Woliner v. Summers et al

Filing 120

ORDER granting in part and denying in part 116 Defendants' Motion for Protective Order to Plaintiff's Non-party Subpoena to the Department of Health Filed on November 13, 2018. Signed by Magistrate Judge William Matthewman on 12/7/2018. See attached document for full details. (kza)

UNI
TED STA TES D I
STRI COU RT
CT
SOU TH ED D I
STRI OF FLO RI
CT
DA
CA SE N O .l cv 8- 8o3os- m ir ea / a w m an
Di t oul s M ûhe
KEN N ETH W O LI ER,M . .
N
D,
Pl ntf ,
ai i f

FI b
LED y

D.
C.

DEC 2? 2 1
23
M A RTHA SOFRON SK Y , RI
K STEN
SUM M ERS,
LOU I W I I ST.
SE LH TE
LA UREN T,a LU CY GEE,
nd

S%F )k -w.!.
J . '%7? E
t7 ! k
7.
sn oFFS. FB
.
L

Def nda s
e nt .
O R DER G M N TI I PA RT A N D DEN Y I G I PA R T DEFEN DA N TS SU M M ER S.
NG N
N N
ST . U REN T. N D G EE' M O TI N FO R PR O TEC TI E O RD ER TO PLAI TI S
LA
A
S
O
V
N FF'
NONPARTY SUBPOENA TO THE DEPARTM ENT OF HEALTH FI
LED ON

NOVEM BER 13.201 I 1161
8 DE
THIS CAUSE i be or t Co tupon De e nt ,Krse Summ e s Louie W ihie
s f e he ur
f nda s itn
r,
s
lt
St La e ,a Luc Ge s M oton f Pr ec i Or r t Pl ntf ' N on- ry Subpoe t
. ur nt nd
y e'
i or ot tve de o ai if s
pa t
na o

t De rme ofHe 1h Fied No mber1 2018 ( 11 .Thi ma t wa rfred t t
he pa t nt
at l
ve
3,
DE 61 s ter s eer o he
unde s g by U nie St t s D i ti tJ
r i ned
t d a e sr c udge W ila P.D i ir e s upon a Or r f rng al
li m
m toul a
n der e er i
l
di c ve y t t unde s g
s o r o he
r i ned f f na di poston.Se DE l Pr Se Pl ntf ,Ke t W olne
or i l s ii
e
7. o
ai if nne h
i r

tld a Repo e g 11 .Defnda s fl no Re y.Pli if fld hi scond Notc of
ie
s ns DE 71 e nt ied
pl antf ie s e
ie
Subpoe t Non- ry,heFl i De rme ofHe lh ( 11 wiht Cour onNove r
na o
pa t t orda pa t nt
at DE 01 t he
t
mbe
13,2018.
Pl ntf sN ot ce ofSubpoena.D ef
ai if'
i
endant' M ot on.and R es
s
i
ponse

TheCour hasc r f l r viwedPli ifsNotc ofSubpoe g 11 ,Dee nt'
t
a euly e e
antf
ie
na DE 01 fnda s

Mo in( 1 6 , litf sRe p ns ( 1 7 , n teatc me t. an if ie t No ieof
to DE 1 q P an if s o e DE 1 1 a d h ta h n s Plitf fld he tc
Subpoe on N o m be 1 201 The N otce ofSubpoe i 44 page l , t duce t cum i 11
na
ve r 3, 8.
i
na s
s ong he
se
s

pa l a i c ans91r sst t DOH (xcudi s
ges ong, nd t onti
eque t o he
e l ng ubpars.SeeDE 11
t)
0.
A . M ot on
i

I t erM oin g 1 6 , fn nso j d t t erq e t o t es meba i a Plitf s
n h i to DE 1 1Dee da t b e o h e u ss n h a
ss s an if
pr vi Notc ofPr ton t Non- ry.Se DE 8 Ac or ng t De e nt ,Pl i ifha
e ous ie
oduc i o
pa t e
7. c di o f nda s antf s
a e t wihdr w hi r quessf rdoc e slsed a num be s 1 21,22,26,27,a 28. g
gr ed o t a s e t o
um nt it t
r 9,
nd
DE

1 6 pg 3 . we e, fn a t o j c t r q e t n mbee 4 l , , , - , , - , 3
1 , . ) Ho v r Dee d ns be t o e u ss u rd - 8 21 25 3141 45 47 51 8 ,
a 91 o t bas s t t t y a e o r oa ir l nt a notpr r i
nd
n he i ha he r ve br d, r e eva , nd
opo tonalt t nee oft s
o he ds hi

c e. d.De e nt sa et tm a oft r ue t i ves cfce a lco r po nc t tdo
as 1
f nda s tt ha ny he eq ss nvol pe i m i res nde e ha
noti ve pa test t s c s a do no c e n t pi r l va t t s m a t r 1 D ef nda s
nvol
r i o hi a e nd
t onc r o cs e e nt o hi
te . d. e nt
s a e t tt s e a l we e E s bl pa tofpr or publc r ques s m a by Pl i if a w hi h
t t ha he e m is r i i y r
pos
i
i e
t
de
a ntf nd
c

ha be n r da t d by DOH. 1 Exhi tB ofPl i ifsNo i a a st be t r da t d c es
d e e ce
' d.
'
bi
antf ' tce ppe r o he e c e opi

oft e l hes eks g 11 pgs 2144) Dee nt c r cei Pl ntf sr que tf t s
he mais e .DE 0, . - . fnda s ha a trze ai if e s or he e
e isasa ûfs ng e dii ' be us Pl ntf cli t tt e al coul pos i y c an
ma l
tihi xpe ton,' ca e ai if a ms ha he m is
d sbl ont i

i onnai dic sngt a i ofDee nt g 11 pg.41 Alhoug s oft e is
nf ton susi he ctons
fnda s. DE 6,
. t h ome he mal

c nan P an ifsn me i t e s b e tl e Dee d n sa tiue t i t t e fc ta Plitf
o ti litf' a n h u j c i , fn a t trb t h s o h a t h t an if
n
f eq nty f l d com pl nt w ih t D OH a m a s ver lpublc r c dsr ue t t t D OH .
r ue l ie
ai s t he
nd de e a
i e or eq s s o he

Dee d n srj c Pli tf sa s rin ta t ee i c re po d n ei rlv n t û h w
fn a t ee t anif s et h t h mal or s n e c s ee a t o t o
o
s
c pia t d Pl ntf hi ci lrght a of fe s e h and due pr es , bec us t
ons r cy o eny ai if s vi i s nd
r e pe c
oc s' a e he
'
c piac cl i s onl i ve t nn e Def nda s a no ot m e be s of t D e r m e
ons r y a m
y nvol he m d
e nt nd
her m r
he pa t nt

ofHeat g 11 pg.41 De e nt s s t tPli ifmi be s ki t s doc
lh. DE 6,
. f nda s ugget ha antf ght ee ng hee ument
s

t p ru t ealg to sh ma ei hi p o os dAme d d Co lita DE 4 ( 1 6 p .
o u s e h le ain e d n s r p e
n e mpan t
4. DE 1 , g
4) The Cour notst tJ
.
t e ha udgeDi toulasde e Pli ifsM oi f Le vet Ame t
mir e nid antf
ton or a o
nd he
Compl n onNove r27,201 g 11 .
ait
mbe
8. DE 81

Dee d nsas o j c t Plitf srq e t a n mbes8 - 7 8 , n 91 g 1 6, .
fn a t lo be t o an if e u ss t u r 4 8 , 9 a d . DE 1 pg
51 Dee nsaguet tt s rquessa eduplc tveoft prvi dic r rquess a
. fnda t r ha he e e t r
iai
he e ous s ove y e t, nd
t tr ques s 84- a e exte el co usng t f l .1 D e e nt a s a gue t tr ques 91
ha e
t
87 r
r m y nf i o olow d. f nda s l o r
ha e
t
i o r oa bec us i pe ti t t ac i t ofal DO H e pl es Fur he ,D e e
s ve br d a e t ra ns o he tviy
l
m oye . t r f ndan s a s r
t s et
t tast r que t pe t i t Def nda s Sum m e and St La e t t e doc e sha a r dy
ha
he e s s r a n o
e nt
r
. ur n , hos
um nt ve lea
bee pr vi d i r s ns t Pl i i f si e r t i .
n o de n e po e o a ntf nt r oga ores
B. R esponse

Plitf fldhi Re p n eo No e r27 2 8 g 1 7 . an ifsae ta h h s
anif ie s s o s n v mbe , 01 . DE 1 1 Plitf tts h t e a
w ihd a n 1 r ques s nd no 6 a s a ed by D e e nt . Spec f c l Pl ntf wihdr w
t rw
0 e
t ,a
t
s tt
f nda s
ii aly, ai if t e

r q e t n mb rd l ,21 2 2 ,2 ,2 ,2 ,4 5 a d 5 ( 1 7 p .2 . anifrj cs
e u ss u ee 9 , 2, 3 6 7 8 4, 2, n 3. DE 1 , g 1 Plitf ee t
De e
f ndan sas e ton t tDe e ntSt La e ha ar a pr ed doc nt i r pons t
t s ri ha f nda
. ur nt d le dy oduc
ume s n es e o

rquess8 a 85asksmpl nottue. ( 11 pg.4J Pl ntf sae t tt doc t t t
e t 4 nd
fi y
r ' DE 7,
'
. ai if ttd ha he umens ha
he r c ve f om D e e nt c a n ta tonal pa s of o ous y ir l nt m a e i l' 1
e ei d r
f nda s ont i l ddii
ge
bvi l r e eva
t r a . d.
'
Pl n if c r c e i d hi r ques s as a û a ge ed huntng t i ' whi h r ue t s c f c
ai tf ha a t rze
s e
t
sr t
t
i
rp'
c eq s s pe ii
i or a i n f s cii i or a i a t t t r
nf m to or pe fc nf m ton, nd ha he eque t ar r l vant a pr pori na t t
ss e ee
nd o to l o he
ne of t ca e.1 H e a g s t t t r ques s r a e t D e e nt Gee s r e i t alege
eds he s d.
r ue ha he e
t el t o f nda
' ol n he l d
c piac a ns Pl ntf a he çs fc e c r ove he e pl s t die t m t t ke
ons r y gai t ai i f nd r lufi i nt ont ol r r m oyee o r ct he o a
a ton a ns Pl i if' I
c i gai t a ntf . d
'

II.

A nal i
vs s

TheCour hasr e dPlitf' Notc ofSubpoe g 1101Dee nt'Motong
t eviwe anifs ie
na DE
, fnda s i DE
1 61 Pl ntf sRes e ( 11 ,a t at hme s a fnds t tDee nt'M oi
1 , ai if
pons DE 71 nd he tac nt nd i ha fnda s ton

s o l b g a td i p r a d d ne i pat F rt t caiy De e d n sh ven to j ce t
h ud e rn e n a t n e id n r. is, o lrf, fn a t a o b e td o
r ue t num ber d 1 2, 3,20, 24, 29, 30,42,43,46, 54 - 82, 88, a 90. Acc di l t
eq s s
e ,
nd
or ng y, he

Non- ry Fl i De rm e ofHe t i r r t r pond t t er quess
pa t orda pa t nt
a1h s equied o es
o hos e t .

Fe r Rul ofCi lPr e e26( s t a cla sa r f t s ope ofdic r
deal e
vi oc dur b) es e r tndad or he c
s ovey.
Spe iialy,Rul 26( defne t s pe ofdicovey asûa non- i lge matrt ti
cfc l
e b) i s he co
s r
sny
prvie d te ha s
r l va t a pa t s cl m or def ns and pr
e e nt o ny ry' ai
e e
opor i
tonalt t ne ds of t c s ' I a pa t
o he e
he a e. f
'
ry

as e t t tdoc nt s ug by t opposng pa t a e outi t s ope of dico r Rul
s rs ha
ume s o ht
he
i
ry r
sde he c
s ve y, e

26()1 pr de t tapa t ora peronma movef apr e tveor r a t tc tma
c( ) ovi s ha ry ny s
y
or otci de, nd he kour y,
f good c e, i s a o der t pr t c a paly or pe s f om am oya , em ba r s en ,
or
aus s ue n r
o oe t
'
t
r on r
l
nce
r as m t

oppr sono und bur nore ns 'Fed.R.Ci P.26()1 . Cour wilnow a e st
esi r ue de
xpe e.
'
v.
c( ) The
t l
ddrs he
r m a ni r ue t .
e i ng eq s s
A.Re
ques N um be s 4 - 7,9 - 18,25,31 - 41,45,49 - 51 and 83
t
r
,

I lg ofPli ifspendi c aitg 12,pgs 1 46)a Deenda s Ans r
n iht
antf
ng ompl n DE . 3- nd f nt' we s
r 4,DE 51 t Cour fndst ts rloft doc
DE
, he
t i ha evea he ument s
s oughtby Pli ifae a g bl
antf r r ua y
r e ntpurua t t s ope of dic r unde Rul 26( () Specfc ly,i Pl ntf
elva
s nt o he c
s ove y
r e b) 1.
iial n ai ifs
r ues s num be e 5 - 7,9 - 1 25,31 - 41 45,a 49 - 51 Pl ntf s e e ais be w e n
eq t
rd
8,
,
nd
, ai if e ks m l t e
e pl es of t De rm e ofH e t A 1 of t s e a l co a n Dr W olne ' na e i t
m oye
he pa t nt
a1h. 1 he e m is nt i
.
i r s m n he

s j c lneoft e i.Therf e,heCou tag e wihPl ntf sa sri t tt e isae
ube t i
he mal
eor t
r r es t ai if se ton ha he mal r
a gua y r l nt t Pl i tf s c a m s t t Def nda s a s em pl yees of t D e r m e of
r bl e eva o a n if l i ha
e nt , l o
o
he pa t nt
4

Hea t c pi e t vi a e Pl ntf s c vi rght , be us i a
lh, ons r d o ol t ai if i l i s ca e t ppea s t t e pl es a t
r ha m oye t he
D e r m e of H e lh ofe di c s d Dr W olner The pr
pa t nt
a t t n s us e
.
i .
oduc i oft e a l by D e e nt
ton
he m is
f nda s
i no undul bur ns e nori i di pr tona e t t ne ds oft s c e.The Cour w ila s
s t
y de om
s t s opori t o he e
hi as
t l lo
r r t De rm e ofH e t t r s nd t Pl ntf s Re
equie he pa t nt
alh o e po o ai i f
ques #4.Acc di t Pl ntf ,he
t
or ng o ai i f

se adoc nte il EM imiNe Ti - STRS ( 5,whih waspr ed o oraound
e ks
ume ntted,é a
w mes
3)5 c
oduc n r
J nua y 31 201 a l how s Def nda Ge s a t m pta da a c r i r s
a r , 3 nd ç
s
e nt e' te
t m ge ont ol n e pons t a tc es
e o ri l

i t prs t tquot Plitf. ( 110,pg.9q TheCour as fndst si a g yr lva t
n he e s ha
ed anif' DE
'
.
t lo i hi s r uabl ee n
t Pl i if scl i t tD e e ntG e co pi e t vi a e Pl i if s c vi r g s
o a ntf
a m ha f nda
e ns r d o ol t a ntf i l i ht .
Re
ques 83 s ekse a lcores
t e
m i r ponde e be w e n M a 1, 3 t ough Febr r 2,
nc t e
y 201 hr
ua y 2018, o
t

a fom Dee ntSofons t ffe nna de oye a t Depa t ntofHe t g 11
nd r
fnda
r ky o ite me mpl es t he
rme
alh. DE 0,
pg.1 1 Defnda saguet tt pr tonofs hcore ponde es dbelmie t t e
7 . e nt r ha he oduci
uc rs
nc houl i td o hos
w ih na e D e e nt .The a s a k t Cour t c t i t tm e pe i f om Fe ar 2,201
t m d f nda s
y l o s he
t o ur a l he i
r od r
bnz y
8

t t daet tt undel ngltgai concude Ocobe 30,201 ( 11 pg.41 Pli if
o he t ha he
ryi ii ton
l d, t r
7. DE 6,
. antf
a l ges t t t e e a l pe t n t t M P3 s
le
ha hes m is rai o he
ound r c di t t i a i s i Count I of hi
e or ng ha s t s ue n
s

Compli .( 117,pg.5;DE 12,pg.421 The Cour tndst tt e e l ar a g y
ant DE
.
t i ha hes mais e r uabl
r e ntbot t Pl i if s a l ga i a Count1 Countl , Co tI lofPl ntf Com pl n ,
el va
h o a ntf le tons t
,
l and un 1
ai i fs
ai t
a pr
nd opori lt t nee oft sc e.The e or D e enda s M o i n f Pr e i O r e as
tona o he ds hi as
r f e, f
nt ' t o or ot ctve d r
t Req t num ber d 4 - 7, 9 - 1 25, 31 - 41,45,49 - 51 a 83 i DEN I ,a t
o
ues s
e
8,
, nd
s
ED nd he
D e rm e ofH e t i r uie t com pl wih t r ques s
pa t nt
a1h s eq r d o
y t he e
t.
How e r t ee of t e a l r ques e by Pl i if do not c ai a r e e
ve , hr
he m is e
td
a ntf
ont n ny ef r nce t
o

Pli if i t s j c lne,a t e l ae bewee non- ry De rme of He lh
antf n he ub e t i nd he mais r t n
pa t pat nt
at
e pl yee ,r t r t n t nnm e D e enda s Bec us t r i no i c ton t tt r quesed
m o s a he ha he
d f
nt . a e he e s
ndi a i ha he e
t

e al pe ti t Pli if t Cour doe io fnd Reque tNumbe s8, 47,or48 t be r e ntor
m is ran o antf, he
t s lt i
s
r
o
el va
pr tona t t ne ds of t s c s The Cour wilnotr uie t Depa t e ofHe t t
opori l o he e
hi a e.
t l
eq r he
rm nt
a1h o
pr uce t e a l r ques e i num be s 8, a 48.D e e nt 'M oton f Pr e tve Or
od
he m is e
td n
r 47, nd
f nda s
i or ot c i
der
a t Re
s o quess 8,47,a 48 i G R AN TED.
t
nd
s
B. R e s s 84 - 87,89,and 91
que t
D e e nt a s s e a pr t c i or f Re
f nda s l o e k
o e tve der or ques s num be ed 84 - 87,8 a 91 The
t
r
9, nd .

Cour a e wihDefnda s aseto t tRe t 8 8 aec usngt f l ( 11 pg.
t gres t e nt' s rin ha quess 4- 7 r onf i o olow. DE 6,
51 Ther uessa a t s kdo nt t tweeprvi l rquetd unde apublcrc ds
. eq t ppe r o ee cume s ha r e ousy e se
r
i e or
s a c a s e ia le al'c ani s ve a wo dsors r h tr , r dace fom C olne
e r h nd e k ll m is' ont i ng e r l r
ea c e ms but e t d r t i r
W

Pa kes' Se DE 11 pgs 1 18 .Ther ss s e i or ton t tdoe notappe rt be
c t. e
'
0, . 7- 1
eque t e k nf mai ha s
a o
rlva t t damsas re i Plitf sCompli g 1- , pecal i lg oft fd t t
ee nt o he i se td n anif
ant DE 21 es ily n iht he a ha
t De rme ofHe t i nota pa t t t saci Addii ly,t s r s sa a t s e
he pa t nt
alh s
ry o hi ton.
tona l he e eque t ppe r o e k
i onna i t t i r l ntt t Pl ntf ' unde l ng s a e l w s t c em i publc r or
nf
ton ha s e eva o he ai if s
ryi t t a ui onc ng
i ec ds
r que t r t rt n t t cl i si t i t ntl w s t Bec us t i onna i i no r l va or
e s s a he ha o he a m n he ns a a ui. a e he nf
ton s t e e nt
pr po tona t t nee of t s c e,t Cour w il not r qui e t D e t ent of He t t
o r i l o he
ds
hi as he
t l
e r he parm
alh o
pr uc t i or a i n s ug by Pl i if i Re
od e he nf m to o ht
a ntf n ques s 8 - 8
t 4
7.D ef nda s M oton f
e nt '
i or
Pr e tve Or era t Re
ot c i
d s o ques s 84- i G R AN TED .
t
87 s
Fi l D e e
naly, f ndan s s k a pr e tve o de f Req s num be s 89 a 91. o h r ques s
t ee
ot c i r r or ue t
r
nd
B t e
t

r aet t 201 MP3r or nga is i Pli ifsCompli .g 12J Req s 89s e al
elt o he 3
ec di t sue n antf
ant DE - . ue t e ks l
not s m a of t r co di by D e e nt Sof ons a gi t D ef nda s Sum m e s St
e
de
he e r ng
f nda
r ky nd ven o
e nt
r, .

La e ,a Br Ros ,af me DOH empl e.g 11 pg.1 . e nt cli t tt s
ur nt nd ynna s or r
oye DE 0, 91Defnda s am ha hi
r ques i duplc tve be us t y ha ale dy pr
e
ts
ia i
ca e he ve r a
oduce a l e r r ng t r or ng i t r
d l not s ega di he ec di n hei
6

r s o s t Plitf sRe u ssf rPr d cin.( 1 6, g.5 . eCo r fn st a t en ts
ep n e o anif q e t o o u to DE 1 p 1 Th u t i d h t h o e
r q s e i N um be 89 a e r e ta pr
e ue t d n
r
r el van nd opor i lt t s c s ,a t r o e i t De rm e
tona o hi a e nd he ef r f he pa t nt
ofH e t i i pos es i ofa no e t have nota r a bee pr de t Pl i tf ,i s l be
a1h s n
s s on
ny t s hat
l e dy n ovi d o a n i f t ha l
r uie t co pl wih Pl i tf sr
eq r d o m y t a n if eque t Def nda s M oton f Pr t c i Or rast Re s
s . e nt ' i or o e tve de
o que t
8 i D ENI .
9 s
ED
D e e nt ne a s r t tRe
f nda s xt s e t ha ques 91 i ove br bec us i perai t t a tviy ofa l
t s r oad a e t t ns o he c i t
1

e pl esoft DOH . d.De e nt sae t ta t r que t pe ti t De enda sSum me s
m oye
he
1
f nda s t t ha s he e ss ra n o f nt
r
a St Laur nt D e e nt ha a r dy pr ded t s i or a i i r s ns t Pl i tf '
nd .
e , f nda s ve lea
ovi
hi nf m ton n e po e o a n if s
i t r oga o i s 1 The Co tagr e t t Re
n e r t r e . d.
ur
e s ha ques 91 i ove br d be a e i s e doc ent
t
s r oa
c us t e ks um s

desrbi eforsma by DOH e oye whoa enotpa test t sa ton.( 11 pg.1 .
ci ng f t de
mpl es
r
ri o hi ci DE 0, 91
The e or ,t Cour w ilr qui e t De rm e ofH e lh t o y pr
r f e he
t l e r he pa t nt
a t o nl oduc doc e spe t i ng
e um nt r a ni

t t M P3 r co di a is t t co e n De enda s St La e , Sum m e s and Gee.
o he
e r ng t s ue ha nc r
f nt . ur nt
r,
D e e nt 'M o i n f r Pr e tve O r rast Re
f nda s
t o o ot c i
de
o ques 91 i G R AN TED I PA RT .
t s
N
11
1.

Concl on
usi

Assa e a
tt d bove,Def nda s sM oto f rPr e tve Or ri DENI I PART AND
e nt '
i n o ot c i
de s
ED N
G R AN TED I PA R T,a f l s
N
s olow :
1 D e e nt 'M oton f Pr ec i Or r a t Re
. f nda s
i or ot tve de s o ques s num be e 4 - 7,9 - 1 25,31t
rd
8,
41 45,49 - 51 a 83 i D EN I . The D e t e of H e t i r r t c pl
,
, nd
s
ED
parm nt
alh s equied o om y
wih t r que t .
t he e s s
2. Def nt 'M o i f Pr e tve O r rast Re
enda s
ton or ot c i
de
o ques s 8, a 48 i G R AN TED .
t 47, nd
s
3. D e enda s M o i f Pr e tve O r rast Re
f
nt ' ton or ot c i
de
o ques s 8 87 i G R ANTED .
t 4- s
4. D ef
endant M oton f Pr ectve O r ast Reques 89 i D ENIED .
s' i or ot i
der o
t s

5. D e e nt 'M o i f r Pr t c i Or ra t Re
f nda s
ton o o e tve de s o ques 91 i G R AN TED I PA RT .The
t s
N
D O H s l onl pr uc doc e st tpe t n t t M P3 r c di a i s t tc er
ha l y od e um nt ha rai o he
e or ng t s ue ha onc n
D e e nt St La e t Sum m e s a G e
f nda s . ur n ,
r , nd e.
D N E and O RD ER ED i Cha be sa W e tPa m Be h,Pa m Be h Count Fl i ,
n
m r t s l
ac
l
ac
y, or da
t s
hi

F dyfee e,08
aoDcmbr21.

.

W I AM M A T H EW M AN
LLI
Unie St t M a sr t J
t d aes gita e udge