Woliner v. Summers et al

Filing 92

ORDER granting 82 Defendant's Objection to Plaintiff's Notice of Production of Non-Parties Served September 30, 2018 or in the Alternative, Motion for Protective Order. Signed by Magistrate Judge William Matthewman on 10/30/2018. See attached document for full details. (kza)

UNI
TED STA TES D I
STRI C OU RT
CT
SOU TH ERN D I I O F FLO RI A
STR CT
D
CA SE N O .l8- cv 8o3os- i ir eas athewm r
D m toul N t
KEN N ETH W O LI
NER,M . .
D,
Pl ntf ,
ai if

FI b
LED y

D.
C.

22T 3 22 1
23
M A RTH A SO FR ON SK Y ,KRISTEN
SUM M ERS, U I W I I ST.
LO SE LH TE
LA UREN T,a LU CY G EE,
nd

sïj!ys-bt'
ilo-u.7sj
'vj )MjE
rt
E )pL ?,
B
.

Def nda s
e nt .
O RD ER G R ANT I G D EFEN DA N T' O BJECT I N T O PLA I TI S N O TI E O F
N
S
O
N FF'
C
PR O D U CTI N O F N ON - R TI SERV ED SEPTEM B ER 30. 8 O R I TH E
O
PA
ES
201
N
ALTERNATI M OTI FOR PROTECTI ORDER I 8
VE.
ON
VE
DE 21
TH I C A USE i bef r t Cour upon D e e nt ,K r sen Sum m e s Loui e W ihie
S
s o e he
t
f nda s i t
r,
s
lt

S . u e t a d Lu y Ge ' Obe to t Plitf' No ieo Pr d to o No - ris s r e
t La rn , n c es j cin o anifs tc f o ucin f n pa t , e v d
e
Se e r30,201 ori t atr tve,M oin f Pr eci Or rg 82J Thi ma trwa
ptmbe
8, n he lenai
to or ot tve de DE . s te s
r f r e t t unde s gne by Unie St t D it i t J
e e r d o he
ri d
t d a es s rc udge W ila P.D i ir e upon a
li m
m t oul as
n

Or rrfri a1dic r t t t rine f tna diposton.SeeDE 1 Pr SePlitf
de eerng 1 s ovey o he mde sg d or i l s ii
7. o
ani:
Kel e h W olne ,ha notfl d a Res
m t
i r s
ie
pons ,a t tm e f rf lng a s h Res
e nd he i o ii ny uc
pons hase r
e
xpied.

Th Co r h sc r f l rv e dDee a t'Mo in ( 8 )a t atc me t.
e u t a ae ul e iwe fnd n s to DE 2 nd he ta h n s The
y
M o i was fl d o O c obe 5,201 a Pl i if ha fl d no r s
ton
ie n t r
8, nd a ntf s ie
e pons Pl i i fha t r or
e. a ntf s he ef e
f ie t tm el r s
a l d o i y e pond t t M oton a r r d by t Cour ' O r r Se tng D ico y
o he
i s equie
he
ts de
ti
s ver

Pr e e g 1 a Sout m Ditit of Fl i Loca Rul 7.() Ac or ng t
oc dur DE 8J nd
he
src
orda
l e lc . c di o
Lo lRul 7.( ,fiur t tl ar po e k y be dee s fcintc us f grntng t
ca e 1c) al e o ie es ns û
ma
med ufi e a e or a i he
1

motonbydeful. S. Fl. R.7.()Acc di y, ts ntt Loc Rul 7.() Dee nt'
i
a t' D. a L. 1c. or ngl ptrua o al e 1c , fnda s
'
M oton i G R AN TED by def ul d t Pl ntf sf iur t r s
i s
a t ue o ai i f a l e o e pond. e Ar i gt v. au m an
Se r n on H s ,

No.1562326- VCl GAYLES,201 W L 78 6, S. Fl Fe 17, 6 .
6
241 ( D. a. b. 201 )
The Cour hasa tona l i pe
t
ddii ly nde nden l r vi w e t M oton a f ndst tD e e nt '
ty e e d he
i nd i
ha f nda s
M oton s d a s be g ant d on t m elt . s a s r e i Def nda s M oton, t eve ng of
i houl l o
r e
he i s A s e t d n
e nt ' i On he ni
Se e be 30, 8, ai i fs nta s resoft e e a l t Def nda s'c
pt m r 201 Pl ntf e
ei
hr e m is o
e nt ouns l ea h l l d a
e , c abe e s

arques f pr ton.( 8 pg.1,! 1 .Howe r t emal alor er t t no pa t
e t or oduci DE 2,
1
ve ,he is s efred o he n- ry
s poe pr edur unde Fed a Rul ofCi lPr ce e45()4) g 82,pg.1, 21 Pli if
ub na oc e r erl e
vi o dur a( .DE
! . antf

ddn ti l r s o dt arq e tfrca iiai nfo Dee d ns c u e ( 8 , g. , 2 ,
i o tmey e p n o e u s o lrfc to r m fn a t' o ns l DE 2 p 2 ! )
j s a h ddn t e p n t tep n i gM o in.
u t s e i o r s o d o h e d n to
The Cour ca
t nnotde e ne whet rPl i ifhass Re
t nni
he a ntf
ent ques sf Pr
t or oduc i n pu s ntt
to r ua o

Rul 34,orno i ofa non- ry s
e
tce
pa t ubpoe pe Rul 45.The t ee lngt e a l we e s ntby
na r e
hr e hy m is r e
Pli if t Def nda wihi hou s of e c ot on t a tr
a ntf o
e nt t n
r
a h her
he fe noon a e ni of Sunda
nd ve ng
y,
Se embe 30,
pt
r 2018. t
AlhoughPl ntf i pr s a t sCour s
ai if s o e nd hi
t howslninc t o s Pl ntfs
e e y opr e ai if,
t Cou tw ilnot r w rt Pl i if s de i i nt di c r r ques s or a t m pt t i e pr t w ha
he
r l
e- ie a ntf ' f c e
s ove y e
t
te
o nt r e
t

Plitf itn e i h sd fce t ic v r e ir q e t. e v Elv nt J dca Cic io a,
an ifn e d d n i eiin d so e y male u ss f e . e e h u iil r ut fFl .
699 F.App' 897,898 ( 1h Ci.201 .Thi i e pe al tuewhe Pl ntf fie t tmey
x
1 t r 7) s s s cily r
n ai if ald o i l
r s nd t t r as bl r que tfom D e e ant 'c ns f cl ii ton,f ied t r pond t
e po o he e ona e e s r
f nd s ou el or arfca i a l o es
o
t M oto i a tm e y m a r a f ie t com pl w ih t Fe r lRul sofCi lPr dur a
he
i n n i l nne , nd a l d o
y t he de a
e
vi oce e nd

t sCour' Or rSetngDico r Pr e eg 1 .
hi
ts de ti s vey oc dur DE 81
A ddii ly, a D e e
tona l s f ndan s ha poi ed out t r que t a e i l r pa t va
t ve
nt
, he e s s r n a ge r gue,

c nf i , ove br d, undul bur ns e a i r l va a di pr
o usng
r oa
y
de om , nd r e e nt nd s opor i t t t s c e.
tona e o hi as l

Dee nspr ry s e a pr eci or runde Rul 26( on t ba i t tt r quet ae
fnda t opel e k ot tve de
r e c) he ss ha he e ss r
o r oa a irl nt ( 82,pg.3) TheCour tndst tPli ifstle emaiedr uet
vebr d nd reeva . DE
.
ti ha antf' ire
l eq ss
a e a l a ti pa t f i ous a ha a s ng i a a r nte f t o ca e ul e es a y e ns t
r , t e s n r , r vol
nd r s i n n ppa e f or t us m c s r xpe e o

Defnda s. rviw oft tr ee ie rque t g 82- ,8 2,8 31ceal r lcst tt y
e nt A e e
he h e mald e ss DE 1 2- 2- l ry efe t ha he
ar i pr ,asst ed above.
e m oper
at

Fedea Rul of Ci l Pr e e 26( defne t s ope of dic y as Sa
rl e
vi oc dur
b) i s he c
sover
tny
non- i l ge m a t r t t i r e nt t a pa t s cl i or de e e a pr
prvie d te ha s el va o ny r y' a m
f ns nd opori l t t
tona o he

ne dsoft ca e' I lg ofPli ifspe ng compli ( 12,pg.1 ja Def nt
e
he s .' n iht
antf' ndi
ant DE 3 nd enda s'
Ans r ( 4,DE 5J t doc nt s ghtby Pli ife ee t s ofdic y u
wes DE
,he ume s ou
antf xc d he cope
sover nder
Rul 26( ( ) l s h ac e,Rul 26()1 pr dest apa t ora pes ma mo fra
e b)1. n uc as
e c( ) ovi hat ry ny ron y ve o
pr t c i or r a t ç tma f good ca e is a or rt pr ec a pa t o pe s n
o e tve de , nd he i
cour y, or
us , s ue n de o ot t ry r r o
fom a
r
nnoya e, e r a s t oppr son or undue bur n or e ns ' Fed.R. Ci P.
nc mba r s men ,
es i
de
xpe e.
'
v.

26( ( )Defnda sha etbls goodc us frt e r ofapr e tveode .
c)1. e nt ve sa ihed
a e o he nty
otci r r
Ac or ngl Def nda s'M oton f Pr t c i Or ri GR ANTED .To t e e t t
c di y, e nt
i or o e tve de s
he xt nt ha
Pl i if i e d t t e r f r nc em ais t be r ques s f pr
a ntf nt nde he hr e e e e ed
l o
e
t or oduc i unde Rul 34,
ton
r
e
Def nda sa e notr quied t r po .2 A nd f r he ,t t e e t tPl ntf i ende t t e
e nt r
e r o es nd
u t r o he xt nt ha ai if nt d he hr e

r f r nc d e ist beno i sofs
e e e e ma l o
tce
ubpoena unde Rul 45,a r ula s
s
r e
ny es t nt ubpoena a e q s d
s r ua he
1For e m pl , Plitf rq e t tec mplt p ro n lfls( t rd cino p ro a ie tfes o 2 Flrd
xa e anif e u ss h o ee es n e i wi e a to f es n l d niir) f 0 o ia
e
h
De at n o He l Empo e s( 8 -,p s 23 . s o to ee ly e aen tDee d nsi ti c s a d
p rme t f at
h ly e DE 2 1 g . -1 Mo t f h s mpo e s r o fn a t n hs ae n

hav ltl r atons p,i a t t pe n f r Iws t Pl nif as s kst peronnelfl ofnon- ry
e ite el i hi f ny, o he ndig ede al a ui. aitf lo ee he s
ie
pa t

Br n aRo s( t t er d ci n o p r o a ie tfe s d rn h re o me ta t eS a eAt n y' Ofie i t e
y n s wi h e a to f e s n l d n iir) u ig e mply n t h t t t e s fc n h
h
or
Se o d J d ca Ci uto Flrd ( 8 - ,p 31 S c p ro e fl h sn r lv n e t t i p n n fd r l
c n u ii l r i f o i a DE 2 1 g. . u h e s nn l i a o e e a c o hs e dig e e a
c
e
lws tPlitf as se sav g els o t% c tg re o d c me t ( 8 -,p s 12 , ihaeo ebo d
a ui anif lo e k a u it f 5 ae o is f o u ns DE 22 g . -1 whc r v r ra ,
.
mo ty ir lv n , n ds r po t aeu e Rue2 ( )1 .
sl ree a ta d ip o ri t nd r l 6 b ( )
on
2 Howe , t p te aediecedt f t t pe s lyconfrby t e
ver he aris r r t o orhwih r onal
e
elphone i agoodf ihefor t agr on
n
at f t o ee
De enda s pr ton ofa r e nta pr tona doc e s i De e
f nt ' oduc i
ny el va nd opori l um nt n f ndant 'pos es i cus od orc t ol
s s son, t y, on r

s a t a oi ten c si o a yfrh r seo jdiile o re a datr e a dI ia trs uc s
o s o v d h e est f n u te wat f u ca rs uc s n t n y n ig n e o re .
y
o
t
3

and s l be ofno f r a efec .
ha l
o ce nd f t Any pa t ornon- r y who r ce ve a s
ry
pa t
e i s ubpoe ba e upon t
na s d
he

t ee e al r e e d i t s Or r s l notbe r quie t r pond.The Cour' gr ntng of
hr m is ef r nce n hi de ha l
e r d o es
ts a i

Dee nt'M oi f Pr e tveOr rheeni wihoutprj cet Pli ifsa lt t is a
fnda s ton or otci de ri s t
eudi o antf biiy o sue
pr r ce ra s ct r ues frpr to underRul 34 a Rul 26( ( ) ort is a
ope , la nd pe ik eq t o oducin
e nd e b)1 , o sue
pr r s
ope ubpoe t a non- r y afe f lc planc w ih t r qui e en s ofRul 45 a Rul
na o
pa t t r ul om i e t he e r m t
e
nd
e

26( ( ) i atmel ma i a or ncewiht Cour' Sc dulngOr rg 8)
b)l,n i y nner n cc da
t he
ts he i de DE .
The Cour w ilnotpe ta f rhe del y orf u ta i oft di co r pr s i t s
t l
nni ny u t r a
r s r ton he s ve y oce s n hi
ca e. l t s r r t Cour no e t t Fe a R ul ofC i lPr dur 1 pr de t t t
s n hi ega d, he
t t s ha der l e
vi oce e
ovi s ha he
Fe r lRul of Ci lPr ed e t houl be c tued,adm i s e e a e pl ye by t c ur
de a
es
vi oc ur i
s d
ons r
ni t r d, nd m o d
he o t

a d te pat st s c r t ej t s e d ,a d ie pe sv d tl n to o e e' a to a d
n h ri o e ue h us, p e y n n x n ie ee- ain f v l cin n
e
mi
y
pr e ng. Fe R.Ci P.1 U nf t t l t di co r pr es i t s c s has be n exa ty
oc edi ' d.
'
v. . or una e y, he s ve y oc s n hi a e
e
cl
t oppos t of Rul 1 s r r l nt . The a ton of t t
he
ie
e ' equieme s
ddii
he enn C nd t pa te ' i t
t
a
he r i s ' n he
D e e be 1 2015 a e ne t Rul 1 c e r y pl ce s r d r s
cm r ,
m ndl nt o e l a l a s ha e e pons biiy upon t pa te a
i lt
he ri s nd
t rc
hei ouns lt em pl t r es i t m a r c e pl t by Rul 1 Se Fe R .Ci P. 1
e o
oy he ul n he nne ont m a ed
e . e d.
v. ,

Advioy Co
s r mm.Not 201 Ame ) ( f tveadvoc cy i co itntwih- a i ed
es( 5
nd.. t eci
Ef
a s nsse
t nd nde
de ndsupon- coo r tve a pr po to lus of pr ed e ' 1 , A :#/.pHo s,n . . t o
pe
pe a i nd o r i na e
oc ur .' d.
.
/ u .I c v Ci f
.
y
'

Jac s le No.3:5- 1 J32PDB,201 W L 7446407,a *1( . Fl Apr 8,201 .
k onvil,
1 CV- 380-6
t M D. a. .
6)
The Cour ha s en a ol t y no c
t s e bs u el
oope aton dur ng t di c r pr es a t r or or r
r i
i he s ove y oc s nd he ef e de s
t pa te t c pl w ih a loft i oblg tonsunde t Fe r Rul s of Ci lPr e e a
he ri s o om y t l
he r i a i
r he de al e
vi oc dur nd

t sCour' Or rSeti Dico l Pr e e.( 1 .
hi
ts de tng s ve' oc dur DE 81
y

4

DO NE and O RD ER ED i Cha ber a W es Pa m Bea h, m Bea h Cot y,Fl i
n
m st
t l
c Pal
c
mt orda,

t i 35 Aa o Oco e , 2018.
hs d y f tb r
W I AM
LLI
T EW M AN
Unie St t
t d a es a sr t J e
gi t a e udg

5