
e r fndantt pr e
o oduc
doc e s r l va t Def nda ' a l ge f iur t i ta e s t l m ent di c s ons be or and
um nt e e nt o
e nt s le d a l e o nii t e te
s us i
f e

a tr h Asa h nv r ita dalg dr fs l oa c p ra o a estlme t fr a tijmcu e
fe t e tp a edc n le e e u a t c e t e s n bl ete n ofe s th s t tr
be us s h doc e s a e t u y o y r e nt t t ba f ih c
ca e uc
um nt r r l nl el va o he d a t ount w hi h ha be n a t d.
, c
s e ba e
Si pl i l ng ba f ih l ngua i o he c
m y nc udi
d at a
ge n t r ount of t A m e
s he
nded Com pl i t f br a h of
a n or e c
c r ta dec a a or r i fdoesnote il Pl i ift ba f t di c r
ontac nd l r t y ele
ntte a ntf o d aih s ove y.
4

Pl i ifalo a guest ts ve a ca ego i s ofdocum e sa e r l va t s
a ntf s r
ha e r l t r e
nt r e e nt o how D e e nt s
f nda '
i e r ga di D e e nt s r us t i ta e s tl m e ne i tons t a e r s bl
nt nt e r ng f nda ' ef al o nii t e te nt gota i , o cc pt ea ona e
s te e a o s t c rpunii da age , nd t c rt e ie bond a o . H ow e r i
etl m nt m unt , o ove
tve m s a o ove he ntr
m unt
ve , t
i cl a t ta i ur nce c pany' i e ,co
s e r ha n ns a
om
s nt nt nduc ,a belef a e nott be cons de e unde
t nd i s r
o
i rd
r
Fl i 1 w he i e pr tng w he he t i lr nc c pany ha br ac t i ur nc polc
orda aw
n nt r e i
t r he nsz a e om
s e hed he ns a e i y.
The Fl i Su e e Cour ha dec i d t a
orda pr m
t s lne o doptt ç t i ofr s bl e c a i . The e
he s rne ea ona e xpe t tons
doc
r
i no nee f i i t polc pr sons a e a bi uo be us i Fl i am bi tes a e
s
d or t f he i y ovi i
r m g us ca e n or da
guii r
c t ue a i tt i ur r To a y t doc rne t a una bi
ons r d ga ns he ns e .
ppl he t i o n
m guous pr s on w oul be t
ovi i
d
o

rwrt t co rc a t ba i uponwhih t prmi aec ge 'De Asoc .o a.
e ie he nta t nd he ss
c he e ums r har d.' ni s s fFl ,
I . .St eFar FiedrCa l s. , 1So. 11 11 ( a.1 . Furhe , rFl i
nc v at m r
s.n Co.71
2d 35, 40 F1 998)
t r unde orda
l ,1a r
aw t easonabl belef cont ar t t pl n m eani of polcy t --or even t uncl t
e i
r y o he ai
ng
i ext
o
ear ext

c pa e of be ng f i l r ad t pr de co r ge i ir l va t c tuc i of t polc '
a bl
i a ry e o ovi
ve a
s r e e nt o onsr ton
he i y.
'

fe tv. de atdNatIs.Co. 95 So. 454,461( a. hDCA 2007)
nhar Fe r e
.n
, 0 2d
F1 4t
.

Coursi t Sout r DititofFl iaha smiaryf t tCgq t r lva tpolc
t n he hen src
ord ve i l l ound ha,iif he ee n iy
l nguag i c ea a una bi ous t c t us i e t pa te 'i e f om ispl i l ngua
a
e s l r nd m gu , he our m t nf r he r i s nt nt r t a n a
ge,

n tfo e tisce ie c . O hc De tI c v Nat Un o FieI s Co. fpis u gh Pa ,
o r m x rn i vd n e' f e po, n . . ' in r n . o t b r , .
'
l
t
7 4F. u p. d 1 0 1 1 ( D. a 2 0 , f ds bn m.O /c De tI . . t Uno Fie
3 S p 2 3 4, 3 5 S. Fl. 01 ) a u o /z: po, nc v Na ' in r
l
I s Co o t b r , 45 F. px 8 ( 1h Ci. 01 ) M o e v r i u n e Flrdalw,
n . . fpis ugh PA, 3 Ap ' 71 1 t r 2 1. ro e ,t l d r o i a
t
l
t i eprttonofa i ur nc polc i aquesi oflw frt c t' 1 (ii Te hnial
he ntr eai
n ns a e iy s
ton a o he our. d. ctng c c
'

Co i Applc or,I v US.Fi lt d:Guar y Co. 1 F. 8 ( 1h Ci.1
atng
iat s nc. .
deiy
ant , 57 3d 43 1 t r 998:.
The e or ,t Cour f nds t tt doc e s s
r f e he
ti
ha he um nt ough by D ef ntt t pe t i t Def nda '
t
enda ha r a n o
e nts
i ent belef and/ conducti t underyi A s aphan l s t ar notr evantt t pendi
nt , i ,
or
n he
l ng t
aw ui e
el
o he
ng

camsf rb e c o c n rc a dd caao yj d me t n s o dn t eo d rdt b p o u e .
li o ra h f o ta t n e lrt r u g n a d h ul o b r ee o e r d c d
Th Co r' fn i sa o e h we e , r wi u prj diet Pli tf a ii t fl a
e u ts idng b v , o v r ae t t eu c o anifs b ly o ie
ho
t
m oton t c pe s h ba f t di c r a a l t r da e i t ba f t c m ti r i t t d ort
i o om l uc d aih s ove y t a e t f he d aih ot s e ns a e
he
pa te ' c ai s or de e e c
ri s l m
f ns s hange i s h a w a t t m a
n uc
y ha
kes t di c
he s over s
y ough r l va .
t e e nt

Be a et eCo r tnd ta ted c me t s u h aen t ee a t thij ncu e te ei n n e
c us h u ti s h th o u n s o g t r o rlv n a t s u tr ,h r s o e d
t c i r Pl ntf s a gum e abo t s f c enc of D e e nt s prvieg l a t s tm e.
o ons de ai i f r
nt ut he ufi i y
f nda ' i l e og t hi i
M or ove , he e i no nee t de e m i t da e on whi h D e e nta i i t ltga i
e rt r s
d o t r ne he t
c
f nda ntc pa ed ii ton.
Bas d on t f e ng,i i O RD ERE D A ND A DJUD G ED a f l s
e
he or goi t s
s olow :

Pl nifs M oton t Co l ( 57) i DENI W I
aitf
i o mpe DE
s
ED
THOUT PREJUDI t
CE o
Pl ntf sa lt t fl a r ne e m oton t c pe ata l t r da e i t bad f ih c nti
ai if biiy o ie e w d
i o om l
a e t f he
a t ou s
r ns a ed or t pari c ai s or def e c nge i s h a m a r t t m a s t
ei t t
he tes' l m
ens s ha
n uc
nne ha
ke he

di co r s
s ve y oughtr l va .
e e nt
Pl ntf sr ques f t i pos ton ofRul 37 s nc i a i tDef nda i D EN I .
ai if e
t or he m
ii
e
a tons ga ns
e nt s
ED
A s di c s d a t J
s us e t he une 1 201 he r ng,D ef nda i r qui e t e ur t t i ha
2, 8 a i
e nt s e r d o ns e ha t s
pr
oduc al oft r e nts dow f l s t xt m es a ,a ca enda e r e r
ed 1 he el va ha
ie , e s s ges nd l r nti s eque t d by
se
Pl ntf . Once D e e ntha de e m i d whe hera loft s ie sha be n pr
ai if
f nda
s t r ne
t
1 he e t m
ve e oduc d
e
orlsed on t pr vie l D e e ntsco m s s lpr pty notf Pl i ifsc
it
he i l ge og, f nda ' t el hal om l
iy a ntf ouns l
e.
D O N E and O R D ERED i Cha be s t s 1 t da ofJ , 201 atW es Pa m Be c
n
m r hi 5 l y
l
une
8,
t l
a h,
Pal Be ch Co y i t So he n D it i tofFl i
m a
unt n he ut r s rc
orda.

p ,
u
W I A M M A TTH EW M AN
LLI
UNI
TED STA TES M A G I ATE J D GE
STR
U
6