All-Tag Corporation v. Checkpoint Systems, Incorporated
Filing
276
ORDER granting [236/239] Defendant's Motion to Strike the Supplemental Report of Dr. Graeme Hunter and [237/240] Motion to Strike the Supplemental Report of Patrick O'Leary. Signed by Magistrate Judge William Matthewman on 10/9/2019. See attached document for full details. (kza)
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLOM DA
CT
Ca eN o. l c 8l - i ir e s a wm a
s
9: 7- v- z6l D m toul a N ûhe
n
A l- g Co .
lTa
p ,
FI
LED BY
Pl i if
antf,
D. .
C
1
.
VS.
02I 2, 2 1
S 29
Che kpo ntSys e s I ,
c i
t m , nc.
ANGELA E.
NOBLE
CL
ERK U S DI .
ST CX
s.. /.. w...
o oF L - pB
:
De e nt
f nda .
/
O R DER G R AN TI G D EFEN DA NT CH EC K PO I T' M O TI N T O ST RI E TH E
N
N S
O
K
SUPPLEM ENTAL REPORT OF DR.GRAEM E HUNTER f 236 2391AND M OTI
DE /
ON
TO STRI THE SUPPLEM ENTAL REPORT OF PATRI O '
KE
CK LEARY I 237 2401
DE
/
TH I CA U SE i be or t Co to t m o i ûl d by D ef nda Che kpoi Sys e s
S
s f e he ur n wo tons e
e nt c nt t m ,
I Bot r l t t t s e e a r por s oft ofPl i if A lnc. h e a e o he uppl m nt l e t
wo
a ntf lTag Cor ' e r w ine s s
p.s xpe t t s e ,
Dr Gr me Huntr a Parc O' a y.The frt( 236239)s kst 'ti Dr Huntrs
. ae
e nd tik Le r
is DE /
ee o srke . e '
s p e na rp r (h f- n e M oint S rk ' , n t s c n ( 23 / 4 4se t srk
u plme tl e o tt e ll tr to o tie' a d he e o d DE 72 0 e ks o tie
lu
)
M r O' ay' s p e n a rpo tt eç le r M oint Srk ' The ematr weerfre
. Le r s u plme tl e r (h t way to o tie). s te s r eerd
o'
t t t ri d by Unie SttsDititJ
o he mdesgne
td ae src udge W ila P.Di toula .( 51 .Pl ntf
lim
mir e s DE j ai if
rs n e t De e d n ' moi n o Oco e 1a d2, 01 .( 2 52 4 2 62 6 . f n a t
epo d d o fn a ts to s n tb r n 2 9 DE 4 /5 , 4 / 5 1 De e d n
rple t Pli ifsrs ns o Ocobe 7, 9.DE 268272,2692734Thust smatri rpe
e id o antf' epo es n t r 201 g
/
/ . ,hi te s i
.
f r vi w . t r as s tf r h be ow ,t Cour GR AN TS bot m o i t s r ke
or e e For he e ons e o t l
he
t
h tons o ti .
1 B ackground
.
The hi t y a c r nt pr ed a pos ur of t s c s i i po t nt t t Cour '
s or nd ur e
oc ur l t e
hi a e s m r a o he
ts
de e m i to o t t o pe ng m o i . s c e w a fl on N ove be 1 201 a m os t o
t r na i n f he w
ndi
tons Thi as s ied
m r 7, 7, l t w
yeasa ( 1.OnM a 4,201 t Cour eneedas he i o de sti t ti pei i
r go.DE )
y
8,he
t tr
c dulng r r etng he ral rod n
t sc ef rJ nuay6, 20, t adic r c of daeo Se e r6,
hi as o a r 20 wih s ovey ut f t f ptmbe 2019.( 43 . Aprl
DE ) On i
4,201 t Co te ee a or r( 1 s ti t f l nge pe tdicos ede i s:
9,he ur ntrd n de DE 04) etng he olowi x r s l ur adlne
Pl i ifsExpe tRe t ndDic os es
antf'
r por a
s l ur
D e e ntsExpe t po ta Di c os e
f nda '
r Re r nd s l ur s
R e talExpe tRe t
bu t
r pors
Expe t i c r Cut f
r D s ove y
of
Jme21 201
t
, 9
J m e 22,201
t
9
A ugps 5,201
t
9
Se e be 1 201
pt m r 1, 9
On M a 18, 8, he Co ta e
y 201 t
ur m nded isprors he i or r ke pi t s m e t i lda e
t i c dulng de , e ng he a ra t
a dp etilsh d l,b ti ldngan tto t r fe ttec re t ie ma itaej d e (
n r -ra c e u e u ncu i
o ain o elc h or c pard gsrt u g . DE
51 .On J 5,201 t Cour e e ed t dic r c - f9o Se e r 11 201 t
j
une
9, he
t xtnd he sovey utof m ptmbe , 9, o
Se e r18 201 g 1 . ra trt pa tesa e dt a t Co ta ptda o dee
ptmbe , 9.DE 644Thee fe,he ri gre o, nd he ur do e nd r rd
( 1 ,t f l nga ndede r dicos ede dlne :
DE 671 he olowi me
xpe t sl ur a i s
Af im a i Expe t e t
fr tve
r R por s
Com pl ton ofD e ii ns ofA 1 Expe t
ei
pos to
1
rs
Re t lExpe tRe r s
buta
r po t
Com pl t o ofD e ii nsofRe t Expe t
ein
pos to
butal
rs
Fa ta Expe t i c r Cut f
c nd
r D s ove y of
J y 1 201
ul 7, 9
Augus 9, 9 ,
t 201
Aug t23, 9
us
201
Se e be 18,
pt m r 2019
Se e be 18,
pt m r 2019
Thus i i i por a t t t Co ' de e m i t o of t pa te ' t o pe ng m otons
, t s m t n o he M s t r na i n
he ri s w
ndi
i
adc e s d i t s Or r t t t e r dic r dea i s ha pas e dic r i cos d,
l s e n hi de ha he xpe t s ove y
r
dlne ve s d, s ove y s l e
s t ntve pr -ra motonsa e d Oc o r 11 201 Daube tmotonsa e d 60 da be or
ubsa i
e ti l i
r ue t be , 9,
r
i
r ue
ys f e
t sa'oft tilst wee pei a t tilpei begi J nuay6,2020.g 51.
he tl he ra' wo- k rod, nd he ra rod ns a r
t
DE 1
Furhe , t sc s hasbe n e h e e y a unnec s a iy ltgi , pe a l i t di co r
t r hi a e
e xt m l nd
r
e s r l ii ous es ci ly n he s ve y
p s . ep ris(n c ranno pate fo wh m d so eywa s ug t h v fldc u te s
ha e Th a t a d e ti n- ris r m o ic v r s o h ) a e ie o n ls
e
di c r m otons r pons s a r ple , a unde s a . Cour , n a ef o t o ge t pa te
s ove y
i , es
e , nd e i s m ny
r e l The
t i n f r t t he r i s
t c o eae ha rq ie t e pate t fl n meo sj itn tc s rg r i g t e n l r u
o o p rt, s e u rd h ris o ie u r u on o ie e a dn h tmeo s
di c r di pu es To ke p t sc s o tac t t r i ne hashe d l ngt di c ve y he dngs
s ove y s t .
e hi a e n r k, he mde s g d
l e hy s o r a
onNove r30, 8( 734M a 6, 9 ( 1 q M a 1 201 ( 1 , t 6,201 (
mbe 201 DE , y 201 DE 31, y 5, 9 DE 441Jme
9 DE
1 ,Aug t23,201 ( 200j a Se e r23,201 ( 23 .
651 us
9 DE
, nd ptmbe
9 DE 24
N o c mtng t s Or r t Co tha ha t e e no l s t n 1 s t ntve di c r
t ot i hi de , he ur s d o nt r
e s ha 3 ubs a i
s ove y
or r ( 75,1 1 1 1 1 1 16 1 1 7,1 263,a 265j a nols t n
des DES
04, 22, 32, 34, 43, 47, 4, 66, 6 68,
nd
, nd e s ha
34pr d a' s ver o des( 65,68 99,1 1 1 i11 11 11 1 1 1 1 ,
oce ur ldico y r r DES
, 00, 07, 09, , 5, 9, 29, 37, 38, 48
2
15 1 1 1 1 1 1 204,2J 21 221 225 226,238,
5, 56, 60, 90, 92, 94, 98,
0, 9, , ,
243, ,25 25 260,261
251 2, 3,
,
a 26 )
nd 4 .
Thes ar t pa te 't r a f t m otonst sr ke. e D Es 21 205- /
e e he ri s hid nd ourh
i o ti Se
6,
1 223,237/ 9,
23
a 236/
nd
240. Oc o r7, 9,t Cot ' g a t i pa t de e i pa' a m o i n t s rke by
On t be 201 he ut r n ed n r and ni d n l
t
t o o ti
D e e nt Che kpo n co e i D r Hunt r s r butal r por , fndi t t Se ton I of li
f nda
c i t nc m ng .
e ' e t e t i ng ha c i V
ls
r butalrpor c ane a fnna i opi o pr e welpas t a sr tve e r r por
e t e t ont i d fi tve ni ns oduc d l t he f ma i xpe t e t
dea i ,a de ed a s co m o i t s rke Pl i if A l- g' a e d Rul 26 di cl ur s
dlne nd ni
e nd ton o t i
a ntf lTa s m nde
e
s os e .
( 26 a d26 j De pt t i p irCo r o d rrg r i gDr Hu trstsi n teCo r fn s
DES 3 n 5 . s ie hs ro u t r e e ad n . n e ' e tmo y,h u ti d
is l ha ng t ye a i w a i o a di c r di put abo one ofD r H t t r s e r r po t ,
t e f vi o t ga n de nt
s ove y s e ut
. m e ' xpe t e r s
e e tls tm e ac om pa e by a di put conc m i M r O ' r s s e e a e r r por .
xc pt li i
c
ni d
s e
e ng . Lea y' uppl m nt l xpe t e t
W ih t sba kgr und i m i t Cour now t nst t t o pe ng m o i t s rke
t hi c o
n nd, he
t
ur o he w
ndi
tons o t i .
l .Di put sU nde l ng Eac M oton t St i
l s e
r yi
h
i o r ke
Reg di Dr Ht e ' s e nt lr por, f nda a g st Coul s d srkei a
ar ng . mt rs uppl me a e tDe e nt r ue he
' houl ti t s
t
i ()c nan n w,a fr tv o i in a d ( )i r p ry rb t t rb ta r p r o o o
t 1 o ti s e fimaie p no s n 2 mp o el e u s he e u tl e o t f ne f
De e d n ' e p r win se , . lseS rvi. nr s o s , anifc ne d ()Dr Hu tr
f n a ts x e t t e s s Dr Ceet a a a I e p n e Plitf o tn s 1 . n e
wa pe m it d t s pl m e hi i tal e t s d on ne i or a i obt ned t ough di co r
s r te o up e nt s nii r por ba e
w nf m ton ai hr
s ve y
a tr siiil e r wa s r e o J l 1 , 1 a d( ) rl i o Fe R. v. 2 ()2 ,h t
fe hi nta rpo t s e v d n uy 7 20 9 n 2 , eyng n d. Ci P. 6 e( ) ta
hi Se e be 1 201 s e e a r por wa tmel be us i wa acualy note n d untl
s ptm r 8, 9, upplm nt l e t s i y ca e t s t l
ve ue i
3 d y beo e til( ih wo l b De e e 6 2 9 ,rt rt n b t e J y 1 ,2 9
0 a s f r ra whc u d e c mb r , 01 ) ahe ha y h ul 7 01 ,
a tr a i e r r por dea i o t Aug t23,
fi m tve xpe t e t dlne r he
us
2019, e t lr po tde dlne.
r buta e r a i
Tt lng t M r O ' a y' s e e al r por, D e e nt Chec nt a gue i ( s
m i o
. Le r s uppl m nt e t
f nda
kpoi r s t G
i
untt r i a wa t 'hi i tale r rpo tt ndi t aprj calylt ne afimai
eheed n ny y o' s nii xpe t e r,s s hus eudii l ae w tr tve
a
o ni .' ( 237,p.3) Pli ifAl- g rpe t muc oft sme agt ns i ma i
pi onlj' DE
. antf l- e as h he a r une t t kes n
fa
r ponse t t H t er M oton t St i M r O ' y' s em ent repor i not i pr ,
es
o he mt
i o rke. . Lear s uppl
al
ts
m oper
Pl ntf a gue ,be aus i ( ie m a e i la i or a i t tw a onl a ia e t M r O ' a y
ai if r s c e t G t s t r a nd nf m ton ha s y va l bl o . Le r
c
a e hi i talrpor wa fl 'onJ y1 201 ( 245, 4)(mphassi orgna)
jtr s nii e t s ied' ul 7, 9. DE
p. e
i n ii l.
11 A nal i
1.
ys s
a Hu tr oi nt S rk ( 2 62 9
. n e M to o tie DE 3 / 3 1
D r Hunt r spur r e s e e alr por i a cl a vi a i n oft Cour ' J m e 7, 9,
.
e ' po t d uppl m nt e t s e r ol to
he
ts t
201
Or r( 1 a ndi t e r dic vey de dlnei tlsc e.Tha Or r whih meey
de DE 67j me ng he xpe t s o r a i n li as
t de, c rl
a o d a m a of i i t pa te own a r e e ,r quied t pa tes t s r e h o he
ppr ve nd de f c al he r i s'
g e m nt e r he r i o e ve ac t r
wih t i i tala fr tve e r r po t by J y 1 201 a t rr bu t r pors by A ugus
t he r nii fi ma i xpe t e r s
ul 7, 9, nd hei e tal e t
t
23,201 f a p. The pa te w e e t n pe m it d t de e ea h o he ' r buta e rs by t
9. J. t 2.
r i s r he r te o pos c t r s e t l xpe t
he
c o e oft di c r on Se e be 1 201 f Si pl e ugh.
ls
he s ove y
pt m r 8, 9. #. m e no
But notf Pl ntf .I t d,Pl i if fr t al m pt d t i p o ry s a a a fnua i
or ai if ns ea
a ntf i s te e o m r pe l ne k n f i tve
e r o ni i o D r H t t ' r buta r por .Se D E 263.The Cour or r d t t a fnua i
xpe t pi on nt . m er s e t l e t e
t de e ha f i tve
opi onsrc n onOcobe 7, 9. J. ts ul ha be nt e oft m a trN ow,Pl i if
ni tike
t r 201 f Tha ho d ve e he nd he te .
antf,
i vi ainoft Co tsJ 7, 9,Or rg 1 ,i et t e c s meafnuai opi on
n olto he ur' une 201 de DE 671 ns rs he xa t a fi tve ni
t Cour odeedsrc ni isprorOr e ( 263 i oane t up e ntl'e r fldwel
he
t r r tike n t i d r DE 2 nt
w G plme a'rpo t ie l
s
afe et rt J y 1 201 a fr tve e r r por de i ort Aug t23,201 r b t
tr ihe he ul 7, 9, fima i xpe t e t pdlne he
us
9, e utal
e r r po ' de dlne.
xpe t e l a i
t
Unde Fe R. v. 26()pa tesmus s pplme a e r' r por fnatmeymame
r d. Ci P. e, ri
t u e nt n xpe ts e t' i l r r
i
i t pa t l a n t ti s em a e i la pec t di c os e o r s
f he ry e r s ha n om
t r a s t he s l ur f e pons i i om pl t ori or ec '
e s nc
e e nc r t'
a t addii
nd he
tonalor c r tve i o to m us t O he wi e be n m ade know n t t ot r
or ec i nf nna i n
ti
not t r s e
o he he
pate d i t dic r pr es o i wrtngEq'Thi doe notme n,howe rt tpatesc n
ris urng he s ovey oc s r n ii .' s s
a
ve,ha ri a
be a e y a ne o ni o untm el r buta opi o unde t gui e ofs e e a r po t .
l t dl dd w pi ons r i y e t l ni ns
r he s
uppl m nt l e r s
( ca e t e r w ine s di c r r e a e de i d t a l bot s d i a c s t
G us he xpe t t s s ove y ul s r s gne o low
Be
h i es n a e o
pr pa et i c s sade t y a t pr ve s p r s . . om pla e w ih t r qui e e sofRul
e r he r a e
qua el nd o e nt u ie . c
i nc t he e r m nt
e
4
2 i no meeyapiain l'Co pe v S uh r Co, 9 F.d6 5 7 8( 1hCi. 0 4 (n en l
6 s t rl s rto a. o r . o te n .3 0 3 9 , 2 1 t r 2 0 ) itr a
'
ctto o te . R.Ci P. c()i tu t t twhee1 pat fist pr dei o maton
iains mitd) Fed. v. 37()1 nsr cs ha r $ ry al o ovi nf r i
a
. . .
a rquiedby Rul 26()o () t pa t i no al t us t ti or ton o wine s...
se r
e a r e ,he ry s t lowed o e ha nf mai r t s
une stefi ewa s b tn il u tfe o h r e s'S e eg , t hv R. Re n lsT b c o
ls h al
ur s u sa tal siid r amls . e , ..Poi . J y od o a c
yj
'
s
Co,9 1 -v- 1 , 01 W L 5 5 9 a * - ( . Fl. v. 0 20 7 ; n g d Ca eSos,
. :5c 81 71 2 7
9 28 2, t 2 4 SD. a No 3 , 1 ) Ma a e r l.
I c v Ese He l c r ,I c, 9 c - 0 51 2 1 W L 1 3 7 4 a * ( D. a M a 3 2 0 .
n . . s nt at a e n . 0 -v 6 3 , 0 0
h
8 7 2 , t 3 S. Fl. y , 01 )
Th b r e o s o ngt a afi r t dsl s o c mp ywa s b tn ilyj tfe o h r e s
e u d n f h wi h t al e o ico e r o l s u sa tal usiid r a mls
u
i o t n n ds lsngpa t M i h l v Fo d Moo Co,3 8Fe Ap 8 ,8 4 ( 1h Ci.
s n he o - ico i ry. t el . r tr . 1 d. px. 21 2 1 t r
c
2 0 ) Excu i ni as a a p o raerme yu e Fe R. v. 1 () whih a t o ie te
0 9 . lso s lo n p r p it e d nd r d. Ci P. 6b , c uh rz s h
c t o co r a e d t pr ti ldico y t ough a s he i or ra gi t c t oad
our t nt ol nd xpe ie e r a s ver hr
c dulng de nd ves he our br
di c e i t pr e v t i e iy a pur e of a pr ti l or r i l ng t e us on of
s r ton o es r e he nt grt nd pos
e r a de , nc udi he xcl i
e denc Companhi Ener i Potgu v.Cat r larI , o.1 c 24277, 6 W L 31
vi e.
a
getc i ar
e pil nc.N
4- v201
02225,
a *5( D. a J 2,201 )
t S. Fl. une
6.
Cours ha br ad di c e i n t e l t i e y- s l e e r r por s e n one
t ve o
s r to o xc ude mtm l di c os d xpe t e t, ve
s
1
de i t d a Ss e e a ' r po t . d. se al o eg. Cook v Ro Ca i an Cr s s N o.11
s gna e s Guppl m nt l' e r s 1 ; e s , . ,
. yal r bbe
ui e ,
-
c 20732,201 W L231
v2
9089( D. a.une1 201 ;Goodb Cr e ,LLC v. c I .Co,
S. Fl J 5, 2)
ys e k
Arh ns .No.
7-vc 0947,2009 W L 11
39575,a * ( . Fl Apr 27,2009 .Pa test c mota eRul
t 2 M D. a. .
) ri hus ar bus
e
26()a us as e ntlrpor t t r l boltradee tveorpr e tce r wine s
e nd e upplme a e t o ç ey se
me
fci
oblmai xpe t t s
rpor. Catr larI .201 W L 31 225,a * Rul 26()(snotad viet al apa t s
e t' epil nc, 6
'
02
t 6. e e i
i
e c o low
ry'
e r t e ge i addii na w or o t ar opi ons orof e ne onest pe f c a ltga i
xpe t o nga n
to l k, r o mul ni
fr w
o r e t ii tng
srtgy. Coc anv,TheBrnk nn Cor , 8-v- 790,2009W L 48
tae ' hr
'
i ma
p.No. c 1
23858 a *5 ( D.Ga
, t N.
.
De .9 2 0 ) afd b 38 Fe Ap x.9 8 ( 1h Ci. 2 ) Th o l p pos o Rue 2 ()
c , 0 9 , f ' y, 1 d. p 6 1 t r 20 0 . e ny u e f l 6 e
i nf m to ha
s em ent ton i çf t nar pur
uppl
a i s lor he row
pose ofcor ectng i c ac es oradd ng i or a i n t t
r i nac ur i
.
w as notavaia e att tm e oft i talrepor.'Potsh,2017 W L 5952892,at*3.
l bl he i
he nii
t' i
The Cour ' de i i n i Pots i i t u tve he e.The e t Cour or r t pa te t
ts c s o n
i h s nsr c i
r
r , he
t de ed he ri s o
fl t i e r di cl ur by Se e be 26,201 1 N e rhe e s t pl i if w aie un i
ie he r xpe t s os es
pt m r
7. d. ve t l s , he a ntf
t d tl
N o be 1 201 t fl t s e e a r po tof o ofis wine s s 1 Tha s ppl m e t
vem r 3, 7, o ie he uppl m nt l e r
ne t t s e . d. t u e n al
r por S i f c nty c nge f om a g ne i o ni r r ng t t ba c i ty t one w hi h
e t t gnii a l ha d r
s
e rc pi on ega di he o c o ndus r o
c
a i d diec l t t de e nt'pl i ifw a r pr s ntng. #.a 4.Thus t Co tf und t tt
pple r ty o he c de ' a ntf s e e e i f t
, he ur o
ha he
e r' a tons i hi s e nt lr po t' r nott c r c a e si i onuai n, bu
xpe ts ddii n s uppl me a e r t e
'
we
o ore t ny xitng nf
to
t
r t rt bolt rt e s i opi o a i l i pe m i sbl opi onsa t rt e r di c osles
a he o s e he xi tng ni n nd nc ude m r s i e ni
fe he xpe t s l tr
dea i .' d
dlne '1
The Cour ha ve y c r f l r viwe bot Dr Hunt rsi ta a fr ai r po ta li
t s r a e uly e e d h .
e ' nii l fim tve e r nd ls
PUT or e ( u e e a ' r po ta c l st tD r Hunt r sIs e e a ' r por i a diec
P t d G ppl m nt l' e r nd onc ude ha .
s
e ' tuppl m nt l' e t s r t
and un i e y r bu t t t r buta r por ofD e e ntChe kpoi ' e r wines D r Sa a a
tm l e tal o he e tl e t
f nda
c nt s xpe t t s . r vi ,
no a m e e s e e a i ofhi pror r por . Li t ç uppl m e a ' r por s nz k i Pots
t
r uppl m nt ton
s i e tl ke he s
s e nt l' e t t c n
i h,
D r H unt r s ts e e a ' r po tw a S t t c r e t a e s i i br a i but r t r t
.
e ' duppl m nt l' e r s i o o r c ny xi tng nt m ton,
no
a he o
bolt r t e s i opi o a i l e i pe m i s bl o ni a tr t e r di c os e
s e he xitng
ni n nd nc ud m r s i e pi ons fe he xpe t s l ur s
de dlne. 1
a i ' d.
'
H a ng c l d D r H un e ' S uppl m e a ' r por w a t tm e y, t Cour m us
vi
onc ude
.
t rs û
s e nt l' e t s m i l he
t
t
c n ie wh t e d t i o e Plitf Al- gag e i wa s b tn ilyj siidi tikig
o sd r a r me y o mp s . an if lTa r u s t s u sa tal u tfe n hn n
i c u ds p lme tise pe te rsa s c alt d t b c u eFe . Ci P. 6 e( )p o d s
t o l u pe n t k r rpo t t u h ae ae e a s d R. v. 2 ()2 rvie
t ta pa t ss em e si us bedi c os d by t tm e t pa t spr t i ldi c os esu rRul
ha
r y' uppl nt û t
m
sl e
he i he ry' e r a s l ur nde
e
2 ()3 ae d e' Th s u d r Rue 2 ()3 ,whc isnlt ta (u nls t c u to d r
6 a( ) r u . u , n e l 6 a() ih n t cs h t t l e s he o r r es
'
f
ot nv s t s dic oj e mus bem a a las 30 d bef r til'Pli ifc ntndsi c d
he ie, he e s l ur s
t
de t e t ays o e ra y' a ntf o e
t oul
i 80 h Dr Huntrs i tala fr ai r por a hi (s e e al'r por wer fld unde s ali s ppo tof
t
e ' nii fim tve e t nd s tupplm nt ' e t e ie
r e n u r
.
D eenda ' m oto Se DE 239- 239 3.l lghtoft rs al saus t Cour w ilnotgo it deai a
f nts in. e
2, - n i
hei e ed tt , he
t l
n o t l boutt
he
dif r nc bewee Dr Hunersafim a i r r a hi t upplm e al rpo tN o t ls ,e n acuror r vi
fe e es t n . t ' fr tve epo t nd s t
s e nt ' e r. nehee s ve
'
s y e ew
oft r l sm a s i abu n l clart tD r Hunt r s f uppl
he epo' ke t nda ty e ha .
t
e ' s ement ' r ' con a nsnum e o untm ey r bu t
s
al' epol t i
t
r us i l e tal
opi onsdie tya t ki D r Sar a' r butalrpor.
ni
r cl tac ng . avi s e t e t
6
s e e is ç r r pors untl 30 da be or t i l i t s m a t r Pl i i f s pos to i
uppl m nt t xpe t e t
i
ys f e r a n hi
te . a ntf'
ii n s
m i g de a w r ng.
s ui d nd o
Pl nifa Defnda s cfc lyagee t a t Co to d e a a pt ( 1 ,
aitf nd e nt pe iial r d o, nd he ur r erd nd do ed DE 671
s cii e r di c ve y de lne .The pa te di notpr pos or a r e t a t Co ts Or r
pe fc xpe t s o r ad i s
ris d
o e
g e o, nd he ur ' de
neve pe te a C t - e tal'da e The l s da e f r pr
r nnit d, t l r bu t ' t .
sr
a t t o oduc ng a r buta e r r por w a
i
e t l xpe t e t s
Augus 9,201 g 1 ,a ye bot o Pli ifse rs s e ntlrpo t we epr e
t
9 DE 671 nd t h f antf' xpe t' upplme a e rs r oduc d
o t e ni of Se e be 18 201 t ve y l s da ofdi c ve y. a ntf ' a t m ptt r m i e
n he ve ng
pt m r , 9, he r a t y
s o r Pl i if s te
o e t
t hit r oft sc e,dir ga d isa ee t a Cour-mpos d e r dic os e d dlne , nd
he so y hi as s e r t gr d-o nd
ti
e xpe t s l ur ea i s a
t n a g Dr Ht e ' ts e nt l' e t snotdueuntl30da be or t J nua y 6,
he r ue . mt r s tupplme a'r por wy
i
ys f e he a r 2020,
til ae( ti, c mbe 6 2 9 i fal rj ce .No i Plitf' e o h nnls. so r
ra d t t s De e r , 01 ) s lt ee tdz r s an ifs n'r n e s Dic vey
ha
y
i t sca e ha c os d. ft s Cour w e et pe tPl i ift r l upon isuntm e y s e e a
n hi s s l e I hi
t r o nni a ntf o e y
t
i l uppl m nt l
e r r po t t n i w oul ha t 1 tDe e n e ge i f rhe w or a di c r t a l is
xpe t e r , he t
d ve o e f nda t nga n u t r k nd s ove y o low t
e r t rs
xpe t o e pond,t r by sa lng a dea ng t sc e.Thi c e hasbe n pe ng f am os
he e tli nd lyi hi as
s as
e ndi or l t
t o yea s I i tm e f t di c r a e r di c os e s a oft s c e t be c os s t
w
r . t s i or he s ove y nd xpe t s l ur t ge hi as o
l ed o he
Cour ca f us o s t ntve m o i a t i l
t n oc n ubs a i
tons nd ra .
Thi i t s co tm ePl n ifA l- ha ti t s a i D r H t e ' a fnnatve e r
s s he e nd i
ai t f lTag s red o ne k n . mt r s f
i xpe t
o ni n bylbei i s m ehi i i not Ther q ti t s m e. .
pi o
a lng t o t ng t s .
e ul s he a Dr Hunt ' ( u e e t 'r po t
ers G pplm n al'e r
s
s r e on Se embe 18,201 i he e src n.Pl i ifma notr l upon orot r s us
evd
pt
r
9, s r by tike
antf y
ey
he wie e,
eihe d r c l ori r ty, he Suppl m e a Expe t e tofGr e e H unt r PI. . ta poi
t r i e ty ndiec l t
e nt l
r R por
am
e , AD a ny nt
i t sc e, nc udi i di postvem oto ,r s ns s o a t i l
n hi as i l ng n s ii
i ns e po e , r t ra .
2Plitf a gu ntt ti c dpr eiss eme t expe t e t da be or ti r coun e t t eCour'
an ifs r me ha t oul oduc t uppl nal r r por 30 ys f e ràl uns t r o h
ts
Ame e S h d igOr e E 51, c rq rsa1 u et t n t b fld6 d y beo ec ln a cl,h t
nd d c e ul
n d r DE 1whih e uie lDa b r moi s o e ie 0 a s fr ae d r alta
o
i,o orbef eNove be 3, l Pl n ifsm igui d agumentwoul m e t tt pariscoul fl s emenal
s n
or
m r 20 9. aitf' s de r
d an ha he te
d ie uppl t
e e'rp rsa rted a l efrGln Da b r moin .Thsag me td fe lgca d c mmo s nea di
xp l e o t pe h e di o ig u et to s i r u n eis o i n o n e s n s
t
n
rjce .
eetd
7
b.O' a y M o i t S'i r 237 2401
Le r
ton o t ke DE /
r
Th fcsu d ryngt eO' a yM oint S rk ( 23 / 4 )aelr eyt s mea d
e a t n eli h Le r to o tie DE 72 0 r ag l he a n ,
t , s i t r s t M r O ' a y' ( uppl e a ' r po t c ai untm e y a i pr per
hus o s he e ul. . Le r s ç
s em nt l' e r ont ns i l nd m o
afr tveopi o i vi ai oft Cour' prorOr r( 1 a wilbesrc n.
fimai
nins n olton he
ts i de DE 674 nd l tike
Assae a o e Rue2 ()(jn t d v c t al w apat se petoe g g i a d t n l
ttd b v , l 6 e t 0 a e ie o lo
i
ry' x r t n a e n d ii a
o
w o k,ort a nulo ni or o f r ne onest perec a ltga i s r t gy. Coc an,20 W L
r
o n
pi ons
fe w
o f t ii tng t a e '
' hr
09
48 58,a * Theonl pur e o Rul 26e s e ntto i Sort na
238 t 5.
y pos f e () upplme ain s s he now pur eof
f
pos
c r tng i cc a esora ng i o m a i n t tw > no a l e a t tm e oft i t a r por.'
or ec i na ur ci
ddi nf r to ha s t vaiabl t he i
he nii l e t'
Pots 201 W L 5
i h, 7
9528 a * M r O ' a y' s e e alr por w e f rbe
92, t 3. . Le r s uppl m nt e t nt a yond t tt r o
ha s r w
na
PY9 CS0.'
'
The Cour hasve y c r uly r vi we bot ofM r O' r s e r r pors The Cour
t
r a ef l e e d h
. Lea y' xpe t e t.
t
nee notgo i o de a lr ar ng t dif r nc s be wee M .. ' r s i tala fr a i e r
d
nt t i eg di he f e e e t n 1 O Lea y' nii f im tve xpe t
.
r por a hi ne s c le ts e e al'r por.A sm pl c pa i o of t t r po t i
e t nd s w o- a l d iuppl m nt ' e t
i e om r s n
he wo e r s s
enough. M r. O ' a y' i talà fr a i e r r por w a s r e on J y 1 201 a g ne a l
S
Le r s nii f im tve xpe t e t s e v d
ul 7, 9 nd e r ly
o ne o D e enda Chec nt s a l e f l e ad tsng az m a ke i H i ç uppl m e a '
pi d n f
nt
kpoi ' leg d a s veri i ld r tng. s s
s e nt l'
r por,by c r s ,w a s z on Se e be 18,201 a of e s a hos ofe t rne ,a fr a i
e t
ont a t s e ved
pt m z
9, nd f r
t ihe w f im tve
o ni nsoropi onsm e ntt r butt e ofDr Sa a a
pi o
ni
a o e hos
. r vi .
W ih r pe tt M r O ' a y' d u e e a 'r po t Pl i ifA l- r pea sm uc oft
t es c o . Le r s û ppl m nt l' e r , a ntf lTag e t
s
h he
s me s b tn ilj siiain a d h r e s s agi n st a i ma e r g r ig Dr Ht e '
a u sa ta u t c to n a mlsnes r l t h t t d e adn . mtrs
f
me
s m ia l untm e y a i pr pe d uppl m e a 'r po t Pl ntf nd Def nda s cii ly a e
i l r y i l nd m o r ç
s e nt l' e r . ai i fa
e nt pe fca l gr ed
t andt Cour or r a ado e ( 16 ,s cfce r dico r de dlne .l Pli if
o, he
t deed nd ptd DE 71 pe ii xpe t s vey a i s f antf
ne ded m or tm e t pr uc is e r opi o ,i s d ha s ug r le f om t e de dlne
e
e i o od e t xpe t ni ns t houl ve o ht e i f r hos a i s
3 Bot M r O' ar s i talafim ai r ta hi ç uppl
h . Le y' nii fr tve epor nd s < ementl'r por we e fl unders ali s
s
a' e t r ied
e n uppor o
tf
D eenda ' m o i Se DE 239- 239- I lghtoft rs ae saus t Cour w ilnotgo it deala
f nts ton. e
2,
3. n i
hei e ld tt , he
t l
n o ti boutt
he
dif r e be we M r O' r sa tr a i r por a hi ts e e a ' r r .
f e enc s t en . Lea y' fs m tve e t nd s fuppl m nt l' epo t
( e d ie i a r e t )fo t e Co r.l dd n t l ta ,Plit f tid t s u e e i n w
d a ln s t g e d o r m h u t t i o . nse d ani re o q e z n e
f
a fnna i a r bu t l o ni m a ke as t up e e t ' r pors i di e t vi a i of is
f i tve nd e t a pi ons s d
d pl m n al' e t n r c ol ton
s
t
agee ntwihDee nta t sCour' prorOr r( 1 .
r me t fnda nd hi
ts i de DE 674
M . O ' a y' çs e e a r por ' s r e o Se e be 18 201 i he e sr c n.
1 Le r s tuppl m nt l e t' e v d n pt m r , 9, s r by ti ke
.
.
Pl i i fm a notr l upon oro he wi e us ,e t rdiec l ori r c l t Suppl m e a Expe t
a ntf y
ey
t r s e ihe r ty ndie ty, he
e nt l
r
Re tofPa rc O' r a a poi i t sc s i l ngi dipostvem oto , es e ,
por
tik Lea y t ny nt n hi a e, ncudi n s ii
i ns r pons s or
a ti l
t ra .
lV .C oncl i
us on
Ba e on t f e ng,i i he e O R DER ED t t
sd
he or goi t s r by
ha :
1. D e e n Che poi ' M o i t St i Untm e y tsuppl m e a Expe tRe tof
f nda t
ck nts ton o rke
i l ç
e nt l
r por
Gre Huntr Ph. ' Se v d Se e r1 201 ( 2362394i GRANTED,a
a me
e, D. r e ptmbe 8, 9 DE /
'
s
s
f l s
olow :
The Suppl m e a Expe t po to Gr e e H t t r Ph. . ss rc n. a ntf m a
e nt l
r Re r f a m
m e , D i ti ke Pl i if y
notr y upon orot r s us ,e t rdiec l ori r c l t Suppl m e t lExpe t
el
he wi e e ihe r ty ndie ty, he
e na
r
R e tof Gr e e H unt r PI. .a a po nt i t s c s ,i l ng i dipos tve
por
am
e , AD t ny i n hi a e nc udi n s ii
m otons r
i , esponses,oratti .
ral
Def nda Che kpoi ' M oton t St i U ntm e y d ppl m e a Expe tRe r of
e nt
c nt s
i o rke
i l ç
su e nt l
r po t
Parc O' r ' r dSe e r18, 9g 237/ i GRANTED,a f l
tik Leay'Seve ptmbe 201 DE
2404 s
s olows:
The Suppl m e t lRe t Pa rc O ' a y i sr c n. a ntf m a notr l upo
e n a por of t i k Le r s ti ke Pl i if y
ey n
or ot wi e us eiher diecty or i r l t Suppl ent Expe Reportof
her s e, t
r l
ndiecty, he
em al
rt
Pa r c O ' a y a a poi i t s c e, i l ng i dipostve m o i ,
ti k Le r t ny
nt n hi as nc udi n s ii
tons
r ponses,or atti .
es
r al
9
DO E and ORDERED i c mbe sa W es Pam Bea h,Pam Bea h Coun y,Fl rda
n ha r t
t l
c
l
c
t oi ,
ti 1 zyooc br21.
hs a f t e,09
o
.
J .-*
# -
W I AM M AT 1 EW *
LLI
1
Unied St t sM agita eJ
t
ae
sr t udge
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?