All-Tag Corporation v. Checkpoint Systems, Incorporated

Filing 281

ORDER denying 259 Plaintiff's Expedited Motion to Compel. Signed by Magistrate Judge William Matthewman on 10/10/2019. See attached document for full details. (kza)

UN I
TED STA TES D I I COU RT
STR CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
Ca eN o.9: 7- v- z6l D i ir ul as a = a
s
l e 8l - m t o e N dhe
n
A l- a Cor ,
l- g
f
p.

FI
LED BY

Pli it
antfl

D.
C.

VS.

02T 12 2 1
29
Che kpo ntSyse ,I ,
c i
t ms nc.

ANGELA E.
NOBL
E
CL
ERK U S DII CX
S

so. F A. w. B
, oF ' - I .
L
:
t

De e nt
f nda .

.

/

ORDER DENYI PLAI FF' EXPEDI
NG
NTI S
TED M OTI TO COM PEL ( 2591
ON
DE
THI CAUSE i be or t Co t Pl i ifAl-fa Cor ' Expe t dM oto t Co pe
S
s f e he ur on antf l- g p.s
die
in o m l

Doc nt W ihhed a Prvie a No Dicos d o aPrvieg Log y 25 .Thi malr
ume s t l/ s i lged nd t s l e n i l e
DE 91 s te
wa rf re t t unde sgne byUniedStt DititJ eW ila P. mir e .g 51
s e erd o he ri d
t aes src udg lim Di toulas DE 1.
Themotonwa tldo Ocobe 4, 9, t Cour e die brei oft moi ( 261 .
i s ie n t r 201 and he
t xpe td ifng he ton.DE 2
The m o i i now f l br e e Se D Es 259,274,276 277,28 Thus t m oton i rpe f r
ton s
uly i f d. e
,
0.
, he
i si o

rviw. rt ras nss tfrhbeow,heCour DENI t moi ( 2591
e e Fo he e o e o t l t
t
ES he ton DE
.
1 Bac
. kgro
und
As s a ed i r ce t Or r ,s DEs 263,265,276,t Cour i e r m e y f usr t d a
t t n e n de s ee
he
t s xt e l r t a e nd
dia
s ppoi ed by t pa te ' di c r co
nt
he ri s s ove y nduc t o
t hr ughoutt s c e.Eve t
hi as
n hough t di c r
he s ove y

c of da e was Se e r 18 201 a e n t
ut f t
pt mbe , 9, nd ve hough s tntve m o i a e due t
ubsa i
tons r
omorow,
r
Oc obe 11 201 t sCour ha ha t putas de o he c e a m a tr i an e f t o r o ve t
t r , 9, hi
t s do
i t r as s nd te s n
f or t es l he
num e ous a r pe t d di c r r l t di put whi h ha a i e t o ho tts ltga i n.
r
nd e a e s ove y- e a ed s es
c ve r s n hr ug ut li ii to
,

Eve w ihi t pa t s ve alw e ks a t t Se e be 18 2019,di c r c of da e t s
n t n he s e r
e - fer he pt m r ,
s ove y ut f t - hi
Co tha ha t i s a pl t a ofs t ntve a pr e za di c r - el t d o de s ba e on
ur s d o s ue e hor
ubsa i nd oc dlr l s ove y r a e r r s d

l tm i em otonsfl by t pa te .Thi i nothow t di c ve ypr s i s
as- nut
i ied he ris s s
he s o r oce s s uppos d t wo k.
e o r

Subs a i m otonsa e duet or ow , c obe 11 201 and ye ,d piet e ensve a
t ntve i
r
om r O t r , 9,
t es t he xt i nd

tmec ns mi j iillb rt eCouth sar a y d v td t t i c s,t eesilrman o
i -o u ng udca a o h t' a le d e oe o hs a e h r tl e is ne
pe ng di c r r l t d m oton, t t i , Pl i if Al- g' Expedied M o i n t Com pel
ndi
s ove y- e a e
i
ha s a ntf
lTa s
t
to o

Do nt W ihhed a Prvie d a No Dicos donaPrvie Logg 2591 tldOcobe
cume s t l s i lge nd t s l e
i lge
DE
,ie t r
4,2019.I lghtoft pr d a s a usoft s c s ,t Cour e died brefng o t s m oton
ni
he oce ur l t t
hi a e he
t xpe t
i i n hi
i

( 26 1 a dt eCo r h s w ha a o p rt t t c r flyrviw De e d n ' Repo s (
DE 1 , n h u t a no d n p o t y o ae ul e e f n a ts s n e DE
mi
I

274jfldOcobe 8,201 Pli ifsRe y ( 277 fldOcobe 9, 9,a Pl nifss aed
ie t r
9, antf' pl DE 1 ie t r 201 nd aitf' e l
Exhi tA ( 2802t isrpl fl Oco r1 201
bi DE
o t e y,ied tbe 0, 9.
W ih t tbe ng s d,t Co ti no pr pa e t i s a e die nzi o Pl i if s
t ha i ai he ur s w e r d o s ue n xpe t d lng n a ntf '
pe ng e die m o i
ndi xpe t d ton.
I Di cuss on and A nal s
I. s i
ysi

Th ds t u d ryn Plitf smoin t c mpe ( 2 3 i sr ih f r r .Un e
e ipue n elig an if
t o o l DE 0 ) s tag to wad d r
o
Fe R.Ci P. 1 5 a S. Fl L.R. 1 e( ( ,ltga smus,unl seihe t ya ee
d.
v. 26(9() nd D. a.
26.( )2)D) ii nt t es t r he gr
ort Cour or r o he wi e, e v e h ot rw ih aprvieg 1 ls i doc e sr s
he
t de s t r s s r e ac he t
i l e og itng um nt e ponsve t
i o

t opposngpa t sdic r r ue t t twe ewihhedfom pr to ont basso prvie
he
i
ry' s ove y eq ss ha r t l r
oduci n he i f i l ge

C o ltrt nf u te (4 d y flo n s r ieo : i a y itro ao' r s ns o d c me t
d ae ha o re n 1 ) a s olwig evc f () n ner g t l epo e r o u n
n
y
pr tonfom whihs i o to o doc nt aewihhel ...or(i t r s ns t t
oduci r
c ome nf nnain r ume s r t d ; i) he epo e o he
r q s f pr ton i a1rs i docl nt aebeng wihhedgj'Net rpa t di t t
e uet or oduci f 1 e ponsve tme s r i t l .' ihe ry d ha
he e N e t rpa t tm el c pled w ih t r l a l w a i bl t prvie l .
r . ihe ry i y om i
t he u es nd a pplca e o i l ge ogs
A c r ng t D e e ntChec nt Pl i ifA l- g s r d isprvieg 1 onD ef nda
co di o f nda
kpoi , a ntf l Ta e ve t i l e og
e nt

a 1 25p. onSe e r1 201 t veyl tda ofdic r ( 274, 3) Dee nt fr
t 0: m. ptmbe 8, 9,he r as y s ovey.DE
p. . fnda , o
ispart di nots
t
, d
erve isprviege 1 on Pl ntf untlOct
t i l og
ai if i
ober4,2019 16 days aft t cl of
er he ose

dic r a svea hour a t Pli iffl ismotont c
s ovey nd e rl s fer antf ied t i o ompe.( 274,p.1.
l DE
)

2

N o ,Pl n if de pie ha ng s r d is own prvie 1 l t a ni on t cl e o
w ai tf , s t vi e ve t
i l ge og a e t ght
he os f
di c r s e a Or rtndi D e e
s ove y, e ks n de i ng f ndan ha w a ve isr g t as e t i l ge by flng a l t
t s i d t i ht o s r prvie
ii
ae
prvie l a c pe lng D e e n t pr
i l ge og nd om li
f nda t o oduc a 1do e s w ihhe d on prvie gr
e l cum nt t l
i l ge ounds
.
D e e nt o c s ,o
f nda , f our e ppos Pl i i f sm o i n,a g ng t t m o i n i es e i ly m ootnow
es a ntf ' t o r ui hat he t o s s nta l
t ti ha s r e isprvie 1 an f rhe , ha Pl i if sow n dia or conduc i pr
ha t s e v d t i l ge og d, u t r t t a ntf '
lt y
t n oduc ng is
i t

pr lg l ga tev r ls mo n o fesa ypoe ta p eu iet Plitf fo Dee da ts
i e e o t h ey a t me t fst n tnil rj dc o an if r m fn n '
vi
untm ey s r e prviegel
i l e v d i l og.

Pli ifa g si ismoto ( c wa fld as ttmebeor Dee ntpr
antf r ue n t in whih s ie hor i
f e fnda oduce is
dt

p iie el g t a Dee d n ' S alr t p o u eap iie elg o ewe kfo t d a l efr
rvlg o ) h t fn a ts t i e o r d c rv lg o , n e r m he e di o
fu
n
Slmma yJ
l r udgme motons i unf ra prj ca t g antf s a lt t d a'Ees e t ,
nt i ,s ai nd eudiil o pli if j biiy o r f r pons s oj
t

a d d fnd' g i tDee d n ' a tcp td mo in frs mmayj d me ta p ndn mo in
n ee 'a ans f n a ts niiae to o u r u g n nd e ig to
f r u g n o tep e dng g 2 7 . anifas a c s sDe e d n o tyn t çu p es
o j d me t n h la i s DE 0 J Plit lo c u e fn a t f r ig o l p r s
f
s
e de e' by f ii t tm e y pr
vi nc '
a lng o i l oduc doc e s a e gi i çde i r t ' del y t ough
e
um nt nd nga ng n d lbe a e ' a hr

( nt o e nsvedea tcisgl'( 259, 5 .
ç hs f xpe i ly a tc .' DE
mo
p. j
A tt sl t dat i t s c s t Cou ' i unpe s de by Pl i if sar l e s The s m pl
hi a e e n hi a e, he
l s
t
r ua d
a ntf ' glm nt .
i e

tuhi t a n i e p ryt ti c s c mpidwihS. Fl. R. .()2 ( O Fe . Ci P.
r t s h t et r a t o h s a e o le t D. a L. 26 1e ( )D) r d R. v.
h
26b)5) Bot pa te s r t i rs ci prvie l o e hot rwela tr1 da fo
( ( . h ris eved her epe tve i lge ogs n ac he l fe 4 ys r m
t da et y e c w ihhel pr
he t he a h t d oduc i The Co lt le sbo h pa te di t si a e f t o o a n
ton.
tr be i ve t r i s d hi n n f or t bt i

s mes 4ofsrt ca nt .Pli ifma i fc,a i cams beprj c byDee n '
o ol taegi dva age antf y,n a t s t li , eudied
fnda ts
u i e y prvie 1 a di c r ha c os d i t s c e a Pl i if no l r ha tm e t
ntm l i l ge og s s ove y s l e n hi as nd a ntf
onge s i o
c l nge D e e nt s a s r i o p iie e Bu ti came p eu ie a p is e ual t
hale
f nda ' s e tons f rv lg . t h s li d rj dc p le q ly o
t i l ge bg nd
e nts onc t nt na lt o
Pl i t f s untm el di c os e of is prvie l a D ef nda ' c om ia i biiy t
a n if
i y s l ur
i l ge s o t l
um nt .
ri
ve y
c l
halenge Pl ntf s as i of prvie a t w ihhe d doc e s The pa tes ha onl
ai if' sertons

t ms l st blmef whatve prj cet ma s fra ars toft i c ndu .
he eve o a or e r eudi hey y ufe s e ul her o ct

3

Bec us bo h s de , n a a r nte f ta gn es a hi w a t d t i t ve y l s m i e
a e t i s i n ppa e f or t m m ns p, ie mtl he r a t nut

t tl prvie l ,t y ha putt Cour i a t e bl postdn.Tha i be us t Co t
o ie i l ge ogs he ve
he
t n n mt na e ii
t s ca e he ur
s m pl c l otpos i y or ra i c e a r vi w oft nlm e o doc l e t ls e on D e e nt s
i y am
sbl de n n am r e e
he l r us lm n s i t d
f nda '
l ng hy prvie l c r uly r vi w t e do um e s de e m i whe he D e e n ' c ai s of
e t
i l ge og, a ef l e e hos c nt , t r ne
t r f nda t s l m
prvie a e pr pe ,a e e a a opra e O r rby t or ow ,O c obe 11 2019 t de dlne
i l ge r o r nd nt r n ppr i t de
om r
t r ,
, he a i
f f lng s t n i m otons
or ii ubs a tve i .
The pa te c s ofconduc i t sltga i w a t m u ua l notpr
r i s' our e
t n hi ii ton s o t ly
oduc prvie l gs
e i l ge o
unt1t ve y e o di c r a t n bel t dl r s t i s w ih t Cour . H a t pa tes
i he r nd f s ove y nd he
a e y ai e he s ue t he
tl d he r i
i i t d upon t tm e y flng o prvie l sm ont a
ns s e
he i l ii f i l ge og
hs go a r s d a a l ge de i i nci i
nd ai e ny le d f c e es n
t m m ont a by pr pe a tm e y m oton t Cou tcou d ha he r f o t pa tes a
he
hs go
o r nd i l
i - he
r
l ve a d r m he ri nd
c
onduc ed a i c e a r e i a pr r a or r y m a r The Cour ha done t ti m a
t n n am r evi w n
ope nd de l nne .
t s
ha n ny
c e .But be aus of bot pa tes dia or c
as s
, c e
h r i ' l t y onduc ,s h a c r ' i c e a r vi w pr es i
t uc
a ef n am r e e
ul
oc s s
now i pos i e.
m s bl

Thi la t Cour wiht opto :()de m bot pa te 'prvie l t i l a
s e ves he
t t wo ins 1 e
h ris i lge ogs mtmey nd

o d rte b t t p o u ea1d c me t t e h v wih ed a p i lg do ( )tk nof rhe
r e h m oh o r d c 1 o u ns h y a e t h l s rvi e r 2 a e ' t r
e
u
a i a t e t r pa t s prvie l a t s l t da e due t t pa te m ut l dia or a
cton s o ihe ry' i l ge og t hi a e t
o he ri s' ua l t y nd
uncoo r tve c
pe a i onduc .
t
Be wee t m ,t pa te t t s ca e ha vi a ed t i ow n ag e m e s t s Cour '
t n he he ri s o hi s ve ol t he r
r e nt , hi
ts
or r ,a now ,tls Di ti t sLoc lRul a t Fe r lR u e ofCi lPr edur .Se D E 275
de s nd,
li s rc '
a
es nd he de a l s
vi oc
e e

(i dn Plitf vo ae t e Co r' Jme 7 201 ,Or e r 1 7 ) 26 (a ) 25 ,p.3
fn ig anif iltd h u ts t , l 9 d r DE 6 J; 3 s me ; 9
( ec iig h w b t Pli ifa d Dee da tvo ae S. Fl.L.R.2 .()2 ( ) Th Co r
d srbn o oh ant n fn n iltd D. a . 6 1e( )D). e u t
f
w il not now , a t el ve h ho m pe m i t s c e t be de a d f t r by a l hy, tm e
l
t he e nt t
r t hi as o
l ye urhe
engt
i
co um i e
ns ng xpar e prvie 1 a doc e tr vi w pr ce s
t i l ge og nd um n e e
o s.

1 anifrie teis eof fn a tsn n o in ei i p n igmoinE 25 1a dDee d n rie teis e
Plitf ass h su h Dee d n ' o c mpl c n t e dn to DE 9 n fn a tas d h su
a
s
o PlitT sno c mpl n ei isRep n eE 27 1
f ani
n o i c n t s o s DE 4.
a
4

Boh p risce ry viltd S. Fl. R. 6.()2 ( a Fe R.Ci P. 6 b ( )
t a t lal o ae D. a L. 2 1e ()D) nd d.
e
v. 2 ( )5 .
I pos ng Pl i if sr quesed r m e y w oul unf il a o ve i of is own un i e y d s l ur of
m
i
a ntf e
t e d
d a ry bs l t t
tm l i c os e

isprvie 1 a d s o ri t l ha m De e nt Se StLoui Condomi um As oc,I .v
t i l ge og nd ipr po tona ey r
f nda . e . s
ni
s . nc .

Ro k il n .Co, .1 -v 21 6 , 01 W L 2 3 2 ,a * ( D. l. a .1 , 01 )(e i
c h lI s .No 8 c - 3 5 2 9
01 0 3 t 3 S. F a M r 1 2 9 d nyng
m o i n f s nc i nsw he e1 0 h pa tesa e a f ul f rt di c r i s si t sc e a ne t r
t o or a t o
r % t r i r t a t o he s ove y s ue n hi as nd ihe

h sc mple wihteFe ea o Lo a Rue ' .
a o id t h d rl r c l 1s'
)
Furhe , he Co ti toubl by t l k ofcoo r ton e biedby co e i t sc s
t rt
ur s r ed he ac
pe ai xhi t
uns l n hi a e.
ç ico r i de i ne as a c
o s ve y s sg d
oope ai ,s l- xec i m e ha s no a de t by- -hous ndr tve efe utng c nim, t
ah- at a

pa rc se rie. fe sv Tar Cor ,No.c 41 1 2015W L 4092450,a * n. ( D.
pe-ut xecs ' ak . get p.
'
v- 4-06,
t 5, 5 S.
Ga J y6,201 .Couns ls ul belude f rz l l a a yrprs ntngt i cle s But
. ul
5)
e ho d a d o eaousy nd bl e e e i her int.
t r co
hei nduc i t s c e ha t n on a c nt ntous s t t i w holy unne s a y a ha
t n hi as s ake
o e i ne s ha s
l
ce s r nd s

c ns me a sg iia ta u to t Co r' rs u c s Thi c n e to ne sS er cg)fo
o u d infc n mo n f he u ts e o r e . s o tnius s t ta ts ' m
d
r
o he i s si t c e whi h r quiet pa te 'a t c ur ' a t nto N otonl t t butneihe
t r s ue n he as
c e r he r i s nd he o ts te i n.
y ha ,
t r

pat c me o t mel l ear s . Br wnn ri I d s o l, n . . e Ma t 1 F.u p.d
ry o s u s li i o e' o ipFe rs n u .fI1 l c v T r a , 3 s p z
ng k
'
.
7 6 7 ( D.1. uy29 1 98, e ' i r o ohe g o n sb 1 5F.d9 3(t Ci.1 9 )
5 , 78 N. 11J l , 9 ) r vd npa t n t r r u d y, 9 3 5 7h r 9 9 .
111.C oncl on
usi

Bas on t f e ng i i he e O R DER ED t tPl i ifA l- g' Expe t d M o i
ed he or goi , t s r by
ha a ntf lTa s
die
ton

t Compe Doc nt W ihhed asPrvie d a NotDicos d o aPrvie Log ( 259)i
o
l ume s t l
i lge nd
s l e n i lge
DE
s
D EN I .
ED

The pa te a e onc ag n r m i ed t ts t n i m o i ns a e due t onow ,O c obe
ri s r
e ai e nd ha ubs a tve t o r
om
t r
11,2019,and t tti i s
ha ral s chedul f t t o- eek per od begim i Januar 6,2020.D i
ed or he w w
i
l ng
y
scove
ry
i cl
s osed.

D O E and O R DER ED i c m be s a W e tPa m Be h,Pal Be h Co mt Fl r da
n ha r t s l
ac
m ac
t y, o i ,

ti / dy f tbr21.
hs P v- Oc e,09
o o
%

W I AM M ATTHE
LLI
N
Unied St esM agita Judge
t
at
sr

6