All-Tag Corporation v. Checkpoint Systems, Incorporated

Filing 263

ORDER denying 203 Plaintiff's Motion to Compel and granting in part and denying in part [205-1/223] Defendant's Motion to Strike. Signed by Magistrate Judge William Matthewman on 10/7/2019. See attached document for full details. (kza)

UNI S
TED TATESDI TRI COURT
S CY
SOU TH ERN DI
STRI OF FLORI A
CT
D

Cas No. 1 - v- l - m ir e sM a t wma
e
9: 7 c 8 z6lDi toul a / the
n
A l- Cop .
lTag
,

FI
LED BY

D C.
.

Pl ntf ,
ai i f
V S.

02T 2 2 1
29
ANGEL E.
A NOBL
E
CLERK O S DI CI
SX

Che kpoi tSys e s I ,
c
n
t m , nc.

s. oF/ :. w..
D. u - pa.

Def nda .
e nt

/

ORDER DENYI PLAI FF' M OTI TO COM PEL f 20
NG
NTI S
ON
DE 31
AN D
GRANTI I PART AND DENW NG I PART DEFENDANT' M OTI TO STRI
NG N
N
S
ON
KE

I 20 12231
DE 5- /
TH I CA U SE i be or t Co tu
S
s f e he ur pon Pl i ifA l- g Cor ' M o i n t Com pe M or
a ntf lTa
p.s t o o
l
e
Com pl t A ns e s t 1 s Thi d Se of I e r t i a D oc e s R e ponsve t Is Thid
ee
w r o t
r
t
nt r oga ores nd
um nt
s
i o t
r

Re uetfrPr d cino Do u n s( 2 3 (ç oint Co e' a dDee d n Che k on
q s o o u to f c me t DE 0 ) t to o mp l) n fn a t c p it
M
'
Syse s l ' M oto t Sti Al- g' Ne Afima i Opi on l ope l a Untmel
t m , nc.s
i n o rke lTa s w fr tve ni mpr ry nd
i y

Ofee i t Re u tl p r o Gr e Hu tr P D g 20 -/ 3 (s oint Srke) The e
fr d n he b ta Re o t f a me n e, h. DE 5 122 j E to o ti '. s
M
m at r we er f red t t unde sgne by Urie St t sDiti tJ
te s r e e r o he
ri d
lt d a e src udgeW iln P.Di ir ulas
lim
m to e .

( 51 . hmotonsaef l bree a t Courhedahe rngonbot motonsonSe e be
DE 1Bot i r uly ifd, nd he
t l ai
h i
ptm r
'
23,2019.( 2321 Themoi aerpef rviw.Fort ras s tf t bel t Cour
DE
.
tons r i or e e
he e ons e orh ow,he
t
DENI Plitf lTa sM oi t Co l( 203)a GRANTSI PART a DENI I
ES anifAl- g' ton o mpe DE
nd
N
nd
ES N
PART Defnda Chec ntsM otont Sti ( 205 12 .
e nt
kpoi '
i o rke DE - /232
1.Background

The hi t r a c r n pr ce a posur of t s ca e i i por a t t Cour '
s o y nd ur e t o dur l t e
hi s s m t nt o he
ts
de e m i ton oft t pe ng m o i ns Thi c e wasfl d on N o m be 1 201 al os t
t r na i
he wo ndi
t o . s as
ie
ve r 7, 7, m t wo

y r a ( 1 . M ay4, 8,heCour e ee ashedulngor rsti t tilpe i i
eas go.DE q On
201 t
t ntrd c
i de etng he ra rod n

t sc s frJ n ay6 20 , t ad so eyc t f d t o S p e e 6 2 9.DE 4 1 OnAp i
hi a e o a u r , 20 wi ic v r u o f ae f e tmb r , 01 ( 3 .
h
rl
4, 0 9 t Co r e trda o d r( 1 4 stigteflo n e p r d sl s r d a ln s
2 1 ,he u t n ee n r e DE 0 ) et h o lwig x e t ico u e e di e :
n
Pl i ifsExpe t po ta Dicl m es
antf '
r Re r nd s os

Jme 21 201
t
, 9

D ef nda ' Expe tRe ta D i c osle
e nts
r por nd s l tr s
R e t lExpe tRe t
buta
r por s
Expe t i co r Cut f
r D s ve y of

J 22,201
une
9
Augus 5,201
t
9
Se e be 11 201
pt m r , 9

On M a 1 2018 t Cour a e d ispr o s he i o d r ke pi t s m e ti lda e
y 8,
, he
t m nde t i t c dulng r e , e ng he a r a t

a dp etil c e ue b ti cu i gan tto t rfe t h c re tp ie ma itaej d e (
n r -ra s h d l, u n ld n oain o elc t e or c ar d gsrt u g .DE
51.On J n 5 201 ,t Co r e tn e te dso e y c to ffo S p e e 1 ,201 ,t
)
u e , 9 he u t x e d d h ic v r u -f z m e tmb r 1 9 o
S p e e 1 , 1 ( 1 4 . ee fe,h pa t sa r e t , ndt Co r a o tda odee
e tmb r 8 20 9.DE 6 J Th ra tr te ri g e d o a he u t d p e nd r r d
e
g 1 7, h f lo nga n e e pe t ico u ed a l s
DE 6 ) t e ol wi me d d x r ds ls r e di :
ne
Af
fnna i Expe t po t
tve
r Re rs
Co pl ton ofD e ii ofA 1 Expe t
m ei
pos tons
1
rs
RebutalExpe'Re t
t
l pors
t
Co pl ton ofD e ii ofR e utalExpe t
m ei
pos tons
b t
rs
Fac a Expe t i c r Cut f
t nd
r D s ove y o f

J y 1 201
ul 7, 9
A ugus 9,201
t
9
Augus 23, 9
t 201
Se e be 18, 9
pt m r 201
Se e be 1 201
pt m r 8, 9

Thus i i i
, t s mpora t t Cou ts de e mi to o t pa te ' t pe ng m o i
tnt o he
r' t r nai n f he ris wo ndi
tons
a es e i t s Or r t t t e r dic r de dlne ha pa s dico r i c os d,
ddr s d n hi de ha he xpe t s ove y a i s ve s ed, s vey s l e
C

s t ntve pr -ra m o i a e d Oc obe 11,201 Daub r m o i a e due 60 da bef r
ubsa i
e til tons r ue t r
9,
e t tons r
ys o e

t sa to t tilst wee pei a t tilpei be nsJ nuay6,2020.( 51.
he tr f he ra' wo- k rod, nd he ra rod gi a r
DE 1
Furhe , hi c eha bee e r m e y a unne e s rl ltgi us e pe i ly i t di c r
t r t s as s n xt e l nd
c s a iy ii o , s c a l n he s ove y

p s . ep ris(n c rann npate fo wh m d so e ywa s ug t h v fldc t ls
hae Th a t a d eti o - ris r m o ic v r s o h) a e i omte s
e
e
di c r m o i , es
s ove y tons r pons s a r ple , a unde s l The Cour , n a ef ol t ge t pm i
e , nd e i s m ny
r ea .
t i n f ' o t he
t
es

t c rt,ha r quied t pa test fl numeousj ntnotc s r r ng t nln eous
o oope ae s e r he ri o ie
r oi
ie egadi he lh r
dic r diput . ke p t sc eonta k,t t r i d ha he dl ngt dic r he rngs
s ove y s es To e hi as
r c he mde sgne s l e hy s ove y a i

o No mb r3 , 01 g 7 ) M a 6 2 9g 1 qM a 1 , 9( 1 4 , u e6 201 (
n ve e 0 2 8 DE 3, y , 01 DE 31, y 5 201 DE 4 2J n , 9 DE
1 1 Augus 23,201 ( 200 ,a Se e r23, 9( 2321
65 ,
t
9 DE j nd ptmbe 201 DE
.

Notc i t sOr r t Cour ha had t en e no l s t n 11 s t ntve dic ve y
ountng hi de , he
t s
o t r e s ha
ubsa i
so r

o d r ( 7 ,1 4 1 2 1 2 1 4,1 3 1 7 1 4 1 6 1 7 a d 1 j a d n ls t a 29
r e s DES 5 0 , 2 , 3 , 3 4 , 4 , 6 , 6 , 6 , n 68 , n o e s h n
pr durldic r or r ( 65, 99,1 1 109 111 115 11 1 1 1 1 1
oce a s ove y de s DES 68, 00, 07, , , , 9, 29, 37, 38, 48, 55,
1 1 190,19 19 1 ,204,21 21 221 225,226,238, a 249jFurhe t pates
56, 60,
2, 4, 98
0, 9, ,
248, nd . t r he ri
ha fl ye m o e di c ve y- e a e m otons a t r t d s o r c of da e t t r m a n
ve ied t r s o r r l t d
i - fe he i c ve y ut f t - ha e i

pe dn ( 2 62 9a d2 724 2
n ig.DES 3 / 3 n 3 / 0 .
W ih t sba kgr
t hi c ound i m i t Co t
n nd, he ur now t nst t pa tes t o pe ng m o i t ta e
ur o he r i ' w
ndi
tons ha r

t s j c oft sOr r
he ub e t hi de .
ll.A nal s
ysi

a.Pl ntf Al-raz' M o i t Com pe f 20
ai if lr s ton o
l DE 31
'

Pl ntf A l- s Thid Re
ai if l Tag'
r
ques f r Pr
t o oduc i s e doc e s a c r s
ton e ks
um nt nd or e ponde
nce

( ewe n S n o uai a d Ch c p itrltn t t ej g n 'i ag r s me ta to b o g t
i t e e s n tc n e k on eai g o h ud me t'n anih n cin r u h
b
by De e ntChec i a i tPli if Se o m ai i one ofDe e nts ot rc
f nda
kpo nt gans antf . ns r tc s
f nda ' he ompeior .
tt s
I 2001 De e nt fl a pa e i rnge e s i a i t Pl ntf , Se or tc,a ot r
n
, f nda ied
t nt nfi m nt u t gans ai if ns ma i nd he
c pe ior . e Che k ntSy .I c v Al-ngS c rt uA.e a.31 F.u p.d6 0( D. .
om tt s Se
c poi . w, n . . ll e u i % , t 1 5 s p z 6 E. Pa
a
y
,

20 4 . tratila u yrt me av z it o ted fn a t a d i 20 9 Dee d n wa o d r d
0 )Afe ra, j r eu d ed c f r h ee d n s n ,n 0 , fn a t s r ee
t pay a t ne 'f st t de e n s Se Che k ntS . I .v Al- g Se r t S. , 01
o
tor ys ee o he f nda t . e c poi ys, nc . lTa cu iy A. No. -

CV2223,2011 W L 5237573 ( D.Pa Nov.2,2011.Bu Dee nt a ald t tr i
E.
.
) t fnda ppe e ha ulng,
e nm a l a di t f e a s s e .Fu - r D e e ntwase il d t r m bur e e f t
ve ly voi ng he e s s es m nt l he , f nda
t
ntte o ei
s m nt or he
cos of a bond i pos ed t pur ue appeal oft atonz
t
t t o s
s he t eys'f as m ent See Check ntSys.
ees sess
.
poi
,

I .v Al- gSe urt u ,e al,858F. 1 ( d.Ci.201 )
nc . lTa c i %A. t .
y
3d 371 Fe r 7 .
De e ntChec ntt n i ta e aga nihmen a ton i t sDititf rt c toft
f nda
kpoi he niit d
r s
t c i n hi src o he os he
bond a i tPl i ifA1- g,but Se o m a i, antf sc de e nti t pae ltgai n,
gans antf lTa
not ns r tc Pl i if' o- f nda n he tnt ii to
w hi h pu poredl ha a r dy t nde e ha ft cos oft bo Se Chec poi S . I .v A1c z t y d lea e r d l he t he nd. e
k nt ys, nc . 1

T gSe u i S. , ta.No 9 1 - - 0 4( D. a) S n omai a dDe e d n e c p ru d
a c rt A.e l . :9 mc8 71 S. Fl.. e s r tc n fn a t a h u s e
y
,
s pa a er c r e aga ns Pl i tf , ih D e e ntpur ui t f lc toft bond f om Pl i if
e r t e ove i s i t a n i f w t f nda
s ng he ' os he
ul
r
a ntf
i vi ualy. Pl i if a l ges D e e nt a Se o m a i c l bor t d i pur ui Pl i if
ndi d l
a ntf le
f nda nd ns r tc ola a e n
s ng a ntf
s pa a e y a pa to D e e nt Chec nts E at tant- om pe ii t c i 'i e d t G r e
e r t l s r f f nda
kpoi ' ' es ic
l
ttve a tc' nt nde o û e ze
f

Al- gsa st. g 2 3 p.) Thsg mih n a to i tef c so Pli ifsmoi na dte
lTa ' s es' DE 0 , 1. i a s me t cin s h o u f ant ' to n h
'
f
diput dic ve y r quess
s ed s o r e t .

De e d n o j cst Plit fsr q ssf rp o u to r ltd t t ep irg r ih n
fn a t be t o ani e uet o r d cin eae o h ro a ns me t
f
ac i n as ir e nt l D e e n ' vi w , t ga ni hm e ac i i unr a e t a of t
to
r el va . n f nda t s e he r s nt ton s el t d o ny
he

ale to i Pl i ifs Se nd Am e d Compl i .Thi i bec us ,Pl i ifC
lgai ns n antf' co
nde
ant s s a e antf t d ne rbe
woul ve

a et ag t a ac le to pr c e igiiitdt e fr ealwf l e trdj g n c u dbe
bl o r ue h t o lcin o e dn ntae o n o c a ul n ee ud me t o l
y
a me ns of a i mpeii c
a
ntco ttve onduc.'( 208,p.j To De e nt Plitf s r uet fr
t' DE
1.
f nda , anif eq s o
pr uc i n a ount t C n a tm ptt ha as Che poi a tir l va c l t r li s t ta e
od to m
s o ç te
a
o r s
ck nt bou r e e nt ola e a s ues ha r
nowhe e aleg i A l- g' pl a ngs' 1
r l ed n lTa s e di . d.
'
A le a i l D e e ntc e t t e n i t ga ni hm entac i n i r l va he e and
t m tve y, f nda ont nds ha , ve f he r s
to s e e nt r
Pl i i fr i e t i s i is pl a ngs i i G m m t i d' f om a pot nta a ir t labiiy
a ntf a s d he s ue n t e di , t s t
i m ze ' r
ny e i l ntt us i lt
r s tng f om t ga nihm e a ton be a e oft N oe r pe ngt n doc rne,whi h Gs el a
e uli r he r s nt c i
c us
he
r - nni o
ti
c shi ds
de e ntf o a inz tla lt f r s tng t ltg ton t obt i f om a co t a i m pe ii
f nda r m ntt s i biiy or e or i o ii a i o a n r
ur an ntco ttve

o to . An r Pha ms,l c v Eln Cop.PLC, 21F.d 1 2 ,1 3 ( 1hCi. 0 5 . u ,
uc me' d x r . n . . a r ,
'
4 3 2 7 2 3 1 t r 2 0 ) Th s
Ehedic yAl- g s e i pontes a ha no va uet tzsc e'asS c i tca
'
t
s over lTa e ks s i l s nd s
l o li as ' t kpo n nnotbe
che

s j c t poe il a ir t la lt fr smpl e r sng is lwf rght t purue't
ube t o tnta nttus ibiiy o i y xecii t a ul i o s ' he
gar s ntacin a i tPli if g 208 p. .
nihme to gans antf DE , 3)

Plitf Al -a a g e i rpl ta ()c o dn to b t e De e d n Ch c pon a d
anif lf g r u s n e y h t 1 o r iain ewe n fn a t e k it n
Se o tc i t pr vi us g ni hm e a to i r l va C s i r vea s Che kpoi ' ye r -ong
ns nua i n he e o ar s nt c i n s e e nt c t e l
a
c nt s a s l

c mpag o a t-o eiiec nd c a an tisc mpei r'a d ()De e d n i n te tte t
a i n f nic mp ttv o u t g is t o tt s' n 2 fn a t s o n ild o
o

i m uniy r r ng t prora ton unde N oe r pe n on be a e D e e ntm i r pr e e t
m
t ega di he i c i
r r - nni gt
c us f nda
s e es nt d o
t Co ti t ga ni hm e a ton t tPl i if o e i t e ie c t o t bond,e n t ug
he ur n he r s nt c i ha a ntf w d t he ntr os f he
ve ho h
Se or a i pup or e y ha a r ad t nde e ha f of i.Se Cal M ot Tr p.Co v Tr k ng
ns m tc
t dl d le y e r d l
t e
. or ans
. . uc i

Un i td, 0 U. 5 8 51 ( 9 2 ; J sph'Hop.I c v Hop. r o , 9 F.d9 ,
lmie 4 4 S. 0 , 3 1 7 ) &. o e s s , n . . s Cop.fAm.7 5 2 48

9 5( 1hCi. 9 6 . an if l g sDee d n d dn tds ls S ns r tc stn e t teCou
5 1 t r 1 8 ) Plitf al e fn a t i o ico e e o mai' e d ro h tt
e
nor di i dicos is c l bor to wih Se or i Thus Pl i if a gue De e
d t s l e t ola ai n t ns matc.
, antf r s f ndan i not
ts
i m une t a inz tla lt r s tng f om t ga ni hm e ac i n, nd s t r que t pr
m
o ntt s i biiy e uli r he r s nt t o a o he e s ed oduc i
ton
i r l va a s ul be pr
s e e nt nd ho d
oduc d.
e
The Coul fndst tt Noe r pe ngt n doc r ne a i . nPenni on, 1U . a 51
' i ha he r - nni o
t
t i pples I
ngt 38 S. t 3,
t U nie St t Cour ofA ppe sf t El ve h Cic ts m a i d t t s o ca esi whi h
he t d a es
t
al or he e nt r ui um rze he ype f s n
c

c ut s d e mpt a ir t de e a s fo la lt f obt i ng fom a co ' a
ot' houl xe
s
nttus f nd nt r m ibiiy or
ani r
ul n
t
antcom pettve out e'
i
ii
com .

Oppo nt be o e ag i s orco t ofe t nk poory o t ot rs t ci s
ne s f r enc e
urs tn hi
l f he he ' a tc ,
m o i ,ordef ns s a m a r diy c l t m ba ees .One ca m,whi h a
tons
e e nd y ea l a l he
sl s
li
c
co torag nc ma t nk ba ees ,ma g unnotc d; apa tr ofba ees ,
ur
e y y hi
sl s y o
ie but te n
sl s
r pettve c am s m a e e ge whih lads t f ti r t c ncude t tt
e ii l i
y m r
c e
he acfnde o o l
ha he

a miitai a j d ca p o e s sha eb e a u e . tma beadfiut
d n srtve nd u iil r c s e v e n b s d Tha y
ifc l
lne t dic r a dr w.Bu o i i dr wn,t ca e i e tbls d t ta e
i o s e n nd a
t nce t s a
he s s s a ihe ha bus
of t e pr e s pr
hos oc s es oduce a il ga r s t e f tvel ba rng r s nde s
d n le l e ul, f ec i y r i e po nt

fom a e st t age isa c t.I ofra t a mi srtveo j iil
r cc s o he nce nd ours ns a s he d nitai r udca
pr e s a ei ve aci oft tki cam o a uiei t t by s ki
oc s es r nvol d, tons ha nd l t cq r mm miy
ee ng
r f t de t um br la ofC ltc le e s o '
e uge m r he
el
t ii a xpr s i n.
po
'
Pe n on,381U. a 51 . e eg. St J e ' Hos ,I . 795 F. a 955.He e,t Cour
nnigt
S. t 3,se , . , . osph j p. nc,
2d t
r he
t
tndst tDef nda Che kpoi ' c nd ti t ga nihme ltga i bew e n i a Al- g t
i
ha
e nt c nts o uc n he r s nt ii ton t e t nd lTa o
be f r f o G pa t r ofbas l s ,r pettve cl i s ...whi h l adst f t i e t co l t t
a r m ( te n
a
e e s e ii a m
c e
he ac fnd r o nc ude ha

t a nitai a j ca pr ese ha bee a e 'Pe .gtn,381U. a 51 I d,
he dmi srtve nd udiil oc s s ve n bus d.' nnl o
n
S. t 3.ndee
as D e e nt a gues i Pl ntf A l- g wi hed t c l nge t ga ni bm e ac i n,t pr pe
f nda r , f ai if l Ta
s
o hale
he r s nt to he o r
tm e a pl et do s wasi t tac i n, he e. ns ea no o y di Pl i ifnotc l nge t
i nd ac o
o
n ha t o not r l t d, t nl d a ntf
hale
he

ganihme a ton a amirpr e ain,i agr d t afna j me ofgamilme a i t
r s nt ci s
se esntto t ee o i l udg nt
l sa nt gans

is l f t f l a o owedt De e nt Se Che k ntS . l c.v Al- Se urt S. ,et
t ef or he ul m unt
o f nda . e
c poi ys, n . lTag c i A.
y

a.No 9:9 mc8 71 ( D. a)a L 2 1
l, . 1 - - 0 4 S. F1. t DE 7 .
Pl ntf cannotnow accus D ef
ai if
e
endantof engagi i f aud i t gar shm entacton and
ng n r
n he ni
i

s e t atc t tud me t nt i a to a tri a re t ta j d me ta dfie t c aln ei
e k o ta k ha j g n i h s cin fe t g e d o h t u g n n ald o h le g t
a fa u e tAl o g Pli t fma dhikpo ry'o De e d n ' tcisa e nGhn g m)
s rud ln . t u h ani y ç n o l ' f f n a ts a tc nd ve t ik t
h
f
t
t
he
b sls , i h sfie t e tbl ht a Dee d n ' a to E fe t l (a e j( an if fo
a ee s' t a ald o sa i h t fn a ts cins t f ci y b n-d Plitfl rm
'
s
e ve
ac es t t a nce a co t' o t tt ganihme a to G oduc a il lr ulll'
c s o he ge is nd urs' r ha he r s nt cin t
pr ed n lega es t.'
Pe n on,381U . a 51 Thus D e e a i i m uni e f o a inztla lt f r s r i t
nni gt
S. t 3.
, f nd nt s m
z d r m ntt s i biiy or e o tng o

l iaint c l c o i j g n a an t anifa dPlit fsr q e tdd s o r i irlv n
i g to o ol t n t ud me t g i s Plitf n ani ' e u se ic vey s ree a t
t
e
s
f
t t s a ir s a ton.
o hi ntt u t c i

The Cour a s fnds t t dic r Pl ntf Al- g s ks by wa ofis m o i n i
t lo i hat he s ove y ai if lTa ee
y
t
to s

irlva ta diprpori eunde Fe R.Ci P.26() 1, eHankiso v R. Fur t e
ree n nd s o tonat
r d. v.
b () se
n n . TG. niur

Cop.No. 5c 81 3 , 01 W L 1 8 7 8 a * ( D. a M a. , 1 )( ic si gr lv n e;
r , 1 -v- 1 9 2 6
1 2 6 , t 1 S. Fl. r 28 20 6 ds u sn ee a c )
Ti rv Dyn mi S rsNurto , LC, 1 -v 1 01 2 6W L 1 8 9 , t* ( . F a Ap .
ge . a c po t tiin . No. 5c - 7 , 01
L
40 0 8 a 2 M D. l. r
1 ,2 6 (ic sn p o o t nai ) a d t ul c u et p rist r n d wn a rb thoe
1 01 ) dsusig r p ri ly , n t d a s he a t o u o
o t
wo
e
a bi l
c i ir l va i or a i o c l t r l m a t r , r s tng i t ne e s a w a t f l
hasng r e e nt nf m ton n ola e a
te s e uli n he edl s nd
se'
u

e ndt eoftm ea mone byt pa te . O ' o ev.
xpe iur
i nd
y he ri s' B yl Sweea e, 1 c 81
'
tppl No. 4-v- 250, 6 W L
201

4 2 55 a * ( D. a Fe 8 2 6 . rhe,e urngDee d n t p o u et d so eys ug t
9 6 ,t 5 S. Fl. b. , 01 )Fu t rrq ii
fn a to r d c he ic v r o h
w oul be t dul bur ns e e ns ve, nd lke y c us a del y i t s c s
d m y de om , xpe i a i l a e
a n hi a e.

F0 alt a
r 1 he bove ras ,Pli ifAl- s moton t c
e ons antf lTag' i o ompeldic r r 2031i
s ovey DE
s
D EN I .
ED

b.De e
f ndantChe kpo ntsM oto t St ke ( 205- /
c i '
i n o ri DE
1 2231
Tunzng t De e ntChe poi ' M o i t Sti Pli i sNe Afim ai Opi on
i o f nda
ck nts ton o rke antY
w fr tve ni

I opel a UntmeyOfee i t Re tlRe r o Gre HuntrPh. r 205-/ J
mpr ry nd i l frd n he buta po t f a me
e, D DE
1223 ,

De e n a gu t Cour s ul srke Se ton I oft r buta r po tofPl i ifAl- g'
f nda t r es he
t ho d ti
ci V
he e tl e r
antf lTa s
e r w ines ,D r G r e e H unt r ashi r por i untm e y a r s a e ie y ne t y of
xpe t t s . a m
e,
s e t s i l nd aies n ntr l w heor
da age . a ntf c e isr po t astm e y a t tis Se nd A m ende Co pl n pr ry
m s Pl i if ont nds t e r w i l nd ha t co
d m ai t ope l
pl d ale na i t r e ofda age .
e t r tve heo i s
m s
The Cour fnds t t D r H unt r s r butal e r r po ti untm e y.A lhoug Pl ntf
ti
ha .
e ' e t xpe t e r s i l
t
h ai if

a gue Dr Hunt rsr por i pr pe l co i r daS e t 'r por,Dr Hunt rhi efm a cla
r s .
e ' e t s o ry nsde e t butal' e t .
r
e ms l de e r
t t Seci 1 I,a I1ofhi opi on a e it nd t r butt r por ofone ofDe e nts
ha
tons , I nd I
s ni r n e ed o e
he e t
f nda '

ex rs M s lwi whieSecin I ofhi rpor i C nafr tverpor ( ba e onM s Iwi s
pet, .l n, l to V
s e ts s fimai e t ) s d
a
.r n'
a oa h. ( 205- p. Thus Se i I ofDr Huntrsrpo ti ce ryane afr tve
ppr c ' DE
'
3, %. , cton V
. e ' e r s lal
w fimai
opi on.
ni

A pro Cour or rr quie t pa test s r e e c ot rwih t i a fr ai e r
ir
t de e r d he ri o e v a h he t her fim tve xpe t

rporsby J y 1 201 a t rrbuta e r rporsby Augus 23,201 g 16 .On J y
e t ul 7, 9, nd hei e tl xpe t e t
t
9.DE 72
ul
1 201 Pl n ifs r d De e ntwih Dr Huntr safima i e r r por.The on Augus
7, 9, aitf e ve
f nda
t .
e ' fr tve xpe t e t
n,
t
23,201 Pl i i f s r ed D e e nt w ih D r H un e ' pur r e r b t r pol .A s di c s d
9, a ntf e v
f nda
t
.
t r s po t d e utal e '
t
s us e

a ve Seci n I ofDr Hunt rsrpor i pr pe l c i r d a ne a fr a i e r o ni n,
bo , to V
.
e ' e t s o ry onsde e
w fim tve xpe t pi o
r t rt n a r butalr por.Thus Pl i ifwa r quied t s r De e ntwih i by J y 1
ahe ha
e t e t
, antf s e r o e ve f nda
t t
ul 7,
201 t a fr a i e r r por de dlne notA ug t23,
9, he fi m tve xpe t e t a i ,
us
2019 t r buta r pol de i l
, he e t l e ' adlne.
t

Ha ng de i Pl i ifs e l r por wa u i y, t Cour mus c i r wha
vi
cded antf ' xpe' e t s ntmel he
t
t
t onsde
t
r medy t i
e
o mpos E3 ca et e twine sdic r r esa e de i d t al bot sde i
e. c e us he xper t s s ove y ul r sgne o low h i s n
l
a c s t pr pa e t r c es a qua e y a t pr nt s r i e . . . co pla e wih t
a e o e r hei as de t l nd o eve u prs
m i nc
t he

r uie nt ofRul 26 i notm e ey a pia i l' Coo v,Sout n Co. 390 F.d 695,728
eq r me s
e
s
r l s r tona .
' per
her
,
3

( 1h Ci. 0 4 (ne n lctto so te ) Fe . Ci P. () 1 isn csta whee: p ry
1 t r 2 0 ) itr a iai n mitd . d R. v. 37c () n tzt h t r $ a t
a

lfPlitfne e a etnino t t c mplfl wi teJ y1 , 1 a maieepetrp ldslsr
I anif edd n xeso fi o o y ul t h ul 7209,mr tv x r eo' icoue
me
y h
t

dea i ,i s d ha m ove f s h a ext ns on prort t J y 1 2019,de i ,r t rt n a t m ptt s i
dlne t houl ve
d or uc n e i l o he ul 7,
adlne a he ha te
o lp
anafim ai e r opi oni oar tp r tonAugu t23, 9.
fr tve xpe t ni nt ebu tl epor
s
201

7

fist p o iei fnuain. . srq ie b Rul 26a o () tepat i n i lo dt u et a
al o r v d n o to . a e urd y e () r e,h ry s o alwe o s h t
i onuai o wine s ...ulls t fiur wa s t talyj tfed orha ml s'See eg.
nf ton r t s
le s he al e s ubsani l usii
r es. , . ,
'
Pots v R. Re dsTobac o Co.9:5-vih . J ynol
c
, 1 c 81171,201 W L 59528 a * 4 ( D.Fl No
7
92, t 2- S. a. v.
30,201 ;Manage Car Sol.I .v. s He t e I .09-v- 351 201 W L 1 24,
7)
d e s, nc Esent alhcar, nc, c 60 , 0
8377

a * ( D. a M a 3 2 0 .Th b r e o s wig t a afiu et ds ls o c mp y wa
t 3 S. Fl. y , 01 ) e u d n f ho n h t alz o ico e r o l s

s bsa tal j si do hamls i o t en n d sl sngpa t M i h lv Fo dMo o Co, 8
u tnil u tfe r r e s s n h o - ico i ry. t el . r t r .31
y
c
Fe Appx.8 ,8 ( 1hCi.2009 .Excuso i as a a opraerme underFe R.Ci
d.
21 24 1 t r
) l in s lo n ppr it e dy
d. v.

P. 6 b , iha to ie t ec u toc nr l nde p dt p era d s o r t r u hash d l g
1 ( )wh c uh rz s h o r t o to a x e i rtil ic vey h o g c e ui
e
n
o de a g ve t c tbr d di c e i n t pr s l t i eg iy a pur e ofa pr t i lor r
r r nd i s he our oa s r to o e e ve he nt rt nd pos
e ra de ,

i l ngt e l i n ofe d nc Companhi Ene getcPotguarv Cat r larl .N o.1 c
nc udi he xc uso
vi e e.
a
r i
i
. epil nc,
4- v-

24277,201 W L 310
6
2225,a *5( D.Fl.Jme2,201 )
t S. a t
6.
Pli ifAl-fa a gue is f iu e t tmel dic os Seci n I o Dr Hunt rsz po' i
a ntf l-'g r s t al r o i y s l e to V f .
e' e z s
t

ha ml sa dhe ewasnot ngi Dr Huntrsrbuta rpor t tca e anyprj c orham t
r es s i r
t
hi n . e ' e tl e tha us s
eudie
r o

Ch c p itsp e aain f rter me y p a eo ti c s . ( 21 ,p.j Bu t i i ce ry
e k on ' r p rto o h e d h s f h s a e' DE 4 4 . t hs s lal
'
wr
ong.A s di c s d a
s us e bove,Se ton I ofD r H unt r sr po ti a ne a f r a i e r o ni
ci V
.
e' e r s
w f i m tve xpe t pi on
t tPl i i fw a r quied t s r ' D e e ntbe o et J y 1 201 a fnua i e r r pol
ha a ntf s e r o e ve on f nda
f r he ul 7, 9, f i tve xpe t e '
t

d a ln . n t a ,i s l dhi rpo to emo t ltro Aug t23 20 9. rt pa t s j it
e d ie I se d t ewe s e r n nh ae n us , 1 Pe he ri ' on
e
a re n a dt eCo r' p irOr e g 1 7 ,terp r (ra la tS cin I o t erp r)
g e me t n h u ts ro d r DE 6 j h e o t o t e s e to V f h e o t
wa dueJ y 17,201 a dico r i t sc s cl edonSe e r18 201 ( 1 .Thus
s
ul
9, nd s ve y n hi a e os
ptmbe , 9. DE 67J
,
D e e ntChe kpoi no l ng rha a tm el f t r butD r Hunt r s a âz a i opi o
f nda
c
nt o e s ny i e t o e
.
e ' f m tve ni n.
A lo i Pl i if t no us Se to I of D r H unt r s r pol w oul be ha m fz a
l w ng a ntf o w e c i n V
.
e' e '
t
d
r tl nd

s veeyprj ca t Dee nt Pe t af vi ofKrsenSoi,Dee ntsUSConr lr i
e rl eudiil o fnda . r he ûda t
it fa fnda '
tole,f
D e e nti r qui e t r s nd t Se ton I ofD r H t e ' r po t i w oul t ke is s a ftl e
f nda s e r d o e po o c i V
. mt r s e r , t
d a t tf l e
r

m o hst gahe t ne s a y da aa r quie i t e oy t f l-i e sa fac ount nt t do
nt o t r he ce s r t nd e r t o mpl wo u ltm t f c a s o

8

s ( 22 - , 3 .ft Co r weet i ta gv Dee a taf i o po tnt t rb tS cin
o.DE 3 3 p.) l he u t r o nse d ie fnd n ar p ru iy o e u e to
I o D r H u e ' r por,i woul s gnii a l del y t s ca e r uie a m odii a i of c r a n
V f . nt r s e t t
d i f c nty a hi s , eq r
f c ton
e ti
pr -r a de dlne a m os i pora l t ti lda e,a unf il a ol Pl i if o vi a i
e t i l a i s nd, t m tnty, he r a t nd a ry bs ve a ntf f ol tng

t Cour' Jme7, 9Or rg 1 . sc eha bee pe ngf amos t ye r. ai if
he
ts t 201 de DE 671Thi as s n ndi or l two as Pl ntf
AllTag ha had pl nt of tm e t ga he expe t a pr de t r z po t i a tm e y m a r
s
e y
i o t r
rs nd ovi hei e r s n i l
nne .

Pli if sdea i c
a ntf' ly n ompl ngwih ise r dicos eo i tonswilnotbepe m i e l i tm e
yi
t t xpe t s l ur blga i
l
r t d. t s i
l
f t d s ve y a e r di c os r s a oft s c e t be c os d s t Cour c n f us on
or he i co r nd xpe t s l u e t ge hi as o
l e o he
t a oc
s t ntve m o i a ti l
ubs a i
tons nd r a .
1 C oncl on
11.
usi

Bas on t f eg ng, ti he e ORDERED t t
ed he or oi i s r by
ha :
Pl i if A l- s M oto t Co pe M or Co pl t Ans e s t 1s Thid Se of
a ntf lTag'
in o m l
e m ee
w r o t
r
t
l e r t i a D oc e s R e pons ve t ls Thid R e s f Pr
nt r oga ores nd
um nt
s
i o t
r
que t or oduc i of
ton

Do l n s( 2 3 i DENI
cl t DE 0 ) s
me
ED.
De e n Chec poi ' M o i t Sti Al- s Ne Afim ai Opi on
f nda t
k nts
ton o rke lTag'
w
fr tve
ni

I r pel a dUn i l öfee i teRe utl p r o Gre Hu tr PID.DE
mp o ry n tmey fr d n h b t Re o t f a me n e, A (
a
.
205-/ )i GRANTED I PART a DENI I PART,asf l :
1223 s
N
nd
ED N
olows
t

Se ton I o t R e t a Re r of G r em e Ht t r Ph. i sr c n.
c i V f he bu t l po t
a
m e , D s ti ke

Pl i ifmay no r l u
antf
t e y pon orot r s us et r die l o i r ty,
he wie e, ihe r cty r ndiecl
Sec i n I oft Reb t lRe ' of Gr m e H unt r Ph. ,ata poi i
to V
he
uta pol
t
ae
e, D
ny nt n
t s c e, nc udi i dipostve m o i ,r s ns ,ora ti l
hi as i l ng n s ii
tons e po es
t ra .
D NE and O RD ERED i c m be s a W es Pa m Bea h,Pa m Bea h Count Fl r da
n ha r t
t l
c
l
c
y, o i ,

ti 1RaoOt e,09
h dy f cbr21.
s
o
W I AM M ATTHE
LLI
N
Unied St esM agitat J
t at
s r udge

9