All-Tag Corporation v. Checkpoint Systems, Incorporated

Filing 276

ORDER granting [236/239] Defendant's Motion to Strike the Supplemental Report of Dr. Graeme Hunter and [237/240] Motion to Strike the Supplemental Report of Patrick O'Leary. Signed by Magistrate Judge William Matthewman on 10/9/2019. See attached document for full details. (kza)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLOM DA
CT
Ca eN o. l c 8l - i ir e s a wm a
s
9: 7- v- z6l D m toul a N ûhe
n
A l- g Co .
lTa
p ,

FI
LED BY

Pl i if
antf,

D. .
C
1

.

VS.

02I 2, 2 1
S 29

Che kpo ntSys e s I ,
c i
t m , nc.

ANGELA E.
NOBLE
CL
ERK U S DI .
ST CX

s.. /.. w...
o oF L - pB
:

De e nt
f nda .

/
O R DER G R AN TI G D EFEN DA NT CH EC K PO I T' M O TI N T O ST RI E TH E
N
N S
O
K

SUPPLEM ENTAL REPORT OF DR.GRAEM E HUNTER f 236 2391AND M OTI
DE /
ON
TO STRI THE SUPPLEM ENTAL REPORT OF PATRI O '
KE
CK LEARY I 237 2401
DE
/
TH I CA U SE i be or t Co to t m o i ûl d by D ef nda Che kpoi Sys e s
S
s f e he ur n wo tons e
e nt c nt t m ,
I Bot r l t t t s e e a r por s oft ofPl i if A lnc. h e a e o he uppl m nt l e t
wo
a ntf lTag Cor ' e r w ine s s
p.s xpe t t s e ,

Dr Gr me Huntr a Parc O' a y.The frt( 236239)s kst 'ti Dr Huntrs
. ae
e nd tik Le r
is DE /
ee o srke . e '

s p e na rp r (h f- n e M oint S rk ' , n t s c n ( 23 / 4 4se t srk
u plme tl e o tt e ll tr to o tie' a d he e o d DE 72 0 e ks o tie
lu
)
M r O' ay' s p e n a rpo tt eç le r M oint Srk ' The ematr weerfre
. Le r s u plme tl e r (h t way to o tie). s te s r eerd
o'
t t t ri d by Unie SttsDititJ
o he mdesgne
td ae src udge W ila P.Di toula .( 51 .Pl ntf
lim
mir e s DE j ai if

rs n e t De e d n ' moi n o Oco e 1a d2, 01 .( 2 52 4 2 62 6 . f n a t
epo d d o fn a ts to s n tb r n 2 9 DE 4 /5 , 4 / 5 1 De e d n
rple t Pli ifsrs ns o Ocobe 7, 9.DE 268272,2692734Thust smatri rpe
e id o antf' epo es n t r 201 g
/
/ . ,hi te s i

.

f r vi w . t r as s tf r h be ow ,t Cour GR AN TS bot m o i t s r ke
or e e For he e ons e o t l
he
t
h tons o ti .
1 B ackground
.

The hi t y a c r nt pr ed a pos ur of t s c s i i po t nt t t Cour '
s or nd ur e
oc ur l t e
hi a e s m r a o he
ts
de e m i to o t t o pe ng m o i . s c e w a fl on N ove be 1 201 a m os t o
t r na i n f he w
ndi
tons Thi as s ied
m r 7, 7, l t w

yeasa ( 1.OnM a 4,201 t Cour eneedas he i o de sti t ti pei i
r go.DE )
y
8,he
t tr
c dulng r r etng he ral rod n
t sc ef rJ nuay6, 20, t adic r c of daeo Se e r6,
hi as o a r 20 wih s ovey ut f t f ptmbe 2019.( 43 . Aprl
DE ) On i
4,201 t Co te ee a or r( 1 s ti t f l nge pe tdicos ede i s:
9,he ur ntrd n de DE 04) etng he olowi x r s l ur adlne

Pl i ifsExpe tRe t ndDic os es
antf'
r por a
s l ur
D e e ntsExpe t po ta Di c os e
f nda '
r Re r nd s l ur s
R e talExpe tRe t
bu t
r pors
Expe t i c r Cut f
r D s ove y
of

Jme21 201
t
, 9
J m e 22,201
t
9
A ugps 5,201
t
9
Se e be 1 201
pt m r 1, 9

On M a 18, 8, he Co ta e
y 201 t
ur m nded isprors he i or r ke pi t s m e t i lda e
t i c dulng de , e ng he a ra t

a dp etilsh d l,b ti ldngan tto t r fe ttec re t ie ma itaej d e (
n r -ra c e u e u ncu i
o ain o elc h or c pard gsrt u g . DE
51 .On J 5,201 t Cour e e ed t dic r c - f9o Se e r 11 201 t
j
une
9, he
t xtnd he sovey utof m ptmbe , 9, o
Se e r18 201 g 1 . ra trt pa tesa e dt a t Co ta ptda o dee
ptmbe , 9.DE 644Thee fe,he ri gre o, nd he ur do e nd r rd
( 1 ,t f l nga ndede r dicos ede dlne :
DE 671 he olowi me
xpe t sl ur a i s
Af im a i Expe t e t
fr tve
r R por s
Com pl ton ofD e ii ns ofA 1 Expe t
ei
pos to
1
rs
Re t lExpe tRe r s
buta
r po t
Com pl t o ofD e ii nsofRe t Expe t
ein
pos to
butal
rs
Fa ta Expe t i c r Cut f
c nd
r D s ove y of

J y 1 201
ul 7, 9
Augus 9, 9 ,
t 201
Aug t23, 9
us
201
Se e be 18,
pt m r 2019
Se e be 18,
pt m r 2019

Thus i i i por a t t t Co ' de e m i t o of t pa te ' t o pe ng m otons
, t s m t n o he M s t r na i n
he ri s w
ndi
i

adc e s d i t s Or r t t t e r dic r dea i s ha pas e dic r i cos d,
l s e n hi de ha he xpe t s ove y
r
dlne ve s d, s ove y s l e
s t ntve pr -ra motonsa e d Oc o r 11 201 Daube tmotonsa e d 60 da be or
ubsa i
e ti l i
r ue t be , 9,
r
i
r ue
ys f e

t sa'oft tilst wee pei a t tilpei begi J nuay6,2020.g 51.
he tl he ra' wo- k rod, nd he ra rod ns a r
t
DE 1
Furhe , t sc s hasbe n e h e e y a unnec s a iy ltgi , pe a l i t di co r
t r hi a e
e xt m l nd
r
e s r l ii ous es ci ly n he s ve y

p s . ep ris(n c ranno pate fo wh m d so eywa s ug t h v fldc u te s
ha e Th a t a d e ti n- ris r m o ic v r s o h ) a e ie o n ls
e
di c r m otons r pons s a r ple , a unde s a . Cour , n a ef o t o ge t pa te
s ove y
i , es
e , nd e i s m ny
r e l The
t i n f r t t he r i s

t c o eae ha rq ie t e pate t fl n meo sj itn tc s rg r i g t e n l r u
o o p rt, s e u rd h ris o ie u r u on o ie e a dn h tmeo s
di c r di pu es To ke p t sc s o tac t t r i ne hashe d l ngt di c ve y he dngs
s ove y s t .
e hi a e n r k, he mde s g d
l e hy s o r a

onNove r30, 8( 734M a 6, 9 ( 1 q M a 1 201 ( 1 , t 6,201 (
mbe 201 DE , y 201 DE 31, y 5, 9 DE 441Jme
9 DE

1 ,Aug t23,201 ( 200j a Se e r23,201 ( 23 .
651 us
9 DE
, nd ptmbe
9 DE 24
N o c mtng t s Or r t Co tha ha t e e no l s t n 1 s t ntve di c r
t ot i hi de , he ur s d o nt r
e s ha 3 ubs a i
s ove y

or r ( 75,1 1 1 1 1 1 16 1 1 7,1 263,a 265j a nols t n
des DES
04, 22, 32, 34, 43, 47, 4, 66, 6 68,
nd
, nd e s ha

34pr d a' s ver o des( 65,68 99,1 1 1 i11 11 11 1 1 1 1 ,
oce ur ldico y r r DES
, 00, 07, 09, , 5, 9, 29, 37, 38, 48

2

15 1 1 1 1 1 1 204,2J 21 221 225 226,238,
5, 56, 60, 90, 92, 94, 98,
0, 9, , ,
243, ,25 25 260,261
251 2, 3,
,

a 26 )
nd 4 .
Thes ar t pa te 't r a f t m otonst sr ke. e D Es 21 205- /
e e he ri s hid nd ourh
i o ti Se
6,
1 223,237/ 9,
23
a 236/
nd
240. Oc o r7, 9,t Cot ' g a t i pa t de e i pa' a m o i n t s rke by
On t be 201 he ut r n ed n r and ni d n l
t
t o o ti
D e e nt Che kpo n co e i D r Hunt r s r butal r por , fndi t t Se ton I of li
f nda
c i t nc m ng .
e ' e t e t i ng ha c i V
ls

r butalrpor c ane a fnna i opi o pr e welpas t a sr tve e r r por
e t e t ont i d fi tve ni ns oduc d l t he f ma i xpe t e t
dea i ,a de ed a s co m o i t s rke Pl i if A l- g' a e d Rul 26 di cl ur s
dlne nd ni
e nd ton o t i
a ntf lTa s m nde
e
s os e .

( 26 a d26 j De pt t i p irCo r o d rrg r i gDr Hu trstsi n teCo r fn s
DES 3 n 5 . s ie hs ro u t r e e ad n . n e ' e tmo y,h u ti d
is l ha ng t ye a i w a i o a di c r di put abo one ofD r H t t r s e r r po t ,
t e f vi o t ga n de nt
s ove y s e ut
. m e ' xpe t e r s
e e tls tm e ac om pa e by a di put conc m i M r O ' r s s e e a e r r por .
xc pt li i
c
ni d
s e
e ng . Lea y' uppl m nt l xpe t e t
W ih t sba kgr und i m i t Cour now t nst t t o pe ng m o i t s rke
t hi c o
n nd, he
t
ur o he w
ndi
tons o t i .
l .Di put sU nde l ng Eac M oton t St i
l s e
r yi
h
i o r ke

Reg di Dr Ht e ' s e nt lr por, f nda a g st Coul s d srkei a
ar ng . mt rs uppl me a e tDe e nt r ue he
' houl ti t s
t

i ()c nan n w,a fr tv o i in a d ( )i r p ry rb t t rb ta r p r o o o
t 1 o ti s e fimaie p no s n 2 mp o el e u s he e u tl e o t f ne f
De e d n ' e p r win se , . lseS rvi. nr s o s , anifc ne d ()Dr Hu tr
f n a ts x e t t e s s Dr Ceet a a a I e p n e Plitf o tn s 1 . n e
wa pe m it d t s pl m e hi i tal e t s d on ne i or a i obt ned t ough di co r
s r te o up e nt s nii r por ba e
w nf m ton ai hr
s ve y

a tr siiil e r wa s r e o J l 1 , 1 a d( ) rl i o Fe R. v. 2 ()2 ,h t
fe hi nta rpo t s e v d n uy 7 20 9 n 2 , eyng n d. Ci P. 6 e( ) ta
hi Se e be 1 201 s e e a r por wa tmel be us i wa acualy note n d untl
s ptm r 8, 9, upplm nt l e t s i y ca e t s t l
ve ue i

3 d y beo e til( ih wo l b De e e 6 2 9 ,rt rt n b t e J y 1 ,2 9
0 a s f r ra whc u d e c mb r , 01 ) ahe ha y h ul 7 01 ,
a tr a i e r r por dea i o t Aug t23,
fi m tve xpe t e t dlne r he
us
2019, e t lr po tde dlne.
r buta e r a i
Tt lng t M r O ' a y' s e e al r por, D e e nt Chec nt a gue i ( s
m i o
. Le r s uppl m nt e t
f nda
kpoi r s t G
i

untt r i a wa t 'hi i tale r rpo tt ndi t aprj calylt ne afimai
eheed n ny y o' s nii xpe t e r,s s hus eudii l ae w tr tve
a
o ni .' ( 237,p.3) Pli ifAl- g rpe t muc oft sme agt ns i ma i
pi onlj' DE
. antf l- e as h he a r une t t kes n
fa
r ponse t t H t er M oton t St i M r O ' y' s em ent repor i not i pr ,
es
o he mt
i o rke. . Lear s uppl
al
ts
m oper

Pl ntf a gue ,be aus i ( ie m a e i la i or a i t tw a onl a ia e t M r O ' a y
ai if r s c e t G t s t r a nd nf m ton ha s y va l bl o . Le r
c

a e hi i talrpor wa fl 'onJ y1 201 ( 245, 4)(mphassi orgna)
jtr s nii e t s ied' ul 7, 9. DE
p. e
i n ii l.
11 A nal i
1.
ys s

a Hu tr oi nt S rk ( 2 62 9
. n e M to o tie DE 3 / 3 1
D r Hunt r spur r e s e e alr por i a cl a vi a i n oft Cour ' J m e 7, 9,
.
e ' po t d uppl m nt e t s e r ol to
he
ts t
201

Or r( 1 a ndi t e r dic vey de dlnei tlsc e.Tha Or r whih meey
de DE 67j me ng he xpe t s o r a i n li as
t de, c rl
a o d a m a of i i t pa te own a r e e ,r quied t pa tes t s r e h o he
ppr ve nd de f c al he r i s'
g e m nt e r he r i o e ve ac t r
wih t i i tala fr tve e r r po t by J y 1 201 a t rr bu t r pors by A ugus
t he r nii fi ma i xpe t e r s
ul 7, 9, nd hei e tal e t
t
23,201 f a p. The pa te w e e t n pe m it d t de e ea h o he ' r buta e rs by t
9. J. t 2.
r i s r he r te o pos c t r s e t l xpe t
he
c o e oft di c r on Se e be 1 201 f Si pl e ugh.
ls
he s ove y
pt m r 8, 9. #. m e no
But notf Pl ntf .I t d,Pl i if fr t al m pt d t i p o ry s a a a fnua i
or ai if ns ea
a ntf i s te e o m r pe l ne k n f i tve
e r o ni i o D r H t t ' r buta r por .Se D E 263.The Cour or r d t t a fnua i
xpe t pi on nt . m er s e t l e t e
t de e ha f i tve

opi onsrc n onOcobe 7, 9. J. ts ul ha be nt e oft m a trN ow,Pl i if
ni tike
t r 201 f Tha ho d ve e he nd he te .
antf,

i vi ainoft Co tsJ 7, 9,Or rg 1 ,i et t e c s meafnuai opi on
n olto he ur' une 201 de DE 671 ns rs he xa t a fi tve ni
t Cour odeedsrc ni isprorOr e ( 263 i oane t up e ntl'e r fldwel
he
t r r tike n t i d r DE 2 nt
w G plme a'rpo t ie l
s
afe et rt J y 1 201 a fr tve e r r por de i ort Aug t23,201 r b t
tr ihe he ul 7, 9, fima i xpe t e t pdlne he
us
9, e utal
e r r po ' de dlne.
xpe t e l a i
t

Unde Fe R. v. 26()pa tesmus s pplme a e r' r por fnatmeymame
r d. Ci P. e, ri
t u e nt n xpe ts e t' i l r r
i
i t pa t l a n t ti s em a e i la pec t di c os e o r s
f he ry e r s ha n om
t r a s t he s l ur f e pons i i om pl t ori or ec '
e s nc
e e nc r t'
a t addii
nd he
tonalor c r tve i o to m us t O he wi e be n m ade know n t t ot r
or ec i nf nna i n
ti
not t r s e
o he he

pate d i t dic r pr es o i wrtngEq'Thi doe notme n,howe rt tpatesc n
ris urng he s ovey oc s r n ii .' s s
a
ve,ha ri a
be a e y a ne o ni o untm el r buta opi o unde t gui e ofs e e a r po t .
l t dl dd w pi ons r i y e t l ni ns
r he s
uppl m nt l e r s
( ca e t e r w ine s di c r r e a e de i d t a l bot s d i a c s t
G us he xpe t t s s ove y ul s r s gne o low
Be
h i es n a e o
pr pa et i c s sade t y a t pr ve s p r s . . om pla e w ih t r qui e e sofRul
e r he r a e
qua el nd o e nt u ie . c
i nc t he e r m nt
e

4

2 i no meeyapiain l'Co pe v S uh r Co, 9 F.d6 5 7 8( 1hCi. 0 4 (n en l
6 s t rl s rto a. o r . o te n .3 0 3 9 , 2 1 t r 2 0 ) itr a
'
ctto o te . R.Ci P. c()i tu t t twhee1 pat fist pr dei o maton
iains mitd) Fed. v. 37()1 nsr cs ha r $ ry al o ovi nf r i
a
. . .

a rquiedby Rul 26()o () t pa t i no al t us t ti or ton o wine s...
se r
e a r e ,he ry s t lowed o e ha nf mai r t s

une stefi ewa s b tn il u tfe o h r e s'S e eg , t hv R. Re n lsT b c o
ls h al
ur s u sa tal siid r amls . e , ..Poi . J y od o a c
yj
'
s
Co,9 1 -v- 1 , 01 W L 5 5 9 a * - ( . Fl. v. 0 20 7 ; n g d Ca eSos,
. :5c 81 71 2 7
9 28 2, t 2 4 SD. a No 3 , 1 ) Ma a e r l.
I c v Ese He l c r ,I c, 9 c - 0 51 2 1 W L 1 3 7 4 a * ( D. a M a 3 2 0 .
n . . s nt at a e n . 0 -v 6 3 , 0 0
h
8 7 2 , t 3 S. Fl. y , 01 )
Th b r e o s o ngt a afi r t dsl s o c mp ywa s b tn ilyj tfe o h r e s
e u d n f h wi h t al e o ico e r o l s u sa tal usiid r a mls
u
i o t n n ds lsngpa t M i h l v Fo d Moo Co,3 8Fe Ap 8 ,8 4 ( 1h Ci.
s n he o - ico i ry. t el . r tr . 1 d. px. 21 2 1 t r
c
2 0 ) Excu i ni as a a p o raerme yu e Fe R. v. 1 () whih a t o ie te
0 9 . lso s lo n p r p it e d nd r d. Ci P. 6b , c uh rz s h
c t o co r a e d t pr ti ldico y t ough a s he i or ra gi t c t oad
our t nt ol nd xpe ie e r a s ver hr
c dulng de nd ves he our br
di c e i t pr e v t i e iy a pur e of a pr ti l or r i l ng t e us on of
s r ton o es r e he nt grt nd pos
e r a de , nc udi he xcl i
e denc Companhi Ener i Potgu v.Cat r larI , o.1 c 24277, 6 W L 31
vi e.
a
getc i ar
e pil nc.N
4- v201
02225,

a *5( D. a J 2,201 )
t S. Fl. une
6.
Cours ha br ad di c e i n t e l t i e y- s l e e r r por s e n one
t ve o
s r to o xc ude mtm l di c os d xpe t e t, ve
s
1

de i t d a Ss e e a ' r po t . d. se al o eg. Cook v Ro Ca i an Cr s s N o.11
s gna e s Guppl m nt l' e r s 1 ; e s , . ,
. yal r bbe
ui e ,
-

c 20732,201 W L231
v2
9089( D. a.une1 201 ;Goodb Cr e ,LLC v. c I .Co,
S. Fl J 5, 2)
ys e k
Arh ns .No.
7-vc 0947,2009 W L 11
39575,a * ( . Fl Apr 27,2009 .Pa test c mota eRul
t 2 M D. a. .
) ri hus ar bus
e
26()a us as e ntlrpor t t r l boltradee tveorpr e tce r wine s
e nd e upplme a e t o ç ey se
me
fci
oblmai xpe t t s
rpor. Catr larI .201 W L 31 225,a * Rul 26()(snotad viet al apa t s
e t' epil nc, 6
'
02
t 6. e e i
i
e c o low
ry'
e r t e ge i addii na w or o t ar opi ons orof e ne onest pe f c a ltga i
xpe t o nga n
to l k, r o mul ni
fr w
o r e t ii tng

srtgy. Coc anv,TheBrnk nn Cor , 8-v- 790,2009W L 48
tae ' hr
'
i ma
p.No. c 1
23858 a *5 ( D.Ga
, t N.
.

De .9 2 0 ) afd b 38 Fe Ap x.9 8 ( 1h Ci. 2 ) Th o l p pos o Rue 2 ()
c , 0 9 , f ' y, 1 d. p 6 1 t r 20 0 . e ny u e f l 6 e
i nf m to ha
s em ent ton i çf t nar pur
uppl
a i s lor he row
pose ofcor ectng i c ac es oradd ng i or a i n t t
r i nac ur i
.

w as notavaia e att tm e oft i talrepor.'Potsh,2017 W L 5952892,at*3.
l bl he i
he nii
t' i

The Cour ' de i i n i Pots i i t u tve he e.The e t Cour or r t pa te t
ts c s o n
i h s nsr c i
r
r , he
t de ed he ri s o
fl t i e r di cl ur by Se e be 26,201 1 N e rhe e s t pl i if w aie un i
ie he r xpe t s os es
pt m r
7. d. ve t l s , he a ntf
t d tl
N o be 1 201 t fl t s e e a r po tof o ofis wine s s 1 Tha s ppl m e t
vem r 3, 7, o ie he uppl m nt l e r
ne t t s e . d. t u e n al
r por S i f c nty c nge f om a g ne i o ni r r ng t t ba c i ty t one w hi h
e t t gnii a l ha d r
s
e rc pi on ega di he o c o ndus r o
c
a i d diec l t t de e nt'pl i ifw a r pr s ntng. #.a 4.Thus t Co tf und t tt
pple r ty o he c de ' a ntf s e e e i f t
, he ur o
ha he

e r' a tons i hi s e nt lr po t' r nott c r c a e si i onuai n, bu
xpe ts ddii n s uppl me a e r t e
'
we
o ore t ny xitng nf
to
t
r t rt bolt rt e s i opi o a i l i pe m i sbl opi onsa t rt e r di c osles
a he o s e he xi tng ni n nd nc ude m r s i e ni
fe he xpe t s l tr
dea i .' d
dlne '1

The Cour ha ve y c r f l r viwe bot Dr Hunt rsi ta a fr ai r po ta li
t s r a e uly e e d h .
e ' nii l fim tve e r nd ls
PUT or e ( u e e a ' r po ta c l st tD r Hunt r sIs e e a ' r por i a diec
P t d G ppl m nt l' e r nd onc ude ha .
s
e ' tuppl m nt l' e t s r t
and un i e y r bu t t t r buta r por ofD e e ntChe kpoi ' e r wines D r Sa a a
tm l e tal o he e tl e t
f nda
c nt s xpe t t s . r vi ,
no a m e e s e e a i ofhi pror r por . Li t ç uppl m e a ' r por s nz k i Pots
t
r uppl m nt ton
s i e tl ke he s
s e nt l' e t t c n
i h,
D r H unt r s ts e e a ' r po tw a S t t c r e t a e s i i br a i but r t r t
.
e ' duppl m nt l' e r s i o o r c ny xi tng nt m ton,
no
a he o
bolt r t e s i opi o a i l e i pe m i s bl o ni a tr t e r di c os e
s e he xitng
ni n nd nc ud m r s i e pi ons fe he xpe t s l ur s
de dlne. 1
a i ' d.
'
H a ng c l d D r H un e ' S uppl m e a ' r por w a t tm e y, t Cour m us
vi
onc ude
.
t rs û
s e nt l' e t s m i l he
t
t

c n ie wh t e d t i o e Plitf Al- gag e i wa s b tn ilyj siidi tikig
o sd r a r me y o mp s . an if lTa r u s t s u sa tal u tfe n hn n
i c u ds p lme tise pe te rsa s c alt d t b c u eFe . Ci P. 6 e( )p o d s
t o l u pe n t k r rpo t t u h ae ae e a s d R. v. 2 ()2 rvie
t ta pa t ss em e si us bedi c os d by t tm e t pa t spr t i ldi c os esu rRul
ha
r y' uppl nt û t
m
sl e
he i he ry' e r a s l ur nde
e

2 ()3 ae d e' Th s u d r Rue 2 ()3 ,whc isnlt ta (u nls t c u to d r
6 a( ) r u . u , n e l 6 a() ih n t cs h t t l e s he o r r es
'
f
ot nv s t s dic oj e mus bem a a las 30 d bef r til'Pli ifc ntndsi c d
he ie, he e s l ur s
t
de t e t ays o e ra y' a ntf o e
t oul

i 80 h Dr Huntrs i tala fr ai r por a hi (s e e al'r por wer fld unde s ali s ppo tof
t
e ' nii fim tve e t nd s tupplm nt ' e t e ie
r e n u r
.
D eenda ' m oto Se DE 239- 239 3.l lghtoft rs al saus t Cour w ilnotgo it deai a
f nts in. e
2, - n i
hei e ed tt , he
t l
n o t l boutt
he
dif r nc bewee Dr Hunersafim a i r r a hi t upplm e al rpo tN o t ls ,e n acuror r vi
fe e es t n . t ' fr tve epo t nd s t
s e nt ' e r. nehee s ve
'
s y e ew
oft r l sm a s i abu n l clart tD r Hunt r s f uppl
he epo' ke t nda ty e ha .
t
e ' s ement ' r ' con a nsnum e o untm ey r bu t
s
al' epol t i
t
r us i l e tal
opi onsdie tya t ki D r Sar a' r butalrpor.
ni
r cl tac ng . avi s e t e t

6

s e e is ç r r pors untl 30 da be or t i l i t s m a t r Pl i i f s pos to i
uppl m nt t xpe t e t
i
ys f e r a n hi
te . a ntf'
ii n s
m i g de a w r ng.
s ui d nd o

Pl nifa Defnda s cfc lyagee t a t Co to d e a a pt ( 1 ,
aitf nd e nt pe iial r d o, nd he ur r erd nd do ed DE 671
s cii e r di c ve y de lne .The pa te di notpr pos or a r e t a t Co ts Or r
pe fc xpe t s o r ad i s
ris d
o e
g e o, nd he ur ' de
neve pe te a C t - e tal'da e The l s da e f r pr
r nnit d, t l r bu t ' t .
sr
a t t o oduc ng a r buta e r r por w a
i
e t l xpe t e t s

Augus 9,201 g 1 ,a ye bot o Pli ifse rs s e ntlrpo t we epr e
t
9 DE 671 nd t h f antf' xpe t' upplme a e rs r oduc d
o t e ni of Se e be 18 201 t ve y l s da ofdi c ve y. a ntf ' a t m ptt r m i e
n he ve ng
pt m r , 9, he r a t y
s o r Pl i if s te
o e t

t hit r oft sc e,dir ga d isa ee t a Cour-mpos d e r dic os e d dlne , nd
he so y hi as s e r t gr d-o nd
ti
e xpe t s l ur ea i s a

t n a g Dr Ht e ' ts e nt l' e t snotdueuntl30da be or t J nua y 6,
he r ue . mt r s tupplme a'r por wy
i
ys f e he a r 2020,

til ae( ti, c mbe 6 2 9 i fal rj ce .No i Plitf' e o h nnls. so r
ra d t t s De e r , 01 ) s lt ee tdz r s an ifs n'r n e s Dic vey
ha
y
i t sca e ha c os d. ft s Cour w e et pe tPl i ift r l upon isuntm e y s e e a
n hi s s l e I hi
t r o nni a ntf o e y
t
i l uppl m nt l
e r r po t t n i w oul ha t 1 tDe e n e ge i f rhe w or a di c r t a l is
xpe t e r , he t
d ve o e f nda t nga n u t r k nd s ove y o low t

e r t rs
xpe t o e pond,t r by sa lng a dea ng t sc e.Thi c e hasbe n pe ng f am os
he e tli nd lyi hi as
s as
e ndi or l t
t o yea s I i tm e f t di c r a e r di c os e s a oft s c e t be c os s t
w
r . t s i or he s ove y nd xpe t s l ur t ge hi as o
l ed o he
Cour ca f us o s t ntve m o i a t i l
t n oc n ubs a i
tons nd ra .
Thi i t s co tm ePl n ifA l- ha ti t s a i D r H t e ' a fnnatve e r
s s he e nd i
ai t f lTag s red o ne k n . mt r s f
i xpe t

o ni n bylbei i s m ehi i i not Ther q ti t s m e. .
pi o
a lng t o t ng t s .
e ul s he a Dr Hunt ' ( u e e t 'r po t
ers G pplm n al'e r
s
s r e on Se embe 18,201 i he e src n.Pl i ifma notr l upon orot r s us
evd
pt
r
9, s r by tike
antf y
ey
he wie e,
eihe d r c l ori r ty, he Suppl m e a Expe t e tofGr e e H unt r PI. . ta poi
t r i e ty ndiec l t
e nt l
r R por
am
e , AD a ny nt
i t sc e, nc udi i di postvem oto ,r s ns s o a t i l
n hi as i l ng n s ii
i ns e po e , r t ra .

2Plitf a gu ntt ti c dpr eiss eme t expe t e t da be or ti r coun e t t eCour'
an ifs r me ha t oul oduc t uppl nal r r por 30 ys f e ràl uns t r o h
ts

Ame e S h d igOr e E 51, c rq rsa1 u et t n t b fld6 d y beo ec ln a cl,h t
nd d c e ul
n d r DE 1whih e uie lDa b r moi s o e ie 0 a s fr ae d r alta
o
i,o orbef eNove be 3, l Pl n ifsm igui d agumentwoul m e t tt pariscoul fl s emenal
s n
or
m r 20 9. aitf' s de r
d an ha he te
d ie uppl t

e e'rp rsa rted a l efrGln Da b r moin .Thsag me td fe lgca d c mmo s nea di
xp l e o t pe h e di o ig u et to s i r u n eis o i n o n e s n s
t
n
rjce .
eetd
7

b.O' a y M o i t S'i r 237 2401
Le r
ton o t ke DE /
r

Th fcsu d ryngt eO' a yM oint S rk ( 23 / 4 )aelr eyt s mea d
e a t n eli h Le r to o tie DE 72 0 r ag l he a n ,
t , s i t r s t M r O ' a y' ( uppl e a ' r po t c ai untm e y a i pr per
hus o s he e ul. . Le r s ç
s em nt l' e r ont ns i l nd m o

afr tveopi o i vi ai oft Cour' prorOr r( 1 a wilbesrc n.
fimai
nins n olton he
ts i de DE 674 nd l tike

Assae a o e Rue2 ()(jn t d v c t al w apat se petoe g g i a d t n l
ttd b v , l 6 e t 0 a e ie o lo
i
ry' x r t n a e n d ii a
o
w o k,ort a nulo ni or o f r ne onest perec a ltga i s r t gy. Coc an,20 W L
r
o n
pi ons
fe w
o f t ii tng t a e '
' hr
09

48 58,a * Theonl pur e o Rul 26e s e ntto i Sort na
238 t 5.
y pos f e () upplme ain s s he now pur eof
f
pos
c r tng i cc a esora ng i o m a i n t tw > no a l e a t tm e oft i t a r por.'
or ec i na ur ci
ddi nf r to ha s t vaiabl t he i
he nii l e t'
Pots 201 W L 5
i h, 7
9528 a * M r O ' a y' s e e alr por w e f rbe
92, t 3. . Le r s uppl m nt e t nt a yond t tt r o
ha s r w
na
PY9 CS0.'
'

The Cour hasve y c r uly r vi we bot ofM r O' r s e r r pors The Cour
t
r a ef l e e d h
. Lea y' xpe t e t.
t
nee notgo i o de a lr ar ng t dif r nc s be wee M .. ' r s i tala fr a i e r
d
nt t i eg di he f e e e t n 1 O Lea y' nii f im tve xpe t
.
r por a hi ne s c le ts e e al'r por.A sm pl c pa i o of t t r po t i
e t nd s w o- a l d iuppl m nt ' e t
i e om r s n
he wo e r s s
enough. M r. O ' a y' i talà fr a i e r r por w a s r e on J y 1 201 a g ne a l
S
Le r s nii f im tve xpe t e t s e v d
ul 7, 9 nd e r ly

o ne o D e enda Chec nt s a l e f l e ad tsng az m a ke i H i ç uppl m e a '
pi d n f
nt
kpoi ' leg d a s veri i ld r tng. s s
s e nt l'
r por,by c r s ,w a s z on Se e be 18,201 a of e s a hos ofe t rne ,a fr a i
e t
ont a t s e ved
pt m z
9, nd f r
t ihe w f im tve
o ni nsoropi onsm e ntt r butt e ofDr Sa a a
pi o
ni
a o e hos
. r vi .
W ih r pe tt M r O ' a y' d u e e a 'r po t Pl i ifA l- r pea sm uc oft
t es c o . Le r s û ppl m nt l' e r , a ntf lTag e t
s
h he

s me s b tn ilj siiain a d h r e s s agi n st a i ma e r g r ig Dr Ht e '
a u sa ta u t c to n a mlsnes r l t h t t d e adn . mtrs
f
me
s m ia l untm e y a i pr pe d uppl m e a 'r po t Pl ntf nd Def nda s cii ly a e
i l r y i l nd m o r ç
s e nt l' e r . ai i fa
e nt pe fca l gr ed

t andt Cour or r a ado e ( 16 ,s cfce r dico r de dlne .l Pli if
o, he
t deed nd ptd DE 71 pe ii xpe t s vey a i s f antf
ne ded m or tm e t pr uc is e r opi o ,i s d ha s ug r le f om t e de dlne
e
e i o od e t xpe t ni ns t houl ve o ht e i f r hos a i s

3 Bot M r O' ar s i talafim ai r ta hi ç uppl
h . Le y' nii fr tve epor nd s < ementl'r por we e fl unders ali s
s
a' e t r ied
e n uppor o
tf
D eenda ' m o i Se DE 239- 239- I lghtoft rs ae saus t Cour w ilnotgo it deala
f nts ton. e
2,
3. n i
hei e ld tt , he
t l
n o ti boutt
he
dif r e be we M r O' r sa tr a i r por a hi ts e e a ' r r .
f e enc s t en . Lea y' fs m tve e t nd s fuppl m nt l' epo t

( e d ie i a r e t )fo t e Co r.l dd n t l ta ,Plit f tid t s u e e i n w
d a ln s t g e d o r m h u t t i o . nse d ani re o q e z n e
f
a fnna i a r bu t l o ni m a ke as t up e e t ' r pors i di e t vi a i of is
f i tve nd e t a pi ons s d
d pl m n al' e t n r c ol ton
s
t

agee ntwihDee nta t sCour' prorOr r( 1 .
r me t fnda nd hi
ts i de DE 674
M . O ' a y' çs e e a r por ' s r e o Se e be 18 201 i he e sr c n.
1 Le r s tuppl m nt l e t' e v d n pt m r , 9, s r by ti ke
.
.
Pl i i fm a notr l upon oro he wi e us ,e t rdiec l ori r c l t Suppl m e a Expe t
a ntf y
ey
t r s e ihe r ty ndie ty, he
e nt l
r

Re tofPa rc O' r a a poi i t sc s i l ngi dipostvem oto , es e ,
por
tik Lea y t ny nt n hi a e, ncudi n s ii
i ns r pons s or
a ti l
t ra .
lV .C oncl i
us on

Ba e on t f e ng,i i he e O R DER ED t t
sd
he or goi t s r by
ha :
1. D e e n Che poi ' M o i t St i Untm e y tsuppl m e a Expe tRe tof
f nda t
ck nts ton o rke
i l ç
e nt l
r por

Gre Huntr Ph. ' Se v d Se e r1 201 ( 2362394i GRANTED,a
a me
e, D. r e ptmbe 8, 9 DE /
'
s
s
f l s
olow :
The Suppl m e a Expe t po to Gr e e H t t r Ph. . ss rc n. a ntf m a
e nt l
r Re r f a m
m e , D i ti ke Pl i if y
notr y upon orot r s us ,e t rdiec l ori r c l t Suppl m e t lExpe t
el
he wi e e ihe r ty ndie ty, he
e na
r
R e tof Gr e e H unt r PI. .a a po nt i t s c s ,i l ng i dipos tve
por
am
e , AD t ny i n hi a e nc udi n s ii
m otons r
i , esponses,oratti .
ral

Def nda Che kpoi ' M oton t St i U ntm e y d ppl m e a Expe tRe r of
e nt
c nt s
i o rke
i l ç
su e nt l
r po t

Parc O' r ' r dSe e r18, 9g 237/ i GRANTED,a f l
tik Leay'Seve ptmbe 201 DE
2404 s
s olows:
The Suppl m e t lRe t Pa rc O ' a y i sr c n. a ntf m a notr l upo
e n a por of t i k Le r s ti ke Pl i if y
ey n
or ot wi e us eiher diecty or i r l t Suppl ent Expe Reportof
her s e, t
r l
ndiecty, he
em al
rt

Pa r c O ' a y a a poi i t s c e, i l ng i dipostve m o i ,
ti k Le r t ny
nt n hi as nc udi n s ii
tons
r ponses,or atti .
es
r al

9

DO E and ORDERED i c mbe sa W es Pam Bea h,Pam Bea h Coun y,Fl rda
n ha r t
t l
c
l
c
t oi ,

ti 1 zyooc br21.
hs a f t e,09
o
.

J .-*
# -

W I AM M AT 1 EW *
LLI
1
Unied St t sM agita eJ
t
ae
sr t udge