Woliner v. Summers et al

Filing 96

ORDER granting 87 Defendants' Motion for Protective Order From Non-Party Subpoena Issued to the Department of Health and denying as moot 86 Defendants' Motion to Strike Plaintiff's Certificate of Non-Objection as Untimely. Signed by Magistrate Judge William Matthewman on 11/1/2018. See attached document for full details. (kza)

UN I
TED STA TES D I
STRI COU RT
CT
SOU TH ERN D I
STRI OF FLO RI A
CT
D
C A SE N O .l - 8 cv 8o3os D i ir ea N a t w m a
- m t oul s the
n
K EN NETH W O LI
NER ,M . .
D,
Pl ntf ,
ai i f

FI by
LED

D.
C.

N2 2 12 1
k
28
M ARTHA SOFRON SKY ,K RI
STEN
SUM M ERS,
LOU I W I I ST.
SE LH TE
LAU REN T,and LU CY G EE,

SJ' ),.W7.
J)) '%l .
l!
b
E
so. F i - na
. oF u w

D e e nt .
f nda s
O R DER G M N TI G D EFEN DA N TS'M O TI N FO R PRO TEC TI E O RD ER FR O M
N
O
V

NONPARTY SUBPOENA I
SSUED TO THE DEPARTM ENT OF HEALTH I 871
DE
A ND DEN Y I G A S M O O T DEFEN D AN TS'M O T I N TO ST RI E PLA I TI S
N
O
K
N FF'
CERTI CATE OF NONFI
OBJECTI A S UNTI ELY I 861
ON
M
DE
TH I C A USE i be o e t Cour upon D e e nt ,K r s e Sum m e s Lo s W ihie
S
s f r he
t
f nda s i t n
r , ui e l t

S .Laze t a d Lu y Ge ' Mo in t S rk Plitf' Ce t iae o No - j cin a
t l n, n
r
c
e s to o tie an ifs ri c t f n obe to s
f
Untmel ( 861 a Dee nt'M oton f Pr eci Or r fom Non- ry Sub na
i y DE
nd fnda s
i or ot tve de r
pat
poe
is d t t De rme ofHe t ( 871 The ema tr weer erd t t undesgnedby
sue o he pa t nt
alh DE . s te s r efre o he
ri
Unie S a e Di t i tJ
t d t t s sr c udge W ila P.Di ir e upon an Or rr f r i al dicove y t t
li m
m t oul as
de e e rng l s
r o he
u r i ned f tnal di post o See D E 1 Pr Se Pl ntf , K e t W olne , fl hi
nde s g
or i
s ii n.
7. o
ai if nne h
i r ied s

Repons t t M oi t Sti g 861a t M oi f Pr tci Or r( 871onOcobe
s e o he ton o rke DE
nd he ton or oe tve de DE
t r
29, 8.( 91 .
201 DE 1
A . ProceduralH i t
s ory

On Ocobe 1 201 Pl ntf fl hi Ce tfc t ofNon- j ton ( 841 whih
t r 2, 8, ai if ied s riiae
obeci DE , c
1

sae - a d c riid t a d o o j cins wee fld t te Noie o Pr d cin fo te
ttd n e t e - h t s be to
f
n
r i o h tc f o u to r m h
e
No pat dae Se e r30,201 ' g 8 . es bl Pli ifwasrfri t t s is
n- ry td ptmbe
8. DE 41 Pr uma y, antf
9
eerng o he ere
ofe al he s ntt Def nda son Septm be 30,201 De e
m is e o e nt
e r
8. f ndant i tal wer conf e ast
s nii ly
e
us d o
whe he Pl ntf st e e aied r quess w e e i s by Pl i i fa a Re s f Pr
t r ai if hr e m l e
t r s ued
a ntf s
que t or oduc i t
ton o

Defnda st rRul 3 ora anotc ofnon- rys
e nt mde e 4 s
ie
pa t ubpoenaunderRul 45()4)( 82,pgs
e a( DE
.
12, 1a 2 a ha now a rntyc t edt m t beanotc ofpr
- ! nd ) nd ve
ppae l onsnz he o
ie odudi ofanon- ry
on
pat

s b o na ( 8 , g. , 1 . fn a t o j ce t t o et ree ir q ssa fldaM oin
u p e .DE 6 p 1 ! 1Dee d n s b e td o h s h e mal e uet nd ie
to
f Pr e i O r r on Oc obe 5, 201 a w e k be or Pl i if fl d hi Cerik a e of
or ot ctve de
t r
8,
e
f e a ntf ie
s
tt t

No - jcin. g; i g .
n obe to l jy g j
Ac r ng t D e e nt , he pa tesa s epo ntc e r on apo e i ls
co di o f nda s t
r i t om
i onf r ed
t nta ubpoe t t
na o he

De rme ofHeat ( 8 pg. !3) Pli ifi tal rpr enedt thewoul onl s nda
pat nt
lh.DE 6, 2, . antf niily e es t ha
d ye
s
ubpoe t t DOH f Def nt'e oymentfl ,a Defnda sdi notobe t 1 Afe
na o he
or enda s mpl
ies nd e nt d
j c. d. tr
t Ce tfca e w astl d,de e e c
he r ii t
ie
f ns ouns li m e a e y r ue t d a c oft s
e m di t l eq s e
opy he ubpoe i s d t
na s ue o

t De rme ofHe 1hbyDee nt ( 86, 2, 41 Dee nt ase tha, rviw of
he pat nt
at
fnda .DE pg. ! . fnda s s r t tupon e e
t s
he ubpoe t l m e t tt r wer ei a tonal eque t i l d i t s
na, hey ea d ha he e e ght ddii r
s s nc ude n he ubpoe duc s
na e

tcu whihweene rdic s dbyt pate .g 86, 2, 4)
e m c r ve suse
he ris DE pg. ! .
On Oc obe 1 2018,D e e nt f l d t r M oton t St i Pl i if s Ce tfca e of
t r 6,
f nda s ie hei
i o rke a ntf ' r ii t

Non- j ci a Untmel ( 864 l t i M oton,t y ase tt tt y weenotpr de a
ob e ton s i y DE . n her i he s r ha he r
ovi d
l On Oc ober30, 2 1 ,h Cout rne Dee d ns Moin( 9 1 saig:çtotee tn ta Plitf itn e
t
0 8 te r ga td fn a t' to DE 2 ,ttn t l h xe th t an ifne d d
l
t t eerf r ce emaist ber essf pr duci unde Rul 3 De e t a en r quiedt r s
he hr e een d
l o equ t or o ton
r e 4, f ndan s r ot e r o e pond.
And
f t r t t exentt tPl ntf i ende t t eer eenc emaist benotc ofs
urhe ,o he t ha ai if nt d he hr efr ed
l o
ies ubpoen u
as nderRul 45,a
e
ny
r ulants
es t ubpoe ar qua he a s l ofno f c a e fct Anypa t ornon- t w hor c ve a s
nas e s d nd halbe
or e nd fe .
ry
pary
e ei s ubpoena
bas d upon t t ee em a l r f r nc i t s Or s lnot be r r d t r pond.Th Cour' gr i g of
e
he hr
is e e e ed n hi der hal
equie o es
e
ts antn

Dee da t' to frP oetv Or e h ri i wi o tpeu c t Plitf' a it t is eap o r ce ra d
fn ns Moin o rtcie d r een s t u rj die o anifs bly o su rpe, la n
h
i
s e ii r q e t o p o u to un e Ru e3 a d Ru e26 b ( ) o t is eap o e s b o n t an n p ry a trf 1
p cfc e u s f r r d c in d r l 4 n l ( ) 1, r o s u r p r u p e a o o - a t fe u1
c mpin ewihterq ie nso Rue45a dRue2 ()l,i at l ma n ri a c ra c wi teCo r'
o la c t h e urme t f l n l 6b () n i y n e n c od n e t h uts
me
h
S h d igOr e ( 8 .
c e ul
n d r DE )'
*
2

c oft s poe be or i wa i s d,a t tt woul r vi w t s
opy he ub na f e t s s ue nd ha hey
d e e he ubpoe t de e mi i
na o t r ne f

t e wo l ma ea o j cin On Oco r1 , 01 , fn a t fldt erM o inf r o e tv
h y ud k n b e to .
tbe 7 2 8 De e d n s ie h i to o Pr tcie
Or rfo Non- ry Subpoe is d t t De rme o Heat ( 8 .I t i M oton,
de rm
pat
na sue o he pat nt f lh DE 7) n her i

Dee d n so j c t Plitf sRe u ssfrrc r sr ltn t Pli tf salg to t a t eMP3
fn a t b e t o an if q e t o e o d eaig o anif l ai n h t h
e
r co di a i s i t sc e w a apublc r or whi h i t bas sofPl i t f spe ng l w s t
e r ng t s ue n hi as s
i ec d, c s he i
a n if
ndi a ui

i saec tunde t PublcRec dsAc.( 87, 21 Dee nt aguet tt doc ns
n tt our
r he i or t DE pg. . fnda s r ha he ume t
a e no r l va t t t c a m s i t i t nt c e,a t y a e o r oa ir l va , a not
r t e e n o he l i n he ns a as nd he r ve br d, r e e nt nd
pr to t t ne oft c e. d.
opori nal o he eds he as 1

Pli iffld hi Repons t Dee nt'M oton t Sti ( 86 a Dee ns
antf ie s s e o fnda s
i o rke DE q nd fnda t'
e
M oton f Pr e tveOr rg 8 onOcobe 29,2018.( 91. I hi Respons , heague
i or otci de DE 7j
t r
DE 12 n s
r s

t theprperynoi dDefnda soft ss po onsverlocc sons ( 9l pg.5 . as
ha
o l tce
e nt hi ub ena e a a i .DE , ) He lo
cl i st tt r quesed e de e i r l va t Ss
a m ha he e
t vi nc s e e nt o ihow t tD e e nt .r c es l orne i nty,
ha f nda s. .e kl s y
glge l

d sr y d e ie c . ( 91 pg 6 . an ifsae ta h i e kse d n er lv n t s o ta
e to e vd n e' DE , . 1 Plitf tts h t e k e vie c ee a t o h w h t
'
s
D e e nt , who t Cour de m s a e pr e ut s r kl s y or ne i nty, desr d
f nda s
he
t e
r
os c or , ec es l
glge l
t oye
'
e de e.3 g 91,pg 6, 1 .
vi nc ' DE
! 51
.

B. Anal i
yss

The Cour ha c r uly rvi
t s aef l e ewed Dee t'M oinsg 86,DE 871and Plitf s
fndans to DE
anif
2Th Co r n tsta p ru n t teCo r' Ore Set gDic v r P o e ur ( 1 1 o whc Plitf i wel
e ut oe h t us a t o h u ts d r ti so ey r cd e DE 8, f ih ani s l
n
f
a r ,Pli ifsRes e t D eenda ' M otont Sti wa duet beGld no lt t n Ocober23,2018,a
wa e antf'
pons o f nts
i o rke s
o
e
aer ha t
nd
Pl n ifs Re pons t De e t M o i t St i wa d t be Gld no l t t Oc ober 24,2018.Yet
aitf ' s e o f ndan s' ton o rke s ue o
e
a er han t
,
Plitf ' Re pons wa notGld un i Ocober29,20l8an he ha ne s tl veoft Cour f per ison
an ifs s e s
e tl t
d
s ver ough ea
he
t or m s i
t fl hi It Res e.Thi i notPli ifs frtvi ai of t Cour' Or r .See e. ,Or r De ng
o ie s ae
pons
ss
antf' is olton
he
ts de s
, g. de nyi

PanifsMoi t Co e wi ou Prjdie( 28 p s 12 ; d rGrnigDee d ns Mo int Co e
litf' t o mp l t t eu c DE , g . -) Ore a tn fn a t' to o mp l
on
h
a dfrPrtcieOre a dGrnigDee d ns MoinfrExe so o Ti t Ta ePlit fsDe sto (
n o oetv d r n a tn fn a t' t o tn in f me o k ani ' po i n DE
o
f
i
6 ,p 4:Seto ();Or e Grnig Dee d ns Obe to t Plitf Noieo Prd cin o No - at s
4 g. cin b) d r a tn fn a t' jcin o anips tc f o u to f n p ri
e
sr e S pe e 3 , 01 o i teAl raie Moinf rPrtcieOre ( 9 p s 12 . an i h sb e
ev d e tmb r 0 2 8 r n h t n tv , to o oetv d r DE 2, g . -) Plitf a e n
e
f
r pe e y w aned a or r d t c pl wih t Cou tsOr r a ye he c i st know i y vi aet .
e atdl r
nd de e o om y t he
r' de s nd t ontnue o
ngl olt hem
Plitf i ye a n or edt f l andcom pl ey c pl wihal Cour Or r a Ruls
an if s t gai der o uly
etl om y t l
t de s nd e .
3 Pl ntf c t a crm i c e, J n k v Un tds a e , 3U. 6 7 ( 9 7 >n s p o t f hi a s ri n
ai if ies i nal as e c s . i t ts 35 S. 5 1 5 ) i u p r o t s s e t .
e
o

3

Re p ns ( 91 . fn a t' oint Srk ( 8 1wa fldo Oco e 1 , 01 , n ter
s o e DE 1 De e d n s M to o tie DE 6 s ie n t b r 6 2 8 a d h i
MotonfrPrtci Or rg 871wastldonOct r1 201 Asat es d matr a as
i o oe tve de DE
ie
obe 7, 8.
hr hol te, nd
no e i f not 1,Pl i if s Res
t d n oot e
a ntf
pons w a untm e y pur ua t t e e s l ng ge oft
e s i l
s nt o he xpr s a ua
he

Cour' Or rSetngDico r Pr dur g 18,whih rquie a opposngpa t t fl a
ts de ti
s vey oce e DE 1 c e rs n
i ry o ie
r pons t apendi motonwihi fvebusne sda ofs r i oft dico ymoi g
es e o
ng i t n i
i s ys e vee he s ver ton. DE
1 1 Pl ntf Res et Def nt'M oto t Sti wa dueo Tues y,Oct r23,201
8 . ai ips pons o enda s in o rke s
n
da
obe
8
a hi Res ns t Def nda s M o i f Pr ec i Or rw a due on W e s y,O c obe 24,
nd s po e o
e nt ' ton or ot tve de s
dne da
t r

201 Pli iftldhi Res etvedaysltronM onda Ocobe 29,
8. antf ie s pons i
ae,
y, t r 2018.DE 91 , t t
g
J wihou
e r s e ng l ve oft Cour .The Co tr cog ze t tPl ntf i pr s i t sca e a ha
ve e ki ea
he
t
ur e ni s ha ai i f s o e n hi s nd s
c ns de e t Res
o i r d he pons a co di t t s a r f pr s pa tes es a i he by t El ve h
e c r ng o he t nda d or o e r i
t bls d
he e nt

Cic t whih sae t tSl r s pla ngsaehel t al ssrnge sa r t n pl di
rui, c tts ha tplo e e di r d o es ti nt tndad ha ea ngs
d afe by a t ne a w il t r f e,be lbe a l cons r d. Tanne
r td
tor ys nd l, he e or
i r ly
t ue '
'
nbaum v U S. 1 F.
.
, 48 3d

1 2,1 ( 1h Ci.1 ) Thels srnge sa r doesnotgi apr s pat t rghtt
26 263 1 t r 998 .
e s ti nt tndad
ve o e ry he i o
vi a e Cour Or er orr e .The Cour has s f c e ba i t s r ke Pl ntf ' l t Re po e but
ol t
t d s ul s
t
uf i i nt s s o ti
ai i f s a e s ns
dec i st do s a t stm e. ow e r t Cour hasnot d Pl i if spr orvi a i a t f c
lne o
o t hi i H
ve , he
t
e a ntf
i ol tons nd he a t
t tPl i i fha be n pr vi usy wa ne t the m us c pl w ih a la i a e r l a co t
ha a ntf s e e o l r d ha
t om y t l pplc bl u es nd ur
o de s Se fn.1, u a. a ntf i w a ned onc aga n t thi r pea e vi a i nsofCou tOr r
r r . e . s pr Pl i if s r
e i ha s e t d ol to
r de s
s l notbe t e a e by t s Cour .
ha l
ol r t d
hi
t
The Cour ha c r uly r vi w e t M o i ,Pl i t f sRe pons ,a t r or i t s
t s a ef l e e d he tons a n if
s
e nd he ec d n hi
ca e, a e w ih Def nda s post o t tt doc en s s
s and gr es t
e nt ' ii n ha he um t oughtby Pl ntf i s e tonsF,
ai if n ubs c i
G , H , a 1 of t s
nd
he ubpoe duc s t c t t D e rm e of H e 1h a a t be l r l
na
e e um o he pa t nt
a t ppe r o
a ge y

ir e ntt t s c s .The alo a a t be lr el dipr tonae unde Rul 26( ( ) I
relva o hi a e y s ppe r o a g y s opori t
r e b)1. t
4

a
ppea s t t Pl i i f s e , i e ala û l docum e s' r l tng t t S i 29, 201 M P3
r ha a ntf e ks nt r i , s l
a
nt ' e a i o he i l
Apr
3
Re di ' t c m uni ton w hi h S hi h Pl i if c ai s w a il galy r cor d by
cor ng,' he om
ca i
c k c
w
a ntf l m
s le l e de
D e e nt Sof ons a il ga l di c os d a hi a i s r tve he i by St La e a
f nda
r ky, nd le ly s l e t s dm nit a i
arng
. ur nt nd

Summes' ( 87,pg.2,fn.1.Plitf s e numeous a tonaldoc
r. DE
'
. ) anif e ks
r ddii
ument.Defnda t
s e ns
pr ry s k apr e tve or runde Rul 26()on t basst tt r quessaeover oa
opel ee
otci de
r e c
he i ha he e t r
br d,
haasi bur ns me a irlva .( 87, 41TheCo ti t Pli ifsr ssae,
r sng, de o , nd ree nt DE pg. .
ur fnds hat antf equet r
a l as i pa t f i ous a har s i i a appa e e f tt c e ul e s a y e
t e t n r , r vol
nd a sng n n
r nt f or o aus m ce s r xpens a
e nd
bur n t D e e nt .The r ques s ar a s i l r e pa tvag ,conf i ove br d,undul
de o f nda s
e
t e lo n a g r
ue
us ng, r oa
y
bur ns e, r el van ,a di pr
de om ir e t nd s opor i t t t s c s
tona e o hi a e.

Fe rl Rul of Ci l Pr e e 26( defne t s ope of dico r a t ny
dea
e
vi oc dur
b) i s he c
s vey s s
a
non- i l ge m a t r t t i r e nt t a pa t s cl i or de e e and pr tona t t
prvie d te ha s el va o ny r y' a m
f ns
opori l o he

ne oft ca e. l lg ofPli ifspe ng c ant( 12,pg.13 a Dee nt'
eds he s ' n iht
'
antf' ndi ompli DE 1 nd fnda s
Ans r ( 4,DE 5 ,t doc
wes DE
1 he umenss
t oughtby Pl ntf e ee t s opeofdic yunder
ai if xc d he c
sover

Rul 26( ( ) l s h a c e,Rul 26( ( )pr de t tapat ora pes ma movef a
e b)1. n uc as
e c)1 ovi s ha
ry ny ron y
or
pr ec i or r a t k our m a f good c e,i s a or r t pr t c a pa t orpe s
ot tve de , nd he ç t y, or
c
aus s ue n de o o e t
ry
r on
f om a
r
nnoya , e ba r s m e , oppr s i o undue bur n or e
nce m r a s nt
e s on r
de
xpens .' Fe R . Ci P.
e ' d.
v.

26c () Dee nt ha e tbls d good c e f t enty ofapr e tve o de .Plitf'
() 1. fnda s ve sa ihe
aus or he r
otci r r anifs
a g e t tt Cour hass
r um nt ha he
t
uppos dl de m e t D e e nt aspr e ut r who m us a r t
e y e d he f nda s
os c o s
t dhe e o

acrmi lw sa r ( 91 pg.6, 1 i fi ous
i nal a tndad DE ,
! 51 s rvol .
Acc di y,Deenda s M oi f Pr tci Or r ( 87 i GRANTED.The
or ngl
f nt' ton or oe tve de DE 1 s
Cour' ga i ofDefnda s M oi f Prtci Or r he en i wihoutprj ce t
ts rntng
e nt' ton or oe tve de r i s t
eudi o
Pli ifsa lt t is a pr rs poe t anon- ry whih f l co iswih ( )te
antf' biiy o s ue ope ub na o
pat
c uly mple t 1 h

r uie e s ofRul 45 i udi t r quie e of pr pe notce t D e e nt i ac or nc
eq r m nt
e
ncl ng he e r m nt
o r i o f nda s n c da e

wih t tr e ( t r e ncy and p o ri iy r rme s of Rul 26( () () t
t ha ul; 2) he elva
r po tonalt equie nt
e b) 1, 3 he
'
c
oope a i a c e r r quie e s oft Fede a Rul s of Ci lPr edur a t s Cour '
r ton nd onf r al e r m nt
he
rl e
vi oc
e nd hi
ts

Or r Se tng Dic r Pr ed e ( 18 4a ( t de dlnes s tf t i t Cour'
de ti
sovey oc ur DE 1 nd 4) he a i e orh n he
ts
Sc dulngOr r( 8 .
he i de DE 14
Ast Pli ifsCe ttcaeofNon- jdi g 8 daedOdo r1 201 t Cour
o antf
rii t
obe on DE 4) t
be 2, 8,he
t
tnds i t be i cc a e and m i l adi t t s Cour .Thi i s f s ve a r as .Fis , o
i
to
na ur t
s e ng o hi
t
s s o or e r l e ons r t n

Oco e 5 2 8 s v n d y bf r Plitf tld h sCe t iae o No ob e to ,Dee d n s
tb r , 01 , e e a s eo e an if ie i ri c t f n- j cin fn a t
f
fldo j cinst t S p e r3 2 8e iss n b Pli tf ( 8 1 S c nd Dee d n s
ie b e to o he e tmbe 0, 01 mal e t y anif DE 2 . e o , fn a t
ddo j c t P an ifse isi e ic re p n e c d tdOdo e 1 2 8 t 911 pg 1 1
i be t o litf mal n mal o rs o d n e ae
b r , 01 DE - , . 0 ,
bf r Plitf Eldh sc ri t o n n o jcin. r , fnd n s n a e it Plitf o
eo e an if e i e tkae f o -b e to Thid Dee a t e t n malo an if n
t
O c obe 9,201 a ee ng t Pl ntf ss ndi a s
t r
8, gr i o ai if e ng ubpoe t t D e r m e ofH e 1h û n or r
na o he pa t nt
a t s de
i

t obant pes lflsofM s Summes M s St La e ,a M s Ge ' ( 91 1 pg.35 ,
o ti he ronne ie
.
r, . . urnt nd . e' DE - ,
2
a notf t e i e y oft doc e s s htby Pl i ifi hi s
nd
or he ntr t
he um nt oug
a ntf n s ubpoe I t t D e e nt
na. n nlh, f nda s

ddh v o j cin t ma yo t ed c me t s u h b Pli tf, v nt o g Dee d n sddn t
i a e be to s o n f h o u ns o g t y anif e e h u h fn a t i o
o j c t Plitf s r ig a s b o nau o te De a t n o He 1h f rt p rome flso
be t o an if e vn u p e p n h p rme t f at o he e s l l ie f
Def nda s Sum m e s St La e ,a Gee A l oft sw as k w n t Pl i i fbe or he f l d hi
e nt
r , . ur nt nd
. 1 hi
no
o a ntf f e
ie s

ia c rt a d mila i Ce tfc t o No - j cin o Oco r 1 2 8 Th Co r
n c u ae n
se dng riiae f n ob e to n tbe 2, 01 . e u t
a oni he Pl i ift be tut ula a c a e i hi f lngs w ih t sCour a a1 f t e tm esor
dm s s a ntf o r hf nd c ur t n s ii
t hi
t t 1 u ur i

4Defnda s'c elandpr s Pl ntf ar diece t con e i a good f t efor t smplf and e die t
e nt ouns
o e ai if e r td o f r n
aih f t o i iy
xpe t he

dso r po e s l Dee d nsh v n o jcin t c ran d c me t s gh b Plitf t n i soud b a
ic vey rc s. f fn a t a e o beto s o e ti o u ns ou t y anit he t h l e
l

sm pl m a t f t pari s t a ee t t Pl n if c is a s
i e ter or he te o gr ha ai tf an s ue ubpoe i ne s y, f t e documen s i a
na, f ces ar or hos
t n
tmel m a .And,i t r a edicovey diputs t Def dant'c ela pr s Pl n ifs d f lyconf
i y nner
f he e r s r s e , he en s ouns nd o e aitf houl ul
er

a rq rd b te Co r' Ore Set g Dic v r Po e u e ( 1 )beo eb r e igt eCo r wih frh r
s e ui y h u ts d r ti s o ey rc d r DE 8 fr u d nn h ut t u te
e
n
dic y m otons.
s over
i

6

f c s nc i .
a e a tons

Nonehel s i lg oft f tt tt Cour ha he en g a ed De e nt 'M oto f
t es , n i ht he ac ha he
t s r i r nt
f nda s
i n or

PrtcieOr e ( 8 1 teCo r DENI AS M OOT Dee d n s M oi nt Stie( 8 1
oe tv d r DE 7 ,h u t
ES
fn a t' to o rk DE 6 .
DO NE and O R D ERED i Cha ber a W e tPa m Be h,Pa m Bea h Count Fl i
n
m s t s l
ac
l
c
y, orda,
t s
hi

/ L< otx ovem ber,2018.
d ay
f A ,-!
Z .
-

W I A M M A T EW M AN
LLI
U nie St t s M a s r e J
td ae
gi tat udge

7