Parker v. Mentor Corporation

Filing 223

ORDER - Partly resolves Doc. 154 in 4:08-md-2004 -- denies SJ as to design defect claims (spread to 3:07-cv-88; 3:07-cv-101; 3:07-cv-102; 3:07-cv-130). Remaining FDA claims will be ruled on in forthcoming order.Partly resolves Doc. 156 in 4:08-md-2004 -- grants in part and denies in part motion to exclude expert witness testimony (spread to 3:07-cv-88; 3:07-cv-101; 3:07-cv-102; 3:07-cv-130; 4:08-cv-5000; 4:08-cv-5003; 4:08-cv-5010)Remaining Daubert motions will be ruled on in fort hcoming order.Completely resolves (grants in part and denies in part these MSJs)Doc. 140 in 3:07-cv-88 (Parker Plaintiffs); Doc. 142 in 3:07-cv-88 (Olson Plaintiffs); Doc. 114 in 3:07-cv-101 (Plaintiffs Stafford and Pinkney); Doc. 110 in 3:07- cv-102 (Crowther Plaintiffs); Doc. 111 in 3:07-cv-102 (Booth Plaintiffs); Doc. 112 in 3:07-cv-102 (Tucker Plaintiffs); Doc. 105 in 3:07-cv-130 (Plaintiff Mills); Doc. 106 in 3:07-cv-130 (Dover Plaintiffs); Doc. 108 in 3:07-cv-130 (Merritt Plaintiffs) ; Doc. 109 in 3:07-cv-130 (Looper Plaintiffs)Doc. 110 in 3:07-cv-130 (Turner Plaintiffs)Ordered by Judge Clay D. Land on 4/22/2010 Associated Cases: 4:08-md-02004-CDL, 3:07-cv-00088-CDL, 3:07-cv-00101-CDL, 3:07-cv-00102-CDL, 3:07-cv-00130-CDL, 4:08-cv-05000-CDL, 4:08-cv-05003-CDL, 4:08-cv-05010-CDL(esl)