All-Tag Corporation v. Checkpoint Systems, Incorporated

Filing 265

ORDER denying 216 Defendant Checkpoint's Motion to Strike. Signed by Magistrate Judge William Matthewman on 10/7/2019. See attached document for full details. (kza)

UNI
TED STA TES D I
STRI COU RT
CT
SOU THERN D I
STRI OF FLORI A
CT
D
Cas N o. 9: 7- v- l - i if ea / a t wm a
e
: 1 c 8 z6l D m t oul s M the
n
A l- Cor ,
lTag p.

FI
LED BY

D. .
C

Pl i tf ,
a n if
V S.

02T 2? 2 1
29
ANGEL E.
A NOBL
E
CL
ERK U S DI .
ST CX

Checkpoi Sys em s,l ,
nt t
nc.

s.. F /. w, .
o oF k - RB
D e e nt
f nda .
/

ORDER DENYI DEFENDANT CH ECK POI S M O TI TO STRI E ( 216
NG
NT'
ON
K DE
1
TH I CAU SE i be or t Cour on D e enda Che kpoi ' M oton t St i A l- g
S
s f e he
t
f
nt
c nt s
i o rke l Ta
Cor ' A m e
p.s
nded Rul 26 D i c os e ofProrLa s tD e
e
s l ur s
i
w ui pone ,a t Excl The rTesi ony,
nt nd o
ude i
tm

o i t eAle t f rLi tdDic veyEx e in g 21 )(t oint Srke'. smatr
r n h tmai o mi
ve
e s o r tnso DE 6 t to o ti ' Thi te
M
)
wasr e e t t undesgne byUniedSttsDititJ W ila P. mir e s ( 51.
efn-d o he ri d
t ae src udge lim Di toula . DE 2

Pli iffld a rs ns o Oco e 1 2 9 DE 2 4 .De e d n fie t r py t Plitf'
ant ie epo e n tb r , 01 .( 4 J fn a t ald o e l o an ifs
f
he s ns e or h l
he
t
rs
e pons . Acc di y, t s m a t r i rpe f r r vi w .For t m a o s tf t be ow ,t Cour
e l or ngl hi te s i o e e
D EN I D e e ntChe kpoi ' M oto t Sti
ES f nda
c nt s
i n o r ke.
1.B ackground

The hit y- nd c r nt p oc dur l posur o t s c s i i
sor '
a
ure r e a
t e f hi a e s mpora t t Co ts
tnt o he ur'
de e m i ton oft t o pe ng m otons Thi c s w a fl d on N ove be 1 201 a m os t
t r na i
he w
ndi
i . s a e s ie
m r 7, 7, l t wo

y a sa o.DE 1 . M a 4 2 8 t eCo l e tr dashe ui o d rstigt etil ro i
e r g ( ) On y , 01 ,h u' n ee c d l r e et h ra pei d n
t
ng
n
t sc s f rJ n ay6 20 , t ads o eyc tf d t o Se tmb z6 2 9 g 4 2 OnAp i
hi a e o a u r , 20 wi ic v r uo f ae f pe e , 01 .DE 3 .
h
rl
4, 1 t Cour e ee a o d ( 10 sti t f l nge r dicoslede dlne :
20 9,he
t ntrd n r er DE 4) etng he olowi xpe t sl tr a i s
Pl i i f sExpe' Re ta D i c oszes
a ntf'
l por nd s l lr
t
De e ntsExpe tRe ta Dicos e
f nda '
r por nd s l ur s

J me 21 201
t
, 9
Jme 22,201
t
9

1 u sa tt teCoutsOr e Set gDic v r P o e u e( 5 1Dee d n' rpywa d eo o b fr
P ru n o h
r' d r ti so ey r c d r DE 3, fn a ts e l s u n r eoe
n
Oct be 4,201
o r
9.

RebutalExpertR e s
t
port
Expe' D i c r Cu of
l s ove y t f
t

A ugus 5,2019
t
Se e be 11 201
pt m r , 9

O n M ay 18,2018,t Courtam ended ispri s
he
t or chedulng or keepi t sam e ti dat
i
der,
ng he
r al e

andpr tils he e,buti l ng anottont rfe tt c r tpard ma srt j .(
e-ra c dul
ncudi
ai o elc he orec ie gitae udge DE

51.On J n 5 2 9 te Co r e tnd d t e ds o e y c to ffo Se tmb r 1 ,2 9 t
2
u e , 01 , h u t xe e h ic v r u - f r m p e e 1 01 , o
Se tmbe 1 , 01 .DE 1 4 . ra tr t p risa re t , n t eCo r a o tda do d r d
p e r 8 2 9 k 6 1Thee fe,he a t g e d o a d h u t d pe n r ee
e
g 1 ,hef l nga nde e r ds l ur de dlne
DE 674t olowi me d xpe t icos e a i s:
Jul 17,2019
y
Af im a i Expe tRe t
fr tve
r por s
Com pl t o ofD e ii ofA 1 Expe t
ei n
pos tons
1
rs
A ugus 9,201
t
9
Re t lExpe t po t
buta
r Re r s
A ugus 23,201
t
9
pt mbe 8, 9
Com pl ton o D e ii ofRe t lExpe t Se e r 1 201
e i f pos tons
buta
rs
Se e be 1 201
pt m r 8, 9
Fa ta Expe tDi co r Cut f
c nd
r s ve y of

Thus i i i por a t t Cou ts d e m i to of t pa tes t o pe ng m o i ns
, t s m t nt o he
r ' et r na i n
he r i ' w
ndi
to
dlnes ve s d, s ove y s l e
a e s d i t s Or r t t t e r di c ve y dea i ha pas e di c r i c os d,
ddr s e n hi de ha he xpe t s o r
,

s t i pr tilm otons a e due Ocobe 11 201 Daube tm otonsa e due 60 da be or
ubsantve e-ra
i
r
t r , 9,
r
i
r
ys f e

t sar oft tilst we kpe i a t tilp:i begnsJ nua y6, 20.( 51.
he t t he ra' wo- e rod, nd he ra rod i a r 20 DE J
Furhe , hi ca ehasbe n e r m e y a t ne s a iy ltgi , s ci ly i t di c r
t rt s s
e xte l nd m ce s r l ii ous e pe a l n he s ove y

pha e. pa te (ndc ranno pa te fom who dic r wa s
s The ris a e ti n- ris '
r
m s ovey s ought ha fldco ls
) ve ie unte s
dico r m o i , es e , ndr ple , a unde s alTheCour,i a efo t oge t pa te
s ve y tons r pons s a e i s m ny
re .
t n n f r t t he ri s

t c peae h s rq ie t e pate t fl n meo sj itn tc s rg r ig t nl r u
o oo r t, a e ur d h ris o i u r u on o ie e a dn he l o s
e
me
dico r diput s Toke t sc s on ta k,heunde sg hashed lng hy d s o r he rngs
s ve y s e .
ep hi a e r c t
r i ned
l e t i c ve y a i

o No e r 0 2 8( 7 1 M a 6 2 1 ( 1 1 M a 1 , 01 E 1 4 ,u 6 2 9(
n v mbe 3 , 01 DE 3 , y , 0 9 DE 31, y 5 2 9 DE 4 1 J ne , 01 DE
l ,Augus 23,2019r 2001 a Se e r23,201 g 232 .
654
t
DE
, nd ptmbe
9 DE )
Not c ntng t s Or r t Cou ' ha ha t e e no l s t n 1 s t i di co r
ou i hi de , he
r s d o nt r
t
es ha 2 ubs antve s ve y

or r E 75,1 22,1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 a 263) a nol st n 34
de s DES
04,1 32, 34, 43, 47, 64, 66, 67, 68, nd
, nd es ha
pr e a dic r or r ( 65 68, 1 1 1 ,111 11 11 1 1 1 1 1
oc durl s ove y des DES , 99, 00, 07, 09 , 5, 9, 29, 37, 38, 48, 55,
1 1 190 1 1 1 204,
56, 60, , 92, 94, 98,
210, 9,221 225,
21
,
226, ,243,251 252,253,
238
,
260, ,a
261 nd

2 3 . rhe t ep rish v fldy t r ds o ey r ltdmoins a trteds o r c t f
6 1Fu t r h a t a e ie e mo e ic v r -eae to - fe h ic vey u of
e
dae t tr manpe ng.( 236239,2372402
t- ha e i ndi DES /
/ .
W ih t sba kg o i m i t Cour no t r t D e e nt sM o i t St i
t hi c r und n nd, he
t w u ns o f nda '
ton o r ke.

I .Pe ngDiput Underyi Dee
l ndi s e
l ng fndantChe
ckpoi ' M o i t St keI 21
nts ton o ri DE 6)
The Cour' M a 1 2019 Or r( 1 ,r uie Dee ntChe kpoi t pr e
ts y 6,
de DE 47j eq rd fnda
c nt o oduc

c ran d po iin ta s rp sfo ap irlws t (h ( S Tr n cit' a od r dPlitf
eti e sto r n cit r m ro a ui te I
z
US a s rp s' nd r e e an if
)
Al- g t pr
lTa o ompty i or De e ntwhehe i i e t r y on a oft USS Tr ns rpt i
l nf m f nda
t r t nt nds o el
ny he
a ci s n
s
uppor ofa m oto ori r ducea oft de ii a s tntvee de a ti .The a
t ny
in nto
ny he postons s ubsa i vi nce t ral n, t
as e ntJ 6, 9 hea i t Cour, ponDe e ntsr s, de e Pl ntf t i onn
ubs que une 201 , rng, he
tu
f nda ' eque tor r d ai if o nf

De e ntofisi e
f nda
t ntndedus ofa oft USS Tr ci sbyJ 20,201 ( 21 1 p.24e ny he
ansrpt une
9. DE 6- ,

22
5.
Defnda ' Moton t Sti ( 21 tkes is wih Pli ifs a nde Rul 26
e nts i o rke DE 62 a sue t antf' me d e
dic os esr ga di fvewines es Ge geBabih, rLe n,Ca l Pe e Da Re ds a
s l ur e r ng i
t s : or
c Pe vi
ros r z, n ynol , nd

S a Ry n.( 21 2 Plitf' rs o s ( 2 4 ,h we e,s e iial sae ta i i no
e n a DE 6 . anifs ep n e DE 4 2 o v r p cfc l tts h t t s t
y
s e ng t r y on t Pe e Rey l ,o Rya de ii n t s i oni s as afi m atve e de e
e ki o el
he r z, no ds r
n pos to e tm e
fr i vi nc .

( 2 4 p. )Thu , an ifa srsta teo l tsi ne a is eh r a eBa iha dLe i s
DE 4 , 2 . s Plitf se t h th ny e t is ts u e e r bc n vn'.
mo
1 The Cour w ilt a e st di c osle pe t i ng t B a c a Le n.
d.
t l hus ddr s he s l tr r a ni o bi h nd vi
1 A nal i
11.
ys s

The is he e i whehe Pli tf Al- g comple wih t Cour' Jme 20,201
s ue r s
t r a n if lr
fa
i d t he
ts t
9,
dea i .I i cl arf om t flngst ton J m e 20,201 Pl i if a s D e e ntvi e m a l
dlne t s e r he ii
ha
t
9, a ntf dvi ed f nda
a - i

t tPl i if '
ha antf s d lke t r s r otr rghtt us t f l ng de ii fom t USS
woul i o e e ve l i o e he olowi
postons r he
ltga i a e de e i t pr s ntltga i n, ncl ng a t i l Pe Le n,Sea Rya a G e ge
ii ton s vi nc n he e e ii t o i udi t ra : r vi
n
n, nd or

Ba ch.'g 216 1 p. .Dee nt rs
bi ' DE
- , 2j fnda eponded vi emalt next da sai Pl ntf s
a - i he
y, ttng ai if

2Unv ra Su viln eCop. . e k it y .Ic, l -vo1 5 ( D. i)
ies l rel c r v Ch cpon S s,n .No. lc - 7 5 N. Oho
a
3

d s ls r wa C ts fiin u d rteJ d esgu 6 2 9 Or e 'a drq e tn Plitf tl
ico u e s t u fce t n e h u g ' l ne , 01 ) d r' n e u sig an if el
no
D e e n C t r i oft t tm on you m i tr l o s w e c n de er i w he he a f t r
f nda t t
wha po tons he esi y
gh e y n o
a t m ne
t r ' he
ur
depos ton i t scas i necessar '1
ii n hi e s
y?' d.

The Co ttnds Pl i if A l- g' J
ur i
a ntf lTa s une 20,201 e m a lw a s fc e di c os e a
9, - i s uf i i nt s l ur nd

c
omple wih t lte a s rto t Co ti
id t he e tr nd pii f he ur-mpos d Jme20,
e t
2019, adlne l t a ofsmpl
de i . nse d i y
piki up t phone a c e ng wih Pl i ifs co e a t Pli tf s dicos es
c ng
he
nd onf ni
t antf' uns l bou a n if
s l ur ,

Dee ntsco elpl i f m ove s tnce i tado j ce vi emait t dicos eby
fnda ' uns , acng or
r ubsa ,nse b e td a - l o he s l ur
$

as e t t t Pli ifs r s r to of t rg t us t t e na e USS Tr ns rpt Wa
s ri ha antf e e va in
ng
he iht o e he hr e m d
a ci s s
i uf int De e ntsc
ns fce . f nda ' ouns lt n de nd Pl i ifi ntf t s c fcpori oft USS
e he ma ed antf de iy he pe ii
tons he

Tr ns rpt whih i i e d t r l on,s t ng t Cour d d no o de Pli tf t do by Jme
a c i s c t ntnde o ey
omehi he
t i t r r a n if o
t
20, 201 The Cour fnds D e e n has ha pl nt o tm e afe Pl i if s J
9.
ti
f nda t
d e y f i
t r a ntf ' une 20, 201
9,

dicosle a be or t Se e r 1 201 dic r c of da e t de e t i vi s
s l tr , nd f e he pt mbe 8, 9, s ove y ut f t , o pos he ndi dual

Pl n ifdic os I t a ho ve ,De e nts ton isha ,a on isf malsi o j cin
aitf s l ed. nse d, we r f nda a
t nds nd t or itq b e to ,
.

a f l t de ea o t m . si cla l De e n ' f ul.
nd aied o pos ny f he Thi s e ry f nda ts a t

M o e ve , o S p e r 4 2 9 P an if Al- g s z d a nd d Ru e 2 ()1
ro r n e tmbe , 01 , litf lTa eve me e l 6 a( )
dic os e whi h i ude t i i duasa is a c e a i sa e t ti may r l upon t
s l ur s c ncl d he ndvi l t s ue nd mc gan t t d ha t
ey
he

Ba c Le n, ndRya de iins g 21 41Thepa test nco e rdonSe e
bih, vi a
n posto .DE 6- .
ri he nfre
ptmber6, 9,
201
a tyi t avoi Cot' i ewe i Pl i ifa e t lmi is a fr tve us oft USS
' r ng o
nd,
d
ut nt l nton, antf gr ed o i t t fima i
e he

Trnsrpt t Ba c a Le n,bot ofwhom ha be ndicosdi t J 20,2019e i g
a ci s o bih nd vi h
d e s l e n he une
mal DE

244,p.342 Defnda sildi notatmptt de eet rBa c orLe n.The ei abs utl
- . e nt tl d
te o pos ihe bih
vi
r s ol ey

n t n p eu iila u te a n d d s ls rs wh c f lo d t tmey J n 2 ,2 9
ohig rj d ca bo t h me de ico u e , ih olwe he i l u e 0 01 ,
dicl lr. e26() 1 r quie s pplme ai o dicos e .Tha wasalPl ntf di hee.
s osze Rul e () e rs u e ntton f s l urs t
1 ai if d r
l o c ly,i t d of ag e s ve y ltga i t s m o i n t s rke,D ef nda w oul ha
r ni a l nsea
gr s i l ii tng hi
to o ti
e nt
d ve
be n m uc be t rs l by c e rng w ih o
e
h te ewed
onf r i
t ppbsng c
i ouns ,t ki t de ii ,a r s vi
el a ng he postons nd e ol ng

4

t s diput i a c
hi s e n oope ai ma rwihoutCour i e ve i Thi i one oft da st t
r tve nne t
t ntr nton. s s
he nger ha
pa tes a t i c m s lrs w he t r i a l c of c pe a i dtr ng t di c ve y pr ce s I
r i nd he r ot e i k
n he e s a k
oo r ton li he s o r o s . t
a s a a st t Coul ha D e e nti pr de l m ade a s r t gy de s on t m o t s rke,
l o ppe r o he
it t f nda m ovi nty
ta e
ci i o ve o t i
r t rt de e t i vi l .
a he han pos , he ndi dua s

Ac odngy teCo r DENI Dee d n Ch c p itsM oint Srk ( 21 )t te
c r i l,h u t
ES fn a t e k on ' to o tie DE 6 o h
e e i s e t srkePl i ifA l- g' Am e d Rul 26 D i c os e a t e l t s i ony.
xt nt t e ks o ti
a ntf lTa s
nde
e
s l ur s nd o xc ude e tm
''e Cour w il no or r a f rhe de ii be nd t de i c of da e a
I
h
t l t de ny u t r postons yo
he adlne ut f t s

Def nda at r tve y r que t.Howe r gve t r pr s n a i of Pl ntf s co ms t t
e nt le na i l e ss
ve , i n he e e e t ton
ai if
t el ha

Dee d n h sn o j cint Dee d n d po i Ba iha dLe i a tr h ds o eyc tf d t
fn a t a o b e to o fh a t e sng bc n vn fe t e ic v r u o f ae
( 2 4 p.)t eCo r a v s s h p rist t o n e ma a r ea ngt ms l st tk t s
DE 4 , 7 ,h u t d ie t e a t ha c u s l y g e mo he eve o a e hee
e
t de ii be nd t dico r de dlne bu s d no e
wo postons yo he s ve y a i , t houl t xpec t Cour t r ol a
t he
t o es ve ny
dipu e a i i a t t Cour' e t bls d d dlneofSe e r 1 201 Thet ki oft s
s t s rsng fer he
ts sa ihe ea i
pt mbe 8, 9.
a ng he e
de ii ns ora e f t t do s ,s l noti a w a be co t e orus d a a ba i f rs ki
pos to , ny f or s o
o ha l
n ny y
nsnl d
e s
s s o ee ng

ade a oft r mai ng pr tilde dlne o t 'ra da ei t sc s
l y he e ni
e-ra a i s r heti l t n hi a e.
I .Conc us on
V
l i

Ba e on t f r ng,i i he e ORDERED t tDe e n Che kpoi ' M oton t
sd
he o egoi t s r by
ha f nda t c nts
i o
Sti A l- g Co p.sA m e d Rul 26 D i c os e ofPr o La s tD e
r ke l Ta
r '
nde
e
s l uz s
i r w ui pone ,a t Excl
nt nd o
ude

TherTe tmo o i t Alenai f Li t Dico r Extnso ( 21 )i DENI
i si ny, r n he tr tve or mied s ve y e in DE 6 s
ED.
D N E and O R DER ED i c be s a W e tPa m Be h,Pal B e h Co m t Fl r da
n ham r t s l
ac
m ac
t y, o i ,
t s
hi

1Xdyootbr2019.
a f coe
,

#*
:

,

W I AM M AT HEW M AN
LLI
Unied St esM agitat Judge
t
at
sr e

5