Woliner v. Summers et al

Filing 140

ORDER DETERMINING AMOUNT OF ATTORNEYS' FEES, COSTS AND EXPENSES TO BE PAID BY PLAINTIFF, KENNETH WOLINER, TO DEFENDANTS KRISTEN SUMMERS, LOUISE ST. LAURENT, AND LUCY GEE PURSUANT TO THIS COURT'S ORDER GRANTING DEFENDANTS' MOTION FOR SA NCTIONS DATED NOVEMBER 13, 2018 [DE 108]. Plaintiff, Kenneth Woliner shall reimburse Defendants, Kristen Summers, Louise St. Laurent, and Lucy Gee, for their attorneys fees in the amount of $1,922.50, and costs in the amount of $676.20, for a total of $2,598.70. Plaintiff is hereby ORDERED to pay the sum of $2,598.70 to Defendants on or before February 21, 2019. Signed by Magistrate Judge William Matthewman on 1/10/2019. See attached document for full details. (kza)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
SOU TH ERN D I
STRI O F FLORI A
CT
D
Cas No.I CVe
8- 8O3OS- M I
DI TROULEASN ATTHEW M AN
KEN N ETH W O LI ER ,M . .
N
D,

Pl i if
a ntf ,

FI
LED BY

D.
C.

VS.

J 12 2 1
AN
99
ANGELA E.NOBL
E
CL
ERK U S DI Q CX
S

M A RTH A SO FRO N SK Y , RI
K STEN
SU M M ER S,LO U I W I I ST.
SE LH TE
LA UREN T, D LU CY GEE,
AN

s. oFd à. w.,.
n. L - p
a

Dee
f ndant .
s

ORDER DE TO BE NGID BY PLA INTIFFJ K EN N ET' EEY COS ,TO
EXP ES NI AMOUNTOFATTORNEYSHF O LIN ER AND
ENS
TERMI PA
TS
W
D EFEND AN T S K R ISTEN SU M M ER S,LO U ISE ST .LA U R ENT UA N D LUC Y
G EE PU RSUA N T TO TH I C O UR T ' O R DER G M NT I G D EFEN D AN T S'
S
S
N

M OTI FO R SANCTI
ON
ONS DATED NOVEM BER 1 201 I 1
3. 8 DE 081
TH I C AU SE w as orgi ly be or t Cour upon D e e nt , K rs e Slm m e s
S
i na l
f e he
t
f nda s
itn l
r,

LouieSt La e ,a Luc Ge s(r efnda s' M oi f Sa tonsg 771a M oi t
s . urnt nd y e' C e nt') ton or nci DE
nd ton o
Compe t Complto of Plitf' De iin a fr Sa tons g 891 Thi Co t
l he
ein
anifs posto nd o nci
DE
. s ur

prvi l ga e Defnda ' M oton f Sanci g 771 a M oto t Compelt
e ousy rntd e nts i or
tons DE
nd
in o
he
Complton ofPli ifsDe ii a f Sanci g 89 a detnni t tPl ntf
ei
antf' poston nd or
tons DE 1 nd e ned ha ai if
s lbe r uie t pa Def nda s r as bl expe e ,cos s a a t m e 'f es i r l ton t
hal
eq r d o y
e nt ' e ona e
ns s
t nd t o ys e n e a i o

t s he e Se e r24,2018de ii Dee ns M oton f Sa tons ( 771 t
he c duld ptmbe
poston, fnda t' i or nci DE , he
cost ass at w ih t s
s oci ed t he econd deposii ofD ef
ton
endant and D ef
,
endant M oton t Com pelt
s'
i o
he

Complton ofPli ifsDe ii and f Sa tons( 891 Acc di y,t sCour mus
ei
antf' poston
or nci DE . or ngl hi
t t

1

now de e m i t a opra e am ount of a t r ys f es c t a e ns t be a ar d t
t r ne he ppr i t
to ne ' e , os s nd xpe es o
w de o
D e e nt Sum m e s St La ent a Ge Se D E 1 pg.1
f nda s
r , . ur , nd e. e
08,
7.
BA CK G R O U ND

The Cour pr vi l e e e a O r r G r ntng D e e nt 'M oton f Sa i ns and
t e ous y nt r d n de a i
f nda s
i or ncto
M oton t Co pelt Com pl ton of Pl i if s D e ii a f r Sa i ns See DE 1
i o m
he
ei
a ntf ' poston nd o ncto .
08. l
n
t tOr ,t Cour sa e t ti w oul a d D e e
ha der he
t t t d ha t
d war
f ndan s Sum m er ,St La e ,a G e t i
t
s . ur nt nd e he r
r a ona e e ns s i r t ni a c ' r por e f t s hed ed Se e be 24, 201
e s bl xpe e n e ai ng
oul e t r or he c ul
t
pt m r
8
de ii a D e e
pos ton, nd f ndant ' tor 'f esf r s a chi a dr tng t M o i f Sa tons
s a t neys e or e e r ng nd afi he ton or nc i

( 771 rviwi a rs achi Pli ifsRes e r s achi a d atng Dee nt'
DE , e e ng nd e e r ng antf
pons, e e r ng nd r fi
fnda s
Re y,asw e la t tm e s nti r vi w i a c pl ng w ih Cour O r r t t ke Pl i if s
pl
l s he i pe n e e ng nd om yi
t
t de s o a
a ntf
de ii n,s e ntt t Se e ber24,2018 Cour O r r a D ef nda s r as
pos to ubs que o he pt m
t de ; nd
e nt ' e onabl c t
e os s
i co c i wih t s c
n nne ton t he e ond de ii i l ng t c tr pore ' f e a t cos of t
pos ton, nc udi he our e t rs e nd he t he
sc
e ond de ii n t a crpt a a t ne 'f es i r ea c ng a dr f i Def nda s M oto
pos to r ns i , nd tor ys e n es r hi nd a tng
e nt ' i n

t Compe t Complton of Pli ifs De ii a f Sa i g 891 Plitf s
o
l he
ei
antf' poston nd or nctons DE , anif
Re pons a Cr sM oi ( 99 , Dee nt' pl ( 1 21
s e nd os- ton DE 1 and fnda sRe y DE 0 .
l or rt de e m i t a opr a e a ountofa t neys f es cos s a e ns s t be
n de o t r ne he ppr i t m
tor
' e , t , nd xpe e o
a a de t Def nda s t s C o t r r d D e e
w r d o
e nt , hi
ur equie
f ndant t fl a a fda t doc e i a l
s o ie n f i vi
um ntng l
a t e ' f s c t ,and e ns s i ur ed, i l ng t a ount of a t ne ' f e s ug ,
tom ys ee , os s
xpe e nc r
nc udi he m
tor ys e s o ht
hour e nded,s r i s r nde e a houry r t s
s xpe
e v ce e r d, nd
l a e ought Se D E 1 The Cour t n or e
. e
08.
t he der d

Pli ift fl ar pons oro j ci t t ho l rt came by Defnda s c e a t
antf o ie es e b e ton o he ury ae li d
e nt' ouns l nd he
num be of hour i ur e by couns l whi h r l t t t s he e Se e be 24, 201
r
s nc r d
e
c e a e o he c dul d pt m r
8

de ii Dee nt'Moton f Sa tons ( 771 t c t asocaed wih t s c
poston, fnda s
i or nci DE , he oss s it
t he e ond

2

de ii of Defnda t a De e nt ' M oton t Compel t Compl ton of Pli ifs
poston
e n , nd f nda s
i o
he
ei
antf'

De ii a f Sa tons( 891 Se DE 1
poston nd or nci DE . e
08.
I
I.

A FFI A VIT.R ESPO N SE .A N D REPLY
D

A . D ef
endant A f
s' sdavi
t

Def nda stl d a N otc ofCom planc w ih Cou tO r rD E 1 on D ec m be 4,201
e nt i e
ie
i e t
r de
08
e r
8.

( 1 9 . f n a t atc e t er q ie Afi a i fo terc u e t t No ie ( 1 9
DE 1 1 Dee d ns ta h d h e urd fd vt r m h i o ns l o he tc . DE 1 1 .I t Afi vi ofJ me 0.W ila ,J .Es ,M r W ila s e ator 'fesi t
) n he fda t a s
lims r, q. . lims e ks t neys e n he
a
moun of$1992. a c t i t amountof$1 ( 11 1 pg.31 Tha Afi vi di no
t
, 50 nd oss n he
00. DE 9- ,
. t fda t d t
co a n cos s r l e t t s cond de ii of Pl i if w hi h t pl c on Dec m be 5,
nt i
t e at d o he e
pos ton
a ntf , c ook a e
e r

2018.De e nt fl an Amende Notc ofCompla e g 1 o De mbe 27,201
f nda s ied
d ie
inc DE 271 n ce r
8,
w hi h i ude a Am e d A f i vi by M r W ila s The A m e d A f i vi de aied t
c ncl d n
nde
fda t
. li m .
nde
fda t t l he
f es a c t f t c i ton o Pl i if s de ii on D ec m be 5,201 i t am ount
e nd os s or he ontnua i f a ntf
pos ton
e r
8, n he

of$5 20.( 1 1 pg.61 Dee nt s e an houry rt of$95. f at ne tme a
76. DE 27- ,
. fnda s e k
l ae
00 or tor y i nd
$40. f rpa a e ltm e.
00 o z l ga i
B. Pl ntf R es
ai ips pons i O pposii
en
t on

Plitf fld h s Co la c wi Co r Or e DE 1 8 a d Re p n eobe to s t
anif i i mpin e t u t d r
e
h
0 n
s o s / j ci n o
Dee e Co els Re tf Fe a Coss o De embe 27,201 ( 1 .I hi
fns uns ' ques or es nd t n c r
8. DE 241 n s
Res
pons ,Pl ntf s a es t t he has s gnii nt de ,a no e t tt Cour a l
e ai i f t t ha
i fca
bt nd t s ha he
t lowed hi t
m o

puruehi a alt t Elve h Cic ti mapau rs ( 1 pgs 121 Pli ifase t
s s ppe o he e nt rui nfor
pe i. DE 24, . - . antf srs
t t Cour ' s i ofdenyi hi M oton t A m end Com pl ntw as sever 'cert nl has
hat he
ts ancton
ng s
i o
ai
e, l ai y

punihe Pli if a ha a e a a ef tve deer n . g 1 pg.21 Plitf a kst
s d antf, nd s ctd s n feci
tre t' DE 24,
'
. anif s he
Co tt c i r hi t r fna i s a us'a t f tt the i notper it t w or pur ua
ur o onsde s s e i nc al t t ' nd he ac ha
di
s
m ted o
k s nt

3

t t Am e ia Ba As oca i Re ti to a Nova La Sc ' polc e ,a fnd t ta
o he
rc n r s iton srci ns nd
w hools ii s nd i ha n

a dofat neys f swoul beun us i lghtofPli ifsi biiyt pa ( 1 pg.2- .
war tor ' ee
d
j tn i
antf' na lt o y.DE 24,
41
Fi l Pl i ifa kst ti m o tr s nci a ei
naly, antf s ha f nea y a tons r mpos d,t s nc i be lm ie t $100.0
e he a tons i t d o
0

frt e ns i ure f t c trpore ,a t tapa tplnbee tbls d.g 1 4,
o he xpe es nc rd or he our e tr nd ha ymen a
sa ihe DE 2
Pg. .
51
C. D ef
endants R epl
'
y
D ef nda t f l d a N otc of Co planc w ih Cour Or D E 1 and Re y t
e n s ie
ie
m i e t
t der
08
pl o

Plitf' Re p n eobe t nst De e s Co ns lsRe u ssf rFe sa d Co t ( 1 4 .n
an ifs s o s / jci o fn e u e' q et o e n ss DE 2 1 l
o
rpy, fn a t n t t a Plitf fie t o j c t t rt a dh u scame b Dee d n s
e l Dee d n s oe h t an if ald o be t o he ae n o r li d y fn a t'
c u s l ( 1 4 p .2 .Dee d nsas rj c Plitf sag me tt tf e a d c sss ul
o n e. DE 2 , g 1 f n a t lo ee t an if r u n ha e s n o t ho d
not be i pos d bec us Pl ntf i i ge ,poi i out t t Pl ntf ha dde ons r t a
m e
a e ai if s ndi nt ntng
ha ai if s s m t a ed n
a lt t pa l galc t as oc a e w ih hi ca e 'i udi cos s ofta crpt ,de ii ,a
biiy o y e
oss s i t d t s s ' ncl ng t
r ns i s pos tons nd
a e r . d.
n xpe t 1
111.

D ISCU SSIO N

A r s bl a t ne s f e aw a d i d ope l ca cul t d by m uli yi t num be of
ea ona e tor y' e
r s'
pr r y l a e
tpl ng he
r
hour r as bl e
s e ona y xpende on t ltga i n tm es a r s bl holry r t ' Am .Ci i Li te
d
he ii to i
ea ona e zl a e.
'
v l ber i s

Uni v Bar s l F.3d 423,427 ( lh Ci.1
on . ne , 68
1 t r 999)( i Bl v St son,465U. 886,
quotng um . en
S.

8 8 ( 9 4 ) Thi 'o sa'ma te b a j se f rter s lso ti e b t at me S e
8 1 9 ). s i detr y h n e du td o h e ut ban d y he to y. e
l
'
Bar s 1 F.3d a 427( tng Lor
ne , 68
t
cii
angerv Ster m,10F.3d 776,781( 1h Ci.1 ) (n
. i hei
1 t r 994).t
l
det m i ng w hat i a S easonabl houry r e and w hat num ber of com pensabl hour i
er ni
s r
e'
l at
e
s s

û e s bl 't c ti t c i r t 1 f t s e er t d i Johns v Geor a H i
r a ona e, he our s o ons de he 2 ac or num a e n
on .
gi ghwa
y

4

Ex es I . 488F.2d 71 (t Ci.1 . Bii v Wrp l Up,I ,548F.3d 1 1
prs , nc,
4 5h r 974)' vns . a t
'
nc.
348, 350
( lhCi.2008) Thes f t sae:
1t r
.
e acor r
()t tmea lborr rd;( t novely a difculy oft quesi ;(
1 he i nd a equie 2) he
t nd fi t he tons 3)
t s l r quiie t pe f m t l alsr c pr ry;( t prcl i of
he kil e st o ror he eg e vie ope l 4) he e uson
e oymen byt at ne duet a ce a oft c s ( t c t r fe;
mpl
t he tor y
o c ptnce he a e; 5) he usomay e
( whehe t fe i txe orc i nt ( tme lmiai i e by t
6) t r he e s i d ontnge ; 7) i i ttons mposd he
cle o t crumsa s ( t a
int r he ic tnce ; 8) he mountivol a t rs t obti (
n ved nd he e uls aned; 9)
t e re e,rput i anda lt oft at ne '( 0)t d
he xpe inc e aton, biiy he tor ys 1 he s ia lt 'of
,
undesrbiiy'
t c e;( 1 t naur andlnghoft pr e sona r ai hi wiht cint
he as 1 ) he t e
e t he ofsi l eltons p t he le ;
a (2)a r i smia c es
nd 1 wads n i lr as .
f a 1 n. (iai omitd)
#. t 350 2 ctton te .
The r as bl houry r t i de i as t u e ii m a ke r t i t r l va l ga
e ona e
l a e s fned he pr va lng r t a e n he e e nt e l
c m uniy f s m ia s r i es by l w ye s of r as bl com pa a e s ls e re , a
om
t or i l r e v c
a r
e ona y
r bl kil , xpe i nce nd

rp tt n. Ba n s 1 F. d a 4 6( u tn No ma v Ho sn Auh o o t mey,8 6F.
e u ai ' r e , 68 3 t 3 q o ig r n . u ig t. fM ngo r 3
o '
2d 1 2,1 ( 1h Ci.1 ).Thefea ian be r t bur ofesa ihi t cai
29 299 1 t r 999 )
e pplc t a s he den
tbls ng he l med
m ar r e.See Barnes,168 F.3d at427.The Cour m ay use is own exper ence i ass ng t
ket at
t
t
i
n essi he

r as bl ne s of a t neys f s N or an, 8 F.2d a 1
e ona e s
tor
' ee . m
36
t 299; Tou
zoutv.Am .Be t Car Re al
s
nt

KF Cor , 1 61 CV,201 W L 2541 a *1( D. a. une 1 201 .
psNo. 5- 7677
225, t S. Fl J
2, 7)
W ih r ar t t t of e de e t tt f e cl i a s d pr
t eg d o he ype
vi nc ha he e a m nt houl oduce i s ppor ofa
n u
t
c a m ,i Bar s, he El ve h Cic tha s a e
li n
ne t
e nt r ui s t t d,
The ' e a i n bea s t bur n of es a i hi e ttem e a doc e i
f e pplca t r he de
t bls ng n il nt nd
um ntng
t a opra e hour a ho l r t s 'N or an,836 F.2d a 1
he ppr i t
s nd ur y a e .
' m
t 303. Tha bur n
t de
i ude i uppl ng t c tw ih s cii a de aied e de e f om w hi h t
ncl s d
s yi he our t pe fc nd t l vi nc r
c he
c tc de enni t r s na e ho l r t .Furhe ,f e couns s d ha
our an t ne he ea o bl ur y a e
t r e
el houl ve
m ai t i r c dst s
n a ned e or o how t tm e s nton t dif r ntcl i s a t ge r
he i pe
he f e e
a m , nd he ne al

s j c matr o t tme e ndiur ough t be s t out wih s fce
ub e t te f he i xpe t es
to
e
t ufiint
pa tc a iy s t tt di ti tc tc n a s st tm e cl m ed f ea h a tviy
ri ul r t o ha he sr c our a s es he i
ai
or c c i t
. . . . A w el- epar
lpr ed f petton al w oul i ude a sum m ar gr ng t
ee ii
so
d ncl
y, oupi he

tme e re by t naur of t aci t or sa of t ca e. 1 ( ttons
i ntis
he t e he tviy
tge he s ' d. ciai
omitd)
te .

5

1 F.3 a 427.
68
d t

I s itng ar ue tf rat ne sf es f e a i nt a e r quied t exe cie' li
n ubm ti
eq s o tor y' e , e pplca s r e r o r s d lng
bi

j d me t'Ba n s 1 F.3 a 4 8 ( o ig He se v Ec e h r,4 U. 4 4, 3 ( 9 3)
u g n . r e , 68 d t 2 qu tn n ly . k r a t 61 S. 2 4 4 1 8 ).
'
I f applca s do notexcl '
f ee
i nt
ude d
excessi r
ve, edundant or ot w i ul eces y' hour , w hi
,
her se m
sar '
s
ch

a e hour iha woul be unr as nabl t bil t a ci nt a t r f e t one' a r a y
r
s d t
t
d
e o e o l o
le nd he e or o
s dve s r

irs cie o t e s il e tto o epe in e o c u s lnte c u tmu te rie b l n
repe tv f h kl,rpua in r x re c f o n e, h o r s xecs il g
i
j d me tf rte S eBa ne ,1 8F. d a 4 8( u tn No ma 8 6 F. da 1 0 (mph ss
u g n o h m. e r s 6 3 t 2 q o ig r n, 3 2 t 3 1 e a i
i orgi j.The b de rssont f a ia t s bmi arques frf st twilena e
n i nal)
ur n e t
he ee pplc nt o u t e t o ee ha l bl
t c t o de e m i ho m uc tm e w a r a ona y e nde Lor
he our t t r ne w
hi
s e s bl xpe d. ange ,10 F.3 a 782.
r
d t
W he r pondi t m otons f a t ney' f s o nent a e r quied t l dg s ci c
n es
ng o
i
or tor s ee , ppo s r e r o o e pe t
i

o j cin t a y rq e t.S e Ba n s 1 F.3 a 4 (ttn t t o j cin fo fe
be to s o n e u ss e r e , 68
d t 27 saig ha b e to s rm e
o
pponensmus bet bes ii a de ona ypr ie'; man,836F.2da 13 ('ast
t t o pecfc nd ' as bl ecs ' Nor
r
)
t 01 $ 1 he
(
dit i t c t m us be r as bl pr c s i e l ng hour t
s rc our
t
e ona y e i e n xc udi
s houg t be urr s na e or
ht o
lea o bl

ume e s r ,s s o l t eo j cinsfo feo p n n sl F ingt ld es ctco j cins
r c say o h u d h be to r m e p o e t.) al o o g pe i be to
' i
i
i ge r l de m e f t l Se , e g. a v fock ed A e onautc s't Co. 1 F.3d 1 7,
s ne aly e d a a . e . ,Gr y .
he
r
i al y, 25
38

1 ( 1h Ci.1 ) Sc t v.Deiats e Su tSr s I . 203 F.Su 2d 1 ,133
389 1 t r 997 ; ela
lc e s n ppor vc . nc,
pp. 328 3
( . Fl 200 .
M D. a. 2)
A . C ounsels H ourl Rat
'
y
e

l s eki r m bur e e f r t ra t neys f es D ef nda sr l on t bilng r or
n e ng ei
s m nt o hei tor
' e , e nt e y
he li ec ds

oft i at ne Mr J me 0.W ila ,J. Es g 1 1 pgs 4- .Def nt s e
her tor y, . a s
lims r, q. DE 27- , . 71 enda s e k
$1, 5 i at ne ' f es a pa a e l f es a $95. per hour f at ne J m e 0.
992.0 n tor ys e nd r l ga e , t
00
or tor y a s
W ila sa f al ne J sca R.Bute of W ilams Le ni e ,& Cos P. a $40.
lim nd or tor y es i
lr
li , i ng r
by, A. nd
00

6

pe hourf parl lJ ( 1 1 pg.3) I s
r
or aega L. DE 27- ,
. n uppor ofDe e nt'rques,Mr W ila
t
f nda s e t . lims
s a ed i hi Am e d A f i vi t the ha be n a m e beroft Fl r da B a snce 198 a he
tt n s
nde
fda t ha
s e
m
he o i
ri
6 nd

i a pat r a W ila ,Leni r & Cos P. ( 1 1,pg.1 .Defnda s fie t
s
rne t lims i nge ,
by, A. DE 27j e nt ald o
i l a bi a c l i o m a i of a t e J s ca R . Bute and f ie t i l t
nc ude ny ogr phi a nf r ton
tom y es i
lr
a l d o nc ude he

i ntt and q lfc tonsofpar l lJ Howe r Pli ifdoesnotchal nget hou l r t
de iy
uaii a i
aega L.
ve , antf
le
he ry aes
of c
ouns as urr as
el
le onabl B a ed u
e. s pon t Cour ' own knowl dge a expe i e,t Cour
he
ts
e
nd
renc he
t

fndst t$ 00 pe ho f a t ne tm eand $40. pe ho f pa aega tme i r s
i ha 95.
r ur or tor y i
00 r ur or r l l i s ea onabl
e
i t scas
n hi e.
B. Num ber O fH oursR easonabl Expended
y

N e ,t Cour m us de e m i w he he t num be of hour bil w e e r a e t t
xt he
t
t t r ne
t r he
r
s led r el t d o he

sheduld Se e r 24,201 de ii Def nt'M oton f Sa to ( 771 t
c
e ptmbe
8 poston, enda s
i or ncins DE , he
s ond de ii of Def nda , a Def nda s M o i n t Com pel t Co pl ton of
ec
pos ton
e nt nd
e nt '
to o
he m e i

Pli ifs De ii and fr Sa tons ( 891 l M r W ilnm' Ame
antf
poston
o nci DE . n . li s
nded Afi vi,he
fda t
a s r s t t he M s Buter a hi pa a e s nt a t t l of 20. ho s i co c i w ih
s e t ha , . l , nd s r l gal pe
oa
7 ur n nne ton t
r t i ng a c t r po t r f r t Se e be 24, 201 de ii r e c ng a dr tng
e a ni
our e r e o he pt m r
8 pos ton, es ar hi
nd afi

Defnda s'M oton f Sa tons ( 771 r viwi a r eac ng Pli ifs Res e
e nt
i or nci DE , e e ng nd es rhi
antf
pons ,
r ea c ng a d afi D e e nt 'Re y,r vi w i a co pl ng w ih t C o ts Or rt
es r hi nd r tng f nda s pl e e ng nd m yi
t he ur ' de o
t ke Pl i tf s de ii a tr Se em be 24, 201 r e c ng a dr tng Def nda s
a
a n if
poston fe
pt
r
8, es ar hi
nd afi
e nt '

M otont Compelt c ei ofPl ntf' De ii a frSa tons( 89 ,eviwi
i o
he omplton
ai ifs poston nd o nci DE 1 r e ng
Pl ntf' Repons a Cr sM oin,a r s ac ng a dr tng Dee t Re y.g
ai ifs s e nd os- to nd e e rhi nd afi
fndans' pl DE
1 1 pg.21 TheCour hasc r ulyrviwe t tmee re ,a doe notfndt 20. hou s
27- ,
.
t
aef l e e d he i ntis nd s i he 7 r
bil f t dr fi and lt ga i oft o di e r m otons a m uli e e m uni a i wih
led or he a tng
ii ton w
s ove y
i
nd
tpl om
c tons t

7

Pl n if r ga di t r s he i of Pl n i f s de ii t be e es i r dunda or
ai tf e r ng he e c dulng
ai t f
pos ton o
xc s ve, e
nt

ume e sr I i de rt tDe e d n s c u s le ecs dp u e tbil j d me ti rc r ig
l c say.t s a ha fn a t' o n e x r ie r d n li u g n n e o dn
ng
tme e tis M o e v r Plitf h sn to j ce t a y o t e h u scame b De e d n s
i nre . ro e, anif a o b e td o n f h o r li d y fn a t'
couns .
el

C . C al ul i ofLode t A m ount
c aton
s ar
The Cour fnds t houry r t r ques e by D e e nt ' c
ti
he
l ae e
td
f nda s ouns a t ntm be of
el nd he l r
hour e nde by c
s xpe d
ouns t be r as
el o
e onabl The e or t Cour wil a d a t a am ountof
e. r f e, he
t l war ot l

$1922. i at e 'f est De e nt Sum me s St Laur nt a Ge
, 50 n tom ys e o f nda s
r , . e , nd e.
D . C os s
t

Dee nt s k a a r of $676. i coss L 1 1 pg. 61 Spe ii al
fnda s ee n wad
20 n t. DE 27- ,
. ctc ly,
De e nt s e $1 00 f r t c nc lton f e ofPli ifs Se e be 24,2018 de iin
f nda s e k 00. o he a ela i e
a ntf
pt m r
posto
fom Pam Be c Re tng Ser c I .a $57 20 f t a tnda e a ta c i f e of
r
l
a h pori
vie, nc nd 6. or he te nc nd r ns rpt e s

Plitf ss c n d p iinDe e e 5 2 8 1 . an ifd e n t b e tt t e ec t. s
anif e o d e osto c mb r , 01 .d Plitf o s o o j c o h s oss Thee
c t wee s cii ly a r d b t Co t i is Novembe 1 201 Or r ( 1 .
oss r pe tcal wade y he ur n t
r 3, 8 de DE 081
The ef e t Cour fnds t t t s c t a e r s bl and a ar D e enda s c t i t
r or he
ti
ha he e os s r ea ona e,
w ds f
nt os s n he

a ou of$676.
m nt
20.
E. Pl nt f Fi
ai i ps nanci St us
al at

Plitf aksteCo r t f t a amo eay a r o at r e s fe wo d b u j s
an if s h u t o i h t n tr wad f to n y ' e s ul e nu t
nd
i l h o Plitf' sau a apr s l ia tp o e dng i f r pa pe i.. pr s l ia t
n i t f an ifs tt s s o e i g n r c e i n o ma u rs d o e i g n
g
t
t
p o e dn i f r pau rsr man s b e tt ter lv n lw a l lso c u t icudn
r c e ig n o ma pe i e is u j c o h ee a t a nd ' e f o r, n l ig
u
t Fedea RulsofCi lPr ed e Moonv. ws ,8 F. 835,837 ( 1h Ci.1 .
he rl e
vi oc ur .
Ne ome 63 2d
-38 1 t r 989)
Thes r espr d f s tons f m i c
e ul ovi e or anc i
or s onduc a f f l e t c pl w ih c r o de s I
t nd or aiur o om y t ou t r r . d.

8

l apr s ltga i esadico y or ,he i a s d be s jctt s nci lke a
f o e ii nt gnor
s ver der s nd houl
ube o a tons i ny
ot rltga .d.Coursca ase sc t a moneay s tonsa ns l ltga s 1 ( ii
he ii nt1
t n s s oss nd
tr anci gai t FP ii nt. d. ctng

Har i v Foryt 742 F. 1 ( 1h Ci.98 (1 co tha dic ei t a r cossa i t
rs . s h,
2d 277 1 t r1 4) $ ur s sr ton o wa d t gans
a
i ge sCsi ohe ca e '';Cot rv Ho i ,7 F. 900,902( 0t Ci. )(mposto
ndi nt a n t r s s '
) ne . pkns 95 2d
1 h r1986 i iin

o $10 0 tn o imaeltg n n tp e u tv l o j cin bl) Ca trv Un td Sa e,7 3
f ,0 i e n n t i a t o r s mp iey be to a e ; re . ie tts 3
i
S. 61 05 Ct 5,
Ed. 28
F.d 735,737 ( 0t Ci.1 4) c r.de e 469 U. 11 , 1 S. .91 83 L. 2d 9
2
1 h r 98 , e t nii

( 985)(d e a e t tsnci a e a a o it rme t prve abus oft j cil
1
û
W gre ha a tons r n pprprae e dy o e nt
e he udi a
pr e s Resr c i condii , o he t n t t l pr c us on, whi h a e a ia e i l
oc s .
ti tve
tons t r ha o a
el i
c r va l bl nc ude

a s sme ofdama t t prvalngpa t a i ii ofsngl o doubl coss'l To r
s e s nt
ges o he e ii ry nd mposton i e r
e t. ' ne
',
W ison,102 F. . .
l
RD

276 ( . Pa.984) (wad of at
M D. 1
a r
tomeys fes f vi ain
' e or olto

dic r or r pemisbl des t pa t spo rya
sovey des r si e pie ry' vet ndpr s saus)
ö e tt l.
W her m onet y sanctons ar i posed on an i .f?ntpau rsl i nta t l i nt
e
ar
i
e m
n t'k
r z pe i i ga nd he i ga
t
t

c es f w a d s
om
or r howi a tue i biiy t pa i m i ht be a a e of di c e i f t c t
ng r na lt o y, t g
n bus
s r ton or he our

t n t dimis f fiur t pa SeeHe rn v Whie l 804 F. 464, 468 ( t
he o s s or al e o y.
r ig .
thal,
2d
8h

Ci.986) Hor kl v Ar Oi ( GasCo.732 F. 1 (t Ci.984) c r.de e 475
r1 , nbuc e . co l f
'
,
2d 233 5h r1 , c / ni4
U. 1 6,1 S. .11 8 L. 2d31 ( 986) Thomasv Ge be Pr tons 703F. 353
S. 01 06 Ct 98, 9 Ed. 2 1 ;
. r r oduci ,
2d
( h Ci.983 .Ho ver t Cour i no heen c i rngdimis lofPl ntf' lws ta a
9t r1 ) we , he
t s t ri onsde i s s a
ai ifs a ui s
s nc i a t r i i uf i i nte denc f t Cour t fnd t tPl n i fha a t ue i biiy
a ton, nd he e s ns fc e vi e or he
t o i ha ai t f s r na lt
t pa Pl i ips i /?vl pau rssausaonedoesnotl
o y. a ntf n i t pe i tt l
r r
/
nakeobvi hi i biiy t paya
ous s na lt o
ny
x

c t wha s ve . M oon,863 F. a 838.I i c ea t tPl i tf ha de ons r t d a abiiy t
os s
t oe r
2d t
t s l r ha a n if s m
ta e n lt o
pay l
egal cos s lke t cos s of t anscrpt and t
t i he t
r
i s
hree w ines deposii
t s
tons, and he w as abl t
e o

rt na e onomise r.( 1 ,pg.21 l t sc e t f t do nots r t e rieof
eai n c
c xpet DE 31
. n hi as ,he acs
uppo the xecs

t Co ts di c e i t r duc t s nc i a a d.Pl i if hi s f br
he ur ' s r ton o e e he a tons w r
a ntf m el oughtt ac i i t
he ton n he

frtpa e atr tv l i v k d tej rs ito o t s Co r,a d a g e sv l p ru d t i
is lc , fimai ey n o e h u idcin f hi u t n g r s iey u s e hs
c s Pl i i fha alo e ged i a pa t r ofdi co y vi a i .Se D E 1 Pl i i fs d
a e. a ntf s s nga
n
te n
s ver ol tons e
08. a ntf houl
no be a e t s e d hi s f fom a a a d ofa t neys f e and c t i ur e by D e e nt ,
t
bl o hi l m el r
n w r
tor
' es
os s nc r d
f nda s

e pe i l sncet a a d i notunr as bl hi undert f t oft sc s
s caly i he w r s
e ona y gh
he ac s hi a e.
lV .

C O N C LUSIO N

Bas d on t f e ng, i i he e O RD ER ED t t Pl ntf ,K e t W olne s l
e
he or goi
t s r by
ha ai i f nne h
i r ha l
r i bur e Def nda s Kr s e Su m e s Loui e St La le ,a Lucy Gee f t i a t ne '
em s
e nt , i t n m r ,
s . tr nt nd
, or he r tor ys

f esi t a
e n he mountof$1922. a c t i t a
, 50, nd oss n he mountof$676. f r a t alo $2, 70.
20, o ot f 598.
Pli if i he e ORDERED t pay t s of $2, 70 t De enda s on or be or
antf s r by
o
he um
598. o f nt
f e
Fe uar 21,201 The c k,m one or r c hi ' c c or w i e t a f r s l be m a
br y
9.
hec
y de , as er s he k,
r r ns e ha l
de
pa bl t t t s a coun of D e e nt ' a t ne M r J m es 0 .W ila s J .of W ila s
ya e o he nl t c
t
f nda s tor y, . a
li m , r
li m ,

Leni r & Cos P. .Shoul Pli iff lt pa t s of$2, 70 i f lon orbe or
i nge ,
by, A
d antf ai o y he um
598. n ul
f e
Fe a y 21 201 D e e nt s l ha t r ghtt f l a a fdavi ofnon- ym e s a i t
bnl r , 9, f nda s ha l ve he i o ie n f i t
pa nt t tng he

a u t u p i ,a d a a p o it moin se ig e ty o a j dg n a ans Plitf,
mo n n ad n n p r prae to e kn nr f u me t g i t anif

cnm too eaportri.
ot p,rtrprpieee
e
h
a lf

J

DONE AND ORDERED i Ch mb r ti /P d y o Jn ay 2 9 a WetPam
n a es hs
a f a u r, 01 t s l
Be c Pa m Be ch Coun y,i t So he n D i ti tofFl i .
a h, l
a
t n he ut r sr c
or da
<

#

:---- -

W I AM M A T E M A N
LLI
UN I
TED STA TES M A G I
STRA TE JU DG E